14 ms·
Many countries have a funny concept of strategic industries. In mine, dairy is a strategic industry that is coddled by government so that we can have a local s
by Scoundreller 5y ago
Many countries have a funny concept of strategic industries.
In mine, dairy is a strategic industry that is coddled by government so that we can have a local source. But every country thinks that so there’s foes and allies that can supply us UHT or powder milk on a moment’s notice. And if our milk supply disappeared tomorrow, everyone over 1y could substitute with 10000000 different things for nutrition.
Cars are another. Every country props up its auto industry, so why worry about a domestic supply?
Meanwhile, there are critical components, pharma ingredients or other inputs built in 1 factory in a country we could likely end up in a big dispute with.
Just goes to show that industry protection has nothing to do with risk/dependence on that product, and everything to do with picking and choosing which industries are important voting bases.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 5y agoHow the essential farma became nearly 100% reliant on foreign manufacturers is I think the most exemplary case of this nonsense. I read some year ago that there were laws in US which at least somehow discouraged the pharma from shipping manufacturing abroad, and it was the big pharma itself which lobbied these laws out. This is how China held US at gunpoint in the early days of COVID — "Stay put, or we pull 90%+ of your antibiotics supply"
- NotSammyHagar 5y agoI don't think china did that, any supporting news articles?
- cutemonster 5y ago> picking and choosing which industries are important voting bases. And on a bribes and corruption basis, to some extent, too? For example, I never thought about what are the strategic industries, when voting.
- unityByFreedom 5y agoIndeed. The goal is to not have the government pick industries. Politicizing who gets aid to any greater degree would only serve to further subdue innovation.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> For example, I never thought about what are the strategic industries, when voting. You're clearly not a dairy producer in Wisconsin, a military contractor in Virginia/Maryland, or a property owner in Southern Pines, NC.
- sandyarmstrong 5y agoYup! In 2008 I was in my first job, working for a defense contractor, and my boss seriously could not wrap his head around the idea of me voting for Obama. In his mind that should have gone completely against my own self-interest. But he also saw the job as a lifetime career, which is partly generational and partly just a different mindset because a lot (most?) of the engineers there were former military. I will say, though, that his mindset generally made for a very friendly and nurturing team experience.
- diveandfight 5y agoIs there something uniquely strategic about property owners in Southern Pines?? If anything, based on my knowledge, military contractors would be the strategic play down there (just as in VA/MD).
- throwawaygh 5y agoCamp Mackall, Fort Bragg, the complex around those two, and an officer corps/civilian contractor base that enjoys golf. I was just giving it as an example of how whole tertiary industries that aren't directly part of the military-industrial complex will none-the-less vote (R) like their lifestyle depends on it, and for the same reason as contractors.
- mywittyname 5y ago
- shadowgovt 5y ago> Every country props up its auto industry, so why worry about a domestic supply? War. In the event a war breaks out, a running auto plant can be re-tooled relatively rapidly into a light and heavy armor plant. It's not even a question of whether allies could supply tanks and troop transports; it's about having domestic capacity to make them because enemies could execute blockades and disrupt allied resource supply.
- sonthonax 5y agoIs that still true now?
- shadowgovt 5y agoGreat question. It's still doctrinally true (i.e. governments believe it is true; it was one of the reasons cited for the US federal government buying key stake in domestic auto manufacturers instead of letting them go bankrupt during the real estate market crash), but whether light and heavy armor is actually of military worth in an era of drones and air power is a question I don't have the military training or knowledge to answer.
- starfallg 5y agoYes, because heavy industry produces light and heavy armour, and heavy industry is also required to produce military drones and other weapons.
- sonthonax 5y agoI'm unsure whether you can still retool an automotive factory to produce war materiel. During WWII Ford automotive plants produced aircraft, but back then the construction techniques needed to build a bomber weren't all together different from a car (think larger engines and chassis). > whether light and heavy armor is actually of military worth in an era of drones and air power is a question I don't have the military training or knowledge to answer. On this point, it obviously depends on what kind of war we're fighting. The British used unarmoured and open top Land Rovers with 50cals mounted on the rear for the first few years in Afghanistan until the government got its act together (they looked cool, but were IED death traps). There's a similar story with the Humvee. Nonetheless, civilian style vehicles had their use.
- kevin_nisbet 5y agoYea this is very interesting. I suspect another side to this though is I don't know that one country can easily or safely not participate in this chosen industry support. Especially in capital intensive industries, say cars, all of the competing countries are propping up or bailing out their auto industries. So even if companies should theoretically die and get replaced, there is a structural disadvantage as the competition in other countries has an insurance policy against companies failing (bailout / subsidy / tariffs / strategic protection / etc).
- unethical_ban 5y agoIndeed, there seems to be a difference worth noting between "industries that currently employ a large number of the population with little transfer of utility to other industry" and "objectively basic needs for a society". I figure there are also different definitions of strategic depending on the size and capability of an economy. The US is large and geographically fortunate enough that it theoretically "could" be almost entirely self-sustaining if it set its mind to it. Fuel, semiconductors, transport, lumber, food, guns.
- guerrilla 5y ago> Indeed, there seems to be a difference worth noting between "industries that currently employ a large number of the population with little transfer of utility to other industry" and "objectively basic needs for a society". Did you consider that it's because people need an income to survive? Employment is objectively a basic need for anyone who doesn't own sufficient capital being that they have nothing else to sell but their labor.
