19 ms·
Facebook hacker beat my 2FA, bricked my Oculus, and hit the company credit card
- madars 5y ago> I want to start by pointing out I use two-factor authentication just about everywhere and Facebook is not an exception. I wish he'd mention what kind of 2FA. The reason you _really_ should use U2F/WebAuthn is because it does origin binding which, unlike entering a TOTP, a code from your hardware token/authenticator app on your phone/SMS/etc is not phishable, i.e. you can't enter it by accident on accounts.google.com.totallylegit.ru and then have them enter it on real accounts.google.com. This is so because the U2F/WebAuthn security key signs a request, sent by your browser, which embeds the requesting page's domain, so a signature on attacker.com will not pass victim.com's verification checks, whereas a code from your authentication app is trivially copied.
- Scaevolus 5y agoBeating 2FA is almost always SMS hijacking, but sometimes it's social engineering where the attacker has figured out just the right script to tell support ("oh, I dropped my phone and it won't turn on...") to get it disabled. edit: correction, beating 2FA without phishing-- like in the post where he lost his account while asleep.
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoHow does an sms hijacking attack typically work? I know sms isn't secure, but how does one go from having a password to bypassing the sms confirmation? Is it as easy as having the number and carrier?
- cinntaile 5y agoDon't they just hijack your number with the help of the telecom company's helpdesk?
- ImuMotive 5y agoIt happened to me. Cellular carriers, in my case T-Mobile, didn't require any confirmation to port a number to a new phone/sim. Eventually some required the last 4 of your social security number to port a number, which we all know at this point are pretty much public anyway. T-Mobile now lets you set an arbitrary pin, which my parents promptly set to their DOB :facepalm: I haven't looked more into it, but as far as I know, sim swap/port attacks were hilariously simple to execute which is why I only use SMS verification when it's the only option.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoYou might want to edit out what your parents set their pin to! (You can email hn@ycombinator.com if you're past the edit window.)
- ImuMotive 5y agoLol, I had made them change it as soon as they told me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joshuaissac 5y agoMaybe what is needed is regulation that makes the service provider liable (with no option to disclaim it) for all damages suffered by the victim if the provider gives away their phone number to an attacker.
- scrose 5y agoI accidentally ‘hijacked’ a number by typoing one number in my online request. I only found out after my wife pointed out my number was different after porting. It took a couple hours with the telco’s support agents, and practically no verification steps, to actually get my correct number back. Very sad state of affairs here.
- cinntaile 5y agoGoogle is better than all other alternatives in that regard. They have a feature called Advanced Protection where you add your 2FA U2F keys and if you lose them your account is gone. No social engineering possible. https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/ https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/
- pinum 5y ago“If you lose your key and are still signed in on one of your devices, visit account.google.com to add or replace a key. Otherwise, submit a request to recover your account. Google may take a few days to verify that it’s you and restore your access.” I trust that it would be (potentially much) harder than normal, but it still seems to be possible.
- cinntaile 5y agoI was under the impression you were screwed in that case, thanks for pointing out that I was wrong. It's lot less secure than I thought.
- withinboredom 5y agoIIRC, Google will stop the "several day process" if you log in at any time.
- someguydave 5y agoStill sounds like a significant barrier to most phishing attacks.
- cinntaile 5y agoA little bit. It's mostly a time delay, since the alternatives to verify your identity seem to be a different emailaddress or a phone number and then you're back to square one imo. The phone number is still susceptible to social engineering and the alternative mail likely is too. Ideally I want something where keys gone = account gone. Now a dedicated scammer could still succeed and it sure doesn't provide any real safety for political groups which Google kind of claims it does by using testimonies from politically vulnerable people to "advertise" the Advanced Protection Program. This is a tricky situation though since your adversaries could get your keys and your password and then they control your account without any chance of getting it back, so it's definitely a double edged sword.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Beating 2FA is almost always SMS hijacking That's most definitely not true, as someone who works in this space. Plain old phishing is much more common, where the hacker tricks a user into entering their code into a malicious website. To echo OP, this is why it's important to support non-phishable types of 2FA.
- baxtr 5y agoCould you describe the types that are non-phishable?
- fossuser 5y agoYubikey is one - it requires the user touch a hardware device which signs something locally that I think is never sent? I don’t know enough of the implementation specifics, but it’s supposed to guard against this kind of thing.
- klodolph 5y agoYubiKey uses U2F and FIDO2/WebAuthn. The YubiKey also does a lot of other things, depending on which YubiKey you have... but if you want 2FA on random websites, those are the most likely protocols (used for GitHub and the like). The basic U2F + FIDO2/WebAuthn is the least expensive model, around US$25. These days it works seamlessly on Chrome, Firefox, and Safari.
