13 ms·
Private Israeli spyware used to hack cellphones of journalists, activists
- fma 5y agoSo - I guess everyone should use WeChat? Because I'm sure the Chinese government wouldn't put up with Israeli software being able to capture that data.
- mandeepj 5y agoThey are hacking OS. So, WeChat switch would not help
- jokoon 5y agoI'm not even surprised. Snowden needs to repeat and remind people, over and over, that people should just not trust their electronics if they are doing sensitive work that somebody powerful elsewhere (government or a rich company) might not like. I'm also curious how whatsapp/facebook will respond to those vulns. Hard to really trust them at all, it's really easy to imagine a conspiracy theory when intelligence agency negotiate inserting backdoors into popular software. I'm really discouraged from working in computer security, it really looks like a shady industry.
- pmoriarty 5y agoI hate to say it, but if what you're communicating could risk your life or that of someone else you might want to avoid using computers to communicate it altogether. Old-school techniques such as physically smuggling microdots[1] seem much safer than relying on any computer technology, which can always be hacked. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microdot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microdot
- dogorman 5y agoIf these hacking firms succeed in chasing journalists off digital communication, I think the totalitarian regimes they serve will consider that "a win."
- pmoriarty 5y agoIt's arguably an even bigger "win" for them if they kill off or imprison those journalists.
- dogorman 5y agoThey're doing that too... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Jamal_Khashoggi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Jamal_Khashog... These firms are helping authoritarian regimes kill and imprison journalists. The journalists who survive by being paranoid will be made less effective by having to use less effective methods of communication, which likely aren't understood by the people journalists talk to (whistleblowers, witnesses, etc.)
- dillondoyle 5y agoThe articles show that his wife (or whoever was his partner idk status) was hacked around the time of his murder. Also reports Mexican journalist was hacked, then executed right after at an obscure location. Heavily implies GPS tracking was used for the hit.
- buran77 5y agoOld-school techniques were hard to pull off even by trained spies with a proper (and vast) support network, let alone by journalists and John Rando who have never met. If you're on a watch list that gets your phone flagged for malware then it's not a stretch to assume that you can also be physically watched. And meeting in person with journalists or sources while being under surveillance is like painting a target on your back. And that's before considering that a journalist would never have a realistic chance to meet potential sources under repressive regimes on the other side of the world, certainly not a useful number. Computers and encryption made this kind of covert communication far more accessible to the laymen. Anything that sets that back just deters people from even trying and this is exactly the chilling effect those oppressive regimes are looking for.
- pmoriarty 5y ago
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoJournalism is already a profession running on fumes (literally, in the past. More metaphorically, today). It's just not feasible to do without technology. People sometimes seem to imagine some world inhibited by security-conscious professions that is more akin to a slick movie than real life. Witness the common believe that, say, blocking websites at DNS levels has zero impact on crime because it's easy to circumvent. Real-life criminals, journalists, or activists prefer Telegram over code tattooed on a messenger's scalp for the same reason we all do: hair grows too slow and nobody is getting on international flights right now. I know it's fun to imagine all these activities involving "threat actors" and steganographic key exchanges via Pornhub (Alex and Bob getting on?). But that road leads to busywork that doesn't get any corrupt politician's name on that white page.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI think if you sell an exploit and it's used in a crime you should be held accountable as if you sold a weapon to an enemy.
- slg 5y agoWould you want people who develop encryption algorithms held accountable if those algorithms are used to hide illegal activities?
- DangitBobby 5y agoWe can pick and choose.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoNo
- slg 5y agoHow is it different? They are tools that can be used for both legal and illegal means. If you put legal responsibility on one toolmaker to ensure their tools are not used in an illegal fashion, why wouldn't you do the same for other toolmakers?
- zatertip 5y agoIsn't that obvious? An exploit is to encryption as a sword is to a shield. We don't regulate shields.
- slg 5y agoA shield can inflict damage just like a sword can. Encryption hiding the details of a murder plot can be just as crucial as an exploit that reveals a murder target's location.
- 5y ago
- cf100clunk 5y agoEarlier post on this story from a different consortium member: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27874027 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27874027
- tosh 5y agoGuardian: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/18/revealed-leak-uncovers-global-abuse-of-cyber-surveillance-weapon-nso-group-pegasus https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/18/revealed-leak-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ackbar03 5y agoAren't these private hacking companies breaking the law though? Does anyone know why no one has sued them or arrested them or something? From what I understand in most cases, any attempts to reverse engineer or exploit any system is against terms of service with the offender held liable. Some teenager who comes up with a game hack can be slapped with a massive fine, but these hacking companies aren't even breaking the law? How does that work? Cause I think I'm in the wrong game
- markus_zhang 5y agoThose guys don't care about laws.
