6 ms·
A crucial idea for silicon PV cells was excluded by a patent for 20 years
- msandford 5y agoI don't love the language. It was patented. It could have been licensed no? The patent holder refused licensing at any price?
- clarkevans 5y agoPerhaps one manufacturer had obtained an exclusive license, preventing the rest of the industry from using this technology?
- Scoundreller 5y agoUsually when you sign an exclusive license, you also have the ability to sub-license/assign it. Creditors/investors don't like backing something if the asset disappears if the business itself doesn't work out.
- pfdietz 5y agoIt was a completely obvious idea that, when the patent expired, was immediately widely adopted. It's clear in this case that the patent retarded progress rather than promoting it.
- analog31 5y agoI'm not a lawyer, but have been involved in IP issues. What I've learned is that obviousness is phenomenally difficult to prove.
- pfdietz 5y agoI'm not talking about proving it in court, I'm asking you to consider it in your own mind. When the problem with boron doping was realized, how long do you think it would have taken everyone to go down that column of the periodic table and use gallium instead? It's not like there was a huge selection of elements to chose from.
- petra 5y agoMaybe they were the first to discover the problem?
- wallacoloo 5y agoPossibly, but I’d like to pose a relevant question: had they discovered it and then chosen to keep quiet, how long would it have been before someone else discovered it independently? Answer: definitely less than 20 years. So why then should the first group to discover this be given 20 years of exclusivity? People claim that this promise of exclusivity drives the research. On the other hand, why pour money into research if there’s a strong chance that my competitor will beat me to the punch and then forbid me from making use of the equivalent outcome that my own research yields (and of the in-house talent I developed along the way)?
- evgen 5y ago> Possibly, but I’d like to pose a relevant question: had they discovered it and then chosen to keep quiet, how long would it have been before someone else discovered it independently? >Answer: definitely less than 20 years. So why then should the first group to discover this be given 20 years of exclusivity? What is absolutely hilarious about your musings here is that you are completely, 100% wrong. You make un-informed guesses and manage to get just about every aspect of the issue completely wrong. Well done. Would you like to know when it was known that gallium-doped silicon substrate was going to perform well and possibly better than boron-doped substrate? At least the mid-70s. Would you like to know when this patent was issued? 2000. So for almost 25 years everyone KNEW gallium was better. It was literally sitting out there on every periodic table on the planet and for some reason no one produced gallium-doped PV cells at scale or cost. Why is that? Maybe because the trick was not knowing that gallium is what you wanted to dope the silicon with, but in knowing HOW TO ACTUALLY PULL IT OFF. For more than two decades it was staring everyone in the face. For more than two decades everyone knew what the target was. For more than two decades NO ONE DID IT. That is why the first group to figure out how to manufacture gallium-doped silicon with the proper amount of other components were given exclusivity, because if they had not managed to do it then maybe we would all still be waiting for gallium-doped PV cells.
- evgen 5y agoEverything is obvious once you know the secret. This went under patent protection in 2000, which is decades into the hunt for PV improvements and decades into gallium doping silicon substrate (which started in the 50s at the dawn of transistors.) Papers from the early 2000s talk about this improvement and about open questions regarding the cell lifetime and mixing gallium and germanium ratios, so it does not appear to be as obvious as you suggest.
- amelius 5y agoBut did the applicants of the patent show a working model? Or did they just patent a bunch of possible improvements in the hope that one of them would lead to a breakthrough?
- Gibbon1 5y agoRandom thought to throw out. Value patents based on the amount of work required to come up with them. So patenting some random shower thought is worth what you put into it. And what you can recover in a lawsuit is also tied to that. "Yeah we violated your 'something but on the internet patent' Here's a $50 Home Depot card."
- folli 5y agoHow will you objectively measure "amount of work required to come up with them"? That sounds rather infeasible.
