21 ms·
A Twitter thread sparked a lawsuit against Nieman Lab’s founder
- underseacables 5y agoWhat someone does legally, without harming or threatening anyone else, in their private life outside of their job, should have little to zero impact on their ability to maintain employment. I hope her lawsuit is very successful. She was clearly targeted, ostracized, and fired for speaking her mind. I don’t agree with her statement, but academia is poisoning free speech under the guise of righteousness.
- forgingahead 5y agoLike all other religious extremists, their worldview is that heretics and non-believers are not just sinning, they are condemned to an eternity of hellish suffering. It's ironic that supposedly liberal arts universities and "4th estate" journalists are the newest converts to this type of extremism.
- warent 5y agoI would agree if she didn't exhibit racism. Keeping her in a workplace after learning about that would be sending a signal that they care little about how hostile the workplace is.
- mikeyouse 5y agoRight - if she just said dumb nonsense, the school wouldn't have fired her. She was racist against a protected class under Federal employment law, who she certainly interacts with -- how could they possibly keep her on staff? And suing the website for exposing your racism? Why would she think she has any right to anonymity while spewing trash on someone else's platform?
- cryptoz 5y agoAccording to the linked article, her speech was definitely threatening harm to specific groups of people, not at all what you describe in your first sentence.
- adolph 5y agoTemple’s own student news site backed Viola’s right to say what she thought: “We don’t believe she should be removed for her alleged comments, although we condemn them.” And Benton’s actions seemed at odds with Disqus’s own policies, which state that “user information is for moderation purposes only” and adds that “distribution of personal identifiable information is prohibited.”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- afavour 5y agoBut her lawsuit is against the Neiman Lab, not her employer, so it wouldn’t have any bearing on what you’re saying? If anything it feels kind of telling that she’s suing the organisation that named her instead of the organisation that fired her. IMO at the very least the case is a lot more nuanced than you're making it out to be. For example: the fired professor was propagating conspiracy theories about Seth Rich. From the free speech angle, sure, she's free to say whatever she wants. But if you're a journalism professor and you aren't able to tell when something being propagated in the media is a baseless conspiracy theory, what does that say about your ability at your job? And as a teacher? It is not flat out wrong to fire someone for engaging in actions that cast doubt on their professionalism. At the very least it's open for debate. I think there's an interesting debate to be had over her having done this anonymously: if she separated it from her professional persona is she less culpable in a professional sense? Personally I'd still argue no, but I think this is why she's targeting the Lab and not her employer: it's a lot easier to argue that unmasking her (thus combining her anonymous and professional identities) was wrong than to argue that firing her was wrong. It seems their argument is going to be centered around one particular post expressing an anti-Muslim sentiment. Benton said she wrote it, she said she did not, thus he defamed her. All the posts were made under the same Disqus account so she might have a hill to climb in proving that it wasn't her. I'm very far from a lawyer but this feels like a case designed to set the professor up as a cause célèbre on the right rather than one designed to win.
- nostromo 5y agoShe's suing Nieman Lab because she claimed they lied about what she actually said. Yes, I'm sure she would love to sue the university too. However she likely doesn't have a case there. I hope she wins the lawsuit because they sloppily doxxed her and broke the terms of service of Disqus in doing so. > Viola acknowledged writing most of the posts. But she denied being behind the anti-Muslim screed. That was critical to Sorokin’s decision to allow the libel and defamation part of Viola’s suit to proceed. The former professor “has plausibly alleged that Benton may have been negligent in his failure to verify that she was the author,” the judge wrote. He also took note of how Benton managed to discover and reveal her identity. Viola wrote her comments “based on the promise that her user information would be used for ‘moderation purposes only,’ which was violated when Benton posted her information on Twitter,” Sorokin wrote.
- duxup 5y agoGenerally, I think it depends on WHAT they say. If someone says they don't trust / like people of a particular race, and they're in a position where they are expected to work with those folks. That certainly has something to do with their job. That's not threatening or violent, but as an employer I don't think you can ignore it / tell everyone at that workplace "well she didn't say it here so guess you have to ignore it...". Ultimately almost every job involves working with people, and you don't get to pick and choose who that is.
