16 ms·
Support for team members who are mistreated in their country
- sytse 5y agoFor the TLDR; "GitLab has the right to migrate to the Netherlands for qualifying team members. Just added we can waive the 1 year tenure requirement if you are a member of an underrepresented group that is unsafe or if here is a lot of violence in your country" https://twitter.com/sytses/status/1417601595668275201 https://twitter.com/sytses/status/1417601595668275201
- temp8964 5y agoI really don't understand the "has the right" part here. It sounds like GitLab will help qualifying team members to migrate to the Netherlands?
- sytse 5y agoYes, that would be a better way to say it. When I wrote the header for https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/visas/#right-to-immigrate-to-the-netherlands https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/visas/#right-... years ago I was still processing that there is a human right to leave your country but that only works if there is another country that will have you, which isn't the case for the vast majority of people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geofft 5y agoIf I'm reading right, it looks like a company can become a "recognised sponsor," which allows them to sponsor as many of their employees as they want for relocation, provided they meet salary requirements etc. It doesn't look like there is a government-side discretionary approval like the US green card or (at least in the Netherlands) a quota or lottery like the US H-1B. There's a background check but that's it. https://www.eubluecard.nl/dutch-program/recognised-sponsor https://www.eubluecard.nl/dutch-program/recognised-sponsor https://www.government.nl/topics/immigration-to-the-netherlands/question-and-answer/hire-a-highly-skilled-migrant https://www.government.nl/topics/immigration-to-the-netherla... If that interpretation is correct, then I think this is also "GitLab has the power/authority".
- strken 5y agoAnecdata: when I worked at a US tech company, one of our teammates got transferred to the Netherlands because he couldn't get a visa renewal in time. I believe it's a common country to stash anyone who's having visa issues.
- hguant 5y agoMy understanding is that this goes back to Rotterdam being a free or open port, since the late Renaissance period. The Netherlands has been a proponent of free trade and what we'd call international citizenship for a very long time
- xxpor 5y agoAnd, you know, the Dutch East India Company being the largest multinational in world history.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoCanada is also popular, especially BC - it's where Amazon, Google, and Microsoft move people who couldn't get a H-1B renewal but want to keep them in the same time-zone. It's only a 2-hour drive from Seattle so having in-person meetings is still possible.
- chrisseaton 5y agoRight, but I don't think GitLab can enforce the right to come to the Netherlands. Presumably if the Dutch security services have a reason to stop someone coming in there's nothing that GitLab can do about that.
- YorickPeterse 5y agoCorrect, you're still subject to regular immigration laws and such; some parts of it are just made easier.
- kyawzazaw 5y ago
- pm90 5y agoThis is fantastic. I wonder if they could partner with the Canadian government to make this easier for their employees who need to gtfo from their home country.
- sytse 5y agoSomeone else asked a similar question on Twitter earlier https://twitter.com/helmerdavila/status/1417616260431495170 https://twitter.com/helmerdavila/status/1417616260431495170
- redis_mlc 5y ago1) Canada is easy for immigrants with a degree and a job offer since it's a points-based system. The historical reason is that Canada is underpopulated for its size. As far as STEM, a large percentage move to the US, so foreign STEM workers are needed. In addition, Canada is doing a lot of PC/SJW activism today, so there's that too. 2) The easiest US work visa is the TN-1 for a Canadian citizen to work in the US. Note that it's a non-immigrant visa, so if you want to stay long-term in the US, you would need to do further immigration paperwork.
- redis_mlc 5y agoIt's funny and sad how defensive Marxists are. Pro tip: the US will never become a Communist country.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIs there a reason the requests aren’t centralized? Needing a manager to approve first seems like a recipe for very haphazard application of the policy. It probably won’t be heavily used, but still.
- Aeolun 5y agoI think that is only if you do not meet all the requirements?
- john_cogs 5y agoThat is correct. Team members who meet the requirements follow our relocation process which is managed by People Operations Specialists. Team members who do not meet all of the requirements are asked to work with their managers first before bringing the request to the People team.
- paxys 5y agoRegardless of the underrepresented/mistreated group part, why does Gitlab offer immigration to the Netherlands in general?
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y agoBecause they can, and it makes employees happy?
- john_cogs 5y agoBeing an all-remote company allows team members to choose to live and work where they want. This benefit provides folks more choices when deciding where to live and work.
- paxys 5y agoOkay, but why not any of the other 190+ countries? What's so special about that one?
