17 ms·
Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed
- codingdave 5y agoI worked in the oil & gas industry about a decade ago. I recall a conversation with our CEO directly talking about renewables and the environment. He said, very clearly, that this entire industry is about money, and they will do whatever makes them the most money. If renewable ever paid more than oil, they'd go there. But direct from his mouth - it is 100% about money. If anyone doubts that they are greed-driven, just ask. They don't hide it.
- barbazoo 5y agoIsn't that just capitalism? Replace "oil & gas" with any other for profit organizations and the same would be true, no?. E.g. if being privacy focused could make Facebook even more money than what they're doing now, they'd do it, etc.
- aga98mtl 5y ago> Isn't that just capitalism? Soviet Russia was into oil production just as much as anyone else. The simple truth is that oil is very useful and the externalities are easy to ignore. The blame game is not useful for this situation.
- S_A_P 5y agoI’m not sure how that CEOs response differs from <insertanyindustryhere>. It is a rare case that you see a CEO decide that some other metric is more important than making money.
- qeternity 5y agoIt doesn't. It's a CEO's fiduciary duty to act in shareholders best interests. EDIT: HN, you're really getting juvenile. Save downvotes for low quality comments, not 100% factual comments that you simply don't like.
- Dylan16807 5y ago'best interests' can include priorities other than money.
- qeternity 5y agoNo, they can't. This isn't my opinion. This is opinion of the US legal system.
- b3morales 5y agoNo, that's not so; you're under a (common) misapprehension: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529520
- codingdave 5y agoWhile the pendulum goes back and forth on this issue, and in past decades, it did lean towards profits, I'm not aware of any regulatory enforcement of business decisions to maximize profits. Quite the contrary, almost all large businesses make charitable donations, which is the legal basis dating back to a 1956 NJ Supreme Court decision to support the legal rights to put social good above corporate profits. Even if that were not the case, we have recently swung to the other end of the pendulum, with corporate governance groups making an explicit change to work towards more than just profits a couple years ago -- https://fortune.com/longform/business-roundtable-ceos-corporations-purpose/ https://fortune.com/longform/business-roundtable-ceos-corpor...
- sharemywin 5y agoThe question is about long term interests versus short term. having an excellent qtr when you company falls off a cliff at the end of the year would probably be considered not looking out for share holder's best interest.
- qeternity 5y agoSure? All of these evil companies have had many, many good quarters (decades worth...which is pretty long term) and now have tens of billions of quarterly profits at their disposal to invest in wherever the next decades of demand will be.
- qeternity 5y ago> If anyone doubts that they are greed-driven, just ask. They don't hide it. They have a legal obligation to pursue profits for shareholders. This is their fiduciary duty. And they are like this because their consumers are like this. If people weren't so "greedy" demanding hydrocarbons at rock bottom prices, and instead wanted to pay a premium for solar powered EVs, well then hell believe me they would pursue those businesses. But the demand isn't there. Consumers are too greedy. Consumers don't want to change their behavior. EDIT: Downvotes, but no replies. Really HN, we just downvote people we disagree with? How about tossing your hat in the ring.
- throwaway894345 5y agoOf course this is absurd because consumers have no access to information about the emissions that factor into their products, and various corporations work very hard to prevent this kind of transparency (including misleading people on the calculus a la TFA). Not only that, but most consumers don't concretely understand the implications of "climate change" because most people can't summon a dozen climate researchers to do a study and communicate the results (indeed, in most places the actual studies are paywalled). And here too, corporations are deeply invested in making sure people believe that climate change is just a myth or that the implications aren't as severe as the science leads us to believe.
- thinkcontext 5y agoDo they also have a legal obligation to lie and fund disinformation?
- qeternity 5y agoComplete strawman. I never said this. Oil companies/execs should be held accountable for misdeeds. But that is a tiny fraction of the problem facing us. Let's say they came out decades ago and said "hey, there's probably going to be some repercussions for using our products" ... do you really think that would have changed anything? We know right now what needs to be done. And yet Biden is running around pleading with OPEC to increase production to bring gasoline prices down. Why? Because people want cheap hydrocarbons, no matter how many downvotes you throw at me.
