5 ms·
If they’re spending the whole day in a classroom together the effect of masks is going to be minimal.
by Aeolun 5y ago
If they’re spending the whole day in a classroom together the effect of masks is going to be minimal.
- NationalPark 5y agoThat's simply not what the research has found. Edit: Allow me to clarify - the research everyone is citing that says masking is effective in teachers and ineffective in students (the 37% number) predates both the delta variant and widespread infection in Southern states. Further, masking is understood etiologically as a prevention method and has been used successfully in other outbreaks and in other countries. Clinicians and policy makers as a rule work with incomplete data in an emerging situation, so unequivocally stating that masking kids in schools doesn't help is a very bad misrepresentation of both the data/research and the implications to policy.
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoCan you provide a source? My understanding was that masks were primarily effective at preventing high viral load droplets from spreading the virus during short interactions. I don't have any source to prove that to be the case because data on the effectiveness of masks seems frustratingly sparse.
- gzer0 5y agoWhen a novel situation presents itself, sometimes we do not have all of data we would like and clinicians have to make judgement calls to the best of their knowledge. We may not have trials or studies (these things take time) to back a very certain and/or specific claim such as "do masks prevent the spread of Covid 19?" What we do have, is fundamental knowledge and common sense and so typically, in a clinical setting we ask these questions when any new situation arises (as it happens often in medicine): - Does this reccomendation cause more harm than good? - is there even a slight chance that this clinical decision would increase the percentage chance of survival? - is it worth the inconvenience it could cause? This is called Clinical Reasoning. Thinking critically and clinically is a core tenet of the field.
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoI don't disagree with anything you said, and I'm certainlynot an anti-masker, but was skeptical of the parent claim which seems to be "Research shoes masks are still effective even when spending the whole day in the same room" I'm not aware of any evidence that this is the case and I worry that people are putting too much stake in masks when really social distancing is much more effective than masks ever will be.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AdamN 5y agoKeep in mind the initial dose is highly relevant to the impact of the virus in your body. There's a big difference between getting a single virus, enough to cause an infection, and enough to be highly overwhelmed before your immune system kicks in.
- nradov 5y agoThere is no real scientific evidence that disease severity is correlated with initial viral dose. It's a plausible hypothesis but so far due to ethical concerns no one has done the human challenge trials that would be necessary to settle that issue.
- AdamN 5y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8045461/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8045461/ This is a common attribute of infections and is really more of a math issue than anything SARS-specific. The bigger the initial dose, the sooner it will get to the impact stage, and the less prepared your immune system will be at that time.
- Aeolun 5y agoGot a few here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-72798-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-72798-7 It does note that non-medical (e.g. cloth) masks may be less effective, but whether those are used a lot seems to depend on environment (nobody seems to use them here). Edit: One more for cloth masks https://www.nature.com/articles/jes201642 https://www.nature.com/articles/jes201642
- AndrewBissell 5y agoHere's an NPR article discussing a CDC study which found no statistically significant impact from kids wearing masks in school: https://www.npr.org/2021/05/21/999106426/schools-are-dropping-mask-requirements-but-new-cdc-study-suggests-they-shouldnt https://www.npr.org/2021/05/21/999106426/schools-are-droppin... Key paragraph: Between Nov. 16 and Dec. 11, researchers found that infection rates were 37% lower in schools where teachers and staff members were required to wear masks. The difference between schools that did and did not require students to wear masks was not statistically significant. A good recent article in NY Mag also discussing this issue, including the fact that the World Health Organization recommends against masking kids under six: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/the-science-of-masking-kids-at-school-remains-uncertain.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/the-science-of-maski... Many countries in Europe have decided against masking for any students in K-12 schools because it is unclear that the harms outweigh the benefits. The idea there is some "simple" scientific & research consensus on this is wrong.
- Aeolun 5y agoMinimal <> doesn’t help Is it worth the cost? That’s a different question. I’m not really opposed to masks in a classroom as a mitigation method, but if people believe it will significantly alter the trajectory of the infections I have a bridge to sell them.
- cpuguy83 5y agoIs that from that one Armchair U study?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoMasks is too broad of a term as being used. There are OSHA environments where proper N95-type masks can protect you from aerosol risks for 8 hours a day. The likelihood that a cloth mask can do that in a classroom however… Best mitigator would be good HEPA room air purifiers, ideally multiple per classroom.
- handrous 5y ago> Best mitigator would be good HEPA room air purifiers, ideally multiple per classroom. They can be too loud to run while class is in session, especially if they move enough air to be worth a damn. Double-especially if you're also masked (so speaking is already a bit muffled).
- tehjoker 5y agoWhy don't we shift classes to be outside and swap summer and winter for now?
- patentatt 5y agoI've got a couple of Coway HEPA purifiers, and they can be quiet enough for a classroom. At low speeds, the closest to inaudible that I've ever heard, and at higher speeds a very even and tolerable white/brown noise.
- handrous 5y agoI'm sure some that are good-enough and not loud exist, and some classrooms probably have them, but I can also say for a fact that some schools that have managed to get ahold of good purifiers for every classroom haven't also managed to get ahold of quiet good purifiers, which is why those schools only run them part of the time. It's another hurdle to the solution of "just filter the air", which isn't per se a bad idea—but, whoever's procuring them must think to look into the noise when choosing which to buy, must have the budget to buy quiet ones that move as much air as appropriately-effective louder models (I assume there's a cost premium for "quiet and also effective"), and if someone's already bought purifiers and they're too loud, you're out of luck on getting anyone to pony up cash for a second set of (maybe even more expensive) purifiers.
- GeekyBear 5y agoHere's one of the scientists on President Biden's Covid advisory council being interviewed on PBS. TLDR: To get the sort of protection people imagine that cloth masks provide, you would need to be wearing an n95 mask, tightly fitted to your face so no air leaks in through the sides. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/do-masks-provide-much-protection-we-think-bglhwy/ https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/do-masks...
- stetrain 5y agoBut what's the actual effectiveness of most people wearing their normal cloth masks? It doesn't have to personally protect you at high effectiveness from getting infected to reduce spread at a population level. Even a 50% reduction in spread is huge in a population. Maybe we aren't getting that with masks, but it's not a binary "you are protected"/"you are not protected" problem.
- GeekyBear 5y agoFrom the interview: >Needless to say, masking is political hot button beyond anything I've ever seen in public health. At the same time i think we've all done a disservice to the public. When you actually look at face cloth coverings, they actually only have very limited impact in reducing the amount of virus that you inhale in or exhale out. Studies that have been done show that if an individual might get infected within 15 minutes in a room, by time and concentration of the virus in the room, add a face cloth covering you only get about five more minutes of protection. I've been really disappointed with my colleagues in public health for not being more clear about what can masking can do or not do. On the other hand if you use the n95 respirators and fit them tight to your face, you can actually spend 25 hours in that same room and still be protected. The bottom line though is by telling people that in fact just putting a face cloth covering on is going to protect you is simply not true. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/do-masks-provide-much-protection-we-think-bglhwy/ https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/do-masks... Cloth masks are nowhere near good enough protection to allow children too young to be vaccinated to return to school.
- heywherelogingo 5y agoIs there any point spending the day in the classroom with reduced oxygen to the brain?