11 ms·
Federal Court Orders BitMEX to Pay $100M over Illegal Crypto Trading
- qeternity 5y ago> The CFTC’s litigation against BitMEX’s founders continues. I’m surprised that it’s “only” $100m given that they are continuing to pursue criminal charges against the founders.
- ABeeSea 5y agoMost of these entities probably don’t have that much liquid cash. Are they going to need to sell a bunch of crypto to pay the fine? $100M is a huge amount in these shallow markets.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- huac 5y agoA single block order taking out $100M of liquidity could move markets but it's not a priori that big. Bitmex has $1-2B of daily trade volume (per nomics) even after all of the controversy, Binance has $50B and FTX has $11.5B.
- vngzs 5y agoYeah, but trading volume is not liquid cash. It's not the exchange's money. They make money on fees / commissions, but they can't just dip into the customer funds and use them to pay the government.
- rootsudo 5y agoYou'd think but look at Mt. Gox.
- ur-whale 5y ago> You'd think but look at Mt. Gox. Gox was a ridiculously amateurish affair run by a french pimply php hacker and manga lover teenager. Bitmex is in a slightly different league.
- gruez 5y ago>but they can't just dip into the customer funds and use them to pay the government. But if they have $1B-2B worth of trade volume daily and they charge a 0.1% fee per trade, wouldn't that mean they're generating $1M daily in revenue? From that, wouldn't it be reasonable to assume they have profits accumulated to pay the fine?
- schmichael 5y agoHow is trading volume related to cash liquidity? An exchange with 0 fiat on/offramps and no cash in the bank could still trade billions of USD worth of cryptocurrencies a day.
- gruez 5y ago>How is trading volume related to cash liquidity It's not. The parent commentis talking about the liqudity of the market as a whole (ie. what would happen if 100M worth of bitcoin was sold at once) >An exchange with 0 fiat on/offramps and no cash in the bank could still trade billions of USD worth of cryptocurrencies a day. It would presumably have millions of USD worth of crypto in their wallet (since they charge trading fees). They can take the crypto and dump it into the very liquid bitcoin market to turn it into cash.
- latchkey 5y ago$100m is peanuts in crypto now. A Chinese defi site just got hacked for $600m today.
- schmichael 5y ago$100m of USD is different from $600m worth of cryptocurrencies.
- whynotkeithberg 5y agoIt is in a market without liquidity... However, in a market with enough trading volume from enough unique people there isn't that much of a difference. especially not in a market where hundreds of million get dropped in literal minutes.
- latchkey 5y agoMuch of the theft was in pool1 tokens... eth/btc/usd... in fact, the hacker could have taken more, but left a lot of the shttokens on the table just because it was wasted effort.
- whynotkeithberg 5y agoExactly. Someone else commented that 100m in USD is way different than 100 worth of crypto... But that's just not true anymore. 100 million in a highly liquid market where you can see 100 million dropped on a single exchange in a single minute candlestick on bitcoin alone, then it really isn't that much of a difference.
- arcticbull 5y ago100M USDT yeah, USD who knows? It's 85% of trading volume. Check out the plot on Coinlib. [1] Today's USD trading volume was $193M while USDT was $5.2B. USD trading volume is a rounding error against USDT volume. 100M USD is more than 1/2 of the entire day's trading volume of BTC against real dollars. My understanding is the CFTC doesn't take Tethers. [1] https://coinlib.io/coin/BTC/Bitcoin https://coinlib.io/coin/BTC/Bitcoin
- graeme 5y ago900 Bitcoin are mined each day. If we make two assumptions we can get an estimate of how much fiat enters the markets each day: * Bitcoin mining is an efficient market and there are no profits * Bitcoin miners sell all of the bitcoin they mine These assumptions aren't exactly realistic but over the long run they should actually be close enough to the truth. Given those assumptions, at current market rates then an extra $41,121,180 has to enter the markets each day to keep prices stable, assuming buy/sell demand is otherwise equal. More than that wanting to enter, prices go up, less, prices go down. Leaving aside price manipulation by Tether, Binance etc (THIS is a big assumption, but the exercise is still valuable I think). So, the fine is only 2.5x the daily excess needed to keep prices stable. Shouldn't have a giant effect. (You may wonder, if no profits, what are the miners doing? Essential the bitcoin network is an organized effort to take capital, acquire coal, and burn it. Contrary to "store of value" claims, literally all money invested into bitcoin either gets burned up, or goes to pay someone who entered bitcoin previously. It's an entirely negative sum game, with guaranteed capital losses in aggregate. However, this added $100 million is not a meaningful amount in view of the actual scale of energy burnt each year to run the network. It might be a meaningful amount of Bitmex's capital, but likely this won't wreck them on its own.)
