9 ms·
Theocracy may be bad, but an aggressively religious society is worse. Religious here means that certain things are articles of faith, and any attempt to discus
by nine_k 5y ago
Theocracy may be bad, but an aggressively religious society is worse.
Religious here means that certain things are articles of faith, and any attempt to discuss them in any way, let alone disagree with them, gets you marked as an enemy who needs to be driven away and stripped of any respect or role in society.
I won't even say it's the majority that's so aggressive. But the majority of people who are somehow active in the society and thus visible outside the circle of their family and coworkers, either actively or passively agree. Either they share the faith (many do), or they don't want trouble.
What good is the First Amendment if citizens themselves see free speech as a dangerous transgression?
- Zababa 5y agoThe big difference is that religion usually believes in some kind of forgiveness and repentance. I can't say I see the same things in the current society.
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoThe structure of a revolution-- it usually begins when the rabble acts up and no authority is willing or able to stop them. So, 1 out of 1,000 users seek quasi-religious vengeance on Twitter and the mechanisms that used to inform the other 999 don't work. The NYT picks up toxic views of the rabble and reports them as mainstream, which the rabble have converted to a weapon in itself. Most revolutions I've read about, large and small consist of an authentic breakdown in or reorganization of, society. Here and now, seems like we're actually discussing an antifeature of manufactured social technologies combined with capture or weakening of traditional media.
- nine_k 5y agoI think you mischaracterize these people as "rabble". Many of the vocal "woke" figures are highly educated, highly intellectual, and well-off. Professors, top business officers, high-achieving scientists, writers, engineers. They do it not because they are stupid, for they are not. They truly believe that what they do is right, that it's the shining path to the better future.
- type0 5y agoAnd most of the worlds biggest atrocities has also been done on "the shining path to the better future".
- nine_k 5y agoExactly my reference :(
- andrepd 5y agoSo have the world's biggest advances, from the Enlightenment, the Scientific Revolution, or the advent of liberal democracies in the past ~200 years.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThis crowd seems to be pretty much against enlightenment values or science or democracy.
- thu2111 5y agoNone of those things were really the result of some top down utopian master plan, though. The closest might be the enlightenment if you consider the rewards for book finding granted by wealthy benefactors, but it was fundamentally a backward looking "Revolution" that was based on worship of the ancients. The "scientific revolution", is not really a well known or unambiguous label, the growth of science being a long term trend. And it's worth observing that a major part of the present day corruption of science with the replication crisis, the junk sociological sciences and so on, are the result of an explicit top down utopian plan by governments to make a better tomorrow by funding academics.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> I think you mischaracterize these people as "rabble". Many of the vocal "woke" figures are highly educated, highly intellectual, and well-off. Professors, top business officers, high-achieving scientists, writers, engineers. That is the actual structure of a revolution. Your parent comment is misguided; revolutions that aren't led by elites are rare and, when they occur, generally don't go anywhere. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants%27_Revolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants%27_Revolt
- bilbo0s 5y agoThere is no difference. I've heard that Islam and Christianity, as religions, are good and forgiving. I've also witnessed the behavior of actual muslims and christians. I would not call these people good. I certainly wouldn't call them forgiving. My feeling is that the poster is on the right track. Ideological groups, (not trying to pick on politics, but they are usually political ideologues), have become the new pseudo-religions. As people in the West have fallen away from church, we've witnessed the rise of ideologue communities on the right and left. You can't argue with them. You can't question them. Some want to kill off half the people in the country. Others want draconian control over the other half. And people are surprised that the only option available to a reasonable person is to opt-out? If anything, I think people are being shortsighted in viewing the threat. For some people in the US, this ideology war is not only about a right to speech, it can come down to a right to live. Those people have to oppose the ideologues, or die. I don't claim to know the solution, I do know that it's a tough, tough problem.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoJust like with any belief system, there are many more moderates than zealots. The problem is, zealots help the leaders of those belief systems gain more power. Moderates, for the most part, just want things to keep working and not to feel the lash on their back. When the zealots can't let this happen and the powers that be lose control of the zealots, that's usually when revolution happens =(
- raxxorrax 5y agoI don't think they are capable of a revolution at this point. Their wrath can easily be redirected. You don't even have to put up a too convincing target, small overstepping of some arbitrary social rule is enough.
