5 ms·
I find this weird. How can you possibly have negative interest on a savings account? That means it’s quite literally better to withdraw all of your excess cash
by Aeolun 5y ago
I find this weird. How can you possibly have negative interest on a savings account? That means it’s quite literally better to withdraw all of your excess cash and stuff it in an old sock…
- geewee 5y agoVery common in the EU. Every danish bank has negative interest over a certain amount of money
- andi999 5y agoOne day you come home and your sock is gone...
- naasking 5y ago> How can you possibly have negative interest on a savings account? If a bank is forbidden from investing your money, and thus putting your savings at risk, then it costs them money to safely manage it.
- shard972 5y agobut we have fractional reserve banking? so this isn't the case
- space_rock 5y agoI'm learning today that most people on hn don't know how central banks work and how interest rates are set
- naasking 5y agoI wasn't saying that's what's happening here, the OP just asked how banks "could possibly" charge negative interest on savings. In a world where a bank couldn't use the money you deposited, they would have to charge you in some way. Negative interest rates could be one way to do it. Simple answer to a simple question.
- enaaem 5y agoWhy should guarding your money be free? The concept of negative interest is very natural. Banks have found ways to reinvest your deposits. If the earnings there are higher than the storage costs they can share some of the earnings with you. But if they can’t, they have to charge for their service.
- mouzogu 5y agoA lot of Banks already charge account fees, service fees, overdraft fees, maintenance fees, transaction fees - I'm sure there is more. And they are also loaning out your money to others at a non trivial rate of interest.
- Ekaros 5y agoAre they loaning it out at non trivial rates? Outside things like credit card debt I have understood that part of the problem is that rates are or are becoming trivial.
- joshsyn 5y agoIf you ignore the volatility, crypto makes a lot of sense.
- TomVDB 5y agoOther than that, how was the play, Mrs Lincoln?
- yoavm 5y agoYes, if you ignore the possibility of losing access to your funds, the possibility of getting hacked, the massive environmental impact, the inability to use it to pay for most legal things, and a couple of other things - crypto makes a lot of sense!
- joshsyn 5y agoChuckle, do you either work in a bank or government? Scared of losing job? Understandable. You have to be computer illiterate to not know how to keep your keys safe. We'll get there. While you are ok with funny money. Just a matter of time.
- zoobab 5y agoBecause someone at the European Central Bank decided so. Lafarge met with other banksters in a castle, and they had a big fight.
- shric 5y agoI guess it depends on how you value the security of storing your money in socks vs banks. Also, an interest rate of -0.5% is not that much worse than 0% -- they're both a few percentage points below inflation.
- gizmo686 5y agoMost people don't own a savings account because it is profitable. They do it because it us a valuable service. It provides an easy way to store your money that is secured by 'this collapsing is an exustensial threat to the government'. It also provides access to the financial system. I would be willing to pay a lot of money for such a service. Of course, given that I already need it, I might as well choose a cheap option. If that cheap option happens to have a negative cost, I'm not going to complain.
- y7 5y agoBecause if you put it in a sock, you risk it getting stolen or lost in a fire. And it's more of a hassle to pay with it. So the negative interest rate might be worth the safety and convenience of your bank account. As for the reason: it currently costs the bank money to have your money (ECB interest rate on overnight loans is negative), in addition to the costs of operating the bank itself.
- xyzelement 5y agoI am in finance and literally struggled to wrap my mind around this last year, until a proper fixed income trader explained this to me and I'll explain it the same way. Last year, oil futures prices turned negative. Which means "wait, I can take delivery of oil AND get cash for it too." So why didn't people do this? Because there's a cost of cary to oil - I need to pick it up in a train car at a specific place in the US and I need to store it somewhere, which is expensive. So while they were "paying you to take the oil" you couldn't really just jump on it and do it. This is an analogous situation to what's going on with a negative interest rate. You're right, you're literally better off taking the money out into a pile of cash. And if you only have a few thousand bucks you could just do that (but then you need to drive to the bank, figure out how to store it, drive back when the rate goes back up, etc.) But if you have a few hundred thousand bucks - what are you gonna do? Cash it out in hundreds and keep it in your garage? At some point the logistics and theft risk of that adds up too. Meaning, similarly to the oil example, while the raw numbers indicate one strategy, the practicality of carrying the asset on your own tends to outweigh the benefit. So yeah, someone may chose to incur negative interest if their only other option is to pile up cash in the house where they have to worry about it being stolen, burning in a fire, etc.
- razius 5y agoI highly recommend giving this a read: https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2016/12/31/Breaking-Through-the-Zero-Lower-Bound-43358 https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2016/12/31/Bre...
- nostrademons 5y agoNote that this is an inverse of Gresham's Law and is behind the large increases in value of alternative stores of value (art, real estate, cryptocurrency, stocks). Gresham's Law is that "bad money drives out good" - when you have two forms of currency circulating within the economy and one is inflating at a faster rate than the other, people will tend to spend the inflating currency and hoard the appreciating one. The inverse of that is that they will tend to hoard the appreciating currency and spend the inflating one, i.e. as a store of value, nobody with long time preferences is going to hold cash. Instead they pile into any asset with zero cost of carry and a liquid market, which was stocks from about 1980-2010 and now also includes art, cryptocurrency, real estate, NFTs, other securities, etc. It occurs to me that this could play tricks on how we measure interest rates. Assuming no central bank interference, interest rates are set at the equilibrium between people who want to borrow cash and those who want to lend cash. But nobody serious about future returns wants to lend cash! They've exited the cash market entirely, and only touch it when they need to convert long-term holdings to short-term holdings. Instead, they trade amongst themselves in asset markets, which have appreciated far quicker than 3% CPIs and 2% nominal interest rates would suggest. It could be that the divorce between stock market returns (10-15% in recent years) vs. interest rates (2-3% in recent years) might indicate that all of the firms with high time preferences have exited the cash market, leaving behind only those firms who need cash now.
- imtringued 5y agoHere is a paper exploring the elasticity of the zero lower bound: http://mattrognlie.com/negative_rates.pdf http://mattrognlie.com/negative_rates.pdf