- john_cogs 5y agoFrankly, I can't provide a detailed answer to those questions. This tweet from GitLab's CEO provides some additional context: https://twitter.com/sytses/status/1417617071353991169?s=19 https://twitter.com/sytses/status/1417617071353991169?s=19
- tmp_anon_22 5y agoIts objectively better then most? Is this even in contention?
- coldtea 5y agoYes. It's not only not something "objective", it also has nothing to do with the reason why it's it.
- fabianhjr 5y agoNormally a work visa requires a local "visa sponsor" or employer so Gitlab would only be able to offer relocation to countries where they have a fiscal presence.
- gravy 5y agoShould it be 1-3? Please hire me as QA. Edit: Anyways I like this. Love the idea of companies taking over for helping out the underrepresented in their ranks. This is a natural progression from remote work.
- remram 5y ago1. 1. 1. is on purpose, the Markdown rendering software will number it. This has the advantage that you don't need to update the numbers in the source if you move/add/remove lines.
- refulgentis 5y agothat is 3 things: really cool, relying on a hack, and defeating the core purpose of markdown. bravo to all involved, especially the renderer
- remram 5y agoThe core purpose of Markdown is for the source to look decent and readable, not match the output exactly. You can tell it's a numbered list, so it works.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- foxpurple 5y agoI’d argue that seeing 1. 1. 1. Is actually better than seeing them increasing but being out of order. Less of a hack and while reading them unformatted you just think of it like a HTML OL with list items. Or of the 1 as a keyword meaning ordered list item.
- paxys 5y agoNeedlessly numbering lists when bullets would serve the purpose is one of my pet peeves.
- rodarmor 5y agoIf you are mistreated in your country, why does it matter if you are a member of an underrepresented group or not?
- geofft 5y ago"Underrepresented" is in parentheses. So I'm interpreting this as saying that the policy is not specific to members of underrepresented groups, but was crafted with underrepresented groups in mind. I think it does matter whether you're a member of a group that is mistreated as a group vs. whether you are mistreated as a person; it's easier to be confident that you're understanding the situation correctly if there's a lot of data about an entire group vs. a claim that you individually are unsafe/mistreated (which could just be "I am mistreated because my community is ostracizing me for having committed a crime" or whatever). It is obviously possible to be mistreated as a group even if you are from a local-majority group (cf. apartheid in South Africa). As to why they mentioned it even if it's in parentheses - there's a link to a page, and elsewhere on the page they mention that it's a cultural value to include more people from "underrepresented groups" in their definition (https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#gitlabs-definition-of-diversity-inclusion--belonging https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#gitlabs-...).
- smt88 5y agoIt sounds like they mean "systemically mistreated". In what countries are over-represented groups mistreated by systems or institutions?
- rospaya 5y agoIt's not that rare - Iraq, South Africa, Liberia.
- smt88 5y agoI think we're using different terms here. To me (and, I suspect, to Gitlab), "underrepresented" means "present in lower proportions than in the general population". South Africa, to use one of your examples, has a majority Black African population (80%), but business management is overwhelmingly White[1] (67%). That means Black African people are simultaneously the majority of the country and also underrepresented minorities that struggle with systemic, institutional racism. 1. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48123937 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48123937
- biztos 5y agoI like this idea but I wonder whether the company has considered how many people would qualify, or if they just don’t employ enough people for it to be an actual slippery slope for them. All women in America, for starters, per their definition. Not that qualified Americans have any problem moving to Europe. But maybe Arabs in Israel, Copts in Egypt, Russians in Ukraine, Zoroastrians in Iran, lots and lots of ethnicities in China, atheists in most countries… Nice to know their training materials are free from bias though! https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definitions https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definiti...
- kall 5y agoI don‘t know if the slippery slope goes far enough to be a problem. Effectively, if you‘re in a position to work at GitLab, the netherlands are happy to have you. They could relocate the entire company there and it might not be a problem.
- radmuzom 5y agoMoment I read the words "mistreated in their countries", first country which came to mind was USA.
- spoonjim 5y agoHuh. Not Syria? South Sudan? Venezuela? Honduras? Belarus?
- peterburkimsher 5y agoI'm pleased that more is being done to help migrants, especially refugees. What I don't understand is why this must be the responsibility of private companies. The United Nations specifically asks governments to care for people. But asylum seekers are imprisoned if they go to Australia, or stuck in limbo for 27 years of processing time if they come to New Zealand. So now capitalism is triumphing, and visas are issued to (rich, powerful) private companies and the people who work for them, instead of to people based on their skills. I'm tremendously grateful for the (large, powerful) company who hired me just in time for my visa to be processed, after waiting in an immigration queue for 2.5 years. The case officer was treating me quite harshly until I had the new job offer. To any company managers wondering whether this affects employee loyalty: I literally owe my entire career and future to you. Thank you for taking a chance on me.
