10 ms·
I think Wal*Mart has an image problem. I’ve gone into their stores. Their stock assortment isn’t bad compared to the competition. In fact, aside from Whole F
by mc32 5y ago
I think Wal*Mart has an image problem.
I’ve gone into their stores. Their stock assortment isn’t bad compared to the competition. In fact, aside from Whole Foods on the organic/bio side of things, they measure up very well and better compared to their competition. They are more of a hypermart where you can do one stop shopping ala Carrefour.
The issues I see are: very drab color palette. Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum.
They could likely address this by having a second more upscale brand.
- hahamrfunnyguy 5y agoIt's not an image problem, shopping there is a terrible experience. The stores are always a mess and the employees are unhelpful. There always seems to be long lines at the front end. They do have a good selection of products, but I avoid shopping there whenever I can because it's so unpleasant.
- VoodooJuJu 5y agoThis comment is just so wildly delusional. Aristotle was right when he said that most envy and elitism is directed at other members of one's own class.
- mikelward 5y agoI went to a Walmart Supercenter this week to try to buy clothes and groceries. No carts or hand baskets available. One employee reprimanding another employee right in front of customers. No bags for produce. Underwear was in a locked cabinet. I pressed the button but nobody came to help. Grumpy attendant at the self checkout. It's no wonder that people who can afford to shop elsewhere do.
- galgalesh 5y agoWhen I visited the US, I went to Walmart just to see how bad it was. I visited the "sick and dead fish" aisle. Incomprehensible how that's even allowed, but ok. This is more subjective, but in every country I go to, I visit a "cheap supermarket chain store" and look at the people working there. Do they look happy? Do they look healthy? Do they look tired? Switzerland was amazing on that front.
- totalZero 5y ago> Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. The thing about America is that you honestly cannot tell the social status of a person based on appearance alone. The middle class is large and we value frugality and humility. I think of this as a collective tendency: rich or poor, when you go to Wal-Mart you just wear whatever you're wearing. I don't know if you have ever heard of Chris Arnade but he is an ex Wall Streeter who wrote about the "McDonald's Test," which probably lines up with Wal-Mart too. "Eventually I came up with what I call the McDonald’s test. The broad thesis of my book is that our society sorts people into what I call the front row and the back row – the privileged class to which I used to belong, who are financially secure and live in safe neighborhoods with good schools and public services – and everybody else. The test is to ask a person: how do you view McDonald’s? In my experience, the answer usually reveals whether someone belongs to the front or back row." https://www.plough.com/en/topics/justice/social-justice/economic-justice/the-mcdonalds-test https://www.plough.com/en/topics/justice/social-justice/econ...
- lttlrck 5y agoFantastic article. Thank you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- HideousKojima 5y ago>They could likely address this by having a second more upscale brand. That's kinda what Sam's Club is, though Sam's is competing against Costco
- mc32 5y agoLet me restate that: upscale and hip targeted at middle and upper middle/aspirational in urban and proximate suburban enviros.
- mike_d 5y agoUpscale urban areas won't let Walmart even try to build something. Target worked really hard pitching their upscale "City Target" sub-brand to get San Francisco to let them in.
- bombcar 5y agoWalmart is experimenting with something they call “Walmart Neighborhood Market” but I think they’d have done better to leave the Walmart name off it. People who don’t like Walmart won’t try it and people who do like Walmart will be pissed it’s not a Walmart just a grocery store.
- mc32 5y agoYep , I agree. They don’t need that boat anchor of a brand for something like that. New name, new colors, new atmosphere and of course, charge a bit more for the frills.
- bombcar 5y agoThey could have called it Waldi and started an amusing trademark war.
- crowman 5y agoI had one right by my college apartment and was really happy with it. Very clean and always had what I needed, but not 'everything.' If they rebranded & incorporated them into suburban neighborhoods with a focus on walkability it could be a smart move to capture the wealthier 'conscious' shopper.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoBasically you want a Walmart for white people? It’s elitist thinking like this further grows the space between the “working class” and rich.
- mc32 5y agoHa! You obviously don’t shop at Wal*Mart. It’s the working class for whomever is in the vicinity. In many places this is poor white people, in other places it’s a mix.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoI haven’t shopped at Walmart since I moved to Portland because there’s like 2 and they’re on the otherside of town. I frequently shopped at Walmart prior to that. And you’re wrong. I’ve never gone into any Walmart and only seen poor white people. It’s mostly poor everyone. Walmart’s are almost never put in rich areas because rich people don’t want poor people shopping in their areas.