- laggyluke 5y agoYubikey is actually pretty "phishable", at least in the OTP mode. It will happily put the token into a phishing website (or literally anywhere else) as soon as you touch it. It's also good to know that Yubikey's OTP tokens don't expire based on time, but based on a hidden counter that gets incremented with every issued token. So if you've accidentally touched your Yubikey and leaked the token publicly, you just have to log out and then log back in using your Yubikey - that action will invalidate all tokens issued before this point.
- 5y ago
- mushishi 5y agoHow is it possible that some kind of imaginative script can be enough to get SMS sim swapped? Why aren't the operators requiring a strong identification via a passport or something like that? Maybe I'm really dumb but that just boggles my mind, whether or not there exist other types of alternatives to 2FA.
- Destitute 5y agoThere's not much you can confirm over the phone, except the account PIN and sometimes security hint. But an attacker can pretend to have forgotten it and press that the matter is urgent. If the attacker knows enough about the person, they might be able to convince an agent to make the swap so the agent can: 1) Get on with their day to maybe hit a support request quota 2) Make sure this person doesn't give them a bad customer satisfaction score
- cinntaile 5y agoYou could require verifying your identity using your electronic ID if you want to simswap by calling the helpdesk.
- jdavis703 5y agoThey could require this. Most of the big operators have physical stores where they could do an ID check. There should be an advanced protection mode where SIM swaps and other sensitive operations require physical authentication.
- mushishi 5y agoYes this, please!
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoIt’s probably worth faking having lost your 2FA and asking for it to be reset. If you find out they are this careless with 2FA-protected accounts, you should probably not rely on it too much. I manage an authentication and identity provider and if someone gets locked out of 2FA and can’t prove their identity via a previously-uploaded gpg key, they get locked out for good. I never honor requests to reset the device sent by email, no matter how much they beg or offer to prove identity by sending copies of official IDs - I don’t care who they are now, I care about them being the same person that set up the account and 2FA, which can only be proven via a valid 2FA device or a GPG signature.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> It’s probably worth faking having lost your 2FA and asking for it to be reset. I'm not sure I trust that I'd be as good an attacker as a professional, and there's not a great way to replicate "hang up, call again" approaches likely to work with a big org.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoIt could be worth it to spend the 1.50$ on stripe to do identity verification with id documents for accounts of a certain size, so that they can present those documents again to regain access to their account. Re-enabling the account after a certain period of time without activity would also be a good measure (on top of the id verification).
- xwolfi 5y agoAnd then lose the documents in a big hack so that everyone with a forum access can use your passport copy. yes.
- scrollaway 5y agoThe whole point of using Stripe for it would be not to have the documents in question. Kind of like you don't hear about companies using stripe losing their customers' card numbers.
- InitialLastName 5y agoWouldn't that be obvious to the victim the moment their phone didn't work? Or will the carrier leave the old SIM activated?
- withinboredom 5y agoIIRC, in the US, sometimes just give the old sim some random phone number (to keep you paying the bill) and don't cancel the line. In the EU, I'm pretty sure they cancel the old line.
- wunderwuzzi23 5y agoOld school phishing is the most common MFA bypass. Here is a description how it works: https://github.com/wunderwuzzi23/KoiPhish https://github.com/wunderwuzzi23/KoiPhish Unless you use Yubikeys (webauthn) etc these phishing attacks just continue to work. I do consultancy in this space at times and about 95+% of folks who enter their password will also enter their MFA token.
- hackettma 5y agoFollowed the link and the read me is bit spare on details. For the less technical this still would require the phishee to manually enter credentials which then can be relayed to the attacker. Correct? The article mentions this happened while the author was asleep — any thoughts on how that would work?
- tialaramex 5y agoOne thing that can happen is you get enduring credentials from the OTP sign-in, and they last despite other credentials simultaneously existing elsewhere. I only use Facebook trapped inside Facebook Container in one Firefox on one computer. But my understanding is that it's possible to sign in to Facebook from say a phone and a laptop at the same time, so the bad guys could get you to give them working credentials one day and persist those until you're asleep before using them. If you went to Facebook's security settings "Where you're logged in" and it lists two logins, one in "Paris" while you are in New York, you might realise there's a problem and force them out. But most people likely never look at that, why would they?
- FabHK 5y agoI might be tempted to enter the TOTP, but my browser is unlikely to enter the password, and I definitely won't.
- andybak 5y agoI think the fact that password managers can spot incorrect urls better than users is useful. However I've become numbed to this warning flag by those services that seem to have endless different urls that are all legitimate. (Microsoft being a particular offender here). I can imaging some variant of outlook.microsoft.developer.really.yes.com catching me unawares one day.
- ignoramous 5y ago> ...has figured out just the right script to tell support ("oh, I dropped my phone and it won't turn on...") Isn't this vishing? https://youtu.be/BEHl2lAuWCk https://youtu.be/BEHl2lAuWCk
- xsmasher 5y agoNo; phishing / vishing is contacting the customer to get login details. Contacting support and getting them to circumvent security is social engineering.
