10 ms·
List price for stitches at Stanford Health Care: $93K
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 5y agoIt seemed like an opportunity for more people to just learn some of the skills for these expensive procedures so out of curiosity, I looked up what army field medics learn. It's a 16 week course. Stitches, bone setting, and minor surgeries should be done by the equivalent of barbers. The prices are a perfect storm of what is essentially a unionized tightly gatekept profession, obviously perverse inventives in insurance, and the consequent inflation. Swap debt for insurance, and you have the dynanic of the education market as well. Both of them are artifacts of regulatory capture. Arguably, instead of teaching kids to code we could teach them to handle 50%+ of emergency room visit causes and the resultant widespread competence and research impact would make medicine progress at the rate tech has. I suspect the main reason we don't have biohacker first aid kits for routine procedures is drug controls on anesthetic, but there is a already robust global black market for drugs that could meet this need. A list of procedures sorted by risk and pain could be solved pretty fast. Of course there will be wildly irresponsible malpractice, but compared to the consequences of the current system, it probably nets out, and for medical industry people who don't think it would, they aren't really in a position to object to a free market in health services. If we can create a market, knowledge networks and a disitribution system for 3D printed guns, we should apply the same ethos and skills and come for medical care next. We need a Cody Wilson of medicine.
- tablespoon 5y ago> It seemed like an opportunity for more people to just learn some of the skills for these expensive procedures so out of curiosity, I looked up what army field medics learn. It's a 16 week course. Stitches, bone setting, and minor surgeries should be done by the equivalent of barbers. But "can I do it?" and "can I do it well?" are different questions. For instance (IIRC), badly done stitches can leave more of a scar than expertly done ones and a badly set bone may heal in the wrong position. There's also knowing the difference between typical situations and more unusual ones that look similar but require a different treatment. It's not a bad thing to know how to do those things for an emergency, which is the context an army field medic would do them, but that's quite different from an everyday accident with accessible medical care.
- motohagiography 5y agoIf I were to pay $10k or more for stitches anywhere else in the world, they would come with a set of top shelf breast implants and a hollywood quality facelift. In Cuba, they would give you a bonus hip or a new knee. There is no quality case for the price of the majority of routine american health procedures. An Uber for medical toursism would even be more cost effective.
- UncleMeat 5y agoI'd happily take a scar if it saved me $20,000 on stitches. I do agree that I'm not leaping at the opportunity for getting untrained medical care.... but on the other hand I've been treated by residents pretty often and they still charged outrageous amounts.
- addicted 5y agoYou are right. What we need is a completely new mechanism that does not really work all that well and is dependent on completely new technology. What we shouldn’t do is look at what nearly every other developed country has done to manage this situation, to the point where the most expensive amongst them is still half as expensive as the US system. /snark It still completely astonishes me how often Americans will come up with pie in the sky non solutions to solve problems that other similar countries have solved decades ago.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoOne of the last tweets was the most interesting - "Just looking at Stanford's 2011 vs 2020 data, you can see charges going up more than 300% in some cases" That is absolutely insane to me. I really don't understand how that's possible at all - I know no one really pays sticker price on any medical bills but still.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoHere, take this for-profit, inelastic demand service you need right now without seeing the prices. Trust us. You won't be bankrupt soon. Like, what are you going to do? Get up from the ER gurney and comparison shop at another hospital?
- geoduck14 5y agoMy wife had a baby a while back. The hospital she went to did 50% of their business in delivery. Given 9 months of notice (the gestation period of humans), THOUSANDS of babies delivered every year, and professionals talking onthe phone - NO ONE could tell me how much it would cost to give birth. It blew my mind - how can you NOT know?
- geerlingguy 5y ago6 months out, we're still getting random bills from our baby's birth. Only difference from first three is I know to expect it, so I'm numb to the insanity.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoWhat other business in the entire world bills large, random amounts of money without explicit, informed consent? Also, does your insurance cover these random bills or is it copay/80%?
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoLol right? Although I'm guessing even for non-emergency services there's still not a ton of comparison shopping going on. People probably trust their own doctor's referrals and don't know to comparison shop - with the new rules it seems a bit easier but I'm sure hospitals don't make it all that easy.
- moocowtruck 5y agodid they use golden thread? my daughter recently had to have quite a few stitches and it was no where near this.. (also american hospital)
- failwhaleshark 5y agoTo be fair, Stanford's admitted hospital food is really, really good and the care is the best around. Through a botched 12 lead ECG, I ended-up in their cardiac unit over a holiday a few years back. It was better than most hotels. Insurance covered 100%. I don't think I ever saw the actual costs.
