8 ms·
> Many of them want a partner–they’ll be in charge of the idea, and I’ll execute it. Boy, does that sound familiar. In my experience, they'll also get most of
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
> Many of them want a partner–they’ll be in charge of the idea, and I’ll execute it.
Boy, does that sound familiar. In my experience, they'll also get most of the money and credit, and will plan to kick me to the curb, once it gets to alpha.
> I hate to break it to you, but your idea–any idea, really–is worthless. An idea only has value when it is executed, and it only has a lot of value when it’s executed well.
And that "executed well" is important. I have seen so many promising ideas and systems destroyed by being written by "lowest common denominator" implementation talent.
- mysterydip 5y agoIf I could upvote this more than once I would. When people hear that I'm a hobbyist game developer (video and board), a significant number of them will say (paraphrased) "I've got this great idea for a game, would you make it for me?" I've learned to just say "maybe someday when I'm not so busy," because the truth of the article offends too many of them.
- silexia 5y agoThe same principle applies to patents. Ideas are worthless, but execution is everything. Patents prevent other people from executing on an idea, meaning you are stuck with an obnoxious patent troll controlling the idea forever. We need to abolish patents.
- gwright 5y agofalse dichotomy
- wizzwizz4 5y ago> Patents prevent other people from executing on an idea, meaning you are stuck with an obnoxious patent troll controlling the idea forever. Better than an obnoxious oligarch controlling all ideas forever, which could happen if you completely abolish patents. Do you have any more nuanced (i.e. realistic) suggestions for reform?
- flavius29663 5y agoSerious question: how would an oligarch control anything in a patent-less world? I mean, you just have an idea for a SQL Server, you just go ahead and do it, how does the oligarch stop you exactly?
- nxrabl 5y agoI think your example is interesting because it shows just how much we’ve all been spoiled by software. If you have a great idea for a piece of software, you can code it up on your own or in a small team for more-or-less ‘free’, minus time and opportunity costs. As soon as your idea has a physical component, though, you have to start worrying about manufacturing and logistics and materials and personnel and space, all of which are costly and time-consuming and finite. What if your idea requires negotiating for land rights to build infrastructure? What if you need to build an assembly line to manufacture your product at scale? If you’re competing against a counterparty with effectively infinite money, you might need all of the lead time a patent gives you to level the playing field.
- kiba 5y agoAs opposed to a corporation with effectively infinite money preventing the development of 3D printing as an industry and a hobby because they sat on their patents until it expired?
- flavius29663 5y agoI don't see how this is different today. If you're a small guy with a patent trying to bring to market a physical product before a giant...good luck with that. I can think of several examples where a large company stuns the development of a technology just because they can (3D printing, LCD monitors, electric cars, e-ink). Can you give me some examples from today where a startup used the patents as a sufficient moat to get to success? There are many successful startups, I am referring to specifically some that were protected by patents. Even if you do, the second you do it and it sells, it gets copied in China faster that you can say IP.
- flavius29663 5y agoI think the patents might have had a good role sometimes in the past, when small people could protect themselves from the big guys. Or protect small guys stealing each other's work. These days, the big guys can just trample over small ones, and use the list of patents they have as a counter-sue threat against other big guys. Small guys are constantly threatened by big guys with patent lawsuits, they can't really dream about enforcing a patent a large guy. Even if they have the perfect patent they just get bought up for it. And now the patent is part of that big list mentioned above, where it can be used for development or just sit in a drawer and have the project killed just so that competition can't use it. Say you manage to fix this, but then you go to China and they will copy everything you do and sell an exact replica the next day with impunity. There is no win, I don't see any benefit of patents in the western world today, they're only used to slow technological progress - the exact opposite of the intent. What am I missing here? This is a very shallow take with my little knowledge, but I just don't see the benefits of patents.
- kiba 5y agoI think the patents might have had a good role sometimes in the past, when small people could protect themselves from the big guys. Or protect small guys stealing each other's work. OK. Has this ever been true? I remembered a story about the Wright brothers suing competitors and engaging in a patent war, instead of spending their time and energy continuing to innovate. Say you manage to fix this, but then you go to China and they will copy everything you do and sell an exact replica the next day with impunity. Is this necessarily a bad thing? These Chinese firms made open source 3D printers more accessible to the hobbyist communities, and some of them are even known for quality. Granted, some of them cut corners so much that a burning 3d printer became a meme. 3D printing as a hobby only becomes a thing once the patent expired. I am sympathetic to the idea of the small inventor trying to make it in the world. But people, big and small, corporations and individuals, can and did abuse patents, even innovators.