- Swizec 5y ago> Generally, I think it depends on WHAT they say. This argument used to be used to fire gay people from engineering jobs. Because being gay was obviously very bad and you can’t possibly have good judgement if you’re gay. Being gay and racist have obviously different implications on your workplace behavior and biases. The issue is that precedent is precedenty. If we normalize firing people for their personal life issues, where do we stop?
- cortesoft 5y agoYou quoted someone saying it depends on WHAT they say, then posted an example of someone being fired for who they are. That isn't the same.
- duxup 5y agoI'm not sure what you mean, actually focusing on what someone said isn't an argument... it's a thing they actually said.
- dandellion 5y agoI don't agree with him, but his post seems pretty straightforward and easy to understand. You're reasoning that we should fire people based on WHAT they say, that's an argument you're making about how to go about firing people.
- 5y ago
- renewiltord 5y agoWell, obviously the disagreement in this whole space seems to be around what “harming or threatening anyone else” means. Some people, for instance, would find (making up a hypothetical) it “harming” if a large strong person spent spare time drawing incredibly graphic representations of smaller weaker coworkers being sexually assaulted by him. Others believe that no harm has been caused. Hopefully, in that situation you can see both sides of the argument. Now you can weaken that to whether referring to Muslims as people who should be deported is similarly a point where people can disagree. For my part, I believe in the freedom and liberty. No one has the right to have their stuff bought by someone. Temple doesn’t have the right to have students go to them. If they feel like they have to fire people in order to appeal to people, they should be permitted to. If they feel like they would rather lose customers than professors, that’s fine too. Unlike California, which believes that political opinion should be a protected class, I prefer the federal system.
- csours 5y ago> but academia is poisoning free speech under the guise of righteousness. No. "Free speech" is not a get out of jail free card. I think there may some narrow grounds for a lawsuit here, but it's not about free speech, it's about piercing pseudo-anonymity.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe lawsuit is purely a claim that the doxxing false-positived some posts that didn't originate from the doxxed individual. The suit itself isn't purporting to make any claims about the ethical or legal dimensions of using the information available to find someone in the way it was used, only that statements were attributed which the plaintiff did not make.
- jasonlotito 5y ago> What someone does legally, without harming or threatening anyone else, in their private life outside of their job, should have little to zero impact on their ability to maintain employment. Except this has always been the case. What you do outside your work has always affected your ability to maintain employment. The difference is that now those who benefited from this in the past are now suffering from it. > She was clearly targeted, ostracized, and fired for speaking her mind. No, this is literally not what happened. I can point to numerous cases of people speaking their mind without suffering from repercussions. Pretending this was about someone "speaking their mind" ignores the reality and nuances of what is actually happening.
- colechristensen 5y agoI think it highly depends on the content and relation to the profession. You indeed can post things outside of a professional setting which demonstrate that you aren't appropriate for your job. A journalism professor commenting on the news isn't exactly unrelated activity. This is indeed close to the edge of what would be appropriate but it would seem that what she said went beyond opinion and perspective and well into a questionable relationship with the truth and hate speech. A professor should be held to a high standard of rationality and posting things online, even anonymously, should be able to be taken into consideration.
- mc32 5y agoWe’ve had journalists claim that all journalism is (should be) activism --that in itself is an oxymoron. but that's "journalism" in the States, today. So we have journalists who see it in their purview to frame things to fit their objectives as they envision them. We also had someone at the NYT who said what is in this age called hate speech against a majority “color” but wasn’t fired for those comments. So it’s indeed one sided.
- mc32 5y agoAlso, it’s been known that people with normal accounts also have alternate provocateur social media counts where they gauge reaction to what they say. Sometimes they egg their own accounts for sympathy, etc. Imagine if we discovered all those accounts…
- TOMDM 5y agoLets be explicit about what happened here. A) A journalist brought light to the comments made by a journalism professor. B) Said journalism professor's employer chose to fire her for those comments. Now, I think there is little room for taking issue with point A. If we're at the point where Journalists can't discuss the views of people in their own space, I have very little hope for a future environment of open and honest discourse. On point B, I think there are many views people can hold which justify firing someone. The only question is where you draw the line. If an employee was actively spreading hateful messaging concerning a coworker in their own time, away from work, I think most people would agree firing that person is an acceptable course of action (I understand that wasn't the case here). I also think there are a great number of people that believe pushing hateful discourse, even on your own time means that you are unfit for the workplace given that those views aren't conducive to a healthy work environment. In this case they were pushing some rather racist discourse. They said in response to an article about Muslims "Scum. Deport them. They hate us. Get rid of them." Obviously the point where you draw the line on acceptable discourse is in degrees, with active harrassment/hate of coworkers on one end, active hate towards a general group in the middle, and some kinds of conspiracism on the other. Where you draw the line is open for discussion, but lets not pretend it's not acceptable to have a line at all. EDIT: Other people are pointing out that Joshua doxxed Francesca using priveleged information from their Disqus platform. While I think that's condemnable, I find it largely immaterial to how Francesca's employer chooses how to react.
