19 ms·
Netflix is not a tech company (2019)
- dfdz 5y agoAnyone who has used Netflix and HBO MAX (the best and worse streaming site, respectively, in terms of streaming tech) will beg to differ that Netflix is not a tech company...
- btown 5y agoAh, nothing like a clickbaity title to nerd-snipe us the morning after a holiday! > Like Sky, Netflix has used technology as a crowbar to build a new TV business. Everything about how it executed that technology has to be good. The apps are good, the streaming and compression are good, the UI is good, the recommendation engine is good, and the customer service and experience are good. Unlike American cable subscribers, Netflix subscribers are generally pretty happy with the tech. The tech has to be good - but, it’s still all about the TV... It used tech as a crowbar, and the crowbar had to be good, but it’s actually a TV company. By this logic, Google is less a tech company than an advertising firm that used tech as a crowbar! Microsoft is an office supplies manufacturer! Which seems absurdly reductive. In my mind, if you're scaling customized services for individual users far beyond what a team of top-tier customer service professionals could do (or you're cyborg-izing those service professionals!), you're a tech company. Plain and simple. And Netflix fits this bill because part of its approach to content creation is that programming choices should be driven by quantitative insights about individual users - it's just a very, very long iteration cycle on the optimization algorithm.
- eruleman 5y agoIn 1997, Hastings and Randolph mailed a DVD to see if it would be delivered without damage. Netflix was created because a new market (home delivery of movies) was created by an emerging technology. 10 years later, Netflix kick started the streaming revolution. In 2008, Netflix licensed the Starz catalogue of 2,500 titles. In a podcast episode, Ben Thompson said Netflix was his favorite company to write about because they have successfully transitioned their business model multiple times to take advantage of technological shifts. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ben-thompson-platforms-ecosystems-and-aggregators/id1154105909?i=1000476526879 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ben-thompson-platforms...
- pySSK 5y agoThe always had streaming in mind though but the infrastructure for it did not exist for mass adoption. They used DVD and USPS to gain footprint get off the ground. This enabled Netflix to wait it until the market was ready for their big tech-play. c.f. SV failures like WebTV and General Magic who were ahead of their time but the market/infrastructure didn't exist.
- marban 5y agoIn five years, every company will be an Internet company — or they won't be companies at all. Andy Grove, 2000
- andrewla 5y agoThis is attributing much more coherence to Netflix's strategy than could be reasonably assumed. Netflix is still trying to figure out what it is. I think their growth post-DVD was based on the assumption that they would be the clearinghouse for all video content; with Hulu and the further balkanization of the video space, it was clear that this was not going to happen; that Netflix was destined to be one provider among many, and that their sources of content would start to dry up as other companies decided that the streaming and application and appliances were commodity technology that they could just brand in-house. The quality of the UI of Netflix is terrible, but everyone else is so much worse that for the moment they stand out. And they never managed to get on the bandwagon of selling add-on packages like Hulu and Amazon did (although both of those products have such abysmal UX that you gain very little over using the respective native apps). So now they're continuing to play up the original content game, which appears to be where the industry in general is headed, because the Paramount Consent Decree is so dead that it can't even hear our prayers. They are a tech company insofar as they have invested heavily in the tech and as a result have the most reliable and usable platform (and the most research into recommendations), but the gap between Netflix and commodity streaming is narrow enough now that their edge in the technology space is gone. So they're basically a studio/theater at this point, like everyone else in the space. The only difference between Disney and Netflix is that Netflix doesn't have a theme park (yet!).
- btmiller 5y agoThis was only part of your comment, but I’m very happy with my Apple TV purchase (especially now with the “fixed” remote). The hardware has always been sufficiently fast which enables app devs to present the best version of their UIs. Though this isn’t a silver bullet (see the Prime Video app), the same APIs many devs are used to on iOS do enable a delightful experience (insofar as delightful = objectively better than the experiences on alternative hardware). (Woof, so many caveats here!)
- aidenn0 5y ago> based on the assumption that they would be the clearinghouse for all video content Unless they pivoted at lightning speed, I don't think this is true. When I saw the online subscriptions start for Netflix, I, some random person on the street, observed that the moment a white-box streaming service is created, all of the content-owners will have zero incentive to put their content on Netflix. If I could think of this, then so could Netflix, and sure enough we started seeing netflix buying and producing content of their own pretty quickly.
- rodrigosetti 5y agoYup. Netflix doesn’t sell tech, it sells subscriptions to scripted drama. It uses tech to expedite its business, like everyone else. Yes, they invent a little more technology than your typical small business spreadsheet. But tech is a commodity for them because the only strategy for tech is that “it has to be good”.
- mrkramer 5y agoEven WeWork called itself tech company. The term is widely used and abused.
