22 ms·
It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
- SkyMarshal 5y agopaywalled
- fighterpilot 5y agohttps://archive.is/kk0CY https://archive.is/kk0CY
- tedunangst 5y agoWhat would happen if Harvard were required to accept 40 percent of all applicants as before? I think it would be pretty amusing if they got 50000 applicants, admitted 20000, and then said "guess what Cambridge, we're building 200 new dormitories, here, there, and everywhere."
- graeme 5y agoEither it would have to expand its undergrad programs, or student quality (as Harvard measures it) would decline. Joseph Heath has a very interesting article comparing US elite schools (tiny undergrad program) and Canadian elite schools (massive undergrad programs, bigger than Ivy League) http://induecourse.ca/the-bottleneck-in-u-s-higher-education/ http://induecourse.ca/the-bottleneck-in-u-s-higher-education...
- tedunangst 5y agoI've seen this before, and I think it's ridiculous to assume that there's some arbitrary cutoff about top 10 colleges. Why is not percentile based? For reference, there's 12 Houses at Harvard. With a bit of paperwork, they could each be a separate college, pushing Dartmouth all the way down completely out of the top 20. But would the education at Dartmouth have gotten worse in any way? Rephrased, what if we instead classify the Ivy League as a single college with eight campuses? What's the difference?
- sokoloff 5y agoThat’s in the same article where they compare the value of an endowment (measured in dollars) against the GDP of three random countries (measured in a different unit: dollars per year [per country]). Analytic rigor is not high.
- gowld 5y agoIt's interesting to note that Harvard could fund an entire country for a year.
- tedunangst 5y agoYou know GDP and budget aren't the same, right?
- asciident 5y agoI've seen this comparison in a few articles. It makes no sense at all. It's like if I said Microsoft's market cap ($1.942T) is larger than the GDP of Russian ($1.7T), or Apple's Market Cap ($2.125T) is double the combined endowments of every single US university altogether (about $1T). Complete nonsense comparisons.
- graeme 5y agoIt’s because for cultural reasons US people ascribe elite status to precisely those ten colleges. Or T14 in some cases. If the US ascribed sainted elite status to the top 100 colleges to the top 100 colleges, we wouldn’t be having this discussion. By contrast in Canada if you went to UBC, McGill or UBC people assume you are smart.
- tedunangst 5y agoTough break for the Berkeley grads widely assumed to be dumb idiots.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rejectedandsad 5y agoBut...we already have elite large undergrad programs, they’re called the UCs and the UT systems and the rest of the systems that support public ivies (both flagship and secondary campuses). UToronto, Waterloo, and UBC are all public. Our public ivies are big and produce equivalent talent while being accessible to nearly everyone through CC transfer agreements. I don’t think there’s a bottleneck here. The real bottleneck is that people who don’t go to top schools are considered to be inherently inferior and objective failures like myself.
- catgary 5y agoI don’t think school really figures into people’s thought process in Canada. UofT and UBC are massive, and as long as you check the boxes you get in. People in the Saskatchewan may prefer URegina because it’s closer to home, someone from Newfoundland may go to Memorial. Faculty positions are so competitive that I don’t think there’s a huge difference in the quality of the younger professors, just the bigger schools will have more profs and bigger research groups.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoThis is the case for 90% of applicants to college (in general) in the states too, including my undergrad (which happened to exist in the city I was born and grew up in). I hardly went to a prestigious undergrad but I had several brilliant professors that had significant pedigrees, educationally speaking.
- catgary 5y agoI think the unique thing about Canada is that students “fall into” prestigious institutions by virtue of being good students who grew up in the area. Basically every student in Toronto with a 90% average in high school can go to UofT. This is very achievable for anyone from a stable middle class family whose parents care about education.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIt could easily do that, but its status and signaling value would be negatively impacted.
- poopypoopington 5y agoOr why do they have to be in Cambridge? Why not expand in Las Vegas or Houston or something?
- wombatpm 5y agoYou can’t row crew in Las Vegas and the sun it too hot for lacrosse.