- mikeyouse 5y agoI'd argue that someone who talks like that needs to be fired from their position. She was a professor at a State owned college, there are certainly muslim students, professors and staff there. What kind of horrible hostile work environment would you be engendering if you let someone like that stay on staff?
- fennecfoxen 5y agoShe is a professor at a state college. The state is obligated to follow the law, including the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, declaring that "Congress shall make now law... abridging the freedom of speech." Yes, this is incorporated against the states. Yes, it applies to state-run colleges. The firing MAY be legal if this speech is "disruptive" to the university or "subversive" of their goals; if so, the firing must satisfy a balancing test as to whether: • the employee's speech addresses a matter of public concern. • their free-speech interests outweigh their employer’s efficiency interests. The comments do seem to be on a matter of public concern, which is typically interpreted quite broadly. The criteria used to assess these efficiency interests include whether the speech: • Impairs discipline or harmony among co-workers. • Has a detrimental impact on close working relationships for which personal loyalty and confidence are necessary • Interferes with the normal operation of the employer’s business. Any litigation over this firing would focus on whether these are real factors that would disrupt teaching, or whether the university officials are just punishing her for her politics. The specific tweets are presumably not directed against any individuals who are at the college, and do not involve the college's normal operations. This does undermine the case somewhat.
- Hermitian909 5y agoI'm sympathetic to this point of view, but the effect of social media is that people are effectively speaking into a bullhorn for the whole world to hear. Once they've done so it's hard to keep that out of work. Let's say someone, call them Frank, expresses on twitter that he thinks women aren't fit for work outside the home and his coworkers discover he said this. At the very least, Frank's female coworkers will almost certainly not feel comfortable working with him anymore knowing his opinions. They're unlikely to believe he respects them, and since they don't believe that they likely won't want to collaborate with him. If Frank's work requires collaboration (as most does), he's now hamstrung himself at work. From the employer's perspective: Frank is now less effective at work. Frank's coworkers who are uncomfortable may try to leave teams Frank is on, or avoid work that might force them to collaborate with Frank. The result is organizational chaos and Frank becomes a drag on the company. The natural response here, I think, is to let Frank go. It's hard to avoid it because there aren't just social pressures to fire him, but economic ones. The above isn't a thought experiment, I've watched more than one version of the above happen. I just don't really see how this separation can be maintained.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RememberTheFtr 5y agoThis is maybe a fallacy since very few men actually think women shouldn’t work outside the house. A lot of men (and women) think women would be happier in the home than working. There’s also psychological and sexual dynamics in play with submissiveness vs assertiveness required to be competitive. And that our culture of 2 income households and every woman wants to be in STEM to build ad products is a flawed concept. We want all genders to be technically competent but we want a resilient, self sufficient world, that doesn’t have to ‘capitalize’ on every human ambition/potential. Except we live in a world where me saying that makes me sexist. And worthy of doxxing.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoYou’re completely missing his point. Think in generalities, the specifics of his example.
- devwastaken 5y ago"One truthseeker comment that Benton found, responding to a 2017 Gateway Pundit piece about a Muslim protest at Trump Tower, was especially abhorrent: “Scum. Deport them. They hate us. Get rid of them.” Calling an ethnicity of people "scum" and to "deport" them is harmful behavior. Every time something like this comes up the actual matter gets downplayed as if it were "just a comment". When this individual quite literally is being 100% racist with intent to cause harm. Perhaps were all too young to remember what happens when people like that group together.
- underseacables 5y agoWhich she denies saying. In fact the article goes on to state that the journalist never actually verified or even asked her if she made that statement. Just assumed.
- TOMDM 5y agoAre you implying that if it were verified that she made that comment that you would change your mind about her firing?
