17 ms·
Schizophrenia linked to marijuana use disorder is on the rise, study finds
- hereforphone 5y agoI can only speak from personal experience, which is of course limited. I smoked occasionally in my 20s, but not since (I'm middle-aged now). I've been friends and acquaintances with many people that smoke a lot. I see a trend among these people - not necessarily schizophrenia (I'm not a psychologist and probably wouldn't even notice a mild case) - but instead a consistent arrogance and self-importance. It's peculiar - they may be contributing very little to society (or maybe a lot), but regardless there's a sense of superiority that seems to crop up among them all. Maybe even narcissism? I could be completely wrong. I don't express this to assert it, but rather to ask if anyone else has noticed anything similar.
- warent 5y agoThat just sounds like people in their 20s in general, even without weed. Marijuana might make it seem worse because stupid ideas sound much more profound when we're high
- hereforphone 5y agoGood point, I had in mind friends / acquaintances from 20s to 50s however.
- jxramos 5y agoyah I think there's something to this in an opportunity cost motivational angle. Basically there's a cost that comes to being in a high state which lowers your thresholds for profundity, satisfaction, deliciousness/appetite/taste. Basically with the thresholds all lowered one becomes satisfied with things that are objectively lesser quality, less demanding of effort and work. One would be equally satisfied eating junk food as they normally would having eaten some gourmet meal. There's no fire under your feet to hustle or put in the time to need to learn how to cook some truly delicious meal let's say or develop skills that bring longer term satisfaction that takes a while before payoff. Motivation never needs to take off because the cheapest junk already meets ones pleasure and satisfaction needs so why bother.
- crazy_horse 5y agoWeed doesn't affect everybody the same. Not everyone is a stoner that gets high and says whoa dude on the couch. I didn't perceive things as more profound rather the little voice of anxiety inside by head went away and for the first time in my life I was free to figure out who I was.
- random_kris 5y agoHey this little Voice of anxiety I get it to and weed alleviated this.. or so I think. In return it makes me lazy and if I smoke too much it makes it louder and it wants me to stop smoking weed Soo much. But on other hand if I have a steady supply I cannot quit it. So fucked up
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoI agree with this. I hang out at this one bar and this 22 year old I talk to really thinks he "gets it." Incredibly cocky and arrogant a lot of times. He's fun to talk to but when he get's on a major BS kick I gotta tune him out. I'm only 5 years older than him but the contrast in experiences is stark to say the least. It really makes me wonder if I was ever that arrogant too.
- hattmall 5y agoI think it's a thing with liberalism as well though which has a huge overlap with marijuana use. Some people tend to think they know what's better for others without really considering the impacts it may have. Then you add in the existential paranoia brought on by being high all the time and you start espousing unconditional support for ideas that soothe your fears.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nate_meurer 5y agoI think you might be the kind of person the parent is talking about.
- chucksta 5y ago"Some people tend to think they know what's better for others without really considering the impacts it may have." That's hardly limited to that demo. Also generally chronic users aren't going to get that existential paranoia you get from casual use
- mnowicki 5y agoyeah true. I think it'd be best for others if they stopped being liberals. (\s btw)
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoLol thanks for the good chuckle
- dogorman 5y ago> consistent arrogance and self-importance. Would you rather have people demoralized and hating themselves? I think we have quite enough of that already. God forbid an unaccomplished waggie enjoys life and likes who they are. Somebody put these uppity proles back in their place!
- xwolfi 5y agoI've had my weed phase between 16 and 19 and I dont know. There is a sort of arrogance that comes with ignorance in general that subsides as you learn the vastness of what you'll never know. I suppose the intersection of ignorance, criminality and drug consumption may make you think that because they smoke, they exhibit the other traits, but it could be the contrary. You need a bit of arrogance to think cannabis is on your side and you can dominate it, as I witnessed myself when I started stumbling as a teenager.
- jefftechentin 5y ago> You need a bit of arrogance to think cannabis is on your side and you can dominate it, as I witnessed myself when I started stumbling as a teenager. I have had similar experiences. Without your mind you are not you, a drug which changes the minds substrate (in some ways permanently) is going to be outside the control of the effected mind. Beware the Snoop Dogg pool party.
- stevev 5y agoMy experience with the substance is similar to yours. I’ve started again occasionally and see that the experience differs depending on the strain. I do get paranoia that wears off; there were times where I’ve experience schizophrenia like symptoms; where reality seems off or my perception of it changes temporarily until it wears off. Hopefully I don’t have early onset of the disorder. Regarding your friends, is it possible that the behavior you are seeing is when they are under the influence and not during sober?
- Ccecil 5y agoIt is entirely possible that this is a misunderstanding of their true feelings or intents. To quote Kat Williams "Weed has a chemical in it called F*k it..." Maybe when they use they are not having the same anxious feeling that the general public feels and they do not react to others who otherwise might be perceived as "more important" than them. This would appear to the person who typically views themselves as "more important" as arrogance or self importance...when in reality they are just mildly happy and don't care at that moment about the typical societal norms and ranking. More than likely they are just going about their own business and not paying attention to how you are reacting to it. Every life has value...every person is equal.
- babyblueblanket 5y agoI have a co-worker who I would described as mildly happy at all times and doesn't care about societal norms/ranking, but I never interpreted them to consider themselves superior to me. This doesn't jive with my understanding of mildly happy people.
- mikem170 5y agoThat makes sense. But it also makes sense that someone else might look at that same person you know and think to themselves "look at them, doing their own thing, they must think they are special, how arrogant!" Guessing what's going on in someone elses head can be pretty subjective. Sometimes it's the person looking who jumps to conclusions.
- bobthechef 5y ago> Every life has value...every person is equal. What was the point of that remark? Persons may be said to be of equal dignity, but no two people are ever equal, in value or otherwise. But what does that have to do with anything in this context? Are you reading things in? The OP was not making any point about rank, only haughty behavior which has no place no matter who you are.
- Ccecil 5y ago
- colechristensen 5y agoThere is the persistent question: does this attract people who are a certain way or does it transform some people into being that way. But let's be clear, schizophrenia is not a personality trait.
- topkai22 5y agoYes, I've noticed something simila, although way I phrase it is I noticed among high marijauna users from teens to twenties was what is a sense of delayed maturity. This overlaps with the attributes you described but it also felt like they weren't able to accept the increasing responsibility to themselves and others that comes with growth out of adolesence. I accept this is just one lived experience and there are other possible confounding factors, but I've definiutely noticed it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bilekas 5y agoYou've hit the nail on the head with my experience. I have noticed this with a brother who smoke daily.. I never really put it down to the marijuana use entirely, but more of an aversion to any kind of confrontation/disagreement that might make him second guess himself etc. Personally I can't smoke it anymore, I get super anxious now and nervous. I don't enjoy it, but I can see why some people who enjoy it would rather avoid any kind of mental doubt/disagreements.
- GordonS 5y ago> Personally I can't smoke it anymore, I get super anxious now and nervous I've heard so many people say the same thing, that they used to enjoy using cannabis, then some years later they find it induces anxiety, jitters and nervousness - I wonder what the mechanism behind this anxiety is? Is it as simple as "modern" cannabis strains having much THC than older ones, or is it something else, possibly age-related, like thyroid hormones?
- codr7 5y agoLike Shrooms, Cannabis will sooner or later confront you with aspects of yourself that you're not entirely comfortable with. There was always strong weed, and hashish; it just means you either consume less or fall asleep. Hormones are possible, I guess.
- GordonS 5y agoWas there always strong weed though? Modern strains go up to 20% THC and 0% CBD. At least when I were lad (in UK), we only got brick weed (which I remember was a good bit less strong than hash), but it was almost exclusively Moroccan hash we got, and even though that is a "concentrate", THC levels have traditionally[0] been lower, and CBD levels significantly higher, than much of today's modern cannabis flower. [0] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303871898_The_main_cannabinoids_content_in_hashish_samples_seized_in_Israel_and_Czech_Republic https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303871898_The_main_...
- heavenlyblue 5y ago
- eloisius 5y agoSame observation. I also smoked weed in my teens and early twenties and I remember it making some of the most banal horse shit ideas seem profound, or like I really understand how the universe clicked together. I bet hanging out with a bunch of stoners steeping in my own bullshit for another decade would make me a(n even more) pompous ass too.
- alabamacadabra 5y agoThe effect is such that you are activating neurons which are engaged in the learning process. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11064-005-6978-1 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11064-005-6978-1 Because of this, to the untrained mind (most humans are not given manuals to how their mind works) these firings related to any event cause the event to have the perception of presenting deep information which one can learn from. This state allows one to perceive the banal as sublime, or in simpler terms, dumb shit seems cooler, and you can enjoy dumb things more, as you are turning on a relational learning part of your mind and also engaging in a consumption ritual to do so. Genuinely this article and the reactions are giving me some confusion in regards to how other people perceive the world.
- stevev 5y agoI doubt this even happened lol.
- jwilber 5y ago“I doubt that even happened lol.” Says man who, earlier in the same thread on weed-induced arrogance, writes, “my experience is the opposite.“
- brendanclune 5y agoRealistically it was my teens and early twenties that made banal horse shit ideas profound. There's something to be said for age.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alanbernstein 5y agoMy experience is the exact opposite: 1) I would not suggest that marijuana use correlates with any particular behavior very much. 2) The only thing I have noticed in common among some heavy users was stereotypical stoner behavior, primarily forgetfulness and absent-mindedness. They are usually aware of this, which means it does not present as anything remotely like arrogance.
- stevev 5y agoMy experience and opinion are similar to yours. A typical stoner isn’t really there, and when they are there, it’s more of a questioning or socializing activity. Alcoholic behaviors are what I would describe as arrogance and extreme impairment.