- unethical_ban 5y agoI didn't say that keeping people employed was a bad thing. I was making a distinction in definition, not in value.
- nickff 5y agoHighly visible industries tend to get a disproportionate number of subsidies, because the population can relate to them, and politicians aren't that clever either. Film and television are good examples, and fishing tends to get a lot of attention too.
- namelessoracle 5y agoPretty much everyone understands that computer chips are needed for everything these days though. The population can relate just fine. It's just there's no one rich and powerful who wants to make the investment that is making it an issue.
- Johnny555 5y agoI'm not sure that the population can relate to building a semiconductor ecosystem in the USA -- when a state gives incentives to bring movie production there, people think "Well look at all of those jobs and movies give our state great exposure", but when the government wants to spend billions helping to build a next-gen fab plant here, then it's like "wait, I paid thousands of dollars for my phone and computer, why are we paying them to build plants here, don't we pay them enough!?" You may say "But semiconductors are used in far more devices than phones and computers", but I'm not sure the average person realizes that. Well maybe they are now when they can't buy the car they want because it's delayed due to semiconductor availability.
- l33t2328 5y agoI’m pretty sure the average person knows computer chips are important. > wait, I paid thousands of dollars for my phone and computer, why are we paying them to build plants here, don't we pay them enough This line of reasoning isn’t generally extended to any other area of production, so I don’t see why it would apply here.
- Johnny555 5y agoYet there's plenty of people that speak out specifically against semiconductor subsidies: https://foundersbroadsheet.com/does-the-semiconductor-industry-need-government-subsidies/ https://foundersbroadsheet.com/does-the-semiconductor-indust... Supply and demand shocks will work themselves out fairly quickly if just left to market forces without government involvement. But a large section of the US population is under the delusion that if there’s a problem, only government can fix it. https://thehill.com/opinion/international/560338-government-semiconductor-subsidies-the-case-for-limits https://thehill.com/opinion/international/560338-government-... One part of the legislation, the CHIPS Act, allocates $52 billion to subsidize the construction of new chip factories in the United States. Officials believe it could result in seven to 10 new U.S. factories. Although a national security case can be made for it, too much subsidy can do more harm than good.
- jvanderbot 5y agoHow much would it cost to set up TSMC inside US borders? One president cycle? 4 F-35s? One SLS? A nuclear submarine? According to this page, sorting by cost, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabrication_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat... the most expensive fab is 33 Giga$. TSMC is 17G$. pennies on the dollar in our 1-3Trillion infrastructure bill. Make america fab again. EDIT: it appears this is in the 2T infrastructure bill. https://www.eetimes.com/biden-ups-ante-to-50-billion-for-chips-act/ https://www.eetimes.com/biden-ups-ante-to-50-billion-for-chi...
- Kye 5y agoIsn't TSMC working on expanding into the US?
- datameta 5y agoThey are indeed, in Arizona. First they are going to have employees train on-site in Taiwan (will get housing for themselves and their families for duration).
- api 5y agoThis makes it easier for the US to spin up more, since we gain more trained workers who understand these processes.
- datameta 5y agoI thought similarly - this is true if we can have lossless knowledge transfer. I imagine we would have to put what is learned into practice before translating it into distributed knowledge for a US fab workforce.
- zsmi 5y agoThe US does produce ~10% of the global chip supply today, and much of the equipment used in the world's factories, and a very significant portion of the software needed, is made in the U.S.A. This is an economic issue. Not a knowledge gap.
- quadcore 5y agoOn that matter, I think (just a not-so-well-informed opinion but still plausible) most countries should urgently protect their software development industry and dramatically reduce taxes on those companies. Because the day US/China automated-production AIs will get to its prime, nothing produced in your county will have any value whatsoever beside land. Ferrari and Rayban? Near-zero market value tomorrow.
- fsloth 5y ago"Because the day US/China automated-production AIs will get to its prime" I think this time is quite a bit far off. But eventually will have sourcing price of just the raw materials. That said and regarding your next point - "Ferrari and Rayban? Near-zero market value tomorrow." On this I disagree strongly. Current trend is that IP becomes constantly more important. So that while manufacturing costs for said items may tumble, IP laws likely protect the sale of items branded as such. And the price difference does not likely result in cheaper prices, but in a bigger revenues.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quadcore 5y agoThat's interesting thanks. I guess there is a limit to the price of IP. Say if the glasses cost $0.50, can you sell that $400 really?
- eloff 5y agoAre you in Canada by chance? I have fond childhood memories of smuggling cheese across the border from the US because the dairy protectionism has resulted in prices that are 3x higher. We used to do that with electronics too, but Canada has no electronics industry so it's weird why it was so much more expensive. The gap has decreased in recent years.
- jollybean 5y agoIt's definitely worth keeping a skeptical eye on non-market interventions, but there are a ton of good reasons for it. For auto - companies do not exist in isolation. They're a huge pillar for other things, especially the local economy. If you were the CEO of a 'region' that actually owned all of the businesses, this would show up in your balance sheet: it would be perfectly acceptable to lose money in your auto-making 'division' if it meant that the 'education division', 'healthcare division', 'civic division' were made profitable. Japan also makes a ton of money exporting it's cars so it's valuable. Finance, telecoms, farming and entertainment all have different reasons for being supported but the impetus in most cases is rational. If anything we probably need more high end fabs and this whole 'single source with 24/7 operations' is maybe not worth it, we might just have to be paying a little more for our chips.