- dogma1138 5y agoNot anymore than a defense contractor is breaking the law. Their sells are export controlled in a similar manner that arms sales are.
- Ygg2 5y agoIt's easier to go against a Chiuaua, than a dire wolf. Same with suits.
- ruined 5y agonso group is based in israel. suing them for activities directed by the israeli state is not likely to be effective. it would be like trying to sue a ransomware group in russia, or a phone company in america.
- azernik 5y agoIn this case it's not directed by the Israeli state; the Israeli state just doesn't really care, and doesn't want to interfere with the post-army job prospects of intelligence personnel.
- sva_ 5y ago> The Israeli minister of defence closely regulates NSO, granting individual export licences before its surveillance technology can be sold to a new country.
- SpywareThrow 5y agoFirst Hollywood, then media, then computers, now this. Not surprised in the least.
- halotrope 5y agoIt would be really nice if I could own my phone to the point where I could install an outgoing firewall or harden the os to my abilities instead of blind trust into the diligent but not infallible vendor.
- colordrops 5y agohttps://grapheneos.org/ https://grapheneos.org/
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoCat and mouse game. The foundations of computing must be completely reworked if we are to ever have any real security.
- Zigurd 5y agoYou have touched on the real problem: Most of our digital devices have way too many attack surfaces. If you can secure a movie from being copied by the owner of the device showing the movie, you can hide spyware on that device. That's OK for a usb gizmo you plug into your TV, but why would supposedly security minded enterprises accept that in their computers?
- halotrope 5y agoYes but no. Quite frankly I love iOS and my apps and the camera etc. The big disappointment is really that there is no power user mode for the rest of us. The computer/phone is really an extension of the mind at this point and we gave up control so easily. It is as if we let corporations lock down our pleasure center.
- Krasnol 5y agoYou're a good example though for why it works so well. You're not even ready to sacrifice a bit (that bit being still disputable) to gain more control over your phone by switching the vendor. Meanwhile most people wouldn't even get your first desire. We're and have lost already.
- shever73 5y agoI’m currently reading Nicole Pelroth’s book “This Is How They Tell Me The World Ends”, which has a big section on the NSO Group and the Pegasus Project. If even part of what she uncovered is true, then digital privacy is effectively non-existent.
- malshe 5y agoI finished the book last month. It is extremely well researched….and scary!
- Magodo 5y agoApologies for commenting before reading the article. But I'm curious what the sales process is for spyware. I understand the underground groups do all their stuff anonymously, but what sales ops do legitimate companies like NSO Group practice? Do they have sales targets/quotas? Do they vet their clients? What channels do they sell through?
- thefounder 5y agoUsually for profit companies are looking to boost profits and work near the legal limit if that means bigger returns. This happens in finance, tech, food, pharma and pretty much all the industries that have a "legal" risk due regulation. If breaking the law means a fine that sometimes is less than the profit then you can imagine that the incentive is to break the law.
- dogma1138 5y agoSimilar channels as any other arms manufacturer or defense contractor, as far as Israel goes they are regulated in the same manner by the same agency DECA. They likely do not sell to anyone or for any reason that does not contribute to Israel’s foreign policy in some way or another.
- bambax 5y ago> The investigation by the Guardian and 16 other media organisations suggests widespread and continuing abuse of NSO’s hacking spyware, Pegasus, which the company insists is only intended for use against criminals and terrorists. (from the Guardian inquiry about the same topic). Every time we allow special laws or special tools to fight "terrorism" or "child abuse" or other evils that get people worked up, they end up being used against the people in general. Every time. Why are we even surprised.
- krisoft 5y agoHow do I allow laws? Or rather what does it mean to not “allow” a law? You are right. Terrorism and cp are commonly used excuses to enable even more surveillance. When you talk about “allowing laws” it makes it sound as if we somehow got conned into letting them have these laws. In reality powerfull people want these tools. Powerfull people get these tools. Where does the allowing happen exactly? And don’t tell me that all would be well if only we would vote for the other guy.
- bambax 5y agoYes the wording is imperfect. I meant "accept", as in, not protest until they are repealed. Voting is useless as all main political parties typically agree on this.
- josephcsible 5y ago> what does it mean to not “allow” a law? Voting against any politicians who contribute to its passing, even if they're from your preferred political party.
- benlivengood 5y agoVote for approval voting, ranked choice, or even instant runoff at every level of government so that voting against an incumbent at least has a viable candidate.
