5 ms·
Here's my theory of bubbles: You have an asset (doesn't matter what it is). It's going up because the fundamentals improved, or because favorable press, or wh
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Here's my theory of bubbles:
You have an asset (doesn't matter what it is). It's going up because the fundamentals improved, or because favorable press, or whatever. That's not a bubble. Stuff goes up all the time.
So people start buying it, because it's going up, and they want in on the action. That's still not a bubble. People buy stuff that's going up all the time.
Now there's new money flowing into that asset. So now the price goes up because of the new money flowing in, and the new money was flowing in because the price was going up. Now it's a bubble. But it's not dangerous yet. People can lose their shirts, but it won't hurt the overall economy.
It becomes a dangerous bubble when (lots of) people invest in the asset with borrowed money. Now if it crashes, it can take banks with it. If that happens at a large enough scale, you damage the economy as a whole.
- mandelbrotwurst 5y agoIf the government deems all banks “too big to fail”, does that remove the risk?
- pxue 5y agono. because bank going bankrupt doesn't wipe away YOUR debt. it wipes away banks obligation to the governing body. also micro-lending will be as big in west as it's in China in the next decade. borrowing 10k to margin trade the stock market is inherently more risky than borrowing 10M for a mortgage.
- Nursie 5y agoHardly, it may (or may not) help to mitigate the fallout though.
- l33tbro 5y agoIf only. The debt becomes worn as inflation and higher taxes.
- asimjalis 5y agoIt makes things worse because the banks now have an incentive to engage in riskier behavior. Their downside is covered by the government and their upside is payoff. So reckless behavior becomes a nobrainer.
- api 5y agoI think a naturally occurring Ponzi scheme is the simplest and best definition of a bubble.
- taneq 5y agoI like the idea of calling market bubbles "wild Ponzis".
- throwaway803453 5y agoThis definition is not the best since at the very least it missed that a Ponzi scheme lacks transparency and is fraudulent. PG had one of the best definitions: "a rapid increase in buying based on the expectation of soon selling to a sucker willing to pay more". It's in an old Startup School video and I doubt I am getting his wording correct.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_fool https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_fool
- forgotmysn 5y agowhat's the difference between "People buying stuff that's going up" and "New money flowing in?"
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoNone. "People buying stuff that's going up" is exactly "new money flowing in" to that asset. But I may have left some confusion in my fourth paragraph. It's a bubble when it becomes a self-reinforcing feedback loop. People bought because it's going up, which makes it go up more, so more people buy, so it goes up even more, and so on. I didn't state that clearly enough.
- forgotmysn 5y agoI see, thank you. It sounds like you're saying the provenance of the funds is a key indicator. People buying stuff that's going up because those people closely follow industry or sector news. The people who buy because THOSE people bought are what drive the bubble growth.
- taneq 5y agoThe difference is whether people are buying the stuff that's going up because it's going up or they're buying it because it's good and has intrinsic value beyond what they think the market will pay for it tomorrow.
- asimjalis 5y agoWhy not both?
- nicoburns 5y agoIMO the trouble starts all the way back with "So people start buying it, because it's going up". That's speculation. And it uses up some of the wisdom of the crowd rather than contributing to it.
- solveit 5y ago> "So people start buying it, because it's going up". That's speculation. Mostly but not entirely. It's also previous shorters who buy to manage risk. These people are qualitatively different from the speculators.
- chii 5y agothere's nothing wrong with speculation. But there's something wrong with speculating using other people's money.
- nradov 5y agoThere's nothing wrong with speculating using other people's money as long as you're honest about it. Most mutual funds operate that way.
- lmm 5y agoDo mutual fund investors accept that their money is on the line? As the saying goes, a financial crisis is when someone loses money and it's socially unacceptable for them to not be paid back. So perhaps a bubble is when you speculate with money that it would not be socially acceptable to lose.
- nradov 5y agoYes mutual fund investors accept that their money is on the line. Many mutual funds have negative returns. Your definition of a bubble makes no sense.
- gpsx 5y agoI agree with you. I'll put it another way. Usually if the price of something goes up and becomes too high, fewer people buy and the price drops. That is a stable system. An unstable system is when the price of something goes up, so that causes more people to buy causing the price to go up more. That is an unstable system causing exponential growth, which I'd call a bubble.
- dgb23 5y agoCan even get worse if the borrowed money only exists based on promises in the first place. The tragedy is that that these crashes often increase inequality and concetrate power. The victims are innocent and the perpetrators are not held accountable.
- bsedlm 5y ago> Can even get worse if the borrowed money only exists based on promises in the first place. but isn't this all modern fiat money?
- xwolfi 5y agoI dont know if innocent describes people signing a contract. They can be victims of manipulation but maybe people are less stupid than you give them credit for. Maybe they understood that it was an opportunity to seize, a cheap loan in a bubbling up market, and they decided against carefulness. I face this with bitcoin for instance, trying to stay careful in an exciting rising market. If I stick to fundamentals and what I think I know of past experiments, this makes no sense. If I look at making money in my lifetime, I feel stupid resisting.
- rorykoehler 5y agoEvery single working class/ non-asset wealthy person loses out as their relative net worth decreases with every rescue package.
