18 ms·
Rhode island makes financial literacy classes required for high school students
- sigstoat 5y agohopefully the final exam includes working out a post-college graduation budget which includes student loan repayments, and expected earnings.
- burlesona 5y agoThis is great news. I’ve long thought that high school students would be better served if they substituted statistics and finance for pre-calculus and calculus. Most people gain very little utility from Calculus, but a better understanding of Finance and Statistics, especially interest rates, amortization, time value of money, and probabilities.
- josephorjoe 5y agoThe lack of understanding of basic finance and statistics is crippling for many people. I know fairly smart people who understand calculus but just cannot accept that there is a problem with paying interest on all of their purchases. They simply do not understand that eliminating high interest debt as soon as possible (or never acquiring it in the first place) is essential to ever having financial security. Honestly it sometimes feels like the normalizing of financial illiteracy is intentional, although I'm willing to accept that the lenders of high interest debt are just taking advantage of the situation they've found.
- fn-mote 5y ago> I know fairly smart people who understand calculus but just cannot accept that there is a problem with paying interest on all of their purchases. I do not think this is a problem with education. It sounds like they understand, they just do not care. I think that is a different (harder) problem. You're unhappy that people do not believe it is beneficial to be debt-free. As you note - there are many groups who benefit (profit) from this kind of spend-spend-spend consumption culture. Frankly, I am astounded that COVID did not bring about a massive economic collapse that would have driven the point about financial security home in a dreadful way. I'm grateful it didn't, though.
- tekknik 5y agoWell there’s a difference between high interest debt and just debt. And agreed don’t get into high interest debt to begin with and pay it off ASAP if you do anyway. But avoiding interest all together is a massive oversimplification and shows you don’t understand that cash in hand (and the ability to earn more from it) can be better than a low interest loan. If you make 10% from cash on hand and have 5% loans then you got free money and 5% gains.
- theandrewbailey 5y agoEven algebra is of limited to no use for most people, and I support skipping it for something more useful to more people.
- xxpor 5y ago"How long do I need to keep money in an account for it to double if it grows at 8% a year" is an algebra problem. I suspect they're more common than you expect, you're just used to it.
- wmf 5y agoI don't know if the current algebra curriculum is teaching people how to solve real problems though.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoThat might have been a useful project back when we actually had interest rates :)
- imtringued 5y agoYou still pay a premium because of default rates. The better your credit score the lower the predicted default rate and the lower the interest rate. Low interest rates on loans are actually a pretty bad idea to stimulate an economy because the majority of people do not have access to them. If you gave people a $1000 coupon that lets them borrow $1000 at 0% interest regardless of the default rate you are going to see a bigger impact on inflation rates. The benefit is that people only take the loan if they actually spend it, therefore this is superior to helicopter money. If they default that's fine because then it turns into helicopter money which is still better than more loans for houses.
- japhyr 5y agoI taught middle and high school math for many years, and I always offered financial-focused projects as an option for students. I also used financial examples on a regular basis, just to keep a healthy, rational conversation about financial literacy going. The two most important topics over the years seemed to be loan analysis and understanding taxes. To understand loans, I taught students how to determine the monthly payment for a loan using a blank spreadsheet. For students who were intimidated by spreadsheets, we'd start the process on a whiteboard. Just a simple spreadsheet with columns like month, current principal, payment, towards interest, towards principal, new principal. Then guess-and-check to see what the payment needed to be in order to pay off the loan in a specified time period. That was great, because it let everyone see how loan payments are calculated in the first place. Then it let curious students explore the impact of paying above the minimum, making lump sum payments at various intervals, different interest rates, initial no-payment periods, and other loan "features". We also looked at cumulative interest and other long-term aspects of a loan. Students could do their own projects about car loans, home loans, business loans, and more. Every time I've taken out a loan in my life, I've done this myself, and it's made the experience better every time. Just doing this once lets you talk to a loan officer on a much more eye-to-eye level. This is education as consumer advocacy, fighting back against predatory practices one class at a time. For taxes, I just had students either bring in their own pay stubs or W2s, or work with a sample set related to a field they were interested in working in. Then I had them fill out a 1040 by hand. They had to start out with the simplest 1040, and they could choose to try a more complex version after that. I had them repeat the process for several income levels; most students had no idea what a "tax bracket" actually is. I'd start with a question like "You're making $__k/yr, and you're offered a $1k raise. The raise will bump you into the next tax bracket. Should you accept the raise?" Many students said no, because they had no concept of incremental tax rates. You have to present this material carefully. If you tell a whole class of math students, "Okay, everyone's learning to analyze loans this week!" they'll hate it. If you say, "We're learning to analyze numerical patterns, and one of the patterns you can analyze is how banks determine the monthly payment for the car or house loan you might want in a few years", they'll jump on it.
