22 ms·
Some biologists and ecologists think social media is a risk to humanity
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- underseacables 5y agoI think the global reduction in in person communication is a grave risk to humanity. We used to spend so much time together, doing things together, I’m talking in the office to the roller rink. Perhaps this just shows how old I am, but I really felt like that was better for humanity. Global communication and interaction is great and all, but I really miss sitting around the backyard with friends talking
- dantheman 5y agoThere's no reason to not do that; in fact its easier than ever to invite and plan things.
- tayo42 5y agoyeah I don't get that point, its not like people are deciding to scroll facebook instead of going to their friends bbq. maybe you could make the point that people pick activites for how good of a social media post it would make. But that's not even what this article is about, its discussing the spread of misinformation and social media being full of low information content.
- slipframe 5y agoI think that ubiquitous global communication is the "Great Filter" that prevents intelligent civilizations from colonizing the universe. Before any intelligent species can hope to tackle a problem like that, they invent something like the internet. And once they've invented an internet, they become addicted to low latency communication and will never stray far from it, at least not in significant numbers. Even one year of latency becomes utterly intolerable once an intelligent species has been using an internet for a few generations.
- birdyrooster 5y agoHumans will never make it, but our computers will. The internet is the singularity now.
- bckr 5y agoThis comment is probably about 3 or 4 decades too early.
- birdyrooster 5y agoYou had to say probably. For me, that's enough. It could have already happened.
- bckr 5y ago> You had to say probably. For me, that's enough. It could have already happened. This is the inverse of the intended interpretation. By "probably x decades early", I mean "at least x decades early". I did not mean "it has probably not happened". The singularity is not guaranteed to happen and with a high confidence has not already happened.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> at least not in significant numbers That's ok. Insignificant numbers are more than enough to colonize an entire galaxy on geologic timescales. The thing about the "Great Filter" is that it is great. If you can even imagine an exception for your candidate filter, then it's not great enough.
- slipframe 5y agoI'm thinking that if you sent a dozen people to Alpha Centari, it wouldn't make any difference because that is under the threshold of people that would be required to establish a self-sustaining colony that, in turn, sends out similar expeditions in the future. Do that sort of stunt as much as you like, it won't become something more. It's like trying to jump over a building by hopping a bunch. You can hop one time or one billion times, you won't clear the building because after each failed hop you're back to square one.
- CodeGlitch 5y ago> I think the global reduction in in person communication is a grave risk to humanity. I'm not sure I agree. For the most part of humanity, we have been at war, murdering each other, enslaving each other, and numerous other atrocities... Including nearly a nuclear war. The reduction in in person communication is due to the increase in global communication... Which I think is a net benefit. Social media is a bump in the road, and my hope is that we'll overcome the likes of Twitter soon.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoText based communication is the cause. Not social media. Anytime I go to a bar, people are paying attention their friends if something is going on, watching a band, or on their phone. Stranger interaction declines heavily the more people that are there. I've noticed this since the advent of texting. Not since the advent of social media. It's absurd to me honestly that someone would prioritize someone on their phone over the person who took the time and effort to physically be present and engage with them that day. >I really miss sitting around the backyard with friends talking I do as well. But it makes me wonder now, if people always have been flakey and unwilling to hang out with new people. I swear when I was a kid, asking someone to hang out or do something was easy, even if you met them one time. It's almost as if unlimited media and instant communication halts people from pursuing anything with other people unless they have something they dont.
- ido66667 5y agoWe are, to put it simply, too entertained with our technologies to expend the initial effort to "touch some grass", meet people in real life. But we still need connection with people, so we invented technological tools that allow us to quickly and easily get in touch with others. Although the quality and satisfaction we get from this form of communication are much lower, it requires much less initial effort and hassle, so we accept it.
- kingsuper20 5y ago>I think the global reduction in in person communication is a grave risk to humanity. You know, that could be. I'll present a meta-hypothesis. Diversity is generally dangerous and global communications/global movement drives everyone closer to hazardous behavior. Without the filtering of slow tempos, things get sporty.
