35 ms·
Astronomers push for global debate on giant satellite swarms
- PaulHoule 5y agoWhere was the global debate on universal optic fiber? People in rural communities were looking for allies and groups like astronomers weren't there even though it was obviously in their interest to show up. (e.g. wireless communications period is an enemy of astronomy)
- rhacker 5y agoI don't think most astronomers knew that there would need to be 50K more satellites for remote internet to work. Maybe if someone had told them it's not just a few extra satellites?
- Robotbeat 5y agoAstronomers were told how big Starlink would be. In fact, the FCC had a public comment period for Starlink before it was launched. Just no one in the astronomy community took Starlink seriously enough to say anything. (Granted, SpaceX also didn’t know it would be a big impact to astronomy either, but at least SpaceX quickly altered the design of Starlink to mitigate brightness once the problem was apparent.)
- dylan604 5y agoThis is one of those things where I don't buy any of it. The first time I heard a number connected to a Starlink constellation, the first thing I thought about was how many more dirty images are going to be in my footage. So, yes, I happen to be an amateur amateur astrophotographer, but it was litterally the first thing I thought about. Never did I think there's some web form to fill out with this complaint. So I'm sitting here thinking that if I thought about it, surely others have as well. It's not like I'm some amazing genius that sees things others don't so let me reach out to some esoteric gov't agency that I don't even know is a thing to do. We've also known about these issues with the much smaller number of Iridium statellites to the point there are apps/websites dedicated to tell you when you can catch an Iridium flare. We also know what the effects of GeoSync sats, Hubble, ISS, etc look like in images. This is not something new. TL;DR: Stop victim blaming
- xbar 5y agoI do wish that was how policy was developed -- people see a risk to their interests and then they advocate to address the root cause in a way that helps all of society. While we're wishing for things, it would have been nice for climate change if oil companies had actually transitioned to being energy companies a few decades ago in the interest of all current and future generations. On topic: Musk behaves like Vanderbilt and Stanford in this way--he exploits vulnerabilities in the current system prior to regulators being able to address the concerns, leading to a de facto monopoly once market entry is prohibited.
- PaulHoule 5y agoGroups that win at politics think about forming coalitions. Other groups lose.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notquitehuman 5y agoIn life, people who are unable to successfully form coalitions, partnerships, and alliances tend to be at a disadvantage to those who can.
- DennisP 5y agoWhat do you mean by "once market entry is prohibited?"
- ghaff 5y agoJust ten years ago, most people could arguably kinda/sorta get by without home access to good broadband Internet. OK, you couldn't stream Netflix or You Tube but those weren't really necessities. And a telephone landline was fine for real-time communications with people. You maybe had cellular data and some laggy expensive satellite, but you could make do if you cared enough about living somewhere rural. Increasingly that's not the case. I really couldn't have worked for any extended period from my dad's house in Maine with marginal (at best) cell service and flaky 1Mbps ADSL down. So getting broadband to rural locations is really not up for debate even if the method of doing so is.
- Sebb767 5y agoWell, to be fair, the technology and broadband speed promote out each other. If broadband would not have been available to some people, Netflix would've never started streaming. Similarly, once we get low-latency 10 GBit networking, new services will pop up that require these bandwidths. Which is to say that we should really start and get them _good_ speeds now, not something that is somewhat acceptable now.
- PaulHoule 5y agoFrom an infrastructure standpoint the difference between fiber and everything else is that fiber is permanent. That is, if you run fiber optic along the power lines that will be good to support crazy high-speeds for the next 50+ years -- with relatively small investments in the future to improve the transceivers at the ends. If you build fixed wireless the one thing that's certain is that the hardware will be obsolete in 5-10 years and have to be "ripped and replaced".
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoNot seeing a huge difference. The hardware lighting up the fiber will go through the same obsolescence curve, and the airwaves are even more permanent than that fiber will be.
- 5y ago
- jerf 5y agoYeah, I was kinda thinking, the last thing the astronomers want is a "global debate". Keep it inside their community and they might get action. Truly open it up to global debate and they're going to get completely and utterly routed on this matter. For everybody else, benefits clearly outweigh costs. Most of the people in the world already live in such light-polluted areas that they'll hardly notice the difference.