- herodotus 5y agoWhat I learned the hard way is that non-us citizens who need minor medical help should go to a drop-in clinic, not a hospital. In the few times I have done that, the fees were reasonable. The one time I went to a hospital to treat an infection in my thumb, I had to pay over $5,000. The same procedure in Canada would have cost me $50.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoDo they really have a way to track you down as a non-citizen for nonpayment? I know it's not the most ethical to skip out on a bill but charging incredible fees to foreigners who don't understand the American system doesn't seem that ethical either.
- herodotus 5y agoI would never do something like that, but of course I had to provide identification when I checked in to the hospital.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoFair enough! But I do hope you fought that bill really hard and got them to cut it down significantly. I was living in Europe a few years and signed up for travel insurance and thought it was really 'funny' that if you are going to America for more than a few days the rates basically double because the payouts the insurance has to provide are so extreme compared to the rest of the world.
- chrisseaton 5y agoDoesn’t travel insurance cover any hospital you get taken to in an emergency?
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoI don't think it's mandatory for people on tourist visas to come to the U.S. so some portion of visitors probably don't have it.
- Spivak 5y agoSo can anyone who is in the medical field shed some light on this? Because if I was under obligation to list prices but didn’t want to I would probably inflate them like this too since I can give arbitrary 99% discounts. Without a requirement that hospitals list their prices by billing code and must actually charge that price to everyone across the board with no adjustments or discounts laws like this are basically useless.
- chrisseaton 5y agoSo why did they bother with the law?
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoTo make it sound like they're doing something about an issue (healthcare) which continually ranks highest on American's priorities without actually disrupting the status quo?
- chrisseaton 5y agoBut this is pissing off both the people who did want it, because it’s extra regulation, and also the people who didn’t want it, because it’s ineffective. Nobody is happy.
- corty 5y agoEven then it would be kinda useless, because of the difference between hypothetical billing codes 22934a "Stitches, easy location, no complications" and 22934z "Stitches, weird location, infection present, uncooperative patient, resistance or allergy to common anaesthetics". Which is often very much up to interpretation and discussion as well.
- hanniabu 5y agoYet people still say this system is better than universal healthcare, go figure
- gambiting 5y ago"because I can't possibly fathom my hard earned money paying for someone else's treatment" seems to be the most common reason. And you know what? Fine, whatever, in some twisted version of the world I can accept this as an argument. But I wish people would at least realize that by only having private healthcare they are fucking themselves over as shown here. The prices, the copays, the restricted access, the in and out of network treatments......all of that is completely made up to feed the system.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoI mean on the surface level it kind of makes sense but when you add up all the additional costs from rent seekers like collections agencies, the lack of negotiation from medicare (although I vaguely remember hearing they might do this now) on drug and procedure prices, and hospitals overcharging those who can pay or with insurance to offset the emergency treatment they give to those who can't or won't pay I feel like this argument doesn't hold a ton of water. I mean, you're not paying it directly in taxes, just in a bunch of other ways.
- adamcstephens 5y agoWe should consider private taxes just the same as public taxes.
- hef19898 5y agoTechnically different, but all I care about is how much money is left per months after I paid for everything from taxes to mandatory insurance and social security. If somethings has me with more money left after that, I don't care if it called a tax or something else.
- 5y ago
- jbverschoor 5y agoI wonder if the ECB takes this into account when calculating inflation
- 542458 5y agoDoes the European Central Bank calculate inflation in the US? - but healthcare is almost always part of CPI, so people doing CPI calculations would typically include this and this would be part of inflation calculated uuing CPI. And yes, healthcare costs have risen much faster than inflation as a whole.
- jbverschoor 5y agoHousing prices weren't included
- 542458 5y agoI’m not sure what that has do with my comment. But it’s also false, at least for the “official” CPI numbers in the US. 31.8% of the CPI is shelter. This includes rent and home purchases (calculated as owner equivalent rent which is basically mortgage + cost of ownership), but excludes renovations and investment purchases. https://arbor.com/blog/how-does-rent-factor-into-the-consumer-price-index-cpi/ https://arbor.com/blog/how-does-rent-factor-into-the-consume...
- RNCTX 5y agoAmerica's version of paying the barbarians to stay away from the gates of Rome in the last days of a dying empire.
- tw04 5y agoI’m not saying the price is ok, but I’m guessing based on the description that includes a plastic surgeon given its a wound to the face. Generally speaking they’re going to charge a huge premium for one of those guys because that’s the going rate: people don’t like scars on their face. I’d be curious what the price is for non-face stitches.
- Someone 5y agoSo, how much of a premium would that plastic surgeon get? Even if it’s $50k ($2k per millimeter of stitchwork), that still leaves over $40k to explain. Also, can a wound sized 2.5cm or less that can be stitched up be complicated to stitch? I would think/guess many of them would be glued nowadays.
