11 ms·
Forget privacy: you're terrible at targeting anyway (2019)
- dang 5y agoDiscussed at the time: Forget privacy: you're terrible at targeting anyway - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19055119 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19055119 - Feb 2019 (109 comments)
- blunte 5y agoTargeted ads have been useful to me about 1 time in the last 5 years. Being generous, maybe as many as 5 times. The other 99999 ads I've had to endure have either been for something I just do not care about, or more frustratingly for something I already own or currently pay for. If targeted ads worked at least 25% of the time, I might even appreciate them. But they are virtually worthless. People paying to run ads are suckers, because there's no way their ads get much real, useful business. Social marketing and other approaches just must be more effective.
- Jensson 5y agoTargeted ads isn't about targeting people who are very likely to buy the product, they just target people who are slightly more likely than average to buy the product. Take the classical example "I just bought a vacuum cleaner, why do I get lots of vacuum cleaner ads?", well the reason is that people who just bought a vacuum cleaner sometimes are unhappy with the purchase and buy another one. The probability isn't high, but still higher than the probability that a random person would want to buy one. It might still feel like just noise to the person seeing the ads, but to the advertiser getting 20% higher conversion rate is huge (or whatever number they are getting).
- changoplatanero 5y agoHave you considered that the targeted ads might have worked on you without you realizing it? You might have clicked on an ad and it was such a non event for you that it never made it into your long term memory.
- Swenrekcah 5y agoI think you’re describing adverts disguised as content. They can be either context or target based, scummy in either case.
- blunte 5y agoI very much doubt that I have fallen for a ruse like this. However, with all the cookie and newsletter popups, it has happened that an object moved on screen as I was clicking, and I ended up clicking some stupid ad. I don't count that since it wasn't my intention nor my mistake.
- stronglikedan 5y agoTargeted ads have been very useful to me, but I do game the system a bit. When I start seeing targeted ads for irrelevant things, I just do some searches for things I like to look at, and shortly thereafter, all of the ads I get are for things I like to look at. It's a few minutes of effort once every couple of weeks, but I feel the results are a lot less intrusive.
- JohnFen 5y agoHow are they less intrusive? Perhaps they're more "accurate", but that's a different thing.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y agoI can't help but feel that the whole advertisement and "ad targeting" business is built upon quite a few lies and a dose of misinformation to make the whole thing seem way more effective than it is.
- marcus_holmes 5y agoTangentially related but getting on my nerves a lot recently: Ad targeting for stuff that I've just bought. Worst offender: Remarkable - really good product, love mine, but I'm still seeing their ads everywhere. I'm not going to buy a second one. It's almost confidence-inspiring. Like how evil-overlord can this be if they can't even get this basic stuff right?
- dazc 5y agoIronically, I didn't know what 'Remarkable' was so had to search for it.
- new_guy 5y agoStrangely enough I only heard about them the other day, and now I'm constantly getting ads for them on FB and seeing them mentioned everywhere.
- kgwxd 5y agoThey just got you to advertise for them.
- marcus_holmes 5y agohehe, true. I'm OK with that for this case.
- marcosdumay 5y agoAt least is not targeted with user data.
- marcinzm 5y ago>I'm not going to buy a second one. I suspect the % of people who buy a second one for themselves, their spouse, kids, friends, etc. (or recommend someone else to buy one) is higher than the % of other people who buy one for the first time. Neither number is large but as long as the former one is slightly larger it makes sense to pay money for that advertising.
- pessimizer 5y agoThe only people good at targeting are the ad platforms, and they don't use an algorithm. What they do is slice up an audience into interesting enough sounding chunks in order to attract ad buyers, who are their actual customers. There's no reason to think, however, that the ad buyers would be particularly good at figuring out the audience for their product, or that a particular product necessarily even has an audience. So you would expect the vast majority of ads to be bad.