- Communitivity 5y agoThe author says Netflix is not a tech company, but then does not give a definition of what is a tech company. At one point he seems to say anything that sells something online is not a tech company. I disagree, using SaaS companies as one set of counter-examples. For me a tech company is any company that offers product that is computerized hardware, software, digital asset, or digital service that they have created (so not just a case of repackaging). Netflix meets that definition because it offers a viewing experience with recommendations, watch lists, etc. By my definition many of the companies online would be considered tech companies though. I do think Areading314 is partially correct too. Most companies today are going to be using technology. Though not most will be creating it as a product.
- cardosof 5y ago"Tech company" used to be vendors/providers of technology components (IBM, Oracle, Microsoft, etc) but today it is a label you slap on a stock, startup or IPO to mean "monopoly potential with very profitable operations / scalable revenue streams", so demand (and price) for said stock grow up. This is all BS of course - Netflix is a media/content company, Stripe is a financial services company and Tesla is an automotive and clean energy company. The fact they leverage technology much better than their peers (little offshoring, lots of R&D, "built here" mentality) is more relevant to the how they do it than to what they do.
- MargleBlorf 5y agoWhy does industrial help language at all? The idea that Netflix is regulated differently than Time Warner is a scam. It's bad for users. Everything was an insurance company for a while. Then everything was a finance company. Now it's tech. Why not break the cycle instead of just pushing it into the next field? Basically every company just shifts their marketing language to whatever industry has most aggree-able regulations. I kinda think a more important conversation is about what Netflix actually is. Subscribers are the livestock, not the customer. The customer are propagandists who wanna promote something with a documentary. So many of their docs have a clear influence peddling motive. My favorite is Fear vs New York City...a mafia doc? Well it turned into a commercial for Giuliani that was hyper-targeted at New Yorkers when it looked like he was going to get charged by SDNY. You can argue that the content is compelling but the idea is that they interviewed Rudy and Michael Chertoff and a whole bunch of real corrupt villains and...i bet netflix paid them. That's where our subscription money actually goes. We all agree they're not a tech company but what do ya'll think Netflix actually is?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vmception 5y agoIf you can provide a service to an additional subscriber at near zero overhead costs, near zero dollar sales and onboarding process, then you’re a tech company the only reason additional industry specific questions exist is because they have so many simultaneous users that theyve reached theoretical maximums on their near-free resources when other industries reach the same place, if at all ever possible, then we can split hairs over this distinction
- Ekaros 5y agoYeah, when adding new customers is near marginal cost you are tech company. This ofc does fail some like Tesla at far end, but also Apple and Amazon. So tech is bit murky, but Netflix with Google and Facebook should clearly qualify.
- Areading314 5y agoWe should stop thinking in terms of "tech companies" and think of them in terms of "companies that use tech with a high degree of success". Ultimately any company that makes money is not a tech company because pure technology on its own does not make a business. Also, with the right incentives and management it is possible, although hard, for legacy companies to start using tech better to compete.
- dralley 5y agoI agree. What most HN commenters seem to really mean when they say "technology" is "consumer software", or more cynically, "company is made of mostly software engineers". There is an incredible amount of advanced technology being created and used by more "traditional" industries like manufacturing, aerospace, or animation. Why should Facebook be considered a technology company but not Pixar, Ratheon, General Dynamics, Corning or TSMC? It makes zero sense and relies on a very self-serving definition of "technology".
- samhw 5y ago> company is made of mostly software engineers This hits the nail on the head. If you dig down into it, this almost always aligns with the companies people describe as 'tech companies'.
- desas 5y agoUber is mostly made of drivers, yet is considered a tech company. (I'm aware drivers are not technically employees). Maybe it's more to do with the strategy of the company.
- mikeryan 5y agoThis whole argument seems a silly bit of semantics. Is a company's product is not "technology" a tech company? For the vast majority of companies technology is tool, not the product, but whether you call them a "tech company" seems a silly game. I'd think pretty much all companies are "tech companies" and the better you are at using those tools can provide a competitive advantage.
- PieUser 5y agoYes they are.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 5y ago> The tech has to be good - but, it’s still all about the TV. If Netflix was only showing reruns of Frasier and Ally McBeal no-one would have signed up I think this is always a bit of a silly argument. If Netflix was showing everything, but the tech was terrible, no one would've signed up. You need both.
- Mikeb85 5y agoNetflix wasn't the first service to show TV online. Others didn't catch on because the tech WAS terrible. That's why we all would stream torrents before. Netflix's promise was convenience at a good price and it definitely came down to the tech.
- ses1984 5y agoThe tech isn’t just content delivery. It’s also extracting useful information out of their customers’ habits so they know what to license, what to renew, how much to pay for it, etc.
- travoc 5y agoIs that what’s happening? Because it seems like they’re still funding an awful lot of flops to find a couple of successes.
