14 ms·
> Bukele said the country is partnering with digital wallet company, Strike, to build modern financial infrastructure using bitcoin technology. Wow, this seems
by smoldesu 5y ago
> Bukele said the country is partnering with digital wallet company, Strike, to build modern financial infrastructure using bitcoin technology.
Wow, this seems like an incredibly shitty situation for the people of El Salvador. It looks like some lobbyists got hired by a wallet company stacked with angel investors willing to pour money into the idea of being integrated into the government at such a low level. I wouldn't be surprised if they also announced that all transactions will be forced to go through a wrapper or other type of layer, maybe even justified with the classic "think of the coal" argument...
- Geee 5y agoTheir work is open source and they are using standard Bitcoin protocols. Zap is their wallet https://zaphq.io https://zaphq.io Strike is a payment app that uses Bitcoin Lightning network internally to settle payments between financial institutions. It's useful for sending fiat currency denominated remittances instantly and without fees. https://strike.me https://strike.me When they released Strike in El Salvador, it was an instant success. The president himself contacted Jack.
- rawtxapp 5y agoTo add on to that, it's been used pretty nicely in the El Zonte beach town [1]. 1: https://www.forbes.com/sites/tatianakoffman/2020/07/14/this-el-salvador-village-adopts-bitcoin-as-money/?sh=1c8a51bb2044 https://www.forbes.com/sites/tatianakoffman/2020/07/14/this-...
- CyberDildonics 5y agoWhen that article was written the transaction fees were around $1.50-$2.00 USD which is already a lot for meals and snacks. Now that the average transaction fees are anywhere from $7 - $60 I doubt people are buying much with bitcoin's dialup throughput. https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-transactionfees.html#3m https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-transactionfees...
- atweiden 5y agoDoesn’t the Lightning Network scale to millions of transactions per second, which is what El Salvador will be using? Fees are miniscule on LN, as well.
- CyberDildonics 5y agoThat would mean people aren't actually using bitcoin, they are using this wallet's centralized lightning network balance. If they want to actually send money to someone using bitcoin, they will have to get their balance on to the main chain, which means that they will have to take it off this wallet and then incur the transaction fees for getting to the bitcoin chain. Then they will have to take the hit of the transaction fees again to get their actual bitcoin balance somewhere else. This is what happens when you use a purposely crippled cryptocurrency like bitcoin. They could use litecoin, monero or bitcoin cash directly and not have any 'wallet app' that keeps their balance. Then they would be in control of their own money.
- atweiden 5y ago> If they want to actually send money to someone using bitcoin, they will have to get their balance on to the main chain Strike payment recipients can withdraw their USD balance as BTC to any Lightning-enabled wallet (or any other wallet, for that matter) [1]: How to purchase bitcoin with Strike 1. Open a Lightning wallet or Bitcoin wallet of your choice. (If you do not already have one, see our recommendations below) 2. Generate a receive address or invoice for the amount of btc you wish to purchase. 3. Scan with Strike and hit send. Done! You have just converted USD from Strike to btc in your wallet. [1]: https://strike.me/faq/howtopurchase https://strike.me/faq/howtopurchase
- Vecr 5y agoI don't think so, if I have inbound capacity on my lightning node (hooked to my full node, so not centralized), they can just send money to me as long as the routes through the network have enough capacity.
- 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoAccording to the article, someone donated "six-figure" amounts of Bitcoin to the town each year on the condition that they learn how to use Bitcoin: > Beneficiaries of the digital currency had to learn how to use the Bitcoin itself, creating a Bitcoin economy. If you give a relatively poor town the option to take free money as long as they learn how to use Bitcoin, of course they're going to learn how to use Bitcoin. The real test is whether Bitcoin makes sense in an otherwise functioning economy where people aren't given free Bitcoin and they have the option to use a credit card that comes with a lot of consumer protections and zero (or even negative) fees.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samatman 5y agoThe payment system mentioned in the Fine Article is built on top of Bitcoin, using Lightning Network. There's nothing stopping them from putting various consumer protections and rewards programs on top of that, and plenty of motive to do so. It's definitely a wait-and-see sort of thing, but I don't see as to how betting against it is the obvious move.
