15 ms·
Razer bug lets you become a Windows 10 admin by plugging in a mouse
- yrro 5y agoDoes this vulnerability have a CVE? The database has several entries for Razernon eof which is the only only I've ever seen rated 10. I come away with the impression that Razer care even leaa about security than Microsoft did in the early days of XP: an utterly unacceptable state to be in over 20 years later.
- cube00 5y agoHow do companies still think it's acceptable to ignore responsible disclosure in the hopes the problem just goes away? Even companies with the most automated non-existent customer service know they need to provide separate channels for legal and security so that actually get read by a human.
- vmception 5y agowait this is an argument in favor of the practices that are currently called responsible disclosure? somebody NFT this post
- dspillett 5y agoIt could be user or system or prices error rather than malice in this case: the message not getting to the right person (general mail fail, people monitoring that target being unavailable, misidentification as junk, ...) or that person/group missing it assist a sea of other comms. We don't know how much effort was made to chase a response. Their response after the issue hit social media was far more decent than companies have done in the past: > I would like to update that I have been reached out by @Razer and ensured that their security team is working on a fix ASAP. Their manner of communication has been professional and I have even been offered a bounty even though publicly disclosing this issue.
- dspillett 5y ago“Prices” should have been “policy” there. Also, “assist” → “amongst”. Darned auto-carrot strikes again, and I was far too late noticing to be able to edit. Two in a short post, I'm not sure if the slide-keyboard is getting worse over time or my coordination is failing as I age but something seems to be failing more these days than it used to…
- andix 5y agoThey probably just don't read their emails or messages. Maybe customer support agents are just very badly trained. Or there is a second/third/forth level that investigates those emails, but they are getting too many messages to go through all of them.
- mhh__ 5y agoBecause it would mean spending money and the buck stopping somewhere other than the void.
- vmception 5y ago> How do companies still think it's acceptable to ignore responsible disclosure in the hopes the problem just goes away? its not responsible to disclose in secret and hope the company doesn't ignore you or curb stomp you to oblivion its not responsible to push for a little pat on the back and maybe an undervalued $ compensation proverbially nuke them from orbit, responsible is not a factor here
- waterhouse 5y agoI was asking, "How can a Razer bug let you break into Windows? Is it a Razer device driver?" Yes. I'll just quote jonhat's tweet from the article: Need local admin and have physical access? - Plug a Razer mouse (or the dongle) - Windows Update will download and execute RazerInstaller as SYSTEM - Abuse elevated Explorer to open Powershell with Shift+Right click
- azalemeth 5y agoWow. That's a Windows 98 level of "school kid" privilege escalation bug...
- ronsor 5y agoFor reference: https://imgur.com/r/hacking/rG0p0b2 https://imgur.com/r/hacking/rG0p0b2
- azalemeth 5y agoHah, I like that one. The other classic is Right Click -> New -> Shortcut -> cmd.exe in an explorer "open" window, typically one in an otherwise very locked-down environment. This has recently got me service access on an old (but new in 2009!) ultrasound machine, for example, for getting raw data and dicom images off in a hurry when the proper authentication details were lost...
- jmiserez 5y agoOphcrack works too, at least if the underlying machine still runs Windows XP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ophcrack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ophcrack
- lostlogin 5y ago> ultrasound machine The real boss move was navigating a machine with a UI that involved a trackball, keyboard, touch screen(s), touch pad, weird array of custom buttons and a truely stupid menu system. Configuring US machines is horrible. But my major US machine rant is them burning metadata into the images (rather than displaying DICOM tags as an overlay). It’s is beyond ridiculous.
- hhsbz 5y agoThe actual problem here is that Microsoft allows OEMs to install user space programs via their drivers, which are installed automatically without user intervention using Windows Update. This is unacceptable. Microsoft should only accept kernel mode drivers. If users want user space tools they can find them in the OEM website.
- arghwhat 5y agoUhm. If you can't trust them to write a user-mode program without messing up security this badly, you absolutely can't trust them to write a kernel-mode driver without completely screwing everything up. Not to mention one that is automatically downloaded and installed whenever something shows up claiming to be a particular vendor/product ID!
