19 ms·
How the pandemic has affected people’s perspective on travelling to work
- ekianjo 5y agoSo... a few anecdotes packed together is the new journalism?
- gogopuppygogo 5y agoYep. All ad money went to zuck, brin, and page.
- Applejinx 5y agoUpvoting this grayed-out comment. Like it or not, overly generalized/personalized or not, this is still an important truth about how journalism is sustained under capitalism. Extremely large quantities of money have been removed from the business models of traditional, worker-employing journalism and redirected to Google, Facebook etc. to the point where I don't understand how any of the traditional old school businesses remain functioning at all. Hell, Craigslist struggles, and Craigslist was an early wave of the internet hurting what newspapers do. "Yep. All ad money went to zuck, brin, and page" is glib, but does not deserve this degree of downvoting. In important ways, it's the truth.
- luckylion 5y agoNot sure about Craigslist. How is anyone expected not to struggle when they seem to have done little in terms of improvements in 25 years? I checked whether it's still alive and it had a few listings in Berlin, one of which may or may not be offering to sell a baby, so at least it's kind of a weird lawless place, but I'm not sure that's enough to run a business on (might be good enough for a few reddit threads exploring creepy stuff though). I'm sure that ad spending has shifted online, but traditional media companies have been losing audience before Google launched News and Facebook started to dominate. There's plenty to blame, and the web as a whole probably played a part, but I'm not sure it's the primary driver. Before there were online alternatives, there was TV or just not getting "the news" at all. Relying on not having competition feels like a bad idea with regards to being a sustainable business.
- Tycho 5y agoIt’s The Guardian, journalism isn’t what they’re known for.
- gizdan 5y agoWhile I agree that getting the opinions of a few individuals is not particularly good journalism, this opinion seems to be the consensus among almost everyone I've spoken to about this. Colleagues, ex-colleagues, friends, family, everyone. The few who I have talked to that still want an office, have been in leadership positions, and usually this is from those who are higher up in the ranks. Fact of the matter is, an office is an outdated method of working with today's technology. It just took a pandemic for the general public to realise this. You pay for a commute that's not necessary, you pay with your time (that you're not paid for) to get there (time that you could be spending on family, or something else), and depending on where you work, you're probably smelling 100s of people's sweat every day, and taking in, and contributing to, a whole lot pollution.
- dazc 5y agoI dare say it is the consencus but I don't think it's a surprise to learn that people hate commuting. The problem is that managers want to see people working and an office environment is perfect for this purpose. I would be surprised if anything really changes in this regard long-term, other than in a few outlying cases.
- iamstupidsimple 5y agoDo managers really care if you're in seats working? Most managers I know are fans of remote because they're usually older and have family. The push to return is coming from company executives at the very top.
- dazc 5y agoAnecdotally, there are a lot of bad managers around who do care. I'm glad your actual experience contradicts this.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoThis hasn't been my experience so far, I've been looking at moving jobs recently and I've got plenty of options even after discarding anything with required office hours or "temporarily remote" jobs which will return to mandatory commuting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _rpd 5y agoYou're lucky it isn't just images of their tweets tied together with an 'emerging trend' narrative.
- lazyjones 5y agoOnly if they are carefully chosen to support a particular narrative.
- sprafa 5y agoThis was always the case!
- wayanon 5y agoA few days ago there was an online thing on the Guardian site for people to add stories like this of their own experience.
- eplanit 5y agoYup. Anecdotes or lies; take your pick.
- skrebbel 5y agoI wish there was an HN guideline against nihilism.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- simonswords82 5y agoThe BBC news website was previously very high quality mostly impartial journalism. I am not sure why but the quality and impartiality has dropped noticeably over the last 10 years.
- lmm 5y agoAlways has been. The internet exacerbated things by publishing more anecdotes to cherry-pick from, but journalists were never scrupulous about taking a representative sample, and the Guardian in particular has always been practically innumerate.
- hatware 5y agoDo you think the views expressed in the article are something that has been fairly covered through all this time...? This is a breath of fresh air, finally some cost-benefit analysis is being done on what was a very hasty set of decisions.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoMaybe it's Google's algorithm, as I have clicked on several of the articles from an Android, but it feels to me as I have seen more and more of these "pro commuter" and "how the office is a better place to work than home" articles come out now that we're coming to a point where lock downs are supposed to be ending. In the beginning, all of the opinion pieces seemed to be, "Work from home, is it the wave of the future?" style pieces. It's either journalism trying to ride a wave or being paid to push a narrative. Business as usual in the journalism world.