- ses1984 5y agoThey're not optimizing for fewer flops, they're optimizing to attain and retain subscribers for the least amount of money. If that means 20 flops for every success, who cares?
- hardwaregeek 5y agoI'd disagree considering there's more than a few streaming platforms with sub-par tech. Hulu is quite buggy, as is HBO Max. Criterion Channel is literally just Vimeo and didn't even have working closed captioning until recently.
- paxys 5y agoWhile you can make that argument today, Netflix as a company is 24 years old. It got to its current position not by spending $15B/yr on original content (which it can afford to do now) but purely based on a superior and novel tech experience for its users. Of course eventually all discussions of this nature devolve into the intricate definition of "tech company", and in the absence of one that is agreed upon, bringing this whole thing up is pointless.
- tnzk 5y agoDefinitely. The title of OP should be 'Netflix is no longer a tech company' or so.
- saalweachter 5y agoEh, as a user Netflix original content is a large part of why I still have a subscription. I used Netflix back when it was mailing me DVDs, and loved the online streaming back in the halcyon days when it seemed like they had everything. Then came the dark days when content owners began pulling their IP from Netflix and scattering it all over the internet behind a dozen different options that offered them more money or control, and Netflix was a barren wasteland without anything that caught my eye; my queue was a variety of B-tier series that I tried a few episodes of and gave up on. So I canceled my subscription, for several years. It didn't matter what their UX or uptime was or how smooth their video codecs, they didn't have enough content I wanted to watch. Then I came back for the original content -- I forget which series first made me sign back up; House of Cards? -- and while I watch licensed content on Netflix from time to time, at least half of what I watch is produced by Netflix.
- musingsole 5y ago> It didn't matter what their UX or uptime was or how smooth their video codecs, they didn't have enough content I wanted to watch. Netflix has developed a novel data system (as evidenced by papermill) that is likely responsible for countless decisions that manifested the content which brought you back. I don't know first hand but I suspect data is integrated into their everyday processes in ways most companies can't even dream of. Does that make them a technology company again?
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoThey are a tech company. Just not only a tech company.
- throwawayswede 5y agoReads like a clickbait title. Of course they are. Somewhat out of touch if Ben really thinks like that.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 5y agoThey are a crowbar using company. They use leverage. What big news.
- ARussell 5y agoI think "tech company" is a near-useless label, anyway. I struggle to think of any company that isn't, or at least shouldn't be, a tech company. Everyone uses technology to provide their product or service, even if they are rudimentary ones. There are those companies that are pushing the boundaries of what was previously possible, sure, and if that's what people agree is the definition of "tech company" (high innovation), then surely Netflix counts. No one watched much TV on computers or phones before them.
- funman7 5y agoInternet backbone
- rvz 5y agoI would go for 'tech-enabled' company. Simple as that. Downvoters: So Nvidia, Intel, AMD, TSMC are not technology companies?
- ravivyas 5y agoThere are multiple OTT content providers in India, many with "popular" content, but their tech is bad ( to be accurate), so is the experience of watching shows on them. Look at it from that lens, and Netflix is a tech company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beervirus 5y agoRemember when WeWork (oops I mean just We) pretended to be a tech company instead of an office space leasing company?
- nemo44x 5y agoI think I heard someone describe Netflix as a logging company that occasionally streams videos.
- travisjungroth 5y ago> Coming back to TV, there’s an irony here in the fact that the tech industry has spent decades wanting to get into the living room, get into TV, break up the cable bundle and move TV from scheduled linear to on-demand, and yet now that it’s happening, it’s happening in the TV industry, not the tech industry. I don’t see the irony. This seems to be a circular definition of “TV industry”. The technological breakthroughs (cable, satellite, streaming, mobile) that completely change TV don’t count as “tech industry”. Silicon Valley startups Netflix and Apple somehow don’t count, neither does Amazon, and YouTube doesn’t even get mentioned. I also have an issue with the implied definition of “commodity”. I think a commodity needs fungibility and availability. So storage is now a commodity, but large scale streaming is not. You can’t order a Netflix scale infrastructure on the market.
- Crosseye_Jack 5y ago> The box was good, the UI was good, the truck-rolls were good, and the customer service and experience were good. What UI? Back when Sky launched the box would show you the channel number you where tuned to via LEDS over the channel selection buttons and/or via a simple OSD like you would get on any other TV with a OSD displaying channel numbers. The best UI you got was went something wasn't "working" (be it because you didn't have the auth or because something went wrong) and the OSD told you it couldn't decrypt a channel / to insert your viewing card. It wasn't until the launch of digital I would say it gained an UI. Granted the truck rolls and the customer service was decent from what I recall. I don't recall any major issues. (and the UI on the digital boxes wasn't bad when it came out and have been added to since, no idea what the Q boxes are like as I cord cut a fair few years ago.).
