15 ms·
Remove left turns for less dangerous city traffic
- rob_c 5y agoProbably one on the most American articles I've read in a while... "Great job team"... Also, I wonder the impact of introducing proper diving tests and learning to drive.
- goodpoint 5y agoOnce again, a clear warning that an article is US-specific would be nice.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoAgreed. Advice to "avoid left turns " is not directly applicable to "drive on the left" countries.
- andylynch 5y agoIt does closely enough, here it would just translate to ‘avoid right turns’ or ‘avoid turns across opposing traffic’.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoDid you see the word "directly" in the above sentence? yes, it's interpretable after reading the article. It's not a simple or accurate headline, though. As per grandparent comment, " a clear warning that an article is US-specific would be nice."
- goodpoint 5y agoIn many countries such turns are either not dangerous or avoided using roundabouts. Stroads exist almost only in US. https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/3/1/whats-a-stroad-and-why-does-it-matter https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/3/1/whats-a-stroad-...
- bullfightonmars 5y agoDesign plays and engineering play a massive role in the safety of streets. Q: People make mistakes regardless of training. How do you dolve those problems? A: You work to understand them and then eliminate them with intentional action.
- dorfsmay 5y agoGoogle maps, and other similar routing apps, should offer a no left turn option!
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoHeck, I'd be thrilled by a "avoid intersections where the bottom 20% of drivers get stuck waiting for several minutes trying to make the turn" option. 99% of the time I wouldn't use it. But the 1% of the time that I'm doing something stupid the last thing I need is a extraneous hard intersections. It's not like Google doesn't have the location data to figure out the difference between intersections where traffic is slow and steady vs where people routinely get stuck.
- bombcar 5y agoI use the “alternate route” hints for this - if the left turn looks dicey (not protected, busy) I’ll keep going and let it reroute. Usually finds a stop light.
- cameronh90 5y agoAnd while we're at it, in the UK at least they should have an option for not sending you down bidirectional single track roads. No, that 35 mile drive down twisty single track country lane with occasional passing spots will not save any time over the 40 mile motorway. Even if the road is _technically_ 60mph, you'll never reach that speed unless you're on a motorbike...
- somehnacct3757 5y agoThere's this awful route Google Maps will give you, through the twisty back roads of SF because it thinks it can get you to the 101 faster. But it's sending everyone that way, so there's huge traffic on these narrow neighborhood roads. It's not a shortcut if everyone knows about it. I think map apps should be optimizing for something more complex, like least amount of directions within a five minute arrival window. Saving two minutes of driving time isn't worth having to make eight more turns.
- jakubp 5y agoWhile I don't know of the safety impact of removing left turns, the actual trip time impact in a busy city is severely understated. In my city (700k people), an old European town, city center has seen the removal of a few key left turns in the past few years. Consequences for traffic outside city center: probably none. Consequences if you want to drive from within the city center to the outside (e.g. go back from a shopping mall / restaurant / business meeting): walk further (many places to park are inaccessible) back to the car, drive a block or two more than you normally would. Extra time: +5 minutes to walk, +10 minutes for those 1-2 blocks (traffic is heavy). Now the "best" part: Consequences if you want to drive into the city center: you need to make a sequence of correct turns 1-2 kilometers before your target, and if you don't, you are punished with extra 20 minutes in traffic at least (and still won't land where you wanted) - there is simply no route to where you wanted to go unless you pick 1 specific ideal route which many drivers don't know. Results: if you know the city / have good gps (Google Maps sometimes gets it wrong) +10 minutes in traffic, if you don't - + 20-30 minutes in traffic. [edit] You may ask "why you can't do a triple-right-turn?" that's because the city center is not a grid. Many streets are don't have cross-paths for long stretches around historical part of the city. Now the really painful part... Your trip outside the city center is only 5-10 minutes. Losing an EXTRA 20 minutes is a huge loss, it makes the ttrip almost as bad as walking - but inside a car. Bad for everyone really. My main beef is with the fact that many places in the city become almost inaccessible due to a huge reduction in possible routes. E.g. 7 years ago I could get to a large mall / parking area next to the town square maybe in 5-6 diffferent ways (allowing me to balance the traffic out). Now there's 1 way only from my side of the city, and I can't balance anything out by going where others aren't. Guess the "grid" street network is really a hard prerequisite. As for safety, safety records in the city haven't moved at all in the past 10 years so I don't know. (But traffic has grown so maybe it's ok?)
