19 ms·
Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to minors in interrogations
- yasp 5y agoWhy not ban for all ages....?
- zucker42 5y agoPolice claim they need to lie sometimes to effectively fight crime. Also, the presumption is that adults will realize the police are adversarial and won't blindly submit to an authority figure as kids are conditioned to.
- tomalpha 5y agoThat is perhaps what is claimed, but there are plenty of adults who for various reasons, lack capacity to make such judgements as well, or even realise that the Police might not be telling the truth. There could be lots of different reasons for this too - whether something like being raised to trust the police blindly, through to having learning difficulties.
- zucker42 5y agoI agree with this. I was merely trying to summarize the arguments on the other side.
- athenot 5y ago> Police claim they need to lie sometimes to effectively fight crime. Pretty sure that if the roles were reversed, they would be the first to cry martyr. Therefore that's a Golden Rule fail.
- pnutjam 5y agoIF!? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_Enforcement_Officers%27_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_Enforcement_Officers%27_Bi... The LEOBR detailed by the Grand Lodge of the Fraternal Order of Police as follows:[4] Law enforcement officers, except when on duty or acting in an official capacity, have the right to engage in political activity or run for elective office. Law enforcement officers shall, if disciplinary action is expected, be notified of the investigation, the nature of the alleged violation, and be notified of the outcome of the investigation and the recommendations made to superiors by the investigators. Questioning of a law enforcement officer should be conducted for a reasonable length of time and preferably while the officer is on duty unless exigent circumstances apply. Questioning of the law enforcement officer should take place at the offices of those conducting the investigation or at the place where the officer reports to work, unless the officer consents to another location. Law enforcement officers will be questioned by a single investigator, and he or she shall be informed of the name, rank, and command of the officer conducting the investigation. Law enforcement officers under investigation are entitled to have counsel or any other individual of their choice present at the interrogation. Law enforcement officers cannot be threatened, harassed, or promised rewards to induce the answering of any question. Law enforcement officers are entitled to a hearing, with notification in advance of the date, access to transcripts, and other relevant documents and evidence generated by the hearing and to representation by counsel or another non-attorney representative at the hearing. Law enforcement officers shall have the opportunity to comment in writing on any adverse materials placed in his or her personnel file. Law enforcement officers cannot be subject to retaliation for the exercise of these or any other rights under Federal, or State.
- Miner49er 5y agoResearch shows that children are especially susceptible to being lied to in interrogations. I imagine limiting the ban to minors was a compromise from negotiating with police and attorney organizations and pro-police lawmakers.
- lm28469 5y agoIf you're interested there are plenty of interrogation videos on yt, some by the FBI are particularly interesting. Sometimes they have a pretty good case but getting a confession tremendously speed up the process so they lie to get confessions. They also can lie to trigger responses and see how the suspect react, guilty people seem to react in way different ways than innocent ones. It's obviously not an exact science, even though it's heavily studied and has some psychology compounds, but it worked and put countless number of guilty people behind the bars A source I like is: https://www.youtube.com/c/JCSCriminalPsychology https://www.youtube.com/c/JCSCriminalPsychology This timestamped video is an example of a cop lying (to innocent people): https://youtu.be/BemHqUqcpI8?t=704 https://youtu.be/BemHqUqcpI8?t=704
- bloniac 5y agoHoly shit that’s a very low bar.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd they will trip over it, I guarantee you.
- mkl95 5y agoAre they admitting they are lying to everyone?
- cassianoleal 5y agoYes: > Commonly used interrogation tactics, such as promising leniency or insinuating that incriminating evidence exists, are banned for suspects under 18 years old under the new law, which goes into effect Jan. 1.
- PeterisP 5y agoWhy wouldn't they just ban those particular things for all suspects, not just for minors?
- Miner49er 5y agoResearch shows that children are especially susceptible to being lied to in interrogations. I imagine limiting the ban to minors was a compromise from negotiating with police and attorney organizations and pro-police lawmakers.
- emteycz 5y agoWhat's the purpose of your question? It's apparent they went out of their way to limit this to minors - so the reason is they want to have the ability to lie to adults. Probably 'because it helps fight crime' or something.
- eplanit 5y agoThey're allowed to in investigations: "we have a witness who saw you do it" will sometimes cause actually guilty people to confess, or to start naming accomplices, etc. Or, "we think this was an accident" can elicit "it was, I didn't mean to do it" as a confession.