- calkuta 5y agoTheir business is 100% dependent on our demand for their product. Who here has made a significant lifestyle change in order to reduce their personal contribution to oil consumption?
- Bostonian 5y agoBig oil is big because billions of people rely on hydrocarbons for transport, heating their homes, electricity, and many other things. Demonizing "Big Oil" is a way to evade the fact that people are not willing to pay large amounts to stop the world from warming a few degrees.
- j-pb 5y agoThat is ignoring the trillions of dollar this industry has spend on think tanks for the downplay of climate change, funding of paid for scientific articles to spread fud, funding conservative anti-science parties, lobbying for laws that actively hinder progress in renewable energies, hoarding patents on renewable energies, buying sustainable competitors and killing them. This is beyond "people don't want to pay more", this is "we could get the same energy but cheaper, but that wouldn't allow the very powerfull to exhauste an available resource to depletion before they move on and leave us all with the externalised costs".
- Proven 5y ago> That is ignoring the trillions of dollar this industry has spend on think tanks for the downplay of climate change Trillions? That's a lot!
- qeternity 5y ago> That is ignoring the trillions of dollar this industry has spend on think tanks for the downplay of climate change Hahaha oh my. Hyperbolize much? It's difficult to take the rest of your comment seriously after this. > This is beyond "people don't want to pay more", this is "we could get the same energy but cheaper, but that wouldn't allow the very powerfull to exhauste an available resource to depletion before they move on and leave us all with the externalised costs". You don't understand economics. If you make a bad thing cheaper, people will consume more of that bad thing, depleting it and screwing over the environment even faster. Fossil fuels need to be much much more expensive so people stop burning them. You can't have it both ways. Oil companies may be bad and evil, but you don't even have a tenuous grasp on the topic.
- ryan93 5y ago
- thehappypm 5y agoPeople act like oil companies are the ones burning oil. They’re just responding to demand. We need to make oil less competitive, with better alternatives. No point or even value in demonizing these companies — the whole world is complicit.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> People act like oil companies are the ones burning oil. They’re just responding to demand. No, they’re not. > We need to make oil less competitive, with better alternatives. Like tobacco companies, oil companies have actively lied and lobbied to maintain demand and obstruct coordinated effort of exactly the kind you describe as necessary. They are not passive actors simply responding to demand as they find it.
- relax88 5y agoThey are doing both. Cigarettes are a luxury item. Petroleum products are a requirement for modern life. You could fire all of the corporate PR propagandists and lobbyists on the planet and I doubt it would make a dramatic dent in oil consumption. Couldn’t possibly hurt though!
- mindslight 5y agoIf you want to frame this in terms of the demand side, then downsizing all of the PR propagandists would be a great start, along with all the other zero sum jobs. Instead of efficiency gains causing people to work less and consume less resources for the same output, central banks insist on "full employment" stimulus that creates make-work jobs to compensate. And despite their utility being zero-sum, these workers are churning hard in the rat race - buying new cars, fancy clothes, big houses, and other wasteful spending as they're time strapped. If instead of churning these people were allowed to just retire, they would use much less resources. But it seems like we can't insist on financial reform to slow down the economy, because every crisis becomes an excuse for the central banks to pump the gas while scaring people with the deflation bogeyman. And so we're stuck focusing on direct intervention to prevent the ever growing throng of antiproductive labor from doing as much damage.
- someguy321 5y agoThe Guardian coined the headline "Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed" to blame big oil for our collective greed.
- anaerobicover 5y agoEasy snark on the headline contribute nothing positive to this site. Explain what fault you find in the Guardian premise and I will listen. For e.g., the sister comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28315019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28315019 perhaps share your view?
- paulgb 5y agoI upvoted the snark because I think in this case it's warranted. I see this article as part of a broader messaging shift to pin the blame for global warming on the N companies that pollute the most, which I don't think is productive. As an example of how absurd it gets, someone in my local nextdoor group posted something along the lines of “why should I reduce how much I drive when X% of emissions come from N companies”. Those companies are polluting so that you can drive!
- JulianMorrison 5y agoThose companies are polluting because they are allowed to. Only a society level response can rein them in. And then the individuals will change what they do, based on what is still available.