- dna_polymerase 5y agoYou jumped from wealth to race. Who is the racist here?
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoMost rich people are white. Most elitist people are white. The people that want to shop at stores that have like people are white. I wasn’t being racist, but elitist and racism go hand in hand.
- late2part 5y agoMost people in the USA are white: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219
- cogman10 5y ago> Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. Eh, I think the problem isn't even "lower class" it's "I don't want to shop at a store with a meth lab"[1] How does walmart begin to fix problems like that? IDK. Even Kmart back in the day didn't have that sort of image problem. Heck, other brands like Kroger or albertsons/safeway don't have that problem. It's a pretty unique problem to the walmart brand. Oddly enough, Asda (walmart's UK brand name) doesn't have the same image problem. It really is a problem unique to the US walmart brand. [1] https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/03/meth-labs-in-walmart-pretty-common.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/03/meth-labs-in-wal...
- raverbashing 5y agoI wonder if/how Asda got out of the "countryside" style of management of Walmart In other countries their micromanagement made them fail. Like in Germany, where it's the place where it crashed and burned the worse.
- handrous 5y agoObservations about the nearest Wal-Mart: 1) All the employees look sad, all he time. 2) They've obviously carefully tuned their check out staffing so that the lines are always long. This is such a constant that it has to be intentional, and they're doing a good job of it. 3) Sometimes they attempt to check receipts at exit. I don't get that at any other non-membership store. 4) All the shoppers look sad. 5) It's the only place I know where I am 100% guaranteed to smell both strong cigarette odor and way too-strong perfume application multiple times per visit. 6) The shoppers are uniquely talentless when it comes to existing in space without being in others' way. I don't see this anywhere else. It always feels 3x as busy as it is both because they cram the aisles full of crap, and because no-one knows how to walk or stand without being in the way. It's bizarre. 7) The most prominently-placed thing on entering the building is a row of gambling machines. I shit you not. They're directly ahead, and you have to veer right to enter the actual shopping area. That definitely sets a tone. Most of these are true at any other Wal-Mart I visit. I avoid them most of the time, despite their having much lower prices than, say, target. The visits take longer and are miserable. Their weird interior color choices (WTF is up with that dirty-looking orangey-yellow?!) and something they do with the lighting (can't put my finger on it, it's just drab and dingy) make it even worse. I'm about 90% sure that Wal-Mart didn't used to be this gross and unpleasant.
- emodendroket 5y agoI gotta say that either your Walmart is worse than any I’ve ever been to or you’re in your own head a bit.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoVaries by store. The Walmart near me isn't like this. Only #2 is true. Walmart is probably the #1 big box store where I live. Everyone shops there, rich and poor alike. It's clean, the people are fine and the staff are as happy as any other big box store staff. The Walmarts in the adjacent towns are similar. Most Walmarts I've seen are about like this. The tire center will have a Festiva in one bay and a Tesla in the nest The Walmart near my work is very different. Way more dismal in all the ways you've described. I dunno about the gambling thing, that may vary by state and I've never seen it anywhere. But where I work has enough wealthy people to support other stores so the Walmart clientele is much poorer on average. I've been in probably a dozen Walmarts over the years and it's by far the worst.
- godot 5y ago> Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. Not going to comment on the ethics/politics of it, but if people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum, then they have to accept that they have to pay a premium for it (i.e. shop at Whole Foods). You can't really say "I want to shop at the discount store but I also want only other wealthy people to be there". If you accept that premise, then perhaps Walmart doesn't have an image problem, it's simply the fact that it's the cheapest place to shop in the neighborhood, so lower income folks will more likely shop there.
- g00gler 5y ago> if people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum, then they have to accept that they have to pay a premium for it (i.e. shop at Whole Foods). I agree that Walmart can be extremely unpleasant compared to a regular grocery store for many reasons. However, I’ve found Whole Foods staff to be extremely unwelcoming unless you seem like you fit in regardless of how much money you make. Can definitely recommend wegmans for a more upscale shopping experience (Eg fancy cheeses, meats, selection of fish) without any of that “too cool for school” factor if you’re not in an “in” group. Edit: Trader Joe’s is also pretty cool but it reminds me a bit of Aldi.