- underseacables 5y agoGood question. I think yes, if you disparage publicly a persons race or religion, that would be justification for termination from a job. I would put that under hate speech, and it would apply equally to everyone. Here what troubles me is that she denies it, and there’s no proof that she said it, but she’s being made to be accountable for it. With the depositions and everything I’m sure that she is going to be asked did you write this, and she will be required to answer under oath. I think that will be a very telling moment and all of this. The Internet makes it far too easy to attribute things to people. I could create an account on a multitude of services call “TOMDM” Top of your bio, and say some truly horrible things. Your job or employer comes to you and says why would you say these things and you say hey that wasn’t me, someone took a name that I was using on another service. Well I’m sorry, we have to let you go. Now it’s up to you to pursue civil litigation probably in order to identify the person who was actually using that handle, so you could then go back to your former employee and say your termination of me was unjustified. That’s what I’m seeing here, a claim without proof Which has led to someone’s loss of employment. I’m bothered by that and I think we all should be.
- threatofrain 5y agoA professor is someone who speaks with the authority of their associated institution, whether they or the institution wants it that way. In that respect, a professor can drain the credibility of an institution faster than they can repair it, as is typically the case with credibility anywhere. And in this case, then-professor Francesca Viola logged in with her official institutional email. Speaking her mind was the not the issue. The issue is draining the credibility of the institution. The academic institution she hails from, Temple University, has their own interests to watch out for, she did not sue them.
- yumraj 5y ago> in their private life outside of their job Sure, I'll agree if the comments were stated in a private setting and limited to a group which knew each other. Unfortunately this is not that. This is analogous to a person standing in the middle of a market square with a megaphone and a hood over them to hide their identity. Given that, it is only natural for the people who are opposed to the person's views to want to know who that person is in case that is a person who they interact in real-life and might be in a position of influence. This applies to any kind of opinion and not just right leaning. BTW, if we want to allow them to have their free speech, doesn't free speech protect the other side too, Neiman Lab in this case? If the opinions expressed by the person deserve protection, the right of others to investigate and present their findings should also be preserved.
- jtbayly 5y agoInvestigate? He wasn't investigating. He was canceling somebody who criticized him. In violation of his own promises both to Disqus and to the woman whose job he destroyed.
- jlarocco 5y agoIt's a little more complicated than that, though. The underlying issue for the university is whether she can effectively teach Muslim students when she thinks they're "scum" who should be deported. And, will Muslim students be comfortable signing up for her class now, or has she effectively steered them away with her racism? Regardless of how it came to their attention, the university undoutedly has some kind of zero-tolerance policy against racism. Generally I agree with your sentiment, but I think this case squeezes into that small "little to zero" impact section.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoShe is not pursuing a lawsuit against the university itself (at least at this point) for exactly the reason you point out here - a university cannot reasonably trust someone with those views to treat Muslim students fairly.
- pwdisswordfish8 5y ago> for exactly the reason Do you have insider information about the case, or is this your synthesis? The former strikes me as being unlikely, because you seem to have missed that the cornerstone of the suit is the claim that she's not actually the one responsible for the anti-Muslim comment, which is what makes this defamation.
- ceejayoz 5y ago"Someone hacked my account to post that one comment that's in line with the other sorts of comments I've been posting for years... and they managed to use my IP address" is gonna have an uphill battle for credibility in court.
- munk-a 5y agoIt certainly will, but she's got every right to pursue it in court because sometimes that does happen.
- 5y ago
- N1H1L 5y ago> She was clearly targeted, ostracized, and fired for speaking her mind. I don’t agree with her statement, but academia is poisoning free speech under the guise of righteousness. Big claims, iff true.
- fatbird 5y agoThere's a large body of established case law that organizations do not have to bear the consequences of their employee's private lives, or continue their association with an individual when that association is harmful to the organization. You're proposing an appealing ideal, but it's already contrary to a lot of existing decisions on the first amendment and balancing the competing rights of the different parties. In other words, you're stripping the rights of some to enhance the rights of others, which is rarely intended, but still something that has to be recognized.
- 3637383 5y agoI'll never understand how people can respect academia. It's a thoroughly shitty environment for people who at best got gaslighted into not valuing their time. The only reason the hard sciences are more credible than the soft sciences or the humanities is because the hard sciences are forced to tackle reality in a manner where it can tell them they're wrong without room for simply inventing a new critical framework and attacking the topic instead of the question.