- tedunangst 5y agoWhat if we built a Harvard campus in NC and called it Duke?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 5y agoWere harvard required to accept 40% of applicants at some point? (Google fails me) I was part of an experiment where the physics department at my uni admitted everyone who applied. Even those without the required prerequisites. Most of the "extras" dropped out or transfered or failed etc. But about 20% graduated. I think in one way this proved the normal application system was mostly effective. But it also gave people chances they never would have had. I was insulted (I'd got my grades!) initially but it taught me something about opportunity. Maybe we'd be better doing this everywhere?
- tedunangst 5y agoNot required, but the clear implication of the article is that things were more "fair" when the admit rate was 40%, and thus I'm asking what if we mandated that Harvard accept a "fair" portion of applicants.
- jlund-molfese 5y agohttps://outline.com/YAPKuj https://outline.com/YAPKuj Non-paywalled link
- Causality1 5y agoI wonder what the deal is with such a large percentage of submissions being paywalled sites. Do the submitters have subscriptions to everything and just don't realize? Does everybody reading HN have anti-paywall extensions installed? Sure there's always the archive.is link but someone has to see the article in the first place.
- bradleyjg 5y agoMaybe content that has a reasonable revenue stream supporting it is just better.
- Der_Einzige 5y agoMaybe students attending universities who have "reasonable revenue streams" supporting them are just better.
- chirau 5y agoFull no paywall article here https://outline.com/YAPKuj https://outline.com/YAPKuj
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 5y ago> Faculty members at prestigious universities are 50 times more likely than the average person to have a parent with a Ph.D. American meritocracy has become a complex, inefficient, and rigged system conferring its graces on ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families. What’s the ratio in other fields of top achievement for kids to follow in their parents’ footsteps? It’s entirely unsurprising that academics raise academics, doctors doctors, Olympians Olympians, teachers teachers, etc. It’s equally unsurprising that the ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families themselves pursue such a similar path and achieve similar outcomes. I’m an engineer and my spouse a scientist. Our kids have commensurately higher chance to pursue one of those or a closely related field due to exposure and biases.
- ttul 5y agoYou likely don’t realize that your kids will also have an easier chance at succeeding because of other privileges they enjoy, aside from the merits of having intelligent and educated parents. Take a similarly educated family who happen to live in Gaza, for instance, and it’s obvious that the children will have a different set of opportunities available to them.
- sokoloff 5y agoIs there any basis for your assumption that I don’t realize that?
- jedberg 5y agoFrom the NYT: Working sons of working fathers are, on average, 2.7 times as likely as the rest of the population to have the same job but only two times as likely to have the same job as their working mothers, according to an analysis by The New York Times, one of the first to look at mothers and daughters in addition to fathers and sons. Daughters are 1.8 times as likely to have the same job as their mothers and 1.7 times as likely to have the same job as their fathers. [0] From the General Social Survey[1]: If your father was a legislator, you are 354 times more likely to be drawn to that career, too. Kids whose father was a doctor are 23 times more likely to follow in his footsteps. If your father was a lawyer, you’re 17 times more likely to become one, as well. Jobs in the trades figure into these statistics, as well. - The sons and daughters of plumbers are 14 times more likely to pursue a job in this field. - The sons and daughters of electricians are nine times more likely to pursue a job in this field. - The sons and daughters of carpenters are five times more likely to pursue a job in this field. And, maybe it’s all that brushing and flossing – but the sons and daughters of dentists are 13 times more likely to become one, too. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-in-your-parents-footsteps.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-... [1] http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS
- bradleyjg 5y agoThere is a large supply of scholars and teachers ready, willing, and able to work. Public universities, colleges, community colleges, and HBCUs have for decades been starved. The Biden family understands public education, and Jill Biden is an educator. With something like a Works Project Administration program to bring arts and sciences education to Americans, the administration could restore democratic education in the U.S. This makes the mistake of accepting that college is about education. It isn’t. If it were those that barely graduate college and those that barely flunk out would have about the same outcomes, having learned about the same amount. They have very different outcomes because college is about the endless treadmill of credentialism.