- PontifexMinimus 5y ago> I've heard that Islam and Christianity, as religions, are good and forgiving. I've also witnessed the behavior of actual muslims and christians. I would not call these people good. Of course not; the movement isn't the ideology. Whatever the ideology, the people in it will be flawed and fallible human beings.
- nine_k 5y agoRepentance — yes, galore, it's exactly the expexted action from the one accused of transsgression. Write a long blog post condemning the bitter mistake, step out from your post, if you have any. But on the banner on this religion is not Love, but Justice. So, forgiveness is hard to obtain. It takes either converting into a zealot, or hiding in oblivion. "If God were to show justice instead of His endless grace, we would all end up in Hell", wrote one medieval theologician. This whole thing is thoroughly medieval, if you look at it at a certain angle. While declaring that it stands for progress, it rejects the values of the Enlightenment much more deeply than many alt-right philosophers who flaunt this rejection. If you ever wondered what highly westernized Iran might look like before the revolution, this may provide a glimpse. Feeling righteous and rejecting doubt is a powerful and addictive drug :(
- Zababa 5y agoDo you have the source for the quote of the medieval theologian? It's very interesting.
- nine_k 5y agoApparently it was Isaac of Niveneh, a Middle Eastern Christian theoligian from 7th century: https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2013/03/17/st-isaac-the-syrian-the-scandalous-injustice-of-god/ https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2013/03/17/st-isaac-the-syrian... I think Christ himself pushes this view in a number of fables and sermons, right in the canonical gospels.
- Zababa 5y agoThanks.
- nyokodo 5y ago> This whole thing is thoroughly medieval Actually, Medieval Scholastics had a vibrant discourse from a wide array of sources that would look practically libertarian by comparison to contemporary woke discourse. It sounded way more fun too.
- PontifexMinimus 5y agoOne of the main difference between Wokism and Christianity, in my opinion, is that in Christianity there is forgiveness, whereas in Wokism you can be endlessly dragged overf the coals for something you said ages ago when you were a teenager: https://pontifex.substack.com/p/no-redemption-for-the-woke https://pontifex.substack.com/p/no-redemption-for-the-woke
- echelon 5y agoI think most people are beginning to hate woke culture. The pendulum is swinging.
- PontifexMinimus 5y agoI think you are probably right. Maybe Wokism will mutate into something less virulent. Or maybe the opposition to it will become overwhelming and destroy it.
- shkkmo 5y agoYou seem to have missed the log in your own eye.
- Zababa 5y agoAnother big difference is that, from what I understand, in Christianity everyone bears the original sin. In Wokism, only white males do.
- andrei_says_ 5y agoI don’t think the major organized religious institutions believe in anything but power and money. What “Religion” believes in is very hard to define.
- malandrew 5y agoWell current society has chosen "struggle sessions". You get forgiveness if you voluntarily admit to some sin and only then if the sin is mild. If you're found out without coming forth with your sins first, you're excommunicated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struggle_session https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struggle_session
- remram 5y agoIsn't that the same way religion works? Confession and atonement for minor transgressions, "legal" punishment otherwise?
- pstuart 5y ago> The big difference is that religion usually believes in some kind of forgiveness and repentance Usually? There's boatloads of sermons recorded out that that preach hate and fear. Very selective reasoning on both sides of this equation.
- giardini 5y agoZababa says "religion usually believes in some kind of forgiveness and repentance. " Yes, they will forgive you, allow you to repent for your "errors" and then they will burn you at the stake. Religion is just another belief system.
- giardini 5y agoAll belief systems are the same: communism, christianity, mohammedanism, buddhism, etc. No organized belief system (includes any religion) is noteworthy for forgiveness and repentance. Such gems as the religious wars in Europe, CCP treatment of Uighurs today, the Inquisition, the Crusades, Genghis Khan, the current Middle East all showed little mercy for unbelievers. They'll forgive you, maybe let you repent. But then they will kill you, your family, your friends and your business associates.
