14 ms·
“One Day Longer and Those 13 Boys Would Be Dead”
- stanrivers 5y agoGood lord, I am hyperventilating just reading this. The people that went in and saved these boys are amazing. I am glad the author took the time to pull this together to share the story of the divers as well. Absolutely amazing - mind-boggling amazing - what dedicated, skilled, selfless people can do.
- iforgotpassword 5y agoI was wondering how far they had to dive as soon as I started reading, and then when they finally revealed it I was like "holy hell!" It was mentioned that one of the drivers damaged his gear going in, and that's the case where it's something attached to your body, which you can develop a fair amount of feeling for, like you get used to driving a car and just know how wide it is. I can't imagine how it must feel to drag along a sedated human when you can't see anything. There must have been situations where you accidentally hit some obstacle with one of the kids and then this dreaded feeling of not knowing if you displaced the mask and are now dragging a kid drowning in it's sleep across the mud for another hour. As cheesy as it might sound, this is one of these rare stories that restore faith in humanity. Absolutely amazing.
- IX-103 5y agoDid you see the video that was linked where they go back through the path they swam after the water cleared out? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zGEmSHP4Idw&list=UUSPfkBf-K2vQV6jERzj-TzQ&index=12 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zGEmSHP4Idw&list=UUSPfkBf-K2vQ... I'd be too scared to go through there dry. That's insane.
- lightcatcher 5y agoWow. These videos bring home how insane the rescue was. I could not imagine anyone going through those tunnels with zero visibility and diving equipment, let alone while moving a sedated person along as well. Here the diver's blog post to accompany these videos: https://www.mikkopaasi.com/post/return-to-tham-luang-cave https://www.mikkopaasi.com/post/return-to-tham-luang-cave
- ddingus 5y agoMy response was the same. Those divers are very high quality humans. I feel good people like that walk among us.
- emmelaich 5y agoExcellent charts and animations at the SCMP. https://multimedia.scmp.com/news/world/article/2154457/thai-cave-rescue/index.html https://multimedia.scmp.com/news/world/article/2154457/thai-...
- sdfsadfjaslj 5y agohttps://archive.is/j6410 https://archive.is/j6410
- wizzwizz4 5y agoThat's only one page.
- chris_overseas 5y agoThere's a link to page 2 at the bottom https://archive.is/o/j6410/https://www.zeit.de/wissen/2021-07/thai-cave-rescue-thailand-tham-luang-2018-diver-mikko-paasi/seite-2 https://archive.is/o/j6410/https://www.zeit.de/wissen/2021-0...
- detaro 5y agoand if you click the link to the second page you get to ... the second page.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dt3ft 5y agoThank you.
- sandebert 5y agoSeason one of the podcast "Against all odds" is also about this. https://wondery.com/shows/against-the-odds/ https://wondery.com/shows/against-the-odds/
- bastawhiz 5y agoThis man showed some extreme self restraint in not even bringing up Elon Musk beyond a casual mention of the submarine idea. If Elon had called me a pedo because I didn't use his spaceship submarine I don't think I'd have held back quite as much.
- tpmx 5y agoMusk wrote that tweet about a separate UK diver. Still, this Finnish diver did show remarkable restraint here.
- muthdra 5y agoI respect Musk more than many commenters you see around. I understand he's not the billionaire savior many people seem to believe. I remember him mentioning something about how the sub couldn't go wrong because if the kids got there and the water rose, it should get where the kids were. How feasible was it, really?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nradov 5y agoIt was never even remotely feasible. Musk's design was simply too large to fit through the restrictions in the cave. It's the kind of nonsense that only someone with no real diving experience could come up with.
- TheParkShark 5y agoThe restrictions were in the upper part. The article explains the boys walked in through a much larger path underneath.
