19 ms·
Star Citizen Progress Tracker v1.0
- dstick 5y agoI half expected this to just say “When it’s done” :D
- Aeolun 5y agoIs there an actual game to play now? When I backed this a decade ago I kind of expected to see this game before I turned 30.
- chmod775 5y agoYou can see people play this on Twitch, but it'll only be fun if you have a bunch of buddies to roleplay with in the world. Not much of a "game" yet for lack of interesting gameplay loops. Here's a bunch of people having a good time and making a video out of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31v7sSGfTm8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31v7sSGfTm8
- jiofih 5y agoThat actually looks amazing. Hope they can get it to an appealing state before the engine is outdated again!
- tibbydudeza 5y agoThey still on Lumberyard ???. Reminds me of Duke Nukem sequel who never was released because the dev team kept switching engines every few years because of envy.
- Ralfp 5y agoGearbox eventually released that game, and it was complete mess of outdated gameplay and unpolished things cobbled together to fill the game time somehow.
- gmueckl 5y agoFor all the vastness and detail in it, this world is still only a partialy complete single solar system and an even tinier fraction of what was originally promised (about 100 handcrafted star systems). At the same time it is empty, desolate and devoid of fun things to do. The sheer size of everything, which sounds so cool on paper, is a fundamental curse for the gameplay: PvP relies on players encountering players. PvE or anything with NPC involvement needs to be handcrafted to be fun. Generated missions always have a bland structure and get repetitive and boring fast. The end result is that there is no really good way to actually make use of all that empty volume that the game already has. And that ratio is only going to become worse if all the other solar systems get added. And Star Citizen revels in that available playground with excessive travel times, low ship ranges, few ways to discover and intercept nearby ships, etc. For comparison, Elite: Dangerous has an even vaster playing field, but it does three things that make it work: the vast majority of the galaxy is designed for lone explorers cruising out there and trying to survive without assistance. The rest of the gameplay is contricted to "the bubble", a tiny part of the galaxy that contains civilization. There, all the PvP and PvE gameplay is concentrated. Little tricks help focus most of the gameplay on very few spots in each solar system, forcing encounters to happen quite naturally. Arrival in a solar system is always at a specific point near its star. Likewise, trading and resupply happens at only very few places in each system. These are the places you need to reach as a miner or trader to make money. And these are the spots to stake out as a pirate or bounty hunter. Supercruise also turns the vastness of space within a system into a playing field of reasonable size that also reveals most of the traffic.
- deadbunny 5y agoDo they even have a flight model yet? Last I played (a few years ago) the flight model was worse than that of Asteroids.
- dainchi 5y agoThey're on the 5th(or 6th?) iteration now, and the flight model still feels like crap. Part of that is that they have to rebalance every ship with every Iteration, and they keep making more ships... Also, the large size of the world kind of destroys any kind of balance, given that ships need to travel at 1000+ m/s to make travel possible, but combat at those speeds is basically a dps fest where you click on a small icon in the distance, with no dodging or outflying the other pilot. They've tried to adress this in like 3 different ways at this point, and nothing has worked. Regardless, I will never understand why they didn't just massively reduce weapon ranges and copy ED's flight model, given that it is pretty much the best in the "WW2 dogfights in space" business, and has been out for over 8 years now.
- kowlo 5y agoPoor PNC sentenced to forever walk into that wall https://youtu.be/31v7sSGfTm8?t=470 https://youtu.be/31v7sSGfTm8?t=470
- RGamma 5y agoMaybe you'll be able to bridge the rest of the time with Half Life 3. Oh wait..
- Deestan 5y agoIn my view, Half Life 3 did come out. It was just called Wolfenstein. For all practical purposes, there is no longer a HL3 shaped hole.
- dainchi 5y agoGiven all the prep work HL:Alyx did, I wouldn't be surprised if there eventually was a HL3, it's just going to take another decade or so until enough people have a VR headset(or future disruptive equivalent) to make it worth it.
