18 ms·
World's biggest wind turbine shows the disproportionate power of scale
- depaya 5y agoThis may seem like a silly question but I'm genuinely curious... are there are concerns about harnessing too much power from wind and affecting global climate, air currents, etc? It seams far fetched, but we are removing energy from the atmosphere.
- brightball 5y agoI've wondered the same. Especially over an area where we have so much scale for it that's so naturally windy in the middle of the US.
- triceratops 5y agoMost people would consider the impact of planting a forest with tall trees on air currents to be mostly benign. I imagine this is the same, except with less fire risk.
- dylan604 5y agoI seem to recall reading something along these lines from those anti-wind power tirades. They claim they have affects on birds. There's pretty much all sorts of claims. They are claims and not necessarily based on reality, but you could probably find something along these lines if you searched hard enough.
- rtuulik 5y agoWind is caused by the sun. In a single hour, the amount of power from the sun that strikes the Earth is more than the entire world consumes in an year. Humans are currently using nearly as much energy, as 0,011% of sunlight.
- teh_klev 5y agoInitially I thought this seemed like a silly question too given the enormous amount of kinetic energy available in the atmosphere. But...someone did the research and produced a paper: https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30446-X https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30446-X Their conclusion: In agreement with observations and prior model-based analyses, US wind power will likely cause non-negligible climate impacts. While these impacts differ from the climate impacts of GHGs in many important respects, they should not be neglected. Wind's climate impacts are large compared with solar PVs. Similar studies are needed for offshore wind power, for other countries, and for other renewable technologies. There is no simple answer regarding the best renewable technology, but choices between renewable energy sources should be informed by systematic analysis of their generation potential and their environmental impacts. Make of it what you will.
- choeger 5y agoI wonder if that's really the right direction to go. Admittedly, the gains in output are impressive for comparatively small increases in size (I think there's a cubic growth somewhere). But the main problem with offshore wind energy currently seems to be installation. It might be economically better to produce more small turbines and install them much more efficiently instead of doing fewer, more complicated installations. One could, for instance, create 6MW floating in a large factory near the cost turbines and literally ship them to their location.
- 542458 5y agoI mean, we have small wind turbines already but the industry keeps moving to larger ones. That says to me that the economics favour the fewer-but-large approach. I can see why this would be - it has to be nontrivial to anchor an object of any size to the sea floor (not to mention maintenance and inspection) and doing that ten times at a large scales sounds easier than doing it hundreds of times at smaller scales.
- codeulike 5y agoThe article states the opposite - that fewer bigger turbines are overall cheaper to install than many smaller ones to reach the same capacity No wonder these things keep getting bigger; the bigger they get, the better they seem to work, and the fewer expensive installation projects need to be undertaken to develop the same capacity
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoArea = pi * radius ^ 2. Three time bigger turbine sweeps 9 times larger area / volume of air, and gives 9 times more power Faster winds are accessible higher up, and power that can be extracted from the wind goes up as velocity cubed (V3)
- mchusma 5y agoI just can't get into wind energy personally. For a green energy source, it seems worse than geo, solar, and nuclear in almost every way. They are: - intermittent - expensive (more than solar) - look bad (worst of all energy sources) - no plausible route for it getting a significant fraction of the energy mix (nuclear or solar+batteries do) I mean having some wind seems cool for some situations, but I just can't get excited about it.
- Symbiote 5y agoThe United Kingdom generated 25% of power last year from wind. It has a good location for wind, which many countries couldn't match, but it clearly an effective source in this case.
- _ph_ 5y agoIt very much depends on which location you are talking about. Different locations favor different forms of energy creation. Solar very much depends on the climate and laltitude. Even across Germany there are significant local differences. Yes, wind, like solar, is intermittent. But you can combine it with batteries like you could do with solar. The great thing is, wind follows a different weather pattern than solar. It is available at night or when there is cloudy weather. Usually it is strongest at times, when solar doesn't deliver much. A fully renewable grid requires a combination of solar and wind. In Germany, on-shore wind is cheaper than solar and delivering a larger fraction of the total energy consumed than solar, but as said, there is a clear separation by region, what is the prominent form of energy. And I personally think that most of them do look good. I am fond of technology and wind turbines are especially elegant and spectacular looking. I can see that too many of them can be seen negatively. Solar cells can be hidden better.