- tomalpha 5y agoThe difficulty seems to be that it can sometimes cause innocent people to confess too Edit: adding this link to the excellent and oft-cited "Don't talk to the police [even if you're completely innocent]" lecture https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE
- tomalpha 5y ago> After hours of interrogation, police told one of the teenagers, Terrill Swift, that if he just confessed to being at the scene he could go home — so he did. What's the advantage to society of allowing interviewers to lie (to anyone, let alone kids)? Not just insinuate something like "your partner's in the next room, it's only a matter of time until he talks so you should come clean now", but blatantly lie and then be able to rely on the result of that in court? It kinda feels a little like the common law doctrine of Promissary Estoppel [0] where if someone relies on something you've promised, you can't then hold them responsible for relying on that thing. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/promissory_estoppel https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/promissory_estoppel
- elliekelly 5y agoAnd then he didn’t get to go home for 20 years.
- _fat_santa 5y agoI also never understood this. It almost seems as if interrogations aren't for discovery of information but moreso "we have this lead and we're going to beat you into submission until you confirm our lead". You see it all the time with wrongful convictions and people signing confessions to crimes they didn't commit. I often wonder in these cases, do the officers, does law enforcement in this case really care who did it? If you bring someone in and interrogate them for 12+ hours and eventually they give you the answer you want to hear, do they never stop and ask themselves if the reason the person gave that answer is simply to make whatever they were doing stop? It seems like some of these investigations the point isn't to solve the crime, but to dot the I's and cross your T's. It seems like actual public safety is an afterthought as long as you "catch the criminal" on paper.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoInterrogations are where they think they have a case against you but it's not good enough so they try and mislead you into making their jobs easier by giving them more evidence against you. If they're going through the effort of asking you questions in a controlled setting it's because they're trying to make sure anything they get is 100% unambiguously admissible in court.
- rPlayer6554 5y agoEvery American should watch this video. There is no reason to talk to the police, it will pretty much never help you. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE Edit: The lawyer made a follow up video clarifying that in routine traffic stops police do have autonomy. So as long as you are reasonable and just showing the policeman you aren't a public menace is seems ok. For any other reason I'd have my lawyer on me no matter what. Also this video specifically pertains to the 5th US constitutional amendment. Also IANAL but the guy in the video is.
- _fat_santa 5y agoThere's a movie I saw a while back where the main character was being interrogated by police, and in the scene the suspect just kept responding "Lawyer" to any question they asked.
- HumblyTossed 5y agoThere's a bit of a stigma, in the U.S. at least, that if you ask for a lawyer, you must be guilty. Probably comes from too much propaganda type television. Asking for someone who understands law to come and help you is a very smart move.
- i80and 5y agoIANAL, so take this with the requisite grain of salt, but the justice system has the power to be real dicks about how the right to a lawyer has to be invoked[1]. I would go with a very explicit request for a lawyer. [1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2017/11/02/the-suspect-told-police-give-me-a-lawyer-dog-the-court-says-he-wasnt-asking-for-a-lawyer/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2017/11/02...
- selimthegrim 5y agoAh, Louisiana, the state that pioneered the right to a jury trial for misdemeanors. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duncan_v._Louisiana https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duncan_v._Louisiana
- pjbeam 5y agoTalking to the police is a bad idea at any age.
- sethammons 5y agoA number of years ago, I fell into a YouTube rabbit hole on this topic. Many people think, "I've not done anything, I'll help this cop because it is the right thing to do." And that is naive. There is a risk present and you increase your personal risk the more you talk. I've shown my kids the scene in Making a Murderer where they lie to the kid and feed him lines to they can convict. They know if there is an emergency to call 911. They have also been told to not talk to cops outside of needing assistance.
- Clubber 5y agoThe problem is people are generally good and honest and want to be helpful. Many municipalities are not, they're trying to improve their score to justify their salary. Since people are generally good and honest, they naturally assume the government must be as well. Many police do horrible things with impunity. You can easily go down a YouTube rabbit hole for months with countless examples spanning many jurisdictions. I believe this is the greatest threat to our country, and that isn't hyperbole. If your are interested in such an endeavor for personal education, here's a start: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMCSd9ZNL0nshOhXwtfIJBA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMCSd9ZNL0nshOhXwtfIJBA
- aqme28 5y agoMinors might not know that yet (and plenty of adults still don't), so I support this protection.