- anoraca 5y agoSquadron 42 was supposed to be a stand alone game that was part of it, still not ready https://www.polygon.com/2020/12/28/22203055/star-citizen-squadron-42-release-date-beta-delayed-alpha-testing-funding https://www.polygon.com/2020/12/28/22203055/star-citizen-squ...
- liaukovv 5y agoHow many years has it been?
- duskwuff 5y agoAbout ten years now. It's not quite up to Duke Nukem Forever levels yet (15 years), but it's already one of the longest development cycles for a commercial game.
- Shadonic 5y ago8 if you count the scope creep basically requiring a complete redo on how things are done for the entirety of the game.
- beardedscotsman 5y agoI've moved full to Mac since I purchased Star Citizen. I guess I'll never get a chance to play this.
- liaukovv 5y agoMac support feature added, release date pushed back by 5 years.
- danparsonson 5y agoDon't feel bad, no-one else will get a chance to play it either ;-)
- yb17178 5y agoLooks like less is done now than before. Chris roberts and sandi Gardner are theives and prey on the dreams of hopeful space gamers. Shame.
- least 5y agoI bought a ship relatively late, in 2013. I also built my gaming PC that I'm still using to this day around then hoping to have something beefy enough to play Star Citizen. Obviously that was stupid, lesson learned. Chris Roberts has made some phenomenal games that I absolutely love, but even Freelancer was in production hell for years before being reigned in by Microsoft. Star Citizen is pretty much all of those huge ideas he has always wanted to build on but now with an essentially unlimited budget funded by idiots like me that believed he'd actually be able to deliver an actual game. Seeing a progress tracker for it is just a slap in the face. They aren't being held accountable by anyone but themselves and they've proved time and time again that they're incapable of sticking to timelines. They'll just create more awesome looking tech demos that are probably not even linked together into a fully realized and playable game. If Star Citizen could actually deliver everything it promised, it'd be a damned near perfect game for a nerd like me who loves science fiction, outer space, and epic space operas. The idea of zooming through the cosmos on my ship "Freelancer" with a group of friends doing whatever we feel like, exploring new worlds, fighting space pirates, and getting a drink on an old and decrepit space station built a century ago sounds like everything I ever wanted in a video game. Sadly, Star Citizen will never be that game.
- sen 5y agoAnother vote for Elite Dangerous. It might not be quite as flashy and beautiful but it’s depth is seriously awesome. There’s so much to do.
- sleepy_keita 5y agoI still play Freelancer sometimes. It's a great game.
- Causality1 5y agoYes, and so easy to mod. The cancelation of the sequel broke my heart.
- Ralfp 5y agoSequel would break your heart even more, because it was going to be completely different animal with much more linear game and Xbox360 exclusivity.
- notum 5y agoThe game I regularly forget I own.
- bilekas 5y agoThis is an incredible ongoing project that just sums up all of the pitfalls in development. Bad initial design, change of engines, licensing issues, unbelievable feature creep, questionable management.. And I'm not sure exactly, but this progress tracker suggests the game will be complete by March 2022 ? Its just begging for criticism.
- gmueckl 5y agoThis progress tracker only shows the planning until Q1 2022. If you expect a final release then, the joke is on you. The planning timeline will always be extended. Features will always be added. It is a proven business model. Releasing a finished game, however, not so much.
- bilekas 5y agook
- screecwe 5y agoThey haven't changed engines. Lumberyard is just a fork of CryEngine 3.8
- wavefunction 5y agoThey had to adapt the changes they had made to CryEngine to Lumberyard which were different versions of CryEngine if I recall correctly.
- screecwe 5y agoCIG had stopped implementing new CryEngine changes at 3.7. So they just had to include the changes from 3.7 to 3.8(where Lumberyard forked). They said it took 3 engineers one weekend of work, using a diffchecker.