- UncleMeat 5y agoAnother poster has mentioned it, but I will add weight. This is super ultra mega wrong. Phishing SMS and TOTP codes is way more common than SIM-swapping. Outrageously so. SIM-swapping does not scale. You need to call up a company each time you want to do it. Yes, it works. But you cannot sell a tool that just automates it. In comparison, there are many off-the-shelf phishing kits that fully automate SMS and TOTP 2FA theft.
- samstave 5y ago>Beating 2FA is almost always SMS hijacking How exactly does this get executed? I'm pretty technical, but I cant fathom exactly how this occurs; You hijack a cell tower, then have some system to listen to un-encrypted SMS traffic?? Plz ELI5
- ev1 5y agoIt's zero cost and zero effort to port someone's number out, or get a new SIM card issued for the existing account. I've worked with a bunch of streamers and YouTubers, and the threat model is such that people have shown up with professionally made printed fake IDs to attempt hijacking in an actual retail carrier store.
- josephcsible 5y agoIt's an attack on humans, not on technology. You trick their phone carrier's employees into thinking that you're them and that you lost your phone. Then you end up with a SIM card assigned to their phone number, so you receive all of their calls and texts instead of them.
- hulitu 5y agoThere is also the ad which runs on the same webpage and reads what you type or your clipboard.
- encryptluks2 5y agoWhat you're describing here isn't exclusive to hardware tokens and nothing preventing software from checking the domain using TOTP.
- madars 5y agoHow? TOTP does not embed the domain, as it is generated on a separate device which does not communicate with your browser, and does not know the target domain. TOTP is literally HMAC(shared-secret, time-interval) mapped to a short range (e.g. mod 10^6).
- encryptluks2 5y ago> it is generated on a separate device which does not communicate with your browser, and does not know the target domain. No, not always and many password manager solutions do integrate with your browser and know the domain for the password.
- madars 5y agoThen that's not TOTP https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238 but something different. Do you know how it is called and which products support it? I'd love to read up about it!
- encryptluks2 5y agoYes, it is TOTP: https://github.com/tadfisher/pass-otp https://github.com/tadfisher/pass-otp
- valid_username 5y agoBitwarden has TOTP support in paid plan. And it works with browser extension which recognises domains.
- AkshitGarg 5y ago
- theshadowknows 5y agoFor work things I often have to enter a code from one or another app that expires every few seconds. I've always wondered how exactly that works. Where might I go to find out about that? Is it as straight forward as googling "how two factor authentication works" or is there some other terminology?
- cs2733 5y agoThey're called Timed One-Time Passwords or TOTP and they're one form of 2FA
- nine_k 5y agoYou mean TOTP? Imagine a hash function that generates a number from the number of minutes since epoch hashed additionally with some seed. You have it on the server, you have it on your, say, phone. When you enroll you share a seed for the generator. Since your time is synchronized, the server knows what value(s) to expect, and the phone knows which value to generate. The real scheme is a bit more involved: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-Time_Password#Algorithm https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-Time_Password...
- quadrifoliate 5y agoA simplified and inaccurate version: - You and I share a secret at my first login. Let's say our shared secret is "wibble". - For any subsequent successful login with my username and password, for the second factor I send you the last six digits of the SHA1-hash of ("wibble" XOR current timestamp) - You calculate the second factor yourself as well by doing the same operation (you have stored "wibble" for my username, and know the current timestamp), and verify those last six digits. If they are wrong, I am an attacker! An accurate version: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6238
- quelltext 5y agoI always wondered, doesn't that require the clocks to be synchronized? Like, what happens if I set my phone to a different time? What if the server has lost connectivity to an NTP service and its clock is a few minutes off?
- recursive 5y agoHow is that possible? Codes from authenticator apps I've seen are 6-digit decimal codes. I don't know much about how it works. But I can't see how this is immune from mitm. I pretend to $SERVICE and ask you for your authenticator code. If you fall for it, you'd give me the code, which I can use to impersonate you for the next 30 seconds.
- jeffbee 5y agoThat's why they said you should use U2F, not TOTP.
- recursive 5y agoI'm not aware of the acronyms, but I was responding to this: "a code from your hardware token/authenticator app on your phone/SMS/etc is not phishable" That certainly seems like it's wrong, and doesn't include an acronym other than SMS. But apparently there's more depth to this space than I was aware of.
- krastanov 5y agoYou misread that statement and the excerpt you copied completely changes its meaning if you remove the surrounding. Read it as: "U2F/WebAuthn is secure because it does origin binding which is not phishable, unlike entering a TOTP or a code from your hardware token or authenticator app or SMS" Putting the original parenthetical in between the start and end of the main clause definitely makes it easy to misread. I just moved the parenthetical to the end of the sentence.