- pjbeam 5y agoI do too!
- lm28469 5y agoDepends where you live I guess, I've "stopped" two minor crimes by finding the closest cop car and telling them something sketchy was happening. The first time they thanked me and didn't ask anything, the second time they asked for my address/name/phone nbr but never got back to me. My best friend also had to call the cops for a foreigner who didn't speak the language and had been beaten/robbed, nothing happened to the friend besides being thanked.
- wyldfire 5y ago> After hours of interrogation, police told one of the teenagers, Terrill Swift, that if he just confessed to being at the scene he could go home Isn't it already illegal to interrogate a minor without their parents? In any case, this story sounds similar to the Central Park Five / Exonerated Five. Unfortunately, police in Chicago have committed lots of illegal acts during interrogations. I'm worried that making more things illegal may not have significant impact if they just deny lying after the fact.
- Miner49er 5y ago> Isn't it already illegal to interrogate a minor without their parents? No, it's not illegal, I don't think? Parents don't need to be present or informed. Maybe some states are slightly different and I guess it might depend on the charges.
- triceratops 5y agoThat sounds crazy to me.
- wyldfire 5y agoSome cursory searching I did revealed some state and federal guidelines to the contrary. "good faith requirement to search for the parents", e.g. CA statute requires minors taken into custody to consult with attorney prior to questioning. But there's no constitutional guarantee.
- trutannus 5y agoCanada has laws against it, so it is illegal in some places.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoPolice shouldn't be allowed to lie to anyone for any reason.
- myWindoonn 5y agoTwo thoughts. First, should undercover investigations be allowed? Should law enforcement officials be allowed to lie about their identity in order to obtain more evidence? It is not a trivial question, although I agree with you that we don't need secret police. Second, does simply saying that public servants aren't allowed to lie...work? It seems like there are many situations where public officials lie broadly and baldly, and there is no comeuppance, not even when perjurious!
- blendergeek 5y agoI think police should not be allowed to lie in any situation where it is a crime for the non-cop in the situation to lie.
- O_H_E 5y agoHuh, that does make sense to me.
- Cerium 5y agoI think police should be able to lie, but any response to a lie should be presumed a lie by the justice system. So, a lie can be used to get an undercover cop out of trouble, but a lie cannot help an interrogation. Essentially, an officer of the law deciding to lie should invalidate all evidence gained after the lie.
- slumdev 5y agoNow maybe they can stop lying to adults, that is, if they want to earn back the public's trust.
- voakbasda 5y agoTrust will not be regained in my lifetime. They have created a generational problem. I will teach my kids to fear and distrust them too.
- jacob2484 5y agoIf your kids stay out of trouble, they won't be interacting much with them. These people literally put their lives on the line for public safety.
- anonymousab 5y agoOverreach and needless brutality are par for the course. Bad apples and countless years of zero independent accountability has unfortunately spoiled the bunch. > If your kids stay out of trouble, they won't be interacting much with them. Unless they're black, statistically. Then they're being pulled aside or pulled over at night and put into these interactions for just existing. You can't teach your kids to just "stay out" of their skin color, they can't just "stay out" of a system of institutionalized racism.
- slumdev 5y ago> These people literally put their lives on the line for public safety. This is true. It is also true that they don't need to lie to do their jobs. For the record, I think they're pretty good at their jobs, and 99.999% of the time, they act justly. But they still don't need to lie.
- mrguyorama 5y agoThey literally aren't even on the top ten list of most dangerous jobs from BLS https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/27/the-10-most-dangerous-jobs-in-america-according-to-bls-data.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/27/the-10-most-dangerous-jobs-i... We should stop deifying police for "putting their lives on the line" when the vast majority of injuries on duty come from traffic accidents
- vmception 5y agoWhat’s the consequence?
- ashtonkem 5y agoFewer children are coerced into false confessions?