- peanut_worm 5y agoHow do they have so little done after so long? And with so much money? I understand game development is very difficult but I don’t think games normally take over 10 years to make.
- ud_0 5y agoThere has been an absolute mountain of work done on Star Citizen, it's just not in the areas you would expect. As far as I can tell, all the money went into building an engine that generates more money which in turn allows the project to drag on, with all other considerations being secondary. That doesn't mean they're not working on an actual game (or games), but it follows that almost all the effort goes into the in-game asset sales funnel. Creation of new assets and selling them. What you and I would likely consider core parts of game development, namely focusing on technology and gameplay, has never been a priority except in short bursts. But even during those short burst of priorization, development seems to have been hampered by duplication of effort, incompetent programming, and absent project management. Judging by what's being accomplished, the often-repeated reasoning of "it's just very complex and ambitious" is not enough of an explanation. On top of this, I believe there is actually a disincentive of making gameplay progress too quickly, because much like many SV startups there is probably more value in keeping the unicorn phase going. That being said, I don't think SC is a scam. It's just a victim of its overall design in some respects, while continuing to be very successful financially.
- imtringued 5y ago>Judging by what's being accomplished, the often-repeated reasoning of "it's just very complex and ambitious" is not enough of an explanation. It's not. You grow your game organically and incrementally and release early if it is too complex to be ready at launch.
- moritonal 5y agoMaybe from the fact they have a bespoke custom progress tracker? Seems a lot of time's been spent on looking good on paper.
- FartyMcFarter 5y agoThe version numbers say everything (example: 'Alpha 3.13.1').
- Shadonic 5y agocommunity actually voted or pushed on it not to change until we get like a major tech implemented or had a big addition besides planets like the gas giant were getting in a few days. So that's mostly on the backers. Im surprised since they have gotten one of the big techs before server meshing done and it hasnt changed. i guess people just forgot about it.
- saboot 5y agoDoesn't look too great on mobile, can we get a "Star Citizen Progress Tracker" Progress Tracker as well?
- dainchi 5y agoYou joke, but for a while they had an actual "Roadmap for the Roadmap"...
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI'm amazed they decided to rebuild Jira or Trello instead of focusing on getting something out the door.
- cge 5y agoOn desktop, meanwhile, it apparently assumes that you're using one maximized browser window. If you aren't, eg, if you're using half of a 16:10 screen, it pops up an enormous modal overlay warning you that you're on a mobile device and should visit the site on a desktop. Apparently, the only detection mechanism it uses is browser width.
- xwdv 5y agoI feel Star Citizen is a bit of a meta game where the way to play is not by playing the actual finished product but rather by just bikeshedding feature after feature and seeing how many you can cram into a game, never really finishing.
- warpech 5y agoI love the UI aesthetics on the timeline. Anyone knows of a components library with such sci-fi look and feel?
- amarshall 5y agoMaybe Arwes https://arwes.dev/ https://arwes.dev/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24282270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24282270
- Ardren 5y agoCIG know what people really want to know about the development status: When is the estimated release for S42 or Star Citizen. They know what this answer is, but they will go to great lengths not to share. For example, this detailed look at what each team/person is doing, but only for 9 months. With no idea how they relate to an actual release.
- falcolas 5y agoFrankly, at this point, I don’t believe that CIG has any realistic idea when it will be done. I’d say it will be when they run out of financial runway, but they keep extending that by selling hopes and dreams.
- duskwuff 5y ago> When is the estimated release for S42 or Star Citizen. At the rate at which the scope of the project has been expanding? Never.
