12 ms·
Pacific islanders likely found Antarctica first: study
- pseudolus 5y agoOriginal article - "A short scan of Māori journeys to Antarctica" - published in the Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03036758.2021.1917633?src= https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03036758.2021.1...
- throwawaycuriou 5y agoThanks for the source. Something I'm confused by: this article seems to credit Maoris for discovery of Antarctica long before Europeans, but they didn't arrive in Aotearoa (now-New Zealand) till the 14th century, and the paper claims 7th century contact. Wouldn't that mean their Moriori predecessors made this journey? Do Maoris consider themselves part of Moriori lineage? Edit: looks like my knowledge on this came from old textbooks no longer deemed true. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-M%C4%81ori_settlement_of_New_Zealand_theories https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-M%C4%81ori_settlement_of... Even that aside, isn't the evidence a bit thin? Finding oral records of snow or ice doesn't mean a lot when icebergs pass by Aotearoa all the time.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoThe Moriori are not predecessors to the Maori, but rather more likely an offshoot. Their unique culture was perhaps partly due to the resource poor environment but also partly because mainland Maori culture was undergoing a revolution at the time of the split.
- mc32 5y agoI find it interesting that they call out European male explorers but then go on and talk about Hui Te Rangiora who was male but isn't called out for being male... Also your link is a bit more cautious in their claim saying: "they were likely the first humans to set eyes on Antarctic waters and perhaps the continent" which does not diminish their navigational accomplishments but falls short of the post's title.
- elliekelly 5y agoThe end of the section titled “Māori in the European ages of Antarctic exploration” addresses gender and the lack of records about Māori women who were early antarctic explorers.
- swagasaurus-rex 5y agoSeveral months ago a study came out showing that pacific islanders not only made it to South America 800 years ago, but sailed back to Easter Island and other pacific islands after genetic mixing. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/science/polynesian-ancestry.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/science/polynesian-ancest...
- xwdv 5y agoHard to imagine what motivated them to keep sailing all that way with no guarantee they would find anything.
- ch4s3 5y agoHitting the population limit of your island, and strong cultural norms around exploration.
- Ranebow6 5y agoYou could say that about almost any explorer ever.
- fighterpilot 5y agoBut modern explorers don't expect death if the "nothing" situation comes to pass. These were people that staked their life.
- Ranebow6 5y agoWell modern explorers have the benefit of always knowing that there is a "something", but probably still understand that there is risk in what they are doing. Historically though, plenty of explorers from many different cultures travelled to where there was potentially "nothing". Why would Pacific Island cultures be any different?
- pchristensen 5y agoThey brought food, they captured water from rain and condensation, and they could fish. Yes it was risky but they had a lot of runway due to their expertise on the water.
- totetsu 5y agotangentially, the Scott base redevelopment looks pretty neat. https://www.scottbaseredevelopment.govt.nz/ https://www.scottbaseredevelopment.govt.nz/
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoWhile it may be a possible that the Maori discovered Antarctica hundreds of years before the Europeans, I am not sure the evidence is there for likely. I have seen this pattern too many times. Many times a historian with a point to prove (often in the service of something about their nation) looks at poetic writing/oral tradition, and interpreting them in the best possible light, makes a statement that such as such was in fact known hundreds of years before. Other examples include people who talk about the Bible or the Koran having sayings that allude to quantum physics or modern astronomy. Another example is Nostradamus, where his poetry is fluid enough that any interpretation can be pushed into it after the fact. We should just be very leery when a researcher find what they were wanting to find when using very malleable sources(oral poetry tradition many hundreds of years after the fact).
- jmopp 5y agoThe difference is that there is no way that Biblical or ancient Islamic scholars would have the equipment to study quantum physics or advanced astronomy. It is entirely plausible that Polynesians who settled as far south as the Chatham Islands could sail further south. Granted, with no archaeological evidence, we can't say for sure. A better parallel I think would be the Viking discovery of America. Before we found the archaeological evidence, all we had was the sagas and the medieval reports. It's certainly enough of a lead to warrant looking at the ice with some ground-penetrating radar.
- jeltz 5y agoYes, it is similar but one difference is that the Norse oral histories were written down only 250 years after the events plus that there are a couple of references to later expeditions in the Icelandic chronicle, including a logging expedition to the Americas blown off course. So the Norse contact had really strong support even before the archeological evidence.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis doesn't actually claim they found Antarctica proper, but that they found the Antarctic seas and icebergs. Which is not to diminish the accomplishment (Polynesian navigators were crazy good) but to scope it so it's not discarded as ridiculous (since getting within sight of Antarctica proper is next-level difficult).
- shusaku 5y agoI was thinking about this too, but it doesn’t seem like there’s an island far enough north that it would make much of a practical difference: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Antarctic_and_subantarctic_islands#/media/File%3AAntarctica_and_the_Southern_Ocean.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Antarctic_and_subant...
- dahfizz 5y agoThe study makes mention of potentially spotting icebergs, not islands.
- adictator 5y agoIn the Rāmayana (circa 14000 BCE), while searching for Rāma's wife, queen Seeta, the forest king Sugreeva describes Antarctica in great detail. This is documented in Vālmiki's Ramayana and therefore predates the Pacific islanders mentioned in this study. I am guessing because the description is in Sanskrit most of today's researchers find it inaccessible, but I hope they find translators & arrive at the actual truth, instead of half-truths.