- PaulHoule 5y agoAlso it seems Elon Musk could help them get much better space telescopes than they have now.
- thesausageking 5y agoHow does the right to send things into orbit work today? Can anyone just launch whatever they want up?
- asaddhamani 5y agoThere are orbits assigned but then there are also spy satellites which I don't think are getting an assignment. Would like to know more about this.
- 0-_-0 5y agoIn the US it has to be approved by the FCC
- dkarp 5y agoDoes the FCC co-ordinate with other FCC equivalent agencies around the world? Or is everyone just doing their own thing?
- JoeDaDude 5y agoIn general, the United Nations, by means of the International Telecommunications Union, coordinates orbital assignments between member nations [1]. In the US, the FCC mediates for the American satellites to the ITU, so the FCC, as a member of the ITU, approves satellite orbital assignments [2]. In addition, the FAA plays a role in approving satellite launches as a matter of air traffic and safety, etc. [3]. The FAA doesn't get involved once the satellite is in space though. As an example, one US company got in legal hot water by trying to skirt around the FCC in getting its satellites to orbit [4]. [1]. https://www.itu.int/en/plenipotentiary/2014/newsroom/Documents/backgrounders/pp14-backgrounder-sharing-the-sky.pdf https://www.itu.int/en/plenipotentiary/2014/newsroom/Documen... [2]. https://www.fcc.gov/general/international-bureau-satellite-division https://www.fcc.gov/general/international-bureau-satellite-d... [3]. https://www.faa.gov/space/legislation_regulation_guidance/ https://www.faa.gov/space/legislation_regulation_guidance/ [4]. https://qz.com/1503575/swarm-technologies-settles-illegal-launch-for-9000000/ https://qz.com/1503575/swarm-technologies-settles-illegal-la...
- totalZero 5y agoFiber latency is way lower and doesn’t require the sharing of ambient spectrum. Society loses little by curtailing for-profit retail ISP satellite deployment.
- ghaff 5y agoSo who is paying for and laying this fiber to remote rural locations?
- tayo42 5y agoGovernment should be, like a utility.
- sebzim4500 5y agoWouldn't that end up costing $300k+ per house when you get to the really remote areas? I know some people that had to pay that amount to get a few houses connected up, and they weren't that far from civilization. Hard to imagine there is political will to spend that much taxpayer money on such a small portion of the population when it looks like Starlink will provide decent internet for a tiny fraction of the cost.
- ghaff 5y agoYeah. If there were truly no other options, I'd certainly be in favor of a debate about bringing near-universal broadband to people, in the same manner as electricity and telephones. Of course, that only applies country by country and presumably leaves poorer countries SOL. However, given that we do seem to have a good option with the tradeoff that there will be more satellites in LEO, that seems to be a reasonable tradeoff. There are already a lot of satellites in orbit, to say nothing of planes, and a lot of light pollution. So this idea that we're besmirching the virgin night sky seems... overwrought.
- pradn 5y agoBut providing practically every service to a rural person is more expensive, but we do it anyway since we like to have a somewhat equal living standard for our rural citizens. Hell, the same goes for suburbs too. In many cities, poorer urban areas end up being net tax positive compared to suburbs because of the extensive amount of low-density infrastructure required outside the core.
- cryptoz 5y ago> United Nations forum next month might discuss whether humanity has a right to ‘dark and quiet skies’. What about people who live in or near cities? Those skies haven't been dark or quiet for decades or more.
- dorchadas 5y agoAnd perhaps that's something that needs to be discussed. I would absolutely love to see street lights be given a sort of 'shield' that reflects them downwards towards the ground. I'd also figure it could require them to use less energy if it reflected downward since so much of the light wouldn't be escaping. Could also go for red wavelengths like they do in some towns near where turtles hatch, so that they don't miss the moonlight needed to guide them to the water. I think there's many ways we could make cities darker while still keeping it light at ground level for pedestrians. Granted, these are all just speculations on my part, but I feel there's a way somehow.