- mdoms 5y agoYour post assumes that there's no manipulation of the market occurring, an assumption we know to be false.
- csomar 5y agoI don’t think the miners can manipulate their energy bill, salaries, rent, hardware costs, etc…
- Clewza313 5y agoThe OP's assumption was that $42M in fiat has to enter every day to keep prices stable. Manipulation can definitely keep prices stable without a net fiat inflow... until one day it can't, because as you note the bills have to be paid in fiat, not Tether etc.
- felixbraun 5y agoThey have $1.7b in the insurance fund and take in $300-500m / yr (easy calculation if you know their fees and volume, which is known to be "real"; Bitmex is absolutely legit and it is disturbing that charges against their founders continue)
- Permit 5y ago> Bitmex is absolutely legit and it is disturbing that charges against their founders continue When you say "absolutely legit" what exactly do you mean? That they clearly have anti-money laundering programs in place? Or do you mean they are "absolutely legit" in the sense that they created a foreign entity that shouldn't be held to U.S. anti-money laundering laws?
- ac29 5y agoLegit since when? They signed a consent degree and have agreed to pay this huge fine. They are absolutely guilty of what they are accused of here - they allowed US persons to trade in violation of US futures laws. They were trying to play the "we block US IPs, therefore we block US persons" card, which is laughable enough that they were never going to fool anyone serious.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoDeutsche Bank pays fines of hundreds and even billions of dollars on almost monthly basis (for money laundering, fraud, currency manipulation etc). That doesn't make it not a legit bank.
- ur-whale 5y ago> $100M is a huge amount in these shallow markets. Is it? What are your sources?
- arcticbull 5y agoCoinlib says USD trading volume today was $193M vs $5.2B in 3%-backed ersatz dollars (USDT). So that's 60% of a day's entire trading volume globally. [1] https://coinlib.io/coin/BTC/Bitcoin https://coinlib.io/coin/BTC/Bitcoin
- ur-whale 5y agoI very much doubt the USistan racketeer will demand its dues to be paid in full the day after tomorrow. I also very much doubt that selling USD 100M worth of crypto over the course of a couple of months will have any sizable effects on the markets.
- jkhdigital 5y agoEspecially when you’ve got companies like Tesla buying $1.5B. All it takes is one more midsize corporate CFO getting redpilled and converting a chunk of the treasury into crypto.
- arcticbull 5y agoTesla's purchase covered about 5 weeks of miner fees. It burned up long before it was even announced.
- vmception 5y agoThe markets aren't that shallow.
- fuddle 5y agoThey just sponsored an Italian soccer team, so they must be doing okay. https://www.acmilan.com/en/news/articles/sponsor/2021-08-10/bitmex-joins-ac-milan-as-first-ever-sleeve-partner https://www.acmilan.com/en/news/articles/sponsor/2021-08-10/...
- slyrus 5y agoWasn't there some news about a $100M BTC transaction yesterday? Coincidence?
- ac29 5y agoYou're probably thinking of a few $100M Tether transfers over the weekend. I'd say its just a coincidence, but you never know in crypto.
