11 ms·
AFAIK the age restriction credit card thing (inside the EU) is the result of some stupid law change (the Audiovisual Media Services Directive). Google probably
by jeroenhd 5y ago
AFAIK the age restriction credit card thing (inside the EU) is the result of some stupid law change (the Audiovisual Media Services Directive). Google probably doesn't want to validate users' age (because selling ads to impressionable kids is very lucrative) but they have to now.
- StavrosK 5y ago> Google probably doesn't want to validate users' age (because selling ads to impressionable kids is very lucrative) but they have to now. I mean, I hate this age validation as much as everyone else, curbing advertising to impressionable kids doesn't sound too stupid to me...
- wyager 5y agoThis is parents’ job, not Google’s. If you legally require Google to act like a parent, they have to do it to everyone.
- adkadskhj 5y agoIt _sounds_ like you're speaking in absolutes though, lacking nuance. If you are, my reply to absolutes would be that we should stop enforcing alcohol sales to minors, as it's the parent's job to ensure kids their don't drink. Personally i think age verification is good. This implementation is moronic, though. And all around it's very, very difficult. So difficult that it may never be useful.
- h_anna_h 5y ago> my reply to absolutes would be that we should stop enforcing alcohol sales to minors We absolutely should. Thankfully it is already not enforced in a lot of places (such as in greece).
- kowlo 5y agoI hope I won't be considered presumptuous, but I suspect you don't have children? It is simply impossible to monitor absolutely everything.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoAnd you should not do so.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- k12sosse 5y agoI would say YMMV. If you have a child in a problematic scenario, your opinion might change.
- wyager 5y agoCool, so don't let them freely browse the internet if you're that worried.
- Spivak 5y agoSounds good. Say I'm a non-technical parent that wants to give my child access to YouTube but not allow them to watch content that they're not old enough to consume on their own. How should I do this? I want to give them the freedom to explore topics they're interested in so downloading some pre-approved videos isn't going to work. And my kid is smart and will realize that any account-specific setting can trivially be bypassed by logging out. What should I do? Not allowing my kids access to the internet at all is a non-answer in 2020. Hell it was a non-answer in 1995.
- rootusrootus 5y agoThis is a tough question and I share it, with two elementary-age kids myself who love youtube. I don't have a good answer either. We put time limits on youtube and require that the kids use common-area computers to access it, but it would be nice if I could feel more confident about the content they're allowed to be exposed to.
- jtbayly 5y agoEven if you locked them down to YT for kids, do you honestly trust Google to accurately decide what is acceptable for kids? Yeah, no. I don't. (Remember when they had porn in there?) So how does this help, anyway?
- sp332 5y agoLately, they have been good. I don't blame you for mistrusting them because it took at least 4 scandals (I lost track), but they seem to have sorted it out.
- handrous 5y agoStill much worse than just letting parents create an allow-list of channels or videos from any part of YT, including the non-"YouTube Kids" part :-/ It'd be nice to be able to turn them loose on a YouTube that was just educational videos I've curated, no weird toy unboxing shit, without having to, like, maintain my own file server and streaming service.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoWell then parents should apply legislative pressure, which should arrive at Google as "fix this or we legislate", and bingo, Google need to do something. That is parents doing parenting. Parenting happens through societal structures.
- growse 5y agoWhen parenting your own kids isn't enough, but you feel you need to parent everyone else's as well.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoWhen you want to team up with other parents to make all of your lives easier.
- growse 5y ago"all your lives"? Or just the lives of a few, at the cost of the many? Not all parents agree that this is the right thing to do.
- tovej 5y agoDo you know _any_ parents that want their kids to consume ads?
- wyager 5y agoThe sane strategy is to simply avoid using an iPad as a babysitter rather than try to make everyone else’s life worse legislatively.
- tovej 5y agoRight, and it's not the tobacco industry's fault that people die of lung cancer, people should just know better than to smoke in the first place. And if you didn't know, children will eventually start using computers by themselves, probably before they are 12 (probably in first grade or kindergarten, I wouldn't be surprised). A huge portion of internet users are children. That's a fact. The reality is that a huge portion of children are online, and advertisers are specifically targeting children on youtube.
- sp332 5y agoIt's not exactly an age restriction, it's just getting permission from a parent. Either the parent puts in their ID information or they don't. Age restriction would be like movie theaters banning minors from certain movies.
- wyager 5y agoWho cares about the age restriction? The issue here is obviously having to put in government ID to use the internet.
- kube-system 5y agoThe same argument you are using is the justification for this. “It’s should be the parents decision to allow children to watch this content, not Google”
- wyager 5y agoParents' authority over their children does not extend to forcing random strangers to enter government ID to use the internet.
- danShumway 5y agoWell, the devil is in the details. In practice, making sure that kids can't see certain content or making sure that they never get advertised to often involves age validation. There's some stuff we can do with content that is targeted at kids, I don't think those laws are inherently bad. Although... last time we tried to expand laws around advertising in content directed toward kids, that resulted in a huge number of game streamers and animators getting demonetized, to the point where Youtubers were doing wild things like swearing more in their videos so they could prove that they weren't targeted at kids. We seem to have a lot of difficulty articulating legally what the difference is between "kid appropriate" and "kid targeted" is, particularly when it comes to stuff like video games or "wholesome" (for lack of a better word) content. To me, it's very much a "who's going to bell the cat" policy. I don't want kids to be subjected to so much advertising, it's a great policy. In theory. But I have not so far seen any practical implementations of age restrictions online that haven't either been completely worthless or really problematic for both privacy and free expression.
