15 ms·
>Only around 8% of Swedes live in households spending more than 40% of disposable income on housing, compared to 15% in the UK and almost 40% in Greece, accordi
by pydry 5y ago
>Only around 8% of Swedes live in households spending more than 40% of disposable income on housing, compared to 15% in the UK and almost 40% in Greece, according Eurostat data.
I wonder what metric they use for "not working".
It's not like a lack of rent control is creating vast new supplies of housing here in London and as far as Im aware the fastest period of homebuilding in NYC was in the 50-60s when rent control was at its strictest (https://cbcny.org/sites/default/files/media/image-caption/Housing%20Production%20Tables%20and%20Figures-01_2.png https://cbcny.org/sites/default/files/media/image-caption/Ho... ).
- marcinzm 5y ago>It's not like a lack of rent control is creating vast new supplies of housing here in London and as far as Im aware the fastest period of homebuilding in NYC was in the 50s when rent control was at its strictest. They started to remove rent control in the early 50s due to a housing shortage. So by your argument removing rent control helps increase supply. http://www.tenant.net/Oversight/50yrRentReg/history.html http://www.tenant.net/Oversight/50yrRentReg/history.html
- nivenkos 5y agoIn Sweden it _only_ applies to first-hand contracts. So I don't think NY is a good comparison here. The main issue is that the government doesn't build enough. There are just nowhere near enough first-hand contracts, like not even the same order of magnitude. They've effectively abolished the system by just never building any, much like council housing in the UK.
- theonlybutlet 5y agoThinking this might have been the case... Good strategy amongst the more extreme neoliberals out there. Can see them doing it with the NHS too, play the long game, dismantle it piece by piece and then when everyone has forgotten what it once was like, the private solution becomes insatiable when compared to a disfunctional system that supposedly "never worked".
- pydry 5y ago>They started to remove rent control in the early 50s Your article says that it shifted from federal to state control in the 1950s, not that it was removed. Realistically they werent properly weakened until the 1970s.
- ARandumGuy 5y agoYeah, that sounds like rent control doing it's one job: preventing existing tenants from being priced out of the places they already live. I don't think there's a single advocate for rent control that believe it will solve all housing problems.
- marcinzm 5y ago>I don't think there's a single advocate for rent control that believe it will solve all housing problems. I mean, OP literally did that, erroneously implying that rent control increases supply by using a historically incorrect example from 50s NYC. This is why people get so annoyed with many proponents of rent control, they don't stop mid way as you do but keep going and implying it solves all housing problems.
- pydry 5y ago>I mean, OP literally did that, erroneously implying that rent control increases supply False. OP (me) was implying that it didnt meaningfully restrict supply. I suspect a longitudnal study would find the two variables to be tenuously related at best. >This is why people get so annoyed with many proponents of rent control Because they make wrong inferences?
- marcinzm 5y ago>False. OP (me) was implying that it didnt meaningfully restrict supply. The OP said "fastest period of homebuilding" with fastest being in italics. I don't see how that can be read as anything except saying rent control increases supply.
- pydry 5y agoNo. Absolutely not. It simply throws a huge amount of doubt on the prevailing narrative that it severely restricts supply. One could make the argument that it helped increase supply but that wasnt my intention.
- 5y ago
- chrisseaton 5y ago> It's not like a lack of rent control is creating vast new supplies of housing here in London They seem to be building as much housing in London as it's possible to do so - new blocks of flat flying up all the time.
- epistasis 5y agoIt's really hard to estimate the sufficiency of construction visually. What we notice is a change from the past trend. However what's needed is sometimes entirely disconnected from the past trend. Ask a lot of people in San Francisco, and they will say that there's been a huge amount of building of new apartments, even though they are nowhere close to matching the 2% growth rate of US population, much less the much higher growth rate that a thriving urban area needs to match the trend of people moving from rural areas to urban areas, or to match an increased preference for urban life over suburban life.
- zip1234 5y agoIt's because we see construction in a concentrated area where it is allowed, but then there are VAST areas off limits to anything but building a bigger house.
