12 ms·
International coalition calls for action against surveillance-based advertising
- pmoriarty 5y ago"Every day, consumers are exposed to extensive commercial surveillance online. This leads to manipulation, fraud, discrimination and privacy violations. Information about what we like, our purchases, mental and physical health, sexual orientation, location and political views are collected, combined and used under the guise of targeting advertising." Completely agree that commercial surveillance should end. However, ending surveillance-based advertising is not enough to end manipulation, as that's one of the primary goals of most advertising, even when surveillance is not involved. Instead, we should go further and end all unsolicited advertising.
- viro 5y agoThen who pays for 99% of the websites on the internet? hosting isn't free.
- bediger4000 5y agoWe'd be better off without the ad-supported web sites. Twitter, facebook, pinterest, ad-supported web sites centralized something that was arguably better when decentralized. Every web site should be artisanal, a labor of love, like a lot of the better blogs, or subscription based. Content wouldn't be homogenized for mass consumption.
- viro 5y agoyou don't seem to understand... This would have the exact opposite result.. I would pay for a Twitter and YouTube sub and every other website could fuck all the way off. I'm not paying separately for 40 other random sites.
- bediger4000 5y agoGood! Consumer choice in action, Invisible Hand of the Marketplace would help weed out the weak or harmful businesses. Ad supported web sites can be really harmful. Direct, monetary feedback would allow us to have more say in things.
- viro 5y agoit would also kick poor people off the internet
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoBy that logic the status quo says poor people can only participate on the internet if they subject themselves to ever-increasing digital surveillance under the guise of "advertising"
- viro 5y agoThats a rather fancy way to say. poor people can't afford to pay a sub for every ad supported site they use.
- pmoriarty 5y ago" Then who pays for 99% of the websites on the internet? hosting isn't free." Those who can afford it could pay their own hosting fees, and donations, governments, and philanthropic foundations could subsidize the cost of hosting for those who can't. Most businesses could of course pay for their own hosting, and even now don't operate on "free" (ad-supported) hosting services. So, yeah, I'm not really worried about the survival of the internet if unsolicited ads were banned. There's already a glut of content being created every day, and that's unlikely to be significantly reduced.
- nicbou 5y agoI think you underestimate how much of the useful Internet is supported by ads, including affiliate links and the like. The Internet isn't entirely run by volunteers with a hosting budget. Not by a long stretch.
- andrewnicolalde 5y agoWhy do those ads need to be so aggressively targeted? I don’t mind ads related to the primary topic of the website for example. I might actually find those useful! What I have a problem with is the invasion of privacy created by highly personalized, persistent profiling of my life for the purpose of selling things to me.
- nicbou 5y agoYou moved the goalpost
- andrewnicolalde 5y agoI’m not GP.
- goodpoint 5y agoWe are already paying for websites right now. We pay for ads when we buy products and services. Also we pay ISPs who pay carriers who pay for peering with popular networks.
- vincent-toups 5y agoHonestly, I'd be fine with 99% of the internet going away.
- Guest42 5y agoI think I saw some stats showing that beyond the top 1 percent of websites, the usage goes way way down meaning they wouldn’t cost much to maintain. As for the 1 percent, there would probably be various solutions depending on the situation and more ethical ways to advertise. I’d pay for a non-tracking YouTube, email, news, and a small fee to access my banking online.
- swiley 5y agoMy personal website is hosted by: Microsoft who lets people use the github cdn for free if they're not obnoxious about it. and my mail server on linode which I'm paying for anyway. Web hosting is just not that expensive unless your doing stuff like video streaming.
- 0x5FC3 5y agoIs it like a custom setup on a linode vps? Or does linode offer some kind of managed solution? I’ve always wanted to run my own email setup but then, just seems like too much hassle. How is it going for you?
- swiley 5y agoI've run my own email since I was ~18 (I'm 27 now.) Currently I use OpenSMTP with a custom patch for the address parser. My only real issue is that I'm never able to send mail to hotmail (no one seems able to do that so often the users understand.) Otherwise once you have dkim and whatnot set up and you keep things updated it's not a big deal.