- akomtu 5y agoPerhaps social networks need to reinvent clubs? That's what makes HN valuable: it's a club with like-minded members and because their number is small, your voice gets heard. FB, on the other hand, is a club that admits anyone, so it's not really a club, and because it's a stadium packed with random folks, your voice doesn't matter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- incrudible 5y ago"For example, the paper says that tech companies have “fumbled their way through the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, unable to stem the ‘infodemic’ of misinformation” that has hindered widespread acceptance of masks and vaccines" The numbers on masks and vaccines show that acceptance is widespread. What are we looking for here, approval rates to rival Kim Jong Un? The worst thing that could happen to what little is left of social cohesion is an even stricter attempt at controlling information. Sure, some information shared on social media is misinformation. Some information coming from mainstream media is misinformation, too. In some cases, the authorities will spread misinformation. After all, some of the "evidence" used to argue that masks are ineffective came from the CDC itself. With the politicization of everything, even facts can not be considered neutral anymore. For every verifiable fact, there's a set of other verifiable facts that may be omitted to achieve the desired effect. Fact-checks are used for propaganda. When consuming information, always keep your salt dispenser at hand.
- LarryEt 5y agoIt seems many people have a completely unscientific view of reality in that they have absolute certainty in what they believe to be true. I think there are people who are looking for North Korea level approval ratings on things. If you have zero uncertainty in what you think is true then anything contradictory is naturally "misinformation".
- anigbrowl 5y agoIf you wanna go around arguing the Earth is flat, you need to have something more persuasive than 'do the research.' Not that you personally believe in a flat earth, but it's a good example of why we shouldn't treat epistemological uncertainty as the starting point; there is so much evidence for Earth being round and so little offered in favor of it being flat that its roundness should be treated as a fact unless extraordinary new evidence to the contrary is produced. If someone comes along insisting on its flatness without overcoming that bar, then it's OK to treat them as either a fool or a troll and reject their opinions.
- 5y ago
- mudil 5y agoIt sure feels thought provoking to read an article or a paper that essentially predict how the future will unfold, or what we need to do to prevent something from developing in the future. And yet, the future is inherently unpredictable, and these exercises in predicting fail more often than not. Even if there is something that could be predicted becomes the reality, the degree of expression of that reality could not have been predicted.
- grawprog 5y agoI think social media needs to be redefined. What the average person thinks social media is is very different than what it actually is. I think a lot of people think big social media platforms are actually communication platforms, they're not. They're designed intentionally to be difficult to communicate on. That the not the purpose of them, it's in the name 'social media' they are the media, you are the social. They are creating media based on the things users post. They're not made to facilitate communication between friends, family, coworkers, etc... They are designed specifically for users to generate monetizable content and data. They use a veneer of 'connecting the world together' so users will generate content that drives clicks and makes them money. A true global communication platform would look nothing like the social media we have today. It would be designed around allowing people to communicate easily and freely, it would give you control over who and what you interact with and it would allow you to maintain granular levels of privacy. Ya know...like other systems designed to facilitate communications...like say the telephone system...
- krapp 5y agoSocial media is as successful as it is precisely because it works so well as a communications paradigm. No popular social media platform is difficult to communicate on, they draw in so many users because they're easy to use. My mother who can barely use Windows knows how to chat with me on Facebook. People use social media to communicate between friends, family, coworkers etc all the time. That's how all of that monetizable data gets generated. Yes, the purpose of social media is to profit from user-generated content and data, but it still works as intended for 99% of people.
- ppf 5y ago>it still works as intended for 99% of people. I would argue that it feels like it works, for 99% of people. I strongly believe that "social media" is a low-quality and unsatisfactory replacement for meaningful social interaction and bonding.
- krapp 5y agoSocial media was never intended to be a replacement for meaningful social interaction or bonding, any more than telephones or letter writing, or the generation of forums and personal websites it more or less replaced.
