12 ms·
Note to people outside of the US who are worried about this: The rest of the world uses 3G/4G modems in their smart meters, they are usually also connected to
by theshrike79 5y ago
Note to people outside of the US who are worried about this:
The rest of the world uses 3G/4G modems in their smart meters, they are usually also connected to a different APN than generic mobile data. Sometimes multiple meters are connected to a central hub with a physical wire (in apartment buildings for example). The hub is then the only gateway to the internet.
The hack in question is only viable because of the weird way US smart meter collection is done.
US Smart Meters use RF to shout out their values everywhere like an RF beacon. A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on.
Source: I did smart metering software for L+G.
- gruez 5y ago>US Smart Meters use RF to shout out their values everywhere like an RF beacon. A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. I thought they transmitted over the power line? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-line_communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-line_communication
- theshrike79 5y agoPLC does have its limits, mostly in range and bandwidth and it's highly dependent on the type of copper actually in the ground. But when it works, it's a lot more reliable than the RF abomination some networks are doing =)
- orf 5y ago> A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. What the fuck
- tgv 5y agoIt's like the meter man visiting your house, but now they no longer have to enter. Isn't it wonderful? If I lived in the US, I'd immediately try to hack up a small Arduino project to read out my neighbours' energy usage.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoUse SDR networks to do it from afar. http://www.websdr.org/ http://www.websdr.org/
- amluto 5y agoI think most of the modern gear uses ZigBee’s publicly document smart energy protocols. It’s encrypted.
- dperfect 5y agoI do this with a cheap (~$20) USB RTL-SDR – no Arduino or custom electronics necessary. Of course, I only use it to monitor my own energy usage (electricity and gas) using rtlamr[1] and a script that periodically sends the data to InfluxDB, then displayed using Grafana. The result is a smart home energy monitor that doesn't require any clamps near the electrical panel, and it exactly matches the usage for which I'll be billed. [1] https://github.com/bemasher/rtlamr https://github.com/bemasher/rtlamr
- flatiron 5y agoCrazy how easy that is. I bet within a year we hear about criminals using something like this to know when people leave their house for extended periods.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat repo is over 7 years old. It’s exploitable, but I’m pretty convinced that this info has been out for many years. https://hackaday.com/2014/02/25/using-sdr-to-read-your-smart-meter/ https://hackaday.com/2014/02/25/using-sdr-to-read-your-smart...
- wolrah 5y agoCan confirm, I was playing with this in my neighborhood years ago. I'm pretty sure it was the gas meters I was seeing.
- 5y ago
- winrid 5y agoI suppose most of this infra was designed before cell towers were prominent enough.
- AnssiH 5y agoWell, looks like smart meters started appearing in US slightly later than e.g. here in Finland, around 2006-2007, so I'm not sure that explains the difference. Could be explained by lower mobile network coverage in U.S., I guess. US statistic: https://www.statista.com/statistics/676472/number-of-smart-meter-installations-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/676472/number-of-smart-m... In 2005 in Finland about 7% of households had smart meters, with 80%+ coverage mandated by 2013 and actual coverage of 99.6% of under-63A meters in 2016 (Finnish sources: https://www.vttresearch.com/sites/default/files/julkaisut/muut/2006/VTT-R-09048-06.pdf https://www.vttresearch.com/sites/default/files/julkaisut/mu... https://tem.fi/documents/1410877/3481825/AMR+2.0+loppuraportti+15.12.2017/6a2df7e6-a963-40c0-b4d8-d2533fbca488/AMR+2.0+loppuraportti+15.12.2017.pdf https://tem.fi/documents/1410877/3481825/AMR+2.0+loppuraport...).
- Scoundreller 5y agoWhat’s special about 63A meters? That’s low, but I guess nobody has electric heat/AC. I guess they’re the ones that can be installed indoors?
- theshrike79 5y ago3x 63A is the reasonable maximum a normal consumer would want at their house. Normal houses are around 3x 32A. Everything over that is a commercial building and they get billed with different rules and measurements due to the equipment they tend to have. Something about three phase engines and power phases in commercial lighting. I zoned out during those meetings :D
- archi42 5y agoFinland has 230V, so if you're from the US with 110V the low current rating might be confusing ;-) I'd also guess that in Finland they also run three phases into each house/unit (we do in Germany), meaning that's 3*63A = 189A. (Or just shy of 400A on a 110V grid). For us that's the default grid connection you get for your house. As for your guess: That's just a cultural thing I suppose. I've never seen outdoor meters around here.