- hpcjoe 5y agoI had a similar discussion with a young colleague considering grad school recently. My two cents is now, with nearly 25 years post Ph.D. under my belt, that it is a union card for some jobs, and irrelevant for others. The degrees don't make the person. The content of the character and drive do. I got a Ph.D. as I had the goal of being a physics prof someday. I knew that was an essential milestone on the path to this. Now, my goal is to save for retirement, and do what I enjoy doing while doing this, and maybe after retirement teaching physics/math/etc. at a local uni/college. The treadmill of credentialism is an apt phrase though. I don't need a Ph.D. in my current job. Or most of my previous ones.
- b9a2cab5 5y ago> recirculating resources among the most exclusive and wealthy while chanting social-justice keywords Indeed, Harvard aggressively defends its admissions program as "holistic" while rating Asians as having lower personal ratings that they define as measuring "likeability", "courage", and "kindness" [1]. You might ask yourself how an institution which claims to be anti-racist exhibits behavior of the opposite kind. [1]: https://nypost.com/2018/10/19/harvards-own-study-reveals-university-showed-favoritism-toward-certain-students/ https://nypost.com/2018/10/19/harvards-own-study-reveals-uni...
- fighterpilot 5y agoWhat's telling is how similar the Asian admit percentage is between the top colleges except for Caltech. It wasn't always like this, but they've all (ex-Caltech) converged on almost the same number now. It appears to be collusion either of the sort discussed in the article or the informal sort where each college copies their competitors' quotas.
- scarmig 5y agoCollege admissions' treatment of Asian American applicants is the most explicit form of institutional racism in the US today. It's the kind of racist discrimination that, if applied against any other group, would get the perpetrator sued to oblivion.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology is a magnet school in Virginia, often ranked the top high school in the US. Admissions is (or was) based mostly on an admissions test, with a smaller portion based on middle school grades. In recent years, the student body was 70% Asian, 20% White, and the rest other minorities. Despite literally decades of trying to increase percentages of Black and Hispanic students at the school with outreach programs and tutoring, percentages have never exceeded single digits. So what did the school board do? They scrapped the admissions process altogether, in favor of a "holistic" one [1]. Lesson? Be careful if you're in a minority group that over-achieves your population demographics, because you will be punished for it. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/thomas-jefferson-high-admissions-fairfax/2020/12/18/d09a2b3c-40b9-11eb-8bc0-ae155bee4aff_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/thomas-jeffer...
- mlac 5y ago“In 1940, the acceptance rate at Harvard was 85 percent.” I didn’t realize that was the acceptance rate, but JFK’s application to Harvard is interesting and that acceptance rate adds context: https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/11/jfks-very-revealing-harvard-application-essay/281699/ https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/11/jfks-v... And maybe it’s not people pulling the ladder up behind them - it’s that the ladder has become more visible and desirable without expanding or changing. I do have some hope with Coursera and EdX. There are now blended programs starting online that allow students to start remote and show they can do the coursework, before completing the rest on campus: https://scm.mit.edu/program/blended-masters-degree-supply-chain-management https://scm.mit.edu/program/blended-masters-degree-supply-ch... I’d argue the knowledge is becoming more open and freely available, but the network is not. Maybe the value of the network would drop if it was less personal and more people were there. There is some optimal program size and it’s possible some programs could hold more. At the same time, do we really need more Cal tech grads? Not a slam at Cal tech (I chose the smallest), but how many people with those skill sets do we need vs. graduates from other less specialized schools. There is something special about Cal Tech’s community, and I don’t know I would want to dilute it just because other people should have the ability to go there to meet some arbitrary “fairness metric”. The value these institutions have brought, and bring, to the country by making us the top in the world in a number of fields comes from how selective they are and their massive resources they can put toward problems. This makes them attractive to the world’s top talent and gives them the freedom to work on some things without economic constraints, and that’s a societal benefit. Pulling money away because they’ve managed it well could hurt us long term. And it’s not like the Harvard endowment of $40B is just sitting there - it is invested into the economy like other funds until it is needed for investment in the community. Lastly - just because you didn’t go to one of those institutions doesn’t mean you can’t be successful or attend one for grad school. And I’ve found grad school admissions to be meritocratic.
