8 ms·
Why women gymnasts compete to music in their floor routines but men don't
- axiosgunnar 5y agoWhy not just drop the split in „male“ and „female“ gymnastics if we are to tackle „preconceived gender roles“?
- aero-glide2 5y agoThere are physical differences in body structures between men and women, so that would be unfair. on a tangent, gymnastics with music is much more watchable
- deltasixeight 5y agoAre you implying men are superior to women in terms of physical strength? I agree with you but admitting this fact is also sexist so my mind is in a perpetual confused state: unable to resolve the conflict between social justice and reality as we know it. Possibly the best way to solve this issue is to just side step it. Let's not make judgement of female routines more like the mens' routines. Instead make the mens' routines have music and judge the men on artistry, femininity and grace. This would be totally fair to both sexes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- orwin 5y agoAgree. I usually don't care about gymnastic, but if i have to choose, i'd watch women gymnasts over men, and all my friends (men or women) would too, because the music make it look like a dance, an artistic performance, whereas men gymnast feels like a competition of strength and skill, with no "art" component. I know it isn't true, but reason loose to feelings all the time (sadly for all of us). I think this is actually disavantageous for men gymnasts in the long run tbh.
- tolbish 5y agoI don't see how it's irrational to find women's gymnastics more interesting and artistic. You can do that without making a judgment on the difficulty or superiority of one over the other.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Glavnokoman 5y agoHow about chess? And with music!
- pvaldes 5y agoMusic that one of the chess players would deeply loathe? Deliciously evil. I love it. Would be the kind of supervillain move than everybody expects from a chess master. Petting cats should be also encouraged as a part of chess competitions. Lets give viewers what they want.
- rafale 5y agoGender is just one way to segment the population in groups. I agree it makes things more fair. Just like weight groups do. But with the challenges around classifying transsexuals and females born with naturally high testosterone, it's not always perfect. At some point, if we want to continue classifying by gender, we should have 2 groups: "women" and "others". With a very opinionated and scoped definition of female. Because grouping by gender is, ultimately, designed to protect women.
- aksss 5y agoYeah, I don’t think we should design policy around edge cases. Is it worse to make the exceedingly rare instance of a transgender gymnast select a division or to call the vast, vast majority of gymnasts an “other”? Female divisions exist to allow competition within the limits of their biological capabilities, and that’s a good thing. I think the classic example of how Serena Williams is outranked by most college male tennis players is an example of why those limits need to be supported. The whole thing about transgender women competing is thorny, but it can’t be as simple as someone’s identity determining whether they get to disrupt that protected competitive class. Physical traits must be adequately considered. Even that seems very hard to do fairly. Is it fair to only let transgender women compete against biological females if they rate poorer than some female top tier? If they rate higher than the top tier, is it appropriate to let them compete? IDK, but I’m in favor of sober approaches to these question rather than brow-beating from the self righteous.
- lazyeye 5y agoWhy is the issue thorny? I think for most people commonsense would prevail.
- himinlomax 5y agoGender is one of the most predictive classification in social sciences, even taking into account extreme outliers like the 0.1% (at most) of transgender individuals.
- bluesnowmonkey 5y agoThere are physical differences in body structure between any two individuals. Michael Phelps has long arms. Is it not unfair that someone born with short arms has to compete against him?
- syoc 5y agoIn highly competitive physical sports there would no woman at all in the olympics for example. The 100m dash woman world record has disputed legality and sits at 10.49s. That is 6339 fastest recorded time for men. Not having gender separated competition would probably decimate female sport participation in quite a lot of domains. The short armed argument that you actually raise is more interesting. There are weight classes in boxing, and there could probably be arm length classes in swimming as well, but other physical differentiator that would take the place of arm length. I'm not really able to conclude on anything, but have feeling that the physical and cultural gender difference is large and important enough that it is prioritized, while arm length for instance is not.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> In highly competitive physical sports there be would no woman at all in the olympics for example. In (edit: some) highly competitive physical sports there would be no person below median height at all in the olympics for example. We can slice and dice all sorts of extremely visible inborn characteristics that will over time hopefully have just as much cultural relevance as sex or gender, as the cultural relevance of sex and gender decreases [0]. As that happens, we’re going to have to reevaluate what we culturally look for in sports. At the amateur level, hopefully this isn’t too hard, but I have no idea whether it will make professional sports more or less accessible. [0] While height is mostly out of your control, it’s still unclear which of the kids in tryout team will end up tall enough to compete. That’s where sex and gender are more of a clear split, because you know most of the kids on the girls team won’t end up on a men’s team, so the split remains stable as they grow up.
