12 ms·
Publish and Perish
- hirundo 5y ago> But Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine was developed in a few hours back in January 2020. After which over 150 million people got sick and over 3 million people died. It seems possible that the regulatory rigidity responsible for the long roll out is a greater mortal threat than the virus itself. It's hard to imagine plausible scenarios in which a complete failure to regulate could have been more destructive. We have met the enemy and he is us. Apparently the most important technology that we lack to prevent a repeat isn't biotech, but the means to regulate the regulators.
- netrus 5y agoThe plan is in inject 6 Billion people with $vaccine. I have no medical expertise, but the idea of >3 million people dying from 6 Billion unregulated injections does not seem outlandish to me. Edit: especially taking into account one of the main tasks of the regulators was to decide _which_ vaccine to choose. If I remember correctly, there were hundreds of vaccines in development. In hindsight we know which ones were the right choice, but that's the result of rigoros, regulated, time-consuming testing.
- saalweachter 5y agoLet's also keep in mind that the timeline for approving the vaccine still pales in comparison to the timeline for manufacturing and distributing it. Phase III trials for Pfizer took ~16 weeks. It has been 26 weeks since the US granted an EUA based on that trial. In the 26 weeks since then, ~14% of the world has been vaccinated. And that's after we spent those 16 weeks of the trial building out manufacturing capacity. We did skip a lot of steps on this vaccine. When we started mass administration of it, we had no idea whether it would prevent or reduce transmission or just symptomatic infection. We are still figuring out how long we expect immunity to last, whether we need boosters every six months or never. Maybe once we have the technological capacity to manufacture and distribute 8 billion vaccine doses ~instantly it will make sense to skip the "does this even work?" step, but as long as that remains the bottleneck I have a hard time believing it.
- ipaddr 5y agoYou missed the does this have any long term effects on 6 billion people. Without long term testing we may find out in 5 years those who had the vaccine may suffer some side effects unknown today. More worrying is if in the future this delivery model becomes the norm where we roll out solutions before fully testing to save money.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIn my opinion, that's the largest selling point of mRNA vaccines. In 4 weeks you can have the entire world's productivity capacity changed into whatever vaccine you deem urgent, and when it's not urgent, you can just store it in a computer's hard drive. Once this is possible¹, we can ask governments to keep some extra capacity unused to respond to emergencies. What is different from any previous tech, where extra capacity would be useless nearly every time. 1 - AKA, when the patents expire. I vote for greatly rewarding the people that developed them and taking the patents away, but I'm sure that won't happen, so I hope we don't see any larger pandemics for 15 years.
- shoto_io 5y agoI think back in April 2020, the NYT published a calculator where you could play around with the variables to see when a vaccine could be ready. The best you could do back then was mid 2021… I think we have come a long way and pushed the boundaries substantially.
- WnZ39p0Dgydaz1 5y ago> Of late he feels like all the activity of himself and his peers is just playing the Science Game: varying some variable with infinite degrees of freedom and then throwing statistics at it until you get that reportable p-value and write up a narrative short story around it. Just like ML research, we just skip the p-values.
- belval 5y agoThe classic "we achieve SOTA on ImageNet by using a novel training procedure" where they just played with learning rate schedules until they got 0.1% over previous SOTA. To be fair to there are a lot of smells in DL papers, usually you can tell whether an approach is worth your time by looking at code availability, lab, previous publications and the conference where it was published.
- robwwilliams 5y agoGood zinger.