- crazy_horse 5y agoIt's very possible that those are the stoners that stick out. There are a lot of stoners out there that are there and you don't realize are high.
- bobthechef 5y agoAsk yourself why people smoke weed in the first place. It isn't because they're temperate and psychically/spiritually/morally in order. Weed stupefies and dulls a person to certain unwanted feelings, like guilt or anxiety. That isn't any more medicinal than alcoholism. In line with that, if what you write is true, it would be consistent with the idea that they have vices which cause them suffering which they then proceed to numb instead of dealing with the vices. So if they suffer from envy and pride, this will make them miserable people, so they smoke to numb the suffering. It's basically a way of coping with the consequences of denial about those vices: an intentional disintegration of the intellect to prevent conscious realization of one's vices because they can bear down on one's conscience. The only true way out is moral reform, but if you don't want to repent and face the consequences of repentance, if you are a slave to your pride and to your passions, then you will look for something else to kill the guilt and the pain.
- QuercusMax 5y agoWow, this is really ignorant. Have you ever tried cannabis? My guess is no.
- crazy_horse 5y agoIt may help if you asked yourself why you feel qualified to judge a bunch of people's minds.
- burnished 5y agoWhere ever did you get your ideas from? A D.A.R.E advertisement? Are you conflating marijuana and opioids? Seriously. You sound like my grand parents, who ascribe frankly magical effects to marijuana. Do you also believe that people regularly get high and believe they can fly?
- shoemakersteve 5y agoThis sounds like it's coming from someone who has 0 experience with weed and has been told their whole life that it's bad and only bad people do it for bad reasons. And judging by the "repentance" language, probably a religious aspect too.
- walleeee 5y ago> there's a sense of superiority that seems to crop up among them the directionality could be the inverse: e.g. insecurity driving people to social overcompensation as well as cannabis as a reprieve or escape from their anxieties
- stevev 5y agoMy experience is opposite. My experience with cannabis use using a simple activity. Sober, I can clean my office without much thinking and if I had to repeatedly do it, I’d probably do it the same fashion every time. On cannabis, I’m able to see what I believe to be the more or most efficient way of cleaning my office, garage and rooms. I could probably come up with a few ways or road maps for doing so. I don’t know what it is. Maybe there’s a higher level of dopamine from using cannabis that influenced me to have so much attention and focus on such a menial task. I have been told that I’m usually not there mentally and never arrogant; and my friends are pretty outspoken.
- dqpb 5y agoYou should record yourself cleaning in both situations and then compare. Otherwise, you are merely comparing your perception of your self, which obviously is altered in the second case.
- samatman 5y agoSure, that would be interesting on some level. But I see the objective as cleaning the room, not having a clean room, so a subjective experience of being more engaged and enjoying it more is intrinsically valuable. If it takes a lot longer or the results aren't as good, that changes things, sure, but this can be settled with a timer and a before/after photo. Controlling for degree-of-mess probably adds so much noise that this probably isn't useful in practice.
- mjbeswick 5y agoI imagine that's just perception; as in reality cannabis impairs cognitive functions such as motor control, and problem solving. On the other hand, Amphetamines would definitely help you clean your office more efficiently; but you wouldn't want to stop there!
- nimroddy 5y ago> consistent arrogance and self-importance Unfortunately, these words are vague and will only facilitate people projecting their own definitions onto them in order to either support or deny your claim. If there is a CEO making 500% more than some engineer, and some engineer complains about that, then someone may say, "Hey that person is just some engineer, how self-important and arrogant to complain to the CEO like that", but for me it's self-important and arrogant for the CEO to think the pay is proportional, and brave and commendable for the engineer to speak up. I have known many assholes. Some were teetotalers and some used cannabis. Be careful to let your own self-importance and arrogance allow you to think you can or should outright label someone else, or explain another's behavior, especially by pointing at only one facet of their life that you happen to be privvy to.
- RIMR 5y agoYeah, I'm a daily pot-smoker and many of my friends are too, and we're all generally doing great at our careers and personal lives. I did some reflecting upon reading this comment to ensure that I'm not some sort of narcissistic stoner who doesn't get any feedback, but I really can't see that in myself or any of the people I know who are heavy smokers. I'm worried that OP is just looking down on their pot-smoking peers through the lens of stereotypes with a "that's a lot of confidence for a pothead" attitude instead of recognizing that they're legitimately happy, confident people - traits they likely aren't as critical of when they comes from others.
- lrdswrk00 5y agoI take the position that it’s your biochemistry reacting to them. What words you label it as feeling like are subjective. I notice people from all walks of life can feel entitled, and narcissistic. I’m sure some have been stoners.
- pier25 5y agoI think what you describe is pretty common in humans, weed or not. What I've seen in weed users (myself included when I was in my 20s) is a tendency towards magical thinking and enjoying/accepting fantasies.
- _jjkk 5y ago> they may be contributing very little to society (or maybe a lot), but regardless there's a sense of superiority A sober individual's brain is operating on standard (often societally installed) reward mechanism, including "succeeding" on certain self-evaluated measures like "contributions to society" It's commonly said that weed makes you "OK with being bored". i.e. standard reward mechanisms mentioned above don't really matter much when you're high. It has nothing to do with narcissism or sense of superiority as you call it, just that their reward mechanism doesn't include things like "how much am I contributing to society". Apathy is a better word for it.
- Barrin92 5y agowell apathetic individuals still rely on the society they are in, most of the time anyway. I think this is where the narcissism perception comes in. Most stoners in particular people who smoke a lot and for a long time at least in my experience become apathetic and to a degree dependent on their environment. They rely on others to organize their lives, even get simple chores done, they become sort of lethargic. And when you have an individual like that who also acts indifferently towards it you create (I think a justified) negative perception.
- _jjkk 5y agoBe careful not to over-generalize from personal experience... Maybe you've just met a few examples of lethargic, dependent narcissists who smoke a lot of weed? There is selection bias at play, as someone with an admitted negative perception of stoners you probably haven't put yourself in many situations where you might meet counterexamples. In my experience, I've met many stoners whose driving force is empathy and compassion and not narcissism and apathy. Anyway, keep in mind any substance abuse is often an amplifier of issues that already existed.
- Barrin92 5y agoI did qualify that I'm talking about heavy users but I don't think I'm over-generalizing. Any heavy drug use, or addictive or dependent behavior in general crowds out other things. That's just a fact of substance use. Occasional recreational use is one thing but people who are high every day, they aren't able to be as present as they would be if they were sober, and in changes them in I think usually negative ways. Not even because of the particular drug they're using, but because of the patterns of behavior that come with those levels of consumption.
- 01100011 5y agoThat's just society these days... Actually I think you have a point and it probably stems from the way in which MJ modifies your dopamine system. In any case, the reason I ultimately gave up smoking it is it makes my overall psychological health worse. I take a more cynical and negative view of things, even if it makes me mellower and temporarily happy. It affects my memory and my motivation, even as it increases my interest in things(so it slightly helps with ADHD, but effective net benefit to my job is zero). It also costs a hell of a lot of money unless you can grow it yourself these days(thanks, legal weed). Smoked for 16 years constantly, quit for 2, resumed a couple times to help with various issues in mid life, but at the end of the day I quit because it's just not in line with my goals for my life. Weed helped me stay in bad life situations and compromised my ability to plan an effective way of changing my circumstances. It works for some people, I get it. My friend is a paraplegic and loves it for pain. I love the benefits to joint pain and general mid-life aches. That pain relief is what led me to never really dealing with my back problems until now though.
- philote 5y agoHonestly I've noticed the opposite. The pot smokers I've known (which there have been many) have been some of the coolest people. They've been very friendly and giving, and definitely not arrogant or self-important. Maybe it depends on the area you live in and types of social circles you're in?
- beebeepka 5y agoWhat an elaborate way if saying weed smokers are lazy bums. Have you considered you attract a certain type? The long time smokers I know live remarkably normal lives. Kids, jobs, etc
- oblib 5y agoI could certainly be accused of haughtiness when someone made a snide remark about me using marijuana. This is because I got fed up with arrogant people shitting on me when they found out I use it. In my experience it is those who love to flout their sense of superiority by shitting on users who are arrogant. But shit can flow both ways and when I'd point out that they too use "drugs" they'd get very defensive. Back in the 80s my cocaine using friends loved shitting on weed users. "It makes you dumb" was one of their favorite cut downs. My alcohol drinking friends who didn't smoke weed loved to cast the aspersion that weed smokers were "drug users". When I started pointing out that alcohol was a drug too they all very loudly denied it because couldn't stand the idea that they were "drug users" too. And along with and within those two groups are those who do prescription drugs. It was pretty strange to be accused of being a "drug user" by people taking codeine and Xanax and Quaaludes, ect. When I pointed out the serious side effects of alcohol, both personal and to our society at large as compared to weed smokers they started shutting up about that when talking to me. Since Colorado legalized it those kinds of encounters have been far less common, and I've certainly appreciated it. And because of that I'd probably be far less likely to be accused of being arrogant nowadays.
- SquishyPanda23 5y ago> "It makes you dumb" was one of their favorite cut downs. Well, it does measurably decrease IQ. And at least in teens, this reduction seems like it may be permanent.
- oblib 5y agoYeah, I've heard people say that all my life. Some folks love to believe that. But there's nothing that really backs that up with solid proof. A lot of them whom I've heard say that were coke users, which to me would indicate a lack of intelligence. Here's a couple studies that seem to disprove that myth about weed users but, like all of these studies, they really cannot claim to be conclusive. Still better than most I've seen though: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/marijuana-may-not-lower-your-iq/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/marijuana-may-not... https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/01/twins-study-finds-no-evidence-marijuana-lowers-iq-teens https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/01/twins-study-finds-no...
