13 ms·
It's an open secret at least in the tech world that absolutely no one is putting in a productive 40 hours of work a week. This was true well before the pandemic
by paxys 5y ago
It's an open secret at least in the tech world that absolutely no one is putting in a productive 40 hours of work a week. This was true well before the pandemic and is more pronounced than ever now. Everyone needs to be "present" for 8 hours a day 5 days a week, but spends their time in pointless meetings, preparing documents and powerpoints that no one will read, faux social/teambuilding events, hour long lunches, goofing off on the internet, all to maintain the pretense of office culture.
Companies that shuffle things up to prioritize productivity over simply showing up will be set to succeed over the next generation.
- bob1029 5y ago> absolutely no one is putting in a productive 40 hours of work a week You are being a little broad with this statement. One can easily put in 60+ hours for weeks on end and be incredibly productive while doing it. Its all circumstantial. If you have no family, are the sole founder in the company, and really enjoy what you are doing, why the fuck would you stop at a 40 hour work week? Not all of us loathe the thing we do for the majority of our waking hours.
- impostir 5y agoI would just say that choosing to work more than 40 hrs per week is very different to being forced to work 40 hrs per week. Simply because someone can happily choose more work hours does not mean that the de facto standard should be that high or even at 40 hrs.
- monsieurbanana 5y agoI read it more as "no one is having 40 hours per week of productive work continuously". Even in your example, being productive for 60+ hours is possible, but for how long? There might be extreme (extreme!) outliers, but I think it's fair to say that at some point you will increase your productivity by putting in less hours.
- rogerkirkness 5y agoI can work 55 hours a week in perpetuity as a founder, with the exception of four off grid, week long vacations a year. Even two weeks over 60 hours (e.g. fundraising across timezones) and I rapidly lose it.
- monsieurbanana 5y agoBut is your overall productivity higher with 55 hours than it would be with less hours? It's the kind of question where I wouldn't really believe your answer, unless you've actually tried to experiment yourself where is the cutoff (for your specific situation) between hours / productivity. Not because I think you would answer in bad faith, but because it's a really complex question. What if working less hours over multiple years would let you pursue some hobby, turn you more sociable and thus a better leader/CEO? Or maybe it would make you just very slightly better at decision making. You would have less time to manage your company, maybe relying more on others, but in exchange you would have more energy for the really crucial decisions. Or enough energy for extending that 2-weeks international crowdfunding effort into a 3-weeks.
- rogerkirkness 5y agoYes, over the course of a 12 year full time career, if I go above 55 it gets worse, but I can sustain 55. In terms of trade offs, there's something to be said for parkinson's law. If I have way more than 55 hours a week of stuff, I know I have to fit it into 55 or I'll burn out. If I aim for less, I find I never end up working less than 40, even if the absolute amount is much lower.
- etempleton 5y agoIn the marketing agency world 50-60 hour weeks are the norm and 70 hour weeks occur once a month or so. It isn’t really sustainable. Most people burn out and leave the agency world within three years. Those that stay often make work their life or have a way where they can set their own schedules, which is usually because they have reached marketing executive level and the work becomes different. It is a very unhealthy industry. I am not sure if it can be sustained in it’s current form, but I don’t ever see the hours being reduced either. 4 day work weeks would just mean 12+ hour days and you would have to hope your clients aren’t open on Fridays or whatever day you decided to make your company day off. Staggering days wouldn’t work that well as most agencies have little to no redundancy by design.
- goldenchrome 5y agoYes, if you're starting your own business then it could help you to work as much as you can. However, most people do not run their own business. Most people are low-level code monkeys in large firms where individual efforts aren't business critical. When your project gets cancelled for the 3rd time and you still get a raise, it finally clicks that your work doesn't really matter. This takes a psychological toll. As a result, most people I know in FAANG who are 28+ years old will sheepishly admit that they do very little actual work (30 hours max per week). That's the whole point of hiring people straight out of college: you get ~5 years out of them before they realize what the game is. The ones who are happy with the "truth" become managers, and the ones who aren't opt to keep their head down and coast, or just quit from "burnout".
- DSingularity 5y agoYeah, or you can avoid all that by going to startups.
