11 ms·
Walmart gets a lot of flak for being old school and allowing Amazon's rise, but they are one of the very few retailers who have actually been able to respond to
by paxys 5y ago
Walmart gets a lot of flak for being old school and allowing Amazon's rise, but they are one of the very few retailers who have actually been able to respond to competitive threats over the last decade or two. Walmart Labs has some great tech and hires top software talent in the industry. They aren't shy about making large acquisitions when needed (like Jet). They have built out their own delivery and logistics network and now offer 2 day, 1 day or same day shipping. They even have their own "Prime" subscription and grocery deliveries.
The business could easily have gone the way of Sears.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoIn 1982 Wal-Mart was still exclusively a rural retailer, continuing to build scale but only in towns below a certain size. It was not felt they could yet compete with more well-funded better-established chains. Most stores more closely resembled today's Dollar General than a big box There were not yet "superstores", and most people in big cities had never heard of them. With IBM PC's not yet having a significant impact on business, and almost nobody doing any data networking compared to today, Wal-Mart already had a fully computerized POS/inventory/logistics-management system in every store, integrated into their headquarters in small-town Arkansas in almost real-time, with data-mining informing the financial decision making. No one else had anything close, not Sears, Target, or Kmart, who were obviously going to end up having difficulty when Sam thought the time was right for Wal-Mart to come to the big cities. Even though all these retailers had the same computer hardware in their respective headquarters, IBM's good old "impersonal" mainframes which only big companies could afford. Walton would bus all his managers to Bentonville for a pow-wow every year, scheduled to start at 8 all week. If you got there precisely at 8, you had already missed the most important half-hour with Sam, he would start at 0730. Drove an old pickup truck too, so he could save money.
- dalbasal 5y ago>> Walmart gets a lot of flak In a way, it reminds me of "MSFT is Dead" stuff from circa 2008. Google had taken email by storm, was moving on office and seemed to be making web into their own OS. Windows Vista & IE sucked. Google just seemed so much nimbler. Apple had risen from the dead, and was reinventing consumer electronics. MSFT was looking decrepit, the next IBM. MSFT never panicked. Software was a great business to be in, and the pressure was never financial. Meanwhile, they maintained their own ways and their own cultural advantages, long term perseverance, reverse compatibility, etc. They didn't win every race. Google won mobile OS, the "browser war. MSFT's attempts at a search business didn't succeed. They did win enough though, plenty. Google was better at web based software earlier, but MSFT held on to Office/Productivity. Office 365 wasn't as slick as early, but it was/is the product businesses will pay for. Most notably, they beat Google on cloud. Cloud was in Google's wheelhouse, and emphatically not in MSFT's. They started late. Google's "paradigm" mentality was great for the early part of the game. Getting where we are today though, that required carrying old paradigms into the new world. It required lots of mess, details, requirements that don't really make sense... That is MSFT's wheelhouse. Meeting companies where they are. Its a foreign concept to Google. Today, Google is the one that seems weaker. They're plenty rich, and plenty capable technologically. They aren't very good at building businesses though. It's still all about adwords. MSFT could have gone the way of IBM.
- nly 5y agoTo be fair a lot of this is because Google can't execute properly. Office 365 just destroys Google Docs, everything MSFT offer just integrated well, is priced well. Chrome OS + Android + Docs could have been the productivity Windows PC killer if they'd executed it with vision.
- dalbasal 5y agoSure, but this covers a lot of territory. Executing well on a new paradigm for a 30 year old suite, maintaining compatibility, etc. These are really hard, and MSFT's speciality. Office became office originally for maintaining meticulous compatibility with its predecessor, Lotus. It's incredibly tedious, frustrating work. Takes a ton of perseverance. Google docs came out of the gate to oohs and ahs. It was slick. Cool, innovative features like real-time collaboration worked well. MSFT's start was much clunkier, and expectations were already high. It took years before it wasn't an embarrassment. Even then, office 365 was never cool, not even now. These two companies are at opposite ends of the spectrum. Google likes paradigms, impressive launches. Then, they expect that the paradigm, being better, will just win. Everyone will adapt to their new way. They don't have the belly for years of kludgy, schleppy work while everyone makes fun of them. Google cloud was a great example of this. It was early. It solved the problems that needed solving, in theory... especially the sexy ones. Everyone just needed to abandon everything they had been doing and come over to the New Way. This is the exact opposite mentality to the one that maintains badly thought out feature of excel from 1996, itself design to clumsily support Lotus notes features from 1985. A million boring details, technical debt and nothing sexy. Where there's muck there's brass.