- runarberg 5y agoI agree. The state of international migration is very worrying indeed. More people are dying on migration routes then by terrorism ~by a factor of two~ by 50%. That is, hostile border policy by western nations are causing at least many more deaths then global terrorists. And this seems to be getting worse. The global pandemic saw countries double down on their harsh border policy, and there is little reason to believe there is relief in sight. The climate crisis is rendering more and more places inhospitable which will only deepen the ongoing migration crisis. European nations seem indifferent to this fact and continue their hostile border policy even though a global emergency is imminent. I indeed applaud any private efforts to offer any help they are able through this crisis, as much help is needed. But I do wish governments would take this humanitarian crisis more seriously. People are dying, there is an emergency, and we governments need to change their immigration policies to reflect that. We need to open our borders and stop this needless suffering of migrants. But while governments are hellbent on keeping theirs borders this closed, hopefully we will see more companies take action like GitLab here and offer help where they can. EDIT: I cited wrong numbers. Migrant deaths were at least 3,170 by mid December 2019 according to IOM (https://www.iom.int/news/global-migrant-deaths-decline-tragedies-continue-worldwide https://www.iom.int/news/global-migrant-deaths-decline-trage...) while terrorist deaths were around 2051 according to Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_terrorist_incidents_in_2019 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_terrorist_incidents_in...).
- slg 5y agoI can't imagine I would ever actually use this type of support, but knowing it is there increases the odds that I would apply for a job at Gitlab. It makes me admire the company's culture more than probably any other benefit I have seen offered in my time in tech.
- RA_Fisher 5y agoI agree, it shows the company cares about its employees.
- klohto 5y agoWritten “cultures” are quite different from how the company actually acts.
- arvindamirtaa 5y agoTheoretically, yes. Knowing Gitlab, they're very very close.
- mandelbrotwurst 5y agoThis is an operational policy document - they’re making specific guarantees to their employees about how they will support them. That’s a lot stronger than claiming to uphold some set of values because it means that they’re willing to risk losing the trust of their employees if they don’t stick to this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kms_2021 5y agoPlease hire me as tester.
- Google234 5y agoThis will be useful if Trump is elected in 2024
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anonytrary 5y agoWhy is there a space in the email? peopleops@ gitlab.com
- spoonjim 5y agoIs the Netherlands OK with being the destination for all of these mistreated people?
- whazor 5y agoNetherlands is keen on receiving 'highly skilled migrants', aka tax paying citizens. There is a temporary tax discount for expats called the 30% ruling. But I think the discount is only fair because expats coming to Netherlands didn't receive benefits yet, and moving in general is also expensive.
- rutierut 5y agoIt very much is, they skip the part of someone's life where they just cost (a lot of) money and get right to the part where they are making money of them. Expats even get tax breaks to incentivize them to come here. Which is fair IMO. However it sucks big time for the countries they leave behind (brain drain, net negative financial impact).
- hohohmm 5y agoWell, did gitlab forget how it explicitly said to not hire chinese or russian in fear of paranoid espionage concerns, that resulted in a hiring manager quitting gitlab? I wonder how it would do it people are mistreated in GitLab.
- 0xfaded 5y agoUltimately gitlab has a duty of care to the customers whose code they host. If most of your customers are in the West, and there are persistent security and IP threats from certain national governments, I don't see an alternative here.
- drath 5y agoHow so? Why not just refuse to sign contracts containing discriminatory terms and refuse such requests? Discrimination is not a solution to anything and should never even be considered as an option.
- 0xfaded 5y agoI have to disagree with the idea that it's not a solution, governments refuse to hire foreign nationals all the time and even regulate the private sector through things like ITAR. Now I agree it's an unfortunate solution in some respects. There are moral issues both utilitarian (1000 Einsteins) and idealistic (all humans are equal). There are also work arounds. For most purposes if you naturalize and renounce your previous citizenship you will legally be treated as a national. ITAR only requires a green card. Arguing against discrimination in a security context though, when nationality is indeed a reliable discriminant, is difficult.
- trasz 5y agoThe threats you’ve mentioned usually come from Western governments. China is often accused, but attacks by US have actually been proven - numerous times. Same with backdoors.
