5 ms·
There was a comment in yesterday's post about this, which applies here as well – there is zero evidence in the article that "hire to fire" is actually a thing a
by paxys 5y ago
There was a comment in yesterday's post about this, which applies here as well – there is zero evidence in the article that "hire to fire" is actually a thing at Amazon. Managers simply cannot hire people just to fire them because they do not have the final say in who gets hired and who doesn't. They can offer an opinion, the same as all the other 4-5 interviewers in the round, and then the bar raiser makes the final decision. The manager might not even be part of the interview round at all, and if they are they certainly cannot overrule anyone else's opinion.
This "fact" can be sourced back to an article from Business Insider which is pretty much blog spam at this point.
- northern-lights 5y ago> Managers simply cannot hire people just to fire them because they do not have the final say in who gets hired and who doesn't. They can offer an opinion, the same as all the other 4-5 interviewers in the round, and then the bar raiser makes the final decision. Having been part of debriefs, this is not correct. Bar Raiser is there to help the panel make a decision, not be the sole decision maker.
- blackoil 5y agoBar Raiser may not make the final decision, but he/she can block a clearly bad hire.
- northern-lights 5y agoYes, perhaps I should have clarified. BR can only use the veto to make a HIRE to NO_HIRE decision. He doesn't have the veto to make a NO_HIRE to HIRE decision.
- amzn-throw 5y agoNot quite. Source: Am bar raiser. While bar raisers can't make hiring managers take a candidate they don't want, they can absolutely "veto to hire" for Amazon. It just means that Recruiting needs to find another team, which the candidate is not guaranteed to be interested in. And that team's manager will also want to interview the candidate, so an offer is not guaranteed again.
- blackoil 5y agoIn other words, you can recommend recruiter to see if any other team wants to hire the candidate. Which makes sense from perspective of all. But you can't "veto" to hire which makes no sense.
- northern-lights 5y agoYes, agreed. I meant BR can't veto to hire for that team without HM being inclined.
- blackoil 5y agoi.e. without a collusion in people across teams "Hire to Fire" will not work. and for the problem to be systemic, collusion should be happening between thousands of people. What I think is more likely is that managers are ready to take 90% candidates with hope of grooming them because they have a fallback if it was a wrong decision. Which is a positive thing in my 2c opinion.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cryptische 5y agoManagers generally overrule other's opinions by giving promise of personally "coaching" the new hire to make them meet the bar. In most cases such people are put on a plan, ironically called "Coaching Plan" itself, and thereafter fired. URA quota is an open secret at Amazon, and some employee appreciate the practice of hire to fire, as it saves their own employment. That in turn ensures that objection to bad hire, who is going to be "coached" is non existent.
- angarg12 5y agoI've done +200 interviews at Amazon and I have never seen this happen. I only remember one single case where a HM was pushing to hire a clearly unqualified candidate. The Bar Raiser pushed back and didn't let it get through.
- cryptische 5y agoI've started observing this recently. I too didn't see such push earlier. Maybe because of recent supply crunch, hiring managers have become more desperate to save the head of the existing people in their team.
- ndesaulniers 5y agoBar Raiser?
- smadge 5y agoThe important part is if managers have discretion over who to fire.
- owenmarshall 5y ago> there is zero evidence in the article that "hire to fire" is actually a thing at Amazon. In fact it cannot be a thing since managers do not have the final say in who gets hired and who doesn't. Hiring and staffing is always horse-trading even when it’s not being actively manipulated in the way this article suggests. “Send me your req so I can land these two top tier candidates and I’ll be sure to work your projects first”. “Everybody rate your employees for bonuses, then submit the ratings to the CIO so we can decide who gets the two ‘above and beyond’ bonuses we got this year.” I’m not saying it is happening at Amazon as I have no direct knowledge. But it is pretty easy to see how stack ranking can introduce bad incentives: ICs doing the interview recommend candidates worse than them to pad their positions, managers do the same so their chaff gets approved.