- mschuetz 5y ago> Office 365 just destroys Google Docs I disagree. Office licensing and the whole Microsoft account managament is so incredibly annoying to the point where I prefer the google suite simply because it works. Office recently left me stranded with an outdated license and no way to enable it because the ones in charge were not in office that day, so I went with google, and I'm sticking to it now even though there would be the option to enable to license. I don't want to go through the same hoops and hurdles every 6 months again.
- nly 5y agoIt is surprising what businesses have managed to keep up with Amazon. I was amazed last year to find Argos, a traditional bricks and mortar catalogue based outlet here in the UK, now offer a good website and next day delivery to most of the mainland, and at competitive prices.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> allowing Amazon's rise By doing what, clearing out the rest of the local competition?
- fnord77 5y agoI forgot all about Jet until you just mentioned them. I should look into them as an amazon replacement.
- ramphastidae 5y agoJet is gone. Shame, I was a fan.
- bushbaba 5y agoAnd yet I don’t use them. I use Etsy. I use chewy. I use other niche e-commerce but I never use Walmart online. They can’t just replicate Amazon they have to be better than Amazon.
- megablast 5y agoYou do food shopping on Etsy?? Ok.
- ipaddr 5y agoReally I shop walmart first check amazon for products not available. Usually works out cheaper. Etsy for which products?
- bushbaba 5y agoAmazon’s my go to e-commerce place. I use chewy for dog things due to the 30% auto ship price hack. And niche sites for all else. Amazon just has a superior webpage and shopping experience than all the other major players. If it’s a big ticket item I might get it from a retail store. But with the recent kohls Amazon return policy I’m slowly changing that behavior as well.
- afavour 5y agoI don’t think there’s a big crossover between things people buy on Etsy and things they buy on Walmart. I wouldn’t say they’re replicating Amazon, they’re a brick and mortar chain with thousands of locations. That’s definitely a potential edge over Amazon.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey are better than Amazon. You can filter search results on Walmart so that you don’t see third party reseller Aliexpress garbage and only stuff sourced by Walmart themselves. Last I checked, Amazon had removed that option as of maybe a decade ago, and they commingle inventory so they do not assure me of any supply chain integrity. And they are more expensive for any dense, heavy, especially liquid products.
- Spooky23 5y agoWalmart has some weird cultural issues that make store operations hard to adapt. It’s a pretty miserable place to work. They hire anyone, turn them out quickly, and have weird work rules for things like gathering in a group. Target’s pickup operation is superior in every dimension. They made the decision to put it front and center, and their employees seem happier. It takes <3 minutes to have a Target person drop stuff in your car, Walmart requires scheduling and is usually late. The other issue they have is that their logistical operation is best in class for retail, but not so good for shipping.
- pnutjam 5y agoThe other problem is substitution. WalMart will sub something different as if it's the same. They also assume you picked up if you go anywhere near the store.
- Scoundreller 5y agoI look forward to a car-wash pickup. You arrive. They scan your plate. You go through the 5 minute car wash and at the end they fill your trunk.
- redisman 5y ago> It’s a pretty miserable place to work. Huh sounds a bit like another company I happen to know
- medntech 5y agoScAmazon.
- MattGaiser 5y ago> Walmart has some weird cultural issues that make store operations hard to adapt. It’s a pretty miserable place to work. They hire anyone, turn them out quickly, and have weird work rules for things like gathering in a group. Is any company in retail any different? Except for the "hire anyone", most people would probably say that describes Amazon.