- sodafountan 5y agoI'm not a psychologist, but I think narcissism and self-importance simply stem from a small world view. If your main hobby/recreational activity in life is smoking weed (certainly not judging anyone) then you'll likely only associate with people who enjoy the same things, if anyone at all. This leads to a very narrow world-view where you're the center of that world. Going out and meeting people, doing different activities, taking on new jobs and roles, going to school and getting an education all really help to humble people and make people realize that most of us are all very similar in our pursuit of happiness.
- asdff 5y agoI think part of that isn't the symptoms of the drug but the culture surrounding it. In most places its illegal or at the very least frowned upon, so being one who does this regularly makes you perceived by some parts of society as some sort of black sheep. People wear the black sheep badge proudly and can be arrogant and in your face about it. Just look at how techies act online. Smoking pot, like knowing stuff about technology, makes you 'in the know' relative to the rest of society, and can make you feel superior that you are taking part in something that most people will never or might outright refuse to experience. Even in parts of the US where its been legal to smoke pot for some time like California, the social stigma of meeting up for drinks at a bar regularly and meeting up to smoke pot regularly are not equivalent. Your employer might even drug test you still.
- self_buddliea 5y agoReading this article made me recall an incident back in art college. A mature student asked if I smoked cannabis, I said I do. There was another mature student in the room with us. Upon hearing my confession she stared at me with a very serious expression, then lunged forward at me and pushed her face into mine. I was so taken aback I nearly fell off my chair. I had never met this woman before, we were never introduced and I haven't seen her since. I would argue this woman was sufficiently arrogant that she thought it was socially acceptable to invade my personal space because I was a stoner. Perhaps I myself was more arrogant when I was younger, in the spirit that user warent mentioned below. On the other hand, I'm not the type to spontaneously invade the space of others.
- krylon 5y agoI can only provide a single data point, but I used to smoke a lot of weed for a pretty long time, then stopped about 12 years ago, and one of the changes I noticed was that I became much more able to accept responsibility for my mistakes instead of blaming everything wrong with my life on others. After I stopped smoking, I talked about this a friend who also quit weed around that time, and he said it was the same for him. (Okay, so it's two data points.) Make of that what you want, but there is a correlation. That doesn't mean weed turns people into assholes necessarily, but it can certainly amplify preexisting tendencies in that direction. I'm pretty sure the same goes for various other drugs as well - I never spent time around cocaine or methamphetamine enthusiasts, but I've been told, some people have a tendency to become real assholes on cocaine. And of course there's alcohol, which definitely helps all kinds of unpleasant personality traits to float to the surface.
- mikem170 5y agoMaybe growing older and wiser played a part? I've seen some of my friends transform attitudes like that significantly as the years go by, weed never being involved.
- trutannus 5y ago> there's a sense of superiority that seems to crop up among them all As a Canadian where weed is legal, I can say I've not had this experience at all. A lot of folks here use it, at all ages and all personality types. Very unusual for me to meet someone who uses it and for them to strike me as any different than the average Canadian.
- wil421 5y agoI noticed the opposite. In my 30s now and most of the people I know who smoke a lot are pretty relaxed and the complete opposite of a narcissist.
- warent 5y agoThis would not surprise me at all. But I'm curious to know if they got the causation backwards. Maybe people with schizophrenia just have a higher likelihood of smoking marijuana
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 5y agoYeah this is often the debate. Many schizophrenic people self-medicate with drugs and alcohol before they've been diagnosed, so it's very hard to get a clear picture. The "component cause" makes sense... marijuana and other psychedelics don't necessarily cause schizophrenia in most people, but for some people it may serve as a trigger. There's some evidence that trauma in childhood may have a similar impact.
- sharklazer 5y agoI'm curious about alcohol and tobacco usage as well. Tobacco usage in mentally ill has generally been higher. It could simply reflect over all trends in substance choices depending on availability. So many variables unaccounted for.
- rwnspace 5y agoI've heard it on good authority that schizophrenics find nicotine/tobacco significantly ameliorates their symptoms - it can be a lesser evil for some.
- badloginnew 5y agoI think it’s an acetylcholine agonist or something like that.
- InitialLastName 5y agoPlus, if you're going to self-medicate by building a psychological addiction, there are worse substances to do it with than nicotine. I know many alcoholics, for example, who picked up tobacco in rehab. It might not be healthy, but it can be a bit less self-destructive to your personal life.
- hart_russell 5y agoI think it's too common a sentiment that psychoactive substances like cannabis and psilocybin are harmless and in fact are good for mental health. I've had adverse mental reactions to both and I would caution people with family history of anxiety.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoA lot of marijuana smokers like to pretend weed smoke is somehow less harmful than any other smoke. It's still CO whether it comes from the tobacco or hemp plant. It's still bad and creates a tar residue in your lungs. Any time I bring that up, somehow I become anti-pot even though it's a genuine concern. Edit: Carbon Monoxide, not Carbon Dioxide. And some additions since this is a tad controversial. Here is one source - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3340105/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3340105/ Marijuana inhaled is bad for your body. End of story. Let's not pretend like it's some panacea that the government doesn't want us to know about. It shouldn't be illegal, but a lot of people on here lie to themselves that somehow the harmful effects of CO aren't bad just because it's marijuana. I feel like there is some major cognitive dissonance among pot smokers equivalent to religious people that get upset when you say there is no god.
- xxpor 5y agoI don't think anyone who's serious doesn't think the act of burning organic matter and inhaling it is bad. That being said, pot simply has a lot less stuff in it than tobacco smoke. Also, almost no one is smoking a pack of day of joints. Fortunately there are other alternatives too, like sugar free candies.
- olyjohn 5y agoYou hit the nail on the head. Most people I know will smoke like half a joint in an evening and be done. Maybe take a couple bong rips. You don't sit there and smoke all night long. You'd be passed out long before you'd get through a 20 pack of joints. Meanwhile, it's super easy to pick up a pack of cigarettes and suck down 5-10 of them in an evening. Sometimes it feels like people who don't smoke really have to justify it hard. All these justifications they come up with which really aren't even an issue. Maybe they're afraid of it, and don't want to admit it... If you don't wanna smoke it, don't smoke it. There's nothing wrong with that. But some of the reasons I read to not smoke weed are ridiculous.
- Threeve303 5y agoReefer Madness
- DrBenCarson 5y agoObvious I hope, but this doesn’t prove anything other than marijuana use has increased. If the population, independent of other conditions, has an increase in marijuana use disorder, then that same increase would be present in the subset of the population that are diagnosed with schizophrenia or related disorders.
- okareaman 5y agoI would like to see a study exploring the decline (if any) of problems from alcohol abuse in states where marijuana became legal. I am fairly certain that if I could have smoked marijuana when I was in the military then I wouldn't have developed an alcohol habit that has caused me so many problems over the years up until the time I quit.
- rantwasp 5y agoSince we’re here I would like to see a study linking sugar to the increase of health problems (including mental health). Other drugs are small change compared to sugar.
- okareaman 5y agoI recently gave up sugar when I realized I suffered sugar highs/withdrawal depressions and reached for it when I felt anxious, just like a drug. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/318818 https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/318818
- tudorw 5y agoFood As A Machine Gun (Official Lyric Video) - Enemy Radio, Public Enemy https://www.google.com/search?gs_ssp=eJzj4tVP1zc0TCtJMra0yDY1YPQSTcvPT1HILFZIVMhNTM7IzEtVSC_NAwDW8QvT&q=food+is+a+machine+gun&oq=food+is+a+machine&aqs=chrome.1.0i355j46j69i57j0i22i30l4j69i60.4635j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?gs_ssp=eJzj4tVP1zc0TCtJMra0yDY...
- okareaman 5y agosugar sugar call me late at night by daylight stomach busted not feeling right heart burnin' I need oxygen sweet and sour more addictive than your oxycontin
- ipnon 5y agoWho doesn't know someone who went crazy from drinking? It's normalized, especially in the military it seems. A major difference between the long term negative effects of the two drugs is that alcoholics seem to mostly recover after some years of sobriety, but former cannabis users can receive incurable disorders like schizophrenia. More simply, the mental disorders of alcohol abuse resist being pathologized, we assign them sociocultural explanations like "he's going through a rough time." Meanwhile, he's clinically depressed, anxious, has mood swings, all direct results of long term alcohol consumption.
- kvathupo 5y agoAs usual, a sensational headline averring a research article's causal hypothesis, of which the PI even calls for reproducibility. Reading such paltry science articles makes me really appreciate papers like Quanta, whose reporters seem to actually have a semblance of domain knowledge. Indeed, no discussion of the existing link between schizophrenia and tobacco smoking, in conjunction with the increased availability of marijuana?
- ignostic 5y ago> of which the PI even calls for reproducibility You mean like every study I've ever read? I can't recall the last time the conclusion didn't say something like, "In our study X appears to be associated with Y, but more research is needed to understand the relationship." You're right, though, that this article leaves many questions unasked. We know that people who are schizophrenic are far more likely to smoke cigarettes, but there is evidence to suggest they're more likely to smoke before their first episode as well. So is tobacco causal? Probably not. Instead, there are probably precursor symptoms to diagnosable schizophrenia that drive tobacco use: anxiety being the main one. Anxiety and marijuana has already been studied with conflicting results, probably because it's hard to determine out whether people with anxiety are drawn to marijuana (or heavier usage) or whether heavy usage causes anxiety. There are reasons to think marijuana use can cause schizophrenic episodes - sometimes a first episode - but that use may not increase the risk of developing the disorder when viewed in a 20-year window. In other words, it happens sooner. So according to the article the number of schizophrenia cases linked to cannabis use disorder increased by 4x. I'd like to know whether schizophrenia diagnoses overall changed significantly. I am not saying there are no risks. But I am agreeing that the article does a bad job of analyzing the science.