- riedel 5y agoI really wonder why typically the default policy is to convert a totp token to a longer lived token (keep browser authorized) defying the whole idea of totp. Used like this it seems like just two passwords or am I missing anything? Phishing seems really easy.
- ianburrell 5y agoU2F/WebAuthn doesn't use six digit codes. You plug in USB key, press button on top of key, and browser does exchange with key and passes result to site. The exchange between browser and key includes the domain of the site. It only works on the same site where registered the key.
- FabHK 5y agoIn this case it seems the author was asleep, so it was probably not a phishing site passing on the legitimate TOTP.
- quadrifoliate 5y ago> I wish he'd mention what kind of 2FA...U2F/WebAuthn...origin binding...SMS It shouldn't matter, because it's irrelevant to the point of the article, which is that Facebook (at least as reported) leaves a hacking victim with little or no recourse to get their account, and sometimes livelihood back. An imperfect real-world analogy of your question is like asking about what precise brand of bear mace an assault victim was or was not carrying, and whether a better one would have helped. Perhaps it would have, but that's not the point. If having hardware tokens is so important, Facebook should be making them mandatory at its scale.
- rustyminnow 5y agoI for one would appreciate knowing what brands of bear mace are ineffective and worth avoiding.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/jZQNs https://archive.is/jZQNs
- albertgoeswoof 5y agoFascinating blog post. However I don’t know why it took him so long to reach out to Facebook support, everyone knows that to get your account unlocked you just need to write a viral blog post about your experience and use your existing popularity to ensure someone at Facebook reads it, realises you’re not one of their typical peasant end users and unlocks your account for you.
- Applejinx 5y agoThe interesting question is whether this process still functions if you're identified as a person of interest to Facebook.
- sombremesa 5y agoCan confirm, wife had a similar issue and tried to buy an oculus to get in touch with a human - said person could not help at all. Ended up having to use her network to get in touch with a Facebook employee who got it handled immediately.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jeffbee 5y agoI don't think Facebook 2FA is terribly secure. They definitely err on the side of usability. I was using TOTP on Instagram and I forgot to backup my Google Authenticator before wiping my iPhone. But I was then able to just go the the settings on a logged-in device and disable 2FA without 2FA. And it wasn't like I had logged into that device recently, either. I only had to 2FA Instagram once, years ago.
- zmmmmm 5y agoI wonder if having 2FA made it worse ... I can see the review process taking the enablement of 2FA as proof he really did the abuse and discounting the possibility that his account was hacked.
- exikyut 5y agoOh meep. I was going to make the following point to the parent comment then read this reply and realized the situation is even worse: 1. (According to parent comment) 2FA can be disabled without 2FA 2. Having 2FA makes you look studious/thorough/decisive Presumably the tech support is indeed told to pay attention to 2FA. Presumably the entire management/instruction chain there isn't aware of the fact it can be turned off without 2FA confirmation, which effectively neuters it. So you have the worst of all the worlds. Niiice.
- exikyut 5y ago(See reply to sibling comment)
- LegitShady 5y agostop giving facebook money
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoSo in this story Facebook was responsible for $50 of charges, a business disruption and a huge and ongoing hassle. And Facebook refuses so much as to pick up the phone to discuss it. In the old days the equivalent would have been one of those roach motel businesses rated 'F' on the Better Business Bureau, buckets arrayed on the floor to catch rain leaking through the roof. And yet in this day it's one of the most profitable businesses in the world. Weird.
- jokoon 5y agoI think they are at a point where they would rather side with a scammer since they generate more money from this situation. I guess they have data that shows this particular kind of user will almost never buy ads ever again, so at least let a scammer do it. You're right, this is weird, but if you look at the profit model, it makes sense, and there are no laws that would really protect the user.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThose transactions are likely to be reversed thanks to the practically unlimited chargebacks practice which is rampant in our banking system.
- nijave 5y agoSure but then the question is "Should we leave an account with history of compromise in place that will lead to chargebacks or should we just permanently disable it"
- OneLeggedCat 5y agoExactly. From the article, "Personally, I think it’s very telling that Facebook acts so swiftly to block out the original user who can stop an ad scam, and so slowly to stop a scam ad that they can still bill for."
- cs2733 5y agoCompanies like Facebook are as big as Nation States. Any positives that come out of this for the author are just a Facebook PR move. If they did care about users, their support system wouldn't be so anti-user.
- jokoon 5y agoFacebook seems to be "too big to fail", at a point where their game theory is "the scammer is generating profits for us, so letting some of our users get scammed is something we can let happen". It's pretty scary. I think they're really willing to let facebook die off and just keep instagram and whatsapp, I think that's their strategy. Even facebook dating is buggy and not worthy of a giant like facebook. Maybe it's the how GAFA will start to decline.