- tyingq 5y agoLooks like the only consequence is "The presumption of inadmissibility" for evidence gained that way. It does not appear to make it a crime or provide any consequence for any individual police officer. The text of the bill is here: https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&SessionId=110&GA=102&DocTypeId=SB&DocNum=2122&GAID=16&LegID=&SpecSess=&Session= https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&Sessi...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ipunchghosts 5y agoIt's ridiculous that police can lie to you but you can't lie to them.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoImo, all of the major issues related to the US justice system could be resolved if your employer could only fire you with a conviction, the government had to pay for holding people not guilty, and if your held without trial for x amount of days, you must be released. All of these incentives protect working class people and requires prosecutors to have the literal smoking gun to prosecute.
- gpt5 5y agoConviction rates are already sky high. The problem is not with charging people when evidence is low but with the prosecutors and the written laws that don’t hold police accountable.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoI agree with that as well, but even if cops were held accountable, it still leaves the scenario where lower income people lose much needed jobs and have precious time stolen from them with no recourse, just an "oops, guess we couldn't pin anything on ya! Now get lost!" The German/Austrian criminal justice system is vastly superior to the US one more than anything else.
- jacob2484 5y agoYou can just plead the 5th and the lawyer will do the lying for you
- ipunchghosts 5y agoIt's ridiculous that police can lie to you but you cant lie to them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- openasocket 5y agoI honestly think police shouldn't be allowed to interview children at all (at least those under 13), it should be left to forensic psychologists. Not just interrogations, interviews of witnesses or potential victims too. Children are simply so easy to lead in questions, there's an entire field of study in psychology devoted to figuring out how to ask questions of children without leading them. Here's some examples: if you ask a child a yes-no question that they don't understand, they default to saying yes. If you ask them a multi-choice question ("Would you rather X, Y, or Z?") they default to whichever option was given last.
- O_H_E 5y agotbh, I think adults suffer from the same thing, maybe to a lesser extent.
- elpatoisthebest 5y agoI had an experience with this (on a much smaller scale. No police were involved). When I was about 13 or so, I was walking home with a kid from school and he threw a rock at a passing car. He ran off and left me to deal with the driver. I explained that it was this other kid. I called the kid later to let him know that I ratted him out and apologized, but I didn't want to be on the hook for it. The driver, my parents, and the parents of the kid who threw the rock all met with us. Talked through the details, and somewhere in there they mentioned that I had called this kid to apologize, and I said that yeah, I had called him. It wasn't until after everyone left with the agreement that I was guilty and would pay the damage that my dad told me that I had agreed that I called this kid and apologized for lying about him throwing the rock. I was totally blindsided by that interpretation. I didn't understand that anyone had even suggested that I might have lied in that situation. It never crossed my mind, I thought I was just saying that I called him. There's nuance and implications in adult conversation that never crosses the mind of a kid.
- watwut 5y agoSomething similar can happen to adult too. Less likely to a child, but still, adults are not perfect rational players with great social skills. And not all adults are smart. Plus, this right there sound to me like very wishful thinking on the side of dad who don't want his kid to be guilty. It does not sound like honest evaluation of what was said. He was likely eager to interpret and twist anything just to get that result and succeeded.
- kixiQu 5y agoLet's zoom out from the rights of that individual minor, too. If you believe in the role of police in society, you want kids to be able to trust them. You can't teach your kids to trust someone who may lie to them with horrific consequences.
- Miner49er 5y agoThe police's rule in society is to enforce the law. I don't think they need kids to trust them to do that?
- adchari 5y agoEnforcing the law becomes a lot harder when a community lacks trust in you, and kids who don't trust police officers turn into adults who don't trust police officers, and teach their children the same thing.
- kixiQu 5y agoBog-standard "if you get lost and separated from your parents" child-advice is to ask for help from exactly such figures as police, with the idea that this would protect them from ostensibly less savory options
- jMyles 5y agoI certainly don't tell my child that, and I don't know of any American parents who do. Police represent the interests of the state, not the interests of my child.
- kixiQu 5y ago> I don't know of any American parents who do. Really? https://www.allprodad.com/things-your-child-should-know-when-they-are-lost/ https://www.allprodad.com/things-your-child-should-know-when... > The best people to seek out would be the police, security guards, the fire department, and store management and employees. If these can’t be found, teach them to seek a mom with young children. http://achildsworldnc.com/teach-kids-case-get-lost/ http://achildsworldnc.com/teach-kids-case-get-lost/ > Advise children that if they need assistance they should only approach someone such as a security guard, police officer or someone who is clearly a member of the staff. I mean, I know these are just random internet things -- but I vaguely remember that advice even being in kids' books when I was growing up.