- kilroywashere 5y agook but do they have like... proof? anything beyond old folk tales? an actual landing site or artifacts? no? then they didn't get there first.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ehnto 5y agoYou can't say for certain that they did or did not without evidence in either direction. It's not like it would be unlikely for them to have sailed there, they have far long journeys in their history.
- starik36 5y agoJust as you can't argue that an exquisite set of china is orbiting Jupiter, similarly you can't claim that they reached Antarctica without some proof.
- mkl 5y agoYou can argue that they may have reached Antarctica with evidence, which is exactly what this study does and provides. History and science are primarily built on evidence and levels of uncertainty, not proof.
- mkl 5y agoFinding physical evidence in Antarctica seems extremely unlikely. This study does not claim they got to solid ground, or even that they landed on the ice shelves that surround most of the continent. Similarly there are no artefacts proving that the first explorers to reach the north pole actually did, and there are multiple disputed claims. There is physical evidence of Polynesian exploration and settlement on the Auckland Islands, south of New Zealand's main islands by 465km of open ocean [1], about 20% of the way to Antarctic soil, so it seems very unlikely that they wouldn't have explored further south. The thing is there's not much there, just ocean until you meet the ice around Antarctica, so there isn't likely to ever be any physical evidence. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auckland_Islands#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auckland_Islands#History
- ggm 5y agoI think this is falling into conjecture which is unprovable. It is however, the class of outcome I think should definitely be considered plausible, and possible. But that also admits the plausibility of Phoecians, Romans, reaching the Americas. Could have, but didn't to the best of our knowledge. Because of a culture of glass and metalworking, they're both outcomes we could expect to "prove" by archeological finds. Coastal locations to 100km inland might withstand the timescale, and yield something, but its needle in a haystack time, and the vikings didn't leave very much behind. (a counter example we have higher confidence in, which yields very little structural evidence) I do think pacific/island stone tools would stand the same test, but I can't see how an "edge" to antarctica would sustain preservation of worked tools. If you found them in the continental offshore ooze, that would be amazing. (or for that matter, roman artifacts offshore of the americas) It's fantasy science, but then think about "doggerland" and what is being found in shallow waters between the UK and continental Europe. Maybe when we start manganese nodule mining by robot, we're going to turn up the equivalent of roman coke tins, phoecian pencil stubs and Islander burger-wraps?
- trhway 5y ago>the plausibility of Phoecians, Romans, reaching the Americas. Could have not really. Their ships (even quite large ones for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympias_(trireme)#/media/File:Olympias.1.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympias_(trireme)#/media/File...) weren't ocean going (like for example giving the way of construction the hulls wouldn't have been able to sustain the heavy waves stress for many days, etc.). To compare this is an example of the ocean going ships - Viking drakkar - in which Americas were first reached: https://youtu.be/XORSpUUy0lQ?list=RDCMUCNnLNJLZj11RlFYq4HZ6cTQ&t=120 https://youtu.be/XORSpUUy0lQ?list=RDCMUCNnLNJLZj11RlFYq4HZ6c...
- garmaine 5y agoThat said, there is some evidence there may be a roman shipwreck off the coast of Brazil, which has yet to be excavated. While roman designs are not ocean-going, it's entirely possible that they might have been blown off-course and managed to survive the journey.
- trhway 5y ago7th century is the beginning of the Viking Age as it was close to the global warming peak of the first millennium. The waters at those high latitudes became survivable for people in open boats, and similar to Greenland back then, the warmest part of the Antarctica probably became survivable too.
- mkl 5y agoAntarctica being survivable seems unlikely. Unlike Greenland, Antarctica has the Southern Ocean's Circumpolar Current keeping it cold: https://blog.csiro.au/explainer-how-the-antarctic-circumpolar-current-helps-keep-antarctica-frozen/ https://blog.csiro.au/explainer-how-the-antarctic-circumpola...
- mam3 5y agowho cares
- timwaagh 5y ago"beyond the accounts of European male explorers that usually predominate." Here I was reading a fun account about Polynesian Antarctic seafaring and then that happens.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 0_____0 5y agoNot sure what you mean. You were reminded that our historical record of exploration was written by, and mostly features, Europeans? Not exactly a controversy, that in particular.
- thatguy0900 5y agoI love reading out of place attacks on men in every article these days. Really refreshing to see identity politics flamewars in a article about Antarctica discovery. I can't imagine why he would have a problem with it.
- 0_____0 5y agoIt's perfectly contextual (the whole point of the article is looking past records kept by European explorers). I think maybe people grate at seeing the words "white|European male" in any context but that's not the writers problem, that's a fact integral to the story. Here's the passage in question for those that haven't seen TFA. >Wehi said collating traditional Maori accounts helped give a broader view of Antarctic history, beyond the accounts of European male explorers that usually predominate. >"History tends to be told by one voice and there's often a dominant narrative," she told the New Zealand Herald. > "Often indigenous history and even women's history becomes invisible, so for me it's about making that history visible."
- timwaagh 5y agoI was offended because of the male adjective. If they had said European explorers that would have been normal but the gender of the European explorers seems to not be very relevant and included only for political signalling reasons.
- williesleg 5y agoI found it all first and claim it as my own.