- u8mybrownies 5y agoDoesn’t matter. Better to pay explicitly than by being manipulated to pay via the things you’re manipulated into
- stubish 5y agoWeb sites used to exist before advertising was pervasive and will continue to exist after. By removing all the ad funded businesses squatting in the space, we make room for alternatives. Just think - forums run by enthusiasts rather than people who think they can make money off of enthusiasts. Web sites designed to maximize knowledge transfer, rather than maximize rage and web traffic. It can certainly be free or nearly so to host a web site that doesn't need to maximize engagement. They won't be as slick, but they don't need to be because they are not trying to sell you anything. Or... who knows, lets see what people come up with! Its sure to be better than the status quo, which many of us are opting out of with ad-blockers and privacy plugins and simply going to alternative sources.
- lithos 5y agoBack to mechanics like AdWords where it’s based on the content you’re consuming.
- ryandvm 5y agoGood. Advertising is theft. Hear me out. If we agree that my attention has economic value (and it must as that is the entire basis of advertising); and if we agree once my attention is captured it cannot be applied to something else at that moment; then unsolicited advertising is an act of theft. Unlikely legal conclusion I know, but damn, maybe I would like to sit on the beach and have my own thoughts rather than be forced by an airplane banner to wonder if I need a personal injury attorney...
- viro 5y ago> unsolicited advertising Advertising doesn't show up on site without the OWNER of the site wanting it to be there.
- Retric 5y agoWebsite’s can recommend showing me advertising all they want, but it needs my computer equipment to render. Auto playing video adds are both unsolicited and consume significant amounts of expensive cellular data. It’s quite simply theft of resources.
- viro 5y agoIts not theft its you paying for the service of the website. What la la land do you live in.
- Arthur8 5y agoJust to nitpick. What has the first to do with the second? If I finance my free-to-eat restaurant by stealing bikes, the first part (free-to-eat) does not justify the second (stealing). One could even argue, that If I am upfront about this and tell everybody that I steal bikes and that you have to agree to this practice to eat at my restaurant, the situation does not change much. I suspect, your point is that If I only steal bikes of people eating in my restaurant and I ask for permission if they are seated(1), then this is not stealing. Because of the permission. I would argue. It is an incredible.... bad deal for the one eating in my restaurant and it seems to be in bad faith. It is even another story, if it is the only restaurant or food source in town. Then it goes well beyond stealing… (1) And I certainly use all (bad/dark) tricks you can think of to get their permission.
- bediger4000 5y agoDoesn't go far enough: since advertising is virtually all lies, we should prohibit it. The bad effects of advertising are well known, from web ads distributing malware, to print advertisers affecting editorial content and direction to ad spammers ruining faxing, usenet phone calls and email. We, as a society, should acknowledge advertising as a bad thing, and try to live without it.
- viro 5y agoYEA! lets force every ad supported company to force people too pay for content! Nothing bad will happen from that ...
- bediger4000 5y agoThe bad effects of advertising are well known. I personally don't think this is too big of a price to pay.
- viro 5y agoSo we should just kick poor people off the internet?
- arrosenberg 5y agoFun fact - poor people used the internet just fine before 2006.
- viro 5y agoDid you use the internet before 2006? There was ads... a lot of them honestly more annoying too.
- seveneightn9ne 5y agoPerhaps we agree as a society to pay for universal access to the digital "town square" - collectivize Facebook, Google, etc and pay for it through taxes.
- duxup 5y agoI wouldn't mind ads if they were ... accurate, and would just advertise what I want to see, and let me participate and tell them what I want. Let me manage what I want to hear about. I can assure you that my engagement would be a hell of a lot higher than when they advertise "thing you just bought" or "we think you're a woman here's a bunch of products related to" (I'm not a woman, I don't buy those products, amazon ... stop it). Or Google "hey here's some stuff from some sports team you googled" no google that's my team's RIVAL... I already told you I don't like them. Granted advertising dollars come from folks who want to spend them so I'm going to see that stuff, not the other way around.
- andai 5y agoI'm torn: on the one hand I'd rather not be spied on on every damn web page I visit. On the other hand, my experience with Instagram's ads was downright positive, which was very unexpected. They showed me cool stuff that I didn't even know existed, and that I'd actually like to buy. So it seems like we should either have no surveillance, or the absolute maximum -- most ads are still in that gross uncanny valley.
- skinkestek 5y agoInstagram ads are surprisingly good compared to Googles given how little I've told Instagram compared to Google. Google ads are overwhelmingly useless and for years (a decade?) they were outright insulting to my family.