- nirui 5y agoWell at least this thing has reached v1.0 LOL Joke aside, I want to say something controversial here: I don't think the release date/progress matters much anymore for the dev team at this day and age. At least not as matter as it used to be when the game plan was just announced. The same point is somewhat true for their backers: they are not in a hurry as well, they want to (emotionally) see Star Citizen success one day (Or they just don't care anymore). (Assuming they're actually building a game, instead of doing something else with that money, of course) Remember [Freelancer]? It was released back in 2003, some people are still playing the game today, and they even go as far as creating an open source version of it called [Librelancer]. [Freelancer]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freelancer_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freelancer_(video_game) [Librelancer]: https://github.com/Librelancer/Librelancer https://github.com/Librelancer/Librelancer The scale of Star Citizen is way larger than Freelancer, and the potential of the game is greater as well since you can do many things in the game. If one day Star Citizen releases and delivered what's promised, the game will last for a very long time. So for the fans, the wait maybe worth it. (And hopefully it will be released before Elon Musk, NASA, ESA, CNSA or ROSCOSMOS etc give us the real-world version and make us actual 1-heart space-slaves LOL) For the non-fans, however, the market is largely fulfilled by Elite Dangerous, No Man's Sky etc.
- sleepy_keita 5y agoWhoa, TIL Librelancer! I'll have to check this out. Thanks!
- Zardoz84 5y agoInteresting... Also, some day I would like to play again Starlancer (the previous game). Really cool game and the best game on the genere that I played since the Tie-Fighter and XvsTie games
- eghad 5y agoI don't know how you can seriously mention Freelancer without mentioning that it was completely taken out of the over-promising grip of Chris Roberts. Great game, but I despise the fact that people attribute the work of those programmers who worked to actually put the thing out (when he got his golden parachute and all they got was more crunch) to that huckster.
- wpdev_63 5y agoI would be pretty cool if there was a mass effect mmo imo. I prefer the lore of that game over whatever is in star citizen and bioware has actual experience developing AAA. If EA had half a brain they would beatup robert and take his development money.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoStar Wars Online is the closest you'll probably get, also made by Bioware and probably what sucked the life out of the ME team at the time.
- jdhn 5y agoStar Citizen has proven one thing to me, and that is that dreamers (Chris Roberts) who are developing incredibly ambitious need to be held in check by good PMs who are willing to push back when necessary. This thing has been developed for so long, and it seems like there's always excuses as to how there's something new to be added and that's why it's taking so long to even get to 1.0 status.
- jerf 5y agoIt's a problem across the artistic genres. Authors who become too famous to be edited often have a bad decline in their later years, because they really need to be edited. (One of the things I respect Larry Niven for is his insistence that he be edited, even though within his niche he reached the point where he could have done the same thing.) Movie directors that become too big to say no to often turn out to not quite have been the raging individual talents they thought they were, but instead have been the front person for a talented team; I think there's good reason to believe that this is what happened to Star Wars, for instance, that George Lucas is in fact not on his own a supreme talent but instead turned out to be a good person to have on the team. A whole HN thread could be filled naming the flabby, overcomplicated, self-indulgent movies that directors have made when they got large enough to be allowed to do whatever they wanted. It would be a much smaller thread naming such movies that ended up good in the end. I think there's a few. But in my opinion, as much as we complain about studio meddling and such, the track record on just writing a blank check to a creative isn't actually that good either. I'm not sure it's possible, no matter how good you are, to ever get to the point that you don't need someone else assessing what you're doing and willing to be critical, at times even harsh if necessary. You will always be too close to your own work. Cultivating a dispassionate attitude can help, but you'll still be too close to your own work.
- endominus 5y agoAbsolutely agreed. The other big example I can think of is Kojima, one of very few game directors I personally consider a true auteur. I just wish he still has people around him that could tell him, "So the player defeats the boss, learns about her genuinely heartbreaking tragic backstory as victim to vicious war crimes, and then... takes photos of her in lingerie? While she walks around and makes suggestive poses? Is... Is that really the tone we want to go for at this point?" It's a shame, considering how on-point a lot of the messages in his earlier games were (the speech by the AI on the role of automated systems filtering human knowledge to "create context" out of endless junk data streams - in a game that came out in 2001! - always sticks out to me), even if sometimes his actual scientific knowledge was a bit shaky. (You know why Solid Snake never lost his full head of hair? Male pattern baldness is a dominant gene!)