- gwern 5y agoThe population level prevalence is where we should see this. If cannabis really did cause SCZ, as opposed to merely being self-medication, general drug use dysfunctionality, or possibly just accelerating SCZ onset but not increasing total cases, we should see incredibly high rates in recreational legalizing jurisdictions where prevalence is now a large fraction of the population. Instead, buried at the end, we get "The findings could help explain the "general increase in the incidence of schizophrenia that has been observed in recent years" and provides some support that the "long-observed association between cannabis and schizophrenia is likely partially causal in nature," the study said." OK then...
- doublerabbit 5y agoAnecdotal however cannabis has many compounds, The two main ones are: THC and CBD. If your using a strain that has high THC and not much in CBD. CBD being the compound to safe-guard, governor the effects of THC you end up in a trip that can spiral out of control causing negative effects. If you add a CBD strain to the mix. Which are high in CBD and contain trace amounts of THC to your normal method usage, these tend to level out the percentages. My take is this: If your not mentally fit, high THC can cause you to go off the edge compared to strains with lower amounts. The same can be said for Wine and the alcohol volume. And I talk from personal experience from being in a psychosis episode caused by cannabis. -- Edit: I have my own downvote brigade. Yay - Just seems odd that every post I post on HN gets down-voted.
- saryant 5y agoThis matches my experience as someone who struggles with severe anxiety and intrusive/delusional thoughts. THC makes for a very bad time for me, but a high CBD edible calms down my mind and helps me temper those thoughts.
- stevev 5y agoI’m upvoting this. I believe your explanation on the strains are on point. When using the vapor method, very high in thc, sometimes I do experience psychosis or schizophrenic symptoms. My perception of reality does change a bit during peak affect but disappears after wearing off. When smoking raw cannabis the regular way, I experience a more calming affect; emotionally tolerable and focused mindset.
- filoeleven 5y agoDon’t forget the terpenes! Terpenes play a big role in cannabis effects as well, accounting for the differences between sativa and indica strains. Pinine and terpinaline for example are more likely than other terpenes to cause anxiety and paranoia at higher concentrations, meaning >1%. I don’t know if they contribute psychotic episodes though.
- slingnow 5y agoEditing your post to whine about the downvotes will surely get people to stop downvoting you. Well played.
- tremon 5y agoSo, more schizophrenic people are self-medicating with marijuana now that it's more readily available?
- Ovah 5y agoI'm speaking as a medical student. And I can't speak for what it's like in the US - only Sweden. Here it's not uncommon for schizofrenic patients to self medicate with marijuana. I guess it increases their quality of life until they have just a little too much and end up having a psychosis. That said, at least among Swedish psychiatrists, it's well know that marijuana can trigger schizophrenia in people that are ~16 years old.
- tomrod 5y agoBy what pathway is the schizophrenia triggered? And is the trigger causal or catalytic?
- Ovah 5y agoI guess that's the thing with psychiatry: the whole field is pretty far away from basic science, mechanisms etc. My (second hand) understanding is it actually triggers schizofrenia in 16 y.o. people who would not otherwise have gotten it. Not sure if it's clinical experience or if there is data to back it up. The 16 yo-scenario is one of the few medical arguments I've heard for why there should be an age limit on marijuana.
- code_duck 5y agoI had a girlfriend with a brother he was schizophrenic. He had a classic break with Ronald Reagan directly addressing him through the television and all that. Like most patients, he did not like the side effects of anti-psychotics. He tended to drink light beer all day. At some point he started smoking cannabis and said it was the only thing that had made the voices go away for him. However, this effect seem to go away with tolerance, which isn’t surprising. He also ended up hanging out with a different crowd and starting to smoke crack about six months later, which probably is related to how one was forced to access illegal markets that also sell other drugs to obtain cannabis at that time. Not surprisingly, crack was not good for his schizophrenia. Cannabis, however, seems promising. The way he described it is similar to my experience with pain relief from cannabinoids, which is the unpleasant sensation is still there but you don’t pay any attention to it.
- tr1ll10nb1ll 5y agoIs correlation always causation?
- SubiculumCode 5y agoDuring brain development ~< 25, I recommend against indulging in marijuana. It is a psychoactive drug that can alter developmental growth processes with long-term consequences. Well into adulthood, expression of many of the genes regulating development are suppressed, and thus the means for structural change are more limited; thus adults tend to be more resilient to psychoactive exposures.
- macksd 5y ago>> In 1995, 2% of schizophrenia diagnoses in the country were associated with cannabis use disorder. In 2000, it increased to around 4%. Since 2010, that figure increased to 8%, the study found. Worded that way, causation isn't the first thing this suggests to me. If percentage of cases associated with marijuana rise, it could also be that a larger percentage of the population is smoking and admitting to smoking marijuana regularly. If cases themselves rise, it could also be increases in the percentage of cases that actually get diagnosed, etc. It could very well be that marijuana puts you at higher risk of schizophrenia - I certainly have an acquaintance in mind for whom recreational drug usage seems to have led them to a paranoid and narcissistic personality described here in other comments - but the connection in this article feels weak. Certainly weaker than the connection we see between marijuana law enforcement and the negative fallout of that.
- qayxc 5y agoI agree, there's just too many variables here. The drug itself also changed over the years with current breeds having way more active ingredients than the ones used decades ago.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samatman 5y agoThis part is easy to overstate. It's mostly true for the United States, although even back in the day there were strains (Maui was famous for this) which had nice crystals and were grown without males around to spoil the product. In Europe, hashish was the normal form of cannabis, and it's hard to make hash more potent than it already is. It varies in quality and strength like any natural product, but over a range that is higher than a flower can achieve, pretty much by definition. Hard-core concentrates and pure THC products are new, sure, but hashish gets you most of the way there.
- bjourne 5y agoAccording to studies, cannabis potency has indeed increasedi n Europe in the last few decades. See An overview of cannabis potency in Europe (https://www.emcdda.europa.eu/publications/insights/cannabis-potency_en https://www.emcdda.europa.eu/publications/insights/cannabis-...) and Increasing potency and price of cannabis in Europe, 2006–16 (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/add.14525 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/add.14525). From the abstract of the latter study: "Resin potency increased from a mean [95% confidence interval (CI)] of 8.14% THC (6.89, 9.49) in 2006 to 17.22 (15.23, 19.25) in 2016. Resin price increased from 8.21 euros/g (7.54, 8.97) to 12.27 (10.62, 14.16). Resin increased in value, from 11.00 mg THC per euro (8.60, 13.62) to 16.39 (13.68, 19.05). Quadratic time trends for resin potency and value indicated minimal change from 2006 to 2011, followed by marked increases from 2011 to 2016. Herbal cannabis potency increased from 5.00% THC (3.91, 6.23) to 10.22 (9.01, 11.47). Herbal price increased from 7.36 euros/g (6.22, 8.53) to 12.22 (10.59, 14.03). The value of herbal cannabis did not change from 12.65 mg of THC per euro (10.18, 15.34) to 12.72 (10.73, 14.73). All price trends persisted after adjusting for inflation. Conclusions European cannabis resin and herbal cannabis increased in potency and price from 2006 to 2016. Cannabis resin (but not herbal cannabis) increased in the quantity of Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol per euro spent. Marked increases in resin potency and value from 2011 to 2016 are consistent with the emergence of new resin production techniques in European and neighbouring drug markets." Certainly, the potency is much higher than it was in the 1960's and 1970's.
- kerblang 5y agoPurely anecdotal, but a long time ago I read a book by Mark Vonnegut, Kurt Vonnegut's son. He explained how he was diagnosed with schizophrenia, and warned that for him, marijuana made his condition much, much worse, and he learned early on to strictly avoid it. From that one could argue that maybe pot aggravates borderline cases of schizophrenia to the point of a temporary psychotic breakdown & diagnosis. In Mr Vonnegut's case he needed long-term treatment for his schizophrenia either way, but the marijuana effect was short-term and remedied by just staying the heck away from it. Also worth noting that 30+ years ago the stuff people smoked was much weaker than some of the high-end product you can buy today.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jl2718 5y agoWe should all consider what kinds of delusions we’ve conditioned into our brains, and how that might affect our attitudes and opinions. Maybe be a little less certain that the right way to think just so happens to be the only way that is accessible to us personally.
- adam0c 5y ago"heavy use of the drug" ... shocker! problems arise in people woth substance abuse problem's :/
- moate 5y agoPeople with Schizophrenia may abuse drugs (at up to an 8% rate for marijuana). :O
- 74d-fe6-2c6 5y ago1) THC to CBD ratio in Cannabis has been intentionally increased in favor of THC. 2) Cannabis is more and more cut with synthetic cannabinoids which are notoriously bad for the brain and mind. 3) Long-term Cannabis use is not evenly distributed but focused on people with a certain personality open for such an experience. 4) Cannabis has been and still is illegal in most places. That alone will foster a tendency for paranoia. 5) Just as with other drugs, some people aren't able to control their consumption and that's never good for you. 6) Long-term Cannabis enjoyment in the face of prohibition will solidify the realisation that our society is inherently fascist and narrow-minded. (I can confirm that from personal experience.)
- annoyingnoob 5y ago> Cannabis is more and more cut with synthetic cannabinoids which are notoriously bad for the brain and mind. Do you have a link to support that?
- t8e56vd4ih 5y agothat's a pretty well documented trend. Google it.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI've seen products like K2 and Spice that are synthetic, sold as separate products. I haven't seen actual cannabis that had added synthetics.
- jxramos 5y agoReminds me of the opening to this article by a journalist having a casual chat with this wife (a psychiatrist at a state mental institution) one evening where she stated in passing: Of course he’d been smoking pot his whole life. https://imprimis.hillsdale.edu/marijuana-mental-illness-violence/ https://imprimis.hillsdale.edu/marijuana-mental-illness-viol... I've been meaning to read further about that connection because like the author I had never heard of that idea before and everything before it was like taken to be Reefer Madness paranoia.