- dgb23 5y agoI mean people who don’t participate, even cannot, or are convinced to participate by experts. This is the vast majority of affected after a crash. The financial market and its powerful actors have a massive collective responsibility, that they often don’t seem to be aware of. The few that are responsible have been ignored for reasons I cannot otherwise understand but as greed. I speak as an outsider and layman here. I understand that mistakes can be made and that things are very complex and unpredictable. What I have a problem with is that they don’t seem to get accounted for, and certainly not fixed. The criticism of the banking system and financial markets goes way back. It has been discussed and brought to attention by the likes of Adam Smith. But somehow we just keep patching over the symptoms, if at all, rather than question the severed connection between power and responsibility.
- sharker8 5y agoReminds me of a meme about the current state of real estate prices. Which is that because banks became stricter about lending, it's not a bubble this time. The reason it can still be a bubble is that 1) ZIRP and 2) while governments somewhat achieved their mandate of low unemployment, employment stability (not having to constantly job hop to survive) is through the floor. That's why this is a structural megabubble IMO and isn't tracked very well with the proxy of 'how much debt is on individual balance sheets'.
- repsilat 5y ago> ZIRP The naive valuation of a stock that gives it an infinite value at a real 0% interest rate relies on an infinite horizon. Thankfully at least for residential loans it's difficult to get an interest-only mortgage -- in practice deposits and principal payments are binding constraints on valuations. Maybe that changes with corporate landlords becoming more prevalent, though. > employment stability This is interesting: high job turnover is usually seen as a sign of a healthy labour market because it can represent people sorting into jobs they're better suited for. I guess it's a question of what you hold constant: maybe people are changing jobs because jobs are plentiful. If people keep changing when jobs are hard to find things could get dicey.
- fridif 5y agoThe reason I and my colleagues are seemingly changing jobs often is because: 1) newJob pays more than oldJob 2) oldJob is becoming unstable, toxic, and will likely be firing us all in 6 months, so better to leave early and start the clock over In a world where we remain at oldJob til the end, we risk 6 months of that extra pay differential, plus we now have to job hunt while technically not being employed
- repsilat 5y agoI think both points fit the "job market is healthy" description -- (1) explicitly has `newJob`, (2) implicitly assumes `newJob` in its faith in starting over. Conversely, if jobs were scarce it's plausible many of those changes wouldn't happen. Arguable in the case of "toxic" workplaces, though. Bringing this back to shaker8's point about financial risks, I think these kinds of job changes mostly point to systemic resiliency, not fragility.
- bsedlm 5y agoseems like they should restrict the use of debt-based (government emitted credit money) for the purpose stock market speculation. or if they wanna keep the ability to take huge risks, there should be some way to force large financial entities to face the loses when they do risky things and fail as opposed to letting the "market" (i.e. the future taxpayer) pay the bills. at the very least they should cut them off from "new money" (which is government emitted credit=debt-money) until they pay back in whole as opposed to just making even more "money" to dig a deeper hole for the future taxpayer to fill back up. I'm reminded of filling up a hole by digging in other places to fill the original hole without ever realizing that you're actually in the ocean and thus you are just lowering the overall water level.
- nradov 5y agoThere is no separate category of debt-based government emitted credit money. Since we left the gold standard all US dollars have been debt based. That's not a bad thing, it's just how our banking system works. Stock investors are already generally limited to 2× leverage in brokerage accounts.
- bsedlm 5y ago> There is no separate category of debt-based government emitted credit money. maybe there should be
- sooheon 5y agoYou may enjoy this essay, which calls this mechanism "liqudity flywheels": https://lt3000.blogspot.com/2020/07/market-inefficiency-liquidity-flywheels.html https://lt3000.blogspot.com/2020/07/market-inefficiency-liqu... A liquidity flywheel is a situation where inflows into an asset class lead to buying pressure that pushes up prices, leading to favourable apparent return and volatility characteristics in the said asset class. This favourable outcome then attracts yet more inflows, leading to yet more buying, etc. Conversely, poorly performing asset classes with significant downside volatility can lead to investor redemptions, leading to forced selling that contributes to yet further price declines, yielding even worse returns and even greater redemptions, and so on. This process can go on for years, and sometimes even for decades, and is a fundamental contributor - perhaps the most important contributor - to both major asset-class bubbles, as well as asset price busts and secular lows that lead to fire sales prices (which are 'anti-bubbles' driven by the same drivers of bubbles in reverse)
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoGood analysis. It isn’t looking great. https://www.currentmarketvaluation.com/models/buffett-indicator.php https://www.currentmarketvaluation.com/models/buffett-indica...
- rufus_foreman 5y agoHyman Minsky had a concept he called Ponzi financing: "Minsky distinguished between three kinds of financing. The first, which he called “hedge financing”, is the safest: firms rely on their future cashflow to repay all their borrowings. For this to work, they need to have very limited borrowings and healthy profits. The second, speculative financing, is a bit riskier: firms rely on their cashflow to repay the interest on their borrowings but must roll over their debt to repay the principal. This should be manageable as long as the economy functions smoothly, but a downturn could cause distress. The third, Ponzi financing, is the most dangerous. Cashflow covers neither principal nor interest; firms are betting only that the underlying asset will appreciate by enough to cover their liabilities. If that fails to happen, they will be left exposed." -- https://www.economist.com/schools-brief/2016/07/30/minskys-moment https://www.economist.com/schools-brief/2016/07/30/minskys-m... The crash that occurs when people realize that an asset class is not going to keep going up is a "Minsky Moment". His conclusion was that stable growth led people to take on more debt - that stability itself was destabilizing and financial crises are inevitable.