8 ms·
If there is one genetic quirk that I am extremely envious of, it's definitely this one. From the article: > But natural short sleepers actually seem to benefit
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
If there is one genetic quirk that I am extremely envious of, it's definitely this one. From the article:
> But natural short sleepers actually seem to benefit from this quirk of their biology. Fu says researchers have found that short sleepers tend to be more optimistic, more energetic and better multitaskers. They also have a higher pain threshold, don’t suffer from jet lag and some researchers believe they may even live longer.
I'm the opposite, I guess I'd be categorized as a "long sleeper" - the "natural" length of my sleep is ~9 hours. I feel pretty chronically lethargic, and if I go under 8 hours for multiple nights in a row I feel completely awful and often end up getting sick.
- malshe 5y agoI am a long sleeper as well and I don’t see any downside to it!
- balfirevic 5y agoIt's like adding 1-2 hours to the commute, only worse because you can't listen to anything during that time and you have to do it on weekends, the days you WFH and during vacations too.
- amelius 5y agoThere probably are downsides to this gene later in life. Evolution is always about tradeoffs.
- awillen 5y agoThat's not true - evolution is about the best genes for survivability and reproduction continuing to be passed along. The evolutionary perspective here wouldn't be that there are downsides to this, but rather that people with this mutation are better able to survive and reproduce, so we'd expect it to be passed onto more offspring over the generations.
- amelius 5y agoYes, this happens in the long run. In the short term, when a single gene has massive benefit, there must be some negative effect too, otherwise the entire population would quickly get that gene and that's not what we see here.
- neutronicus 5y agoObvious answer: The benefit is real, but minor
- DangitBobby 5y agoI wouldn't say "minor." In real terms, I think it's a huge advantage in our current society. But it's just not strongly selected for.
- parineum 5y agoThere's not been nearly enough time for these genes to spread in modern society. It's hard to imagine this gene was as beneficial as it might be today without cheap and effective night time lighting.
- harry8 5y agoYou are going to live long enough and be able to reproduce with about the same probability all other things equal whether you need 3 hours or 10 sleep nightly. There's very little evolutionary pressure even if you would massively and hugely prefer one of those over the other. The kind of non-survival genetics that could be selected for in the modern world are those that make multiple women (nature can be pretty sexist) want to throw caution to the wind and have babies fathered by a man with some desirable attribute. I have no idea if this actually happens in reality with heritable genes. Eg do basketball players pass on a greater than average amount of their genetics (more children with more women) by virtue of being tall making them more sexually desirable to those who might become single mothers? Plausible, I guess, but could easily be utterly false. I don't know how you'd test it even in the absence of ethical concerns.
- farresito 5y agoMaybe the downside is that someone who sleeps less will also tend to wander during the night, which increased the risk of dying before the modern world.
- grp000 5y agoI think that's down to risk management skills of an individual. It could also be the case that sleeping less means you're more aware of external threats and ambushes and you can be more productive.
- vladvasiliu 5y agoEvolution happens through reproduction, which tends to happen earlier in life. So if some gene confers an advantage in early life but a disadvantage later on, it's likely the disadvantage won't stop it from spreading. If it's not widespread, it's either not an advantage that "matters" or maybe it possibly has some negative interaction with other traits that matter for reproduction.
- astrange 5y agoHumans have much longer lifespans than other animals, so it must be an advantage for our descendants to have us around. Presumably this is because of grandparents providing childcare.
- canadianfella 5y agoNo. Not always.
- edeion 5y agoOn the flip side, I see longer sleep routine as an opportunity to dream more. (Says one who needs 10 hours of sleep to function at normal performance :))
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoSurely there must be some downside to it. If it weren't so, one would have expected this gene to spread across the human genepool millions of years ago. There must be something that is overlooked. Perhaps, optimism is not a good ticket to survival: I am quite optimistic that this larger, scary looking animal has no intention to eat me.
- neutronicus 5y agoUsed to be, boredom killed humans like curiosity kills cats Turning off for 9 hours was a defense mechanism
- IshKebab 5y agoThat's a particularly implausible hypothesis.
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoGiven all the very advantageous qualities this gene has to offer, there must be at leas some considerable downsides to it indeed.
- DangitBobby 5y agoNot necessarily. 1) It could be a relatively recent mutation. 2) It's probably not particularly important for sexual selection.
- woopwoop 5y agoI would imagine short sleepers need more calories.
- lostcolony 5y agoSo they're less likely to be obese. Great. That makes me feel -so- much better about being a long sleeper. :P
- meowface 5y agoA recent podcast episode I watched had a doctor who said something that stuck with me: "when it comes to sleep, it's about the quality, not the quantity". A small amount of high-quality sleep gives you more actual rest than a large amount of lesser-quality sleep, they said. Not sure how true it is, but it seems to line up with my life. I'm also a long sleeper who's still often lethargic during the day. But I find that some (legal) inhibitory substances can bring me into what feels like a much more restful sleep, and I wake up feeling very refreshed and energetic for the whole day. My eyelids feel less heavy, I feel like a fog is lifted, and I just feel better in every way. I suspect my average sleep quality just isn't very good.
- markus_zhang 5y agoMe neither. I rarely had any good sleep that left me with a refreshed mind. Early morning is usually my worst time.
- fighterpilot 5y agoI am very interested to read about the evidence behind this. Do you remember the doctor's or podcast's name?
- meowface 5y agohttps://youtu.be/jhKZIq3SlYE?t=4436 https://youtu.be/jhKZIq3SlYE?t=4436 Can't speak to the veracity of it, and might've paraphrased or misremembered a bit, but it definitely stayed with me.
- 55555 5y ago> some (legal) inhibitory substances Which substances?
- smokelegend 5y agoTHC-A
- meowface 5y ago
- ummonk 5y agoI imagine most of the advantages happen because they've taken over and structured the modern world to make long sleeping difficult.
- markus_zhang 5y agoYeah man, definitely! Just imagine that you have 2 more hours than other people for EVERY DAY. OK, I also figured out that sometimes those 2 extra hours are pretty useless if I couldn't figure out my goal in the world. But still a pretty good 2 hour :/
- raducu 5y agoDo we know for sure it's just this one gene? What if we engineered humans to have this gene, could we do more harm if in fact it's a combination of genes and we introduce just one of them?
- rolleiflex 5y agoIf the gene sequence is short enough, this is probably the best gene to do a clinical trial on the human use of CRISPR-Cas9 because it’s one healthy people would be willing to risk their hide to splice in. It’s essentially as close as we can get to a real-world superpower.