- tyingq 5y agoIt doesn't include a plastic surgeon. That CPT code is very specific and translates to "Simple repair of superficial wounds of face, ears, eyelids, nose, lips and/or mucous membranes". There are different codes for more complex work: Intermediate repair (CPT codes 12031 – 12057) Complex repair (CPT codes 13100 – 13160)
- the_svd_doctor 5y agoThose numbers make kind of no sense. We had a 5 days delivery+postpartum at Stanford and were billed ~200k (insurance paid 50k, we paid 600$) which I found insane already. So 100k billed for stitches makes even less sense.
- lordnacho 5y agoHow does that work? Who paid the rest of the 200K? Seems like a crazy amount for something that mostly goes ok in the modern world.
- marcinzm 5y agoIt's a negotiation. The $200k is simply the starting/maximum ask by the hospital to the insurance company. A bunch of automated and (sometimes) manual systems go back and forth until a price is agreed upon. Eventually everyone agrees on paying $50k. Like any negotiation you want to start high rather than low.
- gccs 5y agoNobody. You aren't ment to pay the price they charge.
- gilbertbw 5y agoThe insurance company negotiated a lower bill.
- ceejayoz 5y agoNo one. The rest just evaporates. The original bill has little relation to the actual costs the hospital has to recoup.
- css 5y agoIn the above example, the remaining balance gets accounted for as a loss to maintain the fiction of the facility’s not-for-profit status. It also provides the basis for a kickback the federal government sends to this hospital called Disproportionate Share Hospital payments [0]. In medical parlance, this is called uncompensated care or uncompensated revenue. The Center for Medicare and Medicaid provides a ton of detail [1]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disproportionate_share_hospital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disproportionate_share_hospita... [1]: https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/Paper-Based-Manuals-Items/CMS021935 https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manual...
- curiousgal 5y agoOh wow I did not know the US helathcare system was broken..said no one ever.
- abledon 5y agoIt's quite disgusting, but the sheer size of this number and seeing the discount etc... really stamps an impression in the mind.
- curiousgal 5y agoI don't know, talking to anyone who went bankrupt because of medical bills would stamp a bigger impression but oh well, it's a circlejerk at this point in my opinion. Everyone keeps pointing at the fruits while ignoring the root of the problem.
- chodeboy 5y ago"If you don't have riches, you don't get stitches"
- wly_cdgr 5y agoGuessing this is the starting figure they use for negotiating with insurance companies, who laugh at them and counter with $395, at which point Stanford says ok yes thank you daddy. But they can't use a different price for you if you don't have insurance. So just send them a couple hundred bucks and tell them to fuck off
- tyingq 5y agoMedicare would pay around $160 (facility+non-facility) total for this procedure. CPT 12011 - "Simple repair of superficial wounds of face, ears, eyelids, nose, lips and/or mucous membranes" See: https://www.cms.gov/medicare/physician-fee-schedule/search?Y=0&T=4&HT=0&CT=3&H1=12011&M=5 https://www.cms.gov/medicare/physician-fee-schedule/search?Y...
- usaar333 5y agoFrom experience cost shopping, Stanford tends to be by far the worst. A simple EKG would cost over $3k, compared to around $1k or so at other providers. Though just a few years back, it was like pulling teeth to get the insurance negotiated prices (which I pay entirely having an HDHP). Hopefully, more transparency results in more cost shopping, but it's been a surprisingly slow social change.
- Joeri 5y agoPrice transparency will only help by putting pressure on providers for PR purposes, but it will not cause free market dynamics because much of the health care sector is not a real market. Take stitches, who would actually shop around before having the stitches done? You would go to your usual hospital and pay whatever the price ends up being. All urgent care is not a market from the point of the patient, because there is no real opportunity to choose providers. Insurers have to follow the patient or be blamed for not supporting out of network care, so insurers have little market shaping power either.
- AuryGlenz 5y agoI don’t believe most medical care is urgent, but I would say the bigger factor is insurance. If you’re going to blow through your deductible anyways the price doesn’t matter much to the consumer.
- xtracto 5y ago$1000 for an EKG sounds crazy! I got one at an ER in an "expensive " private hospital here in Mexico. I paid less than $50 USd for the EKG and a doctors' checkup. I understand that I the US salaries are 3X what in Mexico but even that doesn't justify the $1000.
- mabbo 5y agoAs a Canadian, I am constantly flabbergasted when American friends tell me "Yeah, but a single-payer system would be way too expensive! Taxes would go up!". It does not occur to them that in a single-payer system, the incentive on everyone is to find ways to lower the cost of healthcare, while in a privatized healthcare system the incentives are reversed. And examples like this twitter post show the result of those incentives.
- tashoecraft 5y agoThere has been a massive disinformation campaign pushed on the American people saying “socialism medicine” would be much more expensive and you’d have to let grandma die. That Canada hates their system and you have to wait for days to get seen. Any evidence to the contrary is met with “but my freedom”, idk how to fight back against this
- Vaslo 5y agoJust buy insurance if you are worried about it.