- analog31 5y agoAcceptance rates are meaningless. There is no limit on the denominator.
- 5y ago
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoIt’s time to break up the education system from all the extracurricular fluff. The universities are fostering identities around themselves: students join debate teams, sports teams, religious groups , orchestra, etc under the aegis of their universities and attach their personal identities to these things. To me personally it seems kind of ridiculous. What if you are a young adult who is interested in trades, but you want to play in an orchestra. You can’t access an orchestra (there are seven of them in Harvard!) of any of your local universities. You can’t even join a university gym that probably has far cheaper fees than any other gym in your area. You want to take classes in Shaolin Kempo Karate? We are sorry but you can’t because you didn’t pass “holistic” assessment of your personality by Harvard. What a weird situation where your whole social life as a young adult completely depends on assessment of your personality by gerontic professors who need to fill some quotas.
- s5300 5y agoYou essentially want institutions to bend to your will? Good luck with that... Why don't you go out and build from the ground up/front money to building a place solely for those "just interested in trades"
- thomastjeffery 5y agoThey essentially want institutions to be less involved in their community and social circles. Why should educational institutions be allowed to monopolize social groups in the first place?
- s5300 5y agoWell, once upon a time, likely not too long ago, politicians that were voted in decided to establish a framework in which this was possible/prevailed. For those who personally don't like it, I don't know what to tell you. Your ideology is clearly a minority, and the only way minorities will get what they want in a capitalistic system is through large amounts of money.
- minikites 5y ago
- paulpauper 5y ago>The economist Raj Chetty has found that nearly 40 of the country’s elite colleges and universities, including five in the Ivy League, accept more students from families in the top 1 percent of income earners than from the bottom 60 percent. The computer scientist Allison Morgan recently released a study examining 7,218 professors in Ph.D.-granting departments in the United States across the arts and sciences. She found that the faculty come from families almost 34-percent richer than average and are 25 times more likely than average to have a parent with a Ph.D. Faculty members at prestigious universities are 50 times more likely than the average person to have a parent with a Ph.D. American meritocracy has become a complex, inefficient, and rigged system conferring its graces on ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families. This is like the 'branch cut' equivalent of the social sciences, but rather than making the integral easier to compute, makes the argument sound more convincing than it actually is or supported by the evidence. If one looks aat the actual data, admitees of elite colleges are hardly among the elite, but just somewhat wealthier than average. http://yaledailynews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/admissions-wed-5_maya.png http://yaledailynews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/admissio... We're not taking Rockefeller-level of wealth here. But this holds even for non-elite colleges. It not that top colleges are biased against the lower classes, but that lower classes may just be less inclined to apply or score lower on standardized tests.
- jhayward 5y ago> It not that top colleges are biased against the lower classes, but that lower classes may just be less inclined to apply or score lower on standardized tests Oh, my. This is such a straight-textbook example of not seeing systemic bias.
- paulpauper 5y agoGenerations ago, elite colleges had quotas preventing or discouraging certain groups from applying. Those barriers have been removed. As it turns out, selecting for intelligence yields more for endowments and other benefits than selecting for prestige or lineage. This may not be completely fair, but is more fair than the old way.Tons of people apply to these schools. The SAT is still a useful despite being an imperfect filter.
- eternalban 5y ago> One of the great puzzles of American society is the position of the Ivy League. It is a bastion of privilege and power, and yet full of left-leaning professors who one might imagine would favor the redistribution of wealth. Re-imagining social norms -- not a conservative predisposition -- has nothing to do with redistributing wealth. It is precisely the requirement for a shared mindset, or a demonstration of willingness to adhere to ideological dogma, that requires generational and selective admission. As the re-imaginings take to greater heights of fancy, the distance from the non-indoctrinated society at large (which generally feels and thinks via principles and not ideology) increases and this requires and motivates a greater degree of insularity by an establishment. It is certainly true that some children of the ideologically and/or culturally "unwashed" masses will arrive at the 'acceptable' socio-economic conclusion (due to their superior intellect) -- whether they acknowledge this consciously is not germinal -- but the risk to an establishment (regardless of their leaning on the fabled 1 dimensional L/R spectrum) to an 'open admissions and integration' policy are simply too great.