- quartesixte 5y agoThats cuz apparently Trader Joe’s IS an Aldi’s! Well, not originally, but they’re owned by Aldi Nord for a while now. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trader_Joe's https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trader_Joe's
- late2part 5y agoYes! I remember my first time at Whole Foods I asked where to find the Coca Cola and they were very rude about not carrying it.
- mc32 5y agoForget a Coke (never mind they have other non-alc fizzy drinks) The don’t carry Aspirin (or Advil or Tylenol, but whatever, but Aspirin, WTF?!
- mike_d 5y ago> The issues I see are: very drab color palette. Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. That is just the store you went to. The company crunches tons of data before they decide on store placement, and grouping like-shoppers by socioeconomic status is absolutely a goal. My hometown for example - one side of town has a Walmart that is very run down and exactly as you describe, while on the other side of town the Walmart looks like an upscale Target on the inside and an REI on the outside. They tried the "upscale" brand online with Jet.com and it was an absolute failure. Amazon owns almost all of the non-price-first shoppers and Marc Lore doesn't know how to run a business without oversight.
- wldcordeiro 5y agoJet was an acquisition though. I get they tried to keep some of its "upscale" shine but they eventually shuttered it for their own online offering.
- mike_d 5y agoIt was an aquihire. "Jet" itself was an empty shell that the Walmart marketing folks could build a higher end brand inside. The shuttering happened because the website was racking up seven-figure monthly Azure bills and bringing in five-figure revenue. Marc just couldn't figure out how to drive traffic without all his domains he sold to Amazon (soap.com, diapers.com, etc).
- grillvogel 5y agomaybe i'm weird but i actually prefer the vibe at walmart to the pseudo upscale feel of stores like target. at walmart you know what youre getting, theres no pretense that you are there for any other reason than cheap crap. people of all economic backgrounds are all there just to get the best deals.
- mc32 5y agoThing is the vibe part I see but quality wise, they’re on par with others. It’s not Dollar store crap.
- kbelder 5y agoI agree. Target is much more annoying; just as bottom-of-the-barrel, but they depend on pretending they're not.
- zippergz 5y agoI don't know what's "pseudo" about cleaner floors and surfaces and better-organized merchandise. It's not just about decor. The Wal-Marts I have been to are a filthy mess, and it's clear no one cares.
- potta_coffee 5y agoThe one thing I like about Target is that it's quiet, they don't play music there and there's rarely talking over loudspeakers etc.
- nitwit005 5y agoIf your target market is people who want the lowest price, image issues tend not to matter that much (other than perception of being the lowest price option). You were probably never their first choice.
- everdrive 5y ago>Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. Elitist or not, wouldn't this advice simply move them from one stratum to another?
- cptskippy 5y ago> I think Wal*Mart has an image problem. If you know their history then you understand how they got where they are. Walmart grew in the 80s and 90s by planting itself just outside the city limits of small towns across America. They attracted the towns people with low prices and jobs. Their presence eventually shutdown every competing small business in those towns and the former purveyors of those businesses often wound up working at Walmart. Businesses that didn't directly compete often setup shop inside the Walmart leasing space from them. That is until Walmart started partnering up with larger chains and pushing those small businesses out. At the same time Walmart was strangling small businesses in small town America, they were also putting the squeeze on suppliers. They were demanding custom products at lower prices from companies who were forced to outsource to other countries in order to meet Walmart's demands. Well known American brands like Huffy went from being proudly made in America to just being stickers slapped on products coming off the boat from China. If you drove across the US in the 90s you'd run through empty ghost towns and as soon as you'd hit the "Now leaving..." sign for the town there'd be a Walmart Supercenter with a parking lot full of vehicles. Walmart destroyed small town America by draining towns of tax revenues and running small businesses under. Through all of this Walmart proudly displayed Made in the USA or some other patriotic bullshit on the outside of their stores. Yeah Walmart has an image problem, and there isn't anything they can do about it in my opinion.
- rubicon33 5y agoIt sucks that while there are enumerable benefits to free market capitalism, there's also serious drawbacks. You tend to see the formation of mega corporations that can use economy of scale to secure and hold huge economic advantage. Short of some breakup, or government intervention, what can be done? The system is designed to reward those who find the best market fit. The problem is, there's no brake pedal on their growth. They can absorb entire industries.