- ___luigi 5y ago> .. may one day pose similar risks due to the run-away prestige games scientists play. It is happening in front of our eyes. From where should we start. (1) Responsible AI, but the outcomes didn't challenge AI research enough to stop some of the practices. I would avoid commenting on what happened at Google AI recently, but I would say that most of the AI-based solutions that are deployed at large scale can be challenged. (2) paperswithcode.com solved this issue. Back in the day, we would re-implement models that we see in the paper. When we email authors, we will always figure that an RA implemented the solution and s/he left. (4) Rich is becoming richer. There is a phenomena in academia to blindly trust those who are in good labs. I have seen many papers that are great coming from these labs, but there are bad papers as well. we shouldn't just blindly trust ppl. (5) Review process is broken. Review is a voluntarily work for professors, and imho it shouldn't. In industrial R&D, reviews are one of the most important things as part of the work. Some of our PRs takes days. (6) All recommendation engines are black-boxes. I don't know what YT or FB recommend to a kid and whether this is aligned with some of our values. If s/he accidentally watch something bad, we noticed that their timeline is full by the same ideas. In our spare time, we tried to check if we can influence this behavior as a user. I figured that all of our recommendations engines are black-boxes. I don't know why we don't challenges. I hacked an App to fetch data, new, feed and run it through recommendation engine and started customizing what I can read. (7) It's 2021, most of good papers are coming from industrial labs.
- borrowcheckfml 5y agoI agree that (4) is a problem but there is also some signal in brand name. There is such a flood of (mostly low quality) papers that it's impossible to look at their content to judge what's worth reading. If you want to be at the forefront of research you can't wait to see which one stand the test of time. That's why I fall back on trusting brand name labs. They are "staking" their reputation on a paper. If a paper turns out to be absolute BS their reputation suffers. Even if all talent is equally distributed, this makes it more likely that papers from brand name researchers and institutions are carefully reviewed because they have something to lose. This isn't right, but what is the alternative? (7) Because most resarch happens in industry labs. Many university academics have left, or at least have dual positions in university and industry. (2) IMO paperswithcode didn't solve much. It's nice, but just publishing code doesn't fix any of the incentive problems. You still don't know how that code was generated. Most likely by tuning random knobs until something worked.
- ehnto 5y agoI had no idea the article was littered with links, as the colour difference is too small to see for me and my monitor. They look like the same colour to me. If Substack feels a different colour for links is too distracting or tacky, maybe they could consider a little icon denoting a link. But it's not very good web etiquette to hide links like that.
- extra88 5y agoOn the web, links are underlined by default, a clear, non-color way to visually convey they're links. It has become way too common for sites to remove that styling, maybe showing the underline when the cursor is hovered (useless on mobile devices without a cursor); this one doesn't even show the styling on :focus to make the visible on keyboard navigation.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoThe underline is an affordance, an indicator that it's special. The problem with removing it is there is no way to see it's a link without affirmatively taking an action over the text. Plus, on touch screens, there is no hovering.
- Cyril_HN 5y agoUnderlining is a common way to indicate links. However, Substack allows the author to decide whether to make links bright blue or merely underlined.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoHow would people with screenreaders or limited central vision use this site?
- extra88 5y agoWhile most screen reader users have some vision, screen reader software is mostly not affected by styling changes so they will still say "link" when there is one. People with various kinds of low vision (or color blindness) who do not use a screen reader but use text enlargement, screen zooming, etc. would have a particularly hard time differentiating the links from the surrounding text.
- rook166 5y ago> If you ask a gain-of-function proponent, they will say that by creating viruses that might emerge in nature, you get to understand zoonotic jumps from animals to humans better and possibly prevent them. Specifically, you get a head-start on developing vaccines for them. This possibility of curing future diseases might be true in some cases. But Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine was developed in a few hours back in January 2020. I've been wondering about this for the last few months, I feel like this "better prepare for future viruses" argument is substantially weaker now — coronaviruses were a well-known group of viruses, there was already research directed at gain-of-function work for this family of viruses, and yet as far as I'm aware the mRNA vaccines that were developed derived no benefit from any of that research. So whether or not the virus came from a lab, why should we fund this kind of work since it seems not to be very useful?