- jorangreef 5y agoHey @eternalban, this is completely unrelated but I've been wanting to get in touch with you for some time regarding Viewstamped Replication. We've exchanged a few comments about it in the past, and there are going to be some developments around VR that I think you would be really excited about.
- eternalban 5y agoHi there, Joran. Thanks for the heads-up; I'll get in touch.
- torstenvl 5y agoI strongly disagree. Having elite schools is far far better for upward mobility. Being a poor kid and going to Harvard is a far more effective ticket to the upper middle class than any alternative the author proposes. Sure, you could theoretically dilute academic signaling strength, by force, to the point of homeopathic levels - but who does that help? Whose life completely changes for the better by attending such an institution? EDIT: If you disagree, please feel free to express why. Not complaining about the downvotes, but dialog would be preferred over drive-bys.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoI disagree because you’re succeeding at the expense of the rest of us. Have you considered 99.5% of people will never step one foot on an elite school campus? I’m sick of society being catered to your whims while the rest of us are dismissed as stupid and innately less qualified. Objectively speaking, my life is absolutely terrible BECAUSE of elites like you hoarding opportunity and people like me getting nothing because I only got a 1500/1600 and didn’t know about research opportunities in high school. I’m barely 25 but my life is already irretrievably broken because the elites want to segregate themselves from “my kind” so bad.
- torstenvl 5y agoI'm sorry you feel that way. Before you make up your mind, I hope you consider that this is what I grew up in: https://imgur.com/Hw9zH9j https://imgur.com/Hw9zH9j I worked hard in high school to get a scholarship to a third-tier state school, where I worked hard to get good grades and improve my logical reasoning skills enough to do very well on the LSAT. Nothing about society was ever catered for me. I had to fight very, very hard. And yes, I know others work just as hard and don't get the same opportunities. I'm not claiming the current system is perfect. "Ya gotta take care of business, ya gotta go to school, ya gotta get good grades to even have a chance... I'm talkin' about a chance! You might not make it, but you sure as hell won't if ya don't try." ~Hillbilly Elegy For all its imperfections, it's a lot better than the proposed alternative.
- 5y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoI wonder if a President sometime should pledge in the interest of diversity only to appoint and nominate people who did not go to Ivy League universities for Cabinet and judicial positions.
- digglet90 5y agoSeems like there's an emerging paradigm for ignoring universities but still doing something of value in the "academic" space. This is just a dumb strategy but based on many examples I've seen recently. 1. Customise a curriculum engaging with younger tutors in niche areas (e.g. youtube, teachable or if theres others comment). 2. Do this for a few years and make sure to meet people/do appropriate things and publish them online. E.g. do a good podcast/lecture series. 3. Publish on Xiv like sites with high quality results/arguments/original ideas or demo/explain things on youtube. If a preprint site doesn't exist for you then make one and contact people. This might get you x100 the exposure of your average PI and eventually funding will come around to your ideas as universities become a total farce. 10 years down the line the tepid overtures to gitlab and github turn into a full on rejection of high overhead university education. Rental or pooling services for expensive equipment or access to resources would also help immensely. Castles in the sand!
- digglet90 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/c/thethoughtemporium/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/thethoughtemporium/videos ^ basically the outcome of a section of a university from one person on a limited budget
- digglet90 5y agoOf course I don't mean Edtech platforms that simply try to transfer universities online. There's something overcooked there that doesn't work imo.