- paulgb 5y agoSure, a carbon tax would do essentially that, and I am supportive of it. But absent a carbon tax, the idea that I can morally just consume willy-nilly and blame “corporations” is crazy. It's a form of moral laundering. Exxon isn't spewing CO2 for the heck of it, they're doing so as part of a production process that eventually some consumer demands. That consumer should not be let off the hook so easily.
- bedhead 5y agoI love how people who drive cars, fly on planes, use plastic, get goods delivered by truck, etc etc, act like oil companies just pump oil out of the ground for fun then light it on fire. The mental gymnastics are impressive.
- toiletfuneral 5y agoNobody who travels ‘wants’ to burn oil. Capital decided oil is the most profitable way to deliver that. There was never a point where individual personal consumption habits could have changed this course.
- 542458 5y agoIt’s profitable because it’s physically efficient - fossil fuels are readily available and highly energy dense and relatively safe. Nothing else offers that. This isn’t some sneaky capitalist plot - the soviets burned lots of fuel as well. I’m not defending the continued dependence on fossil fuels, but let’s be realistic about how (externalities aside) fossil fuels are very, very good at what they do. The problem is those externalities have turned out to be pretty bad, and our economic systems have been slow to respond.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> fossil fuels are readily available and highly energy dense and relatively safe. Nothing else offers that. Your car or plane can't tell the difference between fossil hydrocarbons and biofuel hydrocarbons. (Though you might adjust a car to use ethanol instead of longer compounds.)
- andi999 5y agoDoes it still take 1l of (subsidized) fossil fuel to produce 1l of biofuel?
- Dylan16807 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- specialist 5y ago'Carbon Footprints' [2004] smells like Frank Luntz. So I quickly scanned OC. Nope. Ogilvy & Mather, a different repeat offender. Amusingly, sensing an opportunity in the fast growing climate crisis FUD services market, in 2008 they launched OgilvyEarth. https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=OgilvyEarth https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=OgilvyEarth Never let a good crisis go to waste.
- bsanr2 5y ago"Identity theft", likewise, is an attempt to put the onus - and blame - on consumers for the failure of corporations to protect personal information and combat fraud. We should be generally wary of corporate "Do your part!" campaigns.
- rdiddly 5y agoOf course larger-scale changes are larger. One problem is that when you argue for a large-scale change, people generally expect you to be not-a-hypocrite on the small personal level. Small-scale actions give authority to large-scale ideas/arguments.
- qeternity 5y agoGenuine question to all the anti "Big Oil" commenters here: what's your alternative? Let's imagine an alternate history where oil companies hadn't fought against climate change science. What does that alternate universe look like? We have known for years that climate change is real, and yet the vast majority of people simply won't actually change their consumption when push comes to shove. This is the largest, most serious, tragedy of the commons that we will likely ever face. This problem is so much more complicated than just blaming a few evil CEOs.
- germinalphrase 5y agoPerhaps we would already apply environmental legislation to CO2 as a pollutant such that carbon intensive industries and products would be more expensive and low carbon products/industry more competitive giving consumers more choice.
- j_walter 5y agoWho do you mean by "we"...because some countries don't give a shit about the impact they are having on the world and still pollute the air and water worse than EU and US countries 50 years ago (China, India, etc).
- drdeca 5y agoChina has a lower CO2 per capita emissions than the US. Of course, the environment doesn’t care about who has the most per capita emissions, just “cares” about the total emissions, but in terms of measuring efficiency of “how much CO2 needed to support the lifestyle of each person” it seems they currently have a better rate. Like, if you replaced a random subset of China with the population of the US, with another copy of the US, the total emissions would [edit:on average] be increased. Therefore, I think in order to get them to decrease their rate (which is important to do due to their large population/ their large total emissions), it may be useful to lower our own rate in order to have a convincing position.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nyerp 5y ago> "Say you have a certain amount of time and money with which to make change – call it x, since that is what we mathematicians call things. The trick is to increase that x by multiplication, not addition. The trick is to take that 5 percent of people who really care and make them count for far more than 5 percent. And the trick to that is democracy." > That is, private individual actions don’t increase at a rate sufficient to affect the problem in a timely fashion; collective action seeking changes in policy and law can. This is actually a description of the politics of "special interest groups" and it usually leads to horrible things. If an idea is only supported by 5% of the population, we generally do NOT want that 5% of the population driving the legislative agenda. Instead, ideas need to first gain broad support among the general population, at which point enacting legislation may be desirable in order to solve collective action problems such as preventing free riding.