- MattGaiser 5y agoIsn't Netflix the largest server of video in the world? I imagine they have truly massive technical challenges and innovate on those challenges.
- crazygringo 5y agoThis is utterly ridiculous. I think it's generally understood that, in the 21st century, a "tech company" is a company that uses tech as the principal competitive advantage to replace traditional "non-21st-century-tech" incumbents. Obviously, Netflix used streaming, collaborative filtering recommendations, and a massive CDN to replace cable TV subscriptions. If that's not a perfect example of a tech company, I don't know what is. Yes Netflix needed a good content library too, but that's never been its primary differentiator. NBC and HBO have been producing good content for many decades now. That's table stakes. There's another "level" of tech companies, you could argue -- companies that supply tech rather than just use it as a competitive advantage -- e.g. Microsoft, Apple, MongoDB, Dropbox. But today we tend to label those "software" or "hardware" companies specifically (or a combination). Perhaps in the 1980's those were the only "tech" companies. But at least ever since the dot-com era, "tech company" has meant companies that use tech as the principal competitive advantage (as opposed to merely increasing internal efficiency).
- cblconfederate 5y ago> streaming, collaborative filtering recommendations, and a massive CDN Did they develop any of these technologies?
- ronald_raygun 5y agoDid Apple invent much of its early tech, or did it just lift it from Xerox Park?
- cblconfederate 5y agoapple may not be a pure tech company, they re a gadget company, but they have developed a lot of technologies that they can patent, a lot of UX things, and it seems they have evolved many of the preexisting ones. I don't really know what netflix does, do they develop things like video codecs, load balancing tech or recommendation algorithms?
- nkohari 5y ago
- vdnkh 5y ago> , the streaming and compression are good, I've been in video tech for a long time, and you glossed over the part where Netflix does tech company things. They invented VMAF and per-title encoding. I've seen countless video tech talks and Netflix consistently brings innovation to the table.
- simonw 5y agoWhen I worked at Yahoo back in the mid-2000s one of the most depressing internal messages was the idea that "we're not a tech company, we're a media company" - while Google were running circles around us on basically every front.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoIt just depends on the dimension you are talking about. If you describe a company based on the product/service it provides, there is no such thing as a tech company. There are car companies, project management software companies, web search companies, entertainment companies, oil companies, etc. If you describe a company based on their core competency, there are tech companies, product companies, brand companies etc. You can choose any dimension you want. It's usually just helpful to then be consistent, ie Tesla is a car company and Netflix an entertainment company. Or both are technology companies.
- poopypoopington 5y agoFacebook is not a tech company it's a (social) media company, Google is not a tech company, it's an information search company, Apple is not a tech company it's a consumer electronics company, Amazon is not a tech company, it's a retail company. You can say this about any tech company, it's just where you draw the line of what "tech" is.
- bytheway 5y agotech make it possible.
- vincentmarle 5y agoCan Netflix exist without tech? No. Can Netflix compete just on its tech? No. Both can be true at the same time.
- rhacker 5y agoIf no one is a tech company, what IS a tech company? We have the habit of getting into pedantic esoteric arguments that are meaningless. I can't accept that Netflix is a "Television company" because they don't sell TVs. They are a content provider and license holder. However there are billions of content providers and license holders. Also let's say that a mega rich person starts investing in 15Billion / year on content like Netflix, but at the same time does it by creating Blockbuster like stores where people can walk in and rent said content. That's not a Tech company is it? There IS a reason these companies born out of the SV are tech companies. Flagging as this is just a click bait puff.
- eldavido 5y agoI used to read a lot of writing like this and still do (tech strategy newsletters--Stratechery, Benedict Evans, etc) The hazard of reading stuff like this is that it makes the world seem much more orderly and predictable than it is. Case in point: Zoom. "Videoconferencing is a commodity". "Distribution is all that matters". And all of a sudden, someone does this "commodity" a lot better, without the pre-existing network/distribution/brand of someone like Skype, Google, etc. How do they explain this? How does it make sense that a team can work heads-down without any clear distribution advantage and just grind, and build a large, meaningful company by making a better product? It's the same deal with Yamaha Motorcycles. Read their story. Bootstrapped from a "nobody" brand in the US, stiff competition against Harley-Davidson and their ilk. They just got better and better, gradually improving year after year, until they're taken seriously by hardcore enthusiasts and are one of the leading motorcycle companies in the US. How do you explain this success in terms of moats, 2x2 matrices, SWOT analysis, competitive positioning, etc? Sometimes a company wins because they just want it more badly and are willing to push their people harder, and outwork/out-deliver the competition. Calling the tech "still fundamentally a commodity" bothers me not because I'm a technologist, but because it's horribly hand-wavey and imprecise. It sounds precise, but what...exactly...does this mean? As other commenters have pointed out, sure, a commodity that cost oh, 100 billion dollars and a decade to build, isn't easily duplicated, and meaningfully contributes to the user experience? I heard someone describe gold as a "6000-year bubble" last week in the context of the "crypto bubble". Same idea--"a commodity that nobody else has, took a decade to build, and over 100 billion dollars". Some "commodity". As a CEO, I increasingly find all this strategy stuff noise. All that matters is delighting your customers. You do that and charge a reasonable price, you're going to succeed. It might take a while, and of course you need decent sales/marketing execution, but overall, just focus on keeping customers happy, and you'll get there.