- andreilys 5y agoIn the last 20 years they’re stock has only gone up 150%.... Yes that’s better than bankruptcy but Walmart is a far cry from a successful old incumbent being able to address new upstarts. Also what makes you say Walmart Labs has great tech and hires top software talent? A quick look on Glassdoor shows the salary is quite low (esp. as it’s based in San Bruno). I know plenty of new grads that are earning much more, even at non-FANG company. I imagine like most incumbents, Walmart underinvests in tech because they see it as a cost center. The typical Walmart Labs Software Engineer salary is $116,635. Software Engineer salaries at Walmart Labs can range from $66,567 - $184,513. https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Walmart-Labs-Software-Engineer-Salaries-E3293060_D_KO13,30.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Walmart-Labs-Software-Engin...
- sgsgsgsdgd 5y agoGlassdoor numbers are inaccurate and 99% of the time only reflect base salary for every company I've looked up. Stick with levels.fyi https://www.levels.fyi/company/Walmart-Labs/salaries/Software-Engineer/ https://www.levels.fyi/company/Walmart-Labs/salaries/Softwar... While their RSUs are not at a FAANG level, the base + bonus are more than in line with top paying companies in CA.
- kevinventullo 5y agoIn the last 20 years they’re stock has only gone up 150%.... To be fair, they’ve been paying ~ 2% dividend yield that whole time. Still, if your comp is mostly in stock, those dividend payments hurt versus something like a buyback.
- maxtheman 5y agoDividends don't always "hurt". They let one automatically claim profits on a trade, without the hassle of divesting shares.
- kevinventullo 5y agoWhat I mean is, if I get a stock grant spread out over four years, then the shares I receive in year 4 have implicitly had their value decreased by the dividends paid out in years 1-3.
- grouphugs 5y agothis is quite the joke. walmart maintains a standing para-military with a lot of weapons and equipment. when people find mass grave-sites all over south of the the border (and there's A LOT of them), there's some common characteristics. walmart hats, coca cola hats, chikita banana stickers, and goya labels. imperialism and fascism both suck, so does walmart and amazon
- random314 5y agoThe top talent they hire, quit within 2 years leaving behind the terrible engineers. Last I heard, the tried to build an A/B testing infrastructure that somehow managed to count clicks backwards. They tried to build an in house cloud platform too and failed miserably.
- internetslave 5y agoWalmart doesn’t pay that well and isn’t regarded as a great tech place to work. It’s a good job, but someone who’s really serious about programming wouldn’t work there
- turtlebits 5y agoThe Walmart in-store pickup/returns experience is horrible. Long lines, employees are slow and unorganized. Several times I've gone to pick up an order and waited an addition 10+ minutes to have someone bring the item to the front of the store. I would say the only thing that makes them competitive is their price.
- emodendroket 5y agoSomething to be said for just being able to walk in and do all your shopping for everything from groceries to clothes to televisions.
- dylan604 5y ago>I would say the only thing that makes them competitive is their price That's the entire story of Walmart. Pretty much the only person that smiles is the greeter, and they aren't always very friendly.
- kube-system 5y agoI personally haven’t seen a Walmart greeter smile since they had smiley stickers.
- JMTQp8lwXL 5y agoThey could have been Sears, but they haven't made it far enough. They're doing enough to survive, but they're acting reactively, not proactively, to a changing environment. They will never come close to exceeding Amazon's level of innovation, for better or for worse. I think pointing to Jet detracts from their progress, given the Jet acquisition was a complete flop. They're fighting with everything they've got. But not even Walmart can truly compete. It's unclear if its talent, a leadership issue, the company's brand, or what exactly is holding Walmart back. I suppose that's good for Walmart: a lot of the elements look right to position them well. They just haven't figured it out 100%.
- kortilla 5y ago> They will never come close to exceeding Amazon's level of innovation, for better or for worse Amazon stopped innovating as a store 5-10 years ago. Nothing has meaningfully changed for the better and things have gotten worse on the front of fake reviews and counterfeit products. Amazon spent its innovation on AWS, which is not even the same industry Walmart is operating in.
- russdpale 5y agoYeh they also totally fuck over farmers, employees, and even tried to pay Mexican employees in Walmart dollars while housing them in the back of the store. It should have gone the way of sears. Its an abusive business that is bad for everyone.