- jsnell 5y agoHere's my guess at what happened: How was the account hijacked? Via cookie theft. The author installed malware, maybe some dodgy windows binaries or malicious browser extensions. No amount or type of 2FA on sign-in will protect you against the session cookie being stolen. (Now, additional 2FA on sensitive actions might). Why was the account was banned with such finality, with no chance of appeal? Probably for something outright illegal, like the hijacker uploading CSAM to the account. It's totally plausible that in an obvious enough case, the policy is e.g. to refer the case to law enforcement and keep the account disabled. Why did the attacker want to get the account permanently disabled? Maybe an account disable doesn't stop ad campaigns on FB. So the attacker sets up an ad campaign, and then gets the account banned so that the owner can't reverse it.
- drummer 5y agoThat is correct; ads keep running while account is blocked.
- codewithcheese 5y agoclearly shows where their priorities lie. they will shut down your social (media) life without recourse, but heaven forbid that has a negative impact on the ad spends
- firecall 5y agoYep! Happened to me! Account restricted from modifying ads. But yet the account kept going, spending money, and I couldn't stop them! Thankfully I had a second admin on the account and was able to get back in. Now I make multiple accounts to run Ads. If you search, it's a common problem! Whats infuriating is that FB want you to use your own FB account to run business accounts, and it's against T&Cs to make fake accounts. But yet you can be attached to a clients account and get Ad banned for something they do! Gah! The attitude of FB and Google is infuriating!
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThe attacker should have replicated the browser fingerprint and IP on top of stealing the cookie - or just flat out used his computer remotely while he was sleeping. I haven't used FB in a while but I remember login from other places were detected.
- drummer 5y agoAah yes, another day, another user fucked by fuckerberg. When are people going to learn?
- mdoms 5y agoYou told your wife to get some sleep at 11:30am?
- tedivm 5y ago> my wife who works remotely overnight
- cmattoon 5y agoI can't tell you how many obviously-fake profiles and scammers I report, and see other people commenting about reporting, only for them to still be around days, weeks, sometimes even months later. All of these were obvious scammers directing traffic to a single profile - some forex guru or whatever. Shilling get-rich-quick schemes doesn't meet Facebook's definition of "spam", apparently. https://imgur.com/a/xihRPwE https://imgur.com/a/xihRPwE What a garbage app.
- exikyut 5y agoI love the rhetoric: > You anonymously reported ... > You *anonymously* reported ... > *You* *anonymously* reported... "Greetings, human. We have masked your identity from... o̧u͢rs̢e͘lv́e҉s."
- petee 5y agoIronically you have to be careful doing this, as their systems can ban you for too many reports, if they aren't all flagged as 'legitimate' scammers. The last time I filed a report I had this new warning show up at the bottom prior to submission
- rsync 5y agoIn other news, I built and deployed a "2FA Mule" last weekend. It's a stock android phone with no google account and no apps installed except for "SMS Forwarder"[1]. It is configured to forward all SMS to an email address via encrypted SMTP. This means that I can receive these 2FA codes anywhere I have Internet access - such as an airplane or newly arrived in a foreign country where my SIM card does not work. The "2FA Mule" itself is plugged in at my office in a corner. I'm not employing this for anything sensitive but it's interesting to consider that I can use SMS based 2FA while divorcing it from my day to day SIM identity ... [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.frzinapps.smsforward&hl=en_US&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.frzinapps....
- breakingcups 5y agoSo the email address is not 2FA secured?
- danlugo92 5y agoCould be his email address uses OTP or UFA, which would make it secure. If anything SMSs are much more dangerous than OTP and services should eschew them. Sadly some of them still force you to have SMS.
- rsync 5y agoIt's my own mail server. I just tail the mail spool ...
- neartheplain 5y agoIs your account with the DNS registrar who controls your MX record 2FA-secured? >[...] via encrypted SMTP In addition to establishing a secure socket, does the mule validate the mail server's TLS certificate name?
- danlugo92 5y agoNice. Will actually go this route in the future.
- EMM_386 5y ago> Would I kick off the arbitration process to get that shut down? I’m actively exploring the possibility. DO IT. Please, do it. While it's a damning write-up, words won't change anything. Lawsuits might.
- cowturds 5y agoFacebook, 1 Hacker , way. Hah hah ha
- tomhallett 5y agoI had someone contact me on Facebook marketplace, we agreed upon a time/price and then they asked for my phone number (which I sadly gave them). Then they said "I'm going to text you a code, so I can verify you are legit". The text I got was from Google Voice's 2FA.....
- optymizer 5y agoHow would someone use that code to hack into my GV account? Wouldn't they also need to know my password or have access to my e-mail account to login or to reset your password?
- TomVDB 5y agoThey don’t. They want to link a new GV account to a real phone number that is not theirs, so that they can use the GV number for other scams. It only works when your phone number doesn’t already have a GV linked to it.