- liuliu 5y agoI use Apple TV. Netflix does have better user experience (in terms of playing videos) than Prime Video, HBO Max, Hulu for me. It plays faster, seeks faster, properly does Dolby Vision / HDR when the content has it and has different language subtitles. It animates properly from one screen to another (in stark contrast to Prime Video). The content exploration and navigation is something to be desired, but comparing to other apps, it is on par (similarly bad).
- wodenokoto 5y agoNetflix said that their strategy was to become HBO faster than HBO could become Netflix. Which to put it in the words of the author: get as good at “TV decisions” as HBO before HBO got as good at tech (making apps, good UI, good recommendations and streaming back-ends) as Netflix. I think it makes sense. Wish the article was better at explaining how the tech-crowbar worked for sky and Netflix.
- ransom1538 5y agoEh. Netflix gambled hard. Real hard. They thought streaming would destroy all dvd and physical mediums. That was a real gamble in 2005. That was a huge payout. Now we all have "genius" insights how it worked out - but honestly they deserve every penny. And no, they are not a tech company anymore they just produce content. Anyone can upload a video and hide it behind a paywall. Rock on netflix.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pnevares 5y agoCan we get an edit to add (2019) to the title?
- citizenpaul 5y agoThis whole thing is pointless. It is basically about clarifying the definition of a financial/MBA term. Where do you draw the line at "tech company" vs some other classification? It only matters if you need to check a box on a portfolio investment diversification. If a company came out with a fully automated oil drilling solution they are a tech company. Tech defined the company even if the majority of their business 20 years later comes from the fruit of their technical development labor. Netflix is tech company that now mostly makes money from content.
- skohan 5y agoI think the broader point is that this term is getting less and less relevant in general. It would be like if you defined any company that transported goods by rail a “train company”. It would have seemed relevant as a classification when trains were novel, but once it becomes the norm that ceases to be the most relevant characteristic.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoMy biggest gripes with headline and article that they used the term with extreme ambiguity. I'm sure 50% of the world companies are classified as "tech company". Every time I see those term popping up, all the question I have is tech in what? and What is their specialty? Espically with many new entities name and it is harder to track of what they do.
- pyrrhotech 5y agoNeither is Facebook or Amazon. In fact, all three have already been moved from tech sector and into communications / consumer discretionary by economists. Google, Microsoft and Apple still qualify as tech for now.
- nimbius 5y ago>all of the questions that matter are TV questions. I wish ben would do a little more research. Netflix imo very much is a tech company. they released an entire x.509 certificate orchestration framework. HBO and Disney to my knowledge havent released any devops tooling. https://netflixtechblog.com/introducing-lemur-ceae8830f621 https://netflixtechblog.com/introducing-lemur-ceae8830f621
- amelius 5y agoWhat used to be called "tech" is now called "high tech".
- jefb 5y agoNetflix is absolutely a tech company. Everyone wants to be "tech" because the valuation multiples are higher due to non-linear revenue potential per unit invested. That's pretty much what a "tech" company means today - the cost of acquiring user 1 might be millions, but user 2 is pennies. The only way to push those user n+1 costs so low is with heavy tech automation, which Netflix et al. has in spades.
- nashashmi 5y agoFirst focus on Netflix started out as emailing dvds. So it was a supply chain company. Then it started going into recommendations. So it was data mining. Now it is streaming. So it is streaming company. Like Real (remember them?) was a streaming company. Large companies with established proven processes can migrate towards the tech ladder. But small companies cannot become a tech company aka shark tank funded red dress.
- netcan 5y agoThe "tech company" monicker is increasingly nondescript, but any kind of classification needs context to be useful. These big guys, at present, aren't doing obvious head-2-head competition in well defined market categories. Ford, GM and Toyota are similar to each other that Amazon & Google are not. To think in classifications, you pick your classification based on the aspect of company you care about. Netflix's culturalness, financing, hiring/labour practices are more like "tech companies." Their competition, is home entertainment for consumers, and media companies for content. Their business model is basically cable. etc. In any case, it seems the author goes through all these semantics to notice tha: "you can access the same service on any device (Netflix, Spotify, Kindle), or the same content on any service (music, books), or both. Content doesn’t stop you switching - unless it’s exclusive, and that’s a totally different budget." So yep, key point. Media economics is understudied.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoThe more important distinction it seems is how much of your sales is marginal profit, how your revenue scales, and the growth potential. If you have very high fixed costs, but the profit from each additional subscription is ~90%, and you have a clear path to growth - your future profits could be ridiculous. Netflix is selling non-durable goods with insane marginal profits. In this way, it isn't much different than a software company - like Microsoft in the 90s. The distinction between whether you are selling software or NFTs, streaming videos, or ads seems less relevant.