- bmn__ 5y ago> Is this necessarily a bad thing? It pains me that I have to explain this to adults on HN, but: yes, this is bad. The foreign investor/customer paid dearly with time and money for the research and development. The factory runs an additional night shift and makes another batch of product. They then sell the night shift products at a reduced price undercutting the original vendor because they do not have to recoup the development costs. The vendor with the higher price cannot sell his stock of product because the demand is already satisfied from the cheaper night shift product.
- justin_oaks 5y ago... or only grant patents if the inventor has a fully functional prototype of their idea.
- Tom4hawk 5y agoIt works like that in many countries...
- analog31 5y agoI'm not a patent lawyer... In principle, a patent is supposed to cover this. The text of the patent has to provide a recipe for reducing the idea to practice. As I understand it, if the recipe is unworkable, the patent is void. Whether the patent office is stringent enough about this requirement is an open question of course. It may vary from one field to another. For instance, a patent for a new kind of optical lens is required to include a complete "prescription" for the lens, which is recognized as a sufficient set of data needed to replicate the idea. (One of my patents is like that).
- hansvm 5y agoIMO we'd be better off without intellectual property at all, but it's probably worth pointing out that weaker measures can accomplish a similar goal. If independent invention were a valid defense and the terms were a bit shorter then the only patents which would actually affect your business would be those which you legitimately couldn't come up with on your own (which seems like the point of the whole system -- you get a monopoly and we get blueprints in return). Shorter terms of 5-10 yrs would allow for faster iteration on important ideas. Alternatively, compulsory license agreements like you have for some aspects of music could substantially reduce the chilling effect on new inventions. You don't have to worry about somebody suing for multiples of revenue; you just always have the ability to pay a reasonable royalty -- the patent owner still gets handsomely compensated, but important new inventions can start rolling out immediately. Or else if the bar to get patents were a little higher then the system would work a lot more smoothly. The fact that cloudflare was able to invalidate the vast majority of patents when a troll sued them strongly indicates they shouldn't have been awarded in the first place even under current guidelines.
- antihero 5y ago> we'd be better off without intellectual property at all So there's absolutely nothing at all to prevent a situation where you put time and money into developing something, and as soon as it gets legs, a megacorp instead of buying you out or licensing it from you, just copies it and pushes you out of the market?
- kiba 5y agoThere's also nothing preventing a megacorporation from preemptively inventing and patenting everything under the sun. They also have infinite money to fight patent lawsuits. Moreover, these patent lawsuits mean that said inventors spend more time talking to their lawyers instead of getting these inventions to market.
- hansvm 5y agoIs that worse than the current situation where you accidentally infringe on a dozen patents from the megacorp's warchest and get sued to oblivion if you don't quietly agree to their favorite terms? Is that worse than all the innovation being stifled by agreements requiring work on your own time and dime to belong to your employer? Are first-mover advantages and other sources of natural monopolies not really that important in building your moat? Is intellectual property the right mechanism for limiting megacorp power? I'm open to the idea of some intellectual property rights remaining (like the "natural rights" you see in a lot of the world, or retaining current trade secret laws), but I still think we'd be in a better place than we are now if the current system were completely abolished.
- didgeoridoo 5y agoForever? Patents have a 20-year lifespan and require you to disclose your methodology, allowing others to copy your idea as soon as your exclusivity period is up. In a world without patents, small inventors would have their ideas stolen immediately by corporations that have the resources to build and sell the invention.
- kiba 5y agoForever? Patents have a 20-year lifespan and require you to disclose your methodology, allowing others to copy your idea as soon as your exclusivity period is up. In a world without patents, small inventors would have their ideas stolen immediately by corporations that have the resources to build and sell the invention. The big corporations have the resources to build and sell the invention and defend against a patent lawsuit regardless. Moreover, the big corporations already can use patents against smaller competitors and can fund more R&D to get patents and can simply sit on it. Also, it isn't always a good idea to disclose how your stuff work. For example, SpaceX doesn't do that because the Chinese government will copy their stuff. Not that it matters. The problem with the space industry is that the old space contractors and governments rest on their laurel even when SpaceX became the Goliath of the Space industry.
- voakbasda 5y agoThat theft happens now. Small fish cannot compete with big fish without risking getting eaten alive. You think one pathetic patent would stand up against a FAANG’s warchest, if they really wanted to implement it? They will use your idea and bury you with their own patent portfolio, unless you license it under terms that are generous and favorable to their interests. If you want to play hardball, they will use their lawyers to drown you in legal debt before a judge ever hears the case. In this light, it should be clear that innovation has been completely crushed under the heel of the present system of fascist corporatism. Eliminating patents will not solve that overarching problem, though we know such an outcome would never be permitted to happen. Patent pools do not solve it, as that sacrifices the autonomy and independence that is the very essence of being a small fish.