- ghastmaster 5y agoI paid $45 for a ship a long long time ago. The "game" was as buggy and incomplete as they get. I had an incredible time playing around. I'm still in awe at what they have achieved. You really do feel like you are in space. I can float around the station for an hour and not get bored. I walked into a space ship and got lost inside of it one time. So much if it is realistic. Nothing compares. Sadly, it's just a great tech demo. That's all it will ever be. I wish RSI would be more honest.
- cletus 5y agoStar Citizen is a cautionary tale about how too much money can be a curse. Star Citizen and Elite Dangerous came around at roughly the same time but Elite has been a complete game for years. Elite did things right in the sense that they released a complete game and added to it. I've seen videos on Star Citizen talking about new systems they're adding like being put in prison and escaping and all I can think of is that this sounds cool but why are you spending any effort on this before you have a core game? star Citizen development just seems to be completely unfocused with periodic sales of ships to top up the coffers. How much better could it have been had they decided on core features that were a complete game and then just added content releases every 6-12 months? For anyone who just wants to explore without the grittiness and over-realism of Elite Dangerous, check out No Man's Sky. Side note, there's a great Internet Historian video [1] on the redemption of NMS after over-promising on release. Also, I see another game that seems to be falling into the trap of being too ambitious before having core gameplay and that's Ashes of Creation, sadly. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5BJVO3PDeQ&t=26s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5BJVO3PDeQ&t=26s
- KingOfCoders 5y agoI thought so too in the past, I was ridiculing Star Citizen, I've called it a scam, now I'm happy that someone is not releasing another space game - Elite works - but tries to do something very very ambitious, something beyond everyone else. We'll see if they can generate money for the next 10 years, I hope they can. PS: I've bought Elite but not Star Citizen ;-) PPS: I've also bought Elite in 1984 and was blown away.
- jerf 5y agoBut that doesn't contradict what cletus said. Even if they wanted to be ambitious, with such a large scale there simply is no way there isn't some way to carve out a coherent core to deliver early and then iterate on. I've done some ambitious things in my engineering career... nothing like Star Citizen in absolute scope but relative to the resources I had they were ambitious. But I always made sure there was some core I could show off before the project was complete. If nothing else, Agile (by which I mean more the orginal manifesto rather than any specific thing like "scrum") recommends this sort of approach for a reason. The more parts you develop in isolation in your "ambitious" project, the higher the odds are that when it comes time to put them all together, they won't go together. Games have the extra problem that they can both technically fail to go together as expected, but they can also artistically fail to go together as well, making it even riskier to do this in gaming. Many is the game where the obvious fault lines between the various pieces are plainly visible in the final product. (Heck, The Ubisoft Game™ that they keep remaking and just slapping new skins on is all but a game structure designed to make this approach possible, which is basically why they keep remaking it over and over; it's not that they're artistically committed to it, it's that they've probably structured their entire game making organization around it and the rest is just Conway's Law.) I still see little reason to expect Star Citizen to ever be anything like the hopes and dreams. I still expect that whatever finally comes out of this process will be profoundly disappointing. The process just can't work.
- danso 5y agoSo the "Core Tech" for the year are: - volumetric clouds - interior/exterior culling - "dynamic door alignment" - ship engine swapping So looks like they won't be completing their magic millions-of-players-on-a-single-instance tech any time soon. [0] [0] https://www.robertsspaceindustries.com/comm-link/transmission/12770-Chris-Roberts-On-Multiplayer-Single-Player-And-Instancing https://www.robertsspaceindustries.com/comm-link/transmissio...
