8 ms·
The effectiveness of this technique depends on the humidity being low. If you tried this when it's 80+% humidity it probably wouldn't do much.
by gruez 5y ago
The effectiveness of this technique depends on the humidity being low. If you tried this when it's 80+% humidity it probably wouldn't do much.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoWas it in fact that high of humidity in BC during this event? I think it wasn't, right? When I looked at Portland's weather on the day it was really hot there, the humidity was around 20%.
- refurb 5y agoIn the interior of BC it’s typically quite dry during the summer. It’s basically high desert at least in the south.
- xyhopguy 5y agoAt 49C you need a dewpoint of almost 70 (!!) to get 20% relative humidity. thats nasty -- during the heatwave in portland the dewpoint was between 63-68 most days. Usually its ~55. For context, the dewpoint on the east coast during the storm season usually is between 70-75.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoOr when it's over 52 degrees outside, when "wet bulb" temperature (= a thermometer in a wet cloth) goes over 35, which is what they've been having in Pakistan. At that temperature, the evaporative cooling effect of water (like sweat) is no longer enough to manage temperature, and even fully healthy and hydrated people can die from heat exposure. I mean I watched people in Canada in the news this morning and thought, why are they still outside in the sun even?
- klodolph 5y agoJust to elaborate on the "thermometer in a wet cloth" explanation... If you have water at the wet bulb temperature exposed to ambient air, then evaporation and condensation are in equilibrium. Above the wet bulb temperature, there is more evaporation, transferring heat from the water to ambient air. Below it, there is more condensation, transferring heat from ambient air to the water. Except at 100% humidity, this is higher than the dew point, which is the temperature where water spontaneously condenses out of the air.
- pdkl95 5y ago> I mean I watched people in Canada in the news this morning and thought, why are they still outside in the sun even? "Mad Dogs And Englishmen" by Noël Coward (1932) In tropical climes there are certain times of day When all the citizens retire To take their clothes off and perspire It's one of those rules the greatest fools obey Because the sun is far too sultry And one must avoid its ultry-violet ray The natives grieve when the white men leave their huts Because they're obviously, definitely nuts! Mad dogs and Englishmen go out in the midday sun https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPnJM3zWfUo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPnJM3zWfUo https://genius.com/Noel-coward-mad-dogs-and-englishmen-lyrics https://genius.com/Noel-coward-mad-dogs-and-englishmen-lyric...
- mrleinad 5y agoThis gave me a chuckle
- jamal-kumar 5y agoit's funny the note of colonialist superiority at the end of this poem when I live in the tropics and we regularly call burnt as fuck tourists 'cocido como un camaron' which means cooked like a shrimp. then they get to spend the next day moaning in bed while we take their hotel money and hit the beach with proper sun protection early in the morning when there's way fewer tourists getting skin cancer for no good reason other than operating at times they're used to. Haha!
- masklinn 5y ago> I mean I watched people in Canada in the news this morning and thought, why are they still outside in the sun even? Dunno about being in the sun, but if you don’t have AC and the house is at ambient temp you might as well be outside (normally in the shade) as you’ll at least get some air.
- mfer 5y agoIf you're outside you also need to content with the affects of the sun shining on you. If you don't have AC there are things you can do to your home keep the temp low through the day. You essentially trap the cooler evening air and keep the sun out.
- adolph 5y agoAgreed. In the weeks of no electricity after TS Ike I regretted taking my window plywood off. I had waited a few days and during those days the house was reasonably not cool thru the day but comfy. Without the plywood things got stuffy quickly (old original uninsulated windows).
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThat works great until it doesn't. A lot of Canadians depended on this mechanism instead of air conditioning, especially on the prairies which is semi-desert: high days, low nights and low humidity. But when your nighttime low is 27...
- mfer 5y agoA side thought... it's quite incredible how we in "the west" have managed to make our lives flow with little impact from seasons, weather, and stuff like that. Just in general. Thinking about how people had it 200 years ago... it was so different.