- f6v 5y agoNot hiring Russians because they might be a government spy is like not hiring an Arab because he could be a terrorist.
- vood 5y agoI might be wrong, but this update is addressing a real problem that company is facing. This is not some hypothetical, slippery slope kinda thing. For instance, in Belarus right now a lot of engineers seek to get out the country due to dictatorship regime. Poland and neighbourhood countries offer emergency visa plans for people in trouble (business harbour visa). I think what happened is that GitLab started receiving a lot of emergency requests to be relocated immediately that did not comply the existing policy. Hence the update.
- tablespoon 5y ago> For instance, in Belarus right now a lot of engineers seek to get out the country due to dictatorship regime. Poland and neighbourhood countries offer emergency visa plans for people in trouble (business harbour visa). Would this apply to a typical Belarusian engineer in Belarus, though? They'd be White, European, and (correct me if I'm wrong) violence there seems mainly directed at protesters and protest leaders. It seems to me like this tailored for the kinds of racial and sexual minorities the US likes to obsess about. > Tenure of less than 1 year at GitLab may be possibly waived as a requirement if: > - You are a member of a(n [underrepresented](https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definitions https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definiti...)) group that is unsafe or in any way mistreated in your country. > - Violence in your country does not provide a safe environment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dvdkon 5y agoFirst off, there's hardly anyone other than europeans in East European countries. And I don't see why Gitlab engineers wouldn't be involved in the protests. They're probably well-educated and therefore statistically more likely to care about the political situation.
- curiousgal 5y agoIf caring about the political situation translated into action then the US would have no issues at all. Engineers are very much less likely to take part of protests anywhere because they're busy and think they're well off.
- anon4321 5y agoThrow-away account, but this is good. Wish more companies did this kind of thing. I've been mistreated most of my life for my sexuality, even here in Sweden. Can't stand it much longer... EDIT: To clarify, I'm being bullied, not oppressed by the govt. Swedes are known to not reach out and are truly the worst kind of friends that leave you on a whim if they don't relate to you.
- nolok 5y agoYou do realize that making broad sweeping criticizing of an entire group of people based on your personal experiences with a limited amount of members of their group is exactly why these situation happen? I wish the best for you and nobody should be discriminated for their sexual preference as long as everybody is consenting, and if we want the situation to become better we must all work to improve it, so make you sure you don't do that sort of over generalization and simplification just like you wish people wouldn't do it towards you.
- anon4321 5y agoYou're right. I didn't set out to "win an argument", just share my personal experience. In terms of the limitations that applies to what I said, it is clear from context. And they are the majority; their voices will get heard anyway. People think that Sweden is some kind of humanitarian utopia, while in reality there is more homophobia than people realize, and e.g. a relatively high-profile anti-Semitic case just recently... Make of that what you will.
- Accacin 5y agoI do think people think of Sweden like that, even here in the UK. Recently my brother went on a business trip to Sweden, and was quite surprised at the amount of "casual" racism he encountered - although I wasn't sure whether because he was from the UK they were a little more open with him, perhaps? Anyway, not slinging mud. UK is just as bad (probably worse..).
- 5y ago
- mehdix 5y agofwiw, this simple page does not load without javascript. Instead, it only shows the banner and ablank page. *sigh*
- cpursley 5y agoIt's 2021 my friend
- generationP 5y agoIdea good, execution not so much. > - Violence in your country does not provide a safe environment. Why "violence" as opposed to political persecution? It doesn't quite fit the Hong Kong situation, yet it is clear that Hong Kong should be one of the top countries to relocate from. Nor does political opposition count as an "underrepresented group" by their definition.
- consp 5y agoI'm not 100% sure this is the intent but normally (in the Netherlands) political prosecution would not require a work visa and/or immigration requirements and you can follow the normal asylum process. Maybe they would want you to follow that and this is only meant for the edge cases not covered by the normal asylum process. As with all these things, there is a huge list of asterisks involved.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoViolence is a broad term and I'm sure if you ask for relocation because of fear of persecution they'll help you out. It's not a computer processing these requests, it's a person. And this document is not code or law, but guidelines.
- ainiriand 5y agoI just want to comment about the commit itself: - You remove the word 'three' in the first line but then again repeat it a few lines later. Interesting choice. - You have 3 sections labelled 1.
- aloisdg 5y ago> You have 3 sections labelled 1. This is how markdown works. It is handy.
- DougBTX 5y ago> You have 3 sections labelled 1. That’s taking advantage of auto-renumbering in markdown, so if they insert an entry they won’t have to change any others.