- greazy 5y agoThere's more to GoF research than developing vaccines. Sometimes its trying to understand host virus interaction, virus evolution, zoonotic events. The list goes on. The majority of primary research is not at all interested in vaccine development. For coronaviruses they're a huge family of viruses. Sometimes it's not transferable between species
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoThe argument the post is presenting seems like it could be a straw man. Gain-of-function research would surely be useful to things other than vaccines, which might even be more important than vaccines? For example, figuring out in what conditions viruses jump hosts and therefore how to reduce the likelihood of new epidemics.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoWhy wouldn't Gain-of-Function be helpful for research on oncolytic viruses (viruses that target cancer cells)?
- recursivedoubts 5y ago> The only consensus is no consensus. We may never know. Well that's refreshing. Of course, the preceding paragraph gives a lot of strong evidence for a lab link. > Baseless conspiracy theories will run wild, like the American government did it on purpose... or that the Chinese government released it on their own citizens. These aren’t true. And here again we fall into the "things I don't like can't possibly be true" trap, which is just as ridiculous as the wild-eye'd absolutist conspiracy theory position. Consider: There were military games in Wuhan just before the outbreak.[1] Apparently intelligence knew about the coronavirus as early as November[2]. Iran's senior leadership was hit very hard by the virus[3]. Do these facts prove that the virus was intentionally released? Of course not. But we have to at least consider the possibility. If it was intentionally released, does that mean the US or China did it? Of course not. It could have been a rogue group within either of those two countries, another country entirely (trying to stir up tensions?), or a non-governmental group. As the author noted previously: we may never know. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Military_World_Games https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Military_World_Games [2] - https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/intelligence-report-warned-coronavirus-crisis-early-november-sources/story?id=70031273 https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/intelligence-report-warned-c... [3] - https://www.wsj.com/articles/as-irans-leaders-contract-coronavirus-doubts-emerge-over-national-tally-11582903223 https://www.wsj.com/articles/as-irans-leaders-contract-coron...
- evrydayhustling 5y agoScience prestige games suck. But the lynchpin of this thesis is the assertion that gain-of-function research didn't (and won't) improve our ability to respond to epidemics with vaccines and policies. That point isn't substantially argued in the post, author just says that one COVID vaccine was developed in hours. Anyone near the field able to give a perspective?
- mxcrossr 5y agoI think the author just has a complaint about the scientific process (and believe me, all scientists do…) and is trying to fit this topic to that complaint. I doubt that it’s helpful. If we think there aren’t enough safeguards about this kind of research, I think the solution is to restrict funding, not to assume that changing the research incentive structure would stop it.
- Imnimo 5y agoOne might accuse the author of playing a game of his own, where his writing is driven by a desire to get clicks rather than a desire to communicate factually...
- ankurdhama 5y agoIMHO research about human body in general and immune system in specific is more useful to improve our ability to respond to epidemics with vaccines than gain-of-function research.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoThe Moderna covid vaccine was developed in a few hours, because extensive work had already been done on the SARS virus. They could very easily tell by homology which part of the RNA sequence coded for the spike protein. I suppose theoretically, generating novel viruses could prepare us for similarly quick vaccine design in the absence of a natural predecessor, but that would be a huge stretch requiring us to invent vast numbers of novel viruses.
- throw737858 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fridif 5y agoscientific papers are not a good medium of knowledge transfer. show me the code and or a demo.
- jampekka 5y agoAs a researcher I would gladly do this. Unfortunately the funding game doesn't support this at all. I agree that papers are not good for knowledge transfer, but they are required if you want to keep a roof on your head. Academic community seems to be unable do little else than complain about this. Even though at least in countries I'm familiar with (Finland and UK), academic community mostly runs the funding system as well, although some outside politics do shape it too. I think what is needed is public pressure to academia and politicians to fix this mess. Unfortunately any criticism of science from the outside seems to be thrown into conspiracy theory category, but this is done mostly by non-academics.
- jpeloquin 5y agoIf COVID-19 did come from a (accidental) leak from gain of function research, presumably the pandemic itself counts as a demo. Which leads to the posted article's point---it may be better to not do any gain of function research on viruses that are already well-understood, regardless of how well the research is or isn't communicated.