- calkuta 5y agoI believe that the only reason people participate in police interrogations is sheer ignorance. If you are suspected of committing a crime, do not speak to police, other than to assert your right to legal counsel.
- koz1000 5y agoThere was another awful case recently in Illinois that would be prevented by something like this. I'm glad Pritzker passed it. https://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/naperville-sun/ct-nvs-suicide-lawsuit-dismissed-naperville-st-0123-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/naperville-sun/ct-nvs... TLDR: A high-school student made a recording of a sexual encounter and word got out. Kid is called to the principal's office where the resource officer (literally a cop that stays on campus) threatened the kid with being put on the sex offender registry among other actions. Kid slips away while staff is waiting for the mom to arrive and jumps off a parking garage, killing himself. School and police deny any wrong doing and "only meant to scare the kid".
- Miner49er 5y agoThis law wouldn't actually have an effect on that. Police can still lie to minor's in situations like this one, I think.
- sonotathrowaway 5y ago> Wood also wrote that while the interrogation tactics used by the deans and police were “harsh and aggressive, they were nonetheless ordinary police interrogation tactics.” The judge who presided over the case was under the impression that the student was being interrogated.
- throwawayboise 5y agoThat doesn't sound like a lie. Sounds like a very real possible consequence, given the way the laws around that kind of thing are written and enforced.
- smoldesu 5y agoI remember doing something rather stupid in grade school, to the extent that the police were brought in to question me about it. The "crime" itself was really nothing more than unauthorized access to the district's private FTP server, but the officers questioning me started saying some really odd stuff: they were trying to get me to admit culpability to things that I didn't understand, some of which I was very skeptical of. As scared as I was, I recalled my mom telling me to ask for a lawyer when I was younger, so I did. This seemed to disgruntle everyone in the room, but it also ended the whole ordeal pretty quickly. I later learned that these cops had our school's security company on the line, who was flabbergasted by the idea that unsecured FTP could be accessed by wisecracking students. Suffice to say, I'm all for legislation like this.
- erdo 5y agoI just realised that the police are able to lie to you during an interrogation. I feel incredibly naïve (and yes, this probably is related to my white privilege - when I compared my experience of the police growing up with the experiences of my friends it seriously opened my eyes)
- lowmagnet 5y agoCool, hope they expand it to everyone.
- GhostVII 5y agoI think it is fine for police to lie in interrogations to get information. If them telling lies leads them to hard evidence of the crime that's great But lying to get a confession doesn't seem fair, if you confess to a crime you should have full knowledge of the case against you just like you would in a trial.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yabones 5y agoIf a doctor lies to a patient, they go to jail. If a civil engineer lies about the capacity of a bridge, they go to jail. If a lawyer lies in court, they go to jail. Why the hell are police officers not held to the same standard of professional responsibility??
- mayneack 5y agoI'm pretty sure a lot more doctors, engineers, and lawyers lie in a professional context than there are doctors, engineers, and lawyers in jail. Maybe they go to jail more than police, I have no idea, but surely a majority of the time they get away with lying.
- sonotathrowaway 5y ago> If a lawyer lies in court, they go to jail. That’s absolutely not true, prosecutors regularly place themselves above the law without consequences.
- voisin 5y agoWhy not say they can’t lie at all? What social purpose does the ability of a government agent to lie serve? I think a lot of this perpetuates an us/them mentality that pervades government.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoLying police officers really defies the most basic and fundamental ABC on how you build a police force that has both trust, and support from the community they’re supposed to protect. I mean, it’s clearly damaged cops with severe mental issues (most probably PTSD), who have decided that the people they are employed to protect, somehow are their most aggressive enemy.. Like, if the people with a state sanctioned monopoly on violence, decide that beating people isn’t enough, they must also be able to trick people into a prison sentence, you don’t have police you have fascists stormtroopers.
- blooalien 5y agoI remember well the time I learned as a teen that police could outright lie straight to your face. I and a friend got caught walkin' home after dark and accused of a crime that took place in a nearby neighborhood. During questioning, the officer told me "Your friend already admitted to the whole thing" and some BS about reducing the charges if I "came clean" about my involvement. Thing is; I knew for a fact my friend had admitted no such thing, as we didn't do it, and neither he nor I would ever have admitted to a crime we didn't commit. Not how we was raised…