- softwaredoug 5y agoI’m more interested in what would cause people to ignore their doctor and choose to believe whatever insane thing is on social media about, say, vaccines. There’s always been places you could go and find nonsense. But what’s different about this moment? What’s drawing people to nonsense? IMO social media gets the blame, but it’s just the vehicle for something darker happening. Something more about widespread nativism that distrusts an educated, cosmopolitan elite. Just because we see this on social media, doesn’t make social media the cause.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoOn the other hand… have you considered that your doctor, politicians and scientists may also effected by social media in their professional advice you are supposed to take because they are an authority? We don’t need to get into all the times doctors have been way wrong. Now those people who might know that are within your ear shot, perhaps a little less than the lunatics who just want to talk shit. Maybe you are right, maybe it’s not social media but an extreme polarization for another reason and social media is speeding it along? Maybe that’s just what we do over time? Either way, I can’t accept the appeal to authority you started with. I have personally be on the wrong side of a diagnosis and it’s a good thing I didn’t listen to my doctor in favor of information I discovered first on social media.
- epgui 5y agoIt's not an appeal to authority, it's deferral to expertise. This is a very crucial concept: https://thelogicofscience.com/2015/03/20/the-rules-of-logic-part-6-appealing-to-authority-vs-deferring-to-experts/ https://thelogicofscience.com/2015/03/20/the-rules-of-logic-...
- relax88 5y agoI agree with your point, but social media certainly appears to amplify the effect, regardless of what the root cause may be. I wonder if perhaps the main problem is that social media changes the structure of human interaction by allowing those with similar ideas to congregate instead of being spread across the network in a diffuse manner. Like in the 1970s if you believed that Aliens were here on Earth and abducting people, the vast majority of people you interacted with would think you’re a crackpot. It would be very difficult to find validation that your ideas are good. Today you simply need to open a Facebook group for UFO conspiracy theorists and you’ve got all of the confirmation bias you need. It has never been easier to find people who agree with you.
- dasil003 5y agoThe media narrative that social media is the cause of these societal ills, especially environmental problems is laughable. The real danger technology poses is the increased leverage of ever-increasing automation consolidating in the hands of oligarchs who using it to enrich themselves and isolate themselves from the consequences with no regard for broader impact on the planet or future generations. Despite the problems with social media, removing it would have no beneficial effect on this trajectory towards environmental catastrophe. To the contrary, I still believe that lowered barriers to global communication and information access are generally good for society. Sure it hasn't resulted in becoming a nation of philosopher kings in the utopian ideal envisioned by those early Berkeley engineers, but the problems we are seeing are just the same old dance of populism and propaganda that have always been at the heart of large scale politics.
- bumby 5y agoDon’t you think social media impacts policy though? Take your example of automation. Wouldn’t the way to counteract this be through smarter policy (like an automation tax as an off-the-cuff example). I think the angle of the paper is that social media makes enacting smart policy that much harder because weaponized misinformation can be used to stymie such policy.
- jkhdigital 5y agoI know how to solve this: no more democracy, just put the “smart policy” wonks in charge. What could possibly go wrong
- mrkramer 5y agoWasn't early Facebook all about connecting with friends and family and looking for boyfriend/girlfriend? Today I only hear something like "fake news, hate, racism, violence" etc. I wonder what has changed? I think that it is not Facebook's management fault but the reality kicked in. Medium like Facebook is convenient for all type of content and interaction unlike Instagram for example which is more for showing off with photos and following other people's lives.
- donatj 5y agoI'm 90% sure it's when they started personalizing the feeds. You only see things the algorithm thinks you're going to like, but it has a very shallow idea of you as a human being limited to your outward expression. Then It pushes you further and further to the extremes of what it thinks you like. People were warning about filter bubbles even before Facebook did it.
- bckr 5y ago> People were warning about filter bubbles even before Facebook did it. Makes me think of "reality tunnels"[] written of long before Zuck made his website. [] https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Reality_tunnel https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Reality_tunnel
- sewercake 5y agoThere's a lot of 'political' content on instagram. do a quick google search for 'politigram' and you'll see what I'm talking about. That being said, there are definitely per-platform affordances that may change the degree and extent to which its expressed (and, crucially, to whom).