- tralarpa 5y ago> wind follows a different weather pattern than solar Some data to explore: https://transparency.entsoe.eu/generation/r2/actualGenerationPerProductionType/show https://transparency.entsoe.eu/generation/r2/actualGeneratio... Unfortunately, some interesting countries (e.g. Sweden, Germany,...) are missing. I am wondering how electricitymap.org gets their data from there for those countries? But there are also other sources, e.g.: https://www.windjournal.de/erneuerbare-energie/aktuelle_einspeiseleistung_wind_und_solar_energie https://www.windjournal.de/erneuerbare-energie/aktuelle_eins...
- CalRobert 5y agoIs the article not saying the opposite, though? Power is very much proportional to scale.
- unwind 5y agoThe article says: That's 45 percent more than the company's MySE 11.0-203, from just a 19 percent increase in diameter. So I think that their point is that the energy output goes up more (45%) than the diameter (19%), i.e. it's not linear, which is what "proportionality" [1] seems to mean. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportionality_(mathematics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportionality_(mathematics)
- bathMarm0t 5y ago1.2 ** 2 == 1.44. So... ? Power is linear wrt area of the disk?
- vanderZwan 5y agoWell, the wind energy captured depends on the surface area covered by the blades, not the diameter. So let's first check for that: 1.19 * 1.19 = 1.4161 That's still 4% unaccounted for, so there are some efficiency gains there. The question then becomes how building materials and energy required to build one of these scales with size. If that is linearly with blade diameter/turbine height, then yes, the efficiency increases quickly the larger you build them.
- MagnumOpus 5y agoThe remaining 4% are likely due to the higher and steadier winds at the higher altitude. And the cost savings are likely less about building materials which likely scale at more than quadratic pace with height, but about labour and maintenance. Each trip out to an offshore base is costly, fewer trips made both for building and for maintenance saves a lot of money.
- endymi0n 5y agowhich to be honest is less of a testament to increased efficiency and more of a mathematical effect of circle area growing to the square of the diameter. The other main reason to get bigger that‘s not even discussed is increased capacity factor. That doesn‘t have to do with efficiency, but with effectiveness, as the turbine will simply run more days of the year.
- DrBazza 5y agoIf you keep scaling this up, you might naively think the tips of blades could reach Mach 1. They won't, due to a variety of reasons. But that does remind of Thunderscreech: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_XF-84H_Thunderscreech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_XF-84H_Thunderscreech "The XF-84H was almost certainly the loudest aircraft ever built, earning the nickname "Thunderscreech" as well as the "Mighty Ear Banger".[16] On the ground "run ups", the prototypes could reportedly be heard 25 miles (40 km) away.[17] Unlike standard propellers that turn at subsonic speeds, the outer 24–30 inches (61–76 cm) of the blades on the XF-84H's propeller traveled faster than the speed of sound even at idle thrust, producing a continuous visible sonic boom that radiated laterally from the propellers for hundreds of yards."
- jmnicolas 5y agoDo you know what's the speed of a blade at the tip? It's not mentioned in the article.
- hi 5y agoSome have a max blade tip speed of 100-180mph depending on radius and wind speed[0][1] (I use to work on utility scale wind farms with 100+ x 2.1MW turbines) [0] https://www.semprius.com/how-fast-do-wind-turbines-spin/ https://www.semprius.com/how-fast-do-wind-turbines-spin/ [1] https://www.windpowerengineering.com/calculate-blade-tip-speed/ https://www.windpowerengineering.com/calculate-blade-tip-spe...
- DrBazza 5y agoSpeed of sound is 343m/s at sea level. The blade is 113 metres, so that's a circumference of 710m. A quick google says large turbines can rotate up to 20 rpm, so once every 3 seconds, that's 710/3 = 236m/s, so Mach 0.68 (edit) I think 29rpm is when the tips of blades go supersonic for that turbine. "The best way to get the correct answer on the internet is to give the wrong one". I look forward to being corrected...
- dylan604 5y ago
- Clewza313 5y ago> MingYang says the MySE 16.0-242 is just the start of its "new 15MW+ offshore product platform," and that it's capable of operating installed to the sea floor or on a floating base. Am I reading that right? A tower 242 meters tall (read: a 70-floor skyscraper), with moving 118 meter blades, and they're proposing anchoring it to a floating base!?