- goldenchrome 5y agoAnd do a lot more work for way less money? Your work will have more impact, that's for sure. But at some point you'll have a higher-level realization that you're still working in a capitalist hellhole and you're not being fairly compensated for the risk compared to the VCs or the founders. If I was going to work in a startup or FAANG from 22-30, I'd pick FAANG for the guaranteed million dollars in the bank. The only exception I'd personally make is to found a startup with people I enjoy on a problem that I'm personally motivated by. This is basically a band for capitalistic nerds. Even then, you still have to allow VCs to suck out your soul.
- y2bd 5y agoAnd given what kinds of products and services the vast majority of startups out there provide, even "impact" is questionable.
- whateveracct 5y agoWorking 60hr/week for a startup is completely illogical. It's the sort of thing you only do drunk on kool-aid.
- lamontcg 5y ago> are the sole founder in the company yeah in this case, if its really your dream, go right ahead. most workers aren't the founders of the company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lmm 5y ago> One can easily put in 60+ hours for weeks on end and be incredibly productive while doing it. Do you have an objective measure of that? I've worked with plenty of people who thought they were being productive for 60+ hours/week, but none of their productivity actually stacked up. Founder/CTO types were the worst, they'd bypass process and cause outages but because of their position everyone had to coddle their ego and pretend that they were doing good work and the trouble wasn't their fault.
- nrdvana 5y agoI can do 60s in bursts, and the bursts have lasted as long as 2 months before. I usually burn out as soon as we hit the finish line, and work 10-20 hour weeks for a while until all the comp-time is used up. But I can really do a fantastic amount of programming when I dedicate my entire brain to the project and completely exclude all other thoughts. OTOH I have to admit that both of the biggest production screwups I ever made happened in those crunch times. But seeing myself hit those levels of productivity actually gives me a ton of satisfaction. Some of my normal 40 hour weeks when my head isn’t in the game are so un-productive that it depresses me. You asked about objective measures, but I’m not sure how programming can really be quantified. All I can say is my “hyper-mode” has caused projects to reach deadlines that others on the team thought were unlikely.
- JesseMReeves 5y agoCan you give us some advice on how you recharge effectively between such bursts? Since starting receiving salaries I am staying within 40+ hours work weeks but it does depress me because indeed my head is not always in the game. I thought about only doing the necessary busywork for some weeks because I want to get difficult projects done that just won’t work out if I’m not full-in. But I get feelings of guilt whenever I do that, and that prohibits recharging.
- oblio 5y ago> If you have no family So that's... maybe 20% of the workforce? > are the sole founder in the company And with this we narrow it down to maybe 1% or less of the workforce. He can be broad because your conditions don't apply to the overwhelming majority of workers. Statistically, your conditions cover an insignificant group.
- bob1029 5y ago"Absolutely no one" and "1%" have entirely different meanings to me. I thought it important to highlight the "insignificant" case (of which I am a member) to avoid some notion that this applies to 100% of people in reality. The way we usually go on about work around here concerns me, and I fear we risk alienating a very energetic and well-meaning segment of the community.
- oblio 5y agoHN comments (and in general, forum comments) are not PhD theses, they're generic, casual comments that in many cases try to tell a story. Hyperbole is to be expected.
- bob1029 5y agoHyperbole or not it has an impact when repeated like some religion. This comment thread is making me not want to participate on hackernews.
- oblio 5y agoI think (I don't know you) that I wouldn't want you to do that, but to each their own. You sound like you're having a bad day outside of HN, as this has been just a regular and might I say, civil, chat, otherwise. A temporary break from HN (or social media in general), might not be a bad idea :-)
- ggm 5y agoAustralia calling: 37.5hr week please. It be law.
- dtn 5y agoIt's law, but it still gets abused quite frequently (outside of tech, at least). Anecdotally speaking, all my mates who work in private construction office jobs regularly do quite a bit of unpaid overtime. It's very much a combined cultural and managerial issue, clocking off at the correct hours gets you the stink-eye, and the volume of work assigned necessitates overtime.
- irrational 5y agoStill way too long.
- nkssy 5y agoI bet you're envious of the typical US 2 weeks vacation allowance.