- 5y ago
- bjourne 5y agoI know it's not a foolproof solution but perhaps there should be a greater focus on ethics in Computer Science curricula? The Israeli developers who wrote this software may not even have been exposed to the moral and ethical questions writing such software ought to raise. Perhaps there should be trade associations for developers that calls out software companies that writes immoral software? With great power comes great responsibility, and if you knowingly use your great power to write this kind of software you are a terrible person, in my opinion.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoHas an ethics class ever stopped someone from accepting a 6 figure salary?
- heliodor 5y agoPeople's ethics are all over the spectrum regardless of career path. The root problem is that we need to worry about the ethics of our politicians. Overall, they seem like a pretty bad bunch!
- saagarjha 5y agoPoliticians aren’t the ones writing spyware, though.
- antonzabirko 5y agoLol. Sure dude, it's the programmers who are the bad guys, not the people funding the israel/palestine war or in this case the owners of the company who decide to make software that helps assasinate people.
- andyxor 5y agoWaPo? if this is true there must be a better source, otherwise fake news
- teslaberry 5y agothere are no rules in love and war and hacking.
- penguin_booze 5y agoDo we know how this software is able to do something that others can't; and be very successful, especially being invisible while at it?
- sharikone 5y agoFor politicians in democracies citizens are potential voters, foreigners don't matter. It's still arguably better than dictatorships, where your citizens don't matter either, as long as you have a good police system. We act surprised when we notice such things but we shouldn't be, it is a mistake to apply the same standards that we, as the lucky citizens of "free countries" enjoy, to any other system of power. From a less cynical point of view, as an Israeli, I am not happy at all to see this kind of export products from my country. It is in great part because of the conflict. Te SIGINT units are huge and among the people who graduate from the army with this kind of knowledge you will certainly find many who will turn a blind eye to ethics for a huge paycheck. Not to mention that the research itself that the defense apparatus needs attracts capitals from other countries that will buy some of it and use it for unorthodox means. I wish we exported less of these things, especially to autocratic countries. I agree it's horrible.
- hashbig 5y ago> in democracies citizens are potential voters, foreigners don't matter Not long ago, what determined whether you "mattered" or not was your religion and belief. We now replaced it with a state issued piece of paper and convinced ourselves that this is progress.
- sharikone 5y agoThat's correct from a "spiritual" point of view, but pragmatically it is possible to define a spectrum from tyranny to democracy based only on the structure of power. More precisely you can look at the number of people the ruler needs to benefit to get their way. Religion and belief are important, no doubt, but they can be separated a bit from each other with this kind of analysis. In this respect modern democracies with universal suffrage, equal rights, legal protection from state violence are a big deal. It's not necessary for them to represent "progress" to be very very valuable. Also, "belief" has a propensity to produce circular logic (I believe in X because X is true), non-escapable rational traps (you don't believe in anything, so you believe in non believing, so you believe...), tribalism (we should convert the nonbelievers), righteousness (how can't they see it? It is the truth), wishful thinking (I believe that X is good and Y is bad so of course I will ascribe every good event to X and every bad one to Y), insincere debates, existential crisis caused by the lack of it, and so on... So as much as it's possible I in favor of leaving beliefs and religions out of the analysis.
- fortran77 5y agoThere may be another side to this. From NSO's website: > NSO Group licenses its products only to government intelligence and law enforcement agencies for the sole purpose of preventing and investigating terror and serious crime. Our vetting process goes beyond legal and regulatory requirements to ensure the lawful use of our technology as designed. Also, the company's owner, Novalpina, is not Israeli, though the founders and engineers of this particular surveillance product are in Israel.
- 71a54xd 5y agoThis is problematic and wrong, however, in today's climate I think the term "activist" is applied far too liberally. At times, so much that clear enemies of the state could also claim to be "activists". Another important distinction is that for journalists to be truly objective, most of the time that means they can't simultaneously be active as "activists". Hard to think anyone is surprised that top-tier pay-to-play malware is being promulgated by Israeli firms...
- pope_meat 5y agoThat's why I keep it simple. I run things out of a closet with an air gaped computer, a single printer, and a gun...in case the printer starts acting suspicious.
- drummer 5y ago> in case the printer starts acting suspicious. These days that is a very real possibility if you run Windows.
- deregulateMed 5y agoI think the real solution is to use an obscure privacy version of Linux.
- toyg 5y ago> a single printer You've already lost, then. Printers' output can be uniquely identified. Nothing should ever be in dead-tree format. If you need to carry something that does not need electricity to display text, use eInk. Or build your own printer.
- fma 5y agoTime to hoard type writers?
- anigbrowl 5y agoSome can, not all. Also, many printers are cheap, so if you are worried about this just buy them used and change them periodically. Good luck tracking someone down who bought their printer off Craig's list or at a pawn shop.