- Gibbon1 5y agoHow do we measure the value of anything objectively. But there is a world of difference between, 100's of people working for a decade on a problem kind of patents. And someone sitting on their couch for an afternoon patents. You seriously want to protect the former. And not really the latter.
- amelius 5y agoThe same way the government funds any kind of project. Contractor says: we can do this for $X. Government says yes or no to the project. You do the same for patent applications. It's basically answering the question "how much is this technology worth to society?" If they don't pay for it, then the technology will end up as a trade secret.
- fnord77 5y agoif it was obvious, why wasn't it obvious until the patent?
- beervirus 5y agoWell in that case surely someone would have challenged the patent and got it invalidated.
- lambdasquirrel 5y agoI don't see how this works out economically. Having the patent invalidated is a public good. Fighting a patent in court is expensive and risky. Why should any particular company fight a patent for the benefit of its competitors, and against some decently-well-funded conglomerate, when it's already trying to make it in a competitive field?
- refurb 5y agoWidely adopted idea that nobody felt was worth licensing? So more of a nice to have?
- bArray 5y agoAn alternative idea to the ones mentioned here already: Perhaps they simply didn't want to give away the fact that gallium doping is an idea worth holding onto. By letting the patent timeout they save themselves tonnes of licensing money in the future, whilst also offering a reason for customers to upgrade. More cynically, they may have preferred the fact that the panels would degrade over time, driving sales. Now that the patent is expiring, they either dope with gallium or lose customers to their competitors.
- Animats 5y agoThe patent holder, Shin-Etsu Chemical, did license the technology. They licensed it to to JA Solar, Longi and Trina Solar, all large solar panel makers in China. JA Solar panels have had gallium doping since Q3 2020.[1] The article somehow doesn't mention that. JA mentions gallium, but they seem to consider the weather-tightness of the surface film to be a bigger factor in lifespan. [1] http://taiyangnews.info/technology/taiyangnews-500w-conference-ja-solar/ http://taiyangnews.info/technology/taiyangnews-500w-conferen...
- xvilka 5y agoSame story as with fractal compression algorithms. Patents shouldn't last that long.
- mchusma 5y agoI think they should be more expensive too. The government shouldn't give a monopoly for cheap. Maybe $100k fee for first 5 years, with the ability to pay something like $1m to extend another 5 years would be long enough. Maybe $10M for another 5 years, and $100M for another 5 years.
- ford_o 5y agoJust pay a fixed % gross income to the patent owner.
- nextweek2 5y agoYou're forgetting about the small inventor. If I'm sitting in my garage and come up with a cool idea that takes me 5 years of knocking on doors to get funded, then I'll get screwed by your approach.
- bkor 5y ago> You're forgetting about the small inventor. How often will that happen? The existing system seems to massively favour keeping existing big companies big. A small inventor can easily ignored. Meaning, there's quite a difference between being right and ensuring a company does the right thing. Some products (e.g. mobile phones) are covered by hundreds of patents. A small inventor having a huge benefit from patents? It maybe happens, but I really doubt the benefits outweighs the clear damage that patents are having.
- unchocked 5y agoHonestly I'm okay with that.
- riskable 5y agoSmall inventor already can't afford a patent. Let's say the small inventor spent the large amount of money for lawyers and patent searches and got a patent... How will they defend it when litigating a patent starts at around $1 million? What this means is that any practical implementation of an idea needs to be a multi-million dollar idea in order to be worth patenting. Otherwise you're just wasting money.
- wbl 5y agoThere was no reason solar cell makers couldn't license the patent from the owner.
- lambdasquirrel 5y agoIt seems a bit presumptuous that in an industry with many, many actors, that it seems that the vast majority did not license the patent?
- drivingmenuts 5y agoIt’s a big industry now, but 20 years ago? Back then, it was a bunch of smaller companies, probably none large enough on their own to afford the royalties or they were working with their own tech to bypass IP requirements.