- DreamScatter 5y agoThat's pretty much my stance, the universities are obsolete garbage. I did give them another shot and took as many math classes as possible, but they screwed up and drove me away. I now do all my math research independent, as the universities are unable to facilitate my math research activity. https://github.com/chakravala https://github.com/chakravala
- neom 5y agoUsed to have this argument regularly with executives of startups I've worked for who had worked in more "traditional" industries. The number of times I've had to interject around "pedigree" being "useful" is.. sad. (Most)Everyone I've hired from Harvard, Stanford, Columbia, etc have been the worst performing, and the most far behind in relevant skills. RIT, Rutgers, etc, waaaay far ahead. It got to the point where I started to move those people to the bottom because the curriculum they studied was so dated most of the skills became irrelevant; I don't need you to set up some complex excel spreadsheet that shows me the KPIs, and only you know how to update it, I need you to know how to set up mixpanel. I don't need you to program Java, I need you to set up k8s, etc. However, more importantly, these grads(recent or not) often come with an attitude of knowing, vs an attitude of learning. Interestingly, all the "pedigree" obsessed folks who (all) graduated from ivy league schools went on to found one of the most mediocre and poorly focused VC firms I've seen.
- obstacle1 5y agoMaybe the problem is you're hiring CS/engineering students to "show KPIs" or "set up mixpanel" or "not program"? I can't imagine any competent student from those disciplines, never mind a student from a top tier school, being happy at any kind of job like that. Especially if they were sold a job that would use their full abilities. Sounds like a recipe for otherwise talented people half-assing your job while looking for a new one, resulting in you thinking they suck rather than just don't care about doing trivial stuff.
- neom 5y agoWhy would I hire engineers to set up mixpanel? You hire marketing people for that!
- bruce343434 5y ago./.. never said anything about CS/engineering
- Der_Einzige 5y agoI have a funny anecdote here. In competitive parliamentary debate, almost every school "plays by the rules" and doesn't do some relatively easy and hard to detect cheating. Not RIT though - they cheat blatantly and hard. They come in with pages and pages of evidence that they simply could not have hand written in the 15 minutes they're given for preparing. I have a slightly more poor opinion of any RIT graduate as a result of this experience. I know nothing about the school but I can sure tell you that being unscrupulous is not reserved only for the ivy league elite.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhat is the author's thesis? I skimmed and read and re-read, but didn't figure it out. It's well known that elite universities are elitist in their admissions and have over-large endowments. And the elite universities have acted on it, and many of their new classes are very different. And it's well known that the rest of the U.S. educational system is underfunded. > Sen. Tom Cotton, of all political leaders, suggested taxing private colleges with large endowments, and redirecting funds to vocational training. It's not a surprise. Cotton and his party see Ivy League universities as institutions of the political opposition, whom they attack and want to punish and diminish.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rkk3 5y ago> What is the author's thesis? I skimmed and read and re-read, but didn't figure it out. Same. I think they are hoping Biden will put more money into public schools and stop preferential tax treatments for the large endowments. > It's not a surprise. Cotton and his party see Ivy League universities as institutions of the political opposition, whom they attack and want to punish and diminish. Tom Cotton... Harvard University BA , JD You are right that it fits the public narrative & rhetoric, but many (perhaps most) of them went to elite schools. It is probably just posturing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Cotton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Cotton
- tootie 5y agoOn that note, the liberal cry of student loan forgiveness will overwhelmingly favor people who went to expensive private colleges. Taxing big endowments seems pretty senseless and doesn't create any positive incentives either. More support and less stigma against state schools would probably do the most good.
- rkk3 5y ago> the liberal cry of student loan forgiveness will overwhelmingly favor people who went to expensive private colleges. True, but you can be expensive & private & not be elite (most of them are not by definition).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ugh123 5y agoWasn't able to read past the first paragraph due to paywall, but the first 2 sentences stuck out: > Power in the U.S. flows through the gates of the Ivy League and a very small tier of other top universities. These institutions set and sanction the boundaries of knowledge, including what kinds of political and social views are welcomed in prestige cultural spaces. Is that really the case anymore? If the last year has shown us anything, its that technology has further empowered grassroots ideas and activism, and that technology companies themselves are furthering their own influence in politics and knowledge (the free flow of information that is true and not true) way beyond what influencers in academia alone can do right now.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago"Influencers" .... who runs the actual governments? Whether your answer is "an unelected wealthy oligarchy" or "officials appointed by the administration", both ranks are filled with people who came up through the elite university systems.