- mullingitover 5y agoI've seen someone have a textbook psychotic break while consuming a lot of cannabis. Radio was sending them secret messages, coworkers were government spies, believed they were Jesus (and normally they'd been a confirmed atheist). As soon as the cannabis consumption stopped, the psychosis stopped. They started smoking again, symptoms came back. I'd also done some googling to try to understand why some people have panic attacks, and there seems to be a link to cannabis and hypoglycemia for some people. Hypoglycemia can cause: psychosis and panic attacks.
- ajkjk 5y agoI've known a few people that this happens to. Not sure it's the same as long-term schizophrenia but there's definitely similarities.
- code_duck 5y agoIt would be interesting to know more about the hypoglycemia link. I contracted type one diabetes as an adult, somehow, and was hesitant to try anything for the first time after that including alcohol or cannabis. I wear a continuous glucose monitor and as far as I can tell, cannabis has no effect on my blood glucose.
- mullingitover 5y agoThere's this study published in Diabetes Care[1], "Efficacy and Safety of Cannabidiol and Tetrahydrocannabivarin on Glycemic and Lipid Parameters in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled, Parallel Group Pilot Study". > RESULTS Compared with placebo, THCV significantly decreased fasting plasma glucose (estimated treatment difference [ETD] = −1.2 mmol/L; P < 0.05) and improved pancreatic β-cell function (HOMA2 β-cell function [ETD = −44.51 points; P < 0.01]), adiponectin (ETD = −5.9 × 106 pg/mL; P < 0.01), and apolipoprotein A (ETD = −6.02 μmol/L; P < 0.05), although plasma HDL was unaffected. Compared with baseline (but not placebo), CBD decreased resistin (−898 pg/ml; P < 0.05) and increased glucose-dependent insulinotropic peptide (21.9 pg/ml; P < 0.05). None of the combination treatments had a significant impact on end points. CBD and THCV were well tolerated. [1] https://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/39/10/1777.long https://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/39/10/1777.long
- whytaka 5y agoI’m a big proponent of marijuana. I recommend it to others almost as a rite of passage and I’m eager to see a world where marijuana use trumps alcohol consumption. But I admit that it’s not without risk. I like to think I am of stable mind. I have never had a drug experience that had overwhelmed my sense of self or being. I have a couple times felt overwhelmed physically, to the point of exhaustion, but my mind kept pace and knew how to navigate the experience. But I’ve also experienced moments where I sensed a certain line was on the verge of being crossed, where the sense of self/being would not be my ultimate experience. Again, I don’t feel as though I’ve crossed that border myself but I have a rather high tolerance. I recognize these moments to be quite dangerous to those less grounded in their sense of self. I would not be surprised that such an experience could lead to psychosis. The potency of commercially available strains now are on a completely level to the ones I consumed during college. This research is absolutely necessary.
- obsequiosity 5y agoHow do you develop a stronger sense of self?
- whytaka 5y agoI can’t answer that. I don’t think I did anything to be this way. As far as I know I was born with it.
- rantwasp 5y agoAlcohol consumption is not without risk. It literally kills your brain cells and has many negative side effects associated with it. Alcohol is widely produced, distributed and consumed. To me this comes down to having the choice. Do the research, document the possible side effect, give me the choice is I want to drink/do the drug. Also, anecdotally based on my own life experience, I think overall marijuana is less harmful than alcohol.
- whytaka 5y agoI completely agree.
- oblib 5y agoI have some experience with this. My first wife was diagnosed with schizophrenia after birthing a stillborn baby. This was about 14 month after we had our first child. One of her doctors insisted the cause was marijuana, but she really did smoke much at all. I did most everyday though and one of the first questions he asked was if we used it. I told him I thought it was caused by losing the baby and he insisted that had nothing at all to do with it. I knew for sure he was wrong, but he refused to even consider it. But there was more to it than that. Her grandmother was clearly schizophrenic, and her mother was probably was too. Just a few months before this her mother told me she "hated" our first child because "she looks like you" (it was me she was referring to). This was in 1986. 15 years later, in 2001, a woman name Andrea Yates murdered her five children and that was when psychiatrist first diagnosed severe "Post Partum Depression" as the cause of what led her to do that. During those years in between I had pointed out that connection many times to psychiatrists and everyone of them told me I was wrong and they all loved to make the point that I didn't have the credentials to offer a diagnoses of cause. But what I did have that none of them had was real life experience watching my wife slide into schizophrenia. Schizophrenia is genetic and stress is a trigger. It often doesn't show up until one is an adult. By that time almost anyone will have taken a puff of weed and if a doctor asks them "have you ever used marijuana" and they say "yes", in my experience it doesn't matter how often, using it just once, even years prior, is enough for them to associate cause and effect. Truth is you can learn something from anyone if you listen to them. If you don't, you won't. What I learned is psychiatry is still pretty much bullshit and the medical profession still doesn't understand the causes or how to treat schizophrenia effectively. They manage it by giving those suffering with it drugs that are akin to turning their patients into slobbering "zombies" so they can manage them.
- giantg2 5y ago"One of her doctors insisted the cause was marijuana..." "I knew for sure he was wrong, but he refused to even consider it... [even with family history]." I have seen stuff like this a few times, and it is usually the sign of a bad doctor. If there isn't a positive test for something and you're ignoring other evidence, how can you say it absolutely is one thing or the other. This is extremely common with vaccines when providers say it is completely safe and write off adverse events as unrelated without any evidence to support the claim. Vaccines are generally safe, but adverse reactions can occur. If you have doctors underreporting to the VAERS system, then the system will not catch the rare events because the data is too incomplete to show significance. Edit: why downvote? Here's a paper acknowledging limitations like under reporting. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15071280/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15071280/
- subsubzero 5y agoI don't know about schizophrenia and marijuana use, but a ER Dr. friend of mine always complains about the amount of people she sees that have a condition where their body can't handle the weed they regularly smoke. The symptoms are always the same, extremely belligerent, violently sick(constant vomiting), and very nauseous. She says that sometimes its the same people as they just don't get that weed is making them really sick(stopping smoking makes the symptoms go away). For some reason the media never reports on this but if you know someone in the medical field(ER etc) ask them and they will tell you the same thing. I found this medical paper about the issue: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5330965/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5330965/
- zwkrt 5y agoHyperemesis is definitely real, and eventually affects 1/3 of heavy weed smokers. A lover of mine had to self-diagnose because their doctor wasn’t aware. The crazy part is as that smoking weed ameliorated the symptoms in the short term, so there is a strong psychological reinforcement to keep smoking even though it is actually causing the background symptoms.
- code_duck 5y agoThis was discussed a lot in the cannabis community a few years ago though the topic seems to have died down. The consensus among people heavily involved in cannabis is that it is related to overuse of neem oil, an organic pesticide. Some growers had been using neem very liberally without keeping in mind that the active ingredients are toxic to humans. The toxicity of neem seems to be in line with the effects of cyclical vomiting/hypermesis. So, it has been a thing to shun and shame people using that pesticide for a few years.
- pm90 5y agoInstinctively skeptical of mainstream news orgs that report on scientific studies without linking to the actual study.
- michaelmrose 5y agoNo understood method that marijuana could possibly cause the condition check. Trivially comprehensible in terms of increasing usage or increasing admission of usage check. > our findings will have to be replicated elsewhere Check > "long-observed association between cannabis and schizophrenia is likely partially causal in nature," Weasel words. If they had printed their article on toilet paper at least it would be good for something.
- TechBro8615 5y agoRolling papers might be a better medium.
- 52-6F-62 5y agoToo many people might be at risk of contentment and their own personal happiness if we let up now.
- ajkjk 5y agoSneering at the article doesn't really make your case more convincing. Instead it just seems like it provoked an overly-defensive reaction.
- michaelmrose 5y agoThe article is so bad it actually denigrates the publication by its existence and lends unearned weight to the degenerates criticism of CNN. I don't personally have a dog in the fight.
- caymanjim 5y agoReally getting sick of voluntary behavior being labeled as a "disease" or "disorder". That's the mainstream, PC way of presenting it, and while a number of doctors do support that labeling, it's by no means a universal consensus. Plenty of doctors push back against this, but most of them just avoid picking a fight you can't win against the rabid faction that wants to remove any vestige of personal responsibility. And I say this as someone who's (ab)used his fair share of substances.
- euthymiclabs 5y agoPsychiatrist (and addiction psychiatrist in training) here. I agree that calling substance use disorders a disease is highly problematic. However, I think that while the majority of people who use substances don't have a problem, there are many people who use substances in a maladaptive (or disordered) way that dramatically impacts their ability to function, and we need a name to describe that. Substance use disorder is a pretty neutral term, and much better than the older "abuse" and "dependence" terminology for a number of reasons. The wording isn't intended to suggest that personal responsibility isn't required--and any treating clinician would quash that idea right away. It's a way to describe patterns and determine what might be helpful for an individual. It's certainly imperfect, but a much better description than past nomenclature.
- caymanjim 5y agoThanks for replying. I agree with what you've said, and agree that it's helpful to have a term for use that dramatically impacts a person's ability to function. "Use disorder" here does seem to be a reasonable, neutral term for differentiating between normal (or even heavy) use that doesn't cause significant problems and use (at any level) that does cause significant problems (physical, mental, financial, or social). I have a knee-jerk reaction to calling problematic drug use a "disease". "Disorder", as you've described it, does seem like a reasonable term.