- elihu 5y agoAlso, many people who live on those lit streets would rather those street lights didn't exist, shining in their windows all night. I feel fortunate to live in an unincorporated urban area that's like a city in many ways but we don't have street lights nearby. Cities don't need to be illuminated 24/7.
- dorchadas 5y agoHaving one outside my window, I absolutely 100% agree. I just always hear the issues of "What about pedestrians being safe" (which isn't even an issue where I live; it's not a pedestrian street or anywhere near the city center area), so was trying to find a way to combat that. That's why I think some reflective shielding could do well, pointing the light where we want it to go, and also enable us to light with less energy and light needed in general.
- swayvil 5y agoYes. Satellites are just a drop in the ocean compared to city light.
- asaddhamani 5y agoThis is really required. I do some amateur astrophotography in India where Starlink is not even operational yet and have already seen their satellites in my long exposures a couple times. Light pollution from the ground already ruins this wonderful hobby (and stargazing) for so many around the world, adding sky based pollution on top of that would be truly terrible. I recognise all the benefits these satellite constellations provide us, but at what cost?
- Retric 5y agoLEO satellites like StarLink are in earths shadow most of the night. Which means you can avoid unlimited satellites, you just need to wait longer to start and end well before dawn.
- asaddhamani 5y agoI have seen StarLink satellites with my naked eye many times and confirmed with the Dark Sky app, past midnight as well.
- Retric 5y agoFor astronomy, aim up. The closer to the horizon the longer their visible before and after sunset. The sky rotates at night and at different times of the year so the overwhelming majority of things are still observable without any satellites. Also, this is almost exclusively about about wide angel shots. You can still do ultra long exposure closeups of various things, at worse you might need to cover the shutter for a few seconds while a satellite moves into and out of the shot but even that’s generally avoidable.
- asaddhamani 5y agoBut what if something I want to click is near the horizon? For example trying to get a shot of the sky with mountains in the frame. Avoiding the parts where the satellites are is not a viable solution most of the times.
- dweekly 5y agoThe natural place for truly undisrupted observation is going to be the far side of the Moon, so let's put an observatory or two there and stop quibbling about LEO.
- Sebb767 5y agoThis is fine for really high budget astronomy, but anyone not having access to billions of funding will be out of luck. Not to speak of possible territorial conflicts on the moon, so billions might even not help you if you happen to be in the wrong country. Stargazers or hobby astronomers might as well just look at a desktop background ... That's not to say we should not build a observatory there - this is a good idea[0]. But it does not solve most of the issues these satellites pose. [0] Though a space station might solve a lot of similar issues without the need to land and take off.
- fallingknife 5y agoCommercial use is going to be prioritized over hobbyists in any domain. Think about what the reaction would be if drone pilots wanted to add restrictions to airline routes so that they could use the airspace. I don't really see how this is any different.
- ghaff 5y agoIt's not just hobbyists. Earth-based observatories have to contend with light pollution in many locations. And while, in some cases, there have been mitigations, astronomers aren't going to get cities to turn off their lights every night in general.
- zionic 5y agoTourist flights to the moon will be $1-2 mil/person in 2035 ($1000 or so in today’s money). College students will get to visit and set up their own experiments as part of their billion dollar tuition.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fallingknife 5y agoIf orbital launches are cheap enough to make these mega constellations economically viable, then we should be having the debate about moving commercial astronomy into space.
- MengerSponge 5y agoUntil we get a space elevator, our most sensitive optical telescopes will be terrestrial. Space is hard, and modern telescopes have enormous optical elements. Look at these absolute units: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_optical_reflecting_telescopes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_optical_reflec...
- fallingknife 5y agoFrom what I see there, the largest mirror is 30m. JWST has a 6.5m mirror. Assuming that 6.5m is the largest that can be launched at once (which is probably not true, and will be less so when Starship is operational), it would take 25 launches to get a 30m diameter meter built. 25 launches from SpaceX costs $1.5 billion, which is in the budgetary realm of space telescopes. So I don't think it's as far fetched as you think.