- disantlor 5y agoI am biased but why do we even need cars in the city center, or at the very least why should they be convenient? Could there not be a situation where you walk to the edges of the city center to pick up your car and leave from there? There are specific accessibility concerns that certainly need to be accounted for, but the idea that the average driver loses 20 minutes on a trip that should be 5-10 minutes doesn't seem like inherently an issue in this context. edit-add: biased in the sense that I really dislike cars and live in NYC in large part because you do not need one here
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- natmaka 5y agoSee also "Why UPS drivers don't turn left and you probably shouldn't either" at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25379743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25379743
- masklinn 5y agoThat definitely doesn’t apply. UPS drivers have routes with multiple stops. Planning routes to avoid left turns is a very different (much more feasible, convenient, and efficient) than going from A to B without left turns.
- ravenstine 5y agoBetter yet, replace intersections with roundabouts. But that would mean knocking down a lot of buildings.
- zamadatix 5y agoRoundabouts are fantastic for the low to mid traffic density case. When you get into proper city traffic density it can start to become very problematic, particularly if you don't have a good solution for pedestrians or cyclists to bypass each roundabout crossing. Even with that roundabouts tend to get a bit chaotic once they reach the point of "is expected to have a constant stream of cars in it for the next 2 hours" which can get particularly troublesome if the traffic in each direction is unbalanced and you get people awkwardly changing up yielding rules to let the one person going east-west in or that person tries to floor it to make it in an iffy gap. Also if you're relying on them as the only means of left turn (via u-turn) the wait times can significantly increase on busy roundabouts. That being said I absolutely love roundabouts in low/mid density areas. They finally converted the street I live on from 4 "pack cars into wait groups" stoplights and 1 "the highway just turned into an avenue and this is the first extended stoplight for that" into "never stop heaven" whether you want to just continue through or hop on the highway by putting a bunch of roundabouts and a dogbone underpass in and removing left turns for most of the avenue. For proper city areas I'm almost certain better results would be achieved by using the space for any form of mass transit instead of more road. That and I shudder to think of roundabout traffic in a bumper to bumper scenario when one of the arteries out of the city gets blocked for 10 minutes (or months of construction).
- wiredfool 5y agoRoundabouts have better throughput in most cases, but have higher variance for time to complete transit, as one strong stream of cars from a single direction can choke off the alternative directions.
- amelius 5y agoOr just remove cars from the city altogether.
- tomhoward 5y agoHere in Melbourne Australia, lots is being done to remove right turns (we drive on the left here) at the busiest intersections. Several "P turns" [1,2] have been introduced in the most congested areas, in which you need to go straight through the intersection, then wait to do a U-turn at a designated place, then turn left into the road you wanted to turn right into (or vice versa if you're coming from the other direction). And because we have trams (streetcars), many intersections with trams have long had "hook turns" [3], signed as "right turn from left only", in which to turn right you must first pull over to the left to clear the lanes in your direction, wait for the lights to turn green in the road you're entering, then turn right. (This is not exactly eliminating right turns but it's a much safer and less disruptive way of doing them). It all works well when you understand it, but it confuses the hell out of visitors. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIREzujqOUg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIREzujqOUg [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPe8NtwEqeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPe8NtwEqeI [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yh92LirlCf8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yh92LirlCf8
- burlesona 5y agoThanks for sharing. Wow, that hook turn thing is weird! I can see how it works well once you get used to it, though.
- tvphan 5y agoIf you ride a bike and have to make a turn, it’s a similar concept!
- gertlex 5y agoSounds similar to a "Michigan Left"... which I've known of since I was a kid, though I haven't seen any new ones built that I know of (though, I no longer am in Michigan...) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoAlso common in several parts of NJ, notably driving up US1 between Phila and NYC.