- awthroura 5y agoAs also pointed out in the thread yesterday, that comment about Bar Raisers was nonsense. The fact is that HMs do have the final say in most cases. It is very easy to “game the system” and get candidates past the hiring loop, BR or not. Plus, the entire argument that “there’s a bar raiser involved” is irrelevant to the point. Hire-and-fire doesn’t mean that HMs are trying to sneak unqualified candidates through the process. What it means is that HMs will take even qualified candidates, which pass the BR with no problem, and set them up for failure and firing.
- amzn-throw 5y ago> It is very easy to “game the system” and get candidates past the hiring loop, BR or not. False. Source: Am bar raiser. 9 year Amazonian, >500 interviews. Am a manager. I do performance reviews. Yes, there are unregretted attrition rates. But "hire to fire" is absolutely not a thing. > HMs will take even qualified candidates, which pass the BR with no problem, and set them up for failure and firing. That is so ridiculous people are laughing at this concept internally. Hiring good people is HARD. Interviewing takes a lot of time. Amazon sets very ambitious goals internally, and managers are behind on them from the day they got their head count, even it takes months to fill out. If you have a viable quality candidate available, you TAKE THEM. Holy shit do you take them. Hiring managers are DESPERATE For people. And they will beg barter and steal for hires, and try to convince bar raisers to lower the bar to get people in. The idea that some teams have such low-pressure goals and their managers are so loyal to their team members that they would hire a candidate just to fire them is absolutely insanely false. If managers don't meet their goals THEY eventually become "Unregretted attrition". So if a manager has head count to fill it's for a goal, and they are way more loyal to meeting those goals as a team than to protect a good team from unregretted attrition targts. Which by the way is also not mandatory for every team. It needs to average out across Amazon, and directors/VPs will aggegate numbers and roll them up, but ultimately if you have a team full of rockstars, none of them will be marked for URA. I don't care what is written on Blind. Those people are fucking liars. I don't believe a single one about hire to fire. This article and the one yesterday is just pure libel.
- cryptische 5y ago
- reducesuffering 5y agoThere is definitive evidence. Many many threads of Amazon manager's specifying on Blind they're doing this exact hire-to-fire to save their team.
- MattGaiser 5y agoThis story is extremely common, whether it be on Hacker News, Blind (which verifies employee emails), Reddit, or just anecdotes from former Amazon employees. There may not be evidence of fire yet, but the smoke is very thick. BI did not pull this out of a hat. This claim has been around for a while.
- Aeolun 5y agoI don’t understand how this follows? This just means you are hiring eminently qualified candidates that are then later fired, regardless of how well they are actually doing.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThere are two parts of this story. 1. Amazon has attrition metrics. 2. Hiring managers at Amazon are deliberately hiring weak people that they intend to later fire so they can protect the rest of their team. The argument is that because managers can't actually unilaterally hire weak people that this strategy isn't really feasible. There are still bad parts of #1, but that isn't the most controversial part of the story.
- northern-lights 5y ago2. is not accurate. Managers don't have to hire weak people to satisfy the quota. People are rarely ever put into PIP due to performance. Most of the times it is political.
- UncleMeat 5y agoBut that's the whole point of the "Hire to Fire" story. The claims being made here are not that managers are firing people to meet quotas, but that they are deliberately sabotaging some of their hires so they have a sacrificial lamb to fire.
- awthroura 5y agoDeliberately sabotaging people does not require that the sabotaged person be under-performing or low quality. That’s the point. If a BR prevents you from hiring an unqualified person to be a sacrificial lamb, then you just hire a qualified person that can get past the BR to be a sacrificial lamb. The existence of BRs is absolutely not a foolproof check on this. You might ask “why would an HM fire someone who is qualified to do the job?” The answer is that Amazon requires that someone must be fired. If you were an HM, who would you rather fire: an existing qualified tenured team member who already knows the ins-and-outs of your team and system, or a new qualified person who would require extensive training and time to get up to the level of the tenured employee? You’re going to pick the new person, even if they are qualified.