- adrian_b 5y ago
- adamredwoods 5y agoDoes men's ice skating have music? I can't recall.
- erichocean 5y agoYes. TIL that the music in men's ice skating is "tailored to fit the preconceived gender roles" of men according to experts.
- throwawaway902 5y agoBecause men enjoy watching women doing gymnastics accompanied by music
- ck2 5y agoThe way to solve this is to let any gymnast decide if they want music or not and eventually either music won't be used by most or most will want music. I mean why not? Tradition? That's an illusion. In a generation people won't even remember if men had music or not.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThat's not necessarily useful because the issue isn't music per se, it's the "artistic" part of scoring which may implicitly require music due to judge biases. Artistic scoring is also where a lot of subjective corruption is, so it should be removed.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoOh this so much. Breaking is evidently in the Olympics this year, which is explicitly a form of dance. Why not just add ballet and dispense with the idea that this is about sport at all?
- himinlomax 5y agoThere used to be painting competitions, so you're not exactly breaking exciting new sarcastic grounds here.
- masklinn 5y agoToday you learn about competitive ballroom dancing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancesport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancesport
- ummonk 5y agoIt's in the Paris Olympics, not this one. Breaking actually requires a lot more athleticism than e.g. diving.
- avs733 5y agoI'm not sure it is becoming of any of us on HN to be critical of the athleticism of Olympic athletes.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThe article is informative, but the answer is simple and obvious: Traditional sexism.
- kylebyproxy 5y agoThe obvious boss move here would be for all the ladies to choregraph excerpts from 4'33" this year.
- toomanyrichies 5y agoFor those who haven’t yet heard of this John Cage piece: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/4′33″ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/4′33″
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- captn3m0 5y agohttps://usagym.org/PDFs/Women/Rules/J.O.%20Code%20of%20Points/13replacement_floor3.pdf https://usagym.org/PDFs/Women/Rules/J.O.%20Code%20of%20Point... (Page 230) Might just work, since it mentions "music". >The musical accompaniment must be recorded with orchestra, piano or other instruments (without singing/voice). Human sounds are allowed, provided there are no words spoken or sung. >Absence of music or music with words/song incurs a 1.00 deduction, taken from the average score by the Chief Judge.
- jfengel 5y agoThey'd better clear it with ASCAP. Dumb as it sounds, 4'33" is copyrighted, and if you make changes that alter it, you may have violated the licensing. I'm not sure if that applies to music compositions the way it applies to plays, with which I'm more familiar. But when I license a play for performance, I'm usually forbidden from altering lines. (That's one of the reasons I usually do Shakespeare.)
- spoonjim 5y agoThe high level reason across all sports is that much of women’s sports is marketed around sex. Women athletes are often required to show more skin, be more sexy, and do things like wear skirts (tennis) to seem more feminine. Add to this of course that the product endorsements typically go to the highest performing men but the most beautiful women in the sport. It’s more than the natural sex appeal that any top athlete would have — it’s encoded in different sets of rules for the women. Even in gymnastics, the women have to do these little shimmies and shakes between their tumbling passes that the men don’t. Hence the recent protests against the women’s beach handball outfits, and the ridiculous double standard they expose. One nice counterexample is the WNBA, which has gained considerable popularity relative to other women’s sports in the US with very little sexualization of the athletes.
- jimbob45 5y agoThe WNBA is subsidized by the NBA. If you want to build a successful sports organization, don’t model yourself on the WNBA because whatever they’re doing isn’t working.
- deanCommie 5y agoSubsidized or invested in by? I know your point - today the WNBA loses money. But the NBA is a business not a charity. And they're a private enterprise. They don't do this out of the goodness of their heart or some social justice cause. Clearly they believe it's an investment worth making.
- jimbob45 5y agoThey’re 25 years in without turning a profit. If you’re such an optimist that you see that as an investment and not a subsidy, then I encourage you to sally forth because we need more relentlessly optimistic people like you in the world.
- spoonjim 5y agoOK, so female athletes have to win the game and give the male viewers a hardon? I don’t consider that “working” either.