- jltsiren 5y agoPapers are good for communicating the big picture: what is being done, why certain choices were made, and how things are supposed to work. Writing them is useful, because it forces you to think about the big picture. It's common that people who have spent months or years working on a project suddenly understand some aspects of it better when they try to communicate it to other people. Code is good for communicating details, but very few people actually read research code. Those who do usually just check a few details, because it's hard to justify spending weeks or months studying a single project. It doesn't help that the code was probably written before anyone understood what was the exact problem they were trying to solve and what would be a good way of solving it.
- trentnix 5y ago> It is immensely unfortunate this issue became politicized. This comment is over a year too late. Almost immediately after COVID became the topic du jour the technocrats and media were aggressively shutting down anyone who noticed the circumstantial evidence that the coronavirus emerged in close proximity to a lab conducting sloppy coronavirus research. That, coupled with China's refusal to allow anyone outside the CCP apparatus to investigate should have, at least, given thinking people pause. But clearly, "thinking people" doesn't characterize the media or the technocrats and their speech police. And we shouldn't forget the astonishingly sudden about-face by the media (almost all of whom work for companies who also sell their entertainment properties in China) who routinely called COVID the "China virus" or "Wuhan virus" one day and the next day castigated anyone who dared to do so as an irredeemable racist. It was political from the beginning.
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoA lot of this “circumstantial evidence” was and is game-of-telephone nonsense. Many mix together two completely different institutions (the Wuhan Center for Disease Control and the Wuhan Institute of Virology) which are several kilometres apart, for example. (Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab-r0capbzk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab-r0capbzk is a great look at said game of telephone.)
- dimgl 5y agoI’m not sure this is a valid counterargument. The intent is clear when someone says “it likely leaked from the lab in Wuhan”… I’m surprised how pedantic everything has gotten.
- btmorex 5y agoIt's actually this exact attitude that kept it out of the media. I'm curious: what is your goal? Everyone can see the glaringly obvious circumstantial evidence that it was a lab leak. At this point, comments like your's just look ridiculous.
- LudwigNagasena 5y ago
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoI used to work in one of the top fMRI labs. The comments about The Science Game are spot on. The vast majority of scientists, by the time they're midway through their postdocs, just want to do whatever research will get them a professorship and some grants. Actual knowledge generation is a distant second to keeping the ball bouncing by getting out papers and getting in grants.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoJust want to add, it's generally not a conscious choice. Everyone wants to do something that is both a genius experiment and gets published in Nature. The Science Game gets propagated in how scientists conceive and plan their work. Everything must be done in the paradigm of publications and grants. You can't do anything if it doesn't have at least interim results within a year or two. It's an unfathomable career risk to try something absolutely brand new. There's a good chance it fails, at which point you have a 2 year blank spot in your CV and you can never get back in the top 10% of scientists where you need to be to get R01 funding and run your own lab.
- mirker 5y agoOne problem is the incentives are biased toward “ok” papers. h-index should be replaced with a more competitive index (e.g., Max over citations). The publication hyper-competitiveness is due to publication spam, which boosts citation and publication count. However, twisting a knob and getting slightly different results should be viewed as a failed project.
- ModernMech 5y ago> The publication hyper-competitiveness is due to publication spam, which boosts citation and publication count. The publication hyper-competitiveness is a direct result of grant hyper-competitiveness. Funding rates at top US agencies are around 10-20%. Grants are how researchers fund their research, pay their students, pay themselves, and earn tenure, so there's a lot riding on getting them. I see a lot of talk about the problems with publications on HN and possible fixes to the publication process (like requiring code for example, or as you suggest changing the important metrics), but publications really are just a proxy (and prerequisite) for the grant application process. You can change around the publication process all you want, but nothing will improve unless you address the issue of grants, because that's where the money is.
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoThe Science Game is a natural result of the marketisation of science. (It's not the only factor of course.)
- phreeza 5y agoOthers would argue it's kind of the opposite, funding of science by risk-averse and bureaucratic government agencies.