- derekp7 5y agoFor tax brackets, I like the bucket of ping pong balls analogy. After filling up each bucket you color a percentage of the balls green (done on the whiteboard of course), which represents the government's cut. When a bucket gets full, balls overflow into the next bucket. And monthly paycheck deductions are based on 1/12'th of the green balls in each bucket. This then explains why when you get a bonus it is taxed at 22% as those balls go in the last bucket with room in it (or 24%..., whatever the highest marginal tax rate someone is in).
- abdullahkhalids 5y ago> Most people gain very little utility from Calculus Because the purpose of high school and basic university mathematics is to make people smarter. Algebra or calculus deal with abstractions and concepts that are hard to master. They are like lifting heavy weights. A course on statistics and finance is easier and hence like lifting light weights. This has independent of the fact that high school teachers and underpaid, overworked, undertrained, and are forced to teach to the test, and so unable to really teach mathematics as they students deserved
- aidenn0 5y agoI love me some Calculus, but the reason it is required is that 60 years ago we were worried that the Soviets were outpacing us in rocket design, which was seen as a major threat to our national security. Calculus is pretty darn useful for building rockets.
- croes 5y agoSounds like a road to more flat earthers and anti-vaxxers. The more practical math and the less abstraction the less critical thinking.
- tdeck 5y agoI'm not convinced that most of my fellow "spheroid earthers" reached that conclusion through critical thinking - we learned from authority figures. In my science class we explored some arguments for a round earth, but if I recall they were trigonometry based and didn't involve calculus at all. I don't see any connection between calculus and "critical thinking".
- snarf21 5y agoI agree that this would be helpful but people are lazy and don't really care. They know the car costs $60K but they only ask what the monthly payment is. We really need a strong CPB to get rid of all the rent seeking and exploitative business practices that are all the "profit" centers for so many businesses.
- lordnacho 5y agoWell if you had to have one or the other, I think you are actually right. Prob and stats are essential in any discussion of real-world data, which comes up pretty much every day. They are also the best way into dealing with something inherently messy, which data pretty much is all the time. It's a good way to talk about what you think is true and why, critical to decision making. Calculus on the other hand is bit too beautiful. At high school level at least, you get all these smooth curves, everything has a nice closed form answer, and you start to think that maybe these beautiful shapes describe the universe. It's actually not that easy to do, it just happens that we found some examples where it works quite well, and they are just the kinds of things we teach in physics in those same years. When we then get to an economics class, it unravels. There's a whole menagerie of calculus assumptions that creep into the minds of credulous students. Lets assume Cobb-Douglass production function. Let's say the utility must be this shape. Oh look at what beautiful conclusions we get.
- deepserket 5y agoThe thing that i don't understand is how can people that live in the USA accumulate so much debt? As a 24yo European I never had more than 5k € of debt at any point in my life.
- wmf 5y agoMaybe your government provides more/better services...
- julienchastang 5y agoDo Europeans not go into debt (tens to perhaps hundreds of thousands of €s) to purchase a home, for example?
