27 ms·
The Teamsters announce coordinated nationwide project to unionize Amazon
- dantheman 5y agoAre they coordinating to create a monopoly on labor with the goal of price fixing? How can hat be legal? :P
- gorgoiler 5y agoThere’s nothing wrong with a monopoly. Exploiting a monopoly to do something bad — that’s illegal. So now it comes down to who is the doing the bigger evil: unions allegedly hampering free market capitalism, or Amazon allegedly exploiting workers.
- Ericson2314 5y agoBuilding a monopoly in the face of a monopsony is 100% ethical.
- missedthecue 5y agoA monopsony? That's an interesting accusation. Amazon has over 100 warehouses across the country -- that's a lot. Can you name me one, just one, where they have a monopsony on the local labor supply? Where there are no restaurants, hotels, grocery stores, department stores, hardware stores, car washes, janitorial services, couriers, or any other type of business competing for the same labor pool?
- Ericson2314 5y ago|warehouse employers| <<<<<< |warehouse employees| This is not how labor market monopsony is usually defined, but I say that's simply a sign of us setting the bar too low. Fixing this would require at least one - employers with N employees to take on employees with average N jobs - big unions for big corps - Everything becomes co-ops - Full socialism You tell me what sounds the most practical.
- lazide 5y agoSame way baseball, football, etc. labor price fixing is legal - it’s gov’t protected price fixing
- cartoonworld 5y agoFunny :) I can do this too: Amazon is feudalism to their employees, demanding totalitarian fealty in exchange for insulin. They even ban membership in professional organizations by their employees in a rapt, paranoid, control fantasy. Amazon even has cameras in some their homes, steals their wifi, and receives much their internet traffic.
- teclordphrack2 5y agoWhat a right wing insanity post.
- mmastrac 5y agoSemi-related: "Amazon burns through workers so quickly that executives are worried they'll run out of people to employ, according to a new report" https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-warehouse-turnover-worker-shortage-2021-6 https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-warehouse-turnover-wo... (HN comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27524637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27524637)
- titanomachy 5y agoI think that's pretty related. Unionization efforts would be unlikely to succeed if there were so many people lining up for work that Amazon could lay off entire warehouses. Tightening of the labour supply should create a much better bargaining position for workers.
- malandrew 5y ago> "We've been working on this for quite some time—well before Bessemer broke out," Randy Korgan, Teamsters National Director for Amazon, told Motherboard, referring to the unionization drive in Bessemer, Alabama that Amazon thwarted earlier this year. Well the unions lost in Bessemer not because they were "thwarted" but because Amazon was offering really solid employment and benefits relative to the local labor market there and unionization could have led Amazon to divest from that labor market entirely. The employees in Bessemer understood that they had a good thing going that wasn't going to be improved by unionization.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThat is why it's important to have a national campaign. Amazon can relocate any one warehouse but it's not going to want to give up on wide-scale coverage.
- RhysU 5y agoRepeatedly testing the same statistical outcome looking for a one-time, possibly tail event, is p-value hacking writ large.
- beerandt 5y ago"Our side would shade have won if we just had the right voting pool." But this national thing isn't even a vote, it's just straight intimidation and extortion trying to get Amazon to "voluntarily" give in.
- Ericson2314 5y ago> it's just straight intimidation and extortion trying to get Amazon to "voluntarily" give in. Yes? That's what labor organizing is supposed to be. Fighting dirty with monopsony power that should never have arisen in the first place, because that's the only option.
- 5y ago
- disposekinetics 5y agoThe most important think is if Amazon workers want to unionize.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoWould that this were the most important thing in the Amazon unionization effort. We would maintain measures like an actual election with secret ballots — instead of card check, where the Teamsters can see if you've signed the card, and pressure you if you haven't. The Biden administration, I understand, wishes the return of card-check.
- disposekinetics 5y agoI totally agree. I support the theory behind unions, but the practices by employers and unions make me wish for less coercion all around.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoLook on the bright side: it used to be a whole lot worse. I mean on both sides, too. The Pinkerton thugs get all the press, and are rightly condemned, but for coverage of the union men beating their non-union colleagues to death with clubs, blinding a man with thrown stones, I refer you to coverage such as McLure's Magazine article The Right To Work (1903) which gave its name to the type of law: http://moses.law.umn.edu/darrow/documents/Right%20to%20work.pdf http://moses.law.umn.edu/darrow/documents/Right%20to%20work.... I like the distinction that it draws at the beginning, too: "PUBLIC opinion seems to be coming around to the view that the trades' union is here to stay. From many unexpected quarters we hear every now and then a more generous acknowledgment that the organization of labor is not only as inevitable as the combination of capital, but a good thing in itself. At the same time, and from the same fair minds, you hear expressions of passionate indignation at the abuse of power by unions. This means that public opinion is beginning to distinguish between unionism and the sins of unionists, as it is between organized capital and the sins of capitalists." All we have to contend with today, here, are the vengeful downvotes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 5y ago> With the Amazon Project, the Teamsters are taking a different approach that doesn't rely on the traditional National Labor Relations Board election process that allows employers to run sophisticated anti-union campaigns and involves the task of running elections warehouse by warehouse. > Instead the Teamsters plan to focus on a series of pressure campaigns involving work stoppages, petitions, and other collective action to push Amazon to recognize a union and bargain over working conditions. This is good. Even in the "good old days", labor in the U.S. won a rather Pyrrhic victory in that organizing became shoehorned in a narrow legal framework with narrow goals. It makes the decline of union power same rather inevitable. This "going back to the roots", along with the tightening of the labor market we've seen lately, has the promise to attack that problem head-on rather than wishing it away.