- derbOac 5y agoIt's really both. At least some of the marketing hype, maybe most of the hype, in the scientific community tends to coalesce around ideas that are obvious already, or that are on everyone's minds, or are appealing for very risk-averse reasons (something that allows one to churn out papers). The funding is risk averse along these same lines, in that it tends to follow slightly dated hype.
- erikhoel 5y agoAuthor here. Happy to be listening in on some of the thoughts of HN. If you have a specific question or thought feel free to AMA.
- jollybean 5y agoDo you think your thesis would be controversial within the Scientific Community, at least if discussions were to be had in public? Does the Scientific community have enough self-awareness about this to do something about it, and are calls for 'creating new viruses' being actively made and addressed?
- erikhoel 5y agoI actually think most working scientists agree about The Science Game. Almost everyone thinks of things this way in their darker moments, or talks among other scientists like that, although it is a bit of an "open secret." For gain-of-function research in particular, I don't imagine it will survive this news cycle. It has been banned for periods of time before (I believe last ban ended in 2017) and there's almost no way it doesn't get and likely stay banned, at least in the USA.
- toomim 5y agoWhat path in life led you to write articles like this? If you are still a practicing scientist, do you fear any repercussions to speaking against the community like this?
- sdeep27 5y agoGreat article, I think an important one as well. The 'Science Game', really just a misalignment of incentives, seems to be at the core of other issues in science research - the replication problem in social sciences comes to mind (for me, as a non-academic). What do you see as possible solution(s) to this problem?
- dredmorbius 5y agoTechnical site nit: your links are very hard to see as styled even on a colour / emissive display. On my e-ink reader, they're impossible. Note sure if that's your choice or Substack's, but either way, it could stand improvement. (Unfortunately, styling annoyances stand between content and topical response and criticism.) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27412599 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27412599
- walterbell 5y agoVirus and therapeutics researchers, for future history books: Ron Fouchier, Netherlands Yoshihiro Kawaoka, Japan Alexander Kagansky, Russia (died 2020) Bing Liu, USA (died 2020) Frank Plummer, Canada (died 2019) Gita Ramjee, South Africa (died 2020)
- failwhaleshark 5y agoIs this a conspiracy theory dogwhistle, or supposition of uncoordinated acts of stochastic assassination?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- phreeza 5y agoI've seen so many posts about or at least implicitly accepting the lab leak hypothesis in a very short time now, that it almost seems like some sort of concerted campaign to me. Would be interesting to know if there is an upvoting block doing this. Did I miss any new evidence coming out? Everything I saw so far seemed rather circumstantial.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoThis is a pretty good summary of the lab leak hypothesis: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/06/the-lab-leak-theory-inside-the-fight-to-uncover-covid-19s-origins https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/06/the-lab-leak-theory-... Evaluate it on its own merits. Personally I think it's incredibly compelling, but there are certainly many smart people who disagree.
- codyb 5y agoI don’t really have an opinion one way or the other to offer on your concerted campaign comment or the origins of the covid 19 virus but my understanding is basically this… People postulated Trump politicized Others kept researching and found important facts There was internal fighting and dissension throughout various entities about whether or not to pursue these inquiries Certain initial assessments may have been tainted by the biases of their authors And we’re in the stage now where the inconsistencies, biases, and details are all coming out in this steady trickle and things are snowballing a bit.