- euthymiclabs 5y agoAgreed. This paper https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMra1602872 https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMra1602872 (which isn't available open access, unfortunately) argues that the brain changes in substance use are more likely normal learning associated with very strong stimuli than actual disease processes. I find this to be a more helpful, optimistic, and accurate interpretation of the data than the disease model. (And it really complements the other evidence-based interventions for substance use disorders we have!)
- ahofmann 5y agoI know, this isn't scientific, but I met in my life at least 50 people who did all kind of drugs and two of them have problems with schizophrenia and both did smoke much more marijuana, than I could ever do or want. Most of the others stopped at some point to do drugs and are now more or less normal people in their society. I know, this says nothing, but I have become careful with marijuana and don't see it as being completely harmless. This being said, I think that alcohol and tobacco are much more dangerous than marijuana.
- lrdswrk00 5y agoMaybe more people are borderline schizophrenic than we realize. Cancer detection improved and people thought that meant cancer rates are up but, to my current knowledge, no one knows which is true. I’m not going to accept this is marijuana causing schizophrenia given this. Society, their specific DNA, family life, could be, and marijuana use is merely exposing it, and enabling proper diagnosis.
- random_kris 5y agoThis devil's lettuce... I quit daily 24/7 smoking 10 days ago after 6 years of constant smoke. I smoked on 2 occasions with friends since then and I liked it... It makes me calm but lazy and not wanting to socialize. When I'm high I want to quit but when I am not high I am quite anxious and always looking for something to ease me up...
- tomrod 5y agoFrom my personal observation of loved ones, schizophrenics self-medicate, often with what is available. I plan to read this article to understand if they are just seeing selection bias.
- webinvest 5y agoThey may be paranoid because marijuana amplifies paranoia. Nowadays, doctors can prescribe some highly effective tranquilizer medication that can stop schizophrenia and paranoia. Maybe if both you and another person they know simultaneously visit them, advise the same-thing, and ask inquire if getting the brand name medication would be more trust-worthy?
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoI have enjoyed smoking Cannabis for decades, but a recent bought of financial difficulty coupled with a desire to get programming last week has shown some teeth on the cute little bubbly image of Cannabis in my mind. I started smoking more (due to stress) and trying to complete a new project (financial difficulty) and it was just a nightmare. It's noticeably more difficult to concentrate and retain new information when I am ingesting regularly. Learning a new programming language, even having just had a few joints the night before, is so much more difficult that it would be without the Cannabis. I honestly felt like I was losing my mind. I'm not even talking about being high while learning/working... just having the cannabinoids in your system from a few days ago really soaks and coats the mind. So I've cut it out, for now.
- animanoir 5y agoIn my case is different. I tend to focus and learn better with cannabis, but that might be that it relaxes me to some degree that I can take existence better and concentrate stimulating my mind. In fact I believe weed changed me for the better. May sound cliche but now I'm deeply interested in philosophy and technical concepts and aptitudes (like programming), and actually my whole attitude towards life got really bright and mature, with myself and with others. I'm not saying weed alone made that, but definitely helped me. As I said, at least for me concentration, in this case facilitated by weed, is life changing.
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoI have noticed that a very small dose of cannabis can help in work motivation and concentration... but for myself at least, it's a slippery slope. After a few hours of coding well I start thinking about another very small dose of Cannabis... which won't work because you just ingested a few hours ago and you need to up the dosage... rinse and repeat.
- bjourne 5y agoA few joints per night? That's a whole lot, isn't it?
- howmayiannoyyou 5y agoI suffer from severe restless legs, largely treatment resistant unless I acquiesce to opioids. MJ is the only substance that provides me relief during the worst times - and it takes a LOT to get the effect. Weighing the risks, I am firmly on the side of MJ - at least my 'rescue drug'.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoMaybe not cause directly , but seems to trigger something that was laying dormant. From the smokers I know or knew , it becomes a very addictive habit, where they drift off the norm while stoned or worse, while not stoned. They're not as annoying as coke heads or tweakers, these are more extrovert and kinda obvious, while smokers are often more silent, God knows what's going on in them. I wouldn't associate it to weed until it's 100percent proven, to understand the human mind will take a lot more time.
- NoblePublius 5y agoThe only thing I can reasonably conclude from this study is that more schizophrenics are using marijuana because marijuana is more available than it used to be. I see no evidence of an increase in the absolute number of schizophrenics relative to the availability of cannabis. Who funded this, the DEA?
- moate 5y agoLink to the study:https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abstract/2782160?resultClick=1 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abst... I love that they think that smoking weed is causal to schizophrenia...but aren't considering the opposite.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoAnother thing I perceived is would isolate themselves from other groups and think of themselves as the cool kids, same with the sporty folks. Then you have just the regular nerds who aren't impressed by either group. For my college class, the following turned true... Group smokers ended on social ladder at the dole or slightly above or below it. Sports group, none of them turned to Messi or Ronaldo or a new Michael Jordan, they held average jobs, did alcohol and other recreational things and created a family. Group nerd all ended up in very prestigious job segments, some with "global head of " etc titles, some of them went through nasty divorces maybe they didn't gain social competence or street wiseness while studying but at least they are economically safe. My take away lesson was that it's too hard to recover from group 1 and move on. That is my personal study and that's all I need to know. The scientists can figure out the rest, I don't know how much a factor drugs and alc play, there's always other factors as well.
- samatman 5y agoCool story bro! My hometown is notoriously supportive of cannabis consumption, and one of my high-schools has a well rated jazz programme. Of my smoking buddies, one is a multimillionaire platinum artist, several are successful and sought-after session musicians, and those are just the music geeks. In general my social cohort have had successful lives, and cannabis doesn't strike me as a relevant variable in that success. Some of them also fell off and had a hard life. Those tended to be the ones from single-family homes, living on government assistance. Even that wasn't a universal, but in terms of correlation it really stands out.
- dcolkitt 5y agoOne potential confounding factor is the massive drop in smoking rates, particularly among those in the prime age for schizophrenia onset. The evidence seems to strongly indicate that nicotine is a powerful antipsychotic. When smoking was widespread it's possible that many schizophrenics were self-medicating in a basically effective way. The trend is probably particularly acute among cannabis users. 40 years, I'd expect that nearly all cannabis smokers were cigarette smokers. (Non-smoke consumption being essentially a rounding error back then.) Nowadays the sizable majority of cannabis users probably don't smoke cigarettes whatsoever.
- meowface 5y ago>The evidence seems to strongly indicate that nicotine is a powerful antipsychotic. Source? It's commonly known that there's a very high nicotine use rate among people with schizophrenia, but I haven't heard that it has antipsychotic properties. It likely temporarily helps with certain symptoms, but doesn't necessarily reduce psychosis. I think it may generally be used as self-medication for the negative rather than the positive symptoms of schizophrenia.
- dcolkitt 5y agoAs is often the case on these type of topics, Slate Star Codex had a really good roundup of the evidence: https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/01/11/schizophrenia-no-smoking-gun/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/01/11/schizophrenia-no-smoki...
- meowface 5y agoInteresting post. I think nicotine is probably a valuable nootropic for most people and for schizophrenics (though extremely unhealthy if it's consumed via smoking tobacco), but I don't think that post is at all trying to argue that "The evidence seems to strongly indicate that nicotine is a powerful antipsychotic." Rather, it says a single study found that, when controlling for confounders, smokers in their sample were less likely to get schizophrenia, and heavy smokers were much less likely to get schizophrenia. (When not controlling for confounders, they were more likely to get schizophrenia.) First, "antipsychotic" doesn't necessarily imply "reduces chance of developing schizophrenia". Modern-day antipsychotics generally seem to be blunt instruments designed to dampen acute states of psychosis at that moment, often by doing things like antagonizing dopamine receptors. Something that lowers the risk of developing schizophrenia won't necessarily be an antipsychotic in this sense, even if it could be considered anti-"psychotic disorder development". As far as I know, nicotine doesn't work as an antipsychotic in the sense of it helping to stop an ongoing psychotic episode. It may temporarily improve functioning for someone in such a state, but it may not make them feel less delusional or paranoid, for example. Or at least I'm not aware of evidence of that. And, conversely, I don't know if taking antipsychotics actually reduces the chance of developing schizophrenia if you aren't currently diagnosed with it. And this is just a single study, cited by the author of Beware the Man of One Study (https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-study/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-...). He definitely is not trying to claim that this is overall strong evidence for nicotine being a powerful antipsychotic. As he mentions in it, controlling for confounders is very complex and difficult. So, it seems plausible it could possibly help reduce the chance of developing schizophrenia, but there's definitely not strong evidence of it at this time. The only strongly supported phenomenon I know of is that schizophrenics very commonly use it, with some evidence that it may temporarily reduce negative symptoms and improve cognitive functioning.
- CAX 5y agoMost obvious schizophrenics i have come across were not drug users and were just frightened supicious people who couldnt navigate a social interaction including but not limited to food deliveries, drug deliveries, buying batteries etc. I think the uptick in noticed drug user psychosis is Related to something Big Bill Orielly warned us about: the confluence of drugs and technology, esp social media, implying not taking care of sleep hygiene at the least, but at the most you are seeing what can only be described as “cyber torture” in which subjects are persuaded by those without hands to become retarded. Thats what this weapon is
- dkn775 5y agoCan you provide a link to oriellys talk on that
- subpixel 5y agoI admit that I was thinking of some armchair diagnoses while watching this interview of Lee Scratch Perry, a man who has probably smoked more weed than most: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=czf9nZFBmnw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=czf9nZFBmnw
- ameixaseca 5y agoAnything can be a trigger, including alcohol: "Researchers have mostly studied the effects of cannabis and nicotine on people with schizophrenia. But they’ve also found that other things that alter your nervous system and mood (called psychoactive substances), like alcohol, can trigger first-time psychosis." Source: https://www.webmd.com/schizophrenia/features/alcohol-schizophrenia-link https://www.webmd.com/schizophrenia/features/alcohol-schizop... IOW, if you have predisposition to schizophrenia (family history, previous psychotic episodes), you should avoid mind-altering substances. Edit: word
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThat might help. Other things can trigger it, like going away to college, or a breakup with your first girl/boy friend.
