16 ms·
Amazon Echo Dot does not wipe personal content after factory reset
- Causality1 5y agoYet another consumer protection law we sorely need. That a factory reset should leave passwords on a device should open Amazon to enormous liability.
- foxpurple 5y agoIdeally, the OS should be an immutable image and the user partition completely seperate. Than a factory reset simply has to nuke the user partition and place a fresh template over the top. I can understand how something not designed could have difficulty factory resetting when data can be scattered all over the place.
- RicoElectrico 5y agoI don't know about what is it like now (with all this A/B stuff), but /system/ on Android is supposed to be read only. As was ROFS on Symbian. That said, root could modify /system/ anyway.
- jeroenhd 5y agoIt's still read-only on Android these days (there are multiple partitions for A/B stuff). Root can modify it, true, but I don't think anyone is storing any secrets on there. With file-based encryption on the data partitions, Android hard resets should make all files inaccessible even if they're left on the drive.
- haunter 5y ago>Since the storage media in these IoT devices would not last long if true deletions were being performed constantly, “deleted” data is often simply invalidated and moved to an unused page in the block (in a process called “wear leveling”). These invalidated pages, which still contain the data, remain present until a block fills up with them and a true deletion is initiated. >Accessing flash memory that has been factory reset in this way does require some amount of technical skill and specialized equipment, but nothing that is a real barrier to the average enthusiast working at home. By that logic my iPhone 11, my Android phone, my Mac or my Windows PC doesn't wipe personal content either after factory reset Feels like a bit clickbait-ish But at least Macs have a built-in 7-pass erase option to comply with DOD standards https://techpatio.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/disk-utility-mac-osx.jpg https://techpatio.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/disk-utilit...
- ashtonkem 5y agoDo you have any sources for the assertion that resetting an iOS device doesn’t remove data?
- wrboyce 5y agoDo iOS devices not leverage full disk encryption? In which case I’d assume simply wiping the encryption keys/fde headers would be sufficient? (Which it almost certainly does.)
- croon 5y agohttps://www.apple.com/ca/business-docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf https://www.apple.com/ca/business-docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pd... > The “Erase all content and settings” option in Settings obliterates all the keys in Effaceable Storage, rendering all user data on the device cryptographically inaccessible. Semantics debate around whether leaving data practically inaccessible is the same as removing it, but considering where we are, I'd say it isn't. Granted, this is from 2018, but I doubt the defaults and concept have changed.
- Retric 5y agoSecurely deleting the keys is safer than simply practically inaccessible. That suggests their is some impractical way to access the data, care to suggest what that might be?
- emsy 5y agoOverwriting flash with 0s. To be fair I think the iPhone should grant you that option (MacOs does). But to suggesting that leaving an encrypted block of data on the device is on the same level as leaving unencrypted blocks of data lying around is foolish.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- walterbell 5y agoUser/config partitions can be encrypted and factory reset can delete the user/config encryption key. Minimizes writes to physical blocks, user data becomes unrecoverable. This is standard practice for repurposing of multi-TB hard drives. Hopefully the new U.S. FTC focus on "right to repair" will improve transparency on consumer electronics internals for both hardware and software, https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2021/07/ftc-ramp-law-enforcement-against-illegal-repair-restrictions https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2021/07/ftc-r... > Commission unanimously adopts policy statement aimed at restoring Right to Repair for small businesses, workers, consumers, and government entities
- thelucky41 5y agoConsumer electronics are becoming more durable. Where once I might have replaced a cell phone every year and my home router every two, I now have had the same phone for four years and my router for six. Second hand sellers and repair shops need the factory reset feature, but we all benefited when our firmware allowed the devices to become safely transferable and repairable. From the cited paper, most of the acquired devices were not even reset: > Not reset devices: A surprising number of devices (61% ) were not reset by the previous owners. Due to the setup of our experiment, we had no possibility of asking the previous owners any questions. I'm doubtful this exists, but I'd like it if it were possible to perform a factory reset or account transfer completely online, and other features around improving the security in the resale market. For those curious like me how the wifi password was actually leaked: > WPA-supplicant is responsible for connecting to configured access points after provisioning. We found that it creates its con- figuration files on the user data partition in the folder “misc/wifi/”. Here the file “wpa_supplicant.conf ” contains the Wi-Fi credentials, such as the SSID and PSK.