- potiuper 5y agoTldr: roads with 5+ lanes should be one way.
- andi999 5y agoAre there any stats that left turns are/how dangerous? Here most (at least the majority of media reports is about) cyclist die when a truck turns right.
- bullfightonmars 5y agoThe biggest problem with right turns are: 1. Free rights a uncontrolled right turns that don’t protect crossing cyclists and pedestrians through time based segregation. 2. No physical/grade segregation. Cyclists become invisible in blind spots during right turns because intersections are terribly designed to support anything other than cars. A well designed intersection puts cyclists in front of cars where they are visible at all times, instead of in a blind spot. https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/02/20/a-common-urban-intersection-in-the-netherlands/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/02/20/a-common-urban...
- dragonmost 5y agoI can't see this being a solution in places with lots of snow and it also takes a lot more space than the actual road.
- andi999 5y agoThis looks good. Although I do not see how this can be done without tearing down 10% of a city.
- MintsJohn 5y agoThat was my thought as well, when driving in city like environments, its always the cyclists on the right I need to be careful about, traffic I have to cross on the left is clearly visible, the cyclists on the right hide in a blind spot.
- deathanatos 5y agoThose are almost certainly people making what I call "right hand turns from not the rightmost lanes", which is, IMO, the single most dangerous traffic violation a biker can encounter. It happens often, it's hard to avoid, and the consequences are bad¹. My jurisdiction (and most I have encountered) require a right-turning vehicle to merge first into the bike lane, if there is a bike lane to the right. (And no further car lanes. Some intersections will shunt right turning vehicles across the bike lane, first, into a turning lane, and then turn at the intersection.) My "closest call" was here: [1] I was going southbound through that intersection on a fresh green when a vehicle right turned from the left turning lane (i.e. he was also initially headed south bound). Absolutely crazy maneuver. I was forced into the right there (because otherwise, we were going to collide) and was just barely able to make it — I could feel the traction in my back tire was just barely holding onto the road the whole way through, since I was also braking like hell. Driver was just like "uh, oops?" I'll usually watch the lane just left to me for drivers whose movement indicates some inclination of thinking about right turning (again, from the wrong lane). I don't know if people worry about blocking bikers or what. Like, if you're in my lane to make a right, and you're signalling that, I prefer that, because you're not going to pop into my lane & try to kill me. I'll wait behind you while you make the right. (Or merge around you on the left, if I can safely do so.) Or at the very least… if you're going to make an illegal right, please, signal. [1]: https://goo.gl/maps/U2smgkRmagmcwsBAA https://goo.gl/maps/U2smgkRmagmcwsBAA ¹way worse than things that sound worse: car driving the wrong way — which itself happens way more often than it really should — it's much "better": I can see it coming. Honestly, as a cyclist I feel like I'm the only person out there who took a course on how to drive a car.
- johnwalkr 5y agoTrains.
- burlesona 5y agoOne of the best ways to eliminate left turns is to replace four way intersections with roundabouts. This has the advantage of working even where there isn’t a grid to facilitate the “3 right turns” strategy. For a great description of why this is so effective, see the recent freakonomics podcast: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/roundabouts/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/roundabouts/
- alksjdalkj 5y agoI'm a little skeptical that it would be safer for pedestrians and bikes. Bikes need to merge with traffic already in the roundabout instead of simply going straight through an intersection, and pedestrians would need to always check for oncoming cars rather than being able to mostly rely on lights telling them when they can cross. But then most of my experience with roundabouts is with large, multilane roundabouts so the traffic is still pretty fast - maybe smaller roundabouts with significantly slower traffic would be safer than I'm picturing.
- ryukafalz 5y agoIf you have a bike path alongside the car lanes, they seem to work really well. See this one for example - the red paved path is for bikes: https://i.redd.it/1vfvbvntky411.jpg https://i.redd.it/1vfvbvntky411.jpg The bike path crosses before the point where cars merge in, so the driver's attention isn't split. Also, it may not be obvious from the picture, but the car lanes are raised to the level of the bike path where they intersect.