- MengerSponge 5y agoYes, the famously operational JWST. The telescope that should be used as a benchmark for how to implement an orbital system on time, under budget, and if I may be so bold: easily. /s 1) You're talking about replacing existing capabilities. 2) It's easy to spend someone else's money. Those terrestrial telescopes are paid for, built, and running. Finding funding for them was really hard the first time around, and do you think constellation operators will spring for the replacement costs? I'm not saying it's technically impossible to replace all of our terrestrial telescopes because some people want to make a lot of money from the commons of our night sky, but $1.5 billion is just for the launches. It doesn't include design, fabrication, assembly, testing, or contingencies.
- djkorchi 5y ago
- 1053r 5y agoCheap space launch is the cause of, and the solution to, our light pollution issues. 50,000 satellites would be impossible to launch without the recent step change in the wholesale price of launch. And even 5% of that number of space based telescopes will decrease the contention for valuable instrument time enormously. Particularly if the next generation space based telescopes used tethers or precision formation flying for extremely large simulated aperture size, we'll start getting phenomenally amazing data. (Even some of the largest ground based telescopes will be possible to compete with in space using large formations of connected satellites.) So all of the hue and cry around Starlink is really just growing pains. It will hurt some of the science temporarily (particularly around sunrise and sunset), but in the long run, cheap launch is really what the field of astronomy needs to continue to have better and better instrumentation.
- thayne 5y agoThat may be true for NASA and maybe the wealthiest and most connected universities and research centers. But that doesn't really help smaller universities or amateur astronomers. Not to mention that getting a telescope the size of the Keck telescopes into space probably won't be feasible for a long time (although without air pollution you would get similar quality with a slightly smaller telescope). And even ignoring the cost of launch space telescopes are likely more expensive due to needing to deal with the extremities of space like temperature regulation and dealing with cosmic rays (which besides interfering with the computers, also cause noise in the CCD cameras).
- wumpus 5y ago> That may be true for NASA and maybe the wealthiest and most connected universities and research centers. I work at a well funded university, and it's not true for us, either. In fact I haven't met a single astronomer who is optimistic that somehow we'll magically get enough money to replace even a small fraction of the great telescopes we currently have on the ground.
- Robotbeat 5y ago
- timbre1234 5y agoAstronomy is nice to have, but it absolutely pales in comparison to the things satellite swarms can bring us on earth. The cost is well worth it, and if astronomy is affected the solution will have to be more reliance on space-based observation.
- asaddhamani 5y agoWhich is much more expensive and risky, just look at the Hubble($4.7B) failure recently, or the Kepler ($600M) failures before that. How many years (decades?) has James Webb($8.8B) telescope been in development? Ground based can't be easily replaced by space based and will leave lots of people and nations out of astronomy, which will truly be a terrible loss.
- m4rtink 5y agoThat traditional space telescope cost is heavily driven by how expensive space launch used to be, which is already changing now. Also with the upcoming RLVs in space repair or retrieval and redeployment might also become an option, this time much more affordable than with the Shuttle.
- 0-_-0 5y agoI'll just point out that not all ground-based astronomy is affected. Satellites are only visible when the sky is dark but the satellite is not in Earth's shadow, so only observations at dusk and dawn are affected.
- djkorchi 5y agoAre you sure this is true? You can frequently see satellites in the dead of night. Further, they show up quite plainly in non-visible wavelengths like radio or infrared even during the day.
- 0-_-0 5y agoThis of course only applies to visible light, they will be visible in infrared no matter what.
- sudhirj 5y agoGiant satellite swarms will enable space based astronomy at an unprecedented scale. Instead of complaining that we’re putting stuff in space why aren’t astronomers trying to get more telescopes added into next launches? Is there any instrument of astronomy that benefits from being on the surface under the atmosphere instead of up in clear space?
- m4rtink 5y agoThere are some (that are also likely not affected by Starlink at all)! Some observe high energy particles as they produce visible ligh as they break in the atmosphere. Also some neutrino telescopes use a lot of water or ice to observe neutrino collision with the given dense yet transparent mass.
