11 ms·
I’ve been harping on this since learning covid was aerosol based early 2020. I like to tell new parents a trick that worked well for us: use a nice filter-base
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
I’ve been harping on this since learning covid was aerosol based early 2020.
I like to tell new parents a trick that worked well for us: use a nice filter-based air purifier for white noise. It has deep bass, and it keeps the air near the child extremely clean. We have been doing this for our kids for almost 10 years now since birth.
A fun experiment for kids: if you have a laser pointer, shine it close to the ground indoors and kick up dust near the floor. If you see any light in the air, that is all stuff you are breathing in (works really well on carpet)…
Air quality associated with:
Alzheimers: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-new-alzheimers-air-pollution-link/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-new-alzheimer...
Cancers, plural: https://www.aacr.org/patients-caregivers/progress-against-cancer/air-pollution-associated-cancer/ https://www.aacr.org/patients-caregivers/progress-against-ca...
Sperm Quality: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4443398/#sec99552title https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4443398/#sec995...
Female Fertility: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2207560-exposure-to-air-pollution-seems-to-negatively-affect-womens-fertility/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2207560-exposure-to-air...
Autism: https://www.sciencealert.com/particulate-matter-in-air-pollution-raises-autism-risks-in-the-first-few-years https://www.sciencealert.com/particulate-matter-in-air-pollu...
Bipolar/Depression: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/air-pollution-linked-to-bipolar-disorder-depression https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/air-p...
- LegitShady 5y agorecently replaced a robot vacuum with a corded plugin model with 3x the suction power and the amount of dust it removed from carpets already 'clean' by the robovac was pretty incredible. I have the robot vacuum still doing its thing every other day but at least once a week I do a deep clean and it removes a ton of dust. I also have a HEPA filter air purifier going 24 hours. Carpets are the worst.
- tehnub 5y agoMaybe the carpet acts as a filter for dust that you would otherwise be breathing?
- coding123 5y agoCarpets really just molt and let its shit go into the air.
- LegitShady 5y agoI dont think it filters anything - it just provides the dust a place to lay down until something knocks it up into the air. It would have to have some mechanism for getting the dust to the other side to act as a filter, and then you'd still have to clean/dispose of it somehow.
- h2odragon 5y agoMore of a grinder to make sure anything big enough to fall out gets smashed up into particles small enough to stay floating. (Less the occasional cleaning, which... isn't comprehensive. wash a used rug someday. ick.)
- elektor 5y agoWhat vacuum would you recommend?
- LegitShady 5y agoI would recommend doing a bunch of research as there are third party reviewers who test them. I went with a shark uplight apex but I am not a vacuum professional, I just have asthma and hate dust.
- bittercynic 5y agoI bought a cheap used miele canister after reading this: https://old.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1pe2bd/iama_vacuum_repair_technician_and_i_cant_believe/ https://old.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1pe2bd/iama_vacuum_re... It has been great so far. The bags are a little expensive, but worth it. It is quiet and pleasant to use and has strong suction, and parts are available if we need them.
- LegitShady 5y agothe shark I bought doesn't use a bag at all - it has an integrated hepa filter I clean off once a week but aside from that no ongoing costs. I am wary of taking 7 year old advice in general, given how quickly things change and how companies put out new products each year, but I hope you like your vacuum. I paid $215 USD for my vacuum new with a 5 year warranty - there's very little a tech could do on this vacuum that wouldn't cost more than a new vacuum.
- xnyan 5y agoI used to have the same opinion, then I used a Miele and it's really quite shocking how good it is. Not trying to sell you on one, but if you have the chance to try one out you may be surprised.
- driscoll42 5y agoRtings recently started reviewing vacuums which does a nice comparison: https://www.rtings.com/vacuum https://www.rtings.com/vacuum
- goodpoint 5y agoCarpets should be illegal.
- 7thaccount 5y agoI've suffered from terrible allergies my entire life. I bought the best air filter I could find and then bought two portable HEPA air filters running the best filters I could find. It's been great. I went months without allergy medicine. A total quality of life improvement.
- pkdpic_y9k 5y agoLove both of these ideas / tips! Any suggestions on specific air filters?
- colechristensen 5y agoYou have to look quite carefully because "HEPA" became branding rather than rating, and you can find it labelled on filter appliances which vary in capture rates by several orders of magnitude. You want ones with numbers, 99.97% is a good number to find, you can get it on big Honeywell filters. While incredibly difficult to find, there are MPR 2800 rated furnace filters which are better than HEPA.
- londons_explore 5y agoIf you're recirculating the air through the filter many times, the capture rate doesn't really matter. What you don't catch on the first pass you'll catch in the 2nd. From that point of view, even a 90% catch rate sounds fine.
- colechristensen 5y agoWhen you're dealing with a machine that is exchanging air in a room a certain number of times per hour and a continuous influx of particulates, with less efficient filters you need more air exchanges which means more filters, bigger fans, etc. The takeaway is that less particle efficient filters won't ever get you down to the same steady state as better filters in real world applications. And from personal experience with filters and devices to measure airborne particles, it is hard enough getting good numbers with the best filters I can find.
- jalino23 5y agowhere can i buy this filter?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWe purchased a filtrete room air purifier 10 years ago, and amazingly it hasn’t broken down after essentially continuous usage (low speed during the day, high speed at night to make more noise :)). These are on amazon or wherever.
- inter_netuser 5y agoyes, but what about the hygiene hypothesis of increasing allergy/autoimmune disease prevalence?
- jessaustin 5y agoAir indoors should be clean, but children should spend hours outside in nature every day. This won't be an option in some urban environments, but those are simply bad for the health of children (and adults).