- geerlingguy 5y agoWe used to have meter readers running (literally) from house to house jotting down the numbers.
- elliekelly 5y agoYes but that’s one data point at one singular moment in time being collected by one person. Smart meters continually broadcast a constant stream of data to anyone who cares to listen.
- wyldfire 5y agoIf I had to guess, it's likely a response to an [unauthenticated] inquiry. If so it's probably not quite the same but effectively similar.
- toast0 5y agoDepends on the meters. My electric utility just replaced their old (circa 1999) smart meters which were one way broadcast with a new smart meter that's supposed to be two way capable. I didn't notice a lot of change at their data collection base station (which happens to be at the corner of my driveway), so I don't know if they already had a transmitter in addition to a receiver, or if it's small enough to fit in the existing equipment box or if they're using a different station.
- amiga 5y agoThe meters used in my area can be wirelessly shut down by any nearby power technician. They have vans with very visible PVC pipes mounted on the roof to interact with the meters.
- ac29 5y ago> They have vans with very visible PVC pipes mounted on the roof to interact with the meters That's more likely a fiberglass antenna.
- username90 5y agoAlmost surely much cheaper short term than having a team of engineers and installers to fix the problem.
- matmatmatmat 5y agoDifferent power companies use different smart meter tech, not all of which is easily readable. SDG&E uses encrypted Zigbee to transmit data. AFAIK, it has not been cracked.
- nicholashead 5y agoI use a Rainforest https://www.rainforestautomation.com/ https://www.rainforestautomation.com/ device to read my own meter on SDG&E and it works, I think I had to go through an auth process though.
- mschuster91 5y agoIndeed. I wonder if one could set up a fake transmitter that sends corrupt data (to lower one's own energy bill, hide a marijuana plantation, or to cause issues in a neighbor dispute), or what would happen if one would blanket jam the entire frequency.
- elliekelly 5y agoI wonder if they do any sort of audit of the amount of power used vs billed and, if so, at what scale. How long would it take them to identify the discrepancy? As long as it was pretty small-scale and not trying to hide a huge crypto-mining operation of something I suspect it would be a very long time before anyone figured it out.
- theshrike79 5y agoThat depends on the power company. But it's quite trivial to compare your average consumption with similar users and find the outliers. That's how people who steal power get caught for example and grow-houses :) And it's also a useful tool for the consumers themselves to know if they are spending more/less/equal amounts of electricity as people with similar profiles.
- Majromax 5y ago> or what would happen Charges for fraud (in the case of false data) and disruption to electrical service at the state level, and charges for unauthorized radio interference at the federal level.
- netr0ute 5y agoThis is the worst case scenario.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoBut a realistic one, especially if it became common enough to want to crack down and make examples.
- amluto 5y agoI am highly in favor of this type of self contained technology. The last thing we need is for the grid to become inadvertently dependent on the cell network, which is, in turn, dependent on the grid. If there’s a multi-day outage that takes out the cell battery backups, the grid needs to be able to start up independently. This is hard enough without accidental networking dependencies. (I believe that at least some of the blatant inequity in the Texas blackouts was necessary for this type of reason. There were various critical facilities (gas pumping stations, for example) that, if shut down due to rolling blackouts, would have further reduced grid capacity.)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the grid to become inadvertently dependent on the cell network, which is, in turn, dependent on the grid The grid wouldn't be dependent on the cell network. Billing would.
- willis936 5y agoIf I don't get billed for my power usage then I'm 100% craning my AC, as will everyone else.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> If I don't get billed for my power usage then I'm 100% craning my AC, as will everyone else Sorry, in what relevant scenario does the power company never get paid? OP pointed out a potential feedback loop between the cell network going down and the grid failing. Are you suggesting everyone will crank up their AC when the network fails because the power company will have some difficulty collecting metering data that day?
- cesarb 5y agoIf modern smart meters are anything like classic mechanical meters, they have a counter of the total amount of power consumed so far, and the power company bills the difference between the current reading and the previous month's reading. Which means that, once the meter can be read again, you will be billed for all the power consumed in the meantime.
- reaperducer 5y agoI'm not sure what the source of your astonishment is. Water, gas, and power companies have been doing this for at least a decade. It's a good solution for a nation with a low population density. In higher density locations, meter readers and cellular connections are used.