- ainiriand 5y agoIt is absurd if you mention that there are 3 and the cost of typing a 1 is the same as typing a 2 or a 3. No wonder why modern software is a hot mess.
- hnbad 5y agoTrue, the cost of typing 1 is the same, but the cost of changing the numbering on all consecutive items if you break one up or add one or remove one is higher. It's just unfortunate Markdown used that syntax to indicate a numbered list in order to be "human readable".
- ainiriand 5y agoMy point is: why do you have automatic number in a list of 3 items that you mention in the text that there are 3 items? It is locked to 3! You said that in the text! And yet the commit removed the first indication of this 3 elements but not the second!
- greatgib 5y agoThis moment you see that they are doing PIP like any shitty silicon valley company for the case that your manager does not like you... And in that case, they don't care that you are at risk of violence or abuse in your home country .. << You are not on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).>>
- arcticbull 5y agoThis may be contentious but no matter the system, if your manager doesn't like you and decides to kick you out - you're in a tough spot. No PIP system means they just straight-up fire you. PIP system means they let you know you're being fired and give you the chance to quit. Either way you're in a pickle. The only real defense against either is pre-existing political capital. From an HR perspective I'm not sure there's any meaningful way to objectively separate an under-performer from someone whose manager has it out for them. So, I'm kind of with them on this one. If you're going to get fired, then I doubt their sponsorship of your transfer would do you much good - you'd still be forced to return on departure would you not?
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoPro tip: If you're being fired, don't quit. Quitting is on you, firing is on the employer. If you get fired, you're (more?) entitled to benefits and if you feel like it was unjust you have a chance to appeal in court.
- yadaeno 5y agoKeep in mind that you are not obligated to disclose that you were fired to future employers. However your new employer may ask your previous for information which will likely be shared.
- arcticbull 5y agoMost big employers in my experience also have a neutral reference policy, meaning they won't opine on your tenure there except to say you worked there, for X dates and $Y salary. You're welcome to solicit a more specific reference from your choice of former coworkers.
- sschueller 5y agoMistreatment is how pay is adjusted to location assuring poor areas stay poor even though the developer is performing the same task any others in higher paying regions. If cost of living is really a factor why does their product cost the same globally?
- nodelessness 5y agoI wouldn't say that is mistreatment. It is a business transaction where one party has more leverage than the other. 99% of the time the employee in the lower income region gets a far high salary than they expect to get at another employer. So it is not like they are being coerced into a "unable to make ends meet" levels of income. The employee ends up doing pretty well.
- hnbad 5y agoRealistically, the upper limit of a salary is usually determined by the average value the employee will bring to the company because profit is derived from surplus value. This value may range from very direct (number of product produced per unit of time) or very indirect (making the rest of the team happy to increase their overall productivity and reduce employee turnover). The lower limit is generally whatever the company can get away with. This has legal factors (e.g. minimum wage laws) as well as regional (e.g. "market rate", unemployment rates) but ultimately the candidate has to make the call what they can (or have no other choice but to) accept. Crucially, the surplus value only hinges on the value generated and the expenses of employing that person (mostly salary and benefits but cross-state and internationally there may be legal costs avoidable by hiring locally). If you live in an area with a low cost of living and the company's upper limit is defined by the relative cost of living, they're going to extract a lot more surplus value from your labor than if you live in an area with a high cost of living but maintain the same personal cost of living because you manage to be extraordinarily frugal. That you make a lot of money relative to your local peers does not mean the company isn't disproportionately extracting surplus value from you (or in other words: paying you in lower proportion to the value you generate than others). If everyone else in your neighborhood is paid a penny and you earn a dime that does not mean I'm not exploiting you when I pay the locals a dollar for the same generated value. That GitLab only varies pay and not the cost of their software and services demonstrates that they understand this. The value their services provide depends entirely on the customer's market (which is btw why a lot of initial SaaS pricing is based on US startup culture where company expenses are measured as burn rates rather than profitability, even if it makes the services cost prohibitive in other markets). Also of course geographically distributed employees will find it harder to unionize (even more so formally because of different jurisdictions and labor laws) or organize and are less likely to seriously develop solidarity in a way that could get in the way of making a profit. There are arguments for the destructive impact of foreign companies paying above market rate but it's absurd to think companies that use geographical salary ranges do so out of concern for regional competitors.
- zohch 5y agoI hope GitLab will make a commitment to cut economic ties with countries from which they will accept "refugees", something which Europe generally does not seem to have the courage to do.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWhat if Nike did this?