- rdiddly 5y agoI'm sure they're quaking in their boots upon reading this sternly-worded letter! To change things would take this, plus the slightest hint of conviction on the part of those currently living fat lives working in and leading those same institutions - not just academia but others that were supposed to safeguard society against such excesses, such as the press, the media, organized labor (sorry who?), and the vibrant American communist/socialist movement (LOL JK). They've all been neutralized and their brightest individuals bought off in subtle ways e.g. they just happen to make more money and get invited to more parties by agreeing with the elite party line. Or disagreeing with it in principle but crucially misattributing the blame to protect those actually at fault and/or cui bono-ing from it, that's a popular tactic. Ironically if you've got tenure (as increasingly few do) you ought to be able to speak out all the more loudly, and you can, and still make money, but you won't get invited to the parties anymore.
- zumu 5y agoI think this whole debate is centered on the shallow idea that "going to an Ivy League" in and of itself is what ordains "elite-ness". To unravel this, you first must consider the actual value proposition of Ivy Leagues relative to other schools. Firstly, undergrad in America, especially at private schools like the Ivy Leagues, is more a daycare for rich kids, than it is a place of scholarship and learning. The education is certainly good, but there are plenty of other schools with rigorous academics. At these schools the children of the rich fraternize, drink and come of age with other children of the rich. The schools themselves are well connected as well but it's in large part through these bonds with their rich and powerful peers that the graduates of these schools go on to become "the elites". If you reduce the number of kids from rich and powerful families going to these places, you are going to drastically reduce the networking potential amongst classmates and start to erode school level affiliations. In short, you can't just limit admissions to solely "academic merit" without destroying a big part of what makes prestigious schools valuable. Ultimately, if the children of the rich and powerful are excluded, they will congregate elsewhere and all the prestige and kingmakers will follow.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoHonestly, if the admissions committee decides you’re good enough to get into any of the top schools you’re already an elite of some kind (in math, rowing, “activism” etc). All of these elites need to be knocked down a few pegs. I’d go as far as to say all MIT admits are fundamentally, inherently elite (especially compared to a low IQ sap like me) and should be punished regardless. They’re rich because people like me are poor.
- leoh 5y ago> Firstly, undergrad in America, especially at private schools like the Ivy Leagues, is more a daycare for rich kids, than it is a place of scholarship and learning. The education is certainly good, but there are plenty of other schools with rigorous academics. At these schools the children of the rich fraternize, drink and come of age with other children of the rich. The schools themselves are well connected as well but it's in large part through these bonds with their rich and powerful peers that the graduates of these schools go on to become "the elites". If you reduce the number of kids from rich and powerful families going to these places, you are going to drastically reduce the networking potential amongst classmates and start to erode school level affiliations. I went to an Ivy and transferred out to a UC and I can definitively say that this is a highly romanticized take.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jgalt212 5y agoThe wokes won't be happy until English teachers speak broken English and math teachers struggle with algebra.
- longtimegoogler 5y agoI've long thought the same. I've often thought that the University system in Europe, in particular Germany, is a much better model for higher education. From what I gather, admissions is entirely merit based there and money isn't an issue. It isn't just the Ivies that cater to the rich and elite. Many other private universities also do so and promise alumni connections and wealth, think Vanderbilt, Williams, etc. Even when I was applying to colleges as an undergrad I found it a bit off-putting and instead only applied to public universities.
- kingsuper20 5y agoIt would be interesting to know the mix of degrees produced over time by those schools. My guess is that 100 years ago you largely saw the children of the elite receiving general educations centered around classics, the post-war period would have seen an engineering emphasis, and (perhaps) now a push for finance and law. It's hard to have an opinion without knowing the product of the system.