- gregimba 5y agoThe reason we got smart meters in Austin, TX is because they weren't even recording readings just guessing what that reading should be based on historical data. https://texasmonitor.org/settlement-reached-on-austins-made-up-meter-readings/ https://texasmonitor.org/settlement-reached-on-austins-made-...
- yaantc 5y ago> The rest of the world uses 3G/4G modems in their smart meters, they are usually also connected to a different APN than generic mobile data. Yes. I guess it's worth stressing this, as it seems taken for granted by people experienced with cellular M2M/IoT but maybe not so well known in the general public. A cellular modem is first connected to an operator network. For mainstream subscriptions it is then connected from there to the Internet, making a device behind the modem reachable over the Internet, with all the security issues associated. But for business customers the telcos offer "private APN" subscriptions, with a VPN connection to the customer. Then the modems are connected to the customer and not to the internet, and the devices behind are not publicly reachable. Support of private APNs is part of cellular data since 2G GPRS, so from the very start. One can expect industrial cellular users to use them.
- laurencerowe 5y agoMobile networks evolve fairly quickly. Spectrum is limited so mobile operators like to phase out older standards in favour of newer ones to make better use of their available spectrum. Upgrading the modem in a smart meter requires visiting every location you serve. That's not something a utility would like to do more than once every few decades. With 3G and 2G now being phased out, will utilities have to replace all their smart meters? https://hyphabit.io/2g-network-closure-uk/ https://hyphabit.io/2g-network-closure-uk/
- yaantc 5y agoIt's a valid concern, but it's a contractual problem more than a technology one. Companies doing smart meters are not taking the basic subscriptions made for the public. They have dedicated contracts with their telcos, with commitment for long term support. So these smart meters companies have visibility and guarantees, and are updated on the telcos long term plans. That's what enable them to deploy meters with 15 years of life span. The way it works in practice is that telcos may close their "old" 2G (or 3G, but 3G is not used much there. Most jump direct from 2G to 4G) networks to the public, but keep some capacity in operation for those industrial users only for a lot more time --- as long as needed per their contractual obligations. The general public won't see this, as these frequencies will be denied to anyone but specific industrial subscribers. There's no need for much capacity either, as smart meter don't "talk" much. Another way these long term needs can be addressed is through standard support. For IoT, LTE (perceived as a 4G technology) meets the 5G requirements from R15 onward. And there's work to support these LTE IoT devices (LTE-M, NB-IoT) over "5G" (the tech is called "NR", or "New Radio". Engineering naming ;) channels onward, so there won't be a need for dedicated LTE IoT channels for IoT, as is done for 2G. So independent of the way it's done, the cellular industry does support long term commitment for M2M/IoT. But as you can see, it's geared toward big customers in practice. In theory one could think about ways to open this to smaller clients (cloud like subscription and access), but I'm not sure anyone does this. It's not a tech problem, more a cultural and business one.
- jaywalk 5y ago> A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. Maybe it used to work this way, or some uncommon types of meters work this way, but I've never seen them. The only ones I've seen broadcast to collectors that are usually on street lights, which are then connected to the power company's network. If you go to the wiki that's linked at the end of the article, they've even got pictures of one: https://wiki.recessim.com/view/Landis%2BGyr_Collector https://wiki.recessim.com/view/Landis%2BGyr_Collector The connector on the front would have an antenna, and they're usually placed right before the light on the pole facing down.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoI've lived in a couple (new) houses in Texas that all use the method described above. I see the utility trucks driving around pretty frequently, and have even had a guy get out and get closer to my meter until his handheld device beeped, apparently indicating he got the data.
- h2odragon 5y agoMore info: Read Home Power Meters With RTL-SDR https://hackaday.com/2017/12/21/read-home-power-meters-with-rtl-sdr/ https://hackaday.com/2017/12/21/read-home-power-meters-with-...
- organsnyder 5y agoIt depends on your power company. My power company in Michigan uses cellular.