- 5y ago
- lostcolony 5y agoYeah...I recall a family member telling me once "I have this great idea for a novel", and I immediately tuned out. I'm not a writer, but I know that -everyone- has a great idea for a novel. The difference between authors and everyone else is the authors did the work to actually get it down, edited, and published (to where I even have a little respect for the people who self-publish obvious vanity projects, simply for the fact they had the self-discipline to actually sit down and get it on a page).
- ben_w 5y agoAs I’ve been working on my first novel since 2016… I agree completely. An idea isn’t much without the effort backing it up.
- theshadowknows 5y agoMy father-in-law wrote five books during his lifetime. To his credit, they were ok. But he refused to ever work with an editor. And thus none were ever published.
- codazoda 5y agoI wrote a book on how to publish your ebook. The people who read it seem to love it but I haven't marketed it real well. In any case, you might find it interesting if you want to publish your own book or if you wanted to publish your father-in-laws unfinished books. There's even a bit of information in there about using your computers text-to-speech tool for editing. You have it read the book back to you in order to catch mistakes. https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B00A4112ZM https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B00A4112ZM
- andai 5y agoThe text to speech idea is brilliant. I've read some books several times in print, but many finer details escaped me until I listened to the audio version.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI've had great ideas for novels ... until I started to write them. Then I realize there has to be a middle too. And it has to be interesting to read.
- 271828182846 5y agohave you considered creating a fake or 2nd account?
- JKCalhoun 5y agoLOL, so often.... I tell them instead, "Great idea, you should learn to program so that you can write it." While that sounds snarky, I am sincere. I explain to them that is exactly why I am a programmer: I wanted to write my own computer games so badly that I learned programming in order to do it. I should add, since developing for iOS, now it's "I've got a great idea for an iPhone app!"
- paulintrognon 5y agoWhat I do is I explain to them the concept of MVP and tell them to come back with specifications for one. Noone ever came back yet...
- tisdadd 5y agoI make apps and nearly everyone says, "I have a great app idea." Not a one has checked if this idea exists. I had to send a friend this article as he is fairly blunt but wants to dump ideas a lot. Your response is a good one for most people.
- celticninja 5y agoI had a similar experience, they were really cagey even sharing the idea in case I stole it. Searched play store and app store as she told me about it and there were dozens of this type of app already.
- jerf 5y agoStatistically speaking, if you have an idea for an app, and there aren't already apps for it, you have an idea that there is no way to make money with. I'm sure there's a lot of spaces where there's room for a better app, but I can't imagine there's much space left for money-making apps that have no competition today. I believe there are such spaces, but we're probably talking species-wide blind spots at that point, and you probably aren't the first to penetrate whatever the veil is.
- mnowicki 5y agoIf trying to come up with one of these ideas anyway, that is a good way to find one. Ask yourself, if there is one thing that I might be able to think of, that almost nobody else in the world can, what would it be? What unique combination of experiences, perspectives, talents, etc do I have that is extremely uncommon and what unique ideas can I think of because of this? Not super practical in this case since the odds of success are still pretty low(but not 0), but looking at things this way can be useful in other scenarios as well. It's kind of similar to how I often spin negative experiences into a positive in my head, they're still experiences and experiences can always be useful, especially if they're unique
- conductr 5y agoSome people I like to hear out. Then I'll maybe discuss the merits of the idea, meanwhile tally in my head and leave it as "well, sounds great, would probably take me about 4 months to build it. You could probably get it done in 1 month if you had $x?xx,xxx to put into it"
- 1123581321 5y agoAren’t most of their ideas bad, though? That’s my issue with this article; usually both the idea and the execution is lacking.
- Werewolf255 5y agoThis is a great summation of the article. The pandemic gave me the time to start executing some of my favorite ideas and it's really something to see features drop off the timeline as the execution complexities start to spin out geometrically.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI've had a whole bunch of random people message me to implement their idea for some small fraction of equity. They want 95% for their one pager.
- k__ 5y agolol, reminds me of some guys that once contacted me. "We are five business people who have a cool idea for an app and now we need you to build with us!" Like, even IF we would split equity equally, 6 people to start with, wth?
- JKCalhoun 5y agoSplit? How good of an idea would they still think it is if you told them to pay you hourly ($$$!) and they could split the profits five ways?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- swayvil 5y agoTen million authors throughout time, and maybe the scurrying multitudes of the social media scene, might suggest that just communicating the idea renders substantial value all by itself. Unless you consider successful communication an "execution" phaze. But ya, if we're talking about "making machines". You could call that a way of communicating via solid example. It reminds me of the generative art scene. So many valuable ideas communicated via relatively lightweight example. More lightweight than, say, a whole big game.