- EvilEy3 5y agoIt's time to break shitty "sign up" websites.
- throw123123123 5y agoSomething usually amiss with the current talk of universities is that they are an immigration racket. Universities make most of its tuition money from foreign students, but foreign students go to american universities to get visas they can use to get into the labor market. The F1 visa is unlimited, contrary to the H1B one, and allows for a transition out of university. Also for the H1B and multiple categories, one key criteria is having a college degree. College Education: so valuable you need the law to justify they are worth something
- unishark 5y agoI think is especially true of MS programs in technology areas. Schools compete to require the fewest courses possible while including capstones and internships to pad resumes. They basically operate like immigration agencies that will get you a visa and an H1b job in return for $30k or so.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoThe US should staple a green card to the PhD degree of any foreigner who comes here to complete their doctorate. It increased US competitive potential by shifting the best & brightest away from their home countries and toward here. Likewise, I’d expect all foreign nations to follow similar policies.
- throw123123123 5y agoEven better, just not put any labor restriction at all. It would attract labor of all levels world wide for free.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoHow does one "break-up" individual universities? What metrics should be allowable for admissions? (I suggest making legacy admissions and favoring race-/gender-/etc. attributes illegal.) Why not get bright minority and poor students, and girls for STEM, supported with mentoring, admissions coaching, resources/funding, and other assistance that makes a massive impact? This way, admissions standards can, and should, be minimized to merit, rather furthering victimhood or privilege. It's like: If we throw away the SATs, ACTs, and other rank-able tests, what's left to compare students? Essays?
- rdevsrex 5y agoAnother reason why children of academics, doctors and other professionals are likely to have a better shot is simply the age at which their parents had them. I don't have any data, but I'm sure there aren't a ton of grad students with kids. Having kids when you are young, kind of puts a limit on how much you can devote to your career.
- cblconfederate 5y ago> But reform will not come from within the Ivy League, It's ironic that the article is written by two harvard ivy leaguers. They have to replace the Ivies with something else. It's hard to envision that from within.
- Growling_owl 5y agoIvy League is the last intellectual bastion of the country. If you break up Ivy League all you are left with is Silicon Valley cult of personality snake-oil salesmen and pump & dumpers posing as experts in every possible field when in reality their solely expertise is building social consensus around them. How many nuclear fusion companies which are quietly shaping the roadmap for obtaining fusion in the next 20 years came out of MIT/Stanford/Harvard? Facebook spun off Harvard, Microsoft spun off Harvard, Google spun off Stanford, Amazon spun off Princeton with a bit of D.E. Shaw thrown in the mix. The author seems to me has watched too many videos from Lex Friedman and Eric Weinstein type where they endlessly talk about how broken those institutions are and never fail to mention Epstein for the extra views that it will generate. As Bill Gates said the mainstream is always under attack and people of course will charge head down towards such Universites, forgetting how they (very much like the companies emerging from such Universities) are the envy of the world.
- bluenose69 5y agoI'd be more interested in reading a complaint about richly-endowed universities if I were not faced with the necessity to pay to continue reading past the first screenful. I'm disinclined to pay, because history indicates that the HN comments are likely to be more useful than the linked item.
- _pmf_ 5y agoIf rich people lose this way of ensuring a smooth passage for their offspring, they'll just invent a new one.
- toss1 5y agoA merit-less screed that amounts to a bunch of name-calling about "liberal Brahmans" and complaining that the top institutions actually have influence. Of course the top institutions have influence - even if they somehow 'broke up the cartel', the new top institutions would also have influence. Tearing down a society's top achievers & institutions is not a way to achieve a useful equality (see Harrison Bergeron). That said, the encouragement at the end for supporting students going to a far wider range of colleges and universities, including Bernie Sanders' plan for free tuition for students of families under $125k is a great idea.
- ausbah 5y agothe main thesis of this piece as far as I can tell is that Ivy League schools and similar institutions are harmful in their outsized concentration of wealth, ability to set the cultural narratives, dominate the social elite, etc. all while act hypocritically advancing many "leftist" ideas