- jfim 5y ago> If an idea is only supported by 5% of the population, we generally do NOT want that 5% of the population driving the legislative agenda. It depends. The other 95% of the population might be agnostic or unaware of the idea, or the other 95% of the population might be opposed to the idea. If Congress were to pass a law mandating funding for WWVB radio until 2050, for example, would even 5% of the population have an opinion on it either way?
- turbinerneiter 5y agoProbably, if you used words they know instead of acronyms they don't. "Do you want the radio signal that allows clocks to sync to keep running? Here is a list of devices you might know and use that rely on them: ..."
- olyjohn 5y agoI guarantee nobody would care. Even when you tell people the impact it might have on them... they may only have to replace one clock, or not any at all. Their cell phone clock works just fine.
- arbuge 5y agoBlaming climate change on the "greed" of oil companies seems to me just a way to avoid taking personal responsibility for one's own choices as a consumer. You really can't drive a massive SUV where a smaller vehicle or even a bike might work perfectly well and then yell at Exxon about their greed.
- Tijdreiziger 5y agoAnd you can't ride a bicycle or train where the infrastructure doesn't exist because of pro-car lobbying by the oil companies, and then yell at individuals about their 'personal responsibility'.
- arbuge 5y agoI'm going to hazard a wild guess here that there's a lot more pro-car lobbying going on by the car companies than there is by the oil companies.
- throwaway894345 5y ago1. Consumers don't have access to information they need to make climate-optimal decisions. 2. Oil companies lobby hard to make sure people lack the aforementioned information, specifically downplaying climate change. 3. SUVs are not even a drop in the ocean compared to industrial emissions. You're reaching hard to blame consumers for what is transparently industry's fault. We need to pass carbon pricing and decarbonize our energy sector.
- arbuge 5y agoRegarding 1 & 2, I think there's more than enough information out there at this point for anyone to figure out that large SUVs are worse than smaller vehicles or bicycles for the environment, regardless of whatever lobbying is going on by oil companies. Regarding #3, I don't know if your first statement is correct or not, but again it would seem to me that the consumer (industries in this case) would have their own share of responsibility, not just the oil & gas companies supplying them.
- SavantIdiot 5y agongl, their marketing teams are brilliant. yes, they are destroying the planet, but they certainly succeeded in driving the language/narrative.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoLanguage is way more powerful than people realize. Changing the language seems to literally change how we think.
- SCUSKU 5y agoWhile I'm no expert in propaganda, Newsspeak was certainly a major topic in Orwell's 1984. The purpose of Newspeak was solely to build language to control how people think about certain topics [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak#Thought_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak#Thought_control
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoDoublethink [1] also facilitates control. I expect this comment to be controversial, but I will express it nonetheless. Unsurprisingly, doublethink is very prevalent in online discussion boards, I have observed it in both progressive and conservative spaces. > Doublethink is a process of indoctrination whereby the subject is expected to simultaneously accept two mutually contradictory beliefs as correct, often in contravention to one's own memories or sense of reality.[1] Doublethink is related to, but differs from, hypocrisy. An example of this within conservative spaces is demanding freedom, but supporting fascism, such as the instance where the datascientist that reported covid cases from Florida was swatted by the police and had her computers and hardware confiscated. An example of this within progressive spaces is demanding equality across genders, but at the same time screeching about saving women and children from Afghanistan and sending men to die like pigs to the slaughterhouse. Or, supporting women's education and equality while supporting anachronistic systems found within religions that facilitate subjugation. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublethink https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublethink
- 5y ago
- LatteLazy 5y agoWe've known aboht climate change for 40 years. We've all individually and collectively chosen to ignore the problem. Now is the point where we lie and pretend no one told us and it was all somehow a conspiracy by big oil, big meat, big airline-travel etc to force us to emit when we didnt want to. Count me out.