- phreeza 5y agoMaybe I am a bit naive, but I don't understand how this is a big problem. Sure it would have been a problem in the past where long exposures were captured to film, where one satellite streak may overexpose the entire frame. But in the digital era, it will always be 100% known where the satellites were at a given point in time, so why can't software be used to exclude the affected frames and pixels for analysis? Surely that would not result in a very large amount of data being lost?
- petschge 5y agoBecause telescopes are so sensitive that the reflections of a bright satellite inside the optics bascially ruin all pixels in the frame. And there is so many satellite that all frames close to dusk/dawn are impacted. So you loose 1/3 of your observing time. And all of the time in which you are geometrically most likely to find object on orbits that intersect the Earth orbit.
- sebzim4500 5y agoThat works when there are only a few thousand satellites, or when you have a very low FOV, but once you have 100k+ satellites or you are doing a sky survey that becomes unfeasible. This interview goes really in depth on these issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0w0dM_e9a8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0w0dM_e9a8
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoIt's mostly solved for well-funded researchers with modern professional-grade telescopes and professional-grade analysis software. That's far from pervasive. "100% known" is overstating the situation, there's no easy-to-use API for an amateur to query location, date and time, alignment, frames, and pixels to get the location of satellites. Amateurs with basic software - or researchers who don't have the funding/equipment/software triad - just pointing a DSLR at the sky have to manually stack their images, for these users it's far easier to use a long exposure. The other problem is that sensor thermal and atmospheric noise vs. photon signal ratio is mitigated by long exposures in a way that's not the same as stacking short-exposure images, each with their own changing contribution to noise.
- dorchadas 5y agoReminds me of another interesting thread on the topic, from January: "What do we lose when we lose the stars?"[0] Sadly, it seems many on HN don't seem to feel anything towards the dark sky at night. I wonder if it's because most people grew up in an urban area? I'm from a rural area and always had a stunning view of the night sky and would truly miss it, and feel like something of inconceivable value is lost if it just becomes a flickering mass of satellites moving around. It's something I'd love future generations to be able to have, especially as we're already going to be depriving them of so much given our current tendencies. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25969823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25969823
- verdverm 5y agoThis assumes satellite constellations will actually effect the night sky, which it does not appear to generally be the case. From what I understand, it's easier to remove satellites from images than airplanes
- jaqalopes 5y agoGo out on a clear night in any reasonably dark place and look up. The satellites are there, faint tiny moving stars. The human eye is not a camera. The human soul is not an SD card.
- verdverm 5y agoIt's a tradeoff which I am personally OK with.
- 8note 5y agoim not sure how souls and SD cards come into this.
- jaqalopes 5y agoThe post to which I was replying framed the problem as affecting imaging devices. I was introducing a new angle which is the human side, which was admittedly not part of the original article but nevertheless felt important to the conversation.
- swayvil 5y agoThe usual lizards are looking to score a piece of Starlink. Mark my words, these astronomers are pure astroturf.
- lpolovets 5y agoHow much light pollution will this actually create? I've read that SpaceX wants to launch 40k satellites that are 200 miles above earth. Each satellite is the size of a table. Could one see a table-sized satellite 200 miles away? Also given the surface area of the earth, the satellite density would be something like one every 50k square miles. How meaningful is that when it comes to light polution down at the surface of earth? How about for astronomers?
- agloeregrets 5y agoThe issue is for long exposure capture needed for quality astronomy. In that context any reflection from the sun on a satellite can trash any shot in an instant. SpaceX has tried to reduce the reflectivity of the Starlink sats but they still are a factor. Supposedly it was actually really bad at first.
- lpolovets 5y agoThanks!
- elihu 5y agoDoes that actually affect real science, or is it just a matter of astophotographers wanting a nice picture without streaks? It's not like long exposures have to be done on film these days. Anomalous light sources can be removed in software. I think if this is affecting basic science it's a real concern, but if it's just a matter of making long exposures of galaxies and nebulas less pretty then I have a hard time being overly concerned about it.