- Xelbair 5y agoi would mind if ads are accurate. I prefer them to not have ANY information about me - because the holy grail of such system is to dynamically adjust prices, upwards, depending on your preferences. To extract as much money as you are willing to pay for a product. An automated bazaar system, where prices can only rise for you.
- duxup 5y agoI probably should have specified earlier but I was thinking a system where I get to indicate what I want. I wonder about the prices rising thing. If one guy wants to jack up his prices for me ... someone else might be smart enough to lower them.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 5y agoIn my opinion an outright ban like this is the only way to begin to make the internet a net force for good again. The high profitability of exploitative data collection creates a perverse incentive for businesses, which coupled with unfettered capitalism(in the US especially) has led to the current situation with Facebook, Google and others; sacrificing privacy, personal freedoms, and even democracy itself on the altar of ad revenue. This is also a rare window of opportunity where the Democrats control both chambers of congress, making such a ban at least somewhat feasible.
- viro 5y agoyea, fuck those poor people that can't afford to pay subs for every ad supported site they use. /s
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 5y agoI didn't say all ads should be banned, just the exploitative collection of personal data to be sold to the highest bidder, which is also what this coalition calls for. How much of Facebook's ad revenue actually goes into hosting and maintaining their social network? Without having looked it up, I'm willing to bet it's a fairly small percentage. Even if, in some bizarre imaginary universe, the only revenue stream that could support a social network like Facebook, was to steal the private information of a sizable part of the world population and sell it to advertisers, is the "service" Facebook is offering really worth that? I don't think so.
- viro 5y ago> was to steal the private information of a sizable part of the world population and sell it to advertisers, Thats not how ad targeting works.
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoAd targeting worked pretty well before the advent of mass digital surveillance. Every ad does not need a "personal" touch. The diner across the street has paper placemats that are covered in ads - they don't print a personal and customized one for every customer that sits down. They have one placemat that has a wide variety of ads that appeal to the general customer base of the business. That's basically how it worked on the early internet, too. The problem with early internet advertising wasn't how it was targeted - it was that the ads were damned annoying.
- PhillyG 5y agoI personally wish that sites that use advertising just had ads that fit the content that you're looking at.
- GenerocUsername 5y agoAgree 100%. I see everywhere that people "prefer personalized ads" ... but if I am looking at paintball, you can just show me paintball ads! You dont need to understand me in depth at all. No privacy concerns if you just assume my interests based on what I am currently viewing.
- ericholscher 5y agoFWIW, this is exactly what we do at EthicalAds. You can read a bit more about it here: https://www.ethicalads.io/advertising-vision/#how-our-ads-work https://www.ethicalads.io/advertising-vision/#how-our-ads-wo... -- but we should really have a better page explaining how we're doing content-based targeting. Our advertiser find it works really well, and our publishers enjoy having tasteful, reverent ads on their sites.
- thrwaeasddsaf 5y agoI'd be interested in seeing personalized ads but there is no such thing. I recently had a look at what ad categories Google applies to me and honestly.. it is so wide that it is does not feel personal in the slightest, and indeed it's wide & vague and nonspecific enough that "employed male, about 30, western" would be a sufficient description. Indeed, I feel like that just filters for the ads they'd blast on broadcast media all day long anyway. Advertisers don't really understand who I am or what I want, and Youtube history isn't a good substitute. If anything it's circular, because Youtube also keeps recommending the same shit based on viewing history..
- pessimizer 5y agoThis is the worst part - they know enough about me to endanger or hurt me (for example my religion, sexual orientation, the computers I browse with, where they are located, and who I share them with, but they somehow don't know enough about me to give me better than shit recommendations of what to buy. > Advertisers don't really understand who I am or what I want, and Youtube history isn't a good substitute. If anything it's circular, because Youtube also keeps recommending the same shit based on viewing history.. This is why the internet is shit now. It doesn't understand that its tracking is recursive, and simply works to filter out small players and other people bad at gaming SEO.
- olegious 5y agoThe advertising industry has done a terrible job explaining its role in the open internet and how personal the data collected actually gets. "Surveillance" implies that someone is actually watching you, knows and cares who you are as an individual. This can't be further from the truth- no one cares about "you" as an individual, that kind of identifying data is absolutely useless because you by yourself aren't worth anything from a data perspective. You as an anonymous member of a data segment containing tens of thousands (or more) anonymous individuals is what's worth something. So the data collected can't be used to identify you. For those of you saying "ban all ads" are living in a fantasy land. Most popular content and services online are supported by advertising. Email, search, maps, entertainment, news, etc. The vast majority of global internet users can't afford to pay for these services and content. "They don't need to waste time on X" you may say, but why do you get to decide?