- Invictus0 5y agoThere's a good writeup here: https://project-evidence.github.io/ https://project-evidence.github.io/
- raphlinus 5y agoThe latest commit to that anonymously authored repo is over a year ago. I am a bit tired of these "we are an anonymous group pushing the truth" efforts; in the case of HCQ they are unmitigated bullshit. The best sourced argument for lab leak is the Drastic project[1]. This is basically the work that's been getting the media attention for the last few weeks. A good source for arguments holding the lab leak unlikely (there is of course no evidence strong enough to rule it out entirely) is episodes 760 and 762 of the podcast This Week in Virology[2]. Skeptics of authority would say that this is the community of virologists covering their own back. Others who basically believe in science [ETA: meaning basically trust scientists; this is a pretty complex concept to unpack] will find passionate and knowledgeable experts explaining why they find the lab leak hypothesis unlikely. [1]: https://drasticresearch.org/ https://drasticresearch.org/ [2]: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/ https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/
- rvba 5y agoPeople dont call it the way it should be called: "gain of function" is basically biological weapon research. You make a new disease and (supposedly) try to find a treatment for it. Yet somehow we dont hear about new vaccines or drugs found in those labs. Since research on biological weapons is banned by conventions - bad actors try to overcome this by using non military labs. Russia had Biopreparat who tested multiple viruses and bacteria and then made warheads to deliver them (long after it was banned). USA's Reston "accident" with monkeys also looks like reaserch on ebola. China makes "gain of function" in Wuhan, sometimes 300 meters from the wet market testrd as place of origin of the COVID19 virus. What is gained here? Only military can gain something. Those scientists are enemies od humanity - making biological weapons, but nobody will do anything about that. Because supposedly this research can lead to new drugs. Well... where are those new drugs or vaccines? China, Russia and probably USA have those labs - a lot of money is spent, yet all real vaccines and drugs come from private labs. Not military. You can read Ken Alibek's book on his work as one of the heads of Russian biological weapons program (hidden as normal research): the guy got infected with a militarized strain of tularemia - and instead of reporting it and going yo quarantaine, he just took some antibiotics and called in sick. The negligence of someone who knows about bio weapons was astounding. You cannot rule out that same did not happen in China. In fact the press points to it: gain of funcion done in BSL2 labs. Not to mention that USA reasearchers are on China's payroll, what looks like plain treason.
- jakobnissen 5y agoNo, you can absolutely do gain of function research that is not dangerous. Gain of function merely means that you're adding some capability to a virus. It doesn't mean it has to be a virus capable of infecting humans. It doesn't mean it has to make the virus more virulent in vivo. It could be engineering bacteriophages to control resistant bacteria, for example.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoI wondered who is Erik Hoel. He is a writer and neuroscientist. His website is here: https://www.erikphoel.com/about.html https://www.erikphoel.com/about.html "I ended up receiving my PhD in neuroscience at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, where I worked with Giulio Tononi on developing aspects of Integrated Information Theory. Later I was a postdoctoral researcher at Columbia University working with Rafael Yuste, as well as a visiting scholar at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton."
- opaque 5y agoThis article is a general critique of the reward system in academia, bolted on the lab leak hypothesis for clickbait. "The Science Game" is a thing and often discussed on HN, but I don't see any causative link here. > All to say: scientists create dangerous synthetic viruses to achieve “high-impact” scientific output. Does gain of function research yield more high impact papers than more benign types of virology research? The article seems to suggest so, but provides no citations indicating that. Were the scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology publishing their research to general acclaim up until now? Given how little we know about it, doesn't seem so. Are these scientists driven by the same invectives as western university research academics? They're probably state employees on stable contracts for a start, not the PhD students and itinerant PostDocs of the university system, who are the main players of the Science Game. I don't know the answers to these questions, but the article would be more persuasive if it did.
- akkartik 5y ago> Does gain of function research yield more high impact papers than more benign types of virology research? The article puts "high-impact" in quotes. The thesis as I understood it is not that gain-of-function research is higher impact, but that it's _a_ fertile knob capable of stamping out adequate papers. The externalities here should put it out of bounds of the Science Game. The author is basically saying, go find other knobs to play your games.
- azakai 5y agoI'm skeptical of the article's point, but I think it does try to answer this question of yours: > Does gain of function research yield more high impact papers than more benign types of virology research? The article seems to suggest so, but provides no citations indicating that. The article's argument is that gain-of-function research moves the researcher from the set of existing viruses to the set of all the viruses we can create - a far, far larger set, and hence one that allows more publications. Or, to put it another way, after you've run out of viruses to find, and things to publish about them, creating more gives you many more papers to write. There may be something to that argument, but I still agree with your general point that the article needs more evidence.