- yskchu 5y agoOne of the things I love most about Australia (New South Wales at least) is the mandatory 2 months long service leave after 10 years of service https://www.industrialrelations.nsw.gov.au/employers/nsw-employer-essentials/long-service-leave-faq https://www.industrialrelations.nsw.gov.au/employers/nsw-emp...
- reidjs 5y agoI think it makes sense to have people available for regular hours, just so that if I ask someone a question I can expect a response today-ish. But, I agree that a lot of meetings should be emails, teambuilding events are usually poorly done, and procrastination is hard to avoid when you've got access to the internet. Minor nitpick: Is an hour long lunch really that bad?
- agency 5y agoI think the point is not that there’s something wrong with hour long lunches, but that people have to find ways to fill up their day if they’re expected to be “at work” for 8 hours a day and can only be productive for a fraction of that. As a “productive” software engineer, in the sense that I have gotten positive feedback in my career and never had a problem “getting enough done” to satisfy my superiors, it took me a long time to come to terms with the fact that I cannot productively apply myself to work for 40 hours a week. When I have to be in the office for that long, I end up slacking off for hours and hours (like reading HN). I thought for a long time that maybe I was just flying under the radar and I would eventually “get caught” but at this point I’ve made peace with the fact that my productivity comes in bursts and as long as my employer is happy with my output I don’t sweat it too much.
- Akronymus 5y agoOver here lunch time is not part of worktime. Per law we need to have at least half an hour for lunch, but we can take however long (if the company allows). Dunno how it is in other countries. (I am from austria, europe)
- isatty 5y agoWhat’s wrong with an hour long lunch? Isn’t that normal?
- zitterbewegung 5y agoYea, I haven't heard of a job that wouldn't have an hour long lunch. It's a part of labor laws at least in Illinois.
- posguy 5y agoThis appears to be incorrect. Illinois only requires a 20+ minute lunch at or before 5 hours into a shift of 7 and 1/2 hours or more: https://www2.illinois.gov/idol/FAQs/Pages/meals-breaks-faq.aspx https://www2.illinois.gov/idol/FAQs/Pages/meals-breaks-faq.a...
- RikNieu 5y agoNo, you're expected to eat at your desk and type while chewing.
- Svperstar 5y agoNo lie my first job out of college expected you to eat at your desk and not leave for your lunch break.
- mstuyt 5y agoAn insurance company I did some work for had a bell go off for your two coffee breaks and lunchtime. You spent half of your lunchtime waiting for elevators.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoWhaaaat? What year, country, and/or location was this? Call center?
- xwdv 5y agoIndeed, there’s a sort of Moneyball aspect here. Companies that can accurately pay out only for productive time instead of assuming all 40 hours of a work week are spent producing will make huge savings in payroll, increasing cost efficiency and making it feasible to hire larger cross functional teams. A software engineer probably only really works about 20 hours a week. That’s a 50% savings right there.
- tapvt 5y agoWhat’s the definition of “really working?” I once told a freelance client (hourly) that I solved most of the tough problems while I thought about things in the shower. On that project, very little of my time was spent coding. Client then said I ought to pad my hours by 5 per week. He “got it.” If simply “coding” is what constitutes “really working,” that seems problematic.
- ddoolin 5y agoThey're not assuming/under the impression that all 40 hours are spent working. This wouldn't work because this type of tacit admission works for everyone when they need it, even if that happens to be continuously.
- arvinsim 5y agoI would take a paycut to have much less work hours. Could be a win-win but maybe a lot of people prefer to earn more.
- whateveracct 5y agoYou can't actually enforce that. The standard is salaried, at-will employment. The savvy, skilled remote worker is going to be able to put 20-30 hours in - literally just take off 1-2 days a week. But get paid for the "40hrs." Basically, the rules of the game mean a salaried, remote employee can easily work half time at full pay - gg
- opportune 5y agoWhy would any software engineer take an equivalent paying job that micromanages their every minute to make sure the company gets a full 40 hrs out of them, unless the pay were much better than what they'd get otherwise (eating in to that 50%) or they were desperate? This would be a huge mis-optimization IMO. Good luck attracting "top" workers and retaining them with this model. It's just "butts in seats" taken to an extreme.
