11 ms·
I keep thinking of Madoff's fund. It was once called "the Jewish T-bill". It worked just fine until there was a significant net outflow. Then, total crash, beca
by Animats 5y ago
I keep thinking of Madoff's fund. It was once called "the Jewish T-bill". It worked just fine until there was a significant net outflow. Then, total crash, because the backing assets were not there.
Tether is way too much like that.
Remember, Tether has no upside. There is no reason to ever hold Tether for any length of time.
[1] https://www.timesofisrael.com/before-dying-bernie-madoff-lifted-veil-on-the-biggest-ponzi-scheme-in-history/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/before-dying-bernie-madoff-lif...
- pinkybanana 5y ago> Remember, Tether has no upside. There is no reason to ever hold Tether for any length of time. "There is this product/service X, that is bought and traded fro billions. I don't see any use cases myself so clearly there isn't any reason to use it. Market is wrong and I am right."
- ac29 5y agoThe point is that the maximum value of 1 Tether is 1 USD. No matter how long you hold it, it will not be worth more than a dollar held in a safe, insured bank account.
- R0b0t1 5y agoI've been following cryptocurrencies since their inception. No one who knows anything is investing in or holding fiat based currencies. It may make some people some money, but it is assuredly not going to make you any money, and will probably make you lose money.
- menzoic 5y agoPlenty of crypto veterans use stablecoins. The benefits are that its much faster to transfer globally in minutes and works on weekends. There are also high yields from liquidity mining that anyone can benefit from.
- pasxizeis 5y agoI think OP is talking about long-term holders while you are talking about traders.
- rawtxapp 5y agoStablecoins are an unfortunate side-effect of limited banking for the crypto industry. For the longest time, even legitimate exchanges had issues getting deposits/withdrawals working properly with normal banking system. Most traders I know use tether to move funds between exchanges for arbitrages and/or wait out a correction. Some are also using it to generate yield, but other than that, nobody is holding onto it for the very long term. And Tether is not the only game in town, USDC (which is by well known/regulated entities here in US) has been getting a lot of traction, it now has about 1/3rd of Tether's market cap.
- fock 5y agoimho this observation of you just adds to every "stablecoins are a scam"-post. If there is indeed no significant outflow out of the stable-crypto system, I don't know what's stands in the way of companies to just print money out of thin air in there - which then goes to prop up bitcoin, bringing in real money from the bagholders.
- bob33212 5y agoIronically they are doing exactly what the fed does to avoid bankruptcy, just keep the printing presses going whenever your economy is having trouble. As long as you can print infinite money you can always buy BTC at 25k-40k (Keeping your collateral solvent). You can always attract more USD by increasing the interest rates. It only ends when a regulator or judge steps in and asks them to pause their operations for a week for an investigation to begin.
- menzoic 5y agoStablecoins have utility even when there is banking available. The benefits are that its much faster to transfer globally in minutes and works on weekends.
- TacticalCoder 5y ago> Remember, Tether has no upside. There is no reason to ever hold Tether for any length of time. It looks like USDC, issued by a company co-owned by Coinbase (YC incubated right?) and Circle, is quickly replacing tether. One year ago there were about 1/10th of USDC compared to tether, now it's half. Apparently USDC are really fully backed by real USD and the smart contract for USDC can block any address containing USDC at any time (which eases some concerns regarding complying with authorities while it probably raises some concerns for others). I take it for those concerned it wouldn't be unwise to sell your USDTs for USDCs. For somehow I don't believe that Coinbase is pulling a ponzi scheme with USDC.
- out_of_protocol 5y agoRegarding USDC - people in control of usdc can (and did) blacklist any wallet at their own desire, so it's not much different from storing money in bank, exchange etc How about DAI ? This stablecoin doesn't have both USDT's and USDC's disadvantages
- mhluongo 5y agoUnfortunately, it's largely backed by USDC right now... The failure of USDC would hurt the DAI peg. If your threat model is government-backed censorship, though, it should be an improvement.
- wmf 5y agoSomething is off in USDC land though: https://news.bitcoin.com/usdc-attestations-run-late-raising-alarms-in-the-crypto-community/ https://news.bitcoin.com/usdc-attestations-run-late-raising-...
- latchkey 5y agoThat site is generally not a trusted news source. I'd follow that link up with something else.
- 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoHonestly Tether doesn't really to be that much different compared to fractional reserve banking. The biggest difference is the government protects banks from bank runs while Tether enjoys no such privilege.
- roywiggins 5y agoIt's a wildcat bank. That's what wildcat banks are.
- menzoic 5y agoTether has a $100k minimum withdrawal requirement
- cturner 5y agoThere are complex and strict rules around commercial banks that direct to their loan to value ratios, capitalisation and auditing arrangements (Basel accords). Tether is not subject to this. The biggest difference you highlight is a big difference. On youtube, you can watch a series of documentaries by Milton Friedman, Free to Choose. In an early episode of this, he explains how the Great Depression was triggered by the fed failing to lend liquidity to a legitimate commercial bank that needed it. As you point out, there is no equivalent liquidity safety net for Tether. It may be that in a tether crisis the fed would feel compelled to step in and bailout anyway to prevent systemic problems. The Long Term Capital Management bailout had this character. It was not the fed’s responsibility to bail it out, but there was noone else to do it, and if they had not then it would have created a systemic crisis comparable to the start of the great depression. This will not happen in 2021. Crypto is not systemically important now. But as it becomes integrated, Tether becomes a larger problem.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoOf course. The solution is to have governments back currencies like USDT, BUSD, USDC, Dai, etc. If they're gonna bail out financial institutions when they screw up, Tether should be no exception.
- G3rn0ti 5y ago
- htormey 5y agoPeople, mainly in Asia, use tether where trading crypto with fiat currencies is either prohibited or very difficult, whereas it remains marginal in markets such as the United States. I.e places with exchanges that don’t have good fiat rails for various reasons. https://www.cryptovantage.com/news/why-is-tether-so-popular-outside-of-north-america-and-western-europe/ https://www.cryptovantage.com/news/why-is-tether-so-popular-... I assume these people don’t stay in tether long, they just use it like a checking account when they cash in and out of positions. I also assume that if tether went away tomorrow, people would either use another stablecoin like USDC and if all stablecoins went away, they would just trade in and out of btc.
- Slartie 5y agoIf tether went away tomorrow, 60 billion of "assumed dollars" backing up crypto asset values would also vanish. Such an event would immediately tank the dollar value of all cryptocurrencies (real dollars, not USDT, that one would explode to the moon instead). And not just by 60 billion dollars of total market cap, but more like 600 billion to a trillion. There's a lot of fantasy value for each actual dollar (or USDT, as long as people believe these are basically equal) in the crypto market caps.
- reidjs 5y agoIs it possible that such an event would benefit people who keep their btc off exchanges significantly?
- ac29 5y agoIf price collapses cause the exchanges to fail and disappear with their customer's assets then I suppose you'd be better off having held your own keys. But you still have an asset who's price has collapsed.
- htormey 5y agoYeah sure but would that be worse than the other crashes that have happened over the life of BTC and other crypto assets? What kind of draw down would you expect and why? I think it’s unlikely that this would happen to all stable coins. So what would this scenario look like if USDC or DAI still existed?