- masklinn 5y ago> If you don't have AC there are things you can do to your home keep the temp low through the day. You essentially trap the cooler evening air and keep the sun out. That's the normal way to do it, but it doesn't work when there's no wind and air temp doesn't cool down significantly at night. Even fans throughout the dwelling don't end up cooling that much overall, because they really only move the air that's in their path (unless you already have ceiling fans to create larger turbulences and better mix the air).
- wnkrshm 5y agoNow is there a way to do architecture to passively remove moisture from the air...?
- voisin 5y agoYes, dozens of ways to do this honed over millennia in hot humid climates, but put in use only by the fringe minority off grid types in modern societies now. God how I yearn to be a fringe minority off grid type. My time will come.
- billfruit 5y agoIt often makes me wonder why weather reports dont mention the wet bulb temperatures, is it that these measurements are not usually available from monitoring stations?
- gruez 5y agoDon't most weather reports mention the "feels like" temperature, which is essentially the same thing (temperature adjusted for humidity)?
- TYPE_FASTER 5y agoThe NWS has a map with experimental wet bulb data here: https://digital.mdl.nws.noaa.gov/ https://digital.mdl.nws.noaa.gov/
- elorant 5y ago80% humidity with 35C+ heat means death within 15 minutes.
- tsjq 5y agothis is so common in coastal places in Southern India. no death in 15mins here.
- chromaton 5y agoI read stuff like this on HN and think that many of you must be living in a different physical reality.
- elorant 5y agoI live in Greece where currently we're in the middle of a heatwave (temperatures above 38C for more than a week). I don't recall a single time in my life where we had high temperatures and high humidity levels. But I've read once that if the temperature is higher than 35C and the humidity above 60% you can't live outside because the body can't expel heat fast enough.
- lucozade 5y ago> But I've read once It's best not to assume what you read on the internet is always true. Some people post things that turn out to be utter nonsense. Easily checkable nonsense to boot.
- elorant 5y agoIt's explained further down in the comments. It's the so called wet bulb temperature. I was wrong about the 15 minutes limit though, turns out it's about two hours.
- chromaton 5y agoYou'll be shocked to learn about steam rooms.
- nszceta 5y agoNo it does not. You wet your shirt with unheated tap water, wring it out, and wear it. Repeat as necessary every 15 minutes to 1 hour in extreme heat, no matter how humid it is. In high humidity by wearing a shirt doused in tap water you cool down by heating up your t-shirt. This method does not work if water comes out of your tap already hot. This only happens rarely. In dry environments evaporative cooling helps but it is not necessary to be effective. I recommend using shirts made of elastic breathable material such as under armor shirts for comfort. Cotton tends to stick to your skin extra and feel really nasty.
- xyzzyz 5y agoElastic breathable material in my experience take less water in, so you have to repeat wettin them more often.
- phreeza 5y agoIf that is the effect you are going for, would wearing a camelback water bladder have a similar effect? It has slightly less surface area to interface with your body, but you can carry a much larger amount of water.
- mrkstu 5y agoAnd put it in the freezer intermittently...
- klyrs 5y agoTap water is colder than the inside of the house. Bringing it into the house reduces the heat inside. Putting it into the freezer heats the room that the freezer is in. You're better off replacing the water when it gets warm. Kinda fucked in a drought, though.
- JeremyNT 5y agoHow lasting is this effect though compared to evaporative cooling (which lasts for as long as you stay hydrated due to the replenishment of moisture from sweat)? The volume of liquid you're adding to your garment can't be all that much, and if you combine your body heat with a high ambient temperature it seems like the water should reach equilibrium rather quickly. I don't doubt it helps in the short term - I live in the southeast and I've done this when hiking many times (once my shirt's already soaked from sweat and I can find a cool stream) - but it only provides a temporary respite.
- allannienhuis 5y agoLuckily Lytton is in a semi-desert area - very dry there. Even here on the coast of BC where humidity is higher (and temps slightly lower), it's reasonably dry right now. Beach towels we put out to dry in the sun are dry in a few minutes.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoSeattle is the same, the humidity is high on paper but it didn’t feel like the same 106 in the south, east, or Midwest. It felt…dry hot…like Arizona. Not as dry as Spokane, however.