- rguillebert 5y agoThere's also pretty big restrictions on how high you can build in most places, I looked up the zoning document for Tower Hamlets and the parts of the borough allowing tall buildings is extremely tiny.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoRent control actually works great for the limited number of people who can get into rent-controlled housing. They love it! Unless you want to move to a different apartment, or have your friends move near you, or have any pressure on your landlord to improve the property, or… It’s everyone else who suffers the most. Usually they have no choice but to move somewhere else or stay at home with parents, so you can’t get an accurate picture by looking at aggregate household statistics. Unless you’re deliberately trying to ignore everyone excluded by these policies. Rent control is one of those policies that sounds great as long as you ignore second-order effects and pretend the population and economy never change. In practice it just creates a different system of haves and have-nots while removing any chance for the market to compensate.
- pydry 5y ago>It’s everyone else who suffers. Usually they have no choice but to move somewhere else or stay at home with parents A lot like London without rent control then, but if rent control were implemented it would be the primary culprit for what's happening anyway? Color me skeptical. Seems to me it's the landlords that really "suffer". E.g. the SF landlords that paid a tenant hundreds of thousands to get them out ( https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-business-san-francisco-4fa0a9df027a5c40855af209dedb88e3 https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-business-san-francisco-... ). Rent control just decides whether the "spoils" of restricted supply go to landlords with the most capital or the renters who lived in the city the longest. Hacker news cries bitterly about nimbyism (especially in SF) that restricts development to keep up property values and rents. Whom do they think is most incentivized to do that? Redirect those spoils to leveraged landlords and find out.
- Gimpei 5y agoThere is lots of research on this. Here's one heavily cited paper that finds what the previous poster was suggesting. Fine to disagree, but it would be nice to see some counter evidence. https://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/DMQ.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/DMQ.pdf In terms of London, there is also the problem of building restrictions. I don't think we're going to see tall residential towers popping up in say, Mayfair, anytime soon. I understand that this kind of change would completely transform the character of London. But the price of not wanting change is sky high rents.
- mc32 5y agoA realistic way to manage this demand issue has two options: build more units (can’t go on forever), or stabilize the population. Else, you double bunk or triple bunk like in Soviet times. You can’t magically solve a shortage via price controls.
- Retric 5y agoPopulation doesn’t grow that fast, you can build enough to keep ahead of the curve for a long time especially if you keep zoning in check. What nobody mentions is the real reason rents go up is an oversupply of jobs in the area vs housing. Keep the housing to office space ratio reasonable and rents never explode, except that shifts costs to business rather than individuals.
- luckylion 5y ago> Population doesn’t grow that fast You can't really look at country-wide population though. The population of e.g. Germany is pretty stable, but within Germany there's a lot of movement with people moving to the large cities. Rent is rising in those cities, while it's getting lower and lower the further you move from those cities.
- aidenn0 5y agoI think GP was suggesting that if you limited office space in the large cities, businesses would be priced out, which would reduce demand on housing.
- longlivedeath 5y agoUK has lots of politically-allocated housing too, but its main problem is that it's not adding enough new stock because of the restrictive planning system.
- spankalee 5y ago"politically-allocated housing"?
- longlivedeath 5y agoas opposed to market-allocated
- 8note 5y agoShouldnt that be public-allocated vs private-alocated? Both could be politically minded, or something else Actually, a market-allocated one is always a political allocation since it's got the idea that rich people deserve better housing than poor people asked into the market.
- Aunche 5y agoIt helps that Sweden has a significantly higher median gross income than either the UK or Greece.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y ago> the fastest period of homebuilding in NYC was in the 50s when rent control was at its strictest. A lot of things happened in the 1950s. How am I supposed to untangle cause and effect? I'd more likely credit the return of American troops from the war, the baby boom, home loans as part of the GI Bill, and the economic power of a country still ramped up for wartime industrial output, but existing in a world in which every other industrial power had been reduced to rubble.
- theonlybutlet 5y agoMy first guess is period of time in the early 70's known as The Great Inflation. Primarily driven by the abolishing of the gold standard. Not sure what the gold mining to construction rate was prior to this point but thereafter they could print it faster than they could build and this type of inflation where there is little growth in actual output creates asset bubbles. Just like this latest episode of quantitative easing has led to housing price inflation around the world right now.