- Shadonic 5y agoClouds are done, at least the first iteration and its going to be in the game for us in about a week or 2. Culling i belive they will hit, door alignment is mostly like a small technical addition for the doors to dynamically go down depending on how the players landed and how far down the ground is. Something small but will be helpful. The million players thing is still being worked on and they have said their aiming for this year, they go into more detail on monthly reports. That counts as one of the more major techs like the Icache system which also wasnt on the roadmap but is on the progress tracker. ITs competed already. They get a decent amount of stuff done and info out about things once in a blue moon your going to miss large swaths of info.
- bravetraveler 5y agoFunctionally equivalent to my countries debt counter. It's there to be pointed at but achieve nothing
- a-nikolaev 5y agoStar Citizen becomes http://progressquest.com/ http://progressquest.com/ 2.0 ?
- InternetPerson 5y agoGather round, it's time to talk about Star Citizen again! Tell us, when did you first realize this game would never ship?
- Jedd 5y agoIs Starfield (only recently saw an announcement from Bethesda about this) going to bite into the massive-universe and do-all-the-things market? I played Elite (the original) on the C64, and loved it. I've been 'meaning to play ED for years' - but still haven't. I bought No Man's Sky, was disappointed, as were many, at the time, but about a year ago started playing again - got excited (again) and then lost interest due to the heavy time commitment required to do anything useful. I suspect games like Red Dead Redemption II would be a similar time-sink without an awful lot of ersatz (in-game) accomplishments. I'm tempted, but wary.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoRDR2 is, overall, a more enjoyable game because you can dip in and out of it; with Elite, No Man's Sky, etc you're pretty much expected to play it for a lot of time with little happening in the meanwhile (with more stuff happening in NMS in the same amount of time).
- Shadonic 5y agoapparently starfield been described as elder scrolls in space by the big man himself.
- smudgy 5y agoI'll admit I bought in to Star Citizen - I am/was in a good place financially and the money spent isn't something I fondly miss. I remember the early days where Chris Roberts would say anything to folks asking for things like "can my guy be left handed to shoot but right handed to right?" or "can my character have a tattoo that isn't visible to anyone?" - these aren't really examples but they were the level of questions I remember folks asking. He'd answer "yes" to anything and everything. I quickly realized that the game would become a chore when folks were euphoric that you'd have to manually load cargo on your ships. It felt like folks didn't want a space game but a second life and there was already a great space game that didn't waste my time doing stupid loops that I didn't want (Elite Dangerous, though they did add stupid loops with Engineering). After that I kept following the project's development and having a giggle as the madness increased over time.
- magicalhippo 5y agoHas someone made a variant of Valve Time[1] for SC? [1]: https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Valve_Time https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Valve_Time
- anewguy9000 5y agolol musk will have colonized mars before this game is out
- platz 5y agoThe plot of any game like this is going to be the most bland, insipid storyline ever imagined. It will speak to absolutely no-one, but it will have some filler cinematics that have nice graphics. In general, this is the case the higher profile and more money is poured into it.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoInstead of a game, they release a roadmap. The development of this...I can't even call it a game...are just ridiculous at this point.
- moonshinefe 5y agoSeeing the >$300mil donation bar for that site always makes my jaw drop. It's incredible that people wasted so much money on a scam / vaporware that repeatedly over promised and changed the rules to weasel out of releasing or giving refunds. Seriously, give it a read on wikipedia sometime. It's incredible this wasn't labeled a scam and shut down. Warm fuzzy intangibles like "community" and "the idea of a game" aside, imagine what good in the world that $$$ could've done otherwise.
- arduinomancer 5y agoThis feels like that scene from Malcolm and the middle with Hal fixing the lightbulb. They're making a game but first they have to build and launch a progress tracker website?