- hhsbz 5y agoI expect the developers who write the kernel mode drivers to be much more competent and senior than those who write the flashy, slow GUIs that come with them. Yes, naive assumption, but still!
- zenexer 5y agoI wish that were the case—I also wish it were the case that “senior” meant “competent.” Judging by the number of device drivers I’ve had cause serious problems, especially with consumer gaming hardware (as is the case here), I don’t think it’s safe to make any assumptions about the quality of drivers. For anyone else reading this who’s feeling smug because they would never buy such a device: you don’t need to; only the attacker needs to. Windows will happily download and install the drivers automatically the first time the device is plugged in.
- vlovich123 5y agoIt's also not about seniority or competence. Writing kernel mode drivers is being given the task of juggling running chainsaws with real chains while on a balancing board. "Success" is declared when you're able to do this in a lab without there being an issue, ignoring the fact that in the real world there are dodgeballs being thrown at you. Also, no one I've ever worked with writing them has ever wanted to maintain & improve the quality of the drivers they wrote - they wanted to move on to "interesting" work as quickly as possible. This includes myself. The work isn't interesting, fun & usually not important to the business. In this case, why does a mouse driver need to live in the kernel in the first place? Microsoft should be improving the HID layer to make that unnecessary.
- swamp_gas 5y ago"its not a bug, its a feature"
- im3w1l 5y agoUnless the system has been vaccinated by plugging one beforehand.
- andix 5y agoThis is more a Windows bug. Bad enough for Razer customers, but it affects all Windows users. Windows should not install random drivers from the Internet when a non-admin user is logged in.
- jnwatson 5y agoAnd then you need to call an admin to plug in a mouse. That's not really practical for a lot of organizations.
- andix 5y agoThere are generic mouse drivers.
- jefft255 5y agoAll (I hope) gaming mice with fancy drivers will also just work fine without them.
- ThePadawan 5y agoThat's already the case in more secure environments (company-provided devices plugged into internal USB ports - all other ports filled with sealant).
- OJFord 5y agoOh that's why they did that! I'd forgotten until your comment, but I remember thinking that was odd on an internship. Didn't occur to me that it was to prevent there being usable ports (and nor did I try to plug in any car park devices, like a good intern!). My work was only confidential (and that only by default) but it was definitely interesting to be an in environment with secret sauce about, and processes for handling it. (Fire procedure not being drop everything and exit the building, for one.)
- gruez 5y agoThat's probably more to prevent data exfiltration. If you don't want random drivers being downloaded you can more reliably prevent it using group policy.
- toastal 5y agoRazer, the same company where installing Linux voids the warranty and BIOS and firmware upgrades need to be installed from Windows 10 just so you can have a black and green GUI.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoThere must be a USB gadget where you can just set any USB device ID to report to the host, so any infiltrator not wishing to give Razer money can just copy one of their USB IDs and plug the "yes I'm a Razer USB device" into a USB port.
- nimbius 5y agohttps://blog.adafruit.com/2017/11/07/generate-usb-descriptors-with-python/ https://blog.adafruit.com/2017/11/07/generate-usb-descriptor... there ya go.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoI visited the article's linked tweet and the author's retweeted a product mention called OMG cable, that can do this (a product that looks like a normal USB cable but has things like okeylogging capabilities)
- sp332 5y agoSomeone added a payload for Bash Bunny here https://twitter.com/hak5darren/status/1429463473700888577 https://twitter.com/hak5darren/status/1429463473700888577
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoSo err... easy root access to any Windows 10 machine until this is fixed?
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoIt's probably possible to disable auto-installation of drivers, or even disable USB via software...
- cjbprime 5y agoYou can configure an Android phone to use arbitrary device/product IDs like this.
- hughes 5y ago> The owner of this website (www.bleepingcomputer.com) has banned your IP address I don’t know what I did to deserve this, but I guess I’ll continue my morning without reading this article?