- mattkrause 5y agoPerhaps less so for education, medical care, a car, etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wink 5y agoCan't speak for Europe overall, but in Germany it's highly uncommon to buy a home until you've either finished studying and have a proper job, or in the case of vocational training, having worked a few years. We seem to be pretty averse to debt in general, so for most people "buying a home" is the only acceptable thing to take on a large debt, and even you're probably already 30-40. Of course this is a little different if you live where housing is really cheap, but good luck getting an apartment or a house for under 500k-1m € in a big city.
- pwg 5y agoBecause it is, unfortunately, far too easy to obtain credit in the US (unless one puts a 'freeze' on one's credit reports, one gets about 1-2 offers for new credit cards in the mail daily). Additionally, credit cards are a way of buying things where the actual cost is wholly disconnected from the purchasing activity. Purchasing something for $1 using a credit card feels (and acts) identically to purchasing something for $2000 using a credit card. The only difference is the size of the number being added to the balance, so buying "more than one can actually afford" via credit cards is far too easy, because for many it does not feel like "spending". I.e., there's no "physicality" of having to count out cash bills and seeing the pile grow. As well, credit card payback rates as calculated by the banks are structured such that the principal is paid down as slowly as legally allowed, which naturally increases the banks profits at the detriment of the individual paying the bill (as most of the payment goes to interest, not principal, if paying the "minimum payment" calculated by the holding bank). So it is simply very easy to obtain plural credit cards, and to use them to fuel an instant gratification lifestyle well beyond ones means without considering the consequences of loading up 20k or 30k or more onto credit cards on a take home salary of 2-3k/month. And, once someone has gotten themselves dug into this deep pit of debt, it is extremely difficult to climb up out of the hole.
- Kapura 5y agoHas there been any data to show that financial literacy education improves results? My understanding was that starting with capital is much more important to financial success than coursework.
- josephorjoe 5y agoIf you research this I think you'll find that starting with capital correlates strongly with having a financially literate family who can provide useful guidance. Giving capital to people who are not financially literate will likely end up with that capital quickly moving out of their hands to people who are financially literate.
- cascom 5y agoMoreover - as you go up the capital spectrum you see an increasing emphasis on teaching financial literacy to children (just look at the marketing materials of private banks an wealth managers purporting to help educate the next generation)
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoFinancial literacy is useless if you can't teach folks how to survive when there isn't quite enough money. Teaching how to invest is useless if the person remains poor for the next 10-20 years, and if trends stay the same, they probably will be. Financial literacy should include this stuff, plus how to get help if you can't make rent, are going hungry, or are homeless.
- dhzizns 5y ago“ when there isn't quite enough money” But is it obvious there isn't enough money? My in-laws, immigrants with almost no skills and mext to zero English, work at Walmart. Their income sucks (<40k combined [1]), and they have zero financial skills (they grew up in communism). The one thing they know, however, is that my wife is very sharp. therefore, they have given her full access to their all their accounts. Result? They’re contributing to a 401k despite always blowing money on flashy iPhones (they’re fairly irresponsible). They also bought a modest house (ill admit we did lend them the money for a 10% down, which they've paid back) since rent had become more expensive than a mortgage. They’ve been in the US for just five years and, with very little material help from us, have a reasonable shot at retirement income [2]. The big difference with many others is that my wife took a chunk of their financial autonomy with automatic withdrawals so they wont blow too much money (lottery tickets, booze, fancier iPhones, etc) [1] Note, they don't have to take care of anyone but themselves with <40k [2] retirement means selling the house and coming to live with us as soon as either of them can no longer work.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoA policy wholly informed by boomers‘ stereotypes of younger generations being too stupid or hedonistic to achieve the sort of financial freedoms they got during the post-WW2 boom years. Also sacrificing the idea of a „liberal“ education that seeks to enlighten and build character on the altar of capitalism and pragmatism.
- sp332 5y agoI agree. Nothing wrong with the class itself but it seems like it's being used to blame-shift.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- josephorjoe 5y agoMaybe if people were more financially literate they would stop letting the boomers rob them blind by always protecting their own interests (stocks, houses, healthcare for old people) at the expense of all other aspects of society (education, infrastructure, health care for non-old people).