- brtkdotse 5y ago> Christina Cage, a 38-year-old chartered accountant in Edinburgh, did not appreciate how important her commute was until she stopped doing it. “I came to realise that my commute was a time where I could transition from being a mum to becoming a colleague with a bit of space in between to myself,” says Cage, who has two young children. “Overnight it became a threshold of a door that didn’t close.” While I can’t say I’d like to pay the price of 2x50 minutes each day, I too miss that piece of time that was truly mine and mine alone. I used it to read, do a mediation or just space out and let my mind wander.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI'm completely different, I despise my commute because it's time that doesn't truly belong to me and I'm not being paid for. It's getting up earlier and arriving home later for the exclusive purpose of mindless presenteeism, time that belongs to my boss rather than to me because I certainly wouldn't be doing it out of choice. I also have to cycle through often horrible weather around drivers who I can only presume have WW2 fighter style marks for how may cyclists they've managed to run off the road. My next job will be exclusively remote, and I'll be much better off for it. I don't mind what other people choose to do, as long as I'm not forced to participate in the return to the office.
- brtkdotse 5y agoOh, I have no doubt there are commutes that are horrible. The part that I miss from mine is a 26 minute train ride on a train that was always punctual and never more than 50% full.
- short_sells_poo 5y agoIn a past life I used to commute to a small scenic village out of a city. It was exactly as you describe: scenic and relaxing 25 minute train ride with not another soul on the train and it was always on time. Now I fly around a lot and it feels like half my life is draining away "waiting to get somewhere".
- 5y ago
- marderfarker2 5y agoIt’s not the commute that sucks, it’s the lack of sense of agency sitting in a public transport that starts and stops on a whim going to places you don’t care about.
- gruez 5y agoSo sitting in bumper to bumper traffic is better?
- inglor_cz 5y agoTried both. Both suck. I can at least read when I am not driving, but random smelly individuals do not enter a private car. I no longer own a car, but the fact that it was fairly clean was enjoyable.
- skrebbel 5y agoTraffic jams form a similar kind of agency loss.
- nerdponx 5y agoI personally am not bothered by the agency loss. In fact I want the agency loss; it's my thinking and mind-wandering/clearing time. But driving itself can be very tiring, at least if you are trying to drive safely. That's the main reason I don't ever want a driving commute longer than 30 minutes, but would be okay with a longer transit commute.
- marderfarker2 5y agoReally depends on where you live. In where I reside being stuck in traffic driving to precisely where I want is faster than being stuck in traffic on a bus.
- partido3619463 5y agoInteresting. I find it liberating because you can completely tune out the world. Don’t have to pay attention to anything.
- sneak 5y agoThe times (of NY) is reporting that 50% of tube riders in London are going maskless, despite masks being ostensibly required. That's a good reason as any to tell any boss pushing for in-person work to go to hell. From TFA: > “I really don’t want to be on the tube in rush hour, even with my mask on, because a lot of people aren’t wearing masks. I’ve been double jabbed, but the tube is an incubator for the virus.” Maybe the expensive-ass government should do its fucking job and start fining or banning anyone taking public transit that is maskless or dicknosing. If people were smoking in the tube they'd be fined or arrested. Five minutes of covid exposure is much more damaging to a person than five minutes of passive smoking.
- nerdponx 5y agoMy understanding is that surgical masks don't really work when you're jammed in a small space for a long period of time. There was a thread here recently with a lot of studies linked in it. It seems like masks can only extend your expected time-to-infection inside a building by several minutes.
- sneak 5y agoMaybe they should mandate n95/ffp2 then. They're not expensive now.
- _ph_ 5y agoIn Germany FFP2 masks have been required in most places which require masks for many months. They make a huge difference in tight spaces. I can't really imagine not using a FFP2 mask where I would wear a mask in the first place.