- Animats 5y agoThere have been other studies. Here's a summary.[1] From the current data, we can conclude that the tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) component of cannabis can be the main culprit causing psychosis and schizophrenia in the at-risk population. THC can also be the one exacerbating symptoms and causing an adverse prognosis in already diagnosed patients. Even though CBD shows therapeutic effects and THC opposing effects, the data is minimal and low safety and efficacy warrants more research. The relation between cannabis and schizophrenia needs further investigation. We need more case-control studies and clinical trials with a larger population to get conclusive data. So, something seems to be going on, but there's not enough data yet. Years from now, the cannabis industry may face the product liability problems the tobacco industry did in the past, and the vaping industry is facing now.[2] [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32839678/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32839678/ [2] https://www.cand.uscourts.gov/judges/orrick-william-h-who/in-re-juul-labs-inc-marketing-sales-practices-products-liability-litigation/ https://www.cand.uscourts.gov/judges/orrick-william-h-who/in...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- winrid 5y agoWhat about medicated people diagnosed with Schizophrenia that then start smoking?
- vmception 5y agoOne of my main goals is for real research to occur. People have been saying or alluding to any psychedelics triggering schizophrenia for a long time. Like, its almost dismissive and toxic, people want their psychedelics to be safe so bad that they'll tell people "you should have known that your were predisposed to schizophrenia before you took this, therefore your experience is invalid, its safe ya'll!" Instead of these binary approaches to advocate for legality or illegality, I would just like normal clinical trials done and side effects listed in tiny print at the bottom of the bottle. This shouldn't be that hard of an ask, many approved drugs have "you may get suicidal thoughts and also might randomly die without doing the suicide" as a side effect, which seems worse than schizophrenia and these aren't scheduled drugs at all! Just do the studies and let us know!
- jefftechentin 5y agoSeems like we are leaving the cultural moment that presented Marijuana as a glorious panacea which would open your third eye if only you let go of your fear. Our culture was so scared of the stuff before, maybe we needed to paint an unrealistically bright picture to find the courage to leave the cave. To the unfamiliar it can be a thrilling adventure, to others it can serve as inspiration. It feels like it has mental costs though. Being wary of regular recreational use seems warranted.
- slumpt_ 5y agoNo reason to be wary of recreational use. No more so than you might of caffeine. Not everything is for everyone and that’s 100% ok.
- jefftechentin 5y ago> No reason to be wary of recreational use. No more so than you might of caffeine You should be wary of caffeine use, especially if your culture does not have any rules about its use, or complete enough understanding about its effects. We like drugs because they work, but the problem is we do not know what they do over larger timescales or how to fit them into your life. Weed is a relative newbie in the average American's life and we would be silly to not respect the drug enough to be wary.
- slumpt_ 5y agoPeople have been using both for thousands of years. Feel free to be wary. Many of the rest of us will enjoy our lives otherwise without perpetuating unnecessary and by and large scientifically unfounded, culturally-based fears of reasonably innocuous substances. Beware the “Snoop Dogg pool party” indeed.
- dna_polymerase 5y agoDirect link to the journal: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abstract/2782160?resultClick=24 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abst...
- jbuhbjlnjbn 5y agoLast I read that an order of magnitude more outbreaks of latent schizophrenia occur with alcohol use, compared to marijuana use.
- octokatt 5y agoPrevalence of smoking tobacco is also dramatically higher among schizophrenic people [0]. Before marijuana use is demonized for causing schizophrenia, it would be worthwhile to more robustly prove these results. [0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19794359/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19794359/
- ipnon 5y agoNicotine modulating the hyperactive dopaminergic activity of schizophrenics I recall being one hypothesis for this remarkable connection. 90% of schizophrenics smoked tobacco compared to 20% of non-schizophrenics in 2006![0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia_and_tobacco_smoking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia_and_tobacco_smok...
- throw420420 5y agoI would take this with a grain of salt. Research on illegal substances is highly restricted. That said, a friend of mine developed a psychosis after using Marijuana while he was still a teenager. Although there had been cases of Psychosis in his family before, not Marijuana induced though. It stopped eventually but came back years after when he took other drugs as well combined with a very stressful life situation, things went downhill afterwards. That's already years ago, but my understanding that I got from reading articles about this topic at the time was that this activated some sort of latent psychosis. I also read about a proposal to introduce a "Cannabis driver's license" that could be made at a pharmacy. So people would be able to check before they take it. There are also people that feel positive effects of Marijuana, me included.
- theshadowknows 5y agoI smoked weed the first time when I was 15 or so. A buddy of mine bought some from a friend of a friend. And we continued to smoke mostly on weekends for years. I stopped right around college in 2007 or so. Then a year or so ago I smoked some legal weed from a dispensary. And that shit almost killed me. I was nauseated and sweating and I vomited repeatedly for like two hours. And I couldn’t control my thoughts. They got dark very quickly. Like voices in my head telling me to kill myself…it was fucking insane… So naturally a few months later I tried it again, assuming it was just something with that strain or whatever. And it happened again. And I’m not even talking like I smoked a whole joint. I smoked maybe four puffs from a bong. I know that’s not evidence of any kind. It’s just my reaction. And my wife smokes daily to help with the symptoms of medication she takes. She smokes fairly heavily and the worst thing that happens to her is she gets hungry. I don’t know what the difference is between “modern” weed and the grown-in-the-ditch North Carolina weed I smoked in my youth. But it is not the same thing.
- techrat 5y ago>I don’t know what the difference is between “modern” weed and the grown-in-the-ditch North Carolina weed I smoked in my youth. Several differences. You know if the street stuff was an indica, sativa or hybrid? Some people react much, much worse to specific strain types than others. I'm one of those. I can't smoke strong indicas or I basically have panic attacks. Modern strains can have upwards of FOUR+ TIMES the thc content... I've seen cheap strains in dispensaries that were above 30%. Old cheap street skunk was maybe 6 to 8% if you were lucky. You smoked like you smoked before, ignoring the differences in potency, so you gave yourself a much higher dose right off the bat... with no tolerance from being a regular smoker. Someone who isn't an alcoholic isn't going to be able to drink a bottle of Jack like a habitual drinker is.
- trutannus 5y ago> I don’t know what the difference is between “modern” weed and the grown-in-the-ditch North Carolina weed I smoked in my youth. But it is not the same thing. Doctors in Canada are well versed in this actually. The standing advice I have gotten from every doctor I've seen is to ensure some CBD content in the cannabis at all times to reduce the impact of the substance. That said, there's a push to have higher and higher concentrations of THC as a cost-saving measure, which is not generally considered a good thing.
- szundi 5y agoAnything that has an effect has side effects.
- mikkelam 5y agoNote that cannabis sold in the danish black market is of unknown quality. No one knows what strain they're getting even in terms of indica/sativa as well as THC/CBD mix. It is mostly illegally shipped from Marocco or Albania. Sometimes it is also dusted with synthetic cannabinoids. That said, I would love more research on the topic as it is a wild west right now.
- motohagiography 5y agoIf you want to see mental health problems, force people into social isolation for 18months, tell them strangers can kill them by not hiding their faces, food and surfaces are contaminated, there is conspiracy to eugenicize them encoded in history books and symbols, words don't mean what they think they do, truth is what you make it, their neighbours are part of a plot, reinforce the filter bubbles of the information they consume, elevate and exalt unstable personalities, debase the media of the culture they trusted, reveal that their electronics are spying on them, and wait for it - then give them access to cheap and plentiful THC concentrates on every corner. How do you think that's going to play out? It's a perfect storm. Some of my close friends are among what I call the professionally sane (they work in mental health) and they seem as susceptable to delusion and paranoia as anyone. I don't worry about being crazy anymore, as when you see what the bar is, I only need to be be less crazy than most of everyone else. 80th percentile is sufficient for most purposes. Post pandemic, mental health isn't something you manage or exercise, it's just a poker game. Like a fox. ;)
- wubbert 5y agowho would have thought that a mind-altering substance could permanently alter someone's mind.
- mcguire 5y agoOriginal paper: "Development Over Time of the Population-Attributable Risk Fraction for Cannabis Use Disorder in Schizophrenia in Denmark" (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abstract/2782160 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abst...) "Question Has the population-attributable risk fraction for cannabis use disorder in schizophrenia increased over time, as would be expected with increasing use and potency of cannabis? "Findings In this Danish nationwide, register-based cohort study, the population-attributable risk fraction for cannabis use disorder in schizophrenia increased from approximately 2% in the period to 1995 to approximately 6% to 8% since 2010. "Meaning These findings may indicate that cannabis use disorders are associated with an increase in the proportion of cases of schizophrenia. "* The results from these longitudinal analyses show the proportion of cases of schizophrenia associated with cannabis use disorder has increased 3- to 4-fold during the past 2 decades, which is expected given previously described increases in the use and potency of cannabis. This finding has important ramifications regarding legalization and control of use of cannabis.*"
- moate 5y agoTl;dr- People who have Schizophrenia are more frequently found to also have marijuana use disorder than before. Correlation. This is not been proven causal (which, btw why is it never phrased such that “people inclined towards schizophrenia are more inclined to abuse drugs” which seems like a pretty obvious line to me but I just work in medical publishing, I’m not the actual doctor). Remember everyone: someone is funding all research, often times they have an agenda and a good press agent when they get some results they like. That said, this piece very specifically says “we can’t conclude a causal relationship, we need further research” (or, more specifically, funding for our research)
- Sunspark 5y agoI think part of the problem is that people are using the wrong stuff. My personal preference is for milder balanced strains that are about 50% CBD, or CBD-only strains. The THC-only strains tend to have been bred to be strong and if you are not careful, many will trigger anxiety etc. CBD modulates or stops this effect. Often you can repair a problematic THC-only strain by mixing it 1:1 or 1:2 with CBD. If you live in a legal jurisdiction, please do try a balanced and/or cbd-only strain if you are someone who has had problems with anxiety from many thc-only strains.