- Causality1 5y agoHow is any of it defamation, though? Defamation is the telling of lies about someone in order to damage their reputation. If anything, Nieman violated laws against doxxing.
- getlawgdon 5y agoI would say that aggressively disseminating hate speech and generally forwarding crazy conspiracy theories and racism qualifies as "harming and threatening" others.
- ciupicri 5y agoWhat about the freedom to hire/fire whomever you want to?
- lhorie 5y agoFTA: > In her suit, Viola acknowledged writing most of the posts I'm as pro-free-speech as the next person, but looking at the evidence[0] I frankly don't understand on what leg Viola is hoping to stand. If I understand this right, she's claiming she is the person behind the truthseeker username on Gateway Pundit, but that she didn't write a specific comment that was entered into evidence as being written by truthseeker? How does that not scream lying to evade responsibility? Also, IMHO, the repercussions on her job are not really relevant to the suit. Had Benton outed her for spamming pictures of unicorns, her job would've been just fine. It's her own alleged content that got her into hot water with her employer. Benton has no control over her employer's actions. [0] https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/59725194/8/4/viola-v-benton/ https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/59725194/8/4/viola-v-be... (page 5)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bastardoperator 5y agoShe can't maintain employment because she can't be taken seriously anymore. She is not a victim, she ruined her own reputation through her own actions and words. This literally has nothing to do with free speech which is why she isn't making the claim.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoShe did harm and admitted as much. She’s being petty because she got let go. She has said that she made no anti Semitic comments against Muslims and that’s what the case is about.
- KittenInABox 5y agoI don't think this lawsuit will go anywhere. The lawsuit is a defamation lawsuit, which is notoriously difficult to prove, as you have to prove that the statements were knowingly false (not made as an opinion) and made with purpose to damage you. In this case, from what I can see, the claims were largely true. You can't successfully sue for defamation of statements that are just true. Then, even if there are claims that aren't true, you have to prove the untrue statement wasn't an opinion and that it was made with the intent to say an untrue thing as if were fact in order to damage you. EDIT: A poster below pointed out that you to make claims statements that you knew were false; there is also standing if you didn't know they were false but you didn't confirm if they were true in a manner deemed as "reckless" by the court. I believe this is a lesser burden than I described above, but still a very high bar.
- evgen 5y agoIt is interesting how much conservatives suddenly care about making sure that their speech should suffer no consequences after spending decades oppressing anyone who dares step out of line with similar loss of job, rank, and income. In the 50s you would be attacked for any deviation from anti-communist orthodoxy, in the 60s for deviation from racial orthodoxy, and in the 80s for daring to question sexual orthodoxy. I would probably care more about their claims and complaints if they were not so transparent about the fact that their real complaint is that people who they look down on are now in a position to judge and ostracize them.
- ceejayoz 5y agoYou don't have to go back to the 50s-80s. Colin Kaepernick's situation reveals the hypocrisy, just a couple years ago.
- encryptluks2 5y agoIt goes both ways. While I agree that conservatives appear to be hypocritical, I also think Democrats are equally as guilty. I really see both parties as two sides of the same coin.
- joreilly 5y ago
- ceejayoz 5y ago> And Benton’s actions seemed at odds with Disqus’s own policies, which state that “user information is for moderation purposes only” and adds that “distribution of personal identifiable information is prohibited.” I can't access the link, but it sounds like that's Disqus's policy. It's not necessarily Nieman Lab's. Proving this was libel or defamation seems like an uphill battle, given they admit ownership of the commenting account.
- user982 5y agoShe was a journalism professor who wrote that "[Hannity] is absolutely right about this Seth Rich thing…. The DNC had him killed." That seems fairly disqualifying for the job.
- Leparamour 5y ago>That seems fairly disqualifying for the job. Why? Wrongthink?
- ceejayoz 5y agoAn inability to evaluate sources seems like an issue for someone teaching, at least in part, how to do that.
- xadhominemx 5y agoYes, a university has good reason to believe their journalism instructor who believes obvious lies from known liars is bad at their job
- teachrdan 5y agoAs a journalism professor, you could argue that she has to be able to identify high and low quality journalism to be effective at her job. If she thinks that Fox News adequately researched the Seth Rich story and accurately determined that he was murdered by agents of Hilary Clinton, she probably does not know what quality journalism is, and is therefore unable to perform her duties as a journalism instructor.