- sneak 5y agoI'm in Berlin and even in the Starbucks in Potsdamer Platz some of the staff aren't wearing masks inside. The other places I have seen where people need masks are mostly just the surgical (non-sealing) type, and half are dicknosing on top. Hopefully the rest of Germany is being less stupid and actually enforcing the rules.
- proc0 5y agoEvery day at the same time, with everyone else, jamming the roads and public transportation. It causes so many problems to clog the system that way, and also it's boring to repeat the same day, every day, every week. I never understood the need for having everyone in at 9am, and leave at 5pm like a flock of birds migrating for food. Office hours could be staggered, since some roles don't need that strict timeframe, and it would alleviate the strain on the system.
- zemvpferreira 5y agoThe coordination works wonders for the rest of your life though - when you work shifts/weird hours it makes it difficult to spend time with your loved ones who work regular hours. Jams are the price we pay for social convenience.
- vladvasiliu 5y agoI don't think the point is to go to any extremes. Here in Paris, practically every one seems to start at around 9:30, give or take, and leave by 6:30-7. If you move things around a bit, even by an hour, it could help a lot. Bonus points for this not being fixed, so if you need to synchronize with friends working elsewhere, you could come in later or earlier that day. I, for one, started doing this at work "on my own": I'd show up at the office at 8 AM, and leave by 5:30 at the latest. This way I could avoid rush hour, dividing my commute time by 3. This didn't prevent me from seeing friends, etc in the evening.
- _fat_santa 5y agoFor me my breaking point was in mid 2019 before the pandemic even started. I was a contractor at an F500 and had to be in the office one morning at like 8:30AM so I could attend an "All Hands" meeting. Sat in traffic for close to an hour just so I could drink shitty coffee while watching the VP's of this company jerk off to each other's accomplishments for 2 hours. I don't know why it hit me that day but I just felt sick of my time not being respected. Like yeah I get it if I have to be in early for a meeting that I have to take part in, but don't ask me to come in early so I can listen to things other divisions in the company did that have no bearing on my job (this place was a conglomerate so the other divisions were in totally different industries than mine). After that day I started to ask my team to work from home more and more. When I got sacked in March 2020 I took a remote job and have no plans to return to an office ever.
- Sanguinaire 5y agoWhether working in the office is preferable or even necessary is going to come down to individual teams, not whole companies. The employers who figure that out quickly will do well out of the current labour shortage. Any business insisting on 100% in office or 100% remote is limiting themselves to a subset of the eligible workforce, so it'll be interesting to see how quickly they get out-competed.
- luffapi 5y agoWhen you go 100% remote, you have a massive potential workforce, orders of magnitude more potential employees than those that happen to live within commuting distance to the office. The reason you go 100% wfh is because then all of the systems and relationships are tuned to remote work, which when done right is far superior to the daily office grind, middle management hell, “how was your weekend” small talk, documentation via dropping by someone’s desk… Wfh will ultimately win here because it’s far better suited to information work than being ever present physically in a pseudo-factory.
- Sanguinaire 5y agoI think over a longer timescale (~a decade) I would tend to agree. In the short term, there are too many people addicted to face-to-face work environments; often I feel that this is more down to office politics than productivity, but it'll persist for as long as it is effective in giving a career advantage.
- luffapi 5y agoFor a long time, it’s been true that the internet can help your career far more than whoever works in your office. Open source contributions, emailing people asking for advice, engaging people on social media… all the way up to raising money. The future was already here, it was just unevenly distributed. COVID forced some who were holding out to face reality of a global, distributed work force.
- Sanguinaire 5y ago
- 71a54xd 5y agoPrior to the pandemic I was heavily biased, primarily due to my ADHD, to work in an office setting or at least in a co-working space of some kind. College was a persistent struggle, as I was basically unable to prevent myself from being distracted or sleeping if I was working from my apartment or my room. When covid hit, I'd just started a new job in New York (ironic that my timing was really that bad) and I reached a point where I had to break bad habits. I went through about four "waves" of breaking these habits, as painful as that was it was still progress. There was hope for a new office in August, but that basically didn't happen. I also moved back home when my prior lease was up, because why on earth would I pay to live in New York when half the city is still closed along with insane rent. Cut to now, I was looking forward to going back to new york for the end of my 20's, however at this time I don't really see the point anymore. Being social is a farce (either at work or in person), I'm used to having more space and frankly the financial side makes immense sense. Remote work used to be something I was very against and unexpectedly I now welcome it. I also have bad acne, so the lack of social anxiety with that in a work environment is another plus. I guess I see my time differently now, maybe I'll regret not being more social, but I feel like I got that out of my system in my early twenties living in big cities since I was 19?
