10 ms·
Newly discovered Vigilante malware outs software pirates and blocks them
- caslon 5y agoIs there a prediction market going for whether the MPAA is eventually found to be behind this?
- tyingq 5y ago"When viewed through a hex editor, the executables also contain a racial epithet that’s repeated more than 1,000 times followed by a large, randomly sized block of alphabetical characters." Seems like it wouldn't be a good look for them if so.
- caslon 5y agoHas the MPAA ever been particularly prone to acting ethically? Throwing in some slurs to throw people off their trail seems very much like something they would do. The MPAA itself has been accused of copyright infringement on multiple occasions. In 2007, the creator of a blogging platform called Forest Blog accused the MPAA of violating the license for the platform, which required that users link back to the Forest Blog website. The MPAA had used the platform for its own blog, but without linking back to the Forest Blog website. The MPAA subsequently took the blog offline, and explained that the software had been used on a test basis and the blog had never been publicized.[121][122] Also in 2007, the MPAA released a software toolkit for universities to help identify cases of file sharing on campus. The software used parts of the Ubuntu Linux distribution, released under the General Public License, which stipulates that the source code of any projects using the distribution be made available to third parties. The source code for the MPAA's toolkit, however, was not made available. When the MPAA was made aware of the violation, the software toolkit was removed from their website.[123] In 2006, the MPAA admitted having made illegal copies of This Film Is Not Yet Rated (a documentary exploring the MPAA itself and the history of its rating system)[124] — an act which Ars Technica explicitly described as hypocrisy[125] and which Roger Ebert called "rich irony".[126]
- opheliate 5y agoCould also be a rival torrent site? I haven’t seen the full altered hosts file, but from the screenshots it would appear only TPB/proxies are listed. I can see a lot of people finding that they can’t access TPB and thinking, oh, I’ll use (e.g:) 1337x instead.
- incompatible 5y agoThey are more interested in movies, I think.
- vsareto 5y agolmfao. Imagine being good enough to code malware that does this and wasting your efforts on something like this. Look, if you have skills like these, you're special. Don't fucking waste it on building malware for corporate asshats.
- tyingq 5y agoIt doesn't sound like particulary clever malware to me. It sends a filename to some logging service, then opens the windows hosts file and adds some lines to it. And it's only run because the downloader thinks it's some pirated software or keygen. Not to say there aren't some folks wasting time on more clever malware.
- rsgrn 5y agoSo if you have these skills or interests, what should you do with them?
- vsareto 5y agoBlue team at companies Red team at pentest companies Law enforcement Just about any level of effort will be better spent than going after software pirates, even if you end up only doing entry level jobs. Throw a dart blindfolded and you'll probably end up better than this.
- anoncow 5y agoBetter that they sell their souls to corporates the usual way.
- rozab 5y ago>Padding it out with racist slurs told me all I needed to know about its creator. Clearly that is the intent. These companies have no shame. Remember Sony's response to their rootkit being discovered? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_roo...
- azinman2 5y agoI’m not seeing the connection between Sony and racial slurs. In fact, especially without knowing what racial slur this is, it tells me very little about the creators intent.
- DangitBobby 5y agoThey are saying the slurs could be intended to throw you off of the corporate scent and should be discarded as any evidence one way or the other who commissioned the creation.
- tedunangst 5y agoIt seems like most people are saying that all evidence found and all evidence not found should be interpreted to prove Sony or the MPAA or whoever is responsible. Evidence they didn't is fake and proof they did. Absence of evidence is proof of a coverup.
- edgyquant 5y agoSounds like your typical conspiracy theory.
- squiggleblaz 5y agoThat isn't the claim. The claim is the inclusion of a racial slur doesn't tell us anything. Instinctively, when I read it, I thought, "Oh, this is written by a independent vigilante, not by stakeholder". But other commenters are right. It is compatible with being written by an independent vigilante, and it is compatible with being written by or on behalf of stakeholders. I will withhold conclusion until further evidence is tendered.
- anoncow 5y agoAre people still pirating software? Apart from kids trying out software, people from countries where the product is not officially available or is exhorbitantly priced as compared to their purchasing power, I doubt there is a reason to pirate. Most tools have alternatives available or an easy on the pocket subscription plan (Adobe is an exception, subscription plans should not come with a lock-in, no matter how you justify it).
- underseacables 5y agoAdobe products are really the only software I advocate pirating. There’s a lot of great software out there and we should pay for it, but some companies have just turned to greed and screwing over customers.