- blibble 5y agoit always wound me up that the SteelSeries 900mb bullshit keyboard bloatware somehow downloaded itself and popped up on a brand new clean Windows install (even disconnecting the machine from the internet first and disabling the various automatic driver downloads in GPO wasn't enough to stop it...)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xyst 5y agoOn the plus side, now people can remove the invasive software installed by education institutions and some enterprise companies
- nicolas_t 5y agoShouldn't Jonhat disclose it to Microsoft before publishing it as a zero-day? This would really be something that Microsoft can and should block on their side. It's a bit crazy that Windows downloads and install random drivers when plugging in a device when a non-admin user is logged in and that should be fixed but besides this, they also have a way to block the offending driver for a while. Publishing it as a zero-day instead feels a bit irresponsible
- smoldesu 5y agoThis is part of why I don't use Razer (or Microsoft) products anymore. Razer's UX is horrible on Windows, which is a shame since that's where most of their customers will use their products. The moment you plug in a Razer device, Windows starts downloading a 300mb installer that will prompt you to install the Razer management software each time you reboot/plug in the device. If you deny it, Windows will keep the installer and ask you next time anyways.
- gsibble 5y agoGood lord.......I've been on Linux for years and rarely look at Windows anymore but that's dumb on so many levels. Come to Linux. It's nice over here.
- herpderperator 5y agoThere are a lot of issues here, but isn't a glaring one the fact that any random file browser window lets you get a shell? Shouldn't this be something for the developer to disable for their particular program if their use case of browsing to choose an install folder in no means requires it? Do the Microsoft APIs even allow for this kind of configuration? Given they already have admin rights it's basically game over, but not having the option to open a shell would have still reduced the attack surface and required a "real" exploit to do so.
- jgoldshlag 5y agoNot really, the windows file browser also lets you create and move files and directories. I guess you could ask to go down the route of not allowing that, but directory creation for one is super common.
- herpderperator 5y agoCreating and moving files and directories doesn't result in arbitrary code execution with elevated privileges.
- bluecalm 5y agoNot surprised. I once bought top of the line Razer mechanical keyboard. The software if a steaming pile of crap and a known bug (random spamming of c key when pressing Ctrl + c) makes it unusable. Avoid.
- dang 5y agoThis is related to a different thread which is currently at #1: My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28274305 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28274305 Normally we'd downweight one or the other (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=follow-up%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...) but in this case I don't think that makes sense.
- ApexCan 5y agoThey appear to be two unrelated issues.
- dang 5y agoTechnically unrelated yes, but the one post seems clearly a follow-up to the other. Normally we downweight those, since avoiding repetition is a principle here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=follow-up%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20repetition%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... In this case that didn't seem indicated though.
- EastSmith 5y agoRecently my son is using / installing lots of gaming peripherals and software for it and I have to say that I have not seen this much crapware bullshit since Windows XP (with no Service Pack). If you want to setup the LED lights for your fans - you must install this crap; if you want to customize your mouse somehow - install this other crap. Same companies have not one, but two software suits that manage different peripherals. Razer is the worst of these. Asus ROG takes second place.
- f0e4c2f7 5y agoI recently picked up a new mouse and was shocked by how much of a problem this has become. For RGB controls check out https://openrgb.org/ https://openrgb.org/. The UI is pretty bad but once you figure it out it works great otherwise. As an aside, are there any periferal brands that are known for minimalist drivers etc?
- 10000truths 5y agoI’m just going by the screenshot on the website, but I think the UI looks fine just the way it is.
- xxpor 5y agoMy Glorious Model D and Model O mice works perfectly fine with the normal HID driver. I suppose there's an app for RGB control and changing the DPI settings but the defaults are fine for me. It doesn't attempt to download anything when I plug it in.
- crtasm 5y agoI had to install software to turn off the lights on my CPU cooler (wraith prism included with an AMD CPU) - it's ridiculous.
- sandyarmstrong 5y agoSame for me and my GPU!
- 5y ago
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoThis should qualify as a modern-day Captain Crunch whistle.