- polynomial 5y ago"Don't commute; communicate." -Arthur C. Clarke (1:50) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1vQ_cB0f4w&t=7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1vQ_cB0f4w&t=7s
- woranl 5y agoCompanies that required employees to work in the office, who otherwise can work from home should be heavily taxed. Taxed for generating necessary emissions.
- woranl 5y ago*unnecessary
- miked85 5y agoAnecdote, but I and friends at other workplaces keep being told that we need to the return to the office for "company culture" - which is something I am not sure exists, or anyone other than management seems to be concerned with.
- dboreham 5y agoLots of psychology in the workplace. Some participants' self esteem is bound up with physical proximity to subordinates. Some lose their identity without physical location. Object constancy issues.
- co2benzoate 5y agoReplace culture with hierarchy and it may be easier to understand.
- Mister_Snuggles 5y agoAt my work, we've been told to go back to the office, however the messaging has been vague, contradictory, and ever-changing. For example, a few months ago the Telecom area announced that they purchased hardware to move our phone system into Microsoft Teams. Phone numbers would be moved over department by department, your desk phone would stop working once your number moved over, and here's some recommended headsets if you'd like one. Then, after the phone system switch was well underway, an email from the President announced that we'd all be back in the office in September and that WFH would no longer be a thing. On a positive note, the MS Teams telephone integration works really well, so regardless of where I work it's an improvement over the desk phones. Then, after I'd told my team to prepare for coming back full time, the messaging changed to "We're going to transition back to the office and you only need to be in two days per week, but we'll be back full time by January." Honestly, I'm not sure how I feel about returning to the office. I'm sure I'll get used to it much like I got used to working from home. And I'm sure my co-workers will get used to me leaving at exactly 4pm (thanks to the bus schedule) instead of staying a bit afterwards to finish whatever I'm working on. From the rumours I hear though, not everyone is feeling the same way. I know of five people that have left who would have likely stayed if they could work from home. On top of all of this, COVID cases in my province are skyrocketing (10% of Canada's population, but 35% of its cases) and our elected leaders have disappeared. Apparently the Premier is finishing up a two-week vacation next week, so maybe we'll see restrictions re-imposed at the last minute and returning to the office will be postponed.
- walshemj 5y agoI just noticed the comment about WFH and traveling costs, if your a home worker then traveling into the office is paid expenses.
- mkw2000 5y agoI will never do it again , unless i find myself in some dire circumstances
- fassssst 5y agoI’m looking forward to it, but I’ll be commuting by ebike more often now. Less bus and train, more exercise!
- mikewarot 5y agoThere are two types of commute. The first is where you don't have to take an active interest in your surroundings, you are free to use a laptop, read a book, chat with your friends, or even sleep. This commute allows you to spend the time how you like, and can be quite rewarding. The other type of commute is when you are required to pay continuous attention to your environment for your safety. I played "pay attention or die" (aka driving) on 2 of the top 10 most congested expressways in the country as part of my daily commute... being able to have a friend along for part of it helped, but that time is never truly your own. I imagine it's the same for using a form of public transit that is less than safe, especially as anyone other than a large old grumpy white guy. Transition time in the first case can be quite rewarding, although both are a tax.
- ghaff 5y agoI had about a 90 minute commute for a bit over a year that required getting up at about 6am. Still wasn't great.
- benhurmarcel 5y agoEven the first case isn’t often that nice, because it’s only a fraction of the time that you’re not busy. For example I went to work by local train for a while, but in practice it was a 10 minutes walk, a 5 minutes wait, a 5 minutes ride, a 10 minutes wait, a 20 minutes ride, then a 10 minutes walk. So in 1 hour there was only 20 minutes “free”.
- filoeleven 5y agoThe company I work for can have me back at the office again if they drastically increase my salary. Otherwise, I’ll take the 20% raise I could get from switching jobs to a fully-remote company, skip the drive, and get closer to my actual market rate.