- PhasmaFelis 5y ago> Consumer electronics are becoming more durable. Where once I might have replaced a cell phone every year and my home router every two That's kind of extreme. I'm not sure that means they're becoming more durable, or you're getting less obsessed with owning latest-and-greatest.
- rantwasp 5y agoso your problem is not the potential of the damm thing listening on you 24/7? it’s the wipe after factory reset? i guess I could see some people mind one but not the other, but I guess people that strongly care about their privacy would not buy an echo to start with.
- kadoban 5y agoSecurity isn't binary. Even if you trust Amazon enough, you probably don't trust some random stranger you're selling used electronics to.
- amelius 5y ago> so your problem is not the potential of the damm thing listening on you 24/7? How do you know your smartphone isn't doing the exact same thing?
- jjice 5y agoI have one I got ad a gift years ago that I'd like to get rid of. Is there a good way to get rid of this thing without tossing it or giving my info away?
- maddyboo 5y agoI received one as a gift too. Used it for about a week, got tired of it and creeped. So I pried it open, used a flathead screwdriver + hammer to chisel/smash any chips that looked interesting, and recycled it with some other e-waste. I felt bad destroying a “perfectly good” device, but my reasoning was that the world is better off with one less of these spyware devices, and I resolved to never buy a smart assistant device again. I wouldn’t have destroyed it had I been more trusting of Amazon, but now I’m glad I did.
- maddyboo 5y agoTo clarify: it was not a personal gift, I received it when I signed up for internet service in a new apartment.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoFrom what I gather from folks who worked in the first Echo Dot, it was a tire fire of a project rushed out the door. Apparently the remnants of the failed Fire Phone team decided to Android-ify the Echo software, which was Kindle-based originally. I've always found the quality of the Dots to be subpar compared to the original Pringles can. Not surprised to discover this fuck up.
- swiley 5y agoYou should not own one of these, certainly not without it paying rent.
- 404mm 5y agoThis explanation infuriates me so much. They use technical terms and true technologies to lie about their security issues and measures. Flash memory should easily withstand north of 10k write/erase cycles, base on type. Even if there was somehow some very low limit, users’ request to delete personal & sensitive data should be honored and any cost. But then again, we’re talking about people paying actual money to have these devices in their homes.
- adrian_b 5y agoHigh-density flash memory with more than 1 bit per cell, like in SSD's, withstands usually just a few hundred, some times only one hundred, write-erase cycles. You can easily compute this value by dividing the guaranteed endurance by the SSD capacity. For example, an 1 TB Samsung 980 guarantees only 600 TBW / 1 TB = 600 write-erase cycles. This computation works because the wear-leveling algorithm used by the SSD controller distributes the writes uniformly over the entire SSD, ensuring approximately the same number of write-erase cycles for every cell.
- egberts 5y agoBurn it.
- martialamazon 5y agoWhy did it take nine days for this to make it to hn front page, dang? I am starting to believe in self termination as a viable strategy to exit a farcical reality. Boobs and US Marshal's, after all.
- beckman466 5y agoA device that is a black box does a black box thing. The dynamics in the current system that have, and continue to, reward the privatization of knowledge, will end soon. Come join us in growing the first Open Value Networks using DWeb tools like Valueflows/hREA, Holochain, SSB, DAT, ActivityPub and more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ultimer 5y agoGood afternoon everyone! I don't want to have anything to do with Amazon since I found out about a big hole in the privacy of their security system. As I have heard, they are literally leaking tons of information from cameras to federal and internal authorities, the police. This did not suit me at all and I had to look for alternatives on the Internet, like https://ajax.systems/ https://ajax.systems/ . Of course, this is not a panacea, but it is still much more reliable. In any case, it's safer for me to think so... And what do you think about that?