- user3939382 5y agoIt’s very funny that this is the top comment, because just seeing the headline before seeing the comments or article the first thing that came to mind was all the people that have approached me to be 50/50 partners where their 50% was having an idea and mine was spending months programming and designing.
- mywacaday 5y agoAre there any good examples where the opposite is true, i.e. a relatively terrible idea executed so well it succeeds?
- adventured 5y agoIf it succeeds, there's a pretty serious question about whether it was actually a terrible idea. I'd be doubtful about the premise accordingly. I think the successful outcome is inherently invalidating of the notion it was a terrible idea. I've been reading about business history for decades, I enjoy it. I can't think of an example that matches that setup. Ideas like the pet rock or chia pet or electronic dancing flower pots jump to mind, however my thinking is immediately that: well, they weren't such terrible ideas then, lots of people wanted to buy those things. A combination of disposable income and endless desire to be amused/entertained, is a potent consumption formula. The pet rock for example was a relatively inexpensive tchotchke of very temporary curiosity and amusement. People love to be amused, entertained and to have trinkets to talk about or show off. A lot of seemingly bad ideas fall into that space.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThat's true. "Terrible" is in the eye of the beholder. Many, many companies make bank, by taking classic ideas, and executing them well. It's like Joe Cocker made many obscure songs into mega-hits.
- username90 5y agoIf other companies are making lots profit doing something then it isn't a terrible idea. A terrible idea is trying to build something that will never make lots of money, like the pet dating sites or so.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoLike the songs that Joe Cocker often covered, the ideas may be languishing, with little-to-moderate success. Until done properly, or combined with other ideas or good marketing. Until they make money, they are derided as "terrible ideas."
- fnord77 5y agoJobs/Woz?
- ipiz0618 5y agoYeah I've been there, being the person who executed the idea. It sucked knowing the person giving the "idea" (which I actually gave most of the directions) had so much leisure time for fun, while I was sitting there coding something I'm not interested in. I only execute my own ideas now. Even sometimes I can't finish it, I can only blame myself.
- elcomet 5y agoWell there is much more to do than coding... They should be doing sales and marketing and other stuff. If they're doing nothing, that's a bad sign
- ryandrake 5y agoEven that's lopsided. Assuming the idea is purely software (no hardware manufacturing involved), then the vast majority of the actual work is to make the product. I would not accept a 50/50 split where he "has the idea" and I do the software. I wouldn't even accept a 50/50 split if the Idea Partner also does a little sales and marketing. I would maybe accept 50/50 if the Idea Partner also provided all the capital. Now we're talking...
- MajorBee 5y agoIf your "ideas man" has fully committed to doing all the sales/marketing and the dance of raising capital, leaving you to work on the product, I think that's a very fair division of labour. After all, a finished product is almost as worthless as an unexecuted idea if no one ever actually purchases or uses said product. I say almost because, in theory, your product could have enough "obvious" value on its own that you could just sell it to another company and exit comfortably.
- dequor 5y agoBut now they are taking all the risk and it would make sense to just pay you a salary and keep the 100%
- leoc 5y ago
- an_opabinia 5y agoIf the son of a Tencent executive had a video game idea, it has a ton of value. I don’t know, there are a lot of games out there that are “well executed” that no one plays. Lots of indie developers who repeatedly make hits, and yet still no one finds (or finds) their next game. These takes are kind of obnoxious.
- uncomputation 5y agoIf we followed your line of thinking, we’d never have Doom. You’re just unabashedly proposing a plutocracy.
- username90 5y agoYou couldn't be more wrong, do you have a single example of a rich kid with an idea spending many millions to make others build a game and it was successful? I haven't heard that happen even once! The reason AAA developers almost never innovate and instead just release the same game year after year with new sequels is that good game ideas are extremely rare. Most games wont sell well enough to make back the money if you pour 100 million into making them, so each AAA studio haves one or two ideas that they know will sell and then they just repeat it. Indie developer are the ones building new ideas and they do it for a very small amount of money. See factorio, hollow knight, valheim, darkest dungeons etc, lots of games that sold many millions beating many AAA studio products with new ideas and very modest budgets.
- an_opabinia 5y agoBrandon Beck and Marc Merrill were rich kids who spent millions on other people to develop League of Legends. We don’t talk about them as indie developers obviously, even though in 2009 they were independently publishing (and continuing to independently publish) because the formula of capital, namely a rich kid, is really successful in gaming. It just goes to show how obnoxious, again, this kind of take is. I don’t get why people are so obsessed with purity of creation in games.
- username90 5y ago
- sam0x17 5y agoTrue, but you can also make a career out of preying on these types.
- starkd 5y agoAlso, there's more than one way to execute an idea. If they are executed simultaneously, the better execution will win, making the alternates worthless. The implementation itself IS the business. Ideas are a dime a dozen.