- sharemywin 5y agoIf I benefited just as much as the CEOs where's my 5th empty mansion on the beach?
- ManBlanket 5y ago"Personal virtue is an eternally seductive goal in progressive movements" You don't say... Almost sounds like planting a sign in your yard enumerating the various reasons you're a good person is the brand of activism advocated by regressive causes. Doesn't matter if you do anything to advocate those causes, so long as you pretend to care. Broadcasting it to your other privileged friends and neighbors. That way you can continue business as usual while thriving on the status-quo, but rest assured you're on a pedestal above everyone who didn't plant a sign next to their stoop proclaiming activism. Printed free of regulation in SE Asia, wrapped in plastic, shipped across the ocean, and delivered to your front door. Now if only there were a way to wear it on your face...
- Hermitian909 5y agoA lot of comments here seem to be focusing on the fact that individuals use oil products beyond what is necessary for basic life and in fact do have some personal responsibility. This seems to me to be missing the forest for the trees. Sometimes society ends up in a situation where we need things that are not sustainable, like oil or coal. Producing those unsustainable products to meet the demands of society does not make the producers solely responsible for any side effects. What is immoral is trying to artificially delay the transition to more sustainable alternatives or to socialize the costs of doing business. Oil companies have repeatedly run well funded PR campaigns with the explicit goal of discrediting arguments that more sustainable energy technology was necessary despite knowing them to be false. Similarly, they have lobbied hard to ensure that when the impacts of oil to the environment are larger than expected, society picks up the tab. This lets them be more reckless with our communal environmental resources.
- glogla 5y agoWell said. I will never understand why people protect oil companies. You know how in comic books there's always a villain going trying to DESTROY THE WORLD and it seems unrealistic and over the top? Oil companies are this villain in the real world. They are doing their best to kill off humanity, for short term profit.
- namanyayg 5y agoBig oil downvoted this. Jokes aside, I really don't see the reason for downvotes. Oil made our world what it is; but any company who still focuses on its profits while knowing alternatives exist that are better for the planet, and parallelly spending billions in PR, is downright evil. I'd even say it's much more evil than Facebook's or Google's privacy issues that HN bashes every week.
- SuoDuanDao 5y agoWell, I'd say it's a bit funny to call something evil when a lot of people would die if it disappeared tomorrow. It's very easy to criticise the costs of modern life when the 'evil' is displaced onto someone else. But the truth is, it's a much more morally grey area than we like to admit. And it's hard to opt out of this 'system', but not impossible - I'm sure the Amish would take converts, but not many people want to go that route. It's an appealing story to say that the O&G economy is the villain and all the people participating in it are innocent, but the truth is, we know how to live in bronze age societies. This 'evil system' doesn't stick around because it holds us prisoner, it sticks around because most of us prefer the lifestyle. And a story that absolves us of responsibility for participating seems like just another defence mechanism the system has built up.
- datawaslost 5y agoHuh! It’s not every day you see your work called out in The Guardian as “insidious propaganda”! I worked for Ogilvy and Mather in the 00s and made the Carbon footprint stuff they mention, at least one version of it. Didn’t come up with the concept or wording, but was responsible for the web implementation in the US. AMA, I guess
- datawaslost 5y agoNot my proudest work, but this was pre-Deepwater and BP was honestly putting a lot of new money towards green and renewable projects. At the time, it felt like a step in the right direction.
- rfw300 5y agoDo you think it was wrong to do in hindsight?
- datawaslost 5y agoIt doesn't keep me up at night. In retrospect, it was probably one of the most dubious things I worked on in a decade of advertising, but I (mostly) left the industry because it was morally neutral, not outright wrong. It just felt like a big waste of talent and money, rather than "insidious"
- vanderZwan 5y agoI know someone who joined Shell with the hope of helping it transition to renewable technologies (and who was actively lured with that promise), and who later quit after they realized that Shell was just trying to get all capable people who could be working on sustainability stuff to work for them instead, then drip-feed them promises of change while tempting them to work on other projects and give up on those sustainability things with big sacks o' money. One might almost say "embrace, extend (the usage of oil), extinguish". With hindsight, do you think something like that was happening at BP too?