- zeckalpha 5y ago(2019)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rlewkov 5y agoWho's on first?
- AvocadoCake 5y agoHaving used Paramount+ recently, it has really made me appreciate Netflix as a tech company, in addition to their FOSS contributions and other innovations. I think it's silly to say that only a company that directly sells tech (whether that be software or hardware) is a tech company.
- bilater 5y agoThe salaries for engineers says otherwise. Honestly that's a better metric than anything else as it directly correlates with how valuable they see engineering talent.
- tester756 5y agoIn my opinion Netflix is tech company, but is not part of FAAMG. The reasoning is that the rest of FAAMG does shitton of "other" kind of CS oriented tech (OSes, Databases, Compilers, Heavy ML research) and stuff They're way too big
- robertlagrant 5y agoIt's not your opinion that it's not part of FAAMG, that's definitional.
- bloak 5y agoAs I understand it, the category "tech" was invented by stock traders. The applicable definition of "tech" company is a company whose share price movements correlate with the share price movements of other "tech" companies, which in turn tends to depend on how stock traders view the company, so the definition is circular in at least two ways. But it's probably still a useful concept. For stock traders.
- aynyc 5y agoI have a much simpler definition. 1. If a company sees its technology capability as a profit center, then it's a tech company. 2. If it sees technology as a cost center, then it's not a tech company. It's a bit of over-simplification, but it usually works for me and people I speak with.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rubyist5eva 5y agoalmost every company is a tech company now
- xgulfie 5y agoHonestly what is a "tech company"? Google is an advertising company, so is Facebook. Amazon is a store. Etc etc.
- robertlagrant 5y agoSure and McDonald's is a property company. But that's not particularly helpful well doing things like competitor analysis. You could say that Google sells advertising space on the Google home page, but that is a market with zero competition at that level. The competition is at the search level (e.g. Bing) or at the engagement level (e.g. Facebook drawing eyeballs away).
- InternetPerson 5y agoThis is an important question! Is Netflix a "tech company"?! We should all describe our own thoughts and feelings about the term "tech company", in order to sort this out...
- mandeepj 5y agoI’ve always thought of Netflix as a media company. I believe a simple approach to find out what type of a company - a particular entity is - is to seek what comes to your mind when you think about that co. Toyota - Cars: so, they are a car company. Microsoft - Windows. So, they are a software/tech co. Google - Search. But, they are part of a conglomerate.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoWhy is Microsoft a "software company" but Google a "conglomerate"? What's the difference?
- mandeepj 5y agoGood question. I said ‘Google is part of a Conglomerate’ - Alphabet. I also consider them a software co. But, some of you might disagree by bringing - Google ads and YouTube into discussion. This is where things get complicated. Microsoft also had MSN and serve ads in Skype and Windows. Does that make them a media co? I don’t think so. Similarly, FB also does not consider themselves a media company. They say they are a tech co.
- cletus 5y agoHere's the framework I use: "tech companies" are those where tech still plays a significant factor in the growth of the company such that it's important to an executive level. Example: Google is still a tech company. As much as some might view search as "solved" (just like it was when Google was founded I might add), search continues to get better. Tech still plays a significant role in the actual core business (ie advertising) too. I once again return to the Steve Jobs take on why Xerox failed [1]. An effective monopoly devalued the tech such that Xerox became a sales and finance company. So, returning to Netflix. I agree Netflix isn't a tech company anymore because Netflix ultimately is about serving several thousand VODs and that problem is solved. Now Netflix's core business is about making content, licensing content and acquiring and retaining customers. Obviously doing this (or anything) at scale is a lot harder than it sounds but at the end of the day Youtube is monumentally more technically challenging than Netflix due to the number of videos, the number of viewers, the advertising and live streaming. "Tech company" is still a useful classifier IMHO. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlBjNmXvqIM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlBjNmXvqIM
- websap 5y ago> serving several thousand VODs and that problem is solved You're kidding right? You think this problem is solved? Try using HBO. A tech company is any company that understands it can leverage technology effectively to run a more efficient organization. They treat tech as the way to solve problems rather than throwing people at the problem.
- tapoxi 5y agoCould you clarify? I subscribe to HBO Max and it works fine.