- hyperman1 5y agoPirating Adobe tools = training people in their usage. Their job will then pay for Adobe, as they already know it. If you want to hurt Adobe, advocate not pirating them and point users to alternatives
- zamadatix 5y agoMost people aren't interested in enacting karmic justice when they pirate Adobe software for personal reasons they just want to have access to the best in class software while avoiding the relatively high cost for something that isn't generating their paycheck at the time.
- hyperman1 5y agoCorrect. Piracy results in a market dynamic where even a strong second player can't win from the market leader, and pushes software markets to monopolies. Companies like MS and Adobe know this. They have to perform regular anti pitacy charades, but they vastly prefer someone pirating -a potential future buy- to someone buying an alternative - an actual lost sale. Same dynamic in hollywood: Pirating a film is vastly better for them than finding alternative hobbies and not buying the series merchandise.
- underseacables 5y agoThe main take away I get from this is ..a list of torrent sites.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoAll of them are honeypots nowadays though
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoIts bamboozling that in this new age of 'deplatforming', that video and game entertainment companies have not pushed ISPs, nations, or tech companies harder to deplatform torrent sites. It would yield pretty major benefits for minor effort. Its also strange that people are willing to spend $thousands on a gaming PC, and then risk their entire device to malware just to save a couple bucks on games.
- chucka9 5y agoSaving money is not the only reason to pirate content. Some things aren’t available in my region and never will be (as they are 20+ years old). Some things are presented via a crap app, in dubious formats or with truely horrible DRM. I pirate plenty of shows that I have legal access to or own.
- pftburger 5y agoThe way I see it piracy is mostly a UX problem. Often the UX of pirating a thing is easier than legally acquiring it. Maybe not true for AAA games, but def true for most movies/series. If your outside of the US, often a lot of content isn’t even available because of shitty geo licensing
- andrewzah 5y ago> If your outside of the US, often a lot of content isn’t even available because of shitty geo licensing This is one case where I understand people pirating. I watch some shows from other countries that simply are not published in the US or aren't for sale at all. And sometimes if they are available, certain elements are changed due to copyright reasons so it's not exactly the same. Another reason would be horrible DRM. Again, I wouldn't recommend pirating based on that, but I do understand it. Pirated content doesn't have DRM dictating when, where, or what time(s) I can view the damn thing I paid money for. I also find it fine if someone buys a DRM-locked product, then pirates the same thing to avoid dealing with the DRM.
- Jimmc414 5y agoThe irony is that by adding these 82 pirate sites to the hosts file and having this action publicized, the malware writers are inadvertently promoting a list of 82 sites where users can download pirated software. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- eric__cartman 5y agoI would take that as a list of 82 sites to avoid when looking for pirated software.
- judge2020 5y agoIt's mainly a list of pirate bay sites and proxies. Why would their inclusion in this blocklist be a reason to avoid them?
- akiselev 5y agoThat list of URLs is the torrent tracker equivalent of blog spam. It contains none of the big private trackers that are trivial to join or the big public ones like rutracker or rarbg There's an entire wikipedia article listing them! [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_BitTorrent_sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_BitTorrent_sites
- jchristian- 5y agoAnyone has the list of sites blocked by Vigilante? For research purposes.
- f6v 5y agoCalling it "Vigilante" is a stretch.
- muttled 5y agoYou're right. Since it's more just running a script, I think we should call the creator "batchman".
- afrcnc 5y agoThese reports are so misleading. This is junk malware uploaded on VirusTotal, not something seen in the wild.
- chayleaf 5y agoMy friend did catch it (or a similar virus), so it can be seen in the wild indeed No it's not me, I don't even play games that much
- bserge 5y agoI am against piracy on principle. All of my employers know how hard I work to protect their IP.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWhat principle might that be?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bserge 5y agoIP is incredibly important and we must all protect it at all cost. My wage and health are nothing compared to the employers' properties and wealth. I would die for them.
- andrewzah 5y agoThen don't buy media. But don't pirate it either. Media takes money and lots of man-hours of people working in order to produce things. They, too, need to get paid, regardless of whatever principles you hold personally. edit: kindly stop shadow-editing comments. Your comment is completely different now from the one that I replied to.
- slim 5y agoIt seems this person will be happy if the whole entertainement industry disappeared
- bserge 5y agoIn the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and been widely regarded as a bad move.
- bserge 5y agoIndeed, the media companies deserve their money. The artists should be grateful for the opportunity to become famous even if they don't make that much money and we should all pay to see the same Marvel movie rewritten 10 times. Nothing better exists in this world.