- bagels 5y agoWouldn't the victim have to send the code back to the scammer for it all to work?
- avidiax 5y agoHey! I want to buy your used Ikea furniture! Just a quick safety precaution to make sure: I'm going to text you a code, can you just send it back to me to confirm? Thanks!
- fastball 5y agoSeems easier to just buy a SIM card for cash, no?
- teraflop 5y agoBecause OP specifically mentioned Google Voice, my guess is that it was a phone number "ownership" code, rather than a 2FA code per se. The attacker was probably trying to create a new Google Voice account forwarding to OP's phone number. They could then use the new GV account as its own "legitimate" phone number in order to engage in other scams. (Alternatively, OP's password might have already been compromised, and this was the last stage of a targeted attack by someone trying to get into their account.)
- cwkoss 5y agoFacebook's walled garden around oculus is really disappointing. Updates frequently broke mods, and the last time I tried to get it working again my Quest got bricked. Need to try factory resetting or something to see if I can get it working again, but it's left such a bad taste in my mouth I'm considering just selling it instead and buying a better VR system. The only people I've heard have positive experiences with the Quest either: - haven't had it for very long, or - use Virtual Desktop or sideloading to break out of the walled garden. And are willing to frequently repair the issues that arise after frequent breaking updates. I predict that gap in the fence will closed off and non-Oculus Store games will no longer work within the next two years and Quests will be junk. Please consider other options if you're thinking about buying oculus.
- tibbon 5y agoFor those who have worked at Facebook - why in the world are their policies like this? Why is customer support so... unfriendly and unhelpful? No escalations possible? No way to reach anyone?
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoMy guess is money. Facebook has such a MASSIVE user base. And people are getting accounts stolen a LOT, from either social engineering or password reuse. But there's also a ton of people knowingly breaking rules, getting banned, and then trying to cry that their account was hacked. Trying to differentiate between someone's account being taken over and abused versus someone just simply being abusive and lying about it to support costs a lot of time, and time is money. And with the scale of Facebook, that adds up to a LOT of money. You have to train a large staff to understand social engineering and be able to tell the difference between someone who actually can't figure out how to log in, versus a jealous ex who is trying to social engineer their way into someone else's account. It's a lot cheaper to just let the bans stick, even if it loses a few customers.
- dredmorbius 5y ago3 billion active users. If 0.1% have account issues in a year, that's 8,200 support tickets per day. If each of those takes 20 minutes to resolve, then you'd need 115 support techs ... for three shifts, or about 350 total. Oh, and covering several languages. I'm guessing my 0.1% issue rate is low by a factor of 10--100. Resolution time may also be generous. Increase all other values correspondingly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- croes 5y ago10 billions profit a year, seems like enough money for user support
- jedimastert 5y ago
- fitzroy 5y agoWhat is the point of setting up a hardware or Google Authenticator-type 2FA solution when most companies will fallback to SMS? Is there a way to prevent the SMS fallback (last I checked it was 'No' for most sites except maybe Google if I remember, and then you still had to go in and manually delete it)? Does a master list exist of companies that don't use SMS, or allow the user to exclude it? Otherwise it seems like most 2FA is just opening up a much easier attack vector (social engineering a phone number port) vs guessing a long, random, unique password. A password manager with browser plugin (or iCloud Keychain) mostly solves the phishing issue if you stop a second to think on the rare occasions when you need to manually copy/paste because of a weird subdomain or partner domain. I've been 'about to' set up 2FA for over a decade now, but it always seems like a bad idea. Edit: Also, who's to say customer service agents won't/don't fallback to sending an SMS reset code even if the account supposedly requires a dongle or app for 2FA.
- Y_Y 5y ago2FA (is supposed to) mean you have both factors, not one or the other. It's strictly more secure that either alone, even if SMS sucks.
- mod 5y agoYes, but in some cases it's "2 outta 3" (or worse)
- someguydave 5y ago> What is the point of setting up a hardware or Google Authenticator-type 2FA solution when most companies will fallback to SMS? One possible point is that you could still log in somewhere that has internet but no cell service
- int_19h 5y agoWe have a better way of handling that these days: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_Access_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_Access_Network
- SrslyJosh 5y ago> I’ve gone from a position of caution about Oculus + Facebook to a position of “Run, don’t look back.” As if this wasn't an obvious problem. Relying on any of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, etc. for anything is a risk. Doubly so if it involves your business or a product that won't work without permission from $PLATFORM.
- dataviz1000 5y agoHow to become a Facebook power user: go to https://www.facebook.com/deactivate https://www.facebook.com/deactivate and follow the instructions.