- Aerroon 5y agoI would much rather allow kids to watch trailers of Battlefield than to have to give Google pictures of my ID/passport. But that ship has sailed now. This is the new reality and it'll probably be applied to more websites in the future.
- vineyardmike 5y agoYour kids? Also, there’s much more content on YouTube that most parents would absolutely not want their kids seeing than a battlefield trailer.
- Aerroon 5y agoIf I had kids? Yes. My exploration online was effectively unrestricted while I was growing up. The internet had far more objectionable content back then that was easily accessible. I don't feel that it had any real negative effect on me. Why would I worry myself sick over my kids seeing it? Also, even if there is more objectionable content than a Battlefield trailer, the Battlefield trailer is restricted by the same rules. And if everyone else in your kids' friend group is talking about Battlefield then you'd be excluding your kid from it by limiting access to that. And if you don't limit access to it, then you get all the other 'objectionable' content too.
- jeroenhd 5y agoIt makes total moral sense, but Google has proven that morality is not their top priority when money is at stake. That's why governments fine companies that do undesirable things; it forces shareholders to care about ethics. And perhaps it shouldn't; America's prudeness around sex but glorification of violence has had an effect around the world through Hollywood for years. Adding that morality to the flow of information might not be what we want.
- anfogoat 5y agoApparently you'll need to scan an ID if you don't have a credit card, and I bet the EU has millions of young adults without a credit card. Either way, the end result is that you cannot use a video service without exposing your real identity to the service provider. And for what? Is there an epidemic of video clips wrecking children's minds I'm not aware of? Lacking that, this doesn't seem even remotely justified. All this is either EU lifers keeping themselves busy to justify their existence to themselves, MEPs wanting something to grandstand on, or something equally vapid. A much better approach would have been to keep the age prompt and leave the rest up to the parents, ie, to do nothing.
- cdubzzz 5y ago> And for what? Is there an epidemic of video clips wrecking children's minds I'm not aware of? I mean... maybe. I have young children and have no desire to have them anywhere near YouTube for essentially as long as possible _because_ of that very concern.
- thu2111 5y agoYou can already restrict YouTube on any sort of computing device you might give kids. Parental controls are built in to Android and iOS. There's no need for every website to duplicate that. However, there's a great "need" for the EU to constantly generate massive floods of legislation because they have ~30,000 civil servants they "need" to keep employed, many of whom earn more than the British Prime Minister. And unfortunately the EU loves coming up with reasons to fine tech firms because they managed to ensure there are none in Europe itself, so it looks a lot like free money, to an organization that's desperate for it (huge budget hole now UK has left + fines go straight into the EU spending pot).
- zimpenfish 5y ago> many of whom earn more than the British Prime Minister. Is that the basic pay (£79,936; €92,584) or the basic+entitled pay (£155,376; €179,968)? (via https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/930798/Salaries-of-members-of-Her-Majestys-Government-April-2020.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...) https://eufactcheck.eu/factcheck/uncheckable-4000-eu-officials-are-paid-more-than-merkel/ https://eufactcheck.eu/factcheck/uncheckable-4000-eu-officia... suggests that only 3-4000 (10-13%, not exactly "many"?) are PG13 or above which would be €196,305 (£169,481) - above UKPM.
- delusional 5y agoI'm so tired of tech people saying "it has to suck because the law requires it", when they clearly haven't read it. You hear it all the time when discussing tracking banners or ID verification. NO, the law does NOT require your implementation to suck, and most laws give you plenty of leeway in how you implement it. This is really not personal, but I HATE the argument. Take this as an example. The AVMSD isn't new, it was codified in 2010. It has a website[1], and on that website you can read the rules (they even simplified them for us). The rules about minors are pretty relaxed[2]. For non-linear content (such as on-demand video) the law requires that content which "might seriously impair the physical, mental or moral development of minors" wont "normally" be seen/heard by kids. Nowhere does it say that YouTube has to require a National ID to show a video of a zombie. It's all interpretation, because that's how we do laws. It's true that YouTube said that it's "in line with AVMSD"[3], but it's a lazy excuse to shove in a feature. [1]: https://ec.europa.eu/archives/information_society/avpolicy/reg/tvwf/provisions/index_en.htm https://ec.europa.eu/archives/information_society/avpolicy/r... [2]: https://ec.europa.eu/archives/information_society/avpolicy/reg/tvwf/protection/index_en.htm#12 https://ec.europa.eu/archives/information_society/avpolicy/r... [3]: https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/using-technology-more-consistently-apply-age-restrictions/ https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/using-technology-more-c...
- ehsankia 5y agoIf it was codified in 2010, was is it only going into affect now 10 years later? I'm not an expert in browsing EU law, but I do see a "revision" of AVMSD [0] that passed in 2018 and started going into effect around 2021 in various countries [1]. The two links you posted very clearly say "archived on 2012" so they are not the new version. [0] https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/revision-avmsd https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/revision-a... [1] https://www.obs.coe.int/en/web/observatoire/avmsd-tracking https://www.obs.coe.int/en/web/observatoire/avmsd-tracking
- zo1 5y agoIt's possibly not how they wanted to interpret it (though I see how it helps their ad/tracking business). But it is probably how they have to interpret it because they might get sued if they didn't. At the very least it's an expensive court case to dismiss. All whilst eyeball-thirsty news agencies print articles such as "Google Refuses to Support EU Child-Protection Legislation", and Twitter-personas post tweets like "Uh Google - what about the kids?"
- vkou 5y agoSelling ads for non-kids stuff to impressionable kids is the opposite of lucrative. Advertisers generally don't want to waste their money on advertising to people who aren't buying.