- raffraffraff 5y agoThe problem with these roundabouts is that a car driver cannot simply "exit the roundabout". They have to watch front, side and rear for cyclists. IMHO a roundabout should only ever impede traffic on entry. Once you're in the roundabout your journey around and out should be entirely unimpeded. Following the basic principles, there should never be a situation where a vehicle is going around the outter circumference of the roundabout blocking a vehicle from exiting. (Even a bicycle)
- nabilhat 5y agoThe photos in the article are irrelevant to both subject of the title - city streets, and turning left away from controlled intersections: The intersections are large, arterial-scale, rather than typical surface streets in a city. Both have medians to prevent left turns away from the signalled intersections. The first photo also provides an example of a left turn lane blocked by a t-bone crash of two drivers who appear to have not been turning at the time of their crash. That's one way to stop drivers from turning left, but perhaps not the best possible traffic control strategy. Side note - Based on a quick search of the article's tagline, this article was simultaneously broadcast across many outlets on June 2nd, 2021 [0]. Someone had a motivation to get this distributed far and wide. [0] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22sick+of+dangerous+city+traffic%22 https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22sick+of+dangerous+city+traffic%...
- bostonabrams 5y agoNothing evil about the motivation: this article is from The Conversation (my employer) and we distribute all of our articles widely under a Creative Commons license: https://theconversation.com/us/republishing-guidelines https://theconversation.com/us/republishing-guidelines Our motivation is to publish articles by experts sharing their knowledge and spark discussion, as has been done here on Hacker News: https://theconversation.com/us/who-we-are https://theconversation.com/us/who-we-are
- mastrsushi 5y agoSick of dangerous city traffic? Leave
- tengbretson 5y agoExisting on only 2 dimensions has made my life much simpler and safer.
- _the_inflator 5y agoJames Dean died in an accident caused by just that: "Intersections are dangerous because they are where cars, often moving very fast and in different directions, must cross paths." "As Turnupseed's Ford crossed over the center line..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_James_Dean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_James_Dean Redacted photo (save, only the street is shown), that shows the intersected lines: https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-scene-of-james-dean-crash-scene-of-james-deans-car-crash-1955-31280331.html https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-scene-of-james-dean-crash-...
- acd 5y agoActually to have safer cities remove cars from the traffic equation. A city without cars will be safer and cleaner for pedestrians and bikes. Air quality will also be better.
- benrbray 5y agoYes please! It's unfortunate that this article and so many others focus on how we can design roads to be safer and more convenient for drivers, often requiring larger traffic control devices that make cities even more unnavigable for the rest of us. You know what's crazier the more I think about it, that the article doesn't even mention? With turn-on-red, and an abundance of intersections without dedicated left-turn signals, pedestrian crossings in America are rarely protected. Turners-on-red rarely come to a stop, and are usually looking to the left, meaning they don't notice a crossing pedestrian until the last minute. Same for left-turners, who are paying more attention to the opposite lane. When left-turners misjudge the speed of oncoming traffic, you can bet they'll sooner accelerate into a pedestrian in the crosswalk than allow the oncoming car to hit them. I ran into this problem (or rather, this problem nearly ran into me) quite often in Atlanta, where many impatient drivers use neighborhood streets to leapfrog standstill highway traffic. On the bright side, the city is experimenting with scramble crossings, which feel quite a bit safer to me.
- Ericson2314 5y agoWhew glad to find others saying the same thing. Optimizing car usage in cities is just such a painful misallocation of research effort to read about. Only saving grace is bike roundabouts really are nice. And if we had bike lines grade separated from pedestrians everywhere[1], it could be quite fast even to the point where roundabouts are necessary because the alternative of constantly burning energy on deceleration is so annoying. [1]: A dangerous and macho-sounding idea I nonetheless will involuntary think about every red light.
- dionidium 5y agoAnd quieter. You'll often hear that cities are noisy places, but they aren't, really; it's just that cars are very loud.