- fuzxi 5y agoOlder printers don't add identification to printed pages. I don't remember the exact year but I think the rule of thumb is that anything from the 80's or older is safe.
- rixed 5y ago
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoAre there U.S. laws NSO Group has violated? If not, how would laws define the prohibited activity? We’re at the point of, at the very least, barring NSO Group, its employees and its investors from travelling to the U.S., using our financial system or keeping assets here. (Which would indirectly bar our police departments and agencies from contracting with them.) Financing terrorism is a crime. Aiding and abetting journalistic suppression should be in a similar, albeit lower severity, category.
- Dah00n 5y ago>We’re at the point of, at the very least, barring NSO Group I haven't followed the US response to the behaviour of NSO Group but if things like you mention have already been done I very much doubt it isn't a smokescreen. The US is arguably the biggest user and customer to these kinds of services. >Financing terrorism is a crime Yes but if you have the power to define what is and what isn't terrorism (or journalistic suppression) then a law is useless. Fixing this is beyond the reach of a representative democracy and the likes. It needs a full-on direct democracy and enough citizens that are against it or a Dictatorship with a dictator that is against it. Otherwise any law pretending to be against stuff like this are at best a smokescreen or at worst a plot to keep it for those in power but out of reach of anyone else.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIn at least one of the articles I've read so far they mention an American citizen journalist living in the UK whose phone was hacked. He was reporting on IMDB and looks like UAE corruption was why he got hacked. So perhaps that's a way in? If not law in civil court? pardon my lack of legal jargon/knowledge "Also listed in the leaked records is a UK phone number belonging to the American investigative journalist Bradley Hope, who lives in London. At the time of his selection he was an employee at the Wall Street Journal." https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/18/ft-editor-roula-khalaf-among-180-journalists-targeted-nso-spyware https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/18/ft-editor-roul...
- twobitshifter 5y agoThey claim their software cannot be used on us phone numbers, but it’s suspected that Bezos was hacked using NSO’s “Pegasus” by the Saudis.
- smashah 5y agoThe people who work in these companies should be absolutely shunned and black listed from laundering their past by taking up a role at any major tech firm. The people who work at NSO and companies like this are a stain on the whole tech industry and are outcasted by their own IOF peers for being greedy and morally-lacking. Absolutely disgusting to think your hands are clean while you make tools that directly empower dictators and keep whole regions of people subjugated.
- deregulateMed 5y agoCompletely agree, but that only makes these positions more valued by the black market. Can't get a job at Google under security? Guess I need to hack for Russia. I think we should shun marketers too, they literally use exploits on our brain. So far my quest to encourage only positive jobs hasn't changed anything.
- throwaway984393 5y agoDoes Israel have an entire start-up sector dedicated to spyware or something? I feel like I'm reading about these all the time?
- saagarjha 5y agoIsrael has mandatory military service, and a lot of people go to work in their large SIGINT divisions (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_8200 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_8200). A lot of them then leave service and go on to use those skills in the cybersecurity industry–on both sides.
- smashah 5y agoYes, and major VCs, Big Tech companies, self diagnosed contrarians and the establishment OSINT crowd see nothing wrong with it or see it as a legitimate endeavour.
- underdeserver 5y agoLook back at them - these stories are always about NSO group, the same company. Nobody mildly self-conscious with a shred of ethics works there. It's not fair to an entire industry to be painted in this light because of one bad actor.
- rStar 5y agothis tech is developed against vulnerable people that have no rights, like the uighur muslims in china and the palestinian muslims in israel/palestine. it is then exported all over the world to be unleashed against us all. that's why we need to look out for the "least (powerful) among us." when you protect and advocate for the rights of the weak, you are actually advocating for your future possible self, and any offspring you may bring into the world that you may care about the welfare of, after you are gone.
- throwaway69123 5y agoHow is this any different to selling other types of weapons?
- smashah 5y agoIt cannot be understated how much damage this company done, not only to the quest for freedom for untold amounts of ordinary people but also to its own clients.
- ridiculous_lol 5y agoCan't read due to the paywall. Can anyone share the tech side of this? Did they get full access to the victims' systems? How much of this was Social Engineering?
- ridiculous_lol 5y agoNevermind. Found some old and new reports about it: https://citizenlab.ca/2018/09/hide-and-seek-tracking-nso-groups-pegasus-spyware-to-operations-in-45-countries/ https://citizenlab.ca/2018/09/hide-and-seek-tracking-nso-gro... https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2021/07/forensic-methodology-report-how-to-catch-nso-groups-pegasus/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2021/07/forensic-...
- kaimorid 5y agothis is so crazy, I'm in love
- underdeserver 5y agohttps://archive.is/vIphF https://archive.is/vIphF