- RedShift1 5y agoEven those who have insurance end up paying a lot out of pocket and if the insurance provider decides to not pay the bill it gets chucked onto you and that can easily run in the 100000's of dollars.
- FpUser 5y ago>"That Canada hates their system and you have to wait for days to get seen." I would not call that I hate the whole Canadian system, but parts of it for sure. Especially the ones when they let you wait for months for some things. Some people died because of it. All because the guvvamint only allows for so many procedures per period allowed. The rest does not fit into budget. However you will find enough of deaths in the US that can be attributed to a lack of money as well. Depending on how one gets sick the may hate Canadian system or the one in the US.
- 5y ago
- sjg007 5y agoI had to pay retail prices for some care that insurance didn't cover. Sucked.
- rasz 5y agoUS hospitals operate on 2-5% margin on average? https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/tumultuous-year-for-hospitals-results-in-55-drop-in-median-operating-margin-kaufman-hall-finds.html https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/tumultuous-yea... according to this some manage >15% and profits are best ever https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlaszewski2/2020/02/05/profitability-in-the-health-care-market-has-never-been-better/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlaszewski2/2020/02/05/pro...
- andreskytt 5y agoIt’s the complexity penalty. For years, in trying to make the system “better” for the current definition of “better”, the system has been made more complex. Probably to the point where no stakeholder understands it. But complexity breeds complexity (you need to understand something to not botch any change up) and the price of the system grows fater than the complexity (x times complexity increase leads to about x^1.5 times price increase, there’s research on it). It’s not profit margin, it’s the cost of dealing with the complexity. In a competitive market, companies with high complexity penalties can’t compete, get pushed out or are forced to reduce complexity by force. In this case, there is no external pressure to reduce complexity but an increasing number of parties seeking to benefit from it. Which leads to predictable consequence of complexity growing like crazy.
- AdrianB1 5y agoLooking with European lens and reacting to people that think the universal healthcare is the solution to this problem: no, it is not. The universal healthcare solves the insurance problem, not the cost of the hospital. What US needs is not insurance for people that don't pay for it, but reasonable prices at hospitals. We have this in my country: we have both public and private insurance and public and private hospitals. The competition in the system means private hospitals will never have such prices, otherwise there will never be clients. Instead of universal insurance coverage, you need strong competition to hospitals so there is a market price that is closer to the costs. Here the private hospitals cost more, but offer a much better quality; still, the prices are double and most middle class people can afford to pay it without insurance if needed, so these stiches would be maybe $100 while in public hospitals it would be $50-60 and covered by the public insurance. Even here in Europe there is no full, unlimited insurance, emergency care is free but everything else is covered by a mandatory insurance every employee has (paid only by employee, not the employer) and it covers the spouse and kids (under 18 years old or in college) of the insured person. That means there are people without insurance and they receive only emergency care for free, nothing else.
- hef19898 5y agoEvery EU country I know of (whch doesn't cover all 27, so...) has covered more than just emergency care. Payment is quite different, in germany so the costs are shared 50/50 between employer and employee, soe for unemployment and social security. Would be nice to know where you live.
- AdrianB1 5y agoRomania. It is part of UE since 2007 and this is the way healthcare works here for the past 10+ years. A few years ago the accounting part was changed so all the taxes and any other forms of payments to the state from the payroll appear in the employee payroll, the total amount did not changed but salaries were adjusted (up) to cover former employer part, so now the employee is paying everything (which was always the case everywhere, just differently booked). Some employers offer as a benefit a negotiated private insurance co-payed; for good contracts the private insurance cover all the costs in private hospitals, for my company it covers about 50% of the doctor cost for consultations and about 20% of the hospital costs. I pay about 50% of the cost of this insurance, the benefit is a discount price versus the regular price of the insurance (about 10-15%).
- shdh 5y agoThe fact that there isn't price transparency into all procedures at all facilities is a true market failure. Facilities are incentivized to to maintain opaque pricing so they can gouge. My advise is to respond to the bill and let them know you'll only willing to pay $200 and that's all you can afford. Negotiations with these predatory billers go a long way.
- kleer001 5y agoThis smacks of fraud and the need for a reformation.
- MattGaiser 5y agoDo these things really have purposeful list prices? I had to go to the hospital for an allergic reaction on a visit to the USA. They let me go with $600 in cash. When I asked for an itemized receipt, it has thousands in charges but nobody there really seemed to care if I paid that. The insurance company was welcome to pay if it wanted to though.
- bawana 5y agoWell they have to pay these salaries somehow https://nonprofitlight.com/ca/stanford/stanford-health-care https://nonprofitlight.com/ca/stanford/stanford-health-care
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWe should let other countries bring their healthcare here for competition. If people are traveling for medical tourism and it is profitable, it seems like we could incentivize other countries to set up shop here.