- AussieWog93 5y agoIt's not just tech, it's office jobs in general. People doing 40 hours of actual, necessary work in that environment are the exception.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y ago> Companies that shuffle things up to prioritize productivity over simply showing up will be set to succeed over the next generation. I tend to disagree, but don't argue either way for four or five day weeks, but because it seems success and productivity are only loosely coupled. Company financial success, and / or long term viability, I believe, is largely random. Large, already successful companies will, largely, continue to be so, small to medium enterprises will survive the next five years at about the same rate they historically have. Small business will continue to fail all over the place. People will continue to be super intelligent, flawed and incompetent, easily distracted, lack focus, and easily corrupted by power and vice. And start ups, to anyone who's been paying attention, is almost entirely a branch of gambling for a specific type of whale. I predict that on the whole the next decade will be largely like the last ten years, and there's approximately nothing to be gained from chasing tiny productivity gains.
- arvinsim 5y agoAt least WFH would be normalized which is a big win
- alexashka 5y agoI wonder if it's also an open secret that 99% of office jobs today are typewriter jobs of a few decades ago - soon to be gone. Good riddance if people with a working brain were given any power, we'd all be at 2-3 hours of work per day with robots doing the rest by now.
- irrational 5y agoI work at a company where it is encouraged to use the fitness facilities during work hours. 15 minutes walking to one of the gyms, 5 minutes changing, an hour working out, 10 minutes in the sauna, 10 minute shower, 5 minutes getting dressed, 15 minutes walking back. That is 2 hours of my work day right there ;-)
- tartoran 5y agoThey are smart, the employees are likely to be more productive if they are healthy. Many companies squeeze up employees like tubes of toothpaste then discard them and hire a younger gen. It is sometimes not intentional, just create a stresful environment and dont allow enough time to employees to catch their breath so to speak
- tapland 5y agoI felt pretty wrecked when I, mostly because of lack of affordable housing, moved to a team in a location near my home town, and found out every single employee aged <35 had ended up on sick leave. Didn't have any choise but I wish I could have just gotten out of there as fast as I ended up in it.
- 6f8986c3 5y agoWhy? It'd be helpful to get some idea what workplace factors led to such a negative outcome.
- 8note 5y agoThinking is work too, and you can think from anywhere
- anitil 5y agoThat sounds marvelous! I'm looking at a job at the moment that is mostly WFH and working out during the day is something I'm looking forward to most of all.
- 5y ago
- nixpulvis 5y agoI wonder if this is related to the fact that my computer seems to have more bugs in it than a hive of angry bees.
- justicezyx 5y agoI spend 2-3 hours working, and 3-4 hours commuting, and other time in staring each other and rumbling in some meeting, and have a rather relaxed lunch with friends talking nonsense... This was when I was in Google
- flexie 5y agoI work as a lawyer. When I do brain work such as research, contracts or court meetings, I believe 3-4 hours a day is the max I do continuously. If I have more phone calls, client meetings etc., it's easier to do the 8 hours.
- ryanSrich 5y agoWe did this at my new company. One 30 minute scheduled standup. That’s the only meeting we have all week. Of course people are free to jump on a video call to work through stuff, but scheduled meetings are generally discouraged, and to date we only have the one. Since everyone is contract, we’re seeing an average of about 26 hours per week. It’s by far the most productive team I’ve ever been on or have built. We ship new features weekly. It’s truly an incredible pace, but doesn’t feel hectic like you might think. I think the contract only + no meetings + no HR (no culture bullshit, no “get to know people” social events, no bullshit) company setup is going to be the future. If you give people the opportunity to work on things they like working on, and don’t make work about anything other than work, you get amazing results.
- throwaway1777 5y agoWhy is contract important to this?
- danielheath 5y agoI think it’s a confusing way to say “hourly and work as many or few hours as they feel like”.
- ryanSrich 5y agoAt this point is mostly a filtering mechanism for me. The types of people that want contract are typically more used to (and want) an environment without the HR bullshit. Some, not all, but certainly some people use work as their only form of social life and interaction. Which leads to a lot of time not working. I’m not saying this is inherently bad. It’s just not the type of company we’re building. Filtering for contract work has taken care of this so far. Will continue to evaluate as we scale up.