- throwaway3699 5y agoThere's also a large cohort of people that aren't against targeted ads, but are against large companies like Google and Facebook. The problem is removing 3rd-party targeted ads would not hurt the giants, but embolden them, as 1st-parties will be able to use this data with impunity.
- chalst 5y ago> that kind of identifying data is absolutely useless because you by yourself aren't worth anything from a data perspective. I hate to get all Godwin's law on you, but you don't think, say, Jews in the 1930s might have had reason to worry about the business model of third-party analytics companies if they existed back then?
- varispeed 5y agoI agree completely that the business model of Facebook or Google should be illegal. They don't provide value to consumers, but give unscrupulous companies tool to manipulate people into buying things they don't need or want.
- ericholscher 5y agoThis is exactly why we're building EthicalAds. It's an ad network that only targets based on the content of sites, doesn't allow any third-party JS or images, and is currently only focused on a developer audience: https://www.ethicalads.io/advertising-vision/ https://www.ethicalads.io/advertising-vision/ We had the same choice on Read the Docs, but didn't really have any other way to make money but advertising. We decided to build ethical advertising, so that we could be proud of the ads we show, knowing we weren't adding to massive pool of data out there. I talked a bit more about it here: https://www.ericholscher.com/blog/2016/aug/31/funding-oss-marketing-money/ https://www.ericholscher.com/blog/2016/aug/31/funding-oss-ma...
- metabagel 5y agoLots of sites just started generating pop-ups for me when they detect EFF's Privacy Badger. This is getting really onerous.
- endisneigh 5y agoIs it actually true that tracking results in better ads? Take this very post - couldn't some agent scan all the text, aggregate and basically determine that "anti-ad" sentiment is strong, then some company could advertise in pages that have strong "anti-ad" sentiment. No tracking necessary. Advertising is the ultimate zero-sum game.
- chalst 5y agoI have no idea. The story about tailoring ads to individual consumers that the tracking companies sell is catnip to marketing departments, but I don't have high confidence that the advertising industry is better at the statistics needed to evaluate what they are doing than, say, psychologists were before the replication crisis.
- judge2020 5y agoWhile this works for Google Search (to my knowledge, search ads are still exclusively contextual) most contextual ads only work in limited situations - random blog websites or things like quizlet don't really have any related products you could advertise on based on the domain, while people might still be included to (for example) purchase an Amazon item they viewed a few days ago.
- FredPret 5y agoAdvertising is zero sum in some idealized economists’ fantasy world where everyone knows everything about every product. In real life, targeted ads add value by matching products and consumers that would not have found it in the jungle of information.
- endisneigh 5y agoThe competition among advertisers is zero sum. If A has one ad and B has another had and there's a single consumer, A and B spending more on ads doesn't change the outcome. It's zero-sum, no? Or to make it even more obvious, imagine all advertisements in existence are on a giant billboard. You could imagine people allocating the space perfectly in some fashion. However some people would spend more money and plaster their ad on top of someone else's. This would result in others doing the same. More and more money is being spent but it's zero-sum.
- literallyaduck 5y agoWhy can't we go after surveillance using existing wiretap laws? If they share the surveillance we go after everyone using it under RICO.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIn part because the same investigatory bodies that would investigate and issue those charges benefit greatly not only from our country's mature surveillance infrastructure and the data it sucks up, but also from the friendly partnerships they have with the companies that own the surveillance infrastructure.
- unixhero 5y agoAlright alright alright. Go Norway!
- walshemj 5y agoAh a Norwegian site - so explain how willy nilly publishing everyones income tax is not way worse.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 5y agoIt's actually not "willy nilly". If someone looks you up, you get a notification with their full name. This pretty strongly discourages people snooping on eachother's finances, while also helping to keep wealth hoarders accountable. Either way, this is nothing but a red herring...
- oliv__ 5y agoLol. Advertising is the least of my concerns when it comes to surveillance
- pessimizer 5y agoLuckily, whoever you are concerned about can buy your data from the advertisers.