- nine_k 5y agoGengis Khan, afaik, was not a religious fanatic, or even an ethnic supremacist. His army absorbed warriors from different places and of different religions. What he required was fealty, not faith. This is how he built a colossal empire, Earth's largest IIRC. An empire has to be somehow tolerant towards differences between the many nations it consumes. The process of assimilation, even if forced, can and usually does take centuries. Faith systems are not like that: they require an immediate conversion, and an immediate and willing following the norms.
- giardini 5y agoYou're quibbling about minor details. Khan was head of a belief system: believe and help him and you might not die. He and his men wanted the tundra cleared of cities. He did it. nine_k says>""An empire has to be somehow tolerant towards differences between the many nations it consumes. The process of assimilation, even if forced, can and usually does take centuries."< Khan didn't assimilate, he destroyed. Only after his death and the end of his generation of warriors, was his former empire "assimilated" by groups lucky(?) enough to be alive. The words "tolerant" and "assimilation" have no place when speaking of the advancement of Gengis Khan's armies out of Mongolia. Just like "faith systems" today have no tolerance, accept no "repentance" and refuse "assimilation".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mkr-hn 5y agoIt's always the loudest few. I've read takes from conservatives in favor of BLM, racial justice, queer rights, etc from conservative principles. The "conservatives" who go feral over any queer representation in media or even discussing reparations probably don't represent the majority numerically, but the silence of the rest (probably out of fear) makes it hard to say they aren't, essentially, representatives. I try to do right from my "side," but sometimes it's scary when popular checkmarked people on Twitter call for genocides of "red" states, where I happen to live, to thunderous applause.
- nine_k 5y agoI personally am entirely fine with queer people (some of my closest relatives and friends are queer), I think that racism is wrong due to many reasons, and certainly I'm totally fine with immigrants because this is how America came to be and later became great. What I see as troubling is the "cancel culture", the force of the righteous mob. I believe that a society with more justice and grace than we have now can be built entirely without it, and that the intolerant fighters for inclusion and tolerance make the prospects of building such a society weaker. You can't force people to be just, loving, and caring. You can force them feign that, but I suppose you very well understand how fraught such a society would be. There is a number of historical examples, all sad.
- mkr-hn 5y agoAt the risk of self-promotion, I found some cause for empathy for the crusader types when writing about the subject: "They’re mostly people whose elders, the people who might guide them to a fierce but strategic advocacy, were murdered by police or mob violence, thrown in prison for bullshit reasons, or allowed to die in a plague. If you can bring empathy for the guy who got fired from Google for circulating a paper that made his colleagues uncomfortable, you can bring it for people who are dealing with a strange world with no one to talk to who gets what they’re going through." https://viewfinderfox.com/history-is-canceled/ https://viewfinderfox.com/history-is-canceled/ This is the part where I'd anticipate a crusader type accusing me of infantalizing people if I were on Twitter. I don't think it's entirely people who have no guidance + people taking up their cause (often without asking), but I think it's a large part of it. Some of it, maybe most of it, is Well-Meaning Allies causing a lot of noise while not listening to the people they're trying to help. I had a cis woman on Twitter lecture me on nonbinary identity because she didn't realize I was describing my own experience. I think that type is what most people get annoyed at, and sometimes their anger/fear has splash damage on people who didn't ask for that help.
- malandrew 5y agoTotally agree. What's interesting is that "antiracism" (i.e. neoracism) has analogous tenets and catechisms of a secular religion. They even reinvented original sin. https://www.thedailybeast.com/antiracism-our-flawed-new-religion https://www.thedailybeast.com/antiracism-our-flawed-new-reli...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- swayvil 5y agoYou should generalize that to "aggressively ideological society". It doesn't matter what the ideology is based upon. It's the aggression that matters. And the "solipsism" too, I guess. If that term can be applied to societies. I mean, when the hivemind detaches from all evidence, insulated from reality, self-affirming, self-amplifying, purity-seeking. Modern social media is, of course, great for achieving that.