- adrian_b 5y agoSuch a claim is naive. While I know nothing about this specific patent of the Japanese company Shin-Etsu, when a patent is owned by a very large manufacturer like this, they very seldom want to make money by licensing the patent but they use it to exclude any competitors. This is done by either refusing to license the patent, or more likely by requesting royalties so large that the products made by any other company could not be cheaper than their own. There are many examples of patents which had never been implemented in any product before the day when they expired. In this case, Shin-Etsu would have probably been willing to supply Ga-doped silicon wafers to PV cell manufacturers, but only at prices too high in comparison with the current prices of the PV panels, so such wafers have never seen any significant use.
- Scoundreller 5y agoMaybe there were a few (enough?) out there that will pay stupid high prices for a slightly better PV. E.g. satellite manufacturers? Military? Remote installations? If they sold a consumer version, then they're at risk of losing that business to shuckers (like 'external' HDs that are cheaper than bare units).
- petra 5y agoAny ideas by how much does this increase cell lifetime?
- philipkglass 5y agoLongi has a detailed comparison of boron doped and gallium doped cell characteristics here: https://en.longi-solar.com/home/events/press_detail/id/228_Gallium-doped_monocrystalline_silicon_fully_solves_the_problem_of_a_PERC_module_s_LID.html https://en.longi-solar.com/home/events/press_detail/id/228_G... There are modest but real improvements in efficiency and resistance to multiple cell degradation mechanisms. Cell lifetime does not have a hard cutoff. Typically a panel's lifetime is limited by failed backsheets or wiring/soldering rather than by the more gradual optical-electronic degradation mechanisms that gallium doping helps prevent.
- aerodog 5y agoAren't patents, per the constitution, to promote the progress of science? How can they act to do the opposite?
- setr 5y agoThe primary mechanism patents provide is the open publishing and explanation of the technologies/mechanisms/etc involved. The goal is to extract research from the depths of company archives and promote iteration on existing technologies without outright cloning them. In return, you get a guaranteed monopoly on your technology for X years, and protection from theft after your open-publishing. This system has failed in a number of ways. 1. The rate of technological evolution was significantly slower, and a time-limited monopoly was less impactful, in previous history. The industrial revolution covers some 100 year period. The digital revolution covers about 40. Things get obsoleted much faster these days, to the point that a 20-year monopoly is literally the whole lifetime of the technology 2. Patents have been granted too easily for too little (largely because there’s no repercussion for filing, and re-filing, dumb patents) allowing for extremely broad interpretations, and a single technology incorporating hundreds of different patents (eg h265) 3. Because there’s so many of them, and they’re often so vaguely defined, I’m fairly certain almost no one actually reads them to learn how to implement something, or improve on the design. I’m also fairly certain that reading patents is a great way to “poison” yourself — if it can be shown you read the parent at some point, and then violated it, it’s a trivial lawsuit.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoWhen we create a monopoly through regulation, we should also regulate the prices the monopoly can charge, because any market without competition is broken.
- pydry 5y agoBecause while the justification was more efficient innovation, their actual intended purpose was to create another form of property that could be capitalized.
- bserge 5y ago
- fn-mote 5y agoPV = photovoltaic If the title read "silicon solar cells" it would be clearer to the layperson (like me). Many of us read the comments to decide if the article is worth reading, so it helps.
- riffraff 5y agoFor a non native speaker it's hard to connect P with the F sound in photovoltaic, so this title was extra confusing for me.
- a1369209993 5y ago> it's hard to connect P with the F sound in photovoltaic Strictly speaking, it ought to be "PhV" (compare "PhD"), but no one does that for some reason.
- kragen 5y agoYeah, this is a stupid thing that stems from a sound shift in Ancient Greek about 2000 years ago, when Φ changed its pronunciation from [pʰ] to something like [f]. We have all kinds of evidence of more or less when and where this happened, but not why, although it's a thing that's happened in other languages too, where a phonetic distinction that's originally aspirated/unaspirated becomes a fricative/plosive distinction. English has this stupid policy of keeping the original spelling of any loanword it picks up, gradually drifting closer and closer to being an ideographic script. In this case English got its Greek morphemes by way of Latin, where they'd mostly already acquired standard spellings based on the older pronunciation. In Spanish, which has a phonetic script, it's much saner: "panel fotovoltáico". Maybe we should start calling them ΦV panels.