- freeopinion 5y agoMusk had no diving experience, and no knowledge of these caves. He was working from incomplete knowledge and intuition. Almost all of Musk's critics in the matter were working from no knowledge of the caves and little to no diving experience. Some of Musk's critics were working from the best available knowledge in both areas. But this diver points out exactly what Musk intuited. There was a much easier route for all those boys to have hiked into the cave. Musk's submarine would probably have worked over that route. But nobody had knowledge of that route at the time. One solution would have been for Musk or somebody to build little robots that could explore the caves in zero light with sonar mapping equipment. The robots would need to navigate and operate underwater and abovewater in very difficult terrain. It seems like an impractical pursuit under the circumstances. Why even mention such a ridiculous idea? Well, why not? Why not put all options on the table. You can dismiss the "Have Scotty beam them out" stuff immediately. But they were talking about establishing supply lines for months to keep them alive until the water went down. They were talking about drilling holes 1km+ to hopefully tap the chamber where those kids were. They were talking all sorts of stuff. And yes, somebody was talking body-sized submarines. And somebody might have been talking about dive robots. And sonar mapping. I was glued to my news feed with a bag of potato chips and so were almost all of you. I don't know diving and I don't know those caves. I think the divers who rescued them are mental. I mean really crazy. I mean, seriously, who in their right mind would do stuff like that? I think the effort just to find the kids was risk-taking at a scale that terrifies me. Their brains do not work like mine. Thank goodness. Musk's brain doesn't work like mine, either. I'm not going to criticize the divers. They are clearly heroes. Musk doesn't come off as a hero in this story. But I'm not going to criticize him either. His intuition was right. He did more than click reload on his browser for two weeks. Nobody else liked his idea. Isn't that the story of his life? In the end, his idea was one of many that were rejected. Instead they went with the crazy idea to tie everybody up, knock them out, and hope they don't accidentally knock their masks off. Who's bright idea was that? Well, it worked. Let's not bag on the people who made tremendous efforts to rescue the kids. And let's not bag on the people who made some efforts that didn't produce results. And please don't bag on me, who did nothing.
- chha 5y agoThere is a couple of other stories that comes to mind, unfortunately both of them were about recovering the dead. "Raising the Dead" is about the accidental discovery of a diver in SA, and the recovery efforts there. [1] "The cave divers who went back for their friends" is about a trio of finns who went back into a Norwegian underwater cave system to recover two friends who got stuck and died there. [2] [1] - https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/water-activities/raising-dead/ https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/water-activi... [2] - https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36097300 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36097300
- mongol 5y agoThere is a great documentary about the Finnish cave divers. "Diving into the unknown": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diving_into_the_Unknown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diving_into_the_Unknown "Last breath" is also a really good documentary about rescue under water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Breath_(2019_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Breath_(2019_film) Both of these I rate 5/5
- 34679 5y agoI'm just going to toss this here because I really enjoyed the audiobook: Shadow Divers - The True Adventure of Two Americans Who Risked Everything to Solve One of the Last Mysteries of World War II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_Divers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_Divers
- gpanders 5y agoThis book is absolutely incredible. I just read it recently. I didn’t expect to like it that much (the description doesn’t sound that interesting), but Kurson is such an excellent author that he totally hooked me. Highly recommended.
- goodcanadian 5y agoThis one is more a story of dumb luck, but there was a case of a crew member surviving for 2.5 days in an air pocket in his sunken ship: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-africa-25205914 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-africa-25205914 He was discovered by divers hired to investigate the sinking and recover the bodies.
- mongol 5y agoWhat effect did the sedation have? Were they still conscious?
- ianlevesque 5y agoI don't think so, towards the end the diver stated: > If need be, we were to give them another shot of ketamine in case they were waking up.
- gameswithgo 5y agobeing on ketamine while trapped in a cave would be ammmmaaaaazzziinnngg (ly terrifying)
- dingusthemingus 5y agoYea this sounded pretty strange to me, Im aware sedation slows breathing down, so some oxygen can be saved if human attached to tank is not hyperventilating for hours, Pretty crazy the kids were sedated and hands bound and feet tied!