- cletus 5y agoI wonder if that commenter meant HBO Go? HBO tech has had an interesting history. First came HBO Go. This was the online streaming for those with HBO as part of a standard cable package. Apparently it was built on a .Net stack and had huge problems. HBO Now is the service created for standalone sales of streaming. Apparently it had a completely different tech stack because of issues with HBO Go. Apparently it came from the same people who did the streaming services for MLB (Major League Baseball)> In my experience it was very good. HBO Max is the expanded and updated content ecosystem that came with the merger. I don't know what the tech stack here is. I suspect it's just incremental changes to HBO Now but that's just a guess. Perhaps the commenter was referring to HBO Go's problems as evidence that serving VODs isn't "solved". To clarify, I mean "solved for Netflix".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thehappypm 5y agoNetflix used to be head-and-shoulders above other streaming services, now it seems that streaming (which was unbelievably revolutionary 10 years ago) is trivial now. Look how Peacock and Disney+ just popped up overnight, streaming video is just commoditized now. I think what makes a company a "tech company" is doing actual R&D. Netflix pioneered a lot of technology around streaming. Google invented the modern search engine. Microsoft builds operating systems. Apple designs hardware and operating systems. NBC with Peacock? No, they just bought something off-the-shelf. Is Netflix still doing real cutting-edge R&D? Maybe? Maybe not.
- markus_zhang 5y agoOnce a company has grown to certain stage it HAS to be centered on business. So the ideal life of a technical person is to: 1: Join a start-up 2: Work hard to grab as much technical fields under belt as possible, preferably be the CTO or one of the tech director/VP 3: Leave when it's broke/successful enough to be less technical related 4: GOTO 1
- _greim_ 5y ago"Tech company" is arguably a term whose meaning has shifted into the domain of common popular agreement, away from any rigorous first-principles definition. It would be equally futile to say "Betsy's Diner may serve coffee, but it isn't a cafe; it's mainly just a sandwich and pastry shop." Or, "Fritz's Foods may sell a few items in bulk, but it isn't a grocer; they mainly sell individually-packaged items."
- OneEyedRobot 5y agoI'm probably wrong here, but it seems to me that storage is practically cheap enough (not quite) that Netflix could simply send out a drive with their whole library and then a membership gives you access codes. Send out a new drive per year. Do they really only have 4,000 movies in the US?
- robertlagrant 5y agoI doubt my subscription would cover the cost of that drive every year, even if I wanted to wait 12 months for new content!
- OneEyedRobot 5y agoImagine how small the drive would be if it just had 'things I might ever watch'. The size for 100% isn't even that big given a few iterations of storage tech. I'm just blown away by how little Netflix really gives you. Given the push to internally-financed programming they've basically become a production company with streaming bolted onto the back end. Their market cap is kind of a joke.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> The size for 100% isn't even that big given a few iterations of storage tech. Okay? :-)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdoms 5y agoIs this an interesting or actionable insight? Or just arguing semantics for the sake of it?
- xyzzy21 5y agoVery true. They are NO MORE a tech company than WeWork ever was or is. Simply using "IT" to do a non-technical job does not make you a "tech company"!
- swman 5y agoEvery problem that business solve, even if it is "technical", is still a business problem. Nobody cares about docker, until businesses (that might be in retail/healthcare/cruise/whatever) realize they can use docker for their needs. Nobody cares about stripe. Until businesses realize they just pay for a well documented, easy to use SDK. I work for a company in a sector that is not that familiar with technology. We're bridging that gap, and the software we sell is a technical product, but engineering is only part of the equation. Again, nobody cares about what we make until those business realize that software loaded on those phones everyone carries can help them improve/increase their business. Just solve problems. Labelling problems is for business analysts/consultants/hamster wheel professionals.
- tonymet 5y agoThe confusion here is expecting the tech to be visible in the user experience. Netflix tech is continuing to invest in targeting and data-driven content content production.
- ycomb9 5y agoI think almost every company is a tech company in some ways. Tech enables them and has moved on from a concept of being a cost center to revenue enabler. Also tech resources are likely the most expensive resources as well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- abvdasker 5y agoA fundamentally semantic argument like this seems mostly irrelevant to me. It's like calling Google or Facebook advertising services, which might technically be true but isn't usefully descriptive. Using the author's logic you could call high frequency trading firms tech companies instead of financial services. If his semantics here were correct one might wonder why nobody calls HFTs tech companies. The author ignores the more complicated side of the questions about what makes a company a "tech company" — mushy concepts like internal corporate culture, sources of talent, and participation in the broader tech "ecosystem". Also the idea that Netflix's content strategy is cleanly separable from its tech is totally bogus. Netflix uses some sophisticated tech to decide what content to produce and also has a huge amount of in-house technology involved in the actual production of content.