- gbronner 5y agoNew construction was exempt from rent controls. So people built aggressively. But later, all of that new construction got regulated again, and construction has never picked up to that extent, due to the 'recapture'
- Yoofie 5y agoIs there a source for this?
- jcranmer 5y agoDon't forget that during WW2, the availability of construction materials was heavily curtailed due to diversion to war production. A fair amount of that homebuilding would have been making up for the lack of homebuilding in WW2 and consequent housing shortages.
- hackerNoose 5y agoI live in Sweden and I can attest that rent control is a disaster. Lofty political aspirations aside the simple truth is that the middle class does not want to live in the crime-ridden suburbs and will do anything to stay out of there. As that is the only place where you can rent they're forced into taking huge loans and buying something in the city, or they can try their luck on the unsurprisingly flourishing black market. The effect of this is that Sweden now has one of the highest private debt burdens in the world. As long as the prices keep going up the system keeps limping along, but if that would ever change there could be some interesting consequences.
- toxik 5y agoRent control is not the cause. These suburbs you correctly identify as undesirable would not become more palatable just because landlords were allowed to extract extortionate rents from an inherently limited supply resource. What you suggest would in fact probably lead to MORE segregation and MORE of the same issues. Wages don’t magically rise because you abolish rent control, either. You would simply price out the less wealthy to live… in the shitty suburbs.
- dont__panic 5y agoDo you have any links or additional information about the "crime-ridden suburbs"? As an American, I was really surprised to hear that another country has the opposite issue we seem to have: crime-ridden cities (particularly since Covid-19 started wiping out businesses and foot traffic in many city centers). I'm really curious why Sweden has more crime in the suburbs, and would love to learn more!
- tacker2000 5y agoSweden has a huge problem with violence in their suburbs: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/26/fatal-shootings-have-risen-in-sweden-despite-fall-across-europe-report-finds https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/26/fatal-shooting... https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/03/world/europe/sweden-crime-immigration-hand-grenades.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/03/world/europe/sweden-crime...
- 5y ago
- rory 5y agoHere's a more complete picture. Sweden is consistently among the least affordable across metrics: https://www.oecd.org/els/family/HC1-2-Housing-costs-over-income.pdf https://www.oecd.org/els/family/HC1-2-Housing-costs-over-inc... > The median burden of rent payments for tenant households is highest in Finland, the Netherlands and Sweden (30%), Norway (29%), and Denmark and the United Kingdom (28%) That said, it's not very different from its peers, so I doubt rent control is having a huge effect.
- ruddct 5y agoThe 50s-60s were a boom time compared to the following decades, but were nothing compared to the preceding decades. NYC's biggest building boom was the ~1900s-1930s, after which things fell off considerably. https://www.renthop.com/studies/nyc/building-age-and-rents-in-new-york https://www.renthop.com/studies/nyc/building-age-and-rents-i...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joefife 5y agoThe ONLY reason the BBC have published this article is because Scotland are proposing rent controls. The BBC have gone full union and need to knock any Scottish Government proposal. That is the only reason this article is published. Don't read too much into it.
- oh_sigh 5y agoNot the main point, but there is also a question of how accurate that 40% number for Greece is. From a western European perspective, tax fraud is rampant in Greece. e.g. In Athens, around 400 swimming pools were reported for tax purposes. But satellite analysis shows almost 17,000 houses have swimming pools: https://boingboing.net/2010/05/04/satellite-photos-cat.html https://boingboing.net/2010/05/04/satellite-photos-cat.html
- aidenn0 5y agoIt also sounds like the rent-control in Sweden isn't like that in other places. TFA at least implies: 1. It is universal 2. Rates are collectively negotiated between landlords and tenants This is more like a renters union that there is a 9 year waitlist to join than typical rent control. The impression I get is that Sweden has fewer people sharing flats and more affordable flat rents (adjusted for income) than most places in western Europe.
- pyrrhotech 5y agoSweden is a much richer country than the UK