- bakul 5y agoCould it be that schizophrenics are more likely to partake marijuana? Since it is a mental disorder and tends to run in families, the underlying genetics may predispose such people to marijuana, or marijuana may have a stronger effect on such people. That is, a strong correlation should result in a deeper look at this connection rather than directly influence marijuana legalization.
- tooktomuch 5y agoLong time lurker here. Not sure if this helps the discussion but have actual first hand experience with this. I was a heavy user of marijuana (extremely heavy I would say) from my late 20s to my early 30s. One day in those 30s (combined with significant physical effort that day and heat) smoking my umpteenth spliff of the day led to a complete blackout on a public sidewalk. From that point I began experiencing persistent auditory hallucinations and was eventually diagnosed as schizoaffective. I had no prior expression of schizophrenia and no family history that I am aware of (though there are clearly other family members with some psychological disorders). It is roughly 4 years since the last time I touched marijuana and the auditory hallucinations persist. Still in favor of legalization, but, as with overconsumption of practically anything, it should probably come with clear awareness of the risks involved.
- throwaway8558 5y agoUsing a throwaway account for this. It is hard to write this because of the bad memories it brings back but I hope my experience can help you without you having actually experience it. About 1 in 200 people have experienced schizophrenia at least once in their life so plausibly 1 in 200 comments you read on HN is by someone who has experienced it. My comments is one of those comments. I was in gifted classes in high-school, got a bachelors degree in college, earn a middle-class salary, and saved up enough to buy a home. Stimulant medication helped turn my ADHD from a handicap to an asset. It helped me stay focused and achieve that. I’ve found that every single time I smoke marijuana there is a synergistic effect with the ADHD stimulant medication that is left in my system and I get the effects of Schizophrenia. It might just be serotonin syndrome but that’s just as bad. I don’t have any family history of schizophrenia whatsoever but people with ADHD are 5x more likely to develop schizophrenia. However, if it is non-reoccurring, according to the DSM-IV, it doesn’t yet count as schizophrenia. I think my episode was triggered by all of the following things combined: “marijuana, stimulant medication synergy, fear of Covid-19 anarchy in the streets (hey! It was a valid fear for a little while!), drinking alcohol too frequently reduced the logic and judgement side of my brain, seeing the scary side of Instagram Reels shows when it knows you’re behind a VPN, not getting enough sleep due to heavy work deadlines, the scare mail I was received about various deaths, the news reports of all of the deaths in news, and a darn drone that hovered over my house for too long at the wrong time. Fortunately there is good medication that knocks the schizophrenia out. Highly effective stuff. Both Olanzapine and Quetiapine Fumarate work excellent at stopping the schizophrenia in it’s tracks and getting your sleep back on track. However I was resistant at first to take medication or trust advice. I had experienced a total breakdown of trust in the world. The fear side of my brain had totally hijacked and overrode the logic side of my brain. My amygdala overrode my frontal cortex and I was focused on survival. I didn’t know what paranoia was legitimate and what was overblown. For one, which I mention with a heavy sigh, I didn’t know if my loved ones were agents that just looked like my friends.. I philosophize that paranoid schizophrenia is caused by fear while catatonic schizophrenia is caused by both fear and a lack of trust. When I questioned my two loved ones independently and their stories matched up, I thought that the odds I was the crazy person was high. I was then willing to talk to a general practitioner and a psychiatrist and they gave me those prescriptions I mentioned above. Just tell them you that you’ve been paranoid, want to be lightly tranquilized, and want to catch up on your sleep. I’m happy to say I have not had any relapses into schizophrenia since then! But I had to distanced myself away from my friends that smoked marijuana to do that because it influenced me to smoke too. I couldn’t do that though until I had made new friends in person first which hasn’t been easy… and still isn’t easy. My primary goal for 2021 is to make more close friends.
- leroy_masochist 5y agoNo discussion on this thread yet of the role of AKT1 gene, which I find surprising after 300 comments. If you have a C/C pair at AKT1, your risk of developing schizophrenia jumps from slightly-below-average if you don't smoke marijuana, to over 7x average if you smoke every day [0]. If you've done 23andMe, you can check your own genotype for this risk. [0]: https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/marijuana/there-link-between-marijuana-use-psychiatric-disorders https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/mari...
- solutron 5y agoWhatever underlying mental state you have running in the background will come to surface when you use psychedelics. Marijuana is a mild psychedelic. Many people seem to be under the impression we should live free from scary thoughts, dark thoughts, things that make us worry or anxious. This is all part of the human condition though and as long as these states are transitory and lead to positive change they're not "bad". Recognize there's a time and place for everything. If bringing these things to the surface helps you grow and deal with things in your life, even if it's scary, good. If not, then stop ingesting / smoking it. Really simple. People seem to want things to be good or bad when in fact the state of isness really just is. It's not good or bad. It just is. What you make of it, how you live your life is what matters. If you smoke weed and it helps your back pain, or if it helps you think about your feelings and deal with something you've been putting off, that can be "good". If you smoke it and have heart palpitations and freak out about taxes that can be "bad" but the weed hasn't changed, it's just brought something to the surface. Our minds are complicated. Especially now, in a culture where we're overloaded with information, entertainment, manufactured outrage, and expectations about what we should or shouldn't be, all compared to thousands of other things. How can anyone, smoking weed or not, expect to be sane or live a simple life that doesn't lead to mental health problems?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quickthrowman 5y agoI don’t buy it. In 2006, tobacco smoking rates among schizophrenics was 90% vs 20% of non-schizophrenics. [0] Now, does tobacco cause schizophrenia or do schizophrenics seek out tobacco? Now, s/tobacco/marijuana/g for the above sentence. [0] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1744-6163.2006.00085.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1744-6163.2006...
- grouphugs 5y agocnn is not here to tell the truth, never has been, never will be. two of their reporters just got paid hundreds of millions of nazibuxxx to literally keep spilling bullshit on cnn. bye jeff bezos. some idiots figured out that people who deal with schizophrenia also smoke pot. there's nothing else in that article. the rest of this is just regular abrahamic nazi propaganda, gas-lighting, attrition, and other harmful things. even in this thread, these pompous egotistical white supremacist clowns show just how little they care and just how little they know. the levels of gas-lighting in this thread is a type of culture hacker news promotes. even worse than the microaggression and targeting, they're making it more difficult for people who actually have to deal with this disorder to find treatment, help, and acceptance in this fascist society which already makes it too difficult. even worse, some of these dipshits are lying about their own annecdotes and the circumstances surrounding them because they're ashamed and guilty for what they've done. fuck off
- john579 5y agoBill Clinton said it best, "But I didn't exhale!"
- senectus1 5y agoNo shit... anyone I know thats a heavy pot smoker tends to become unstable....
- cirrus3 5y agoThere is nothing here yet. They literally said: > Many researchers hypothesize that cannabis use may be a "component cause," which interacts with other risk factors, to cause the condition.
- rkk3 5y agoSchizophrenia generally manifests in your 20's, so I wish this article broke out age because I think the causal link is more obvious (vs soothing tendency) when we are talking about the developmental effects of drug use on children.
- JimTheMan 5y agoI recall that there is a specific biochemical pathway that is distinct in people that makes them paranoid when they partake in marijuana. Perhaps if a test for this gene was widely available, the negative effects of the drug could be greatly limited in the community.
- tenfourwookie 5y agoSchizophrenia is a bucket diagnosis that a large number of mentally ill people are placed into because other diagnoses do not fit or do not fit completely. Once psychiatry doesn't know what's wrong with you, and your symptoms have a certain severity, you get diagnosed with schizophrenia. This link between marijuana use and schizophrenia will be tenuous at best. Look deeper (into an article published on the well-respected academic journal that is CNN) (a intern probably wrote your article) and you'll find nothing but unscientific hogwash, irrelevant sample sizes, questionable procedure, and just about everything else you usually find that isn't helpful when the subject being discussed is repleat with cultural bias instead of fact. In short, this is pseudoscientific poppycock written and published to sell you ads.
- mcdramamean 5y agoIf you look at it from a cultural perspective, many African American boys/men in extremely dangerous and poor areas use marijuana as a way to NOT develop mental issues. Considering how little mental help or even how little routine healthcare these men/boys receive, it makes sense to find SOMETHING to cope. Dependence on alcohol has clear bad-examples of the "wino", or street drunk. Same with the use of crack cocaine (the "crack" head/ the "fiend"). So many black men smoke lots of marijuana, but don't drink and don't do any other drugs. Also, the environments they need to navigate requires understanding tattoos, colors, signs and tons of other subtle social cues in order to not become a target or deemed to be weak. There may be an under-reporting of instances of schizophrenia, but on a whole these brothers aren't showing signs of schizophrenia due to over use of marijuana. And really, our current laws are just used to arrest someone, who might be an overall good person, besides the social stigma of "weed smoker". I really do beg anyone who is conservative on this issue due to the POSSIBILITY of someone developing schizophrenia, to maybe consider this as magnitudes less harmful than the use of marijuana policy to target black men; specifically black boys; and putting them in jail and ruining their future. You have to understand the environments they are coming from; so just saying "stay off the dope" is very callous and uninformed. Your life experience isn't the template for everyone. I know this is a touchy topic on HN, but I really do hope we are able to open our circle of trust to people we wouldn't normally think about.