- cameronbrown 5y ago> Could one see a table-sized satellite 200 miles away? We could see many of them with just eyesight when they first went up. Proper instruments are definitely going to pick that up.
- durnygbur 5y agoI can easily observe moving (Starlink?) satellites on the night sky in a city in Central Europe.
- autocorr 5y agoLight pollution from satellite swarms is an economic externality. Any company can dump sewage in the river (and maybe the sewage is necessary for progress!) but the private sector profits by consuming a shared resource. For the night sky and astronomy the externality is not so great in the grand scheme, but if unmitigated it does mean that there will be fewer discoveries per taxpayer dollar sent to the NSF/NASA. I'm a postdoc in astronomy and am all aboard Starlink-style networking. But it also seems fair to me that SpaceX should be the party that's responsible for treating that externality with light pollution, or else it's the same old "privatize the gains and socialize the cleanup." We've already effectively achieved this for radio astronomy by regulating protected bands in the spectrum for passive listening.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't know that the externality comparison and compensation is self evident. it is possible that the positive externalities of satellite swarms outweigh that of ground based astronomy, and they should be prioritized for the visual spectrum.
- CamperBob2 5y agoKey word being "ground based." SpaceX's work will likely lead to much wider access to space-based telescopes. That may turn out to be a more-than-fair tradeoff. The other thing about LEO constellations is that they're not permanent. A polluted river may not clean itself up automatically after a couple of years, but LEO will. We can change our minds about the utility of LEO Internet constellations at any time. There seems no real downside to deploying them and seeing if all stakeholders can find reasonable grounds for compromise.
- wolfram74 5y agostarlink is low enough that it will clean itself /relatively/ quickly, but even doubling the elevation get's into some very long lived debris[0]. If you wanted to tax these mega constellations to mitigate the externality they're causing, directing 2 to 3% towards orbital telescope production/launch costs arguably would be the most immediate remedy. [0]https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/1407747990287171587 https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/1407747990287171587
- gego 5y agoA treaty would be great... or a lot of school projects on how to down low orbit sats... that would make such a treaty more likely :P
- Mizza 5y agoIt's the pollution of space and desecration of the common heritage of all mankind. All of our pictures of space look like this now: https://twitter.com/StarlinkPollut1/status/1253666654560624640/photo/1 https://twitter.com/StarlinkPollut1/status/12536666545606246... A bleak visual reminder of how billionaires exploit free externalities to keep us all in a prison.
- LatteLazy 5y agoWe just need a small tax on satellites (linked to their reflectivity etc) ring fenced to pay for more space based telescopes...
- rtkwe 5y agoThe largest ground based mirrors are pushing 30m now while the largest space mirror we've built (but not launched) is the JWST at 6.5 which requires a complicated folding mechanism to achieve because it has to fit in a faring. So to make one 30m telescope in space we'd need around 20 JWST sized telescopes plus the cost of launching and assembling them in space which currently means using people. That's far from a small tax.
- inlikealamb 5y agoSeems like a per-satellite tax could incentivize reducing the number of satellites where possible, and could help fund some of the research hindered by too-many satellites.
- mberning 5y agoThe undersides are going to have to be painted in vantablack or something similar. Then I’m sure people will notice dark streaks on their photos. But it will at least be a bit better.
- rtkwe 5y agoThey've trialed a couple darker bottomed satellites but they still left streaks across the images. If you get too black the satellites will need bigger heat management fins which can also catch light along with the solar panels.
- simion314 5y agoWhy I have the felling that all the SpaceX fanboys would have the exact opposite opinions if this would be Chinese satellites, - they could use fewer - I am from US why Chinese internet shoudl affect me China, Russia, India will also want their own constellations so I am waiting for when this happen and the hypocrisy starts.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThe SpaceX fanboy reaction would 100% be "This is impressive, but it's crazy that we've let China beat us in the race to universal broadband. The US needs to catch up!" The "SpaceX fanboy" mindset is about a belief that humanity has a future outside the earth. Not about jingoism. I've seen literally nobody rooting for the Chinese space station to fail, or the Chinese rovers to crash on Mars.
