6 ms·
This is about being careful what you put in writing, because the discovery process for lawsuits will find your carelessly written email and opposing lawyers wil
by skybrian 5y ago
This is about being careful what you put in writing, because the discovery process for lawsuits will find your carelessly written email and opposing lawyers will take it out of context, and do you want to end up in court years later explaining what you meant?
Google has so many employees that they need training to limit the damage from random chatter and speculation.
It’s more cumbersome to have to talk about some things via video chat, but it’s not about limiting thought.
- eawoifjaiowepfj 5y ago> discovery process for lawsuits will find your carelessly written email and opposing lawyers will take it out of context I don't work for Google or have much of an opinion on "Googlespeak". However, that the practice of law is allowed to exist in its current state is an indictment on our society. The legal profession is one that polices itself, has no proper oversight (judges are just lawyers with a more refined superiority complex), raises barriers to entry with a level of zeal only matched by medicine (to which it is not actually comparable), and is also allowed to maliciously and limitlessly wield this power over the people who do real work is a foundational problem with governmental design.
- _nalply 5y agoA hard-of-hearing friend of mine got tired listening to videos. He told me that he sneakily ran speech-to-text software and read the text in a separate window. In a different vein, when I was younger I didn't understand why people preferred phoning. I as a Deaf engineer rely on written communication. This exposes myself and people communicating with me to «showing what has been said». I am sure that in my career I missed some important information just because people weren't willing to create a persistent record of communication. My friend «solved» this problem, but I am sure his interlocutors would be miffed if they knew that.
- sa1 5y agoIt might not be intended to limit thought, just to avoid liability, but does it limit thought anyway?
- skybrian 5y agoIt might have some effect, but Googlers can read all the same stuff on the Internet as everyone else.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoHave you ever been a devout practitioner of a religion whose views on the world differ in key parts from the established scientific consensus? Have you ever been affiliated with a political party that was highly popular (or a monoparty even) in your country but was held in contempt by the rest of the world because of how totalitarian/inhumane it was? In both cases, you could read whatever, even critical information about your values. But you would have an explanation ready — enemies envy and slander us, they either know they lie or they are repulsed by the God's light because of how corrupted they are, they are not aware of the whole truth... You would have a whole arsenal to explain things away, because you are committed, and your commitment makes it hurt to realize that the purpose your values serve is not very noble, or that you're a part of something atrocious. It's the human nature.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoGoogle’s internal memegen website does not confirm that. I’ve never seen anything so critical of Google.
- skybrian 5y agoI understand what you’re getting at and there is certainly a lot of closed-mindedness going around. I don’t think any organization is immune to this. But there are also a lot of employees who have strongly opposed various Google policies and engaged in various political activity based on that, so the groupthink doesn’t seem to be working very well? Also, the company leaks like a sieve these days. Even before that, there were a lot of internal debates. (They just didn’t leak as much.) It’s in part because of these debates that you need policies; people sometimes say careless things in heated discussions. (Former Googler, but it’s been a while.)
- Johnie 5y agoMany large companies have the same policies/training for this very reason. You do not want to put something in writing that could potentially appear on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. The training/policies just codify that.
- titzer 5y agoThey also have a corporate email policy where mails get auto-deleted after 18 months, unless you apply labels or are on a litigation hold (which would make such policy completely illegal). The email policy has no other purpose than to limit legal exposure. There is no legitimate business reason for that policy. In fact, it actively harms institutional memory and is frankly Orwellian, IMHO.
- pixl97 5y agoI disagree. If its part of the institutional memory it should be documented on an internal site and kept. Not stuck in an email format to disappear.
- titzer 5y agoPersonally, I often refer back to emails of what people sent me in order to have proper context, both technical, logistical, etc. Instructions on how to do things, how we debugged something or other, etc. That makes me more productive and useful as well as other people. If we gotta write every email over again and put it up on a wiki, that just won't happen.
- owisd 5y agoWrite it on the wiki first then just email the link to the wiki. No additional effort and then the guy who joins two years after everyone on the email chain has left and now has to maintain it also has that info.
- titzer 5y agoI meant specifically, things like "Wait, who is this person? What did they want again? What did I tell them last time?" That's not stuff you put on a wiki.
- aix1 5y agoThis may or may not work for you, but I keep notes in a collection of Google docs. Depending on context, these are either shared with the other person (and usually editable by them) or is accessible only by me.
- zepto 5y agoWhy not both?
- ohazi 5y agoNo, that's just a convenient excuse. The other side of "Be careful what you put in writing because lawyers, lol" that is always ignored is: "If you think we need to dress up the way we talk about this one particular thing we're doing, then maybe we should reevaluate whether we should be doing this thing. If you think we need to dress up the way we talk about literally everything that this company does, then maybe it's time to step back and reevaluate the ethics of what this company stands for." A company is a machine that is going to do whatever it can to print money, including brainwashing its employees. You and your colleagues are the only entities capable of ethical reasoning. The company and its executive functionaries are not going to do this for you. In fact, they're more likely going to try and stop you. It's your responsibility to do it anyway.
- shadowgovt 5y agoWho is "we" and "you" in this context? At Google, the team responsible for deciding whether a given project is legal is the legal team. Googlers are encouraged to get a member of legal on board as soon as a project gels far enough to have a concrete description that could have legal consequences. At that point, a set of attorney client privileged communications could begin where any of the words listed here can be on the table (because that communication is not in discoverable media). But in general, Google doesn't encourage its software engineers to think they're experts in law any more that it encourages its lawyers to think their experts in BigTable performance tuning.
- CPLX 5y ago> the team responsible for deciding whether a given project is legal is the legal team Since legality in a corporate context is not typically a binary evaluation, it would be far more accurate to say that their job is to ascertain the relative financial and business costs of potentially illegal behavior so it can be effectively compared to that behavior’s potential profits
- ohazi 5y agoI'm not talking about what is legal, I'm talking about what is ethical. They are not the same. I'll grant you that not every corporate policy will agree with me, but I would argue that every human with a brain has a responsibility to think about whether what their boss asks them to do is ethical, and a responsibility to raise hell if they think it isn't. I don't believe it's ethical to abdicate this human responsibility to a corporate legal team. Part of what these corporate policies are deliberately designed to do is condition employees into believing that "deferring to the legal team" is where their responsibility ends. They want to convince you that this checks the box for both "legal" and "ethical" so that you feel like you've done your duty, and now you don't need to think about the ethics of your work anymore. This is what I meant by corporations "brainwashing" their employees. But you're always on the hook for the ethics of your work.
- CPLX 5y agoThis is what’s known as a Stringer Bell warning[0] and it doesn’t reflect well on the organization who has to make it this aggressively. Yes, it stands to reason that if you’re engaged in a potentially unlawful conspiracy you need to be careful what you put in writing. However if this is coming up constantly and prevents you from using common sense words for your regular business operations then it’s a pretty clear red flag that your actions may be subjecting you to legal liability. [0] https://youtu.be/pBdGOrcUEg8 https://youtu.be/pBdGOrcUEg8
- pyrale 5y agoFrom don't be evil to don't leave a paper trail...