10 ms·
As a taxpayer and voter (but not a military person), it felt like we could have kept a 10k personnel presence on the cheap. Soldiers weren't dying. Now the wom
by echelon 5y ago
As a taxpayer and voter (but not a military person), it felt like we could have kept a 10k personnel presence on the cheap. Soldiers weren't dying.
Now the women and children will be raped and unfree, ideologically and religiously different killed, and LGBT tortured.
We shouldn't have been there, but this is a horrible outcome far worse than staying.
I find the "but they won't defend themselves" argument abhorrent and totally unsympathetic. I can't imagine if I were in their shoes.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoSo you were willing to stay there forever? Or at least with some sort with some sort of open-ended commitment. How would we ever know when it was time to leave? Lots of other places in the world where bad things are happening - should we send troops to those places as well? Where does it end?
- TchoBeer 5y agoIdeally there should be a solution that's neither "stay there forever" nor "pull out and let the Taliban take complete control".
- adventured 5y agoNo. The US is so broke it's buying its own debt by the trillions of dollars via debasing its currency to keep the federal lights on (to keep social security and medicare solvent). We can't pay our bills properly. When as a nation your central bank has to buy your own debt because nobody else can afford to buy so much garbage paper, you clearly can't afford such irresponsible foreign adventurism. Enough is enough. Time to go home. Time to reduce military spending immediately. Time to stop playing at nation building. Time to stop pretending we can afford to be a globally deployed military superpower, as though WW3 is going on and we have to be at max defense spending. The US couldn't afford Afghanistan 15 years ago. It most certainly can't afford it now.
- int_19h 5y agoThere really isn't. The only practical alternative was to hand it over to some other great power to occupy, but no-one is stupid enough to willingly take that hot potato. And yes, it was occupation. One thing that the rapid collapse made clear, is that Taliban genuinely has plenty of popular support, and the US-backed government had very little. Keep in mind that ANA had three times as much manpower as the Taliban, and military equipment supplied by US - and yet it all just dissipated in less than two weeks, because, apparently, no-one was actually willing to fight.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- neolog 5y ago17 US troops died there in 2019. If that's what it takes to maintain a democracy, it may be worth that cost indefinitely.
- int_19h 5y agoWhat makes you believe Afghanistan was a democracy under US control?
- neolog 5y agoAfghanistan's democracy was weak but improving over time. https://freedomhouse.org/country/afghanistan/freedom-world/2021 https://freedomhouse.org/country/afghanistan/freedom-world/2...
- int_19h 5y agoIMO this assessment is overly optimistic, focusing too much on the outer trappings, and too little on the reality on the ground. They did have competitive politics, yes - but competition was really between various clans, and not for individual votes.
- afutileattempt1 5y agoI mean people launch BLM over 15 or so unarmed black men killed in police encounters in a nation of 350million or so. They definitely don’t think it’s just the cost of a police force.
- karakot 5y agoYeah, "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make"
- kasey_junk 5y agoPerhaps we just start with the places we invaded? The idea that we were in Afghanistan too long seems odd given our bases in Germany, Japan, Korea, the Philippines or Cuba.
- blitz_skull 5y agoIf my tax dollars paying American troops to maintain order prevented a single little girl from being violently raped at the hands of the Taliban—yeah, I'd say let's stay there forever. I mean seriously, this argument holds no weight whatsoever. No one ever intended to stay there forever. But maybe "stay there long enough to help the government be resistant to religious zealots willing to die to subdue non-believers"? That seems like a pretty damn low-bar.
- wwweston 5y agoOr as Colin Powell famously put it: “you break it, you bought it.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pottery_Barn_rule https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pottery_Barn_rule
- adventured 5y ago> We shouldn't have been there, but this is a horrible outcome far worse than staying. You mean it's going to return to what it was before the US got involved. The US attempted to prop up the ~300,000 person Afghan national military. The majority of the people of Afghanistan clearly had no interest in defending anything or keeping anything. It folded instantly, with close to zero resistance, despite outnumbering the Taliban four to one, having control of the skies and superior weaponry. The US can't reasonably stay in Afghanistan forever to defend the 3% of the population that aligns ideologically with Western values. The next thing the US should do is to immediately proceed to close over half of its foreign military bases and start leaving other countries as well. > I find the "but they won't defend themselves" argument abhorrent and totally unsympathetic. They won't fight for Western values - which the US attempted to force on them - because they overwhelmingly don't agree with or believe in Western values. They don't have a fervor for those beliefs, whereas the Taliban do have a fervor for their beliefs. It is that simple, whether you find reality abhorrent or not. The best anyone can hope for is that as many as possible of the small minority of people in Afghanistan that do want those values, are able to flee the country.
- echelon 5y ago> The next thing the US should do is to immediately proceed to close over half of its foreign military bases and start leaving other countries as well. That's an incredible geopolitical farce. Putin would love it. The United States cannot become isolationist, lest it risk its economy, dollar trade, and geopolitical edge. Adversarial nations would gladly step in to fill the void, and our allies would be at a loss. The "America is evil and incompetent" meme is atrocious.
- tzs 5y agoPolls of Afghanis at the time the US went in showed around 80% support for the US toppling the Taliban government. The Taliban has never been popular among more than a small minority of Afghans.
- nradov 5y agoIt was hardly cheap. The logistic train necessary to sustain troops in a landlocked country without secure transportation routes was horribly expensive. In some cases it cost $100 to deliver a gallon of fuel to an outpost after accounting for all the transportation and security costs. Tactical aircraft are wearing our from overuse and we can't afford replacements. Meanwhile the military-industrial complex wants to have those 10k personnel preparing for a future conflict with China.