- janoc 5y agoProbably the last thing you would want is an untrained kid to panic during the rescue. They would most likely kill both themselves and their rescuers in the process.
- indigodaddy 5y ago“ Together with Finnish journalist Johanna Elomaa, I wrote the book "Sukellus Valoon" (Diving into the Light) about my experiences during the rescue mission and how it changed my life” ^ From page 2 of the article. I Googled for this book but wasn’t able to find anywhere to buy it. Supposed to have been published in 2018. Perhaps no English version yet... was anyone able to find the book?
- homarp 5y agohttps://www.johannaelomaa.com/books/sukellus-valoon/#mctmp https://www.johannaelomaa.com/books/sukellus-valoon/#mctmp
- indigodaddy 5y agoAh thanks! It’s unclear whether there is an English version yet. From all indications on that page it appears perhaps not. Also the “Order here” link appears non-functioning (at least on iOS Chrome). I’d bet an English version will be not too far in the future (I hope!)
- tpmx 5y agohttp://kontextagency.com/non-fiction/diving-into-the-light http://kontextagency.com/non-fiction/diving-into-the-light Looks like there's only a Finnish original issue and a Swedish translation published so far.
- trackofalljades 5y agopaywalled
- lilSebastian 5y ago> what dedicated, skilled, selfless people can do. Save lives and earn the accolade 'Peado guy' from Elon Musk for having the audacity to do so. Edit: the Musk fanboys are heavy on the down votes today.
- arcticbull 5y agoYea haha I was going to remind folks of that too. Elon was building a submarine that everyone involved told him was a terrible idea and to please leave them alone because he was hampering the effort, and Elon responded by calling one of the lead rescuers a “pedo guy” and got sued over it. I believe his defense was that “pedo guy” was a common insult in South Africa. Simpler times haha.
- lilSebastian 5y agoSimpler times... 3 years ago...
- arcticbull 5y ago“Before the war” if you will haha - as in before COVID, which has distorted at least my perception of time greatly.
- paledot 5y agoAlso when the very last of my respect for Musk died.
- bambax 5y agoMusk showed his true character.
- Karsteski 5y agoIt was an asshole thing to say, but I don't think someone being an asshole means that that moment defines their "true character"
- happynacho 5y agoNon-paywall?
- jauhar 5y agoyou can view the article if you click the green "i agree" button
- fab1an 5y agoThe most harrowing thing I have read in a long time. I can't even begin to fathom the immense bravery of these divers - and that of the boys. I didn't really follow the Musk bit of the story, but the fact that he had the audacity to shitpost about any of these guys make me think vastly less of him (and I'm usually in the Musk-respecter camp)
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y agoWhen Musk first appeared I was hugely supportive. Definitely a fan of what he was doing both with SpaceX and Tesla. I'm still a fan of what those companies are doing but Elon has destroyed my view of him with his own behavior and words. We should stop turning a blind eye to his labor practices. Likewise, we should give the engineers and other workers that are actually accomplishing these things more credit, vs pretending it's one lone genius. Tom Mueller in particular deserves far more credit.
- tedivm 5y agoGwynne Shotwell deserves far more of the credit for SpaceX than Musk does.
- dylan604 5y agoMost large companies have people that deserve more credit than the sitting CEO. However, that's part of the role of CEO is to be the one people look to as being in "charge". Musk definitely doesn't shy away from that part to his detrement (clearly he doesn't see it that way). But I'm firmly with the previous poster in that I like what Tesla/SpaceX are doing and attempting, but think Musk is a bit of a tool. The irony is not lost on me that sometimes a calmer figurehead might not have been able to lead to success a company like Tesla and/or SpaceX.
- s5300 5y agoAnd Musk repeatedly publicly gives this to her/says this himself.