- elevaet 5y agoWhy not? It must be a very wide floating base
- marvin 5y agoGranted, it's a factor 2.5 difference in height, 1.6 in rotor radius and 6 in rated power, but Equinor operates a floating wind farm with 100 meter hub height outside of Scotland. (I'm assuming that the article reported hub height and not the highest point of the rotor). https://www.equinor.com/en/what-we-do/floating-wind/how-hywind-works.html https://www.equinor.com/en/what-we-do/floating-wind/how-hywi...
- pjc50 5y agoInteresting: not a wide base, but instead a very deep one. Build the tower twice as tall, fill the bottom with rocks: now you have a structure whose center of gravity is very low, and the hollow column gives it buoyancy. Hundred meter turbine just bobbing in the water like a cork.
- akie 5y agoFor scale, you only need 75 of these 16MW turbines to replace one nuclear power plant (1200MW). Crazy. EDIT: Taking operational capacity (26% for wind, 86% for nuclear) into account, you arrive at about 250 to replace one nuclear plant. Still insane. Source: https://qr.ae/pGWlu4 https://qr.ae/pGWlu4
- Tade0 5y agoSuch large wind turbines break the 50% capacity threshold: https://www.ge.com/renewableenergy/wind-energy/offshore-wind/haliade-x-offshore-turbine https://www.ge.com/renewableenergy/wind-energy/offshore-wind... Mostly because at such heights wind is generally higher and more consistent.
- akie 5y agoSo only 125 of these mega turbines to replace one nuclear power plant? Amazing. France produces 75% of their electricity with 56 nuclear power plants, which - if the above is broadly correct - you would be able to replace with 7000 of these wind mills. That's a lot, but on the other hand, Germany has already installed 20k wind turbines so far, so it seems within reach. Obviously you still need to think about matching supply and demand, but I'm surprised by how feasible this appears.
- t0mas88 5y agoThe 20k in Germany are much much smaller. The big ones require more space and can be built in less places due to how gigantic they are. On the other hand, placing them at sea is great for having more wind. And the main objection to sea based wind energy so far is the cost of construction which with a smaller number of them could decrease.
- choeger 5y agoNot that much smaller, actually. A typical run-of-the-mill turbine will have a capacity of 2.5MW. You can easily get up to 5MW onshore (but that's often constrained by proximity to villages or towns - renewable energy does not happen in or close to cities).
- StreamBright 5y ago>> The MySE 16.0-242 is a 16-megawatt, 242-meter-tall (794-ft) behemoth capable of powering 20,000 homes per unit over a 25-year service life. No it is not without a balanced power grid.
- throw0101a 5y agoSeems that no one has updated the Wikipedia page yet: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_powerful_wind_turbines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_powerful_wind_tur... Sorted by "Power rating (MW)", the top three are: * Vesta V236 (15) * Siemens Gamesa SG 14-222 DD (14) * GE Wind Energy Haliade-X (13) MingYang has a MySE 11-203 at 11: currently listed as "Concept" like the top two, above.
- tyingq 5y agoReminds me of a lady at the grocery store complaining about why the 8 inch cake costs 2x the 5 inch cake.
- tmountain 5y agoPizza prices don't seem to track the same trend. An extra large is generally just a dollar or two more than a large, etc. I guess this is because dough and sauce are cheap so the cost impact is negligible from a manufacturing standpoint, so those few extra dollars are essentially pure profit.
- poopypoopington 5y agoHmmm so they haven't even built the prototype yet, and it won't be built for another year, it won't be installed for another 2 years, and they won't start actual commercial production of these things for another 3 years. So this is pretty much just a CAD design / simulation. This is pure PR until all of those are accomplished.
- kitd 5y agoThe article is reporting an announcement, true, but that doesn't invalidate the headline ... scale brings huge advantages in wind turbine economics.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoWell, GE's Halide-X in Rotterdam has 107-meter long blades, and this company's new one will have 118-meter long blades, so objects of similar scale do already exist.
- aitchnyu 5y agoWill wind leave behind countries with narrow roads that wouldnt acomodate large trucks? My place in India has highways with 30kph curves and walls at the very edge.