- ramesh31 5y agoI know there's a lot of hate for the Teamsters union in particular. Corruption exists in every human institution. But in the modern oligarchy that is the US, where politicians are completely bought and paid for with corporate money, organized labor is literally the only tool we have left against a capitalist dystopia. It's easy to forget that we had to fight literal wars in this country to gain things like the 8 hour work day. This stuff doesn't come without a fight. And you can nitpick about the quality of an organization, but you go to war with the army you have.
- hedora 5y agoThe unions also buy off politicians to disastrous effect. In California, you can’t win an election unless the teachers union or the police union backs you, which has led to all sorts of insane policies. Even with that, teachers and police officers are terribly underpaid and also mistreated by the California government. Unions might be the answer. However, the US has a closed shop system where a few unions have a monopoly on labor relations. As a result, the existing national unions have repeatedly demonstrated that they’re not interested in improving working conditions for their members.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gorgoiler 5y agoThis news story — just as much as anything else it might be — is a marketing campaign from the Teamsters. 500,000 new members paying $50 a month in union dues is no joke and they want a piece of that pie — or realistically the entire $100M+ pie itself. Free market capitalism is alive and well, except in this case it will be in the form of the Teamsters vs The RWDSU on who can offer the most organized power at the best price. Regardless of how you feel about unions or Amazon, there’s something fascinating going on here at so many levels.
- seibelj 5y ago> Some states have passed right-to-work or open shop laws that say each worker has the right to hold his job in a company, no matter whether he joins a labor union, or not. If you were asked to vote on such a law, would you vote for it, or against it? 71% for right to work laws > Those in favor of right-to-work or open shop laws say that no American should be required to join any private organization, like a labor union, against his will. Do you agree or disagree with this? 82% agree Gallop America poll https://news.gallup.com/poll/12751/labor-unions.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/12751/labor-unions.aspx
- hedora 5y agoAn open shop implies that employees can form rival unions to oust abusive unions. The poll questions don’t go into that level of detail, so it is hard to interpret the results.
- mc32 5y agoI'm so torn on this. On the one hand Amazon and its bad labor relations and squeezing the last drop out of everyone and discarding ones who have no juice left. Looking the other way on fraud in their marketplace. Copycatting brands and underselling them with inferior copies (the camera bag[1] for example but many others). On the other hand, organized labor and its infamous corruption, bullying, and drive to have everyone do as little as possible (sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you) totally undermining progress, improvement and development. It's hard to pick sides on this one. Both are quite bad and unlikable. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26545421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26545421
- ticviking 5y agoAmazon could avoid this by not squeezing so hard. Over squeezing labor leads to pushback.
- spodek 5y agoIn this community, I think you can say, "The more you tighten your grip, Bezos, the more star systems will slip through your fingers."
- bpodgursky 5y agoAmazon _has_ avoided this by not squeezing so hard. They have no unionized employees. The latest vote lost by a 75-25 margin, humiliating the union organizing the process. The Teamsters wants to force this issue in the political arena because they can't win votes.
- GavinMcG 5y agoThere are a lot of reasons not to take much away from the Bessemer vote. Well ahead of the vote there were lots of signs that the organizers hadn't, you know, organized.[0] Humiliated, absolutely, but by their own ineptitude. [0] https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/bessemer-alabama-amazon-union/ https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/bessemer-alabama-...