- api 5y agoSounds secure. I bet you could build a box to spoof your readings low and steal electricity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tzs 5y ago> US Smart Meters use RF to shout out their values everywhere like an RF beacon. A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. > Source: I did smart metering software for L+G. How long ago? I believe that was how the earliest meters that did not require someone to actually look at the dials worked, but many or most have moved on. For example the meters that Puget Sound Energy is in the middle of upgrading too (they did mine a couple months ago) (Landis+Gyr meter using their Gridstream RF system) form a mesh network to communicate with the mothership, which they describe thusly [1]: > At the center of the Gridstream RF Mesh solution is a true mesh, peer-to-peer network where each endpoint, device and router communicate in a peer-to-peer fashion, extending the coverage and reliability of the network. The asynchronous, multi-channel communication structure allows for increased data throughput and opens more paths to the data collector. > The self-healing network features dynamic routing messages that automatically adjust for changes to endpoints and the introduction of obstructions, such as foliage or new construction. System routers utilize one Watt of power to increase transmit distance and throughput, while data collectors support up to 25,000 meters, further minimizing infrastructure and maintenance costs. The documents tab on that page has PDFs with product sheets for the various components (endpoints, collectors, routers). The previous meters PSE used looked like traditional analog meters, but my account page at PSE showed my daily usage, updated daily, so they definitely had some kind of remote reading capability. I'm sure it was not someone driving around the neighborhood daily because it continued updating even whenever weather made it so it was very difficult to get a vehicle into my area for several days. I don't know if those were a mesh network--they were installed sometime in the very early 2000s I believe which seems a little early for that. Could have been cellular or power line networking. I know that both of those techniques have been used fairly widely--I just don't know what my particular meter was using. [1] https://www.landisgyr.com/product/gridstream-rf-2/ https://www.landisgyr.com/product/gridstream-rf-2/
- theshrike79 5y agoThe RF stuff is old, I didn't touch those that much. Americans had their own systems, did hear the stories though. Meshnets are the newer system, but still use RF and have their own issues (like car keyfobs in the same frequency either freezing completely or randomly opening/locking car doors :D)
- aftbit 5y agoBut that's even worse, because then the meters are connected to the internet, rather than only accessible within a few block radius.
- theshrike79 5y agoNope. Check out yaantc's comment. tl;dr it's a completely separate network with no internet access. Basically a VLAN inside the cell network.
- consp 5y agoThis is also done for the calorimeters on my radiators for centrally provided heating. That is in Europe.
- Scoundreller 5y agoHave you tried modifying/pointing a microwave at your calorimeter exit sensor to heat it so your meter spins backwards? (Source: employer locked up the thermostat to keep us frigid to save money, but I just put an ice pack on top of it)
- consp 5y agoMy neighbors basically heat my home in the winter so that would wind it back below zero which they probably would not like. One of them is close to a refrigerator and actually measured heat output but the radiator is disconnected. I got my 60ct of charge back that year. You might not be able to wind them back (they are digital) but I'm pretty sure you can manipulate them with sufficient heat shielding something like your method to change the value.
- Scoundreller 5y agoWait, what are they measuring? Shouldn’t they measure incoming fluid temperature, outgoing fluid temperature, and volume? I thought the scam would be to heat the metal temperature probe inside the exit pipe faster than it rejected that heat (doable with an RF beam).
- Scoundreller 5y ago> A power company vehicle drives around the neighbourhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. I wonder how long it is until Uber or Amazon, or the postal service, strikes a deal with the power company to power this last mile sneakernet.
- mike_d 5y agoNever because it doesn't work this way. All the smart meters I have seen form a peer-to-peer mesh and relay data until it hits a collector (every 8-10 blocks) on a telephone pole that has a connection to the power/water company.
- markus_zhang 5y agoInteresting. The truck somehow reminds me of the radio signal tracking trucks anti-espionage offcials relied on back in WW2.
- joncrane 5y agoSomeone told me a long time ago that this arrangement was due to employment agreements with the so-called "meter maids." They originally wanted to fully automate it, but they didn't want to un-employ their fleet of meter readers, so the compromise was for the meter readers to simply drive down all the streets rather than go behind all the houses. The meter readers' jobs got a lot easier but they got to collect the same amount of money. I believe a union was involved but don't quote me on that. This is what someone told me, I am not presenting it as fact. If you know differently, please debunk.
- dkarp 5y agoIn the UK, new smart meters can apparently function as a mesh network and forward readings through each other. They also use "Long Range Radio" instead of 2g/3g service in some locations. https://www.smartme.co.uk/technical.html https://www.smartme.co.uk/technical.html
- KirillPanov 5y agoI've noticed that US utilities generally have a "dependency hierarchy": the telephone company is allowed to rely on the electrical utility, but not vice-versa. Water+sewer are another step up (and often have large, expensive diesel generators). I think most electrical utilities in the US would balk at being dependent on a cellular telephone company. Many of them won't even lease fiber from the telcos, insisting on stringing up their own instead.