- spikels 5y agoBuried lede: “pragmatism” is a bad thing. The idea that actually useful information should be excluded to maintain ideological purity is both stupid and surprisingly prevalent.
- skeeter2020 5y agoIs this just rebranding of the home economics class everyone took 20+ years ago in junior/senior high? They could replace "how to balance your cheque book" with reviewing online statements and keep the rest of the curriculum the same IIRC...
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI feel like we also need to teach kids how the IRS works and what withholding, tax returns, credits, and deductions actually mean. Balancing a checkbook is trivial compared to understanding what needs to be filed and when.
- bwb 5y agoya, compound interest, long term returns of the stock market, 401k fees, etc
- kritiko 5y agoa problem with this is that you could eventually get to the truth that the best way to increase your wealth is to get a higher salary.
- reidjs 5y agoNot necessarily IMO. Wealth is a function of assets, liabilities, income, and other factors. There are plenty of people with high salaries who I wouldn’t consider wealthy by any stretch.
- bwb 5y agoya, I think it is a combo of salary + behaviours that build wealth, combined with having some idea about what you want from your brief time on this planet.
- Gunax 5y agoI actually gently disagree. There is a lot of statements that education doesn't teach practical skills, but i think that's a mistake. We don't teach specifics like 'how to do your taxes' or different retirement account types. But we teach general skills that enable those. And frankly, those change too often (both time and jurisdiction) and are far too broad to be very useful. When English teachers discuss Shakespeare, or history teachers discuss analyzing documents: they are generally not expecting students to have to read those particulars, but instead aiming for attainment of a more general skill (literacy, analysis, veracity). Basically, I think it's better to just teach math and literacy in general. Then if they want to know how APR is calculated, they will have the ability to research it. School cannot possibly teach everything one could want or need to know in life. It's more about setting a foundation.
- patpending 5y agoWhat in the world is going on with that URL?
- eesmith 5y agoThe bill says "Thirty-six (36) states guarantee access to personal finance education in their public." - http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/billtext20/housetext20/h7605.htm http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/billtext20/housetext20/h7... . I wonder how that's helped those other states. My personal opinion is that the system is set up to screw people out of their money, with the push for (expensive, self-funded) college education instead of on-the-job training or government-funded college education, the low minimum wage, especially for employees in tipped positions, the nerfing of union power, the high cost of a privatized health system, the difficulties of switching jobs due to employer-funded medical insurance, the lack of funding and political support things like the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, high banking costs, and so on. Do these personal finance classes teach about these systemic issues? Or do they imply that the student is responsible for a system weighted against them? I wonder what part of the existing school curricula will be removed in order to have the time for this class.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoThe only thing you need to teach students is how to use gnucash or kmymoney. Make they log every transaction and monitor their balances. See how much they spend and then tell them "spend less." Maybe the we wouldn't have such a drastic FOMO culture where students and college kids blow their financial aid money on things that absolutely do not matter in the grand scheme of life.
- cascom 5y agoI’m perpetually shocked that many professional people (e.g. journalists with masters degrees) have a tenuous grasp at best on: basic accounting, how the US tax system functions, simple financial concepts (simple math on NPV/perpetuities/annuities, Compounding), and financial market basics (stocks vs bonds, market cap vs enterprise value)
- recursive 5y agoHi. I'm one of the professionals you'd be shocked by. One of my problems is that I don't know who to trust. It seems like most of the people who would explain any of it also have something to sell. Of the concepts you listed, I think I understand compounding, at least the one pertaining to interest rates. The others are a mystery to me. I'm in a stable 6-figure career and in my 40s.
- bitwize 5y agoI'm waiting for this to be repealed because it's thought to disadvantage minority students.