- 5y ago
- djanogo 5y agoIsn't Big oil coining "carbon footprint" similar to Big tech coining "FSD"/"Autonomous Driving"?, doing what they need to do to support their investments?
- TomAbel 5y agoControversial thought(not my opinion) Fossil fuels are good for the world, The reason we used them was because we did not have any real alternative at the time. For the vast majority of history, people were dirt poor. By utilizing fossil fuels we were able to lift billions of people out of poverty. Think about it, you cant really run an industrialized economy on 100% reneable energy. Wind and solar are variable energy sources the more we add to the grid the more storage you have use to balance it out. Hydro(which has its own environmental problems) and geothermal are constrained to certain regions which have favourable geography. Fossil fuels are literally stored energy that you can stockpile and use when you want to. We talk about replacing plastic but plastic is one of the greatest materials we ever made(its waterproof, light, flexible, we can shape it into any form and its cheap so it is accessible) just think about all the food we buy at the supermarket most of it is stored in some form plastic to keep it fresh( not talk about things it does not make sense to store in plastic ie fruit that's just silly/wasteful) Our modern world is built with cement just look around it is everywhere, we use asphalt to build our roads and steel to build means of transport ships, trains, cars etc We talk about decarbonization but some countries have not even really carbonized to grow their economy to what could be considered a decent standard of living. I can't see how we can look at 3rd world countries ie India/Africa and other 3rd world countries and tell them they can't grow their economies because we used up all the carbon "budget".
- majormajor 5y agoThey could certainly have been good for the world and also bad for the world going forward. We even have cliches about this, "too much of a good thing," etc. It's not a difficult concept.
- me_me_me 5y agolet me fix it for you > Fossil fuels 'were' good for 'the current human civilization, as it allowed to quickly develop technology at the cost of future' because we did not have any real alternative at the time.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoYou can run an industrialized economy on renewable energy. It just wouldn't look the same as the one we have developed in the presence of fossil fuels. If there were a colony of modern humans established on an Earth-like planet that lacked surface coal seams, didn't have limestone deposits for cement, and lacked oil fields, you wouldn't expect them to shrug and say "Well, back to the stone age, I guess." No, instead, they'd set up smart grid networks to use power when wind and solar were available and consume less energy when it was not. They'd use DC-DC converters that were more flexible under brownouts, where early energy systems didn't have that technology and had to rely on fixed transformers and fixed frequencies. They'd connect long distance, high-voltage lines between areas with hydro and geothermal energy to regions without, using pumped hydro storage when variable energy sources had excesses. Yes, they'd run Sabatier process factories to generate synthetic hydrocarbons for plastics and portable fuels, they'd precipitate calcium carbonate from ocean salts and atmospheric CO2 to make cements and ceramics; these would probably be less plentiful as a result of their cost and because they'd be aware that they don't decay but they wouldn't be nonexistent. Our energy systems are moving bit by painful bit in this direction already. Indian, African, and other growing economies are growing in a world where renewables are cheap, where we have tech that makes them more usable, and where there's a lot of knowledge about climate and environmental science so they don't have to make the same mistakes we did. Yes, the industrialized world works the way it does because of a history of fossil fuels. It may even have been impossible to jump-start the industrial revolution without them. But it doesn't have to remain that way.
- seanwilson 5y ago> But individual and collective action don’t have to be pitted against each other. Individual choices do add up (they just don’t, in McKibben’s terms, multiply). That vegan options are available at a lot of fast-food chains is because enough consumers have created a profitable market for them. We do influence others through our visible choices. Ideas spread, values spread, habits spread; we are social animals and both good and bad behaviors are contagious. (For the bad, just look at the contagiousness of specious anti-vaccination arguments.) Strong agree with this. I see people argue all the time that individual action won't do anything when it's at least a part of getting to a tipping-point where big changes are made. It's like the public (who want stuff), companies (who want money), governments (who want votes from the public and approval from companies) and countries are locked in a stalemate all pointing fingers at each other over who is responsible and should change first. Everyone has to do their part and stop making excuses. Eat less animal products, fly less and drive less where practical is the bare minimum everyone should be doing in my opinion instead of trying to cling on to unsustainable lifestyles as long as they're allowed to.