- IgorPartola 5y agoI used to live near Boston and work in Boston. Traffic patterns there defy all logic until you think about the fact that the city was laid out before cars and so it’s not sized for cars, and definitely not delivery trucks. My suggestion is to remove cars altogether from that city. Like you aren’t allowed to drive a car into the city limits and delivery trucks are only allowed on certain days or hours (mail being treated separately). Then replace the Green line and a large number of streets with covered moving walkways and the rest with walk paths and bicycle lanes. Would the city economy suffer? Maybe. Would it be a more pleasant place to live and work? I think so.
- ryukafalz 5y ago> Would the city economy suffer? Maybe. Would it be a more pleasant place to live and work? I think so. The results of some European cities doing basically this suggest that the city economy likely wouldn't really suffer (and in fact could improve in many cases). That said you don't need to completely eliminate cars; blocking through traffic and severely restricting car parking can have much the same effect. If you can take a direct route on foot/by bike but have to take a more circuitous route by car, more people will do the former.
- brezina 5y agoThis article is so auto-centric, the author only considers the safety of people inside cars. Banning left turns in cities is a GREAT idea! The group of people most threatened by left turning cars are people walking. Control F for "pedestrian" or "walk" in this article. Nothing. American traffic engineering is so car-dominant, they fail to consider the most vulnerable road users. Pedestrian fatalities in the USA are at 30 year highs. Design for the healthy human living habitat we desperately need. Good human habitat requires safe walking infrastructure for humans of all ages, sizes & abilities.
- hungryforcodes 5y agoActually the safest way to make cities less dangerous is to just ban people from going outside.
- pixel_tracing 5y agoYes banning left turns will definitely stop drivers from illegal left turns /s
- failwhaleshark 5y agoAnd right turns for those driving on the wrong side of the road. ;-)
- lamontcg 5y agoThere's a lot of really idiotic left turns across multiple lanes of traffic which are allowed outside of traffic light controlled intersections. Those lead directly to the "wave of death" situation where people (if they've been explicitly given such a wave or not) tend to try to bolt across traffic that they can't see coming. A traffic safety solution would be to just eliminate those left turns and run the lane divider bumps down the middle of those roads. Businesses would probably scream quite a bit since left turns into their parking lots would no longer be possible, but you'd cut out a ton of accidents. Suicide lanes turning across multiple lane would also similarly need to be removed. There are a ton of drivers who try to push through deeply stupid left turns in the middle of heavy traffic, because they're technically legal. Even making them do a U-turn at the next light would be safer (or yes, roundabouts, please).
- dghughes 5y agoMy city has implemented a displaced left turn. It goes bynother names. Traffic wanting to turn left is shunted leftwards before the main intersection. Then in its own left lane left turning traffic turns left when all other traffic goes straight except for right turns. Right turning vehicles have their own light.
- awillen 5y agoIf you found this interesting, I highly recommend the book Street Fight by Janette Sadik-Khan. She was the Commissioner of the NYDOT, and she was able to make really meaningful improvements by looking at relatively easy, low-cost solutions that didn't require enormous political capital. Things like expanding the sidewalk at corners out into the lane where cars are parked, which reduces the length of crosswalks and lowers pedestrian injuries. It's not just an interesting book about transportation infrastructure, it also really has some great lessons for startups about finding ways to make change in large, hairy systems where many of the participants don't want change.
- aussieguy1234 5y agoIf you're reading this from Australia or any other country that drives on the left, removing right turns has the same effect.
- whalesalad 5y agoThe Michigan Left is such a great concept. Instead of turning left, you turn right and every boulevard has tons of dedicated u-turn lanes. So to go right, you turn right easy peasy. To go left, you also go right and then make your way to the left lane where you will be able to turn around and go your desired direction. There are so many of them that if you miss the one you want, there will be another a hundred feet down the road. It’s great. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left
- fitzie 5y agowhen I lived on California i was amazed at how many pedestrian deaths there were in San Francisco, a city mired with no left turn rules. they allowed right on red, which I think contributed. I think most traffic engineers know about the green wave and improving traffic flow, but the political mission is to slow traffic to save lives and encourage mass transit. it's a shame