12 ms·
My biggest mistake, that I made again and again, was not leaving a job when it was time. I thought I had something to prove, but there was never any point to it
by ncmncm 5y ago
My biggest mistake, that I made again and again, was not leaving a job when it was time. I thought I had something to prove, but there was never any point to it. You don't owe anything to an employer. You can't prove anything to an employer. They have absolutely no loyalty to you, and care less than nothing about what is right or wrong, wise or foolish.
So: If you ever think things might not turn out as well as you hoped, move on. There is so much else going on in the world that is at least as interesting as what you are doing, where you have a much better chance of making a difference, that spending time on things that you might not end up proud of is a terrible waste of your short time on Earth.
- logicchop 5y agoI agree, but just a note: it doesn't do your career any good to hop a lot. I won't hire someone that looks flaky. If you find yourself at a bad job, sure, move on. But work on sussing out the good from the bad so you don't put yourself in a bad situation repeatedly.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoLast I checked, nearly everyone in tech hops jobs frequently. In fact that’s common advice for comp advancement. In my personal experience that advice holds true, even though I change jobs much less frequently than most of my peers (which means my comp tends to lag behind theirs).
- smitty1e 5y agoWhat is "frequently"? I'd like to see a minimum of three years ahead of a transition, and a decent story why. Often the contract ends, the company is sold and the new policies are draconian, etc. Fine. Given the level of effort involved in bringing someone on, my outfit cannot afford to be staffed like a fast food joint.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoFrom memory: last I heard the average is 18 months. I don’t know if that was accurate then or still is, nor how much it varies regionally or by any other criteria (I can look it up later but had a quick moment to reply and HN moves fast and might fill in the gap before I can take more time to look).
- beckingz 5y agoWhat is an acceptable duration for someone to stay at your outfit?
- smitty1e 5y agoPlenty of career people at this consultancy. Also transplants. I just passed 5 years.
- hdhjebebeb 5y agoConsulting is a little unique in my experience - if there's a steady stream of work, you never really stick with the same client full time for the full 5 years. It's a lot easier to keep your skills fresh and move around to find interesting challenges
- alchemism 5y agoDoes your employer offer its people the 10-20% annual salary increase so they do not have to look elsewhere for what the market is willing to provide? I ask this seriously.
- smitty1e 5y agoNo, that sounds a bit excessive. If you're growing the business at a healthy clip, maybe those sorts of raises are sustainable.
- barrkel 5y agoI've refused to hire people who job-hopped every year or two. With a record like that, there's zero reason to expect they're going to stick around. Why invest in bringing them up to speed if they're just going to leave?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoWell, I think other people hire them because there’s high demand for talent and that kind of churn is expected. If you’re not having difficulty hiring while rejecting those candidates, that suggests you’re probably attracting people like me who stick around longer (for better or worse all around) or something about your offer is appealing to talent who have a knack for finding good long term opportunities.
- inopinatus 5y agoBecause maybe they’re just looking for the right environment, and maybe you’re it. Hiring is like dating, after all. This reads instead like an egregious case of the fundamental attribution error, and one that’d I’d view as quite the blunder by my management team, since the real consequence is limiting our access to the talent pool. Even aside from the FAE, this kind of attitude also systematically reinforces structural discrimination within an industry, since candidates from unusual or unprivileged backgrounds are less likely to have been offered major career opportunities, or been obliged to juggle many life priorities along the way, and thereby more likely to have taken whatever they could get, or could realistically manage. Yet these can be some of the most interesting hires, thanks to their diverse/alternative perspectives, and may also be top-tier outliers when it comes to resilience, self-management, and self-directed learning. It’s also a failure of values since there’s an underlying assumption that people are interchangeable widgets, which is both false and dehumanising. For my own account, I hopped a lot in my early career before finding places where I felt I could belong and stay for years, and this pattern has repeated. So you’d likely have taken a pass on me whilst I went on to become senior this and principal that elsewhere, en route to starting my own firm. Go figure.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Hiring is like dating, after all. Past behavior is a pretty good predictor of future behavior. If you're dating someone whose previous 3 spouses died in mysterious kiln explosions, I'd stay away from the ceramics factory.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIn my experience, it is hard to tell the difference between someone who killed it at a job for 1 year and moved on from someone who couldn't hack it and moved on. Promotion at a company signifies that they were well received and able to adapt and meet milestones. Same job title in and out reads to me to believe that they couldn't hack it and were no goes development opportunity. IMHO, a promotion before you leave confer s legitamacy to your tenure.