- justbored123 5y agoWell, I don't know how your friends and families are, but mine are quite racist and quite hateful of minorities and they were that way long before the internet. Facebook just shows that, it doesn't change it. I think that most people (specially white, heterosexual and not poor) were simply living in a bubble of ignorance thinking the world was a much better place that it actually is and social media simply popped that bubble and showed reality for everybody to see. And now they are angry at Social media in a classical shoot the messenger reaction.
- electrondood 5y agoI 100% think that social media is shrinking our collective attention spans, and the cumulative effects of this are unpredictable. Infinitely scrolling through flashy, zero-effort "snackable" content is the equivalent of mental junk food.
- ko29 5y agoLike HN.
- WillDaSilva 5y agoDefinitely true to some extent. I think the degree to which it applies corresponds to how deeply a person engages with an individual post/thread. Having long conversations in the comments of a post is probably not conductive to shortening attention spans. Ideally we could mimic the sorts of deep conversations that can be had with small groups of people/friends in-person. Maybe Hacker News would benefit from live updating comment threads so that people wouldn't have to refresh the page frequently to have a back-and-forth conversation.
- thethethethe 5y agoThis might be an unpopular opinion but I am getting very tired of academics thinking they can comment cross discipline and journalists somehow think it is worthy of writing an article about. This scientist isn't bringing any interesting, new ideas to the table, they are just repeating the same talking points pushed by mainstream "liberal" politicians. > My sense is that social media in particular — as well as a broader range of internet technologies, including algorithmically driven search and click-based advertising — have changed the way that people get information and form opinions about the world. And they seem to have done so in a manner that makes people particularly vulnerable to the spread of misinformation and disinformation. This is such an unbelievably shallow take. Much of the "truth" mainstream liberals have been pushing in the past year has turned out to be false. In the past, before the internet and social media, the media lied to the public all the time. It was probably easier because regular people didn't have a good way to spread primary information quickly. The media got most of their information from government press conferences and, if the government didn't like what an organization was saying, the government would stop inviting those journalists to those press conferences. There's a whole book about it, it's called Manufacturing Consent. That type of information control is no longer possible now that everyone can livestream from their phones to millions of people and the establishment is mad about it. Now they are trying to wrestle back control of information by writing think pieces about the dangers of "algorithms" and threatening tech giants with anti-trust action. Its ironic because I feel like these people are the reason social media is a threat to society. They want to use it to manipulate the public like they always have and are willing to go to great lengths to do so.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This might be an unpopular opinion but I am getting very tired of academics thinking they can comment cross discipline If academics can't comment cross discipline, no one else can comment at all.
- thethethethe 5y agoI never said that they cant, it's more that people are writing articles about their opinions when they are bringing nothing new to the table. Why doesn't vox write articles about a grocery store clerk or trucker's opinion on social media and society? Why does some biologist somehow know more about this stuff than other people who aren't sociologists? This is why conservatives think academics are snooty and elitist
- pelasaco 5y agoBut not all social media are the same. HN for example, is the only social media that I consume completely (news feeds + comment section). Everything else I limit as much as I can.. what makes HN so much better than the others? Lack of ads? Moderation?
- bckr 5y agoIntention of the creators and, yes, moderation. The exact same HTML/CSS/JS could power a community devoted to fighting a holy war against Lizard people.
- pelasaco 5y agobut not all moderation are the same too, right? I mean reddit has moderation, but IMO, there, it doesn't work as good as here.
- bckr 5y agoThat's why I mention intention of the creators. Reddit is meant to be "the front page of the Internet", which means it needs to be enormous and serve many different communities.
- anigbrowl 5y agoThat's because Reddit has a million subreddits and to some extent they compete with each other. You may find this study of virtual conflict dynamics interesting: https://snap.stanford.edu/conflict/ https://snap.stanford.edu/conflict/
- pessimizer 5y agoI think a big part of it was that it was seeded (and continues to be watered with) people who are looking for funding and/or people whose hopes are already dependent on YC and other sources of financing. People have to behave well, or there are consequences far beyond the forum.
- CodeGlitch 5y agoI don't consider HN to be social media. It's a forum isn't it? Mostly anonymous and no "pushing" of feeds or content.