- a-dub 5y agosurprising that the auto-fetch/install stuff allows for non msi based installers. there's a whole vetting process for drivers, you'd think msi would be a requirement. why non msi based installers still exist in any form in 2021 is a mystery to me.
- d23 5y agoNever buying another razer device after I recently found out that the user agreement allows them to collect all the keystrokes from my keyboard and send them to their company -- you know, so I can customize my keys' colors.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoCan you provide citation on this? Edit: I’m genuinely curious about it, as opposed to accusing you of lying.
- tyingq 5y agohttps://www.razer.com/legal/services-and-software-terms-of-use https://www.razer.com/legal/services-and-software-terms-of-u... <ctrl-f>keystrokes It does mention you can turn it off, but still sounds over the top to me. "Mouse Usage Statistics. Synapse 2.0 offers a feature of collecting mouse usage statistics, specifically keystrokes, mouse-clicks, wheel-rotations and pointer distance travelled. Such collection of statistics may be turned on or off within Synapse and is under your own control."
- gruez 5y agoFrom my reading of the paragraph it looks like that feature is totally local? A few sentences before they list out all the data they collect and send to razer, but the sentence about keystrokes doesn't give any indication it's sent to them.
- rodgerd 5y agoHave a look for Razer heatmaps; Razer do in fact run mouse and keyloggers that send your data to their cloud.
- kodah 5y agoIf you're looking for a good keyboard I recommend KeyChron. I have used their mechanical keyboards (K4) for gaming and they feel great while I use their slim optical keyboard (K3) for software and general use. Both keyboards are 1/2 to 1/3 of the cost of the mainstream, brand name equivalents and, IMHO, double the quality. Razer makes a lot of junk. I saw a headset stand with plastic and RGB. I don't know why someone would waste money or a bus port on a 5 dollar part with lights. That said, I do own one of their cameras and it's incredible quality. Corsair and Steel Series are usually my go to's.
- ByteWelder 5y agoCorsair is just as bad with their iCue junk software in my experience. Want to configure the LED colour of your mouse? That'll be a 750MB download currently with iCue 4. What's even worse is that Windows automatically installs some Corsair software, which spams you with an iCue popup: https://imgur.com/0fKRYLT https://imgur.com/0fKRYLT
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hakfoo 5y agoThey should approach this the complete other way: when you WANT admin rights, you have to insert a special device. Sort of like the cash registers where the manager needs to turn a special key to gain access to refund functionality. Maybe you build it into specific other devices-- the administrator's favourite keyboard or mouse has the admin token, but the $4.99 Dells they hand out to the hoi palloi don't have it.
- remuskaos 5y agoI tested this with a Raspberry Pi Pico and it works. The usb device name doesn't even have to match, only the VID and PIDs. I used Adafruits circuitpython and changed these two to 0x1532 and 0x0084. After attaching the Pico to a Windows VW wit all current updates, the Razer Installer comes up and opens a file explorer NT authority/system. The "open powershell here" option was missing in my VW, I don't think it's on by default. EDIT: Oh I have to hold shift while right clicking! My bad. In case anyone want's to try this, I've uploaded the compiled firmware for the Pico here: https://anonfiles.com/T9L8F8D9u1/firmware_uf2 https://anonfiles.com/T9L8F8D9u1/firmware_uf2 (circuitpython with changed VID / PID values)
- eejjjj82 5y agoI'm sorry, how is this seen as anything other than critical vulnerability in Windows?
- crawsome 5y agofuck razer products. Go ahead and make my hardware automatically install software i don’t want. Watch how fast it goes in the dumpster
- jakobov 5y agoAll of windows is a 0-day vulnerability.
- lodonnell9213 5y agoJust to be anal here. It’s not admin, it’s NTAuth\SYSTEM, a much much higher privileged account. System is the most powerful account in Windows, bypassing almost any system protection in place such as group policy, privilege and permissions, it can talk out of the box to a DC using the machine account password (this is different to a user password), and essentially become uncontested in a network.