- jopsen 5y agoNo, probably not.. the big turbines are all designed for offshore deployment. The bigger problem is that going offshore is expensive. On the other hand, shipping by sea should be easier than land :)
- raffraffraff 5y agoI wonder how these huge structures would stand up to the increasingly powerful storms the world is experiencing. Presumably they wouldn't get built if they weren't up to the task.
- p3opl3s 5y agoThis is 3rd article from the site with exadurated claims and stupidly aggresive click-bait titles, I've seen just today. I wonder if these are AI generate somehow.
- londons_explore 5y agoAlong the length of a wind turbine blade, the conditions vary widely. Near the pivot, the blade needs to be really strong, moves slowly and has a steep angle of attack. Near the tip the blade moves hundreds of mph, needs not much strength and has a very shallow angle of attack. Having such widely varying conditions would seem to be very hard to optimise for - only one position along the blade can be at optimal conditions. I would expect that there might exist another design of wind turbine not having this downside - perhaps with a linearly moving blade.
- jokoon 5y agoI don't think it improves the co2 cost per watt versus nuclear.
- cycomanic 5y agoIf it improves, it would certainly improve also vs nuclear. Also regarding CO2 cost, nuclear vs wind is certainly not clear cut. This [1] reference says wind is somewhat worse than European nuclear but better than US nuclear. It's also worth pointing out that lifecycle CO2 analysis of Nuclear often consider only ~50 years of nuclear waste storage [2], which is somewhat misleading considering that we have to store some of the waste for thousands of years. [1] https://escholarship.org/content/qt5fw407kf/qt5fw407kf_noSplash_ff206bfec9ac01cf100fe95ecd0e4cd3.pdf https://escholarship.org/content/qt5fw407kf/qt5fw407kf_noSpl... [2] https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/energy-and-the-environment/energy-return-on-investment.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/energy-and-the...
- pjc50 5y agoThe financial cost per watt has long been won by wind, though.
- thehappypm 5y agoIt does, actually. Bigger is better for wind. A lot of the costs scale with the width of the tower (more expensive tower, tougher to build, bigger generator, etc) but the power output scales with the area covered by the blades, so the power output grows more quickly than the size/cost.
- aaron-santos 5y agoWhat's the limiting factor in wind turbine size? Is it regulatory, construction capital, materials technology, supportive infrastructure, something else?
- geewee 5y agoGenerally construction and materials. Particularly for offshore the supportive infrastructure and maintenance takes up a big chunk of the cost - the expectation is that those costs won't scale with turbine size.
- cipehr 5y agoDoes anyone know why vertical wind turbines didn’t take off? I remember reading an article in popular mechanics about them years ago (found it [1]) and it seemed like a superior turbine… [1]: https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/gadgets/a246/1288371/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/gadgets/a246/128...
- lostlogin 5y ago> Does anyone know why vertical wind turbines didn’t take off? This had me really scratching my head for way too long, I laughed out loud when I realised my error. “They are bolted down surely?”
- nuccy 5y agoOne of the reasons may be a problem with "disabling" vertical turbines during high winds. With properller-like turbines, blade can rotate to move edge-on towards the wind direction or move parts of blades in the opposite direction, so that the overall torque in each blade is zero regardless of the wind speed.
- bserge 5y agoGreat joke :D
- kitd 5y agoReminds me of a report about the floating decision for the UK's first spaceport: Where it will land is still up in the air Me: "Well, thats f**ing no good"
- Animats 5y agoThere are a whole series of problems. Darrieus turbines and their variations are fun to watch.[1] But they have structural strength problems. Also, they're hard to stop. Large bladed turbines have variable pitch, and are set to neutral during high wind conditions to prevent overspeeding. Most of the vertical designs can't do that. In the early days of California wind power, there were some Darrieus turbines at Pacheco Pass. They're probably gone now. In those days, 30KW was a big turbine. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darrieus_wind_turbine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darrieus_wind_turbine
- Gravityloss 5y agoIt's a hybrid design. It's got a single planetary gear and a medium speed medium sized generator. High speed designs have multiple gear stages that enable a small high speed generator. And direct drive turbines don't have gears at all but the generator needs to be massive. More info at http://www.myse.com.cn/en/jtxw/info.aspx?itemid=825 http://www.myse.com.cn/en/jtxw/info.aspx?itemid=825