- noduerme 5y agoI think religion is a poor analogy, because except in a few extreme cases like Iran, religion doesn't seek to create a totalitarian framework for every personal thought or action. And I don't view the Iranian revolution as much as a religious revival as a movement in the sense that a totalitarian movement must stay "in motion". The motion is the point. The revolution carries on, eating its own. To me as a liberal it took a long time to realize that "wokism" has no fixed goal; it's more like a millenarian cult or a utopian movement that is willing to constantly redefine language in the service of forever one-upping its own followers. The winner is whoever can create the most visceral mob anger at last month's winner. It survives without an articulable final goal precisely because each iteration of the dogma pushes the last under a bus. Power comes from staying ahead of the permanent motion of the movement, an impossible task. Similar phenomena can be observed in right wing movements, of course. But the far right is open about its hate, so anyone who demures can ultimately fall back on personal conscience. The far left uses love, not hate, as the grindstone for its acolytes. Thus any dissent leaves the dissenter questioning whether she was insufficiently loving. This kind of "love", detached from its real world object or any true objective, used as a measure of fealty, is one of the key hallmarks of totalitarianism, because it requires absolute obeisance in thought and action, while totally atomizing each member of the community into a fearful, self-censoring follower of whoever claims the mantle of radicalism and motion today.
- rmbyrro 5y ago> I think religion is a poor analogy, because except in a few extreme cases like Iran, religion doesn't seek to create a totalitarian framework for every personal thought or action. Sure, now tell that joke to Giordano Bruno. The left and the right today share so many traits with how religions operate that it freaks me out.
- noduerme 5y agoThe point wasn't to excuse any facets of religion, simply to point out that there are stronger similarities in operational tactics to totalitarian movements than there are to garden-variety religious organizations, which in the modern age tend to calcify around dogma rather than act as engines of motion via constant revolutionary purges.
- pstuart 5y ago> What good is the First Amendment if citizens themselves see free speech as a dangerous transgression? Well, first and foremost, the First is about the government interfering with speech. I don't think that applies to what you're complaining about, which appears to be an increase of intolerance of intolerance. And your usage of "religious" to those of that ilk is sloppy whataboutism. Religion is about believing is something that can't be proven, and countless atrocities have occurred in its name. Equating that to somebody who says "black lives matter" and believes that to be true is flat out dishonest.
- endominus 5y agoMinor but important quibble; religion is about what cannot be disproven. It can potentially be proven (if we ever encounter an alien species that, for example, has a document fundamentally identical to the Qur'an, the weight of evidence would swing quite heavily, I think anyone would agree). In that framework, the people comparing wokism to a religion might point out several unfalsifiable beliefs that it's adherents generally hold. For an example of a fairly common one, "[inequality] is the result of discrimination."
- pstuart 5y ago> "[inequality] is the result of discrimination." That's playing with words. If we can agree that discrimination exists then that clearly impacts "equality". As to the nit about religion -- I was trying to be polite. Religion really exists because people were really ignorant in the beginning and wanted answers to the questions of life. Then it became a self-sustaining self-serving organization that exists because "god". I'd posit that almost all religious people are of their faith because their parents were of that faith. Then it's turtles all the way up.
- pstuart 5y agoMinor quibble: religion is about social control, i.e., God says you can do this but not that. I'm not trying to attack religion (happy to do that elsewhere), just trying to clarify the language being used. Specifically, this game of calling people who believe in a certain morality religious is dishonest. Just because I believe that all people should be treated equally regardless of race, creed, color, gender, sexuality, nationality, etc -- that doesn't make me religious. I hope at worst it makes me avoid being a "bad person".
- lookalike74 5y agoTheocracy isn't religion at all. It's politics that assume a religious veneer, similar to how nationalism assumes a historical veneer. (And honestly... most 'aggressive' religions are really nothing BUT politics.)
- nine_k 5y agoThe idea is that a theocracy forces religious norms on its subjects by the force of the state. The contrast I'm making is that the state in the U.S. does not do that, but citizens themselves seem to act coercively and force the norms of their faith on anyone who voices any doubts loudly enough.