- dperfect 5y agoI'm all for cleaner air (especially reducing dangerous gases and pollutants), but at what point does the over-sterilization of our environment (specifically with regard to microbes) do more harm than good? People in my family suffer from various allergies, and many suspect there may be at least some link to not being exposed to enough allergens at an early age (father was a surgeon and our home was always clean – nearly to the level of an O.R.).
- 8note 5y agoBeing exposed to allergens at home is the worst. I grew up with a dog, and never tasted or smelled anything until a few years after the dog died
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gpm 5y agoThe particulate matter that I worry about isn't microbes, it's all the crap that we're creating and putting into our environment with things like power generation and vehicles, which makes up the majority of the small particulate matter. Sorry for the crappy source, but I'm short on time right now to find you a better one: https://laqm.defra.gov.uk/public-health/pm25.html https://laqm.defra.gov.uk/public-health/pm25.html
- piyh 5y agoThe composition of airborne particles depends highly on what size you're measuring. The stuff you see when you kick the carpet is the "big" stuff like cotton breaking down.
- dwd 5y agoRadon buildup is also a potential concern if you have your house sealed up. Opening the windows is the best way to clear it, but activated carbon filters should capture it. Just make sure you're masked when you clean or replace any of the filters.
- BrianHenryIE 5y agoNice list. I live car-free because it seems immoral to contribute to Alzheimers, cancers, fertility problems, autism and mental health issues. Anyone using a car (including electric) for a journey under ten miles needs to really think about the damage they are part of (disabilities excepted, as in all walks of life). If fewer people used cars, public transit would become more sustainable, more and more routes would be added. Fewer people would die.
- NoPicklez 5y agoWhy electric included?
- vanattab 5y agoProbably because tire ware is a (the primary?) Cause of vehicle air pollution.
- _RPL5_ 5y agoI dunno what the author meant, but probably alluding to the fact that the electricity powering your EV comes from a plant burning fossil fuels. I've been curious about this topic for a while: what contributes more pollution per mile traveled -- an internal combustion engine or a Tesla charged with power from a coal/gas/wind/nuclear plant. If anyone encountered an analysis like that, please link!
- Gibbon1 5y agoThere was a paper I saw about ten years ago that made the claim the influenza is airborne too. And that temperature and humidity have a large effect on how persistant it is in indoor spaces. And that badly ventilated workplaces and schools are large driver of infection. Another thing I saw very recently is ventilation standards for buildings have been reduced by 75% over the last 70 years.
- MengerSponge 5y agoBasically anything that gets labeled as "spread by droplet transmission" is probably primarily aerosol. I mean, sure. If somebody spits in your mouth you're likely to catch the thing, but most people who get the flu probably got it via aerosols. This is terribly inconvenient, because droplets are easy to control, but aerosols are not.
- wirrbel 5y agoAs a German I have a reflex to wanting to open the windows in most indoor situations regularly, when I am in AC'ed/ventilated situations. Of course in my AC'ed office, the windows wouldn't open, but surely the air does not feel 'fresh' enough. Pretty sure when returning to the office post-covid we'll see some discussion on Meeting room CO2 levels. I occasionally had a hard time keeping my eyes open in crowded meeting rooms which never happens even in the most boring meetings that I have remotely.
- Fatboyrunning 5y agoHi, could you please recommend a product you have found worked well?
- Leparamour 5y ago>use a nice filter-based air purifier for white noise. It has deep bass I went nearly insane when this constant humming sound started to appear inside my apartment seemingly coming from several directions. It would start at the oddest times and then go out again after a while, making you think it's over, only to start again after a minute. I wasn't able to focus on work or reading anymore, I was starting to get really irritated and aggressive. Even with active noise-canceling headphones I could feel the bass sound. It took me the six weeks to pinpoint the origin of the sound to my upstairs neighbors, who eventually admitted that they had bought an air purifier because of allergies and kept it running all day long and through the night. If you recommend it to friends please let them know that the bass sound and the vibration translates through walls and might make a helpless neighbor's life miserable.
- unnah 5y agoThe transmission of vibrations can be reduced by putting the device on a thick rubber mat or similar. It also helps to reduce the sound inside the room, so it's not just for the neighbours' benefit.
- shoto_io 5y agoWhy not just open the windows?
- epanchin 5y agoGuessing they live in a city or by a road
- euroderf 5y agoGermany has a practice called "Luft" ("Air"), where tenants are _required_ to throw open the windows for X minutes each day. Seems smart. The room & furnishings retain heat long enough while the air is changed in toto. Can someone who knows about this practice comment ?
- Dylan16807 5y agoSeems smart why? If we check the air two hours later, is it meaningfully better than before we started? A daily changeover seems much worse than constant exchange, and both of those pale in comparison to filtering.
- yobbo 5y agoThe air particles that are visible to you will mostly be caught in your nose and cilia, and either swallowed or spat out. They can still cause plenty of allergies. They are also too heavy to float long enough in the air to pass through the filter. That's why you need to kick it up from surfaces to see. You can remove it from surfaces with vacuum and wiping. Smaller invisible particles, for example pollution or pollen, hang in the air and move with the circulation, so they will eventually be caught as air passes through the filter. The amount of these particles could be reduced by cleaning the air at the "intake" of the house. If there is intake air passing through pipes, these pipes need to be kept clean. If the house is set up such that air moves in both direction through passages, the whole thing is fucked and need to be fixed. Even detecting where intake air is entering the house can be really difficult. Because of indoor temperature and outdoor wind, a house functions like a pump that sucks in outdoor air, heats it, and ejects it. Intake air may be sucked from any crack in the walls, floors and foundation, where it picks up dust and mould. Equipping the house with an intake fan (and filter) will pressurize it and prevent this "sucking".