- drewcoo 5y agoIf the threat is misinformation and use of social media is the risk, then I'd expect a comparison to baseline mass media misinformation. And everyone seems to agree that there is a frightening amount of that. No comparison against control and this is only evidence that scientists publish clickbait.
- enteeentee 5y agoIve often joked about this being the great filter. (Fermi paradox)
- justbored123 5y ago> contributing to phenomena such as “election tampering, disease, violent extremism, famine, racism, and war.” Sorry, but what are you talking about? The holocaust happened before social media, segregation and slavery happened before social media, religious extremism has been going on for at least 2000 years and its latest incarnation like in the middle east happened before social media. We had 2 world wars before social media, election tampering? Did you forgot about the Gore vs Bush fiasco before social media? I could go on all day, what are you talking about? This is the best we had had it on all those fronts today after social media. You are making no sense. The first "cross-disciplinary" change we need is more historians combating this type of unbelievable childish ignorance and lack of perspective of reality.
- JoshTko 5y agoThere is simply too much noise/signal. We truly need a protected class of speech/news that cannot lie by law. This is similar to standardizing currency in order to facilitate trade without risk, except for information.
- polalavik 5y agoBut who will be the arbiter of truth?
- stuntkite 5y agoI’m currently not that busy really. Let me know when the arbiter position opens up and I’ll rearrange my schedule.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoWeb of Trust
- wwweston 5y agoAny society that is premised on the rule of law already has to solve that problem in the enforcement; there is no rule of law without arbitration of facts relating to whether the law is upheld or not. So, probably the courts. That's an imperfect solution, but it beats the hell out of the position that any attempt to arbitrate the truth is unacceptably oppressive. On another level: everyone has an obligation to arbitrate the truth as honestly and ably as they're capable, in every domain they have responsibility for, first and foremost in training themselves to be more careful about their own blind spots, tendencies, incentives, and limits, and then in exercising whatever influence and authority they have.
- errantmind 5y agoThe courts are specialists in the law, not the truth. I sincerely doubt them deciding what is true and what isn't "beats the hell out of the position that any attempt to arbitrate the truth is unacceptably oppressive". It would quickly turn into a dystopian nightmare. Have you never thought about why freedom of speech is an important and worthy fundamental right?
- baby 5y agoHistory repeats itself. The same thing happened when the phone was invented, and radio, and tv, and the mail, and newspapers, etc.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoHumans simply didn't evolve to live in communities as large as the ones which enabled us to really push our foot on the gas in terms of technological and civilization progress. People look at social media but it started waaay earlier, back in old Mesopotamia. Mesopotamic Urbanization>Ability to write>Journals>Newspapers>Radio>TV>Internet>Social Media Social media is just the last step in the process. Each and every step of the process contributed to make humans learn about how many humans are there in the world and this somehow makes us feel less special. When we wrap our minds around how many humans are there in the world, we feel insignificant and we feel like we don't matter at all. In a sense our sense of worth feels diluted by the immense quanity of people who are just like us. This creates anxiety and resentment. Our brain is still the same as we had back in pre-Mesopotamic eras.
- docdeek 5y agoThere's a quote in a Michael Crichton novel (The Lost World) that seems relevant here. As part of a rant connecting the idea of the internet and evolution, a character opines: "This idea that the whole world is wired together is mass death. Every biologist knows that small groups in isolation evolve fastest. You put a thousand birds on an ocean island and they'll evolve very fast. You put ten thousand on a big continent, and their evolution slows down. Now, for our own species, evolution occurs mostly through our behaviour. We innovate new behaviour to adapt. And everybody on earth knows that innovation only occurs in small groups. Put three people on a committee and they may get something done. Ten people, and it gets harder. Thirty people, and nothing happens. Thirty million, it becomes impossible. That's the effect of mass media - it keeps anything from happening. Mass media swamps diversity. It makes every place the same. Bangkok or Tokyo or London: there's a McDonald's on one corner, a Benetton on another, a Gap across the street. Regional differences vanish. All differences vanish. In a mass-media world, there's less of everything except the top ten books, records, movies, ideas. People worry about losing species diversity in the rain forest. But what about intellectual diversity - our most necessary resource? That's disappearing faster than trees. But we haven't figured that out, so now we're planning to put five billion people together in cyberspace. And it'll freeze the entire species. Everything will stop dead in its tracks. Everyone will think the same thing at the same time. Global uniformity."