- cperciva 5y agoWith the Amazon Project, the Teamsters are taking a different approach that doesn't rely on the traditional National Labor Relations Board election process that allows employers to run sophisticated anti-union campaigns and involves the task of running elections warehouse by warehouse. Instead the Teamsters plan to focus on a series of pressure campaigns involving work stoppages, petitions, and other collective action to push Amazon to recognize a union and bargain over working conditions. Faced with workers who don't want to join a union and laws which protect them, the Teamsters plan a series of coercive measures which will force workers into a union whether they want it or not.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's not quite that simple. In a push for unionization it isn't rare at all to see management come down hard on those that favored it, so unless there is an overwhelming chance of success there could easily be a large chunk of people who abstain from voting. Otherwise in the next round of lay-offs your number could easily have a higher chance of popping up, and as the organizers it isn't rare at all to be fired on some pretext. The reported outcome is typically only for those who did vote. Personally I think that unions should be open to membership regardless of whether the company has a majority of the people there that want to be part of a union, and that companies should never be able to deny employees the right to unionize.
- cperciva 5y agoA set of workers can always form a union. A recent example of this took place at Google. The only time there's a vote is when they want to force all the other workers to join the same union.
- jacquesm 5y agoI don't think that's ok, you should never be forced to do business with a particular party, even if that party is a union that ostensibly works to your advantage. Here in NL there are multiple unions and people can join or abstain on an individual basis. I do think people should not be able to join more than one union.
- COGlory 5y agoThe Teamsters understand exactly what they are doing here. The press release was well done and clearly coordinated by savvy people with lots of expertise and good understanding of game theory fundamentals. I'm not sure if it's good or not, but if the Teamsters can't do it, I don't think anyone can unionize Amazon. If I were Amazon, I'd be shaking in my boots at the moment.
- atlgator 5y agoAmazon workers would be immeasurably better off self-unionizing than joining a bloated bureaucracy like the Teamsters. Yikes.
- pkkim 5y agoAmazon employs hundreds of thousands of people. I'm sure that a substantial bureaucracy would be needed in order to represent them effectively. Or are you saying that the Teamsters bureaucracy in particular is bloated relative to what their organization needs? I'm not familiar with them.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoThe Teamsters grew to the behemoth they are today because of Jimmy Hoffa in the 70s, who was heavily connected to the mafia and eventually gunned down.
- slipframe 5y ago> Jimmy Hoffa [...] eventually gunned down. I just want to clarify that we don't know if he was specifically gunned down. He was declared dead years after he went missing. The exact circumstances of his presumed death aren't known, but it's generally believed to be the mob that did it.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoThanks for the clarification.
- teclordphrack2 5y agoAnd. Thanks for the smear job with no context.
- edm0nd 5y agoAnd? That doesn't invalidate anything the Teamsters do or have done IMO.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seany 5y agoThis seems to scream "teamsters management wants to stay relevant" not "lets help the workers"
- eric4smith 5y agoPipe dream. America has changed so much and labor is so mobile now that unionization will not make a dent. It would make sense when you were working at the same company, in the same town for 20 years. But all that has changed. We now change jobs every few years. Or even take time off, or work remotely. We change cities all the time. Mobility and choice is where it's at now. Unions make sense for careers like police and old-style factories. Besides, everyone knows that all the unions -- except the police unions no longer have any teeth. I'm sort of tired of people living in some kind of alternate reality to think that an initiative like this could really work. (I'm by no means anti-union. I'm just a realist.)
- arbitrary_name 5y agoHasn't internal mobility within the US actually declined? And, forgive my ignorance, why would people changing jobs or locations prevent a unionization drive bring successful? Furthermore, what do you propose people do in the context in which jobs are continually made less stable and well paying, while corporate profits are strong, and additionally in which labor appears to be in high demand? Feels like this is exactly the right time to try again to make this happen?
- sokoloff 5y agoIf unions heavily favor long-tenured union members, people who move around a lot (or even an average amount) will be disadvantaged more than typical as the “new employee”. Old-time Charlie will be paying the same 1-1.5% that you are to the union but getting a lot more from it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brundolf 5y ago> We now change jobs every few years. Or even take time off, or work remotely. We change cities all the time. Mobility and choice is where it's at now. I think your anecdata around (presumably) tech labor is pretty wildly irrelevant for Amazon warehouse workers.
- balozi 5y agoIf big labor could actually pull off what they are proposing, they would have done it by now. And not only at Amazon. At McDonalds and Walmart too. But they know they cant. They are playing for relevance.
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago"big labor" what? They CAN pull off what they're proposing, the problem right now is that the employees are (were?) kept too afraid of losing their job, and kept too replaceable. There's no shortage of employees in the US, people willing to work for a pittance because there's nothing else for them, because they're desperate, they're one paycheck away from bankruptcy. And they're reminded constantly that there's a dozen people waiting in line to take their job if they have the audacity to try and improve their conditions.