- zmmmmm 5y agoI really think for the Oculus side of this, they should be on the hook for refunding a significant portion of the cost of the user's Oculus library when they ban the account. This would put the cost of a ban to Facebook for real users in the order of hundreds of dollars which is more than enough to have a support person do a realistic evaluation of the situation. It also reflects the non-recoverable portion of the cost to most users - you can sell the headset, but you can't transfer the value of the library to anybody. That is a straight up and very significant financial loss. While other aspects of the ban policy are obviously still very problematic, the fact that an arbitrary ban that is caused by actions outside the user's control can result in hundreds of dollars of losses sits at a whole different level and should be legally problematic for Facebook.
- judge2020 5y agoThis is another good part of steam - even if your account is banned from the entire community for site-wide spam, you don’t lose access to your game library.
- judge2020 5y agoEdit: looks like, of course, they can ban you and lose access to your games, however it requires threatening legal action against Valve. https://www.oneangrygamer.net/2020/06/steam-user-loses-game-library-after-valve-perma-bans-him-for-extreme-racism/ https://www.oneangrygamer.net/2020/06/steam-user-loses-game-... Looks like this user received this message[0] after being banned from the community and only because he mentioned russian law did Steam suspend his account. > Going to support and blalblab again my rights and the russian law, they slapped me with a perma community ban and 1 month ban to contact the support. 0: https://i.imgur.com/uciPvDC.png https://i.imgur.com/uciPvDC.png
- fuzxi 5y agoGenerally speaking, you don't lose access to your Steam library unless you defraud them, e.g. by charging back purchases. I don't buy that the Russian guy got banned for spamming. The only evidence that that was the ban reason is his own words. Considering that this story seems to have only been picked up by sites like "oneangrygamer", "riseupgamer", and the Daily Stormer, I'd lay money he's not being honest.
- beezischillin 5y agoThis is what I'm worried about, to be honest. Not necessarily getting hacked but just getting flagged, banned and burned with no recourse. This is why I commented on an article here some weeks ago that if they ever offered any paid user experience they'd be in trouble because they'd actually have to help their users with their issues. These tech companies should offer actual support the moment you spend money with them with some actual recourse to solve problems, especially if it's caused by them. It's insane to me that they can just go and run away with your money or burn your account at a moment's notice, even when it's just some automated filter going crazy. At the bare minimum something like Amazon has should be the standard the moment you operate a paid digital software repository or sell a digital service or ads. Losing your investment should not happen to you unless you're a really blatant abuser and if you're the one getting abused your bank or credit card provider should never be your only line of defense. I'm baffled that they have not been in any real conflict over this with any consumer protection agency for any of our governments.
- ElijahLynn 5y agoI guess this is the model when the user is the product and not the customer. Flipping this, if this were a paying advertiser (customer) that got locked out, there probably is a valid path to contact someone. Looks like it is time to remove all my Single Sign On from Google, Facebook, GitHub etc. And have individual user/pass for all of them. I have the same fear as you and way more so after reading this article, just way too much risk now.
- neartheplain 5y ago
- bob229 5y agoJust delete fb already
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoYes, Facebook is a bunch of assholes. This is obviously a grossly incompetent scenario at best, and a deliberate rip-off at worst. But the guy totally glosses over how they could have "beat his 2FA." That is a huge unanswered question.
- ElijahLynn 5y agoIDEA: Build a service that identifies all the Single Sign On accounts tied to your Facebook/Google/GitHub/Twitter accounts for you and gives you a nice list and instructions on how to separate out the accounts with links if possible.
- exikyut 5y agoThat's an interesting concept. Thinking about it for a bit, I'm sadly hesitant that it might need to be built as a browser extension or mobile app, rather than a website, because none of these services provide programmatically-accessible (even read-only) feeds of what you're looking for, so you'd need to scrape everything. This brings up two issues: 1) the headache of IP ratelimiting (and/or flat-out IP bans from trigger-happy systems optimized for fighting fraud/bots hosted on cloud infrastructure). IIUC there are proxy services that you can outsource the workaround problem to, but this is awkward to get behind in the face of 2), which is that users would need to input their actual usernames and passwords so that the service could request the account page with the details on it in order to scrape the data. Given that these are broadly web services poked at via HTTPS, you could potentially get everything you needed from a browser extension (as long as the service doesn't require you to set any HTTP headers that extensions aren't allowed to touch). The second possibility is using an app. Writing a thin layer that lets you craft custom HTTPS/whatever requests from a WebView would probably be the most straightforward approach. The main issue with both the extension and app approaches is that they code-dump both the idea and methodology of "here is how to do X" into the hands of the IQ-99 skiddie group (especially with an extension). So now you have more people running around scraping pages and whatnot and trying to figure out how to weaponize everything. Probably won't go anywhere (in terms of producing actual attacks), but the noise may potentially make your life harder. The least-complex solution seems to just be a giant boring list of links, for example: - https://myaccount.google.com/permissions https://myaccount.google.com/permissions - https://twitter.com/settings/connected_apps https://twitter.com/settings/connected_apps, https://twitter.com/settings/connected_accounts https://twitter.com/settings/connected_accounts - https://github.com/settings/apps/authorizations https://github.com/settings/apps/authorizations, https://github.com/settings/applications https://github.com/settings/applications, https://github.com/settings/installations https://github.com/settings/installations, https://github.com/settings/apps https://github.com/settings/apps, https://github.com/settings/developers https://github.com/settings/developers, https://github.com/settings/tokens https://github.com/settings/tokens Hmm, that's kind of all over the place for some things. A single aggregate view that combines everything could definitely be very interesting...