- abraae 5y ago
- janci 5y agoI still don't get it. The tunnels were too narrow near the ceilling, but wide near the floor. The divers could not keep at the floor because they could not navigate due to zero visibility, zero communication and no tether points. Would not a sonar help? A full spacesuit-like helmet with air to be able to talk via radio? Laying down some flexible tunnels that could be inflated with air or maybe just pumped with clear water to gain visibility? So many ideas come to mind, but they chose the most difficult transport of sedated and tied up kids ever. I assume they had a good reason, but still do not understand it.
- McDyver 5y agoA sonar wouldn't help in such a pressing situation. The sonar would only provide a map that would still need to be interpreted, and wouldn't solve the actual problem of transporting the boys. Those "helmets" exist, but helmets as such are used in commercial diving with a tether to the diver. Not very practical to have it running along the cave for multiple divers. The full face masks that allow that are mainly used in open circuit diving and are bulky. I don't know if the pros/cons would make a huge difference. At one point I believe Tesla or just Musk were planning and developing a pod to carry each boy, but the tunnels and sumps were so narrow that they wouldn't be able to make the turns. Having tunnels with compressed air to inflate them would have similar issues with the bends. Not to mention the amount of gas and pressure needed to displace all that water. I guess they took the most direct and logistically available option. I'm sure it will be a case study for the future.
- brazzy 5y ago> Would not a sonar help? Portable sonar systems with in-helmet displays were put in use by the US Navy only last year: https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2021/03/us-navy-teams-with-nasa-to-test-next-generation-davd-helmet-upgrades/ https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2021/03/us-navy-teams-w... > A full spacesuit-like helmet with air to be able to talk via radio? Would fuck up your buoyancy, but there are systems where you have only an air pockt around your mouth. But the range would be so low as to be nearly useless inside a cave. > Laying down some flexible tunnels that could be inflated with air or maybe just pumped with clear water to gain visibility? Even assuming that you had those already available, laying them would be a very slow process, and they would be a hindrance rather than help in very narrow passages.
- laingc 5y agoWhat is outrageous is that the divers got at most an MBE - on the same New Years Honours list where heroes such as Michael Palin and Twiggy received knighthoods. I have never seen anything really deserving of a knighthood than what those divers did.
- pleaser 5y agopage 1 https://archive.is/j6410 https://archive.is/j6410 page 2 https://archive.is/d6i50 https://archive.is/d6i50
- jtchang 5y agoIt's only after the rescue that they can give retrospectives on exactly how difficult things were at the time. My utmost respect goes out to each of these heroes for doing what needed to be done even at the possible cost of their own lives.
- wintorez 5y agoI wish there was a way to flag behind pay wall links.
- pan69 5y ago> ...as a teenager, I caused the death of a friend and that accident has marked my life. I had largely blocked it out until this mission in Thailand. Whoo. This guy must have gone through so much mental stress during this time.
- jonplackett 5y agoIs there a film being made of this yet?
- cududa 5y agoNo idea why you got downvoted so much, but yes it’s out, it’s called The Cave
- jonplackett 5y agoYeah, seemed like a fairly reasonable question! Thanks! I wonder if it gives as chilling a representation as this article. I will go find out!
- makeitdouble 5y agoDidn’t downvote, but I also share the weird malaise when every remarkable event is expected to become a movie. In this case a the diver (co-?)wrote a book, so a movie is just another step in that direction and he seems cool with it. It would be shitty though to have a movie in any other circumstance.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoYes. It is being made by Elon Musk. Who is undoubtedly the misunderstood hero of this whole situation, of course. (/s, if it wasn't obvious).
- djthorpe 5y agoThirteen Lives is now in production with a good cast and Ron Howard as director. Likely to be released around the middle of 2022
- locallost 5y agoIt's difficult to find the right words. Just reading this felt like a million times more intense than anything I ever experienced. I felt the stress and claustrophobia the whole time as I was reading it. Just wow. Except Elon Musk is a total juvenile jackass. Those words are easy to find. It's a pity he has no shame.
- uoaei 5y agoWhat the fuck is this dark pattern? You must agree to ads before later revoking consent?