- HaNeThrowAway 5y agoWhat if there are no promotions to be had? My longest tenure at any one company was 8 years and I never got promoted because it was all remote and I was technically an independent contractor. No one got promoted.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI am not saying it is a perfect system, but that would a red flag for a full time employee.
- mylons 5y agook boomer. i’ve been on interview panels at several companies due to hopping. someone on the panel will mention it, someone else who wants to hire them will say it’s not a big deal and go from there.
- ddelt 5y agoI’m sorry but I very much disagree. Each hop netted me much better work-life balance and much higher pay, and actually broadened my horizons and whag I bring to the table because I have experienced a wide array of corporate cultures and team styles. What DOESN’T do wonders for your career is thinking/hoping/praying that sticking it out at a subpar company year after year will magically bring you those same benefits, if it’s not already happening and you’ve already asked politely for it to be resolved.
- oldspleen 5y ago> They have absolutely no loyalty to you, and care less than nothing about what is right or wrong, wise or foolish. This is why one should choose opportunity over loyalty -- have no loyalty to location or corporation. Be an absolute opportunist, doing whatever is best for future in the current situation, unbound by the past.
- warmcat 5y agoI really love your comment. Too few people realize this.
- TX0098812 5y agoThis is largely true but I know there are employers who do care and who are loyal to their employees. It's all a matter of people and who you are dealing with.
- kqr 5y agoThat's my experience too. As a junior, however, I couldn't tell good employers from bad so I tended to pick bad ones (they vastly outnumber the good ones, after all) and then stay with them for far too long. I mean, I value continuity and a healthy long-term relationship with a reciprocating organisation more than most, but the first few years I spent at a crap shop for crap pay and with only fear of my superiors motivating me? I think I could have gotten the same experience but better in a few other places I've been since. (On the other hand, maybe that first experience is what made me so picky in selection of employers after that?)
- Popegaf 5y agoThe problem is where to find these companies. Job review sites are either turfed by companies who tell their employees to leave a good review, or by disgruntled leavers who want to unload.
- faitswulff 5y agoCounterpoint: I consistently leave jobs too early when I could have instead stuck around and made larger impacts during restructurings or just sat around and done nothing and gotten paid. Would I be better programmer? Who knows ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ But would I have gotten paid and had a more intact career? Certainly.
- mailshanx 5y agoWhat do you mean by having an "intact career"? Did leaving too early harm your career, and if yes, how so?
- justrudd 5y agoDepends on the company you’re interviewing with and (IME) region you’re looking for work. In my 26 years since graduating university, I’ve had 13 jobs. So an average of 1.8 years per job. My longest was 6 years at Amazon (ironically enough considering they have such a high turnover) and my shortest was 3 weeks (I knew during the interview it wasn’t a good fit, but I was young and they threw a stupid amount of money at me). Where I am now (Seattle area), it isn’t really seen as a that big of a red flag. I always had good reasons for leaving. Other than 2, I’ve tried to never burn bridges intentionally and was even a rebound employee at 1 place (never tell HR during your exit interview what you really think of them). I grew up in the South and moved back there for a brief period of time. It was very hard to find work down there because they called me a “job hopper” (which I was/am). I was asked several times “You’re going to give me a year and then be gone. Why should I hire you?”. Never had a good answer when I was in my 30s. Now that I’m in my 40s, I have a pretty good one. That’s been my experience. I’m at a place now where I can see myself staying for awhile. I’m not curing cancer or doing machine learning or scaling things to gagillion requests per second. But I like the people, like my boss, and the problems are meaty enough to engage me during the day, but not so complicate that I work on them in my off hours.
- pedrosorio 5y ago> “You’re going to give me a year and then be gone. Why should I hire you?”. Never had a good answer when I was in my 30s. Now that I’m in my 40s, I have a pretty good one. What's the answer?
- m463 5y agoEvery time I've left a job, I've been uncertain and conflicted. every. time. Then, after being in the new job for a short while, I thought, "wow! I should have done this sooner!" Related, I remember a friend telling me a story. It wasn't so much about leaving, but how to leave. She was in a job that was just a mess. Finally one day during a spectacle of mismanagement, she just quit in disgust. She said it was a mistake. If she could have done it again, she would have just shut up, quietly gotten a job, and quit in a stable, predictable way.