- adt2bt 5y agoSee: Edison bulbs in every dark bar worldwide. This phenomenon is real.
- amelius 5y agoOn the other hand, are tribes or nations which are not intimately connected to the western world that much better off? And science evolved greatly in the highly interconnected parts of the world.
- notriddle 5y agoThey aren’t better off. That’s what makes this whole thing so dire — there’s value in being different, just for the sake of being different, but nobody is going to willingly choose to do something materially worse just on the off-chance that the Current Best Practice happens to have some horrible, unseen downside 50 years later.
- mrfusion 5y agoI thought this xkcd had a humorous take on this idea https://xkcd.com/2481/ https://xkcd.com/2481/
- sitkack 5y ago"Stewardship of global collective behavior." https://www.pnas.org/content/118/27/e2025764118 https://www.pnas.org/content/118/27/e2025764118 Abstract > Collective behavior provides a framework for understanding how the actions and properties of groups emerge from the way individuals generate and share information. In humans, information flows were initially shaped by natural selection yet are increasingly structured by emerging communication technologies. Our larger, more complex social networks now transfer high-fidelity information over vast distances at low cost. The digital age and the rise of social media have accelerated changes to our social systems, with poorly understood functional consequences. This gap in our knowledge represents a principal challenge to scientific progress, democracy, and actions to address global crises. We argue that the study of collective behavior must rise to a “crisis discipline” just as medicine, conservation, and climate science have, with a focus on providing actionable insight to policymakers and regulators for the stewardship of social systems.
- MrRadar 5y agoI think science fiction author Charles Stores put it best in this 2016 blog post[1]: > 2007 is when the human species accidentally invented telepathy (via the fusion of twitter, facebook, and other disclosure-induction social media with always-connected handheld internet devices). Telepathy, unfortunately, turns out to not be all about elevated Apollonian abstract intellectualism: it's an emotion amplifier and taps into the most toxic wellsprings of the subconscious. As implemented, it brings out the worst in us. Twitter and Facebook et al are fine-tuned to turn us all into car-crash rubberneckers and public execution spectators. It can be used for good, but more often it drags us down into the dim-witted, outraged weltanschauung of the mob. [1] https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2016/01/some-american-political-marker.html https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2016/01/some-am...
- freebuju 5y agoMisinformation and scarcity of quality information on social media platforms was bound to happen when these platforms hit critical mass. Moderating SM is damn near impossible to do effectively. It is also easy to game SM. From fake clicks/views (bots) to old accounts used for astroturfing etc, the information market is not at a level playing field. And since they are all run on some form of hyper-intelligent ML algorithm, none of it from a user perspective is intuitive anymore. The bigger risk in my opinion is how SM and use of it on digital devices has impacted human behavior. More specifically, psychologically. Dopamine hits and instant gratification must have rewired our brains in the past ~2 decades.
- epgui 5y agoI totally agree that "moderating SM is damn near impossible to do effectively", but at the same time, viral misinformation is often super easy to identify and yet is allowed to spread for weeks or months or years. We could do a much better job at moderating the obviously wrong stuff. And no, I'm not talking about censoring unpopular or contrary opinions. I'm just talking about extinguishing obvious and clear mis/dis-information.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoLong before social media, most movies, TV shows and the like in the US came out of California and New York. These are very urban places and I spent a lot of my life feeling kind of like "I must be doing it wrong" because my life didn't seem to match up with what I was seeing in popular media. I eventually concluded that for most of America, what we see on TV and in movies doesn't match our lives. I think the internet is actually an opportunity to give push back against that and better develop local or regional identifies elsewhere and give them a voice.