- rsuelzer 5y agoThis, in my opinion, is the largest role of government in a capitalist society. Capitalism is not sustainable without guard rails. By design, a company will always pass costs onto society if it can. The government has an obligation to ensure negative economic costs are paid by the producers and consumers of goods and services. An example of this would be Walmart for years relying almost exclusively on Medicaid benefits for their employees healthcare. Walmart is hardly the worst company in terms of passing economic costs on to others or future generations. But, the point is, that unless the government forces a company to pay the true costs of doing business it's always going to result in market distortions. It's a design flaw of capitalism, which is actually easy to correct within an equitable political system. However, this is much more rare than it ought be.
- gwbas1c 5y ago> Working class shoppers That doesn't bother me. I'm not so elitist that I need to always be with people who are me same class as me. What's more important is that the people catering to me make a living wage. Or, to put it differently, are comfortable with what they are paid without relying on government assistance? The only kind of stores that I avoid because of the customers are liquor stores where half the drivers in the parking lot are drunk.
- mc32 5y agoWal*Mart, contrary to popular belief is paying $15 in many locations (as good as other chains).
- Noos 5y agothey dont hire full time though, and hours can vary dramatically per week. if you get 12 hours one week and 32 the next, that $15 an hour doesn't help that much. The big problem is we dont do full time work in most retail positions any more apart from the manager and maybe keyholders.
- protomyth 5y agoThe funny part is Walmart is paying better wages here than any competitor in retail space.
- strikhedonia 5y agoThey’re paying a mean of $15 an hour. That’s quite different from a minimum of $15 an hour. Walmart jobs in my fairly HCOL area still start at $12 an hour.
- AuryGlenz 5y agoI just saw a banner outside mine in a very low cost of living area advertising starting at $14 an hour.
- ineedasername 5y agoTheir interior could use a better design. However, the vast majority of people are working class. Their problems aren't shoppers' opinions of other shoppers. An upscale version might attract other customers of a higher socioeconomic status, but there's lots of competition in that market as well, and it's not a core competency of Walmart, making it a longshot bet. Based on what the article says from the memo, a lot if their issues stem from changing shopping behaviors and a desire for more convenience-- such as curbside pickup-- that Walmart has had difficulty scaling up fast enough to meet demand.
- Rapzid 5y agoIt's not the best choice, it's Spacer's Choice!
- JTbane 5y agoWalmart is also one of the few stores that interrogate you on the way out as to what you purchased. Just not a good look.
- Terretta 5y agoBest Buy checks receipts, Costco checks receipts. Best Buy is the most confusing of these as the receipt checker is stationed about 3 feet from the last register by the door watching you get rung up and pay.
- protomyth 5y agoBest Buy also like to hire actual cops for their security. It's a nice part time and the employee discount was good. Did make my brother breathe a bit easier when he worked there.
- teclordphrack2 5y agoCostco, Sams Club and the like have you sign a contract for membership that requires you to show the receipt upon exit. Walmart, Target, etc. are governed by the state, county, and city laws. Most states allow you to ignore them and keep walking unless the theft prevention is activated.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoYou only believe these things are a problem because you don’t understand positioning (in marketing terms). They are successful because of these qualities, not in spite of them.
- wavefunction 5y agoAt least for me, Walmart is just a vehicle for the Waltons to extract wealth from the country. I suppose if Walmart divested themselves from the Waltons and adopted some sort of pro-employee policies I might shop there more frequently.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- barsonme 5y agoTangentially related: one reason I try very hard not to shop at Walmart is because they try hard to make you feel like a criminal. For instance, hanging from the ceiling smack-dab in the middle of some aisles are little TVs showing you that they're recording you. And when you walk down the aisle, the little TV senses you and lights up (it's remarkably bright) so that you _have_ to notice it. And nine times out of ten I get hassled by the LPOs on my way out—demanding to see my receipt like they're busting some sort of birthday card stealing ring. I do get that shoplifting is a big problem for them. The (small, middle-class) city I grew up in always has a cop in the parking lot of the local Walmart because so many people steal things. In high school, kids would grab booze or energy drinks and pass it through the bars in the garden section to their friends. Or just shove it in their backpack and run. And most of the "Do you recognize this shoplifter?" posts on FB or wherever by the local PD are from the Walmart. But I can't help but think that they're driving away the type of people they _want_ to shop there. I'll gladly drive farther and pay more to shop in a pleasant environment.