- sheepdestroyer 5y agoPreserving words history is far from stupid. Spellings of words bear meaning. Ethymology is extremely important to understand your own language, and how it relates to others. If we were to write every languages strictly phonetically, some would lose more than just etymology, but would even become a lot less understandable.
- elcdodedocle 5y agoYou know why release a product to the market that lasts longer when you can just hold the patent and make shitty panels that have to be replaced every so often? Forget the competitors. Forgive the cynicism but this was clearly a 20 year long win-win for the industry. Long live the big wheel industrial complex. F the consumer. *and the environment.
- new299 5y agoWhen I see a broad statement like this, it seems interesting to dig a little further. The article itself doesn’t provide much detail to back up its claims. And specifically it would be interesting to understand the patent issue better. The patent they cite says claims “ A silicon single crystal produced according to Czochralski method using a melt in contact with a quartz crucible, to which Ga (gallium) is added as a dopant that controls resistivity of the crystal in a range of 5Ω.cm to 0.1Ω.cm, wherein a diameter of the single crystal is 4 inches or more, and the single crystal is used for a solar cell.” Which seems pretty broad. Would that really have held up in court if it was tested? Was this patent really blocking fabrication of gallium doped silicon? A text from 2015 suggests there were open issues around fabricating gallium doped silicon: https://books.google.co.jp/books?id=S43SBQAAQBAJ&pg=PA253&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.co.jp/books?id=S43SBQAAQBAJ&pg=PA253&re... So it seems likely that there were open issues around fabrication until at least 2015. Have there been other process developments that have made Gallium doping viable in recent years? The patent largely covers the fabrication process, and was recently licensed to a Chinese fabrication company. Is it likely that this IP was really blocking them? I.e. given that they may not publicly disclose their fabrication process, how would you know they were infringing. If this IP was of such fundamental importance why was it not challenged? This is rare in my experience (outside of semiconductors at least). So, it doesn’t seem clear cut to me. And it would be interesting to understand the issues better.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elcdodedocle 5y agoWell I agree with you. And I also suspected those numbers, to be honest. A sudden increase to 80% of total production? 80% from what? Since when? But I did not do a lot of research: I tried to find sources as the article is not only vague on context but also on references, but the numbers I found were not clear either. They only showed that around 90% of the global production was from silicon crystal based panels already back in 2013, way before the patent expiration. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics citing https://www.webcitation.org/6SFRTUaBS https://www.webcitation.org/6SFRTUaBS and https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC118300/jrc118300_1.pdf https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/J...). I found no breakdowns to compare boron vs. gallium doping over time. I do not know anything about foundries. Maybe replacing boron with gallium is not a trivial change in process. Maybe the patent and planned obsolescence are not the issues here and I was being pretty cynic on my comment without fact checking it anyway. But way too often they are. If that figure, 80%, is true, and the shift from boron to gallium happened over the last year like the article claims, it is very likely that 2 main factors, if not the main ones, were those.
- murkle 5y agoSupposedly it's been licensed (2019) https://www.jasolar.com.cn/index.php?m=content&c=index&a=show&catid=399&id=54 https://www.jasolar.com.cn/index.php?m=content&c=index&a=sho...
- murkle 5y ago... and available https://en.longi-solar.com/home/products/modules.html https://en.longi-solar.com/home/products/modules.html review: https://www.cleanenergyreviews.info/blog/longi-solar-panels-review https://www.cleanenergyreviews.info/blog/longi-solar-panels-...
- philips 5y agoAre there any groups attempting patent reform in an organized way?
- LightBearer 5y agoAh, capitalism working at it's FINEST!!!!!! /s