- reaperducer 5y agoThe only people good at targeting are the ad platforms Honestly, I don't see it. The ad tech industry keeps telling everyone that there are plenty of people out there who see advertisements that matter to them, and they're happier because of it. But my experience has been the opposite. Ever since "ad tech" became a thing, and online advertising started going after people and not context, it just seems to have gotten worse. Just in my open tabs right now: An ad for a food product I cannot consume for medical reasons. An ad for a local pizza joint in a city a thousand miles away. An ad for something to use on body parts that I don't possess because of my gender. Advertising was a solved problem. But as is often the case, a small group of people within the SV bubble decided to reinvent the wheel, and did so badly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 5y agoAdtech isn't particularly complicated. Ad Targeting, broadly fits into these categories (with limited and over simplified descriptions): Geographic - Where are you viewing the ad from? Contextual - What is the content surrounding the ad? Demographic - What do we know about you based on context? (sites have demographics) Behavioral - What did you buy in the past? Appliance - what you are using to view the ad be it a toaster or Chrome on Windows? There are all sorts of possible reasons, to your observed targeting failures. > An ad for a food product I cannot consume for medical reasons. How would an ad company know that? > An ad for a local pizza joint in a city a thousand miles away. This is a geographic targeting failure, unless - you are on a VPN where the IP is misrepresented or you have purchased from the location before. > An ad for something to use on body parts that I don't possess because of my gender. This could be contextual or simply dumping impressions to meet a campaign run expiry. > a small group of people within the SV bubble decided to reinvent the wheel, and did so badly. Nope. So you are disappointed the heuristics don't have more concrete data about you? It's the same as it always was. Smaller and new(er) companies have different priorities for what to focus on, but it's all the same tech.
- woliveirajr 5y agoOnce I was searching for a surprise vacation for family. After buying it, ads began to pop not only in my notebook but at any device at home, no matter who was using wich device.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aeturnum 5y ago> See, the problem is there's almost no way to know if you're right. It turns out that this doesn't matter a lot of the time. You only notice because the advertising to you is bad - but once you can notice the money has already changed hands. I've worked with people who work on what is variously called "data zombies" or "data shadows" or "data doubles" and the problem is that: they often get it wrong and they do not care and pretend it's correct. This is doubly-concerning in the security realm (i.e. the NSA is only supposed to read data streams of non-Americans so they have a lot of incentive to produce classifiers that guess that things are not from the US).
- ericholscher 5y agoThis has been our experience running an ad network that only does content-based targeting (https://www.ethicalads.io/ https://www.ethicalads.io/). As noted in the article, simple heuristics and topics are plenty to target ads, and provide great value for both advertisers and publishers. We're also cutting out all the ad tech middlemen who take a cut, keeping the value in the developer ecosystem, and keeping the web more private & secure. We basically let someone like Sentry or Twilio target JS developers with a specific ad about their JS integrations. They can link to JS-specific landing pages with sample code, etc. It works super well, and doesn't require anything beyond knowing the content of a page.
- float4 5y agoVery inspiring stuff! Given that "simple heuristics and topics are plenty to target ads", is it correct to assume that your payout/cost is similar for publishers/advertisers compared to networks that target users?
- ericholscher 5y agoThat's the goal! It definitely varies by audience & location, but generally we're pretty competitive.
- fxtentacle 5y agoGreat article :) "Embarrassingly, the trackers themselves don't even need to cause a slowdown, but they always do, because their developers are invariably idiots who each need to load thousands of lines of javascript to do what could be done in two"
- seemcat 5y agoHaha yeah, I'd really like to hear this story.
- Jiro 5y agoData that is incorrectly analyzed much of the time is still a privacy threat, and sometimes a bigger privacy threat. It's bad enough if your purchases are correlated with being a terrorist, but having your purchases sometimes incorrectly correlated with being a terrorist is worse.
- mynegation 5y agoThe thesis of the article might be true, but this is a reason to be more careful with private information, not less. If companies are sloppy in analyzing gathered data and do not value it enough, they might not very good at safeguarding it from bad actors who will use it to their advantage more “efficiently”.