- TeeMassive 5y agoI dislike unions. They made me lose work in dire moments of my life when I was out of high school. I avoided and continue to avoid secure good paying unionized positions or positions that has to deal with unions. They are responsible for a lot of corruption and high costs in nearly all government funded projects. During our internships I have had my fair share of unions horror stories. But still, I can see why their presence or the mere possibility of their presence is beneficial even to me. Even after Amazon employees failed to unionized their wage increased and I'm sure that management got the message. In Québec, Canada, a journal infiltrated an Amazon warehouse by getting hired there. They run the place like that would make any Chinese sweatshop look liberating. They use AI and surveillance to systematically fire a fraction of their workforce every year and watch them constantly. They run the place the like a bad cyberpunk dystopia novel. They even go as far as to penalize employees who go to the bathroom. Work accidents are common. They make workers rights look like an afterthought. Amazon's effect on society has become too nefarious for what it provides. I'd rather pay 5$ more per item or shipments on average knowing that the people who are responsible for delivering my goods are treated with a minimum of humanity.
- umvi 5y agoWhat's in it for the Teamsters? I assume they stand to gain a lot of income if they can successfully unionize Amazon?
- cestith 5y agoDrivers and warehouse workers are their main membership. Their members are looking both to help Amazon employees and to set a safety line for their own positions. If a big enough share of delivery and logistics jobs go to bargain basement pay, it threatens the market rate for those jobs everywhere.
- BuckRogers 5y agoCompanies get the union they deserve. Go Teamsters. Hardest punching union in the nation. I've never been in one, but I've worked with them, managed them. This country needs more unions.
- missedthecue 5y agoI think we need fewer cartels. I will continue to vote against unionization efforts in my workplace for this reason.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe Teamsters crippled American industry once. They can do it again. Whatever bright spots appear in the economy, they are immediately targeted by rent-seeking union movements for exploitation.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI wonder if they can communicate a reason to unionise this time, that seemed to be lacking in the previous attempt...
- jcims 5y agoHow much do UPS hub workers make these days? I loaded and unloaded at a hub in 1991 and made $8.50/hr iirc. I was a member of Teamsters then and the position is still unionized by the Teamsters today. From what i see, the pay is pretty commensurate with what Amazon pays, but it’s hard to tell for sure.
- slver 5y agoLet's see how this union competes with Amazon's robot workers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Klinky 5y agoEveryone should welcome automation and reduced working hours, but our system prioritizes underpaid labor so much, that automation is often significantly more expensive. Low labor wages and poor safety nets hinders progress on automation, and it's wheeled out as a threat and bogeyman to scare the poors back into line. Let the robots come in and do this labor, but that doesn't excuse society's responsibility to take care of its humans.
- slver 5y agoThe point here is if unions come in and start having unreasonable demands, this expensive automation you're talking about becomes comparatively affordable. Society should take care of its humans, but this doesn't mean go into private companies and demand all the box movers get their pay tripled. It doesn't work this way.
- Klinky 5y ago>expensive automation you're talking about becomes comparatively affordable Perfect! Isn't that the point? Automation to make our lives easier? More automation will lead to commoditization of robots, instead of the current commoditization and dehumanization of humans. Again your mindset shows you want to use automation as a threat against humanity to keep human cattle in line, and not as a force for good. >It doesn't work this way. Why not? Right now society is failing to take care of a large number of humans in order to maintain status quos that greatly enrich the few.
- slver 5y ago> Perfect! Isn't that the point? Automation to make our lives easier? More automation will lead to commoditization of robots, instead of the current commoditization and dehumanization of humans. > Again your mindset shows you want to use automation as a threat against humanity to keep human cattle in line, and not as a force for good. Look, you're trying very hard to put me in some narrative that solely exists in your head, not mine. Automation is not a "threat". It's happening, but it needs a push. And unions are here to provide that push. You think that millions of unemployable workers is somehow less "dehumanizing" than having a job that matches their skillset. Bizarre. Regarding the Star Wars categories of what's a force for evil and what's a force for good, I'll stay out of that, because those are stories for children. Economics is about incentives and alignment of interests.
- gumby 5y agoThere seems to be some implementation misunderstanding in some of the comments. The teamsters may seek to unionize the hourly workers and not the salaried developers. It's not unusual for very large manufacturers to have multiple unions (e.g. pipe fitters, electricians, clerical workers...). I'm sure the teamsters would Leo to be the only union for 100% of Amazon's workforce but I imagine they have tactical focus.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI have absolutely no problem with workers unionizing if they want to, but I continue to be confused by these kinds of pressure campaigns. The Teamsters appear to be assuming that all workers will love unions if only enough pressure is applied, despite multiple failed unionization votes at Amazon sites. Shouldn’t there be a component here where they talk to the people who voted no and understand how to be more responsive to their needs? I worry that the real goal here is to increase the power and influence of their own organization.
- mtnGoat 5y agoI often wonder… are they doing this protect people/workers or to extend their power and grow their business? ( yes a Union is a business and it has bills and high paid execs, like any other)