- falsaberN1 5y agoYou are expected to believe that what a movie offers is an idealized, exaggerated or just plain fantastic take on real life. Examples exist that cannot tell reality from fiction, but that's generally the gist of it. However, much more people are willing to believe that what they see in social media is real. Now think of how many people are feeling "they must be doing it wrong", with that in mind.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoThe problem is, that social media and the hate waves it generates, can be used to hack the elite - the decision makers. It convinces them, that more social media, more china style social media control is necessary. Fear is a strong vector. And if you can create the proof that you are needed, you control the market.
- motohagiography 5y agoWhat a relief it was to read that these particular people were so concerned about misinformation prevailing, as most of what they consider misinformation is many of us call freedom, leadership, faith, and courage. Social media is horrible for lots of reasons, mainly because it throws everyone who would never normally encounter each other into the same bucket of crabs, but their framing of the problem essentially reduces to being concerned the wrong kind of crabs are climbing too far.
- baldanders 5y agoI believe that we are going to start seeing the rise of purposely stripped-down software, ie text-only social media platforms or social media platforms with hard-caps on the number of connections you can add per account. Information technology will begin to be viewed through a more biological lens. The best analogy I can think of is our current relationship with food. We acknowledge that our biological reward systems can be hijacked via junk food and we have erected massive systems to curtail these destructive impulses. Despite this, there are still those who gorge themselves on unhealthy food due to their lack of education and/or an inability to afford healthier food. As soon as the negative effects of social media begin to manifest themselves in the upper classes (students failing classes en masse, severe incompetence in the job market, increased generation of brain-dead media) new platforms will be created to allow people to take advantage of technology without being caught up in the biological loopholes that modern social media create. The majority of the lower classes will continue to use exploitative platforms, which will probably become much worse as it is made more explicit that their user-base is made up of a cattle-caste. Much like food, I predict that the health-conscious platforms will erect paywalls and other barriers to entry that will further cement the class divide. It would take me hours to really flesh out what I'm trying to say here but I think that I was able to squeeze some of it out.
- grumblenum 5y agoGopher and Gemini are attempts at this. There are a few comfortable online communities out there when you get away from the big web properties. Unless you’re into gamification of showing how orthodox and au currant you are. Then there’s Reddit.
- specialist 5y agoEvery new communications media has the same lifecycle. Initial enthusiasm, lots of disruption & creativity, then captured by reactionaries and traditionalists. Spasms of overreach and overcorrection. Cycles of purges and remything. Obelisks, cuneiform, drums, papyrus, pigeons, pony express, paper, moveable type, radio waves, light beams. The disruption to society and culture is always the same. The only variable is impact predetermined by production costs. Lather, rinse, repeat. The trick for us plebes is finding untapped margins and eddies, do our own thing, maybe find our tribe.
- cratermoon 5y agoAllow me to direct your attention to the works of Tristan Harris, B. J. Fogg, and Herbert A. Simon. Simon coined the term "attention economy" in 1992 with "The Bottleneck of Attention: Connecting Thought with Motivation".
- acituan 5y ago"Focus on the downsides of democratized information; here are some cherry-picked experts." - Vox the entertainment website
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sakopov 5y agoSocial media is part of human evolution. Removing it is unproductive. It's another way of communicating that we haven't yet figured out how to do properly. It seems like it started off on a good path, but quickly turned into hate, violence and just constant spewing of garbage. The reason it doesn't work is because it literally lacks just about everything that is present in real face-to-face interactions such as accountability, responsibility and (most importantly) exchange of social ques either verbally or via body language. The next challenge in social media is how to revolutionize mass communication beyond a blob of text.
- magwa101 5y agoAcademics arguing for control of information, sounds about par.
- epgui 5y agoFor what it's worth, you can add this lowly biochemist to the list.
- ppf 5y agoSo the issue with social media is that it allows mass dissent from the officially-promoted opinions on various subjects? I think social media is a mass contagion that will doom us to ineffectual and isolated failure, but for that first reason, it has been essential. Or maybe, without social media to promote those very officially-approved opinions, we would have used our vast and deep social IRL network to discuss and reason, and would have come to that conclusion anyway. I strongly believe that the various world governments' policies of lockdown, social isolation, and mask wearing would not have worked 50 years ago, because we were too connected.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lifeplusplus 5y agoAs connectedness increases, the diversity of perspectives decreases.