- 5y ago
- failwhaleshark 5y agoIt's a tangent on the example given, but the bigger question is: Does the origin of SARS-CoV-2 really matter at this point? I think it's moot and the lab speculation trope comes across as an agenda-driven conspiracy theory. We can reduce our risks by having strict international conventions on pathogen labs and engineering, eliminating high-density meat agriculture, and reducing overuse of antibiotics/antimycotics/antivirals. Pragmatically, human pathogens should be treated with the same care as nuclear weapons as a matter of risk-management.
- Judgmentality 5y ago> Does the origin of SARS-CoV-2 really matter at this point? I hear this question so often I'm beginning to get upset. Yes, it absolutely 100% matters for the same reason it matters that we learn about anything. Why would we ever want to restrict our knowledge and be willfully ignorant? At this point I just assume the only reason is political. And when has that ever been a good thing for humanity or history? For all we know China is purposefully manufacturing viruses as weapons (in fact there is already some evidence of this happening), and you think it doesn't matter? Honestly none of the anti-China propaganda ever really seemed to do anything for me, but nothing has made me more leery of China than the wall of "we don't really need to know where covid came from" comments I see on the internet. I don't know or care if the person I am replying to is a shill, but I have never seen such a strong front defending ignorance before in my life. JFC everything gets flagged now instead of anyone having a discussion. I'm directly responding to part of the comment which I believe to already be political, so I'm just trying to continue the conversation that OP started. Maybe if most comments suggesting we should explore this issue weren't so quickly flagged on HN it would make me more receptive to the idea this isn't an organized political front.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoIt matters politically. There is a reason both US and China did what they did in terms of messaging. And it does not make sense until you recognize potential political fallout from it. How would it affect your opinion if covid19 gain of function research was funded by US? How would it affect your opinion if it there is an actual proof of China developing this virus? Both have their ramifications and they are not even mutually exclusive.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> In virology, there are only so many dials—only so many natural viruses. .... The big excitement is in finding a new virus How is that supposed to jibe with articles like this in which, unless I badly misread things, the authors found FORTY FIVE THOUSAND new viruses? https://www.pnas.org/content/118/23/e2023202118 https://www.pnas.org/content/118/23/e2023202118
- mynameisvlad 5y agoYour study seems to be looking at remnants of viruses “left behind” in our collective genome by analyzing datasets. The viruses are hypothetical in nature, and might not be complete (they remark in the abstract that some have nearly complete genomes). Finding them would be worthy of a paper, some of them might be complete enough to be able to produce further insights, but at the end of the day there’s only so much you can do when you don’t have a live virus to “tweak the dials” so to speak. 45k is certainly a lot of potentially interesting viruses to study, sure, but it’s a finite supply and the quality of genomes will likely further reduce this number. And that’s kind of where the OP comes back into play. Sure, these new viruses were found, but how much can they contribute to the “Science Game”? Especially compared to a live virus you can tweak and play with to your heart’s content to make whatever you want.