- mberning 5y agoIt’s a bit hard to teach these concepts to somebody that has no practical knowledge of earning a paycheck, paying taxes, investing in a 401k, buying a car, etc. The ideas will seem far off and abstract. Kind of like how I could not appreciate my software engineering curriculum until years later after I worked on some horribly managed projects professionally.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoMaybe the curriculum can simulate someone earning a paycheck and making payments, etc. Each week's lesson would be be a new financial month. I guess having some sort of software to keep track of each student's fictional finances would be cool, but since this is the education sector, there is probably just none to bad such software. I hope they also teach the kids that "stonks" and crypto are no better than gambling. There should be a fictional Lamborghini dealership in this software, to teach the kids that buying a super expensive car is a waste of money. Hah, writing this makes me wonder why I am lusting for an Alfa Romeo Giulia...
- sigstoat 5y ago> It’s a bit hard to teach these concepts to somebody that has no practical knowledge of [...], etc. The ideas will seem far off and abstract. what do you think _can_ be taught to people (K-12 students) who have no practical knowledge of anything?
- mc32 5y agoThis is better than giving people free bus passes[1]. It's too bad that home-ec and shop were closed in many schools and either defunded or replaced by other less impactful classes. These things impact the long term finances of many young people, many more than other niche classes would. This is probably more beneficial than a second language very few put to use. If $100,000/yr millennials can't balance their books[1]... then how can people of lesser means balance theirs? [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27575872 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27575872 [2]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27581105 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27581105
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>If $100,000/yr millennials can't balance their books[1]... then how can people of lesser means balance theirs? Necessity is a hell of a motivator. Don't mistake the standard practices of a 100k/yr single person for what everyone is doing. People who are living on easy mode won't develop the same skills people living on hard mode will.
- mc32 5y agoYes, that is true and I was aware of the discrepancy, never the less, people of lesser means make financial mistakes due to lack of financial literacy because it was not taught to them -these have lasting impact. On the other hand, for schools teaching financial literacy isn't as important as sports or providing a second language to kids but it should be. I agree those $100,000 millennials can pick up the pieces/recover much easier due to a deeper well of marketable skills and resources.
- ghaff 5y agoBeing very far away from a (private) high school education--I could probably go through many individual courses and draw a line through them for not much loss, at least the way they're typically taught--so it does seem as if many high school curricula would benefit from a "practical track." On the other hand, there are a bunch of courses that students going on to college will benefit from. Which basically comes dowsn to whether "trade schools" should be a bigger component of high school.
- subsubzero 5y agoIt took me so long to become "financially literate". I racked up big credit card bills in my 20's, bought a few cars with unfavorable loans around the same time. There was no education on how interest rates work, apr's are calculated and such. I probably lost 10's of thousands on poor financial decisions that I would have avoided if a class like this was around. Some things I have learned that have become invaluable: - Risk/reward with stocks, how bonds work. - Balancing budgets, monthly, yearly. - 401k, roth IRAs, saving for retirement. - Credit debt and how to avoid it. - Interest rates for housing and how it affects the housing market and purchasing power. - The importance of a "rainy day savings fund".
- delaynomore 5y ago>I would have avoided if a class like this was around. I doubt the 20yr old me would've listened anyway. I, too, racked up some CC debt (nothing crazy) in my early 20s. I knew most concepts outlined above but it's really about dealing with temptations when you finally making real money with full-time work.
- jrmg 5y agoSorry for this barrage of questions: How did you rationalize building up big credit card bills? You knew you'd have to pay them back some day. Were you spending without thinking about the bills? Did you not understand what interest was? Could you afford the monthly payments, and think that if you could everything must be fine?
- endymi0n 5y agoThe more I see, the more I think we need a mandatory „Life School“ curriculum in classes. Financial literacy is just one issue, but all that stuff like media competency, scientific method, cui bono, negotiations, assertiveness, how to deal with bullies, mental health basics, economics 101, mechanics of addiction and manipulation aaaand so on, all explained by first principles, would go such a long way towards a better functioning society. Then again, that‘s not going to happen as it would eventually destroy whole industries and populist voter bases. I smell a non-profit I should do one day…
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe state is the last institution I trust to design a "life school" curriculum. Remember, these are the people who require your drivers ed instructor to tell you to go 55 on I95 where the traffic goes 85. They're optimizing for covering their own butts while nominally educating people. They don't really care about truly education people so those people can go do to what will result in the best outcome for them. They'll do something self serving and asinine like tell students you should make minimum payments on high interest debt rather than ask for a financial hardship extension/reduction for government services/fees/fines (which in many cases are legally required to take that into account).