- seemcat 5y agoGood point. But if trackers and profilers aren't that good/accurate at analyzing the data, what makes us think that bad actors are any better at it?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cormacrelf 5y ago> Let's be clear: the best targeted ads I will ever see are the ones I get from a search engine when it serves an ad for exactly the thing I was searching for. Everybody wins: I find what I wanted, the vendor helps me buy their thing, and the search engine gets paid for connecting us. I don't know anybody who complains about this sort of ad. It's a good ad. Not the point of the article, but it's typically the vendors who complain. Other vendors can and do buy up ad space on their keywords, pushing the thing you were searching for further down the page. Search for Miele vacuums, get an ad for Dyson. Now Miele has to buy up ad space for the keyword "miele", which it worked hard to get name recognition for. Some people think this is a bit like extortion, but really it's just the cost of people being able to find your product in 0.00045s. The search engine is just charging the vendor for the service.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> it will recommend you interview people with male, white-sounding names, because it turns out that's what your HR department already does His linked article (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-amazon-com-jobs-automation-insight/amazonscraps-secret-ai-recruiting-tool-that-showed-bias-against-women-idUSKCN1MK08G https://www.reuters.com/article/us-amazon-com-jobs-automatio...) says nothing about white or white-sounding names. And I sincerely doubt that anybody's HR department is screening out non-white sounding names for technical roles. Certainly nowhere I've ever worked - I can't remember the last time I saw a resume that wasn't Indian, male or female.
- 542354234235 5y ago>We perform a field experiment to measure racial discrimination in the labor market. We respond with fictitious resumes to help-wanted ads in Boston and Chicago newspapers. To manipulate perception of race, each resume is assigned either a very African American sounding name or a very White sounding name. The results show significant discrimination against African-American names: White names receive 50 percent more callbacks for interviews. We also find that race affects the benefits of a better resume. For White names, a higher quality resume elicits 30 percent more callbacks whereas for African Americans, it elicits a far smaller increase.[1] >researchers created resumes for black and Asian applicants and sent them out for 1,600 entry-level jobs posted on job search websites in 16 metropolitan sections of the United States. Some of the resumes included information that clearly pointed out the applicants’ minority status, while others were whitened, or scrubbed of racial clues…Twenty-five percent of black candidates received callbacks from their whitened resumes, while only 10 percent got calls when they left ethnic details intact. Among Asians, 21 percent got calls if they used whitened resumes, whereas only 11.5 percent heard back if they sent resumes with racial references[such as name changes, removing membership in organizations, scholarships, or achievements that might reveal race]. [2] >Researchers from the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Chicago sent 83,000 fictitious applications for entry-level job postings to 108 Fortune 500 employers, using randomly assigned and racially distinctive names. They found that distinctively Black names on applications with reduced the likelihood of hearing back from an employer by 2.1 percentage points relative to distinctively White names. But differences in contact rates varied substantially across firms. About 20% of the companies were responsible for roughly half of the discriminatory behavior in the experiment. [3] [1] https://www.nber.org/papers/w9873 https://www.nber.org/papers/w9873 [2] https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/minorities-who-whiten-job-resumes-get-more-interviews https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/minorities-who-whiten-job-resumes... [3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-07-29/job-applicants-with-black-names-still-less-likely-to-get-the-interview https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-07-29/job-appli...
- vmoore 5y agoWhat (nob obvious) ways do people avoid leaving a huge data trail? I'm not talking about the obvious stuff, like not carrying a smartphone, using an AD blocker, choosing privacy-aware operating systems and apps etc I mean, what non-obvious ways are there which people employ to avoid getting their data harvested for AD targeting?
- nicbou 5y agoI think that you covered most bases already. I'd add these: pay with cash, use throwaway emails for everything, scramble anything that can be used to fingerprint you, give false information unless you have a reason not to, move to a cabin in the woods, speak in code, wear a wig.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYour purchase history is probably the largest, most useful, and most difficult-to-hide signal. It can be directly accessed through credit and debit payments, as well as contactless payment mechanisms. It's increasingly possible through facial and other biometrics data. It is specifically associated with spending patterns. Travel data are available through licence plate scanners, tollway tokens, and transit passes, as well as, again, biometrics. Anything online leaves a very fat and wide trail, of course. Your employer's payroll processor would be another data channel. That's going to be available to other prospective employers, increasingly. Utilities data might also be available. Auto repair and smog-station data are collected and reported, and often sold to insurance companies for rating purposes. (Distance driven correlates strongly to risk.)
- helen___keller 5y agoI briefly hit a period right around when I bought a home that the recommended ads on instagram were really really good. I bought a bed and a sofa from instagram recommendations, and looked at a whole bunch of other things that I didn't end up buying. Nowadays it's back to being garbage, but I have to imagine every now and then these algorithms hit a gold mine like they did with me.