- aeturnum 5y agoThis makes me think of the unofficial promise tracker which has been going for years: https://starcitizentracker.github.io/ https://starcitizentracker.github.io/
- thereddaikon 5y agoThis game is the ultimate example of the danger inherent in feature creep. The original goals of an expansive FPS/Space Sim MMO with unprecedented player count and the largest crafted non procedural game world seems lost. Which is a shame because that's what I was buying in to. I wanted massive player counts in a persistent and evolving universe. I didn't want "dynamic door alignment" and "Face over IP". My hope was Star Citizen would be the game to break the mold that WOW created 20 years ago and gave us the next generation of MMO. They cant even finish the single player campaign which they did all the mocap and VA work for years ago. Is Mark Hamill going to still be alive when Squadron 42 is released?
- throw_m239339 5y ago> This game is the ultimate example of the danger inherent in feature creep. Feature creep is their entire business model, that's how the make money. Their game(s) is mediocre and certainly not up to part with the budget they got for developing it, so they are going to stall to get even more money from their fans.
- manigandham 5y agoStar Citizen is no longer a video game, it's a sci-fi simulation. Definitely a vast change in scope, and probably disappointing for early backers, but I'm actually intrigued and excited about how far they can go with this.
- noduerme 5y agoI worked on the first demo of Star Citizen a decade ago, prior to the announcement and up through the first Kickstarter. I haven't followed the development much in recent years. I feel like there's been a joke circulating for awhile about finally implementing a "roadmap to a roadmap". Here's my (very limited) insight into how the project took the direction it did. Chris Roberts is a brilliant guy to work with, a first rate coder and by any standard a visionary. He seems to have a new idea every ten seconds, and they usually begin "it would be cool if..." An hour later, you're still taking notes and he's saying, "and it would be realllly cool if..." Technical difficulties and obstacles were, at that stage anyway, actually a reason to do things. Part of the idea was to prove that PC gaming would always outstrip the console experience. Polygon counts could be made higher, and higher again. The goal wasn't performance, but the opposite - how much could you put on the screen. Think about it now with 10 years of hindsight, that's a race you're only one ever one generation of consoles away from losing. My impression of working with him was that there's no such thing as practical constraints. A good enough coder should be able to get around anything. Prior to the first demo, there was a hard deadline to have something to show, so a lot of corners had to be cut. Once that happened, his attitude immediately shifted to "sky's the limit". And with the wild success of the first round of crowd funding, that became "spare NO expense." This was never just a space game, or even only his magnum opus. It's a fully functioning universe that exists in his mind, that just needs to be turned into code. Everything Wing Commander was limited by, this would be unconstrained by. Everything is possible as long as you're committed to always building for the latest platform, on the most powerful machine in the known universe, and your audience was committed to having the same hardware. A newer engine comes out or newer hardware? Tear down everything and rebuild for it. So, I never thought that this was a crowd-funded game about the making of a game. I think it's what happens when perfectionism meets unlimited resources. I also have to say that the community forum was very, very involved and demanding from the beginning. They were already playing the game they imagined in their own heads. Having put their dollars in, they felt entitled to their say in feature development. And this crowd involvement, their one-upping each other's ideas, mixed with Chris's almost infinite drive to incorporate new features, and his impulse to say yes to almost anything that sounded cool, and then a tsunami of cash, created a dynamic of setting up more and more far-fetched goals right out of the gate. Around that point, what I had built - which was never actually integrated into a working build - was jettisoned for a different approach. He hired 500 people and I sort of drifted off without ever being specifically let go. Still, it was a great experience, one of the most challenging and certainly one of the most fun projects I've ever worked on, especially in the sky's-the-limit phase, and Chris is the kind of demanding but fair person who held everyone to high standards, but who held himself to the highest. He was a pleasure to work with. I hope he finishes his game.
- Tom_neverwinter 5y agoRefunds nut jobs argue their logic fallacies are facts... Based on of course opinion pieces....
- Tom_neverwinter 5y agoRefund nut jobs argue their opinions are fact.. . Based on opinions.. Moving goalposts from 7 years ago that were debunked... Failed to pan out and claims the company was going bankrupt any day now.. .. While magically making a profit... Logic fallacy. .. How do they work.