- SkyPuncher 5y agoWalMart definitely has an image issue for me. In my town (very low crime), they're the only store with clear theft prevention in place. You walk in through a one-way turnstile, they have a permanent police presence, clear loss prevention people randomly throughout the store, and someone doing loss prevention just after check out. I'm sure other stores in our area have loss prevention, but they hide it much better. WalMart is the only store where I feel like I'm being scrutinized for wanting to buy the products they sell.
- bigwavedave 5y ago> The issues I see are: [snip] Working class shoppers. Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. When I was very young, I liked talking to my dad about possible business ideas and how to make millions of dollars so I could buy a castle for our family to live in when I grew up (yeah, yeah, I was a kid). One evening, after proposing yet another crazy idea (I can't for the life of me remember what it was), my dad sat me down and asked me which kind of customer I thought Walmart would prefer to have: 1 customer that spends $100 or 100 customers that spend $1. I naively answered "The $100 customer, because it's a guaranteed higher amount!" He corrected me, saying that they'd prefer 100x $1 customers for two reasons: 1) there will always be a market for them and 2) it's less detrimental to lose a customer when each one pays $1 than it is to lose your only customer. I don't think attracting the average Joe instead of the elitist is a bug, it's a feature.
- BeetleB 5y ago> Their stock assortment isn’t bad compared to the competition. In fact, aside from Whole Foods on the organic/bio side of things, they measure up very well and better compared to their competition. Where I live (a decent sized metro), their stock collection beats all other retail stores in the area. They'll often have SKUs for products I can't find anywhere else. As an example, I have a spray carpet cleaner from what is likely the best selling brand in the country. When it runs out, I want to get a solution refill, not buy a whole new spray. Walmart is the only general purpose store in the city that carries it. All other stores carry just the spray version, which costs about double. Target used to be my go-to place for this kind of stuff, but even they've stopped carrying it. Their fresh produce sucks, but for everything else, they often have good selection and quality. And with good prices. A few other examples: - OTC Medicine/supplements: If you're trying to get one of the well known "alternative" brands (e.g. vegetarian tablets), their prices are much cheaper - perhaps half of that in any other local store. - Perfumes: It's the same perfume as you'd get at Macy's, Nordstrom, etc, but usually at 20-50% off their prices. Reason? They source these perfumes from the Asian market. Perfume manufacturers cannot sell in Asia at the prices they charge in the US, so they sell it cheaper there (again, from all my research, it's the same perfume - not a lower quality one). So Walmart simply "imports" them back in from Asia. I rarely shop at Wal-mart. It's not near me, and I go there only when I simply can't find what I need at another local store. It certainly has its down sides and legitimate criticisms, but I've begun to appreciate the positives to it.
- cbozeman 5y ago> Working class shoppers. Almost everyone in America is "working class". America no longer has a leisure class to speak of, if we ever had one. Looking at the most recent data - I forget where I saw it - but the wealthiest Americans also put in the most hours at work. I know a lot of people have brainwashed themselves into thinking they're something they're not, but they're all wrong. If you have to go to work in the morning to maintain your lifestyle, even if you "work" for yourself, you're just a working class stiff like everyone else, you can just afford bigger shit. If you can decide to just stop what you're doing and go attain spiritual enlightenment for the next 18 months, and literally nothing about your life, your children's lives, your grandchildren's lives, and your great-grandchildren's lives will change - you're not working class. > Sure, it’s elitist, but people like shopping alongside people in their own stratum. That doesn't make someone elitist, it just makes them an asshole.
- taurath 5y ago/someone/ owns the boats in the marina. Usually someone very old for whom the economy worked out well for them. Bought a house worth a million dollars now on a near minimum wage job.
- kube-system 5y ago“Working class”, despite what those words can mean separately, doesn’t mean “class of people with a job”. It is a polite rephrasing of the now antiquated phrase: “lower class”. In fact, the “working class” aren’t necessarily even employed.
- LB232323 5y agoI certainly don't support the labor practices of Walmart, but I think you are the one with the serious image problem. You think you really exist in a different "stratum" when you still have to buy your own groceries? You aren't elitist, you aren't even close to "elite." You're just an asshole. Here's a fun fact, Whole Foods exploited slave labor to supply their tilapia. Here's another fun fact, if you need to work then you are working class.
- faeriechangling 5y agoIt's not that I disagree but it's so depressingly cynical to suggest Walmart make its business less efficient for the sake of allowing for social stratification.