- wincy 5y agoI was inexperienced and moved from one job to another and it was absolutely AWFUL. I feel like I got fed a load of bullshit that I believed and left within 2 months. The first place I worked was great, and the second and third place I worked were churn and burn code monkey houses that were absolutely awful. My fourth software job was (is) great, though, and better than the first one.
- giantandroids 5y agoYep, never ever quit with a list of what you did not like. You gain nothing from it.
- emptysongglass 5y agoI don't know about this one. Sometimes it's important to take a principled stand. I was at a stocks company for all of two weeks, hired by a former friend. The very first day I was told not to email the security team directly and that all my emails from then on must be approved by my team lead. Within a week, I was told to lie to the security team. I spent most of those two weeks either in meetings or as a glorified page. I really felt abused, devalued, and a tool for the shitty ethics of the corporation. So one day I pull my team lead and the other lead into a Zoom meet and unload and quit. I get myself on LinkedIn, canvas a few available jobs and within two weeks get a new job. In the interviews I made it crystal clear that I valued transparency and that I would not be forced to lie to anyone. Turns out that's one of their cultural pillars (transparency is an entire slide in their slide deck). I have a manager I can honestly engage with. He knows what happened at the last company and he values that I spoke up. These principled stands are not for nothing. We have to be able to believe in our own ability to have a social impact, however small. Shutting up and inoffensively walking away just buttresses shitty people (or shitty corporations, which are just egregores that have been hijacked by shitty people).
- logifail 5y ago> My biggest mistake, that I made again and again, was not leaving a job when it was time This. My OH's currently moving jobs and we have been discussing how overdue this move is. Somehow once you make the decision to leave it brings all the blur of past injustices/lunacy* into proper focus. The last time I left somewhere, after a fairly long relationship, they went into insolvency proceedings within a year** * For my OH's move: her old lot couldn't even get the announcement of her departure right - it was announced by accident by a senior manager on a conference call, two weeks before she'd even seen, never mind signed the new contract, or given notice ... <rolls eyes> ** not my fault, honest
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ian-g 5y agoI'd just like to say, sometimes moving on is within your company. If you're somewhere that's good about letting folks try out different parts of the business, it can be good to stay. Make a career change and get a new set of folks around you without having to leave everything behind
- anovikov 5y agoI can only second it so many times!! I can't say i made SO many mistakes in my career, but i have left my then utterly dead-end first job too late, in 2007 while things were abundantly clear about it by 2005 already and i wasted two extremely frustrating years trying to keep it afloat. Lives of everyone who stayed were ever more destroyed than mine was. I was young, and was making more than literally every single person i knew, i bought an apartment in a year in cash. I thought it was once-in-a-lifetime job which will never happen to me again.
- axegon_ 5y agoSeems this is more common than I anticipated. That said, I've only done that at my first job, not so much because I felt like I owed my employer anything but because it was my first full time job as a developer so I questioned every descision.
- GlennS 5y agoI made this mistake once in my first proper job. It took me 2.5 years to leave a place where I was really unhappy. So, move on from bad jobs, move on from meh jobs, and be quick about it. Eventually you'll find somewhere you enjoy and you can stick around for a while.
- ljf 5y agoThis. Your working career is actually pretty short - for many of us in tech each year is at least 2 percent of your total working life. And hit 40 and it might be 5 percent a year. Do you really want to waste 5 percent of your working life/opportunities/salary doing a job you hate?
- ttonkytonk 5y agoSomewhat similarly, I took a job I had a bad feeling about (I was in my early 30's) and things worked out accordingly. Basically taking jobs I knew I wasn't a good fit for because I needed them.
- crucialfelix 5y agoI got a good client and he kept giving me more work. 15 years later it was the only thing I could list on my resume. More variety also means experiences and learning.
- gofreddygo 5y agoI've adapted my mindset to think of my job/role as a car lease . Expires in 3 years. I don't get too comfortable, not too attached, tend to live in the moment, enjoy the good parts, ignore the bad ones, think of the next person in my role, stay on the lookout for my next job/role, but not overdo it. I've been able to stick to this, but haven't come up with a ways to enforce it.
- dave_sid 5y agoBrilliantly put