- dougmwne 5y agoThere is a heck of a lot of this that goes on within the energy and environment community where I have been involved for a decade. Tragedy of the Commons basically means that individual responsibility is a complete dead-end to solve any kind of shared resource issue. We've known this formally within economics for 200 years. Government, law and enforcement is the only solution, whether we're talking a city park or the entire planet's atmosphere. You should know that any time you are getting shamed or guilted into doing something like recycling, reducing energy consumption, cutting up plastic soda rings, instead of there being a law, some monied interest put a lot of effort into shifting the perception of responsibility away from themselves and onto someone else. I am a staunch environmentalist and I full out reject any effort to make any of this somehow my personal fault and that I should guiltily stop having children, stop traveling, stop eating, stop driving or anything else. We are either all in this together, collectively solving the problem through our collectively determined governments or we're not. More and more I think we are not going to solve this in a way that doesn't involve a massive diminishing of planetary carrying capacity. Currently we are bailing out the Titanic with a thimble.
- heurisko 5y ago> I should guiltily stop having children The unintended consequence is that only the conscientious people take themselves out of the gene pool, which is counterproductive.
- olyjohn 5y agoWell, their kids could still end up being assholes.
- birksherty 5y agoWhat is exactly counterproductive? These children will suffer the consequences in coming years, better they don't have to.
- heurisko 5y agoIt is productive to raise conscientious children who can meet challenges of the future. It will increase suffering, to remove the next generation of conscientious leaders, organisers, engineers, scientists.
- boplicity 5y agoThe climate crisis is too big to solve as an individual. Even if a million of us immediately stopped driving cars, and lived in a carbon-neutral commune nothing would change, in terms of the overall climate picture. The only way to solve this is to build new infrastructure that removes the need for carbon emissions, while also stopping oil extraction at an increasingly rapid pace. Anything else is a distraction, and that includes asking people to "help" by driving less. If you want people to make good choices, those good choices need to be made possible, effective, and meaningful. This is what our politicians have been avoiding. Here in Toronto, our local federal MP once posted on Twitter that he fights climate change by shopping at a local produce market. Not only was this absolutely not stopping climate change in any meaningful way at all, it reflects the absolute inability of the vast majority of politicians to communicate that they understand the severity of the situation, much less do anything meaningful about it.
- ivankirigin 5y agoBlaming supply or demand when you have an unpriced negative externality doesn't make sense. Tax carbon, and use the funds to pay for decarbonization. We'll get better and cheaper alternatives and carbon sinks. Many quote $100 to $1000/tCO2e. But if we get down to $10, getting to net zero and negative won't break the bank.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWho do you think opposes carbon taxes, why, and how do you think they express that will politically, and by what means of supporting that action? One of the largely unspoken truths of economics is that wealth is power. Actually, it was spoken, by Adam Smith, in The Wealth of Nations, but somehow that short, succinct, critical phrase is ignored in favour of a much longer one strung together out of multiple sections over hundreds of pages using what for Smith was not an explanatory mechanism, as it's often portrayed, but of a statement of ignorance, that a cause is unknown.
- i1856511 5y agoThis article is right. Individual liability for climate change is a con. The absolute best thing you can do as an individual for the climate is to never have existed in the first place. This sets your climate footprint to 0. However, even in this case, this does not change the trajectory of climate change at all. The hypothetical best is not good enough. So, individual liability is much ado about nothing.
- csours 5y agoI know HN just puts the title from the article, but I'd love it if we could add an OPINION when it's an opinion article.
- kumarvvr 5y agoI would have happily taken that blame, if not for the oil companies decades long and bad faith activities against climate change. Their lobbying, funding dubious studies, tactics of FUD, outright lying, etc. Those must have consequences. Why taxpayers are made to give billions to them every year is beyond understanding.
- arcanon 5y agoStep 1: electric aircraft Step 2: airstrike refineries
- amai 5y ago“People who don’t know the truth are dumb. But people who know the truth and lie about it are criminals. “ Berthold Brecht
- amai 5y ago"The revolution won’t happen by people staying home and being good." A wise quote from the article