- zahrc 5y agoI’ve been sailing the high seas of illegal downloading since I can remember. Back in the days simply because I couldn’t afford it or wasn’t allowed to buy it. Nowadays it’s only TV shows. Anyway, writing something to a HOST file is not that incredible… regarding the motive, that might as well be a troll, or an attempt to drive traffic to private trackers.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWhen developers complain about the walled garden, something that they often forget to factor in is how hard piracy is on iOS and other locked down devices. If iOS was open, how much of a revenue drop would developers receive? I don’t know what it is, but it is not like the devs are going to get 25% more money by bypassing Apple’s commission. If you open the iPhone, yay, you don’t pay the Apple tax, but now you’ve got piracy that wasn’t there. You replaced Apple tax with Pirate tax. For the record, I still support unlocking iPhones and other such devices. I’m just in doubt that removing Apple 30% cut = 25% more money after credit card fees. Maybe 5-10% more money if any? If I was a smaller developer making less than a million a year and only paying the 15% commission (or 10% after credit cards) I might find myself wanting Epic and other unlock attempts to fail, for fear the pirates will be worse than Apple’s cut.
- slim 5y agoApple is grooming high value consumers. If your product targets those consumers, piracy does not matter, because they are well behaved carefully selected to buy your product at a price point that makes your product profitable even with the apple cut. It's the living proof that you can pay for your product and still be the product and be happy about it.
- enraged_camel 5y agoI think this analysis is fairly shallow. A lot of people pirate things not because they cannot afford the actual thing, but because they can. Furthermore, over the years the percentage of paid apps on the App Store has decreased. What this means is that the opposite of what you claim is true: iOS users have been trained to prefer free things.
- ayewo 5y ago> Furthermore, over the years the percentage of paid apps on the App Store has decreased. What this means is that the opposite of what you claim is true: iOS users have been trained to prefer free things. I'm not so sure that it is as clear-cut as you describe. Over the same time period, the total number of free and paid apps on the App Store has increased. To arrive at a reasonable understanding of the effects of free apps, we will need to plot the ratio of paid-to-free apps to see if the ratio has been steadily declining, has stayed roughly the same, or has been increasing, on a year-to-year basis.
- michaelmrose 5y agoSeems like it would be a fun project to find the culprit and see if they can be prosecuted unlike most of the people downloading such files considering only their actions are in fact criminal vs civil.
- surround 5y agoWindows by default prevents programs from editing the hosts file, but... > Many people who routinely download stuff like add-ons or mods to games this get advice to turn off their antivirus or endpoint protection, gamers are susceptible to this kind of deception. When the malware ran, it looks like it just crashed with an error dialog. https://twitter.com/threatresearch/status/1405572557093412867 https://twitter.com/threatresearch/status/140557255709341286...
- ineedasername 5y agoI bet if it was written by a company with lots of IP that gets pirated that no CFAA criminal action would be brought against them.
- js8 5y agoI think pirating is like cheating in relationships. The society should discourage it, but to criminalize it is much worse than just to let it happen. Yes, the solution is possibly not stable or consistent, yet adhering to either side of consistent moral principles is arguably worse. Many people do both, sometimes in a weird, selective way. I know I do, I pirate a lot, yet if I really care about something (or it's harder to obtain, which is kind of equalizing authors' profits), I will buy it.
- uncoder0 5y agoI pirate things that have oppressive DRM that makes people who purchase the software have to jump through unnecessary hoops. I've had 3,000 dollar software not work when I needed it because some license server was down somewhere.
- himinlomax 5y agoBecause of movie piracy, Hollywood is currently a deserted wasteland. And because of video game piracy, nobody makes any of those any more. Also I heard Google is not giving Microsoft any money for their operating systems. Wait, only the last one is true. It's almost as if intellectual schmoperty violations is not a real problem.
- mr_toad 5y agoThat’s an interesting analogy. Legally, copyright infringement is treated much the same as trespassing on property. And in societies that viewed wives as property they did make it a criminal offence.
- guilhas 5y agoVigilante helping the big corporation profits in the fight against poor people and just generally annoying The villain we don't want or need
- aaron695 5y agoMagnet here to a sample, I think this will work - magnet:?xt=urn:btih:55c4d5de85b8f4509f3fd99a1d32fc9d59688281 (Malware duh) > “Padding it out with racist slurs told me all I needed to know about its creator.” It was " nigger". I think there's a lot to tell, like it's not a company or a Western agency. Others can look deeper, but maybe there's more to it than blocking pirate sites. That could be a red herring. Stopping people going back to the torrent sites, stops bad reviews and people reading comments. Currently hundreds of new torrents are being created. Many seed dead, I assume to pollute results. One had the padding changed to rubbish instead. Could still be one person (who doesn't like Ali-TPB for instance)