- smhost 5y agoThat's funny, because public school is where I learned the difference between letter of the law and spirit of the law. We even did a "compare and contrast" worksheet with speed limits as one of the examples. Besides, the alternatives to public education are all worse.
- iammisc 5y agoThe indoctrination is so obvious when statements are made with no justification or even any attempt.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago
- elijaht 5y agoHonestly- I don't think 99% of students will care. And those that do are largely the type that will not need this class (well off, or already would be doing this research, for example). I think it's really hard to care about 99% of personal finance until you are in it, and thankfully most students in this class won't have to care about the material immediately. And the material is bottom of the barrel in terms of intellectual stimulation and a surprising large body of material. Without "hooks" like actually paying rent, electric, etc. it feels so abstract that nothing sticks well. We had a course like this required as part of my high school graduation reqs and among myself/friends it was hugely ineffective. I don't know what the best way to solve this problem is, but I'm dubious this will benefit anyone
- vmception 5y agoits still the exposure that's relevant. simple exposure can alter search queries later, or give people a referential source to look back to, even if rote memorization or even critical thinking was completely neglected. a student going through this class will make fun of it with their peers, but then be completely shocked at how useless and poor the decision making is from people outside their school.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nubb 5y agoI took an independent living class in high school that taught me basic checkboook balancing, cooking, cleaning, etc and while I didn’t care then, I can’t say I didn’t learn and retain anything.
- TheAdamAndChe 5y agoI was required to pass a personal finance class in high school, it resonated with me, and I am far more comfortable than most people my age. A class may not resonate with every person, but for those who take the lessons to heart and grasp the incredible potential of exponential growth, it will be absolutely life changing.
- sigstoat 5y ago
- logicalmonster 5y agoGreat move. It's always been one of my pet peeves that basic personal finance classes weren't taught more in schools. Some of the biggest financial decisions in a person's life comes right as high-school is ending. Not everybody is going to become rich, but at least give people the tools they need to maximize their gifts. The system feels intentionally designed to leave them ignorant, allow them to make dumb decisions, and extract wealth from kids for decades from that. Also, I doubt we'll ever see this as a basic public school requirement, but I'd love to see risk-management explicitly taught as part of that. To me, this guides so much of what smart decision makers do in life and would be wise for everybody to be a little familiar with.
- paulpauper 5y ago>Meanwhile over half of U.S. adults say they’re financially anxious, and over three quarters live paycheck to paycheck. This is not because of lack of financial literary. it's due to not making enough money.
- cascom 5y agoI’m not too sure, have heard antidotally from a number of vets about how much time they spent untangling young enlisted personnel from stupid financial mistakes (e.g. high interest car/motorcycle loans, when they could have qualified for a low interest loan from the navy federal credit union)
- fn-mote 5y agoIn your financial literacy class, try to explain the random behavior of the stock market and the scientifically demonstrated inability of people to pick individual stocks that will increase in value. Watch heads explode, unable to wrap their minds around the idea that certain mutual funds might be profitable many years in a row just from pure luck. Wake me up when these financial literacy classes talk about the stock market in any way other than "it's a game, try to pick the winners". The short-term school "stock market game" is selecting winners from those whose strategies involve the greatest risk/variance. (No mention of this in TFA, but it's popular in my city.) There are some real hard lessons to teach here, but I'm skeptical of both the curriculum's content (who wrote it?) and the audience's ability to make sense of it.
- paulpauper 5y ago> In your financial literacy class, try to explain the random behavior of the stock market and the scientifically demonstrated inability of people to pick individual stocks that will increase in value. Watch heads explode, unable to wrap their minds around the idea that certain mutual funds might be profitable many years in a row just from pure luck. Tons of people on WSB understand these concepts. I am not saying to emulate the behavior of WSB, but these are not concepts that are out of the grasp of a typical teenager.