- jimbob45 5y agoWe’re closer to men adding music than women removing it. The IOC is fully aware that they have to take steps to preserve the popularity and viewership of their sports. Sex sells. This seems like the latest in a series of articles from CNN that hate women for being feminine. That’s fine for them to have that opinion, but it seems like they’ve slid into disguising opinion pieces as news pieces, just like they used to accuse FOX of doing. If a piece is 10% news and 90% analysis, it’s still an opinion piece.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ummonk 5y agoAnecdotally, the main reason women's gymnastics is more popular amongst viewers of the Olympics is that it's seen as more "elegant". If it were purely about strength and athleticism, the huge gap between female and male gymnasts in that respect would likely drive viewership to the latter.
- jeffbee 5y agoSeems crazy because when I watch those athletes mixing those little jerky interludes into their tumbling routine, elegance is the last thing that comes to mind. World-class gymnasts must be the worst dancers around.
- gpsx 5y agoThat's kind of unfair, in a way. They aren't that bad. It's just that you are used to seeing people who are very good. Try making a video of yourself dancing. It doesn't look like you think. (This is a painful fact learned by any hobbyist dancer, like me.) But it's true we don't necessarily want to see someone who is not really good. And by not good meaning that they don't spend a lot of time refining that aspect of the routine. It is up to the sport itself to decide what they want to emphasize and how they want to judge competitions. And it is up to us as viewers to voice our opinions. I think I am with you in my opinion of some of the dancing. I would rather see a gymnast reflect the music less rather than do some unattractive dancing. And when it comes to differences between men's and women's floor routines, that doesn't bother me one bit.
- ilaksh 5y agoPart of the context for female gymnasts, especially when you are talking about floor exercises, is other somewhat similar activities such as rythmic gymnastics and even things like ballet. So that is one area where two different worlds are meeting somewhat. To me even more interesting is that these things can be traced back their origins relatively recently and were specific inventions. It's not as if you have thousands of years of these specific movements being done in this way. It something that was created not too many generations back. And its interesting also because the specific format has become so official and accepted as a given. But also fascinating is the way that these things track (or lag behind) changing values etc. What's really interesting to me is the circumstances that allow for new traditions to be invented and become officially sanctioned. I mean, why are they _officially_ all wearing leotards? Call me crazy, but maybe it's literally because your great uncle Bob or whoever who had some oversight at the time thought it was hotter.
- toolslive 5y agoOther obvious differences are: - no beam for men - Uneven bars versus parallel bars - no pommel horse for women - no rings for women - vault: height of apparatus There are others (fe code of difficulty is completely different)
- GuB-42 5y agoSo in essence, they are different sports with the same name. One is mens-only, the other, womens-only. A bit like decathlon/heptathlon. If there is an interest, they could split the two "gymnastics", give them different names, and have both genders compete in both disciplines. In the same way that there is a women's decathlon (but not in the Olympics).
- robbedpeter 5y agoIn what contest of physical prowess, strength, or endurance can women fairly compete with men? Mental games are wide open, but there's a reason physical games are segregated. Evolution built us to be good at different things. You could use gendered world records and averages to weight individual scores in competitions, allowing desegregated competition, essentially giving women a handicap. There's a chance that the psychology of competition could elicit better performance and even things out, or that competing with men directly could negatively impact performance. Politics du'jour isn't very compatible with reality in some areas. Historically speaking, the strongest and fastest or most endurant person on the planet is going to be male. I don't think it's fair to women to have to compete against the realities of biology without fundamentally changing the way things are being measured. And it's not fair to men to limit the measurement of performance on a direct and literal scale.
- toolslive 5y agoThere are sports/games (don't know the exact difference here) where there's no advantage for a certain sex. Think chess, darts, biljarts, curling, ... However even there, there's typically a separate competition for women. The only relevant argument is: Is there a market for category X ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- belorn 5y ago> Male gymnasts competed in the Olympics for the first time in 1896. Women's gymnastics made its debut more than three decades later, in 1928. When women started competing, the sport was tailored to fit the preconceived gender roles at the time, experts say. When male gymnasts competed in the Olympics in 1896, it was designed from the start with preconceived gender roles with the initial routines highlighting masculine strength. When women started competing, those gender roles were applied again so that while the male version continued to highlight masculinity, the female version highlighted femininity instead.
- KoenDG 5y agoThey don't? Huh.