- asciident 5y agoThat seems like a dangerous line of thought. Imagine a software engineer (maybe one who writes code for airplanes or medical equipment) writes some sloppy code late one night and puts it on their open source github, and the commit log is "this code rocks." You could make the same argument that As a software engineer, you have to be able to identify and write high quality software to be effective at your job. So should your employer fire you for writing this code outside of your regular job duties? What about if a friend shows you their code, and you say "that looks good" but it turns out that this code is vulnerable to a key security issue? Should you get fired from your security job? I think we'd agree not, and more broadly, that making a statement or doing a task related to your job but outside of your job's responsibilities should not be sufficient to fire you from your job. Especially when it's clear you are not representing your employer, by using pseudonym.
- logronoide 5y agoThe craziest part of this story is the fact that the Nieman Foundation purpose is: “to promote and elevate the standards of journalism in the United States and educate persons deemed specially qualified for journalism." But basically they ignored the basics of journalism not verifying the sources. Nice.
- colinmhayes 5y agoshe admitted to writing most of the comments.
- logronoide 5y agoIt’s really scary how people assume anybody’s privacy can be exposed without consequences. No, it can’t. In a full democracy only a judge can ask for it. Even journalists have to be extremely cautious before exposing the identity of anybody, and this is a perfect example. They never contacted her to verify she was the person behind the email and the person that wrote comments in social media. They assumed it was her, but they did not verify it. Even a high school journalist knows this is the first rule to learn: if you assume = ass for you and me.
- colinmhayes 5y agoCouldn't disagree more. There is no right to anonymity, and for good reason. That's how you get people spouting about muslims being scum who all deserve to be deported. Francesca got exactly what she deserved.
- logronoide 5y agoThat is fascism. Everybody deserves the same rights, no matter what they think. If you think she is promoting a speech of hate, go to the court and try prove it.
- colinmhayes 5y ago
- croes 5y agoDidn't Temple university ignored her right of freedom speech by firing her for her comments? Nieman lab's ignored her right of anonymous freedom of speech, wait that right doesn't exist.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt's a private institution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_System_of_Higher_Education; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_System_of_Higher_... "Legally, the universities remain separate and private entities, operating under their own charters, governed by independent boards of trustees, and with assets under their own ownership and control, thereby retaining much of the freedom and individuality of private institutions, both administratively and academically." There is no "right of freedom speech" there. They're not a government actor to which the First Amendment applies. (Even if you work for the government, you can be fired for telling your boss to fuck off, or putting up "Muslims are evil" comics on your cubicle wall. It's not an unlimited right even there; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garcetti_v._Ceballos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garcetti_v._Ceballos and https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1608/pickering-connick-test https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1608/pickering-... apply.)
- croes 5y agoSo there is no freedom for anyone dependent on their wages. Doesn't sound like a freedom at all.
- TOMDM 5y agoYour employer doesn't hire you to promote your freedoms. They hire you to serve a purpose. For private enterprise that's to make money. If you want freedom in the workplace, then that exists in the form of democratic workplaces, like worker co-ops. Joining or starting one is certainly possible if that's something you value.
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoEmployment with this specific organization isn't a right, it's a contract between two parties. She's free to associate with employers who will take her and her racist views.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- amadeuspagel 5y agoI can't comment on the legal issue, but it seems to me that the sites where she made the comments that got her fired deserve a big part of the blame for using disqus. If you want to have a forum where people can speak freely, you should make it easy and natural for people to have separate identities.
- adolph 5y agoBottom line: doxing is doxing no matter who does it. It isn’t about “rights” but about the right way to live. Pseudonymous posting may have been that lady’s cry for help that she couldn’t say elsewhere. As it stands Benton just put another brick in the wall. Remember this guy? https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/01/us/carson-king-hospital-fundraiser-ends-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/01/us/carson-king-hospital-fundr...
- colinmhayes 5y agoMaybe the right way to live is to not spread hatred and laughably false conspiracies? Maybe the right way to live is to call out those that do. Peer pressure is an incredibly powerful force, and if she wrote that comment about muslims the educational environment at Temple is better now that she's gone. Even if she didn't, I believe that most journalism students would not want to be taught by someone who can not tell fact from fiction.