- simion314 5y agoMaybe, but what I see from Musk fans is a lot of statistics and reality bending. so, on short example,you have dudes in big cities with more shit internet then me in a village in eastern Europe so they are pushing for 10000+ of satellites to pollute the entire planet because they and their elected people are incapable of running some cables. Sure, put internet satellites up for the people in isolated places but use the right tool for the job and use cables for the rest, you will use less satellites in the end. Also maybe we should demand this satellites to be placed in a stable geocentrically orbit so it only affects the country of origin.
- bpodgursky 5y ago(1) Latency would be extremely high in geosynchronous orbit. It's a very high orbit. (2) Geosynchronous only works for countries on the equator. There's no such thing as a stable orbit at any orbital inclination (ie, you cannot cover Canada at all).
- simion314 5y ago
- ashneo76 5y agoHow many of those who are saying that this is for the greater good could be bothered to call up and fight for local fiber. Comcast and ATT spend billions in a town and stall that and that ad campaign gets you side tracked. Your inabilities at distinguishing the fake from truth shouldn't take away the night sky from all of us. Go fight the big companies instead of sitting here and talking. Start a local WISP. Stop waiting for the billionaires to save you. This is exactly how the rich stay rich. By dividing us and preying on the natural resources. Nobody goes and fights BSNL in India or the local telecoms in Philippines to establish better wireless links. This is basically moving the goalposts from one duopoly to another one soon. For those that haven't seen the sky, go take a trip to natural park. This is akin to saying, I don't use sea water because it is salty. Let some company mine to for oil, because it is for the "greater good" Nobody should be apologizing for a company. Companies as is cause as much harm as possible. We need better regulation to put checks in these comments and rich ass billionaires who think the world is their toy.
- supperburg 5y agoI want a mesh of satellites around the earth. I’m a normal guy who’s has wanted that before anyone was doing it. I don’t think I was brain washed by the billionaire sat mesh propaganda, probably because it doesn’t exist. Huh. I don’t think your position is very strong. Your team isn’t very large. The vast majority of people live in super light polluted areas, light pollution that takes a way bigger bite out of the night sky than sats ever will. And they don’t seem to care. Plus you have the fact that this emerging space industry, the only part of which you seem to be able to appreciate is low earth orbit, will bring people closer to space than ever before. So who are you to deny space and astronomy enthusiasts of the future the opportunity to actually be in space and experience the stars from there? For real. Minimal changes to the night sky especially for people (majority) who aren’t into space. Revolution in prices that cascades to space telescopes and actual space tourism and multi planetary society. have you lost your mind?
- foobiekr 5y agoThere's a big difference. We can (and should) fix light pollution incrementally. Once we are dependent on satellite arrays, we will never fix it.
- SeanFerree 5y agoI agree! This is much needed
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 5y agoIf the UN could do anything useful like bring 5G to the ultra poor than sure I'll listen then. But they can't even stop mass killings. Until then the rich can send their telescopes to space. It's not like everyone else gets to go to work and not see ads and other junk. And the primative-ness of watching space from a gravity well is depressing.
- CarelessExpert 5y agoThere will be no debate. This is just another commons, and we all know what happens to the commons when private industry is given a free pass to exploit them. It'll be just another tragedy.