- bigbillheck 5y agoWith respect, I think you need to re-skim that paper. > Your study seems to be looking at remnants of viruses “left behind” in our collective genome by analyzing datasets. You appear to be confusing the 'genome' and 'metagenome'. The genome does have plenty of viral remnants[0] that by and large are incomplete fragments. The 'metagenome' in this case is taken from the Human Microbiome Project[1], which took samples of the microbiome from various regions of the bodies of various humans[2], and then sequenced basically everything in there that they could. > might not be complete (they remark in the abstract that some have nearly complete genomes). The only thing about completeness in the abstract I'm looking at is "with historically high per-genome completeness". Later in the paper they write "A total of 14,034 contigs (31.2%) were estimated to be high-quality (90 to 100% complete)" which I'd call more than 'some'! > but at the end of the day there’s only so much you can do when you don’t have a live virus to “tweak the dials” so to speak Many viruses are not currently able to be cultivated. This doesn't mean that they aren't important, or that they can't be studied. For a different example, consider the anelloviruses. From [3]: """ Anelloviruses are small, single stranded circular DNA viruses. They are extremely diverse and have not been associated with any disease so far. Strikingly, these small entities infect most probably the complete human population, and there are no convincing examples demonstrating viral clearance from infected individuals. The main transmission could be via fecal-oral or airway route, as infections occur at an early age. However, due to the lack of an appropriate culture system, the virus–host interactions remain enigmatic. Anelloviruses are obviously mysterious viruses, and their impact on human life is not yet known, but, with no evidence of a disease association, a potential beneficial effect on human health should also be investigated. """ The way I read this, you are almost certainly infected with anelloviruses, I am almost certainly infected with anelloviruses, we don't know how they're transmitted, we don't know what cells they target, and in fact we don't know very much about what it's doing in there at all. > a finite supply Well sure, and there's only so many hundreds of millions of years before the sun devours the earth. Hoel writes: """ In virology, there are only so many dials—only so many natural viruses. And each is a source of competition, as famous labs make claims to various viruses to study and monopolize them by beating others to publication. The big excitement is in finding a new virus, mapping the genome, figuring out its function and transmissibility, comparing to other viruses, etc.""" How many virology labs are out there? The American Society of Virology has about 2500 members[4] in the US, Canada, and Mexico. Multiply by 10 to bring in the rest of the world (surely an overestimate, if anything) gives you 25000, which is still less than the number of brand-new viruses found in this one study! And that's just from a handful of samples focusing on one organism (albeit one of particular interest). Wiki lists 96 families of virus[5], some of which have dozens of subpages. Viruses are everywhere you look, and infect every kind of life on earth including each other[6] I'm also not convinced that labs can "monopolize them by beating others to publication". Many viruses are worked by many labs. As just a quick example, I searched biorxiv for 'herpes' (it's a virus!) and of the first few papers that looked like virology I found authors affiliated with Cambridge (Departments of Pathology, Veterinary Medicine, and Medicine, as well as the Institute for Medical Research) [7], the European Molecular Biology Lab [7], University of Berlin [7], University of Columbo [7], LSU [8], Albert Einstein College of Medicine [9] (Departments of Microbiology and Immunology, Pediatrics, and Medicine), Institute for Virology (Zurich) [10], University of Bern[10]. This doesn't seem like monopolization to me. > quality of genomes will likely further reduce this number 14034 new genomes is still an awful lot, and so is the text in this post, so I'll stop here. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus [1] https://hmpdacc.org/hmp/publications.php https://hmpdacc.org/hmp/publications.php [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5831082/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5831082/ [3] https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/44/3/305/5809966 https://academic.oup.com/femsre/article/44/3/305/5809966 [4] https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2021/04/cornell-virologist-elected-president-worlds-foremost-virology-society https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2021/04/cornell-virologist-... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Viruses_by_family https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Viruses_by_family [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sputnik_virophage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sputnik_virophage with a bit of poetic license. [7] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.04.13.439638v2.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.04.13.439638v2.... [8] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.05.442792v1.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.05.442792v1.... [9] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.05.442792v1.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.05.442792v1.... [10] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.12.23.424160v2.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.12.23.424160v2....
- FriendlyNormie 5y agoThis retarded faggot can blow it out his dickhole. I’m 100% certain he was one of the NPCs telling everyone spreading the lab leak theory in early 2020 to kill themselves. His hands need to be surgically removed and his mouth stitched shut.
- ctoth 5y agoUnrelated to the article, but the author linked to his novel and I grabbed it and have been rather enjoying it on this lazy Sunday. https://www.amazon.com/Revelations-Novel-Erik-Hoel/dp/1419750224 https://www.amazon.com/Revelations-Novel-Erik-Hoel/dp/141975...