- colpabar 5y ago> Temple’s own student news site backed Viola’s right to say what she thought: “We don’t believe she should be removed for her alleged comments, although we condemn them.” To be fair, I don't know how representative the student news site is of journalism students. But I also don't really think you can make a "right way to live" argument for someone who admitted to and apologized for wrongdoing.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> But I also don't really think you can make a "right way to live" argument for someone who admitted to and apologized for wrongdoing. Of course I can. Just because he apologized doesn't mean he was wrong.
- colpabar 5y agoIf you really think it's ok for someone to abuse privileged access on a supposed "anonymous" commenting platform to dox someone because they didn't like their comments, then I don't think our discussion is going anywhere. edit: commenting platform of a _journalism_ organization! Journalists should know better than _anyone_ how important anonymous communication is. If you want to argue that he was just doing what he thought was right, fine. But I think that they should update their organization's website to include something along the lines of "we think journalism is important, unless we disagree with what you're saying."
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/rFLbp https://archive.is/rFLbp
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- filmgirlcw 5y agoI’m conflicted here. On the one hand, I’m not in favor of contacting a person’s employer because you don’t like their comments. Plenty of people have sent me terrible emails over the years from their work emails and I have never even considered emailing their bosses. On the other hand, she used her Temple email for the Disqus account and used it to comment on a different university’s journalism lab website, while openly admitting to being a journalism professor. We can question whether it was ethical for Benton to reveal who she was on Twitter (tho I would hardly call this “doxxing” as he didn’t reveal her phone number or address), especially without reaching out for comment first, but I don’t see anything illegal about it. The fact that she is suing Nieman and not Temple makes it clear she has little basis for anything, in my opinion. She was an assistant professor and almost certainly didn’t have tenure (or else she wouldn’t have been fired) and was, given the amount of time she had been at Temple, probably never even going to approach getting tenure. She used her work email to register for a pseudonymous account; there should be no expectation of that email address being private to the site owners or administrators. That’s something a longtime journalism professor (and professed attorney) should know. Moreover, her claims that she didn’t write the worst comment are just laughable. That isn’t how Disqus works. It also doesn’t matter here. It was entirely reasonable and in good faith to assume that comments made under the linked account at websites, where by her own admission she made comments, were by her. Reading the judge’s decision not to dismiss, the only reason the suit wasn’t dismissed is because at this stage, the judge assumes everything written in the complaint is true. I don’t at all expect this case to survive much further, nor for it to be decided in her favor. Putting the legal issues aside, I do think it is fair to find what Benton did to be in poor judgment. He should have reached out for comment first — or really just let it go. Let people have bad opinions. But I hardly think he did anything worthy of a lawsuit. As for Temple, well, she didn’t have tenure and she embarrassed the school. It seems entirely reasonable for them to not renew her contract. But as I said above, she’s not suing them. She’s suing Harvard and Benton. I wouldn’t have done what Benton did, but I am also not overly sympathetic to someone who decided to use their work email to shitpost and then got called out. Was what Benton did unethical? Without reaching out for comment first, I think it probably was. At the very least, it was punching down and unnecessary. Should he be sued for defamation? I don’t think so.
- Jlsmprof 5y agoOne caution: The story doesn't say that she was fired, it says she lost her job, which could include a decision to eliminate her position. The original story is here. https://www.cjr.org/opinion/nieman-lab-lawsuit-joshua-benton-francesca-viola.php https://www.cjr.org/opinion/nieman-lab-lawsuit-joshua-benton...
- estaseuropano 5y agoI have no strong views either way, but I think it destroys her case that in the original comment she identified herself as a professor on media at a major east coast university. She was basically asking to be named as she explicitly referenced her somewhat unusual job as claim for her credibility.
- ilamont 5y agoIn June 2020, Benton stepped down from his leadership position at Nieman: https://twitter.com/jbenton/status/1276165792195842049?lang=en https://twitter.com/jbenton/status/1276165792195842049?lang=...
- RememberTheFtr 5y agoThis thread is a cautionary tale about the future of freedom. These are dark moments everywhere. Either we pick the Enlightenment or we create some new experiment.
- xadhominemx 5y agoWhat freedom are you refereeing to? The freedom to use an account linked to your work email address to spread lies and racist rhetoric on private third party websites without fear of identification?