- mtnGoat 5y agoi love how they say it cant be reversed in the warning. that is an absolute falsehood. its worded in a way that leads you to believe its final and not possible to undo, which is entirely false. source: recently had to help someone get a developer account out of this position, account was reinstated. just gotta know the right people i guess? this is the biggest example of all, to me, why big tech needs regulating... if you are going to take away access to things i paid for(or worse yet, my families livelihood depends on), you dang well better be willing to explain very explicitly why and provide me with a real person to appeal to. not some automated system(im looking at you too Google and Apple!)
- jedimastert 5y agoYeah, "can't" and "won't" are very different words
- s5300 5y ago, poisoned our water supply, burned our crops and delivered a plague unto our houses! "He did?" No, but are we just gonna wait around until Zuckerberg does?
- nitwit005 5y agoGoogle makes a point in their ads for the chromebook that you need a Google account to login, which my brain immediately translates into "could be randomly bricked at any time". It's possible that's not true, but there's such an endless stream of these stories, that that's the attitude you have to take.
- jedimastert 5y agoI think a Chromebook is a touch different, as there's nothing actually tied to the hardware itself (which, I suppose, is sort of the point). If your Google account is borked, nothing is unrecoverable from the computer and any other account can log into it. That being said, you will be screwed in various other ways, mainly that all of the information you'd lose because it was normally stored on the you've now lost because you got the ban hammer
- deeviant 5y agoMy Spidey-Sense is telling me that the person in the article may not be telling the whole truth.
- paulpauper 5y agoFacebook sucks.what else is new.have not had a personal account in a decade after they terminated it. No regrets.i do however own the stock and remain very optimistic about the business but not for me. Sucks to invest to so much time in a platform that can take it all away from you without warning.
- 101_101 5y agoLOL that's what you get for using a shitty company like that. owner called you a dumb fuck BTW.
- koreanguy 5y agolying piece of snake oil, he is a content writer think about that for a moment. Facebook spends billions on security, its impossible to hack Facebook, this guy is full of snake oil. his a techie and pretty sure he secured his accounts properly. i hate these fake as posts
- Shorel 5y agoIs Firefox multi-account container for Facebook enough to prevent this cookie stealing hack?
- Haga 5y agoCentralized eco systems and monocultures are extremely vulnerable to attacks in nature. May be worth a investment into mastodon or matrix to have the " fb that still works" the day the big one strikes and takes them out.
- zippyy 5y agoits a shame that a corp like microsoft has nerfed the oculus to require a facebook account. and on top of that use shitty 2fa
- 02020202 5y agoyou guys still use facebook?
- golover721 5y agoI honestly have never seen my login to Facebook expire. Even without enabling the remember me checkbox after logging in on iOS safari the login is valid forever unless I clear the cookies. I have never seen that level of brazen disregard for security with any other modern site.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoJust a question: could the author create a new Facebook account and never use it except to login with his Oculus? He would lose his game purchases, though. Once you use a Facebook account with Oculus, is the device not wipeable to factory status? This guy’s story is why I try to split book and other media purchases between Amazon, Google, and Apple - so, if I lose any account I only lose about 1/3 of my purchases.
- bawana 5y agodid he ever say if he found out HOW his account specifically was compromised? There is a lot of discussion here about how SMS is a weak link. But I dont get it. The example of one respondent providedd is koiphish. This is just a MITM attack. Doesnt https protect against this? If a MITM DID worrk, does that mean someone forged/stole facebook's certificate?
- garyfirestorm 5y agoI don’t understand how the hacker bypassed 2FA? Did OP accidentally entered his keys somewhere? Or did the hacker convince FB support to disable 2FA? How can we all avoid OP’s fate. Lot of comments go in-depth on yubi keys and whatnot. But if FB support disabled 2FA what good is a U2F, fido2 and whatnot?
- efficax 5y agoIf it's malware that steals cookies, no 2fa is necessary, just set up your cookies and log in like it's a live session
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoI ditched my Rift as soon as the announcement was made that users would be forced to migrate to Facebook accounts. FB is practically radioactive, I'm not creating an account for them, let alone giving them a direct pipe to built in cameras and microphones in my VR headset.