- runbathtime 5y agoSlippery slope for proponents of bitcoin to slip bitcoin into the curriculum. Imo financial concepts should have been taught along with math, because math is pretty boring to most students the way it is taught currently.
- OnionBlender 5y agoDoes anyone know of any good resources for learning how to invest? I make decent money as a software engineer and max out my 401k but I don't know what to do with the money I have sitting in the bank earning almost no interest. I have a fidelity account for my 401k and company stock awards but I don't know how to go about investing in other things. I'm looking for resources to learn from, not which specific stocks to buy.
- klodolph 5y agoYou can search HN, the typical advice is to go for things like index funds which have low fees... the value rises with the rest of the stock market, but doesn't get eaten by fees. As you get closer to retirement you will want to alter your investments. You have enough money to hire a financial advisor, if you care. They can usually give you much better advice than random resources online (since their advice can be specific to your situation--things like taxes can be a bit complicated).
- gregwebs 5y agoFirst step is probably to avoid 401k rip-offs. You can find details about different providers including Fidelity here: https://www.employeefiduciary.com/sample-fee-comparisons/ https://www.employeefiduciary.com/sample-fee-comparisons/ You might possibly be able to switch your investments from a Fidelity fund with huge fees to something with normal fees. For your savings, M1 Finance offers 1% interest, which is better than nothing. IMHO it is a difficult time to start investing your non-retirement money because that the market has gone up a lot recently and bonds are at all times low. I wouldn't feel bad about staying out of things right now until you can learn a lot more. I would recommend reading everything written by Lyn Alden if you want to learn about all the macro forces effecting finance.
- kinghajj 5y agoInvestopedia, Bogleheads, and Nerdwallet are all great resources to learn about investing. I began investing after graduating and landing my first full-time job. At first, I used a fairly cookie-cutter "three-fund portfolio," as recommended by the Boglehead community. I choose VTI ("Vanguard Total Stock Market"), VEU ("Vanguard All World ex US"), and BND ("Vanguard Total Bond Market") as the three ETFs. In retrospect, I would probably pick VXUS ("Vanguard Total International Stock") in lieu of VEU. But that basic structure is still a good starting point for a new investor. Most brokers these days have features such that you can set up auto deposits from your bank account, and invest them according to a pre-set asset allocation. So say you want 15% in BND, 15% in VXUS, and 70% in VTI. If on the day of deposit your account is at 14% BND, 13% VXUS, and 72% VTI, then only BND and VXUS shares would be purchased, to make the allocation as close to the desired goal as possible. Likewise, any dividends received can be automatically reinvested. Another commenter mentioned M1 finance, which I have not used, but from what I have read, looks like a great platform.
- jrm4 5y agoAlways hated the phrase "financial literacy;" our entire economic system isn't set up to make my personal reading skills and experience more difficult and weighed against my best interest.
- imgabe 5y agoIt bothers me that so many people use the fact that something wasn’t taught in school as an excuse for not knowing it, especially something as obviously necessary as personal finance. I was dumb in college and graduated with about $4k in credit card debt. It didn’t take a classroom lecture to realize that spending more money than I earned was not a sustainable practice. It’s also not that hard to keep track of how much you spend and make sure it’s less than how much you make. For almost anything personal finance related there is free information available all over the Internet if you care to spend a couple minutes googling for it. Likewise with taxes, if you have a regular W2 job, taxes are not hard, just read and follow the instructions. It doesn’t help that people keep repeating the dumb meme that if you make a typo on your tax return the IRS will immediately throw you in jail. They won’t, they just send a letter telling you they corrected it for you (guess how I know).