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoThe freedom to speak without fear of punishment, which can clearly only be protected by increasingly extreme anonymization measures
- vecplane 5y agoThe scrolling on this page doesn't work unless I turn off uBlock Origin.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoAh my goodness, education does not immunize people from adapting very daft racism patterns. To simply throw all Muslims in one box is beyond crazy, there are Muslims of various different races. As a non Muslim, I have experienced Muslims as some of the nicest people out there, while the loudest Christians were often the most bigoted people imaginable and the only thing Christian about them was the label. Freedom of speech should remain firm and never infringed with, but there should always be consequences for such freedom of speech escalations. She has no business being an educator, poisoning the minds of people with her racism. The sack was justified, the doxxing was well deserved, if she wants to be a racist loudmouth, have the guts and show your "face". Compensation, hell no if it was for me to decide.
- baobabKoodaa 5y agoWell, this post had just about everything. Just about the only thing missing is a screed about how there's totally no censorship or cancel culture of conservative voices. Maybe you can write that as a follow up.
- bsd44 5y agoI've met Muslims with the most extreme views you could imagine. Third generation immigrants raised in the Western world still believing that "white" women deserve to be raped, teaching their children to only socialise with their own kind. I'm not sure what can you get from my comment, neither do I understand what anyone could possibly get from yours. Also, saying that someone "deserves" something says more about you than them and can some day come back and bite you on the ass.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoYeah, they happened to tell you that casually? Sure thing, some have radical and outdated views. Sometimes it takes one or two generations until immigrants come around, so what. The way forward is to include these people, make them feel welcome, institutionally and personally, if that doesn't happen, slums and ghettos arise. I still wouldn't bet that more Muslims hold this view than there are racist Christians. And yes, I maintain my view, she deserved what happened, she was ripe for the meltdown, wanted to express herself to the whole world. She should do that in her name if she is so convinced. You simply cannot emit such verbal cacophony and expect nobody will be enraged about it. Some of her students could be Muslims. This brings me to a sledgehammer comparison. Should a pederast be a teacher of teenagers so long he keeps his sexual orientation clandestine?
- rhizome 5y agoWhatever you think of what Viola posted, if she is fired, Benton should definitely also be fired for doxxing her. Disqus should also revoke Nieman Lab's account (but I bet they won't). I don't agree with Viola, but if she's able to live under the radar then more power to her. Frankly, people on the "fake news" side of US politics usually can't keep quiet, so let's maybe even commend her for her discretion. But Benton's acts were worse, WAY worse. Not worse than being a fake-news Republican, but worse than simply being a shithead on Twitter.
- lhorie 5y ago> if she is fired, Benton should definitely also be fired for doxxing her Isn't that anchoring bias? For starters, why equate firing with punishment? Firing an employee is a discretion of an employer meant to be used if they deem that the employee did not fulfill duties adequately, it's not really supposed to be a vehicle for mob appeasement. More generally, I take issue with this idea that doing something bad ought to result in career ruin. Like, is the undertext that they ought to gtfo of their field of expertise and go flip burgers or something instead? I feel like there ought to be better ways to address conduct issues that doesn't involve messing w/ people's livelihoods (twitter lynching is not any better, to be clear) IMHO, it'd be more conducive to a healthy society if we defaulted to talking about remediation strategies in the workplace, like three-strike systems, clearer public comm policies etc than defaulting to tearing people down.
- dntrkv 5y agoBenton's acts were worse? In what way? Viola "anonymously" called Muslim people scum (not really anonymous because she used her work email and exposed info about her location / job). He called her out, in a very public way. Kinda hard to feel sorry for her, to be honest.
- rhizome 5y agoAnd he violated Disqus' TOS to do it, not to mention basic responsibility not to abuse information access. Ah but maybe you've never had to protect sensitive information before, such that the responsibility itself is foreign.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 5y agoDon't comment on disqus threads unless you got VPN. disquss admins can get the email and ip
- ALittleLight 5y ago"the Nieman Lab chose to use Disqus, a platform that allows for anonymized accounts" It seems clear that Disqus doesn't actually allow anonymous accounts. They apparently just limit who can see your name - which creates the trap this journalism professor fell into, thinking she was anonymous when she wasn't.
- JohnClark1337 5y agoTwitter was a mistake