- achow 5y agoContract means no perf eval, no 'culture' events participation, no leadership trainings etc., what OP classified as HR bullshit (true).
- mjcohen 5y ago
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> It's an open secret at least in the tech world that absolutely no one is putting in a productive 40 hours of work a week. Is this true only in the US? What percentage of companies is this true for? How many jobs will tolerate this reality?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoIt is an open secret that people who are productive only 2/3 of the time in 40 hours/week would be productive only 2/3 of the time in 32 hours/week as well.
- Arcanum-XIII 5y agoThat's patently untrue: most of my colleague working 3 or 4 days a week are more focused their days in. The invert is true though: a task will evolve to take the time alloted to it, I see that regularly with "unconstrained" project running amok. Those with fixed time are way more efficient and finish with a minimum of overtime.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoEvery lazy slacker tells this same old story. I believe that most IT professionals don't even know what it means to work really hard. Oh, I worked producing lines of code 4 hours today, of which 25 minutes were spent compiling. I am sooo tired, my job is so difficult, it is the hardest job in the world, I need a rest and a 2 days work week!.
- rainonmoon 5y agoI hear what you're saying, but anecdotally I just cut my days back and find myself a lot more energised and engaged when actually at work. I haven't really compared my degree of output yet, but I can at least say I'm a lot more emotionally invested in the results of my work and my job satisfaction is higher. One's mileage may vary.
- formatjam 5y agomeanwhile, China is doing 996 - 9am to 9pm, 6 days a week. Obviously people hated it. But it is happening and no wonder China tech is catching up fast / winning in some areas already.
- refactor_master 5y agoFrom my experience with Chinese working culture, half of that time is most definitely spent not working. I’d bet the factors are much more political in nature than productivity on the individual level.
- Kalleklovn 5y agoIt is normal for Chinese to sleep/take a nap by the desk during the day.. Pretty sure they are catching up because of other reasons than being most of their waking hours at work..
- CountDrewku 5y agoWinning what? A totalitarian government where the people are all treated like shit? They may be winning the GDP game but that's not translating to any improvements for their citizens or the world. The only people winning in China are the people at the top of the communist party.
- kwere 5y agoor maybe they are faking their gdp numbers with reckless real estate ponzi schemes
- GordonS 5y agoAs someone who has worked in a dev office in Beijing for a bit - no. Devs routinely took up to 2 hours for lunch breaks, and took numerous breaks in a day. I didn't blame them, mind, because the reason was obvious - for most people, it's just not possible to be completely engaged and invested for 12 hours a day, 6 days a week, forever. I'd estimate there was about 4-5 hours a day of properly productive work going on.
- eunos 5y agowhat's wrong with hour long lunches?
- bsder 5y ago> It's an open secret at least in the tech world that absolutely no one is putting in a productive 40 hours of work a week. Be grateful for your privilege. Most employees aren't tech. The workers at companies that schlep things around are working a real, non-stop 8 hours. This is why Amazon warehouse jobs are so shitty. Teachers are pretty much non-stop as well. This is why so many of them have medical issues with their bladders. The vast majority of workers are in positions that really do put in 40 hours of hard work a week--and they don't get paid anywhere near as much as tech.
- blindmute 5y agoYep, I've had full time six figure jobs where I was literally working 5 hours per week including meetings. I've never had a job where I worked more than 20 hours a week, including a hectic 7-employee startup.
- toomanybeersies 5y ago> hour long lunches Are one hour lunches not the norm? I've always worked 0900-1730, with an hour long lunch.
- GhostVII 5y agoI feel like I generally am reasonably productive for 40 hours. Of course I'm not constantly super focused, but if I were to work fewer hours I would get less done. Every once in a while you have a meeting that isn't totally necessary, but reducing working hours wouldn't get rid of those.
- tothecore13423 5y agoYou are subtly implying incorrectly that people are working lesser number of hours while working from home. This is farther from the truth. If anything all the time saved in commute is spent in coding