- blantonl 5y agoA power company vehicle drives around the neighborhood, collecting the values, storing them and moves on. Actually, most is collected now via Internet connected reception points typically installed on traffic lights and electrical poles strategically stationed near neighborhoods.
- theshrike79 5y agoStill you've got RF meters shouting their statistics to everyone. The Germans would have a fit about that. It's illegal to measure electricity with under 24 hour granularity in Germany and IIRC in Switzerland. And there are really specific rules on what can be measured and how much of the data can be stored in the meter.
- ortusdux 5y agoI was at a local hacker space for a photo-op visit by the mayor. One of the things she talked about was the city's new smart power grid. Several members were upset about the fact that they were required to have these meters on their house, mostly because of how insecure they were. If I remember correctly, they were not password protected, and they had just turned off SSID broadcasting. One of the members couldn't help himself and showed her how trivial it was to access the meter's mesh network, which he demonstrated by pinging the meter at the mayors mansion. It was an awkward evening.
- reaperducer 5y agoDo you mine stating which city this was in? I ask because I've a long-standing curiosity about which cities still maintain mayors' mansions (and governors' mansions). I know New York does, but I haven't run into it too many other places.
- keanebean86 5y agoArkansas had a really nice governor's mansion years ago. https://www.nytimes.com/2000/07/19/us/little-rock-journal-governor-s-mansion-is-a-triple-wide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2000/07/19/us/little-rock-journal-go...
- kleton 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Mayors%27_mansions_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Mayors%27_mansions_in...
- ortusdux 5y agoConfusingly enough, the "mayor's house" belonged to the city's first mayor, and is now a museum and event space. It has a proper name, but the locals all know it as the mayors house. It is not a residence set aside for the current mayor.
- canadianfella 5y agoMine?
- tkojames 5y agoI think most places have upgraded to sending the RF signals to a local repeater and backhaul it. I know for pge they send the data hourly no trucks.
- dingosity 5y agoFWIW, this is also how some organizations collected data from grow houses in the 2000s and early 2010s. Though they didn't broadcast SSIDs and wouldn't chat on the network unless they saw a specific sequence broadcast by the mobile station.
- ljm 5y agoI'm sure my UK-based smart meter is RF-based, but you can hook it up to your wifi to link your energy account to it. The metres themselves have a 10m range (one for gas, usually outside, another for leccy, usually inside) so a receiver outside of that won't function.
- reaperducer 5y agoThe rest of the world uses 3G/4G modems in their smart meters I'd suspect this is an exaggeration. I've been plenty of places in the world (yes, even Europe) with no cellular connectivity. So clearly "the rest of the world" is a generalization.
- cool_dude85 5y agoThe drive-by van stuff is old tech, I think most new metering platforms are on mesh networks now where there is some kind of central receiver connected via wire that all the meters communicate to. I don't know if they still use RF to do so, but the van driving is specifically considered very old fashioned these days.
- Faaak 5y agoLandys&Gyr is a bit old school in this regard. Some countries (like France or Spain), use communications via PLC which are encrypted to the local transformer. They are then sent to the distributor via 4g/whatever
- makr17 5y agoFrom my desk in a residential but dense area I can see 60-70 meters at any given time with a usb sdr. Water meters in our area do the same, but since it is near the street and below-grade I can only see a few of those. After having looked around for a while in disbelief, I now filter the capture from the SDR to just the ids of my meters. And I accept the fact that someone sufficiently-motivated could figure out when we're on vacation based on the broadcast consumption values...
- theshrike79 5y agoThis is one of the reasons Germans/Swiss freak out about too exact power metering, it's a privacy issue. Germans did royally fuck this up at one point and they had a provider that measured power consumption at so high a frequency that you could detect what TV show people were watching based on the power consumption. [0] [0] https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/01/08/28c3-smart-meter-hacking-can-disclose-which-tv-shows-and-movies-you-watch/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/01/08/28c3-smart-meter...
- stevenhubertron 5y agoI use my RTL-SDR to read my own power meter and then pipe that data into my Home Assistant instance so I can get depressed when I see the spike when I use my central AC. It's actually quite cool. I haven't yet figured how to do it for my water meter yet though.