- ISO-morphism 5y agoFinancial health is a lot like general physical health, it's truly simple. Don't spend more than you make, don't eat more than you need. They're also difficult, as evidenced by how many fail. There are deep systemic issues that stack the deck against the working class financially. There are also plenty of people that make very detrimental decisions when it comes to money and dig themselves into a deep hole, even without any obvious cause. Both are problems that need to be addressed. The presence of one doesn't invalidate the other, and the solving of one doesn't solve the other. Normally these discussions are people talking past each other as they haggle over the proportion of blame to assign to the individual or system. I say address both simultaneously and let both sides think they're right.
- imtringued 5y ago>Don't spend more than you make I'm not trying to crash the party here but globally this is impossible. If someone spends less than they make, someone else spends more than they make. If everyone tries to spend less then everyone will be worse off. Thus we need an institution that can run a deficit for all eternity. Call it "government". There are other ways but right now that is just how the current system was built. There is no need to feel sad or worry. I personally worry more about idiots who want to keep the current system and avoid government deficits, now that is truly horrifying.
- Ancalagon 5y agoSo they can finally understand how screwed they are by the system, right? (Specifically with regards to housing affordability) /s But no really great for RI, wish my HS would have had a financial literacy class.
- qq4 5y agoFwiw, I went to a public middle school where we balanced checkbooks, went over bank accounts and taxes. I also went to a public high school where we expanded on the above topics along with stock investing and retirement accounts. I used to think these things were the same for everyone, but as I get older it seems like it might have been unique to small Iowa towns.
- Kalium 5y agoI had a class like that my freshman year of high school - a public school outside a medium-sized town in Michigan. It even included all the kitchen sink stuff people tend to ask for: budgeting, basic nutrition, fitness, physical health, emotional health, relationships, etc. Looking back, I think it was about as effective as one could hope for when teaching bored fifteen-year-olds how to calculate interest compounding. Which is to say mostly not very.
- exabrial 5y agonot to be too snarky but, is this sponsored by Chase Bank? There are a lot of ways to do this wrong.
- jbjbjbjb 5y agoI don’t mind it but it is so middle class. This needs to be supplemental to a class about staying in school, away from drugs and alcohol and not getting pregnant.
- underseacables 5y agoBring back Home Economics!! Perhaps I’m old, but when I was in school we learned how to balance a checkbook, use a washing machine, even to sew a pillow for my mother.
- balozi 5y agoI hope they at least tell the kids that the credit score chase game in the US is a giant scum. Has been for a long time. They probably wont though. Abandon all hope.
- jonahbenton 5y agoSad irony that an article about financial literacy education promotes the balanced budget/govt-is-a-family fallacy.
- WalterBright 5y agoFor a real education in how things work, try running a small hotel: "In retrospect, I wish I had known more about the hazards and difficulties of such a business, especially during a recession of the kind that hit New England just as I was acquiring the inn's 43-year leasehold. I also wish that during the years I was in public office, I had had this firsthand experience about the difficulties business people face every day. That knowledge would have made me a better U.S. senator and a more understanding presidential contender. Today we are much closer to a general acknowledgment that government must encourage business to expand and grow. Bill Clinton, Paul Tsongas, Bob Kerrey and others have, I believe, changed the debate of our party. We intuitively know that to create job opportunities we need entrepreneurs who will risk their capital against an expected payoff. Too often, however, public policy does not consider whether we are choking off those opportunities." -- George McGovern https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970203406404578070543545022704 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970203406404578070...
- mrnobody_67 5y agoStep #1, forget everything you learned on wall street bets
- grendelt 5y agoThis article is super low on facts. Can someone locate and link to the state standards for this course? What course does it replace? Anytime there's a call to add something, you must ask what it is replacing. There's only so much time in a school day. Emphasize anything and you're defacto de-emphasizing something else. I work with cyber.org and hear states all the time talking up Computer Science and Cybersecurity. That's great! It's on message for us! ...but something else has to go. What it will be varies from state to state, but education is not something you can continue adding and adding and adding. (Unless you're advocating for longer school days/school year which is a whole different conversation.)
- mooze 5y agoThings that our schools don’t teach but totally should: - Nutrition - Financial literacy - Logical fallacies - Emotional intelligence - The creative process