- arcticbull 5y agoWhy does the Strike app use LN or crypto at all? I just can't wrap my head around this. They're a custodial wallet for your fiat currency, right? You deposit fiat with them. You withdraw fiat from them. You move it between accounts on their service. They, or a designed entity must hold that fiat on deposit on behalf of users. When you 'send' that money (according to Jack Maller), they buy BTC for you, send it over the LN network, then convert it into a stablecoins. Which ends up, notionally, in one of the Strike custodial accounts. So this Rube Goldberg machine of crypto is used for internal account transfers within Strike? Am I missing something? They're a centralized, trusted custodian (and a registered money services business). Why are they sending money from a Strike-owned account to another Strike-owned account this way? Could they not simply record a debit on one account and a credit on another account in any kind of traditional store? One they clearly already have? Why wouldn't they have one account for each country, a small slush fund and/or debt facility to cover near-term transfers, then just record how much of the pot is attributed to each user account - and if money has to move across borders, send a wire from time to time. Is this really just the most complicated intra-company account transfer of all time? Or are they just doing it to avoid regulation?
- habibur 5y agoHow a large a "cut" they take from every transaction is the question here. As for cash,there's no cut taken by any middle man. And when the central government or bank is involved in pushing a legal currency -- there shouldn't be any cut.
- toxik 5y agoYou know damn well that banks and credit card institutions take cuts of transactions. Why this aversion to Bitcoin on HN, even with LN?
- imtringued 5y agoI agree, why would anyone provide payment infrastructure if they don't get paid?
- antb123 5y ago1) information - which might be scary. 2) government control of some kind -
- arcticbull 5y agoWhy the horror when someone asks how a free service is making their money, and how much? The quantification matters because we want to know if, in the future once they've spent all their VC money and have to make payroll themselves, it represents a better deal or not.
- lowkey 5y agoAs for cash, the “cut” that is taken is via inflation. Governments print money increasing the total supply of currency and decreasing the purchasing power of your cash. It’s also called currency debasement and has a history almost as old as currency itself.
- antihero 5y agoYeah but imagine if you bought a beer for $4 and then next week the beer was actually worth $8 and the next it was worth $7 and then a few months later the beer was worth $50. The whole point of fiat is that it is stable and so you aren't fucking yourself by exchanging it for consumables.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis kind of fiat stability is very challenging for small and poor countries. In fact, El Salvador doesn't _have_ its own currency for this reason -- they switched to the US dollar decades ago! Is it worse to peg your economy to a decentralized cryptocurrency, or a fiat currency controlled by a large powerful near-neighbor who only occasionally even remembers you exist? (and sure as hell will not modify their fiscal policy with the needs of your economy). Having a backup official decentralized currency doesn't seem ridiculous to me. Maybe I'd use Eth or something that can scale better, but the point is the same.
- bb88 5y ago> Is it worse to peg your economy to a decentralized cryptocurrency, or a fiat currency controlled by a large powerful near-neighbor who only occasionally even remembers you exist? A currency needs stability. Speculation needs volatility. Speculation only works when there's a stable currency to dump your value into when the the security your trading is going in the wrong direction.
- atweiden 5y ago> A currency needs stability. The word “currency” is inherently a tautology. How does something become a currency? > Speculation only works when there's a stable currency to dump your value into when the the security is going in the wrong direction. Precious metals long predate government monies. Gold and silver couldn’t have become currency under the definition you’ve presented here.
- chii 5y ago
- project2501a 5y agoI am Jack's complete lack of surprise when the next unrest hits El Salvador, due to US fuckery.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sadfasf122 5y agoHN bitcoin haters in shambles
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- question000 5y agoPay taxes in real money, get benefits in Disney Dollars.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Wow, this seems like an incredibly shitty situation for the people of El Salvador. Indeed it is. The government just mandated that everyone in the country is obligated to use a startup's app, more or less. This has to be one of the most egregious examples of regulatory capture I've seen in a long time. "Legal tender" means that people are legally obligated to accept this as payment. Maybe the law will be broad enough that the buyer can set the terms of how the Bitcoin is delivered, but given how prominently this Strike app and their founder are participating in the launch, I suspect it will mostly just drive users to this startup. Forcing everyone to accept Bitcoin, maybe through a specific startup company's app depending on how this is rolled out, is a weird juxtaposition to the libertarian ideals of many Bitcoiners.
- RustyRussell 5y agoLightning developer here. I have no idea what their legal definition would be, but lightning is an open standard, and Strike is but one implementation.
- foepys 5y agoHow do you as a Lighting Network developer propose that the citizens of El Salvador secure their Lighting Network Channels so they don't get drained of their funds? LN channels require each party to observe the channel for malicious transactions so they can forcefully close the channel if one occurs. Can the average user handle this or are intermediaries needed?
- wyager 5y agoLightning isn’t an app - it’s an open protocol supported by dozens of programs. This one app you’re talking about also supports it.