- sfink 5y agoI think it makes sense to an analyst. Is the company's success determined more by {TV,advertising,healthcare,...} concerns or by tech concerns? Which is a very different question from "if I like to do X, where should I try to work?" It's closer to "what is the company's largest expense" but that's still different. Different categorization schemes for different purposes.
- sfink 5y ago"Tech company" is a label that is rapidly outliving its utility. We probably need another name for the small segment of the industry that is producing technology as its product. Looking forward, I'm guessing "tech job" is another label whose days are numbered. Already, "I work in tech" is a fairly nondescriptive phrase. It's the new "I work with a pencil."
- geodel 5y agoBesides all the great comments here about Netflix being not a tech company. I will add that most of Netflix tech blogs lately are just describing integrating a bunch of Open source Apache/Spring Framework software. The "technical challenges" they are facing are similar to those Enterprisey IT developers face when they could not wrap their head around Kludgy Java framework APIs. Also If I look at Netflix OSS at github it gives that feeling of below average enterprise Java software with deeply nested packages with probably 5 percent of meat and 95 percent scaffolding / config around it. I wouldn't be surprised to learn if Netflix's famed extensive systems monitoring is not because they are on cutting edge but that million instances of half-assed Java microservices do need endless monitoring just for standard http/database request processing. So yeah, Netflix is not tech company in many meanings of tech.
- hintymad 5y agoIn a way Netflix is a productivity company. They relentlessly improve productivity in decision making, in building device ecosystems, in lowering streaming cost, in managing streaming assets... Cool technologies emerge from such endeavor.
- didntknowya 5y agotldr: it's a media company
- nostrademons 5y agoThis gets complicated though. Is AirBnB a tech company? A simple analogy to the article would suggest no, AirBnB is a hotel company. However, the actual "hotels" are owned and operated by AirBnB hosts, and AirBnB does not derive significant competitive advantage from the quality of their administration, beyond the value of having a large number of hosts on the platform. AirBnB is fundamentally an information company. Its real competitive advantage is that it owns the channel to the customer, it has a really good search function, and it also owns all the data that makes up reputation-management system that's critical to good hotel reservations. These are all tech areas; AirBnB can afford to lose a bunch of venues, even really good venues, but if it loses the review database a good portion of its competitive advantage goes away. There was a time when lots of people believed Netflix's key competitive advantage was the recommendation algorithm and viewing history. I'm not certain we're in that world anymore - Netflix seems to care a lot more about content than recommendations these days - but I can see why Netflix would've been considered a tech company back then.
- barrenko 5y agoTech company is a company that can sucessfully and repeatedly build product (product in IT sense). Which most companies can't even if it's a cold day in hell.
- skim1420 5y agoI'm not a font guy, but I really dislike the 'a' character in this font set.
- hongloumeng 5y agoIf they use data science to make content decisions, and algorithms to recommend content, is that not a tech company?
- didibus 5y agoWouldn't a tech company simply be a company who values technology as a differentiatior and therefore invests in building tech in-house? If so, I feel like Netflix qualifies. For them not to be a tech company anymore, they'd need to pivot to only producing TV and Films, with outsourcing or licensing their work to a company that builds the technology to host and deliver the content to users on their behalf. I'm not sure Netflix would be doing as well if they pivoted to that. By having in-house technology teams that you invest in, it also means that the company is acquiring engineering and scientist talent, potentially acquiring tech patents, as well as building technological means that in-theory they could pivot to resell the tech or license it to others if they wanted, making tech not just something they invest in and use as a differentiatior, but making it an actual product or service they sell, this is what Amazon did for example.
- hamburgerwah 5y agoI really don't understand how Netflix is not 100% a SaaS tech company. To say they aren't in the way the article describes is to say that no SaaS companies are tech companies which is an obvious fallacy. They have dabbled in making original content but it's far from their core business.
- stereoradonc 5y agoThis is a flawed argument; Netflix is a tech company that dabbles in TV shows (and films). It has the best recommendation engine (and not a commodity) and nothing else comes closer. There is a possibility that it may merely switch to "cloud-generated" characters with multiple plotlines in the same series and its gaming ambitions must be understood in this light. If you use traditional metrics to understand the company, it wouldn't make sense. Why is the company losing more money than it earns from subscriptions? The amount of granular data it has on films (and increasingly on the people's choices) will make it easier to predict the choices users will make. Hollywood's movies rely on "gut-feeling and formulaic approach" to film making. Netflix will replace it with data. Or is it that Ben-Evans missed the initial hype around Netflix and couldn't invest? Its easier to take pot-shots on the blog and call it a commodity. Bandersnatch was an initial experiment. There's more to come with "immersive filmmaking" and "story-telling".
- flashgordon 5y agoUmm arent you a tech company if technology is a major/reasonable export of yours and not just a means of getting things done?