- tiborsaas 5y ago> The Seychelles-based company wrote it agrees to pay as much as $100 million to resolve the charges with the US organizations, but did not clarify how much was going to each agency. https://blockworks.co/bitmex-agrees-to-settlement-up-to-100m-with-us-cftc-and-fincen/ https://blockworks.co/bitmex-agrees-to-settlement-up-to-100m...
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoSo I'm working on a crypto derivatives trading bot... have been for a few years now... it's going alright. I am personally situated in Ontario, Canada, and getting more and more anxious by the day as seemingly every major legitimate derivatives trading platform with any volume is banning Ontarians from trading. Kraken, Bitmex, Okex, and Huobi all won't even look at me simply because I have a personal address inside Ontario. I can trade on their spot markets with them, sure... but the fees are MUCH higher than that of derivatives markets and my bot isn't THAT good to swallow a 0.3% trade cost when it's essentially performing high frequency trading. A fee of 0.075% however is manageable. Binance still allows me to trade derivatives, and I can't figure out how or why. They don't have any legal authority to allow Ontarians to trade afaik, and they're the absolute largest derivatives trading platform on the planet right now. I tried setting up a corporation in the UK back when Bitmex originally banned Ontarians, but when I went to register that corporation as a trader with Bitmex, they demanded to know the identity of all of the owners of the corporation, and if any of them resided inside Ontario then they wouldn't work with that corporation as well. (the bot was originally setup to trade on Bitmex as they had the most liquidity at the time, but that has dwindled significantly ever since they banned Ontarians and all of the USA from trading in October 2020) I don't have millions of dollars in my pocket, so I don't have the money to jump through legal loopholes by registering shell corporations and paying representatives to act as proxy owners in non-banned jurisdictions. I'm not doing anything wrong imho. I'm not risking my life savings or going to crash the cryptocurrency market with my derivatives trading ways or whatever the Ontario government is trying to protect me from? I am just another guy trying to make a buck like everyone else on this planet. Why is my government trying to prevent me from doing so at every turn? I just don't get it? What are my options if/when Binance decides to ban Ontarians as well?
- ur-whale 5y ago> What are my options Vote with your feet.
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoTrust me, I've considered it! I've got a large family and a massive network of friends here in Ontario, however. I grew up here, I can't move. I've considered getting dual citizenship in another country, but that isn't exactly cheap or problem free either. And I don't think the estonia e-residency is enough to satisfy regulators/crypto-exchanges that are serious about KYC.
- hamburgerwah 5y agoTo me this just validates that crypto has gone beyond the too big too fail threshold. Bitmex will pay fines similar to a slap on the wrist that any wall street firm has paid for bad behavior. Make a few billion doing grey area things, pay a tiny % extortion to regulators.
- vmception 5y agoWhat do you prefer to happen? They get curb stomped to oblivion leaving less options in the marketplace? This is something US regulators weigh so I was wondering if you do too.
- idiotsecant 5y agoYes, in a just universe BitMEX would be stomped into nonexistence, just not for this. They have consistently been by far the shadiest and scummiest 'exchange' around.
- gruez 5y ago>They have consistently been by far the shadiest and scummiest 'exchange' around. Can you provide some context for people who's not in the loop?
- jondwillis 5y agoGiven how bad some of these centralized exchanges have been over the years, I can't imagine this is true. 1. Africrypt - 3.6B USD, founders disappeared (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-23/s-african-brothers-vanish-and-so-does-3-6-billion-in-bitcoin https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-23/s-african...) 2. Bitfinex 36% haircut hack (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bitfinex-hacked-hongkong-idUSKCN10I06H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bitfinex-hacked-hongkong-...) - not to mention being in bed with Tether for a long time. 3. MtGox... the list goes on.
- 5y ago
- pyronik19 5y agoIs there anything the government won't just take totalitarian control over at the whim of some slimey bureaucrat?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tablespoon 5y agoI wonder how this will affect the crypto ecosystem and Bitcoin?