- ahupp 5y agoMy Facebook ads are well targeted: I've bought tickets to a book signing for my daughter's favorite author, and awesome map, a couch (!!), and a great pair of underwear off fb ads. I'm sure there's other stuff I'm forgetting. You could imagine an alternate world where FB has total information about my online activity, and the ads are extremely useful because they know what I want before I do.
- thom 5y agoI think it would help dispel the suspicion that the Facebook ad targeting algorithm itself wrote this, if you added a little disclaimer that you work(ed) there.
- ahupp 5y agoFair enough: I did work there, though never on ads, and it's been a few years. To be clear, I realize the privacy tradeoffs are probably unacceptable and I'm not seriously proposing the FB panopticon. But I do think it's an interesting thought experiment to consider how good this could be without constraints.
- jamestanderson 5y ago>they know what I want before I do. Or did they tell you what to want?
- alexslobodnik 5y agoGood targeting is acquiring customers at a profitable cost. Bad targeting is acquiring customers at an unprofitable cost. The difference can be 5% conversion for a segement of prospects vs. 10% for another. In both instances the majority of prospects are not interested. Or more charitable, not interested right now. Expectations for perfect ads and targeting is unreasonable.
- SamirNP 5y agoi think your camera photos seem to be the hottest cake.to get cool ads move your cool images(downloaded or created) to the camera folder in your.AI will "think" you are visiting "these cool places" and "snapping lambos,jets,rubber banded cash" like some really rich person. suddenly i bet you will start seeing the rich traveler's ads. not your damn activity mirror
- fsflover 5y agoThis is completely missing the point of why one should fight surveillance. Surveillance harms journalism and activism, making the government too powerful and not accountable. If only activists and journalists will try to have the privacy, it will be much easier to target them. Everyone should have privacy to protect them. It’s sort of like freedom of speech is necessary not just for journalists, but for everyone, even if you have nothing to say.
- vineyardmike 5y agoI agree, but this is a compelling reason for businesses as to why they should stop spending ("wasting"?) the money and make their product worse. This article doesn't really compel individuals to act differently.
- paulsutter 5y agoThis is no more than Sturgeon's law (90% of everything is crap). Beyond that no, you cant do GPT-3 or Yolo or even MNIST[1][2] with a dumb heuristic. > almost everything produced by ML could have been produced, more cheaply, using a very dumb heuristic you coded up by hand, because mostly the ML is trained by feeding it examples of what humans did while following a very dumb heuristic [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MNIST_database https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MNIST_database [2] http://vision.stanford.edu/cs598_spring07/papers/Lecun98.pdf http://vision.stanford.edu/cs598_spring07/papers/Lecun98.pdf
- truculent 5y agoSome good complementary links on this topic: • "Ads Don't Work That Way" (https://meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/ https://meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/) • "Why Online Ads Haven't Built Brands" (https://adcontrarian.blogspot.com/2019/01/why-online-ads-havent-built-brands.html https://adcontrarian.blogspot.com/2019/01/why-online-ads-hav...) Both discussing theorems for how advertising actually works, and why targeted advertising is counter-productive (for medium-to-large brands, anyway). The basic premise is that advertising works by seeding common-knowledge within a society. It's important not just that I know that Nike makes cool sneakers, but also that I know that my peers know that. Otherwise, how can I be sure that my idea of cool sneakers is the same as everyone else's? Culture exists in the interactions between people; for brands, hyper-targeted ads risk focusing on individuals and not cultural influence.
- MarkMc 5y agoThis article is wrong to assume targeted advertising requires complex machine learning algorithms. Here are some personal examples where my ads have been poorly targeted: - I'm actively looking to buy a house for more than a million dollars, and I'm signed into my real estate app using my Google email address. Meanwhile YouTube is showing me ads for Candy Crush Saga. - A week ago I almost bought an iMac on Apple's website but bailed at the credit card payment screen. I had logged into my Apple account with my Google email address, yet since then I've not seen one ad to suggest I should buy that iMac (although I do see Apple ads for iPhone on Twitter) - Twitter kept showing me Disney Plus ads even after I signed up - In 2019 on holiday in Bali I saw YouTube ads in Indonesian, despite being logged in and being unable to speak that language
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoI am amazed that, in 2021, people who read HN are seeing ads.
- lanevorockz 5y agoSays the influential politician being blackmailed for something that happened decades ago. Privacy is the only way to have a civilised society with a functional democracy