- robscallsign 5y agoLiving in "rural" Canada, 7 miles from a municipality of 160,000 people, getting Starlink a few months ago has been an absolute quantum leap in terms of our connectivity. In the 7 years living here our LTE internet plans have literally gotten twice as expensive: with plans going from 100GB total bandwidth up/down for ~$165CAD (after tax) to 50GB total bandwidth up/down for the same price. During that time I've seen nothing but empty promises and talk by political parties and telecoms. Apparently they're spending millions and doing something, but I haven't seen any results other than taxes going up, and data plans shrinking. In that same time period Space-X and Starlink have literally redesigned space flight and created an entirely new telecom paradigm. I only hope Starlink starts to offer home phone service in addition to internet to further erode the market of incumbents here in Canada. As much as I wish everyone in the globe a beautiful unblemished view of the night sky, a couple of thoughts: (IANAA - I am not an astronomer) * Light pollution in cities already affects the majority of the global population. * There are already satellites in the night sky. It seems like a slippery slope of drawing a line when it becomes a problem. * Astronomy for cutting edge R&D/exploration already seem to be limited by terrestrial astronomy - islands in the pacific are denying access to culturally important mountain tops for new telescopes, atmospheric distortion, cloud cover, light pollution from cities * Isn't the prospect of cheaper commercial spaceflight potentially better for research astronomy? Let's get these telescope platforms into space! Anyway, as with everything, I suspect military control/government security considerations will end up being the overriding decision making factor governing these sorts of global mega-constellations rather than such noble and pure pursuits as preserving the nights sky.
- mrpopo 5y agoIf your government is bad at installing fiber/high-speed internet connectivity to a not-so-rural town of 160,000, you have to fix your government, don't just throw money at global unregulated corporations. This is a common thread in the US/Canada where governments are so bad at their job that people just came to hate the idea of public infrastructure as a result.
- robscallsign 5y agoIn this instance I feel like loudly claiming that I'm paying for Starlink is the best use of my consumer voice. There are dozens of us!
- publicola1990 5y agoI really wonder if this is a real issue or not or is some edge cases being hyped up and being projected as a grave crisis? For example while in earth shadow these satellites would be dark and not visible. Only in cases where observer on dark side earth surface while satellite is at elevation still able catch the sun, would these satellite be visible? Somewhere I read that there are two kinds of arguments or dialogue that can be made: scientific (or rational) and poetic. One must be very careful of those who insidiously offer a poetic argument in the guise of a scientific argument. I fear that's what might be happening with the arguments on this subject.
- rtkwe 5y agoThis is what a telescope sees when Starlink crosses it's view during an observation. They have a picture of what they look like in the article too btw... https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/spacexs-dark-satellites-are-still-too-bright-for-astronomers/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/spacexs-dark-sate...
- publicola1990 5y agoI don't deny that under certain conditions it can appear in images. But these conditions need to be weighed in while discussing the merits on this issue. And the article is silent on this.
- rtkwe 5y agoFrom this image it looks like they'll be visible pretty high in the sky so it'll be an issue over a significant portion of the sky. If you've ever looked at the ISS that orbits below the Starlink constellation so it's more in the Earth's shadow than the Starlink constellation will be and it's visible all over the night sky.
- Trias11 5y agoI'm all against Starlink polluting until i learned how shitty Cox is. As they say - "communist until you get rich, feminist until you get married." Etc...
- issa 5y agoI think this is one of those problems where the only solution is to go forward. Astronomy will be done in the future off-Earth. It will take a long time to get there, but that's the real solution.
- tuatoru 5y agoI thought someone in Shenzen would already be making telescope sats and selling them on AliExpress. Apparently not. Yet...
- dividedbyzero 5y agoWon't there be a lot of constellations up there, possibly soon-ish? I can't imagine SpaceX will remain the only ones who can do this for very long. They are very innovative, but once they figure out how to make those cheap launches a boring process, I guess espionage will take care of transferring that knowledge elsewhere. When it becomes clear what such a constellation can do, no doubt it will become a strategic asset – no way the Chinese will be content to just buy access from a US company. Militaries will be very interested – put cheap-ish sensing capabilities on those birds, or decent ones on some, and you get a pretty decent global surveillance network on top of very useful infrastructure and low-latency, possibly even quite covert global communication infra that can't be taken out with existing tech. And maybe some of those constellations will use higher orbits and care less about the night sky, and that's it for spotting the Milky Way without a computer processing out the bright flashes. That's not a happy thought.
- bob1029 5y agoWhat if Elon started putting telescopes on the back of every starlink satellite and provided the raw live data as a public service? I think there would be plenty of bandwidth to spare for this sort of mission enhancement.