- t0astbread 5y agoWell, at least they're being upfront about it: You can pay or get ads + tracking (or, the hidden third option: leave the site).
- mahathu 5y agothis is very common across German websites. I assumed it was a common pattern elsewhere too!
- Dah00n 5y agoAre you saying German sites doesn't follow the law (only freely given consent is legal)?
- germanier 5y agoThe law is not that absolute in this respect and there have been cases before higher courts accepting "data in exchange for value" contracts under some conditions. There are also legal opinions out there that this is illegal but note that there is a controversy here.
- arendtio 5y agoI also don't understand how this can be in legal in the sense of the GDPR, but AFAIK there are multiple German news sites which use this pattern (e.g. Golem, Heise and Spiegel from the top of my head).
- vilhelm_s 5y agoWhy would it be a GDPR violation? As I understood it, the point of the GDPR is to prevent people from being tracked without knowing about it and consenting to it. Here the consent button is as obvious as it could be, you really can't miss it.
- realityking 5y agoSingle page version: https://www.zeit.de/wissen/2021-07/thai-cave-rescue-thailand-tham-luang-2018-diver-mikko-paasi/komplettansicht https://www.zeit.de/wissen/2021-07/thai-cave-rescue-thailand...
- makeitdouble 5y agoIt’s such an incredible, but also well balanced, very down to earth story. The rescuer is so diligent in putting things into perspective, especially regarding the future repercussions on cave diving or why they had to do it. Personally I was only remembering Elon Musk’s jerkiness from the whole story, and am so glad to be reminded there are so many more positive takeaways, incredibly brave and supportive people working together and putting in all they have to make it work despite the odds. Also RIP the diver who lost his life a few days before while preparing for the rescue.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dools 5y agoThis is such an awe inspiring story, and at the same time it made me sad. It reminded me of the story of a young Rwandan girl who was about the same age as those trapped boys when she and her family escaped to the Congolese jungle … I can’t remember her name but she ultimately survived and has become a public activist. She tells her story now frequently and I remember her saying that she though the entire world must have suffered some catastrophe because no one was coming to save them. Later she found out it was just because no one really cared enough to save them. Imagine if we treated all lives with such value, and applied the same heroism and bravery to their rescue.
- ddingus 5y agoIntriguing take. Priorities. Our world could be very different given a reconsideration of what is worth what. And some of us live more in that world, lucky to have agency, fellowship, resources to make it work. Humanity is partitioned. Not all sets makes sense.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rPlayer6554 5y agoCould you/someone post the link to the article or her name?
- dools 5y agoI can't for the life of me find the quote nor remember where I originally saw it. I thought it was something like a ted talk or at least a review of a ted talk, but I can't find it now :( that sentiment certainly stuck with me though, the idea that this girl assumed that, if they could, someone would have come to help, but that they had actually been abandoned which was a harsh realisation she came to later.
- pentae 5y agoI was staying on the small island in Thailand where Mikko lives in when he returned from the caves. Word had obviously spread through the local Thai community that he was on the passenger ferry and there must have been 100 of them lining the streets to cheer him for his bravery once he arrived. It was a really touching thing to see.
- CRConrad 5y agoI'm not even going to click through to any fricking article or video: Just reading the comments here gives me quite enough claustrophobic shivers.
- jacquesm 5y agoHeroes get their hands dirty, and risk their lives. As opposed to certain CEOs who see the world as a nice background for photo opportunities to boost their own ego.
- mjkpl 5y agoFrom the article, the fragment about the SF2 sidemount rebreather: > There are only a few of these computer-controlled devices in the world. From quick googling I found out that this type of rebreather is "certainly the most popular Sidemount rebreather in the world." [1]. It is relatively inexpensive also (7k EUR). Why are there only a few of them in the world then? Is he talking about some special, modified type of it? [1] https://www.divestock.com/scuba-force-sf2-sidemount-rebreather https://www.divestock.com/scuba-force-sf2-sidemount-rebreath...